Multinational Corporations and Rural India

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Multinational Corporations and Rural India: A Conversation with Wharton Marketing Professor Jagmohan Singh Raju

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] Professor Raju thank you so much for joining us today thank you mul thanks
  2. for inviting me so we're going to talk today about multinationals in rural India and I wonder if we could start by
  3. just talking about which ones do you think have been most successful and why I think we have several more recent
  4. examples LG Nokia but I think to look at it from a historical perspective the ones really successful for many many
  5. years have been companies like Colgate Hindustan uni labor Phillips I think all these companies invested right from the
  6. beginning in rural India saw the value of the market developed product products that were useful for the rural Market
  7. went into the rural markets with their Distribution Systems and and uh really uh were very successful in fact the
  8. rural Market always provided them with a nice buffer uh that they could Bank on and a significant part of their sales
  9. came from the rural markets and these companies have been in rural markets for uh over 50 years now uh you know it's
  10. becoming more fashionable to talk about with these these days but these people have been doing it for
  11. years I think you know I know you talked about mnc's but uh I would consider some Indian
  12. companies to be also mnc's who have done very well in the rural Market they are mnc's in their own right so for example
  13. for example a company like Hiro Honda has uh you know over 50% share of the motorcycle Market in India and nearly
  14. 40% of their sales come from the rural market and then you have godre has historically been very strong in the
  15. rural markets uh and of course uh we don't think of ITC as a multinational today but at one point in time it was a
  16. multinational it's now an Indian company but has a very strong presence in rural
  17. markets uh and has done uh wonders there uh what about the flip side of the equation U if you were to look at
  18. multinationals that have tried to enter the rural Market but have failed any examples of that sort
  19. I I wouldn't say fail but I think they had uh sort of weak starts let me put it that way and some of them then probably
  20. decided not to pursue that any further I think Kellogg had a somewhat of a you know I would say a very weak start in
  21. the rural Market um PNG never sort of really went into the rural markets uh you know this may be sort of hard to
  22. accept but many of the other than Colgate many of the the US multinationals have not done as well in
  23. rural markets in India whereas all the successful examples at least most of them come from the European
  24. multinationals so you're looking at the old ITC uh you know the old Unilever I think Colgate has been
  25. successful Phillips was very successful again another European multinational of all the US
  26. multinationals I think the name that comes to mind is called gate having done very well so so so let's drill a little
  27. into detail on that is there are the reasons why Colgate did well and what were some of the reasons why the other
  28. us multinationals didn't do well and what can be learned from their experience I think uh the first thing is
  29. it the rural Market requires Investments it is not uh a Dumping Ground for things that you couldn't sell
  30. elsewhere if you think of this as you know look I have some products let me go take it there this is a marginal market
  31. I'll take advantage of it that does not work I think the classic principles of marketing apply just as well there you
  32. know try to make what you can sell there rather than just sell what you already make uh that doesn't work I think
  33. another mistake people sort of make is uh they kind of try to equate uh price Consciousness to Value
  34. consciousness which I think is a very important distinction uh rural Market is not price
  35. conscious it's much more value conscious the reason it's more value conscious is you know spending a dollar
  36. for them pinches a lot more than spending a dollar for somebody who earns hundreds of thousands of dollars so in
  37. some sense they can't afford to go wrong in whatever they buy uh I think that's an important uh
  38. thing to keep in mind the other thing to keep in mind is that their frequency of use may be a lot
  39. lower than the frequency of use for the same product in urban markets uh for them some of them it may be occasional
  40. used product as opposed to a regular used product and I think another factor that
  41. people Miss is uh that the rural consumer is buying many things for for emotional
  42. value uh you know if you are very rich uh you show your wealth by giving away to good
  43. causes and uh but if you're are not if you are a rural poor you kind of show that you care for your family by buying
  44. a branded soap so there is an emotional value attached to brands that I think mnc's should should
  45. recognize and take advantage of that so could you give any examples of the way in which they come companies
  46. like uh Colgate have analyzed and understood consumers in rural India to to build their
  47. success I think the first thing you have to do is rather than read the statistics
  48. and uh notes from either some un organization or a consulting company actually observe these customers see
  49. what their problems are see what they what their challenges are how they use their
  50. products uh how they you know uh work with these things what their daily issues are and how you have to then
  51. tailor make your products to meet their needs so for example you know uh let's say a soap uh we might have one soap for
  52. uh bathing and one for something else and one for something else but if you're going to buy one soap you probably want
  53. a multi-purpose soap and and that multi-purpose soap will be used for bathing will be used for you know
  54. bathing children as well as adults but also recognize that you know the environment may not be as clean so it
  55. has some properties that you know should should satisfy those needs so you have a
  56. single you know multi-purpose soap but it's one soap and and you recognize that you also recognize that there's not
  57. place to keep multiple soaps so it has to be one so you build to that need you you recognize that people carry a cell
  58. phone and use it at night when there's no power maybe there has to be a flashlight with the phone all right so
  59. you are you are observing people's behavior you see what they want what they don't want and then build to it I
  60. think it it helps uh so I would urge all companies to actually uh rather than reading books and statistics go visit
  61. and see what people do how they live their lives and what their challenges are or have people in their companies go
  62. do that I think it's a very useful learning experience that's exactly right uh how do you suggest multinationals
  63. identify new business opportunities in rural India I think what I said would help is
  64. you know observe Behavior but also recognize that uh I think not all rural people are the same there are very rich
  65. people in rural areas who live the same lives as people uh live in New York uh but they're also very poor people
  66. there's more heterogeneity but also recognize that uh you know to understand the consumer rural is not really where
  67. you live but it's more of a mindset and uh it's the way of thinking it's the way of approaching
  68. problems so many have argued that there are as many rural people in cities as there are in uh in rural areas that's
  69. very fascinating so what's the difference between the urban and the rural mindset well I think uh a rural mindset
  70. would be one that is a little bit more appreciative as well as fearing of nature all right so a lot of Rural Life
  71. in India still depends on rain so you respect it as well as fear it you love water but you fear it too because there
  72. are floods uh there is a little bit more spirituality in in rural India uh there's a little bit more concern for
  73. family uh so the fraction on education is still very high uh how much people are willing to spend on that uh so I
  74. think it's I I would argue rural is more I mean maybe we could say it's more of a mindset rather
  75. than just where you live and if we sort of recognize that there similar people in in urban areas too uh and and some
  76. Urban mindset exists in rural India right obviously not recognizing this distinction would be a major barrier for
  77. multinationals trying to enter rural India and I wonder what you would uh say are some of the principal barriers uh
  78. that multinationals should expect to face and how can they overcome them I think the the first first barrier
  79. is the appropriate product design I think we should be willing to design products to meet people's
  80. needs if we don't do that I think it's not going to work the second thing you have to recognize is the distribution
  81. system the the Distribution Systems in rural India are different than Distribution Systems that exist in urban
  82. India now rural India the distribution Outlets are small that's good news as well as bad news bad
  83. news is you know they won't carry too many things but the good news is if you are
  84. the one they'll carry you so in some sense we always as as marketing professionals study the relationship
  85. between uh market share and distribution share and if you look at large outlets in in the westernized world pretty much
  86. your distribution share is proportional to your market share so you know if you have 50% share
  87. of the market the person gives you 50% shell space if you have 20% share you get 20%
  88. if you get want more than 20% you pay for it in in rural areas the person who has the highest market share gets 100%
  89. distribution share because think of a person who's traveling on a bicycle going to a village carrying a soap to
  90. sell they're going to carry one brand of soap and which is the one that they're going to carry they're going to car
  91. carry the one that is the most uh popular brand but once you capture that it's yours so there is a there is you
  92. create a barrier to entry but to invest in that so you invest in your brand uh try to build Market Shar so that or
  93. popularity so that they carry your brand so that's the second one I think the the
  94. third is the frequency of use you have to recognize that frequency of use may vary quite a bit uh across urban and
  95. rural areas some products that are regularly used are infrequently used so one might argue one one strategy that
  96. some companies have adopted is to go to smaller sizes another strategy some companies have adopted is to try to
  97. increase the frequency of use try to make one product the product of choice uh then there are other issues also so
  98. for example uh because of uh location because of distances it's not just making a cheaper
  99. product it's also recognizing that you know products may have to have different capabilities if I'm making a television
  100. for rural areas it's not just sufficient to say I'll have the cheapest television
  101. it's also important to recognize that the signal strength may be weaker uh in rural area so I have to provide certain
  102. unique sort of benefits which may be totally Irrelevant in you know when you connect a cable uh to a TV the signal
  103. strength is determined by the fire whereas if you are you know in in a far away location it's mostly through the
  104. air and you need to recognize that so at a lower price and yet higher not necessarily uh you know certain features
  105. could be taken out but that one feature has to be clearly managed because if you
  106. if if you don't see the picture you're not going to like it this goes back to the point you made earlier about
  107. designing your products specifically for the rural Indian market and I think it is this is a principle that is not just
  108. true for Rural India when we say go to any Market try to design a product that the person their needs so but the same
  109. principle applies but I think what what happens is it's often forgotten there and what is remembered is these people
  110. can't pay enough so let's just give them cheap products in fact this is a part of
  111. the mindset if if a person who value conscious is given the cheapest product they says look this is just for you they
  112. will not buy that because in some sense it's a show of disrespect that's a very interesting
  113. point to your uh to your mind which company has been most successful in designing products for the rural Indian
  114. market and what's the most striking example that comes to your mind I think I would of the of the
  115. multinationals I would probably put Unilever at the Forefront amongst people who companies that have been there a
  116. long time I think what was their strategy so for example a soap all right so they have a a simple carbolic soap
  117. that works across many applications uh bathing washing and they realize that and I think it did well this is uh a
  118. good example of uh a company recognizing that need company also recognizing that
  119. uh to sell you also need to create buying power so if you you want to sell your products uh amongst people why
  120. don't we create some incomes there so create jobs for women uh bring them into the distribution system and it increases
  121. the family income and it increases their purchasing power so I think you grow with them rather than you grow at their
  122. expense uh I think people respect that and that's a a better long-term strategy is be a part of the milu as opposed to
  123. try to extract consumer surplus as quickly as you can and then get out that's not uh a viable long-term
  124. strategy in that market so I would I'm sure people would say that's not viable in almost any Market that's true but I
  125. think it's it's more important here that you you create wealth as you uh as you try to you know absorb wealth also and
  126. it has to happen simultaneously and companies that have become a part of of the part of the
  127. society there uh have have done better and I think un is a good example of that uh where they've integrated themselves
  128. well into the system and have gained from it and more recently Now LG is doing a good job with their phones in
  129. India you know they have taken great care to develop phones that are suitable for the rural Market that are
  130. inexpensive have certain characteristics that uh that are needed there and uh and and
  131. done a good job with that so any final words of advice for CEOs of multinationals that want to enter rural
  132. India I would probably say two things distinction between value Consciousness and price Consciousness I
  133. think it's important to remember that people in rural areas care about value more than the
  134. price second grow with them rather than grow at their expense I think if we keep these two
  135. things in mind you'll generally be better off Professor thank you so much for your time thank you mugul thanks for
  136. inviting me so

Brief Summary

Professor Raju discusses multinationals' successes and challenges in rural India, emphasizing value consciousness over price consciousness.

Key points

  • Success of Multinationals in Rural India. Companies like Colgate and Hindustan Unilever have thrived in rural markets by understanding local needs.
  • Challenges for Multinationals. Many US multinationals have struggled in rural India, unlike their European counterparts.
  • Understanding Rural Consumers. Observing consumer behavior is crucial for tailoring products to meet rural needs.
  • Creating Value in Rural Markets. Successful companies grow with rural communities by creating jobs and increasing purchasing power.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes