KSK Power's S. Kishore: 'Local Power Developers Are in the Lead'
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
KSK Power Ventur plc is a power plant developer with extensive business operations in India. It is headed by Sethuraman Kishore and K.A. Sastry. The company is listed in London. Subsidiary KSK Energy Ventures is listed in Mumbai. The company is in the business of developing, operating and maintaining power projects for major local and global industrial houses. Kishore, a speaker at the recent Wharton India Economic Forum, feels that western entrepreneurs wait for everything to be cut and dried before signing up for Indian power projects. That doesn't happen. The result has been that while the country was expecting strategic investors from abroad, only financial investors have come in, says Kishore in this interview with India Knowledge@Wharton. 📂 Innovation
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- [Music] uh Mr Kishore thank you so much for joining us today very kind of you I'm
- looking forward to this great uh to begin with I wonder if you could tell us a little bit about the growth and
- evolution of the independent power sector in India and some of the twists and turns through which it reached the
- position where it is today and what the status of the sector is today um the sector was opened to private sector in
- 1991 uh at that time only private generation was permitted I would say India is among the
- few countries that has actually evolved very well on the legislation side 91 opening up did not really
- great amount of get a great amount of response uh I remember our US ambassador mentioning yesterday that any company
- must have an India strategy and the legislation therefore was not considered very
- responsive then we had a reform uh change over in 1998 and a very comprehensive legislation followed thereafter in 2003
- I must mention that it's possibly one of the most comprehensive legislations in the world
- in so far as the sector is concerned it has a very clear reform path set it's the right approach to
- deregulation and I must say that the response has been tremendous to just give you a
- perspective private sector was hardly responsive till say about 2005 we have added post 1991
- approximately 110 gaw of capacity in the country mhm of that almost 30 7 Garts has been added by private sector in the
- plan of 20071 private sector is adding 30% in the plan of 2011 2016 private sector expected to add
- 60% that speaks well of the legislation absolutely now in terms of international
- interest in investment in the power area uh there was a very high-profile experiment made by Enron which uh did
- not go very well uh did that uh you know offer any lessons to uh the the sector and how how
- things could be done differently yeah I think the very interesting movement forward uh I must be pardoned for saying
- this is that it has really brought out a need for local developers versus International developers so we have seen
- the first phase of all the international developers like andron coming in and the
- substantial part of the change over has happened so much so that what we looked at looked forward to the world for
- strategic investors today has been replaced by huge amount of financial investors occupying the space so there
- is that amount of Interest has continued money has come in in large quantities large numbers but essentially driven by
- local developers being in the lead which is what is shown in the results that that's very interesting and I'll come
- back a little later to the uh idea of International Investment but uh tell me a little bit about your own
- company you know K we were both shastri and myself we are the two founders of this
- company uh the ksk initial stands actually for our uh respective names or expanded names so to say and um we were
- advisers typically called investment bankers we used to do a lot of advis on the power sector at a time I think we
- realized that we need to prove or hold on to what we advise so we took up a 20 megawatt plant uh in conjunction with
- few uh strategic investors but I think the real development we took up was in 2004 so we did a 26 megawatt capacity in
- 2004 costing us approximately 25 million today we are almost a gigawatt of capacity in
- operation and we have also financially closed one of the largest projects in the country for about 3.6 gaw so from
- 2004 to say 2011 uh we have have been interested is what I would say with almost a billion
- dollar of equity and about $3.5 billion of debt so the the the whole environment
- if you so say has been very responsive if you have the right business model that's bankable sustainable and
- competitive what would you consider the right economic model uh as I said the customer must necessarily get power at a
- competitive price this has been are thrust uh earlier on I mean you quoted an example I have many more to
- quote uh India was giving an impression or an impression was gained that India needs power at any
- cost we are a country that is very clearly voting for Darkness versus light so to say in a very cliched way if it's
- not competitive Enron as an example I keep quoting this uh gives about uh 14% of the electricity for the state
- of Maharashtra and was taking away 55% of the receivables of the state which means it was like eating
- into the it was like a marginal cost was so high I'm sure people on your sector will understand it is abnormal so there
- was tremendous amount of resistance even today we live with 40% people not having
- electricity MH so as a nation we very clearly communicating that we need power we need electricity but not at you know
- at any cost so what made it possible for say the local uh power generators to come up with a revenue
- model that is so remarkably different that they were able to provide Power at such a more competitive rates when you
- know enron's costs were so high or at least the the prices were so high yeah see basically uh
- I think um um again pardon me for saying this the Western world has really seemed
- to communicate see why on one hand we are saying there is demand at the same time we are saying
- the supply shall be supported by contracts okay if you believe demand you know there's demand for cars don't
- insist on someone giving you a contract for purchase of cars we are aware that electricity as a commodity is not
- bankable but we know there is huge amount of deficit okay now the moment you use a generator to be a financing
- intermediary he will ensure that all contracts are secure and the moment you make contracts
- very secure so to say in terms of uh International lender coming in an international investor wanting to
- endorse it which is what a strategic investor brings in you you can never have a backup or fall back on the
- developer and that reflects on the cost I see the Indian developers are all very
- conscious that these are realities just to give you an example you know annually
- if you see last 10 years the Indian SE power sector gets about $15 billion of debt you'll be surprise not even 5%
- comes internationally 95% of the debt is supported by Indian lenders alone okay now if you look at it from
- that perspective the lenders there are very conscious that almost 50% of the contracts are not fully tied
- up either there's no not fuel TI up not converted into an agreement land acquisition exists Poss not
- given ex evacuation agreement signed substation not ready water allocation done you were able to see political guys
- opposing it every day just imagine an international lender who sits outside the country wanting to take a view that
- all these will get sorted out in my view it won't be possibly I I will not kind of you know appreciate this point so
- this is exactly where the whole opportunity is right how are you going to be responsive to the situation
- because the stakeholders even at the ground level are aware of this right the guy who sells land knows that there is
- no competitive guy to come and buy his land but he still will protest to the extent that you know where the breaking
- point is so this is where the whole you know system has encouraged entrepreneurs
- like us to find mind that International entrepreneurs are not coming in now what kind of regulatory
- challenges did you face as you were going about building your company I think there was huge amount of adhocism
- um honestly today if you see even today the you know complaint so to say will be
- that power sector is deregulated every sector that needs to support the power sector continues to be
- government owned okay so you have uh you know the power sector generation delicensed evacuation still is Monopoly
- government control fuel supply government controled water government controled Railways government controlled
- allocation of wagons government control equipment supply we have only one government
- company people to be brought in government control so what are you doing you are now enabling the sector opening
- up saying you do anything but you have a set of contradictions and the reactions are completely a do
- Hawk all of you must be reading about how the environment Ministry is reacting today so I keep saying this there is no
- problem of lack of policy there is lack of coordination so how how how does an entrepreneur resolve these
- contradictions this is the only contribution we are happy there is no gation there's we are happy there is no
- integration got it if you actually go to two departments they're two talking two
- different languages yeah you have an environment Minister who tells us about whether the Country Must compromise
- between growth and environment it must be the the prime minister of the country with due respects he's a great
- extraordinary personality a political leader but this is the problem but I think that's where our opportunity
- is uh coming back to the financing situation could you tell me a little bit about the capital markets and the way in
- which you were able to um raise the financing you needed for your Venture when we actually started off I think we
- done a very interesting deal at stage one uh we are the first company to look at this entire need for
- disintermediation we are the first company to look at sale of power directly to the
- consumers and we actually got into a relationship with the consumers where the consumers invested
- in the equity of our company they invested equity and they got no return on their Equity so it's a very
- interesting position for us partly bridgest but we never compromise in returns that was an Outsourcing model
- additionally we also got a very interesting a very unique deal with Leman Brothers where Leman Brothers invested
- $9 for every dollar we invested so if you look at the extent of our leveraging I think we are the
- company that leverage almost 99 is to one where partly Equity came from lemman partly Equity came from our customers we
- have now built almost a gwatt of capacity based on this model and we continue to hold 65% of the equity I
- would certainly urge all your people to look at our model it's very interesting I'm not taking Pride for that but that's
- how it enabled us to uh you know take us to a different level but as promoters we
- had no money so ours is the first company that went directly to get listed on the London Market where instead of
- listing the holding company that held the underlying assets we listed the promoter holding company on the London
- Market we are the company that was listed first on the a market now we are on the main board our shares were resed
- about 107 p in November 2006 the share is now trading at about 560 P so it's a very heartening thing to look at that so
- we raised money there then we raised money on the Indian stock market we got the Indian listed entity also done that
- was a now I mean June 2008 so between these two companies and Leman and customers as as I said in the last seven
- years we raised almost a billion dollar of equity one last question through through this entire Journey what would
- you regard as the toughest leadership challenge you have faced and how did you overcome it and what did you learn from
- it I think the U most important thing is uh you cannot be very structural you cannot be very
- hierarchal and you have to be extremely foot loose in your response you cannot be very uh strong or NE
- go at least in our sector we have seen that while at the the federal level the government of India is saying we
- desperately need power and we'll give you all support then we have the local government that say they'll give you all
- support there's a huge amount of expectation completely uh contradictory and on a
- different plane at the local level J is the ground level I think all that we did
- was no jackets no ties can work we need to just roll up our sleeves go and talk to the local people with the feeling
- that we belong to them and I'm very happy to say that possibly ksk is the only company in the country that has
- done possibly the maximum number of plants in number of maximum number of locations there's no equivalent of our
- company we did a 20 megawatt 25 megawatt 58 megawatt graduated to 135 made it 540
- then now 3,600 we have done about 11 plants in eight states so this entire learning has been to be completely micro
- on almost 50% of the issues and insist that all your people are motivated in that direction uh the company today has
- grown from almost about 40 people in say 2005 2006 to more than 1,500 direct employment so these set of people have
- actually been motivated to understand in this process that you have to be extremely
- responsive I think that's the biggest takeaway I keep telling people in in management schools that if you look at
- supplies in India don't go by contracts take the view on demand I think it's a great opportunity to look
- at thank you so much for joining us today my pleasure thank you great
Brief Summary
Mr. Kishore discusses India's independent power sector growth, local developer roles, and innovative financing strategies in this episode.
Key points
- Evolution of India's Power Sector. The independent power sector in India has evolved significantly since 1991, with private sector involvement growing rapidly.
- Lessons from Enron's Failure. The Enron experiment highlighted the need for local developers in India's power sector.
- Innovative Financing Models. The company leveraged unique financing strategies, including consumer investment and partnerships with financial institutions.
Episode highlights
- Evolution of India's Power SectorThe independent power sector in India has evolved significantly since 1991, with private sector involvement growing rapidly.“India is among the few countries that has actually evolved very well on the legislation side.”0:51May 27, 2011
- Lessons from Enron's FailureThe Enron experiment highlighted the need for local developers in India's power sector.“It has really brought out a need for local developers versus International developers.”2:38May 27, 2011
- Innovative Financing ModelsThe company leveraged unique financing strategies, including consumer investment and partnerships with financial institutions.“We are the first company to look at sale of power directly to the consumers.”11:09May 27, 2011





