The Mobile Challenge for Banks

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Technology is disrupting the banking industry in several ways. For instance, customers today interact with their banks via mobile devices more often than they visit a bank branch. Jay Sidhu, chairman and CEO of Customers Bank and BankMobile, believes that within five years mobile banking will become the norm. 📂 Finance & Accounting

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I guess - AR JC do who is the chairman and CEO of customers bank or customers bank bank mobile and Bank mobile
  2. technologies and also la lien Sidhu who is the co-founder president and chief strategy officer of bank Mobile J and
  3. lovely and thank you so much for coming today to speak with knowledge at Wharton
  4. so happy to be here thank you thanks for inviting us so you launched Bank Mobile
  5. which you call a completely digital Bank almost three years ago in January 2015 I
  6. wonder if you could talk a little bit in the beginning about how did you assess the state of digital banking in the US
  7. and what's the opportunity that you saw for the launch of Bank mobile yeah banking that's a very good question the
  8. banking is all about attracting customers making the customers feel very good about their relationship with a
  9. bank so they become customers for life so traditionally banks have used these are the built bank branches or the
  10. acquired bank branches to acquire customers and then we obviously noticed that customers are coming to the bank
  11. branches less and less and less and you gotta find a way to attract the customers so so we actually put created
  12. a task force and said to the task force imagine if you couldn't open a single bank branch
  13. how can you acquire customers how can you be engaged with the customer so that they say wow this is a great experience
  14. and how can you make them customers for life and Loveleen ended up heading that task force and from that idea where we
  15. said if we won't disrupt ourselves then somebody else will and we don't like to do that so that's where it all started
  16. and maybe Levine can tell you how that idea brew then into where we become America's biggest and fastest growing
  17. digital bank today yeah and just expand upon what you said with a few stats it's kind of astounding
  18. but people on average are walking into a bank branch one to two times a year but they're interacting with their bank
  19. on their mobile device 20 to 30 times a month and then talking about from a business model front for a bank bank
  20. branches are only acquiring 52 net checking accounts a year per branch okay that is not an exponentially growing
  21. customer acquisition vehicle so we were thinking how can we create a sustainable
  22. low-cost high-volume customer acquisition strategy and that's how we were able to really develop Bank mobile
  23. and we can talk to you a lot more about the strategy as we go on absolutely well why don't we take a step
  24. back and look at the banking move the mobile banking market in the US as a whole how do you think it compares to
  25. other parts of the world because as far as I can see a lot of the action actually seems to be happening in places
  26. like Africa and the US Africa and and Asia how does the u.s. compare to those markets yeah I think that it's been a
  27. lot slower in the US and I think it's partly because of the regulatory environment so it's been very difficult
  28. for FinTech players or non banks to enter into the banking space I definitely think that there's there's a
  29. reason why that is the case to really protect the consumer but it also creates a lot of barriers to entry for
  30. innovators in the space so if you look at Africa and you look at MSA and and these that are trying to create
  31. opportunities for the masses to really become banks you look at India now with the $1 card and and these numbers and
  32. being able to Bank them and then you look at China that is creating digital banks that's creating payment systems
  33. through WeChat and Ali pay you're absolutely right but there's also less you know lower barriers to entry in
  34. terms of an opportunity for these players to innovate and I think I think what's happened is US banking system is
  35. built upon having giving access to the vast country's population in a local way and so there's a belief among the
  36. regulators like Loveleen said that if you permit digital banking it'll principally be available in populated
  37. centers that the remote areas of United States which is really the middle part of the
  38. country will not have access I think that's a total fallacy and I think United States my prediction is within
  39. five years we'll be a leader in digital banking globally how will that leadership be established
  40. it'll be established because the Innovation Center of the world is us they are there's a lot of innovation
  41. taking place in the FinTech area but it's the bank charters and it's a partnership is being debated and the
  42. regulator's are preventing banks to have a good solid engagement where the FinTech companies for the benefit of the
  43. consumers because they believe for whatever reason that FinTech is not good may not be good for the consumer I think
  44. there is no question that you need good regulation there's no question you need good consumer protection but why should
  45. one has to walk into a bank branch to open an account why this and it's already disrupted whereby for credit
  46. cards you never have to go to a bank but if you want to open a checking account god forbid you need to go to the bank
  47. how crazy that is so Bank mobile today has really you know change that whole process whereby Bank
  48. mobile today is opening up almost as many checking accounts as Bank of America is opening with approximately
  49. 4,000 plus branches across the nation and I think there'll be more Bank Mobile's coming up and that's why it'll
  50. become a very common way of doing banking in the United States and the regulators are just slow to adapt if you
  51. look today that they've already started working on the FinTech charters that's not allowing these fintax to get FDIC
  52. insured deposits but it is a start where they don't have to go state-by-state and
  53. register and can start you know serving customers nationally you mentioned earlier about you know customer
  54. acquisition strategy and I think one of the advantages that fintechs seem to have over traditional banks is their
  55. ability to come engage with Millennials that I was wondering if you have any ideas on how how banks can engage more
  56. actively with Millennials in terms of customer acquisition mm-hmm I think it's it's a good question but I think it's
  57. actually maybe a false perception because we hear of a couple fintechs that are doing really well and and they
  58. have great PR like Sophie Robin Hood has done an extremely great a great job of acquiring customers and there is a
  59. couple it's like a handful but there's thousands of FinTech companies out there and one of their main struggles is
  60. customer acquisition they're actually resorting to very old-school forms of marketing like direct marketing where
  61. customer acquisition costs are 500 to a thousand dollars or more which is extremely high and not sustainable and
  62. that's why we're seeing a lot of consolidation of fintechs where they're either shutting down or they're having
  63. to partner with banks to be able to create a sustainable customer acquisition strategy so I think it seems
  64. like they're doing a great job in terms of customer acquisition because they're sexy and it's a great user interface and
  65. they're finally paying attention to the customer experience but in in reality banks are much better at customer
  66. acquisition because of the stickiness of the direct deposit checking account relationship and it's interesting we are
  67. a bank for the Malayan Millennials Bank mobile and still about 25 percent of the
  68. customers that we have are over age 35 okay so there's a perception that the non Millennials do not want to get
  69. engaged using digital means but I think it's the age 35 to 55 maybe is less receptive but above age 55 is almost
  70. more receptive because they feel like I don't want to be left behind and definitely the Millennials consider it
  71. to be a real pain to deal with someone with a brick and mortar when they can get a better product at a lower price
  72. and it's more convenient through digital means I have a question specifically for
  73. you because you have spent so many years in the banking industry in fact I think
  74. when the last time knowledge at Wharton interviewed you you were the CEO of sovereign bank
  75. which was later taken over by banco santander and so my question to you is as you enter this new world of digital
  76. and mobile banking from a personal standpoint are there things that you have had to learn or unlearn about how a
  77. banking is going oh no question about it but at the same time the basic business
  78. of banking hasn't changed at all which is acquiring customers getting engaged with those customers and considering
  79. customers for life as the faz through your model for the business and what is it that the customers are looking for
  80. they're looking for ways on how we can make more money save more money get more money get some help on how we can manage
  81. the money it's basic stuff in the bank branches it's a lot tougher to do that basic stuff because there's no
  82. consistency and certain bank branches cost you millions of dollars just like the one across from Wharton over here
  83. you know between the old Commerce Bank and the sovereign bank or something they're bank branches the millions per
  84. year if you can find a way to attract those customers through digital means and that's where it hasn't changed so
  85. yes we were looking to acquire customers through bank branches all the time when
  86. I was running sovereign now we say is no bank branches how do we acquire customers so we have developed
  87. partnerships and partnerships is the way to go in the digital means you look at any disruptor they are all they're
  88. usually not always usually going from B to B to C you look at uber you know you look at Airbnb you know the ones with
  89. the unicorns they're all doing that why are banks not doing that was a question that I kept asking and we kept asking
  90. and we came to an answer and it's working so so lovely I wonder if you could talk about some of these
  91. partnerships that you just mentioned yeah how do partnerships fit into the way in which Bank Mobile is being
  92. growing yeah so for us we call it our leverage growth strategy so how in essence can we have one
  93. distribution partner to give us access to potentially millions of customers and so today the way that we've really done
  94. it is through virtual digital banks that are actually eight hundred campuses across the country so we have contracts
  95. with 800 campuses and what we really provide for them is proprietary technology and a lot of regulatory
  96. oversight for any payments that they need to send between the school and the students and we actually saved these
  97. colleges on average about a quarter of a million dollars every year for our services and in return the students at
  98. these schools get to choose this money that they're receiving from the school do they want it ACH to an existing bank
  99. account or do they want to open a bank mobile checking account and this has been a great way for us to open about
  100. 300 to 400 thousand new checking accounts each year which really makes us the number one are close to the number
  101. one checking account acquirer in the nation with zero bank branches essentially so I understand that you
  102. have something like 1.7 million customers that you've grown to in the past three years was this primarily your
  103. growth strategy yes so right now we're really dominating the student banking market so our 1.8 million customers
  104. today have an average age of 27 and primarily they are students so a lot of people don't know but the student the
  105. education system in the u.s. is 60% two-year Community Schools and vocational schools and and 40%
  106. traditional four-year schools and that's why our average age of 27 is a little higher than you'd think
  107. you know a 20 year old or a 22 year old but it's great because we're able to serve these customers when they're
  108. looking for a bank account it's an inflection point in their life and to there's such a knowledge gap
  109. about credit and how to use money and money management and there's an opportunity for us to play in that space
  110. as well I'd like to come back to that last point you made but I have another question before that and that is both of
  111. you talked about the importance of banks engaging with customers in a way that makes customers you know as you said
  112. feel good about themselves if you look at more almost all the large banks today each of them has a sort of
  113. banking app and are trying to add more and more digital services so whether it's Bank of America or Samsung there
  114. they have apps that you can use for checking your balances for transfers bill payments basic services like that
  115. how can a mobile first you know bank like bank mobile differentiate your offerings from the digital offerings of
  116. the legacy banks I wonder if how do you differentiate yourselves in position yourselves yeah
  117. that's a that's a 4-game good question what they are focused on is engagement with a customer and what we've shared
  118. with you the business of banking first is attracting customers engaging with the customers and making them customers
  119. for life so they are still totally focused on attracting customers to bank branches they haven't yet had that
  120. so-called Kodak moment Kodak was the one that developed a digital camera and the
  121. digital camera put Kodak out of business so they have all these hundreds and thousands of bank branches they are
  122. hoping that the customer doesn't stop going to the bank branches so they are very focused on making their branches
  123. slicker open different hours glass around it for stand outside invite people what the for have video screens
  124. in the bank branches but guess what everybody's walking with a video screen in your pocket why would they want to go
  125. talk to you in a video you know in a bank branch that's sort of crazy so they need to disrupt it themselves
  126. and the reason they are not disrupting themselves is because of their infrastructure and this they are making
  127. money by keeping customers misinformed and I'll be very specific today the interest rates are such that consumers
  128. as an example should be getting at least 1% of their savings accounts and you know what Bank of America and JP Moore
  129. and Wells Fargo's are proud of we only pay point zero five percent interest they're proud of that fact imagine a
  130. business that says we are so proud that we charge the highest prices but we give
  131. them an app to get it but guess what we have found a way to attract customers pay them a competitive price not rip
  132. them off that is true engagement all right give them the benefit of how do you make
  133. more money and that's why they are either gonna have to change themselves or they'll have a gradual death that is
  134. my belief haven't been a banker for the last 40 years and they're realizing this
  135. and the shift is taking place but at a snail's pace so if you recently read about JP Morgan launching fin and then I
  136. think it was a Wells Fargo of greenhouse so they're trying to create these sort of millennial branded cool names where
  137. it will be powered by JP Morgan so they have some of the reputational credibility behind them but they're
  138. trying to use this as a customer acquisition strategy the way that we created Bank mobile but but it's taken
  139. than what we we launched Bank mobile like three years ago and and now they're finally you know piloting these ideas so
  140. they're thinking about it but it's it's it's a slow pace I think within five years you'll see at least a 50 to a 75%
  141. reduction in the number of bank branches and I think these banks will wake up and
  142. they have the resources to wake up and they will be fine like the Bank of America and the JP Morgan Chase for the
  143. world but Loveleen is so right that they are moving at us very snail's pace Bank
  144. of America closed 20% of their branches last year hmm what will the bank branch of the future look like Bank branch of
  145. the future will be where people are working out of their ok to interact with their customers in the main segments and
  146. they don't expect a single customer to walk in but the customer will see it just in case they ever need to walk in
  147. they can walk in it's not going to be the most expensive street corner all right it could be in the 15th floor I'll
  148. give you an example of customers back customers Bank has a branch at 101 Park Avenue in New York it's on the 11th
  149. floor okay has 1.8 billion dollars in deposits that by itself is in the top 50 tanks in the country in size and it's on
  150. the 11th 4th floor of our building imagine that is so much more efficient than all these little branches all over
  151. the place in the streets of Philadelphia it's happening woken up yeah so let me ask you coming back to Bank mobile you
  152. have I believe you're spinning off Bank mobile and merging it with flagship Community Bank what are your goals for
  153. doing that yes so for us so we basically have a regulatory sort of arbitrage that
  154. exists today because 70% of our non-interest income is coming from what you call interchange revenue that is
  155. when someone swipes their debit card or their credit card but here specifically we're just looking at the debit card
  156. being a bank under 10 billion in assets which is what customers bank our parent company was when we started our
  157. partnership we were able to leverage as much of this interchange revenue as we possibly could but under the dodd-frank
  158. it's part of the Durbin amendment banks that are over 10 billion in assets make about 4 or 5 times less an interchange
  159. revenue so for us to protect our growth and our future opportunity it really makes sense for Bank Mobile to be able
  160. to again be part of a banking institution that's under 10 billion in assets and so we have a lot of room for
  161. growth and you can give a customer's bank perspective yeah we don't like to charge fees we like to have tremendous
  162. engagement we think in the technology model ok you gotta be able to have a very low cost operation
  163. and the only way like Lavigne said that we make money right now is when when the
  164. our customers swipe their cards so today we are making about forty five million dollars a year just with customers
  165. swiping their cards if if we wouldn't spin-off Bank mobile and make it a little baby Bank again then that forty
  166. five million will go down to about thirty million and that fifteen million would have to be recovered by charging
  167. fees which is not a part of our model okay so we are basically spinning it off letting the team flourish and we believe
  168. there is so much room for growth in this partnership banking that besides students we've announced that we will be
  169. having a very large white label partner with a top-notch retail institution in the nation and we believe that was in
  170. two to three years you know our customer acquisitions will go from 300 400 thousand a year to perhaps a million
  171. checking accounts a year 1 million that's what I meant by that would be more than what Bank of America is doing
  172. and that's only possible by spinning it off that wouldn't be possible for us to do if it was part of customers Bank
  173. brings me back to a point you made earlier about you know providing banking services to those who may not be part of
  174. the banking world today how important is Financial Inclusion for you as a goal he's passionate about that
  175. you should you know part of the reason we launched Bank Mobile is because there's millions of Americans that are
  176. really locked out of the banking system whether it's you know because it's cynicism and and they don't trust the
  177. banking system whether it's they can't afford the monthly fees the minimum balance requirements and in reality big
  178. banks are charging Americans thirty three billion dollars a year in just overdraft fees that doesn't create a
  179. sentiment of trust so we wanted to really provide a banking experience that is affordable and that can really serve
  180. these individuals that are underbanked that banks that are low middle-income Americans so today we do that by
  181. creating a very affordable banking product which we have today we also have a very strong educational component so
  182. we have curriculums that help people understand the psychology of money basic money management to be able to
  183. understand that credit components of credit because even as a you know a Wharton grad myself there was a learning
  184. curve for me to understand what is actually the components of credit and credit is so important for all of us to
  185. be able to you know aspire and reach our dreams we're all going to need some form
  186. of credit so we have one on one coaching with our financial coach as well and we
  187. have a blog that is be empowered and we're rebranding as paradigm money coming out in in January so there's all
  188. different formats from visual from auditory you know different ways that people can learn and really connect with
  189. us and and and really get a solid financial foundation 20% of Americans are spending more than 15% of their
  190. income just to have access to financial services 20% of Americans and that Bank mobile will end there we think the ones
  191. who can least afford it should spend nothing and we should have a we have a duty to help those who are underserved
  192. become more financially literate and financially less dependent upon the society where do you hope to go with
  193. bank mobile or the next couple of years you know for us we want to become the number one acquire of checking accounts
  194. and it's not just about high volume and getting as many customers that we can but it's really about this social
  195. mission that we've been talking to you about there is 65 million Americans that are unbanked and underbanked there's
  196. such an opportunity to serve these customers and and provide them with the financial foundation they need to really
  197. reach their dreams and so it's it's really about creating customers for life adding value to their banking experience
  198. all the way from convenience to your products and services that they really need and I hope that in the
  199. process that we serve our customer customers we also have 220 employees to be able to impact their lives and in
  200. beautiful ways and be able to expand their lives professionally personally our shareholders we hope to really grow
  201. Bank Mobile in terms of very profitable endeavor over the next three to five years which should be a awesome
  202. opportunity for our investors and the communities that we serve so really excited about the opportunity I think we
  203. are doing good and at the same time doing really well you know and those kind of opportunities exist using
  204. technology I've been in like you said in the banking business for forty five years this is about the most exciting
  205. times I have ever been in the business you see an opportunity to use a new means to really has your exponential
  206. growth it's no longer that 10% growth American businesses have been going through either cutting the cost or
  207. finding Schloss small ways to incremental ease have slight increases in revenues so that the street expects
  208. if you get 10% increase in revenues you are a growth company well I think with technology the street is gonna be
  209. realizing that 20% sustainable growth is possible and that's only possible if you
  210. do something unique in and deliver it in a unique way and you have a disruptive model so the future of banking in my
  211. opinion is going to be based upon doing few things really well it'll be niche banking I believe
  212. business banking will remain at least in the foreseeable future as a human contact that relationship at the
  213. eyeball-to-eyeball level but consumer banking is going to go through a very disruptive change and that's why like we
  214. were talking about the role of the bank branches is going to be totally different I just hope there are more
  215. entrepreneurs looking for restaurants because bank branches to we'll make some very nice restaurants
  216. you know easy to get in and out of because I can't imagine banks being able to continue to afford them anymore and
  217. we have found a way to continue to attract those customers that is the key you cannot get engagement unless you
  218. attract them and just like if knowledge at Wharton could get over 3 billion 3 million users globally you know we think
  219. just bank mobile should have between three to five million checking account customers within a five to a seven year
  220. period that is very possible and when I was running sovereign sovereign was the 20th largest bank in the nation and we
  221. had 1.2 million checking account customers that's it so you're talking about three times bigger than sovereign
  222. in consumer banking within a ten year period because it's been in business three and I'm talking about maybe seven
  223. more years that's called exponential growth thank you both very much for speaking with knowledge at Wharton it's
  224. been great to have you here thank you so much for more insight from knowledge at
  225. Wharton please visit knowledge Wharton UPenn edu [Music] you

Brief Summary

AR JC and Loveleen Sidhu discuss digital banking trends, customer acquisition, and Bank Mobile's growth strategy in the U.S.

Key points

  • The Rise of Digital Banking. Bank Mobile launched as a completely digital bank, aiming to attract customers without branches.
  • Customer Engagement Strategies. Discussion on how banks can better engage with Millennials and the importance of customer experience.
  • Future of Bank Branches. Predictions on the reduction of bank branches and the evolution of banking services.
  • Financial Inclusion Importance. Discussing the significance of financial inclusion for millions of Americans.
  • The Future of Banking. Exploring the disruptive changes in consumer banking and the role of technology.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes