The Promise and Peril of Digital Mortality
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
Martine Rothblatt, Co-CEO and chair of United Therapeutics, and founder of Sirius Satellite Radio, discusses the future of humanity in her new book, "Virtually Human." More: http://knlg.net/1TnzOsW 📂 Technology
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- our guest today is Martine Rothblatt CEO and chair co-ceo and share of United therapeutics Martine you have an
- extraordinary background and I thought I would give a quick summary of how your often described so we can get through a
- lot of a lot of your accomplishments so Martine Rothblatt lawyer author satellite entrepreneur futurist pharma
- tycoon philosopher helicopter pilot founder of sirius satellite radio chair and co-ceo of the biotechnology company
- united therapeutics which you founded to save your daughter's life highest paid female CEO in 2013 born a man now a
- transgender woman father of four spouse to the same woman being a flat for thirty-three years I believe all correct
- Katherine that is an extraordinary life to date so let's start with this question what accomplishment are you
- most proud of I think I'm most proud of the family that Ben and I have created together my certainly my favorite part
- of every day is the part of the day that I'm with bina my partner and the only thing that makes that even better is
- when we're with one of our kids or grandkids I'd love to talk to you about your leadership you've led a number of
- companies who founded a number of companies let's start with your life as a CEO what is a typical week in your
- life if you if you're looking at the week ahead in your day when it's a typical week what's a typical week
- typical week is interacting with different people that work in our company so if I'm someplace where I
- could see them face-to-face I'd like to walk through the corridor I like to go to people's offices I like to go into
- laboratories and I just like to say hi what's going on whether you working on look people hi to I so that you can
- really engage with people and not make them feel rushed like you're talking in an elevator you're on your way to
- someplace if it's somebody that I mean they're scheduled to talk with or I know they've requested talk with me or I need
- to talk them and we're not face-to-face then I'll call them up so I spend you know a
- good chunk of each day I don't know quarter of it maybe more on the telephone doing the same sort of thing
- talking through a particular challenge or problem or different options and trying to reach a a kind of a mind meld
- with everybody I talk with in terms of what should we do together next and you know you're leading a highly technical
- company a company as I said United therapeutics which you founded to save your daughter's life when she was
- diagnosed with pulmonary arterial hypertension you're not a you're not a doctor an m.d. you're not a pharmacist
- as elite as leading this company how do you navigate you know where you are pushing forward the scientific R&D
- agenda and where you are deferring to others so it's on the sort of the larger scale issues Kathryn that I'm leading
- and on the on the finer scale which which depending on how you look at it could be large-scale within a fine scale
- domain I delegate to others so for example a classical decision would be whether to develop a medicine or not
- I've never made one of those decisions dictatorial ii but i would lead that decision and and try to urge people to
- see the benefits of developing a medicine for a particular disease and hopefully there's altom utley a
- consensus to do so so that's in something that I would lead exactly how you go about developing the drug for
- that disease involves literally thousands of sub decisions that have to be made in terms of for example a
- clinical trial the the most important part of a clinical trial is what's the endpoint a clinical trial is an
- experiment it's an experiment involving human beings therefore you have to have a hypothesis and the hypothesis has to
- be stated in such a way that there's going to be sort of an either/or answer that either-or answer is the endpoint
- depending on what that endpoint is a clinical trial which will take you know millions of dollars and years of
- effort can either be set up to fail can be set up to succeed or can be kind of of indeterminant failure or success um
- it's really somewhat in the in the science in the randomness whether it's a successful or failure so I won't be the
- person that that sets the end points I won't be the person that decides the main elements of the trial but I'll
- definitely be the person that questions every decision that's made and I and even them so my main job on the lower
- level is to question people's decisions and to do the best I can to see that they have thought through the decision
- interesting so I know that in the company there's a line one hears often once I think sees on your website
- certainly I've seen it written about you that a motto or guideline to identify the corridors of indifference and run
- like hell down them what does that mean so what that means it's it's actually it's great to them here at Wharton and
- you're talking about that because it's a concept really I learned in business school that originally I think that this
- principle was best identified perhaps by Jack Welch the the iconic CEO of General
- Electric who said to be successful in the business you need to be either number one or number two in that
- business and if you enter business you're not number one or number two you're going to have to spend an amount
- of money equal to the revenues of number one or number two which often could be a
- huge sum especially if you're just entering the business so instead it's always better in business to be a big
- fish in a small pond to put it in a very cloak wheel sort of way then a small fish in a big pond and I really absorb
- that lesson from business go at UCLA's Anderson School and hence when we say identify the corridors of indifference
- that really means look for the small ponds we're there are no fish and then run like hell
- down them that means jump in that pond and become the big fish in that small pond and was just part of the the
- philosophy that led you to think I can actually start a company and we'll make this a successful company around an
- orphan disease as I said the disease that your daughter has um I can't really say that I was very intellectual about
- founding the company to go after my daughter's disease I'm reminded of a great line that I read
- just last weekend Diane Von Furstenburg most recent book the moment kind of whom
- I want to be where she says she's built DVF into a huge enterprise and she said she never had a business plan
- she just pursued her passion which for her was fashion for me as I had to save Genesis my daughter and I didn't really
- think through it so much like okay this is an orphan disease I'll be a leader in
- this business segment frankly I didn't care if I made a penny in this entire area I just wanted to save my daughter
- right right so let's talk a little bit more about the company United therapeutics you've had a run of
- successful medicines drugs but now are moving to think about lung transplantation and xenotransplantation
- why the why the shift or why this progression help us understand that choice sure so what we're trying to do
- is to develop a market for manufactured organs and manufactured organs such as lungs for example are really just
- another type of medicine it's a medicine that you take just one time and it pretty much cures your disease people
- are used to thinking of medicines as something that you know are pills in a bottle or something that's injected in a
- in a syringe but they don't have to be that way I mean for a number of years there has been skin as a product for
- people who have terrible burns and it's possible to grow skin as layers and lay it down for other conditions there have
- been tissues which are collections of literally millions or even tens of millions of cells which are provided
- patience my original inspiration in in manufactured organs was in fact from my maternal grandmother who required a
- porcine heart valve because she had cardiac valvular disease and she would have died of a heart attack they removed
- her heart valve and put in the heart valve from a pig this was in the seventies so it's been around for a
- while yep so that was my initial kind of interest arm and and the credibility that I gave this field our daughter's
- condition and pulmonary hypertension is treated by our medicine and in fact our competitors also have medicines for this
- disease but not one of these medicines is a cure for the disease and the disease involves at least three and
- maybe five different things going wrong in the body that's probably why it's an orphan or rare disease because you need
- to have three to five different things all go wrong to end up with this disease and as a result of that coming up with a
- cure like a silver bullet is pretty darn hard because then you need actually like
- five cures you know to cure it it so happens that when you replace a person's lung they never get the disease again so
- whatever causes the disease its resident in the lung so to me developing an unlimited supply of manufactured lungs
- was just developing a better medicine for my daughter and everybody else with pulmonary hypertension and where how far
- away are we from a point when we will have this this ready supply of lungs lungs are in short supply now people die
- all the time from unable to get transplanted lung and other transplanted organs how far in the future do you
- think it is before I don't know yet over a replacement lung will be as common I would imagine as a replacement hip yeah
- exactly so a question like this Katherine by its very nature you're going to have like a bell curve of
- distribution of people's opinions that's always the case when you're developing the next technology some people will say
- that it's you know 20 years in the future other people will say it's it's two years in the future
- the reality is probably a bit more finely granulated than that because new technologies they don't pop
- into being fully formed and perfect if you take a look at something that people love right now the iPhone well it began
- as a hi pod and if you're old enough to have had like you know an iPod one or iPod two they look pretty weird compared
- to like a iPod Nano today so the manufactured organs will start small and grow larger and larger to get to the
- point of today where pretty much anybody that needs an artificial hip can have an
- artificial hip there's two or three manufacturers to choose from I think you'd be looking at the end of the 2020s
- and I would say that that would be not so much just my opinion but sort of like the center point of of the bell curve
- and you'll find some people that would say that point would be in the 30s you'd find some people would say it could be
- earlier in the 20s I think you'd be really hard-pressed I would certainly say this less than 5% of any medical
- experts in scientists would say that there will never be an endless supply of manufactured organs this is a
- engineering challenge not requiring new laws of biology to be discovered yeah fascinating fascinating so you you talk
- about developing technologies and you've written recently the book virtually human the promise and peril of digital
- immortality digital immortality what the what in the world is digital immortality
- so digital immortality is what is what you have when you combine big data with AI so big data is the outside of our
- device storage of all the different digital data points about our life all of our Amazon eeper choises all of our
- social media tweets and posts all of our emails all of the surveillance data from
- when we swipe an ID card to enter a building public surveillance all of this stuff is stored ultimately and they're
- out there with them actually multiple cloud provide and so that's big data AI or artificial
- intelligence is an operating system that tries to replicate one or more functions
- of the human mind so there is AI that for example can navigate your way around a new city just like your mind would try
- to navigate your way around a new city there's AI that can recognize multiple on the can recognize Kathryn or Martine
- out of a list of 50 different photos many of us even have that AI now on Google photos on our phone so it's a
- kind of operating system so what happens with a virtual human is when ie AI gets
- better and better and better and cobbles together dozens hundreds even thousands
- of different types of AI software programs and is mated with the part of big data that is Catherine's or Martines
- part of big data you then can have a digital simulcram or a digital doppelganger that will certainly look
- like you it will sound like you a voice and images are not that difficult but more remarkably we'll begin to think and
- analyze and perhaps even feel like you because it will have had access to so much of your history this is such a wild
- thought so a few a few questions about this I think what many of us think about artificial intelligence we think about
- sort of thinking thinking thinking programs memories we can map problem solving you know yes a computer can play
- chess we get all that part of the something that I certainly hadn't thought about before reading your book
- was oh it's gonna look and sound like me it's gonna be a clone of me why would we
- want that well I think people want it in a number of different applications it's
- remarkable to me Catherine how many new technological developments have arisen from trying to help with a human
- disability for example the telephone which we all take for granted that grew out of Alexander Graham Bell's efforts
- to help the deaf another example of the scanner which we use to every scan me this PDF me that that arose out of Ray
- Kurzweil efforts to help the blind find a way to read things other than Braille information so what's happening right
- now is that as with the aging population there are larger larger numbers of people who are suffering from dementia
- and Alzheimer's and my own company United therapeutics has already received a patent on what we call an Alzheimer's
- cognitive an abler and this would be a software system that would employ visual recognition image recognition voice
- synthesis and voice recognition to be able to interact with family and friends visiting an Alzheimer's patient who has
- lost the ability to interact on their own wow that is that is mind-boggling so I'm reminded of discussions about you
- know and when if we sign an agreement you know do not resuscitate if we're when we would make a decision that we're
- ready to die but this might be our body our doppelganger our mind clone is making the decision for us based on our
- thinking our thoughts encoded in this machine when we can't think them any way absolutely Catholic but whoa flashback
- fifty years ago okay imagine like our grandparents yeah can you imagine our grandparents signing
- a do not resuscitate order I mean they would say what do you mean resuscitation I mean my heart stops I'm dead the
- notion of like there being an AED every hundred feet in in a shopping mall that could bring a dead person back to life
- that doesn't exist fifty years ago and now we think it's routinely possible that if you code in a hospital the odds
- are not 100% but are pretty good that they can bring you back and hence lawyer said you know you if you don't want to
- come back with the tube in your mouth and tubes out your nose and whatnot you better sign a DNR order so and so it is
- for the 21st century generation they'll get comfortable with the fact that there
- will be mine clones some people will want their mine clone to continue to go already there are apps on Twitter for
- example the tagline is when your heart stops beating you keep tweeting okay I saw that in your book that is so
- creepy yeah but you know it's it's creepy to actually bring a dead person back to life yet we do that routinely so
- I have in my book what I call a social acceptance of weirdness chart and things that are creepy or weird whatever word
- we want to use they change over time in society there was a time when there would have been nothing creepier than
- the notion of in vitro fertilization and a test-tube baby was considered an abomination there are now something like
- 2% of all births in America are IVF burst I mean it's a common way to be it's a big minority group and I do
- believe that as we move forward with these virtual humans a future version probably not passed the 2020s of DNR
- orders are going to include my mind clone and and it would seem to me that this really will could change so many
- things including in some fundamental way perhaps our our relationship to death our sense of I mean it would assume a
- lot of rationality on our parts I might to not be sad to leave my family but I'm
- leaving my mind clone behind you'll interact with my mind clone more amazing to me Katherine is how it's going to
- redefine our vision of life because for the first time in our lives we will be able to talk to ourselves outside of
- ourselves I mean I don't think I'm more or less vain than the actual than the average person but it's pretty hard to
- like pass a mirror in the morning without checking yourself out you know and all the time every single person
- bounces ideas back and forth in their head should I do this shouldn't I do this should I go out with this person
- shouldn't I go out to this with this person to have a chance to actually discuss those things in a coherent
- objective way with our mind clone is I think going to make our lives much more vibrant much more interesting and people
- in the next few decades will wonder how the humans ever get through life without
- a mind clone really it is it is a it is a mind-boggling proposition maybe what it does to therapy right and maybe you
- could just tell people all the time I say you know the two best professions I recommend for people
- in the 21st century is cyber psychology and that by that I mean a cyber psychology by that I mean being a
- psychologist who is an expert on on cyber consciousness or what might be also called cognitive commuting
- computing is a more secular turn left less loaded term than cyber consciousness people would say what that
- implies that there is consciousness cognitive computing means sort of the same thing but it's a little bit less of
- a loaded term so cyber psychologists I think are going to be a huge profession and these will be psychologists who are
- experts in determining whether or not some software that purports to be conscious that purports to be autonomous
- that purports to be empathetic that purports to value its life actually is or whether it's just a fancy puppet and
- I point out in my book you know it's a transgendered woman I went through a similar experience when I transition
- from male to female I it was necessary for my legal documentation as a woman to meet with psychologists for a period of
- years and they were looking at me and talking to me and analyzing is this somebody who really feels like a woman
- is this somebody who really is a woman although without the female female phenotype is this somebody who their
- soul is that of a woman soul and you know they had to reach a judgment so there's a subset of psychologists that
- work on that cyber psychologists would be much much larger the second grade field I I recommend to people in the
- future and I know a lot of people gonna hate me for this but cyber law ultimately the way although I mean I
- know a lot of people feel we have enough lawyers and you know we do have a lot of
- lawyers but there are very very few of the lawyers out here right now who are prepared to deal with questions of cyber
- law of the legal rights and obligations of mine clones are these virtual humans are they agents of the biological human
- so that everything that the virtual human does is in fact the responsibility of the biological human that created
- them these are going to be major legal issues the civil rights issues will be almost as big as the women
- and gay and african-american civil rights movements all combined and you and so you would like to get the world
- thinking about these issues and preparing for them and the reason I waited to write the book Katherine is I
- think that it's always better to be prepared for something and that's certainly been a big business adage of
- mine is to look around the corner one of the reasons why I'm excited about manufactured organs is I see how all the
- hard work we did on small molecules the ones that produce most of our company's revenues today is then under threat by
- generic companies after just a few years biologics which are more complex type of
- medicines made in living cells are much harder for companies to genera size but they too are under threat from a type of
- generic called a biosimilar so I'm trying to think of like you know what would be very hard for somebody to kind
- of gobble up all the value that we work so hard to create and certainly creating
- a whole organ is is sort of like the mother of all biologics it's a very very complicated thing to knock out but I
- digress a little bit only to say that if we if we don't think about these issues
- ahead of time I think mine clones will inevitably be created from the technological forces I mentioned at the
- beginning conscious mind clones I think will inevitably arise or at least many humans will feel they are conscious just
- as many humans feel their dogs and and their pets are conscious and some of those conscious cyber humans will be
- treated horribly because people do horrible things you know not all humans are good and and I believe that the
- psychic pain and the mental anguish to a cyber human is just as bad as a psychic
- pain or mental anguish to a flesh human pain pain is pain and pain is bad and this cyber human is not a machine it is
- something that is feeling pain it's not just a program that these bad things mean I feel that's not I mean that's
- something ultimately I think for psychologists and and lawyers to determine mostly
- psychologists on whether or not the pain is authentic there's a big diversion distribution of points of view on that
- some people feel that only something that is structured as the human brain could ever feel pain could ever feel
- emotion other people say well let's say if I built a replica of the human brain molecule by molecule with nanotubes and
- little nano machines wouldn't it still feel the same pain and the first camp then says some of them would say well
- upon birth you know God breathed the spirit into that flesh brain and only the spirit infused flesh brain could
- feel pain the so-called materialist philosophical point of view would say well if God breathed
- spirit into a flesh brain why would God not breathe the same spirit into the mechanized brain you are indeed a
- philosopher in addition to your many rules let me ask one more question about this these these cyber clones these
- money close as I contemplate them and as I contemplate this kind of technological
- advance it sounds very first world and and I wonder how you envision these developments affecting you know emerging
- economies economies where people living in extreme poverty what does that look like have you thought about that I have
- thought about a lot and and the book for two human covers it quite a bit it talks
- about the fact that nothing spreads faster and more democratically than does software it has zero manufacturing costs
- associated with it in the short span of our adult lives we went from only the wealthiest people
- having access to the world's knowledge at their fingertips with a Bloomberg terminal or being in a big academic
- library to the fact that now almost three-fourths of the world's population has a smartphone those smartphones can
- access Google and and other search engines and have access to the entire world's knowledge and apps such as on
- messaging apps are in fact free Facebook Twitter most of their customers are in fact
- outside the US there are more social media users in China than there are in all of the previously considered first
- world Google one of the most successful companies in history is devoting a full-fledged
- effort to wire all of Africa by floating stratospheric balloons that will provide
- high high speed bandwidth all over all of Africa already the rate of cellphone adoption in Africa is faster than it was
- in the United States so I believe that the the thing I like best of all about this field of virtual humanity is I
- believe that it will democratize faster than any technology in history fascinating and let me just to wrap up I
- mean some some folks have referred to you as sort of a transhuman trans everything certainly your you you have
- this passion of breaking through boundaries of all of all kinds technological communication gender so
- coming back to you where where does that that passion come from has this always been part of you to push through the
- boundaries well I I think it's too much to say that like I pushed through all boundaries and I'm trans everything I am
- transgendered I do believe in the transhumanist philosophy especially the ethical transhumanist philosophy I I am
- very much of a pro migration PEEP person I believe that if there aren't tariffs on porkbelly's and semiconductors and
- there shouldn't be tariffs on people and people should be free to go wherever they want to go where that comes from I
- to me it's just kind of logical deduction actually I mean I was brought up in tradition of two schools of
- thought that boasts both promoted freedom of movement one I was brought up Jewish and the Jewish history is
- basically one of being kicked out of this country kicked out of that country kicked out of another country and it was
- kind of beaten to my head as a little kid in in in the Hebrew day school that learning is important because people can
- take away everything that you have but they can't take away what's inside your head and then the other tradition I was
- brought up in was the American tradition of freedom and it's the notion that we came here to escape tyranny from Europe
- or poverty from Asia and then once we got here there was a quote unquote manifest destiny to reach from shore to
- shore so this instinct for movement there's a word called transhumance T RA NS h um ance it's not as well known as
- trans human but humans the root of that word is houmous which is the Latin for earth and human the argument is made
- that human populations are by nature transhumance because we moved out of africa at least four different times and
- before we settle down with agriculture we constantly move back and forth with the with the with the animals and the
- food sources that we've lived off of so I feel that I'm not so much a trans everything but I'm just like a human to
- the core yeah fascinating fascinating discussion thank you so much you know you you've brought us from traditional
- your childhood roots and and you know traditions to cyber clones in the future and everything in between thank you so
- much for being with us thanks for talking with me Catherine you
Brief Summary
Martine Rothblatt discusses her life, leadership, and the future of biotechnology and digital immortality.
Key points
- Martine Rothblatt: A Life of Innovation. Martine Rothblatt, a transgender woman and CEO, founded United Therapeutics to save her daughter.
- The Concept of Digital Immortality. Martine discusses how AI and big data could create digital versions of ourselves.
- The Future of Mind Clones. Exploring how mind clones could change our relationship with life and death.
- The Rise of Cyber Law. As technology evolves, so do the legal challenges surrounding virtual humans and their rights.
- Democratization Through Technology. Software spreads knowledge and access rapidly, changing lives globally.
- Transhumanism and Freedom of Movement. Exploring the philosophical roots of transhumanism and the instinct for human migration.
Episode highlights
- Martine Rothblatt: A Life of InnovationMartine Rothblatt, a transgender woman and CEO, founded United Therapeutics to save her daughter.“I just wanted to save my daughter.”7:43Dec 3, 2015
- The Concept of Digital ImmortalityMartine discusses how AI and big data could create digital versions of ourselves.“Digital immortality is a wild thought.”14:45Dec 3, 2015
- The Future of Mind ClonesExploring how mind clones could change our relationship with life and death.“We will be able to talk to ourselves outside of ourselves.”19:11Dec 3, 2015
- The Rise of Cyber LawAs technology evolves, so do the legal challenges surrounding virtual humans and their rights.“These are going to be major legal issues.”22:05Dec 3, 2015
- Democratization Through TechnologySoftware spreads knowledge and access rapidly, changing lives globally.“Nothing spreads faster and more democratically than software.”25:55Dec 3, 2015
- Transhumanism and Freedom of MovementExploring the philosophical roots of transhumanism and the instinct for human migration.“I believe that if there aren’t tariffs on porkbelly’s and semiconductors, there shouldn’t be tariffs on people.”28:13Dec 3, 2015
Tension
50/ 100Some tension





