Topp William SF
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- I don't know where i saw the notice that you guys were putting together this program it was on one of
- the standard outlets maybe Wall Street Journal maybe Bloomberg but I read an article that you were putting together
- this forecasting tournament and that you were trying to find out what it is makes
- a good forecaster and I feel like I owe the system for so many years I've been doing research and I've relied on other
- people to contribute to that research and they have selflessly and so I'm a chronic volunteer as well when somebody
- says I need your help to do my research I volunteer for instance the new york blood center contacted me and said
- you're not allowed to give blood but we've got this research program and blood donation will you come in and
- donate a pint of blood every month so we can see what happens so I did that just
- to pay back the system so i'm paying back the system by being in the good judgment project
- I think that I make connections for instance I couldn't figure out why Putin was in Syria none of the explanations
- that people gave the talking heads made any sense to me Syria does not a join Russia the Ukraine does Syria is of no
- strategic importance to Putin why is he in Syria there was just no reason all of
- this business about how he couldn't let one of his henchmen down or else all the
- other henchmen would feel insecure just didn't buy that I wanted to make sense of that and all of a sudden I remembered
- something and that is that Putin is building up the bread Russian fleet in the Mediterranean but they don't have a
- home port in the Mediterranean so they have to go all the way back to Russia and the Black Sea to get a home port
- well where is Putin landing his troops next to the port of Latakia which is a major port on the Mediterranean so
- perhaps what Putin wants is a deal with Assad for a 50-year lease on the port of
- Latakia now that to me makes sense that would explain why Putin is in Syria it accomplishes a strategic thing for him
- it gives him a port for his Mediterranean fleet so I think that's probably part of the reason why I was
- successful I feel uncomfortable saying successful because I don't feel successful you tell me I was successful
- I don't feel successful it I that's part of the modus operandi that I go through
- is I I see disparate things and I try to make sense of them for instance another
- thing when the third Kim took over North Korea all of a sudden there was a huge round of executions including his own
- uncle he blew his uncle up with it aircraft anti-aircraft gun things were then fairly quiet and then another big
- round of executions I couldn't figure out why he was executing all these people I contacted somebody who was an expert
- in North Korean relations and I said while the executions he said well they've been more than you know they
- just not publicized have been to big rounds I thought what's going on here and then I saw something that said Kim
- has not yet traveled outside of North Korea not even to Beijing to visit his sponsors we don't know when Kim's going
- to travel outside of North Korea all of a sudden you put the two together perhaps the guys afraid that if he
- leaves the country he won't be able to come back that there'll be a coup in his absence and he's taking care of
- everybody who might be involved in such a coup and in fact he's now due to go to
- Moscow I think in december so again trying to make sense out of something just looking around at where how things
- might fit together to make things make more sense than they would otherwise 30 years ago a good friend of mine also
- named Barbara Barbara McClintock advised me over and over in our conversations that I should always questioned my
- fundamental assumptions my underlying assumptions and I think that's something that's been very important to me was
- Barbara's advice for instance a spacecraft just flew past jupiter and took a whole bunch of high-resolution
- pictures of Jupiter I'm sorry Pluto and took a whole bunch of high-resolution pictures of Pluto and son of a gun this
- 4.5 billion year old planet is geologically active and everybody is absolutely floored the solar system is
- 4.5 billion years old the planets are not supposed to be geologically active when they're the size of Pluto why is
- this so everybody's trying to figure out why 4.5 billion year old Pluto is by geologically active they're talking
- about more missions to Pluto have hundred-million-dollar missions half-billion-dollar missions I'm certain
- that there are all sorts of young planetary scientists who are trying to figure out how they can start their
- careers by figuring out and making a name for themselves wipe loot Pluto is geologically active well what's the
- underlying assumption here the underlying assumption is that Pluto's 4.5 billion years old what happens if
- Pluto isn't 4.5 billion years old what happens with Pluto is a good deal younger then in fact you expect it to be
- geologically active and there's no inconsistency here at all the inconsistency is that your fundamental
- assumption that Pluto is 4.5 billion years old was incorrect so I'd advise those young planetary scientists who are
- thinking about trying to explain how a 4.5 billion year old celestial body could be geologically active to question
- whether or not it's really 4.5 billion years old there's another something else that gets a lot more attention and
- that's it ran for the last four to five years the entire economy of the world has
- in an uproar because all of the major nations have slapped an embargo on dealing with Iran because Iran is trying
- to build a nuclear weapon and they had to negotiate long and hard with Iran to negotiate I ran away from a posture
- where they could be capable of building the nuclear weapon that they were trying
- to build and this brought us a lot closer to allies like Saudi Arabia to whom we perhaps should not be close and
- it's caused no end to trouble throughout the entire world particularly the Middle
- East which is troubled enough well what's the underlying assumption here that Iran wants to build a nuclear
- weapon they kept saying that they didn't want to build a nuclear weapon why didn't we believe them well we have x
- y&z reasons why we didn't believe them but again it's a fundamental assumption the entire foreign policy in the Middle
- East of nearly the entire world was dictated by the underlying assumption that Iran wanted to build a nuclear
- device I personally wouldn't want to build a nuclear device I can't see why Iran would want a nuclear device nuclear
- bombs are so 20th century we've moved on I happen to think Iran didn't particularly want to build a nuclear
- bomb but everybody's fundamental assumption was that it did and I would go out on a limb and I'd say that even
- in spite of all the acrimony that we've had over Iran that it's quite possible that in 20 years Iran will be our
- closest ally in the Middle East and the reason for that is that Iran is the largest Persian nation on earth the
- United States is the second-largest Persian nation on earth and Canada is the fourth-largest Persian nation on
- earth there's a natural affinity there and as soon as that embargo is lifted the Persians are not going to start
- doing deals with the British or the Chinese or the Russians they're going to do business with their Persian American
- friends so I see business between Iran Persia and the United States particularly the Persian community
- building very quickly I think that could lead to good political relations as well
- that would be a major casualty of misunderstanding Iran's intentions with nuclear weapons
- I recommend that when you come to a new field about which you know nothing that you browse the literature talk to people
- if you can attend lectures if you can and listen for the totem words the words which either consciously or
- unconsciously people in the field give special meeting and I find that if you can figure out what those totem words
- are and then go away and figure out what they mean you'll find out at least one of the things that's very important to
- people in the field that they don't say is important to them necessarily but they give it importance by continually
- using these totem words or continually emphasizing them for instance last week I went to grand rounds at our regional
- hospital and there was a cardiologist giving a talk and he was giving a talk on the pharmaceutical management of
- cardiac patients who had circulatory problems problems with blockages problems leakages he would go through a
- series of example patients this patient comes in with these symptoms what do you
- do we immediately stent this patient how do we drug this patient for the stent we're going to use this compound and
- we're going to use this compound but we're going to stay away from that compound because it can cause bleeding
- and we don't want bleeding now this patient has got a partially occluded artery and is in a lot of pain we're
- going to give this patient warfarin because we need to dissolve that clot and prevent it from growing however
- we're not going to give this patient these other two drugs because they can lead to bleeding even worse than
- warfarin can lead to bleeding we give combinations of these drugs because it reduces bleeding bleeding this bleeding
- that what I came away from not knowing really that very much about how to treat cardiac patients was that if we can
- generalize from just this one talk what's most important is to keep the patient from bleeding no
- matter what you do and so if I was given a new drug and asked to predict whether
- or not it was going to be a success the first thing I look at is whether it causes uncontrolled bleeding or not what
- the likelihood is how it can be combined with other things all from a standpoint
- of does it cause bleeding now that doesn't give you the answer to how that new drug is going to do but it gives you
- a lead into it so that you can then begin to understand how things are going on so I'd say look for the totem words
- when you're reading an article look for the words that the author of the article
- seems to come back to over and over and then start by figuring out what those words mean
- I've been very insecure all my life for a variety of reasons and I never really thought very much of my own opinions I
- always figured well is the world crazy or is it me in the answer was I must be crazy I think the good judgment project
- has shown me that occasionally I'm right and other people are wrong which is not
- something that I expected going in I expected to be wrong all the time and curiously and I've seen this in Phil's
- book and I've heard it from other people the things about which I was most wrong
- with the things I was supposed to know something about namely the medical questions so I think the good judgment
- project has given me a little bit of confidence in myself that I didn't have before I went into it
- you
Brief Summary
Participants discuss forecasting, geopolitical analysis, and the importance of questioning assumptions in research.
Key points
- The Good Judgment Project. A participant reflects on their journey and contributions to forecasting research.
- Putin's Strategy in Syria. Exploring the geopolitical motivations behind Putin's actions in Syria.
- Questioning Assumptions. The importance of questioning fundamental assumptions in various fields.
Episode highlights
- The Good Judgment ProjectA participant reflects on their journey and contributions to forecasting research.“I feel like I owe the system for so many years.”0:29Feb 25, 2016
- Putin's Strategy in SyriaExploring the geopolitical motivations behind Putin's actions in Syria.“Perhaps what Putin wants is a deal with Assad for a 50-year lease on the port of Latakia.”2:25Feb 25, 2016
- Questioning AssumptionsThe importance of questioning fundamental assumptions in various fields.“I should always question my fundamental assumptions.”4:44Feb 25, 2016
Episode quotes
Tension
45/ 100Some tension





