The Pacific Ocean's Role in the Modern World

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Public Policy

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I'm Steve carbon publisher of Wharton digital press and I'm here today with Simon Winchester who's editor of a
  2. fascinating and wide-ranging new book Pacific which covers a great deal of ground to read from the subtitle silicon
  3. chips and surfboards coral reefs and atom bombs brutal dictators fading empires in the coming collision of the
  4. world's superpowers Simon good afternoon hello you begin your book earth being a book talk about
  5. the fact that the Pacific Ocean is coming to symbolize the future that the Mediterranean was once the Inland Sea of
  6. the ancient world the Atlantic to some people was the Inland Sea of the modern world and that you can argue that the
  7. Pacific Ocean will be the Inland Sea of tomorrow's world what does that mean well it's the place
  8. where at least in my view the two great civilizations finally meet and confront each other and we have humankind
  9. originating in Ethiopia with one group going off east to Mesopotamia and the Indus Valley and Peking and the other
  10. group going through the Balkans and up into Europe many Europeans crossing the Atlantic into the Americas and under the
  11. impress of the manifest destiny making their way west to the shores of the Pacific and then after Balboa first saw
  12. it in 15-20 crossing it and then confronting the other great civilization so you've got the East and civilization
  13. on the west side of the Pacific and the west and civilizations on the east side of the Pacific it's all a bit of
  14. geographical topsy-turvy damn and how do these two peoples deal with each other and the way that has happened is that in
  15. the past they have generally speaking colonized or brutalized or enslaved or in some way spoiled the lives of the
  16. Easterners but then in the beginning I suppose in the 1970s the Americans withdrew from Southeast Asia
  17. the British withdrew from their vast colonial Imperium in the Pacific Ocean the Germans the Japanese have left and
  18. the Pacific peoples are now says it were standing on their own two feet for the first time since we Europeans
  19. began interfering with their lives and now it seems to me that these two great civilizations are have the potential to
  20. cooperate at long last with one another and I think as a consequence of that we're seeing a real sort of hinge point
  21. of history that we're going to see that shift in the sort of dominance of let's say Rome and it's going to move now to
  22. the dominance of let us say Peking or Beijing very roughly and that change of order is going to happen in and around
  23. the Pacific which is why I think the Pacific is important in all of humankind's futures interestingly one
  24. underlying motive of your book is the when you notice the end of the Vasco de Gama era the sudden and very wholesale
  25. distribution of world power and then after you just know that after half a millennium of the West's dominating
  26. Pacific it now seems to be the turn of the Asians and you argue that it would be a good thing that the Asia for the
  27. Asians office are possibly of greatest stability for the region why should the Asians do a better job than the West
  28. Minister because with the single exception of the Japanese in a spasm of unpleasantness from the 1930s to the
  29. middle of the 1940s the Asians have been much more benign in their management of
  30. the world than we Westerners have I mean the Chinese to give a classy example I mean the most populous country on earth
  31. has not with the single exception of Tibet really overreached itself they have remained contentedly within their
  32. own borders they've been the Middle Kingdom John Wall they have been content with who they are and not wishing to
  33. export themselves culturally or imperially in the way that we Westerners done I mean we Westerners have gone
  34. around the world dominating and may enslaving and influencing millions billions of people and generally
  35. although leaving in the case of the British and the Americans leaving the legacy of the English language that's
  36. true and certain types of legal frameworks and so forth and one might argue railways and postal systems and so
  37. forth but nonetheless generally speaking we have left a legacy which is embedded
  38. in it the seeds of all sorts of conflicts I mean you've only got to look in the Middle East and look at the
  39. borders that we drew look at India Pakistan look at Northern Ireland look at Israel so Eastern countries have not
  40. done that kind of thing generally speaking yes there have been some excesses so I think I would rather live
  41. in a world run by Asians than in a rat world run by us is it likely to be that smoother transition are we likely to go
  42. from a world run by Asians we're run by us to world run by Asians without conflict and disorder well that's my
  43. hope I think no they're going to be all sorts of rough patches which may take many decades to resolve and out of the
  44. classical situation is the one evolving at the moment in in the South China Sea which is the Chinese have this fairly
  45. worked out stratagem of expanding their Navy into the Pacific they've already as
  46. it were taken a factor if not de jure control of the South China Sea and they have these imagine Bastion chains of
  47. islands extending outwards all the way up to Hawaii and they think and in my view quite reasonably the Americans have
  48. dominated the Pacific Ocean naval air for the last 60 years we're a Pacific nation we have a big Navy we're rich and
  49. influential why can't we at least have maritime equivalents well the Pentagon regards that as
  50. threatening idea regarded as threatening in the slightest because the Chinese are
  51. not likely to do what we have done which is to colonize and enslave and dominate
  52. they just want to as I say enjoy equivalents but so long as that is feared by people then there's the
  53. potential for conflict there's also the potential for accidents of course and so
  54. the potential for conflict will lead undeniably to confrontations here and there but in overall general long-term
  55. historical sense nothing that can't be dealt with and then it'll all settle down into this new world order I think
  56. one hopes China does seem to be extending its territoriality sequentially in the Pacific from the
  57. first chain to the second chain to the third chain how should the u.s. react to that I think by trying to understand why
  58. she's doing this why China is seeking this maritime equivalents and not being fearful of its potential because I don't
  59. think that it is dangerous I think I mean a classic example is is the Yangtze River I mean I was watching recently
  60. this wonderful film I daresay have seen it called the sand pebbles with Candice Bergen and Steve McQueen on an American
  61. gunboat in the Yangtze putting down all sorts of problems in the 1920s and 30s reminds us that American warships
  62. Italian German French and British warships were able to operate deep inside China on the Yangtze River for 50
  63. years and that if anyone committed a crime for a ship the Sailor got involved in a fight in Wuhan or Chongqing that
  64. wouldn't be judged by the Chinese courts heaven no we were not gonna have one of
  65. our people judged by a Chinese Magister see we'll try them on our own course it was this principle of
  66. extraterritoriality which we you know arrogantly assumed was right but how would we feel if the Chinese Navy were
  67. operating in the Mississippi and one of their sailors gets involved in a fight in Hannibal Missouri and says we don't
  68. want to be judged by your Missouri courts will be judged by our naval courts so because we have behaved in a
  69. certain way in the Pacific doesn't necessarily mean that the rest of the civilized world and no one would argue
  70. that China is not part of the civilized worlds I mean after all their civilization is 20 times as old as ours
  71. I think they'll behave in a perfectly civilized manner they simply want equivalents and they want respect and I
  72. think they should be given it will you characterize Western dominance in terms of aircraft carriers nuclear tests coral
  73. bleaching and pollution and argue that the Chinese warships and them being a little unfair will lead to
  74. reverence accommodation admiration and awe and the question is why should the Chinese warships going out to the second
  75. and third chain of islands be more benign than the Western warships were in the same place because they they're
  76. simply seeking equivalents they're not suggesting that their warships are there for any malign purpose it's simply a
  77. symbol of the extension of Chinese influence Chinese cultural influence will follow the flag if you like in the
  78. same way that trade tended to follow the flag I just don't think we need to fear
  79. them but the Pentagon does and of course what does the the military-industrial complex too modest or the Chinese are
  80. ramping up their Navy so we need to get a second aircraft carrier into the western Pacific and we need to buy more
  81. submarines and we all know that that's that leads to leads nowhere except whatever increasing tax burden on the
  82. American people and let me shift gears a minute and you talk about climate change
  83. and you know the increasing extreme weather events in the western Pacific and North America but then you argued
  84. that the point and the planet may heal itself and that the world in its creature who survived and that the
  85. Pacific Ocean could serve as a gigantic safety valve that's essential to the future of the planet
  86. how will the Pacific Ocean help to provide some self-regulating remedy to the man-made disruption of the well
  87. there are two answers to that one is that undeniably the Pacific simply because of its vastness is an enormous
  88. absorber of heat from the Sun I mean its water holds heat much longer than rocks
  89. do if you stand under a rock in the desert at night the rock goes cold if you stand in a body of water it will
  90. retain that heat for a very much longer time the Pacific absorbs heat and as it does so it produces because it's taking
  91. so much more heat at the moment it produces more ferocious weather locally bigger storms all that sort of thing but
  92. nonetheless it is there to absorb the heat and to create yes by doing so inconveniences for human
  93. kind but nonetheless for the planet as a whole the fact that it is absorbing heat
  94. is a good thing because this helps the planet as a whole disregarding humankind survive it maybe
  95. it helps it whether these changes these distortions in the atmosphere but there's another aspect of this which I
  96. found completely fascinating in which I discovered when I was writing a book about the Atlantic Ocean which is that
  97. there is this creature which we didn't even know existed until 1989 which exists in all the oceans of the world in
  98. the warm waters from about 40 North to about 30 south called prochlorococcus which is a single-celled algal creature
  99. which absorbs carbon dioxide and expels oxygen and this is the most numerous creature on the planet trillions upon
  100. trillions of these things which emit oxygen such that 1 in 5 of the breaths that you and I are taking in the studio
  101. today has been generated by a creature that we didn't even even know existed as recently as 1989 well the thing about
  102. prochlorococcus is it loves warm water and so the warmer the waters get the warm that the higher the temperature of
  103. the oceans produced by the global warming that we all disapprove of the more prochlorococcus they'll be the
  104. greater the range the more carbon dioxide they limit their there they'll absorb and the more oxygen they'll emit
  105. this is a classic example of the planet healing itself the Gaia theory James Lovelock's theory that the planet as a
  106. whole is a self-regulating mechanism we humans are in irrelevance really we're just we're soon going to be fossils we
  107. will love be like ammonites and tryla bites will just be another slightly more annoying temporary inhabitant of the
  108. planet the planet will be okay will disappear hoist on our own petard troubled by the troubles that we created
  109. you close by talking about sailing canoes in navigation in the attempt to replicate some of the older
  110. trans-pacific ventures could you talk about that a little bit and it all where we going in the future Hokulea is
  111. a traditional Hawaiian sailing canoe huge thing about 60 feet long twin hulls two sails built in 1976 by a group of
  112. Hawaiians as Hawaii's gift to America for the bicentenary they weren't just gifting the physical physical object of
  113. the canoe they were gifting the skill of navigating without instruments because that's what the Polynesians did for
  114. thousands of years before we came along they you know this is big triangle with Hawaii in the north and Easter Island in
  115. the east and New Zealand or air tiara in the West and the Polynesians would happily sail from Easter Island to New
  116. Zealand without using any instruments without any compass without any sixth and just by studying the movement of
  117. clouds the Stars the feel of the waves the tracks of seabirds and things and if they wanted to go 5,000 miles from from
  118. Easter Island they could in the old days until we came along and said sorry Easter Island is Chilean and the next
  119. islands are French and then there's a British and these are American islands to sail through them you'll need a
  120. passport and they said what what's a passport and they swirl you need application forms and they said we can't
  121. read or write we've never seen a need to and the navigation effectively died people stopped doing this there were one
  122. or two people that knew how to do it one in particular when they hold him up to Hawaii in 1976 taught a group of local
  123. Hawaiians how to sail this canoe without any instruments and he said we can get to Tahiti in six weeks and they got to
  124. Tahiti in exactly six weeks and this encouraged the Hawaiians and they set to learning these skills and they took
  125. their little boat up to Japan reminding the Japanese that they were very much of
  126. Pacific peoples they took it to Vancouver they took it to Chile and now they've become incredibly good at it and
  127. now they're sailing it around the world and this little craft is at the time we're talking she's just arrived in
  128. South Africa in Mossel Bay and she'll be going round Cape of Good Hope up in to the Atlantic Ocean and the aim is
  129. that by sometime this coming summer she will sail up the Potomac and show herself and introduce the crew of this
  130. remarkable venture to their Hawaiian president to remind him what Polynesian people should do and then they'll scoot
  131. down the east coast of South America through the Magellan straits and up two boards Hawaii and home it'll take four
  132. years to do the whole journey and my feeling is that if they get adequate publicity and we come to realize this
  133. extraordinary nature of this achievement then we will give to them and the ocean
  134. on which they're sailing something which has been sorely lacking from us Westerners and that is our respect and
  135. that's what I'm hoping for and I think that's what they're hoping for so Hokulea dot-com is the website that
  136. you can go to to follow the progress of this remarkable little craft salmon we Chesser thank you very much and again
  137. the book is called Pacific thank you very much indeed you

Brief Summary

Simon Winchester discusses his book <i>Pacific</i>, exploring the future of global power dynamics and climate change implications in the Pacific region.

Key points

  • The Pacific's Future. Simon Winchester argues that the Pacific Ocean symbolizes the future of global civilization.
  • A Shift in Power. Winchester discusses the potential for Asian civilizations to lead in the future.
  • Nature's Healing Power. Winchester explains how the Pacific Ocean could serve as a self-regulating remedy for the planet.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes