Topp William SF

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I don't know where i saw the notice that you guys were putting together this program it was on one of
  2. the standard outlets maybe Wall Street Journal maybe Bloomberg but I read an article that you were putting together
  3. this forecasting tournament and that you were trying to find out what it is makes
  4. a good forecaster and I feel like I owe the system for so many years I've been doing research and I've relied on other
  5. people to contribute to that research and they have selflessly and so I'm a chronic volunteer as well when somebody
  6. says I need your help to do my research I volunteer for instance the new york blood center contacted me and said
  7. you're not allowed to give blood but we've got this research program and blood donation will you come in and
  8. donate a pint of blood every month so we can see what happens so I did that just
  9. to pay back the system so i'm paying back the system by being in the good judgment project
  10. I think that I make connections for instance I couldn't figure out why Putin was in Syria none of the explanations
  11. that people gave the talking heads made any sense to me Syria does not a join Russia the Ukraine does Syria is of no
  12. strategic importance to Putin why is he in Syria there was just no reason all of
  13. this business about how he couldn't let one of his henchmen down or else all the
  14. other henchmen would feel insecure just didn't buy that I wanted to make sense of that and all of a sudden I remembered
  15. something and that is that Putin is building up the bread Russian fleet in the Mediterranean but they don't have a
  16. home port in the Mediterranean so they have to go all the way back to Russia and the Black Sea to get a home port
  17. well where is Putin landing his troops next to the port of Latakia which is a major port on the Mediterranean so
  18. perhaps what Putin wants is a deal with Assad for a 50-year lease on the port of
  19. Latakia now that to me makes sense that would explain why Putin is in Syria it accomplishes a strategic thing for him
  20. it gives him a port for his Mediterranean fleet so I think that's probably part of the reason why I was
  21. successful I feel uncomfortable saying successful because I don't feel successful you tell me I was successful
  22. I don't feel successful it I that's part of the modus operandi that I go through
  23. is I I see disparate things and I try to make sense of them for instance another
  24. thing when the third Kim took over North Korea all of a sudden there was a huge round of executions including his own
  25. uncle he blew his uncle up with it aircraft anti-aircraft gun things were then fairly quiet and then another big
  26. round of executions I couldn't figure out why he was executing all these people I contacted somebody who was an expert
  27. in North Korean relations and I said while the executions he said well they've been more than you know they
  28. just not publicized have been to big rounds I thought what's going on here and then I saw something that said Kim
  29. has not yet traveled outside of North Korea not even to Beijing to visit his sponsors we don't know when Kim's going
  30. to travel outside of North Korea all of a sudden you put the two together perhaps the guys afraid that if he
  31. leaves the country he won't be able to come back that there'll be a coup in his absence and he's taking care of
  32. everybody who might be involved in such a coup and in fact he's now due to go to
  33. Moscow I think in december so again trying to make sense out of something just looking around at where how things
  34. might fit together to make things make more sense than they would otherwise 30 years ago a good friend of mine also
  35. named Barbara Barbara McClintock advised me over and over in our conversations that I should always questioned my
  36. fundamental assumptions my underlying assumptions and I think that's something that's been very important to me was
  37. Barbara's advice for instance a spacecraft just flew past jupiter and took a whole bunch of high-resolution
  38. pictures of Jupiter I'm sorry Pluto and took a whole bunch of high-resolution pictures of Pluto and son of a gun this
  39. 4.5 billion year old planet is geologically active and everybody is absolutely floored the solar system is
  40. 4.5 billion years old the planets are not supposed to be geologically active when they're the size of Pluto why is
  41. this so everybody's trying to figure out why 4.5 billion year old Pluto is by geologically active they're talking
  42. about more missions to Pluto have hundred-million-dollar missions half-billion-dollar missions I'm certain
  43. that there are all sorts of young planetary scientists who are trying to figure out how they can start their
  44. careers by figuring out and making a name for themselves wipe loot Pluto is geologically active well what's the
  45. underlying assumption here the underlying assumption is that Pluto's 4.5 billion years old what happens if
  46. Pluto isn't 4.5 billion years old what happens with Pluto is a good deal younger then in fact you expect it to be
  47. geologically active and there's no inconsistency here at all the inconsistency is that your fundamental
  48. assumption that Pluto is 4.5 billion years old was incorrect so I'd advise those young planetary scientists who are
  49. thinking about trying to explain how a 4.5 billion year old celestial body could be geologically active to question
  50. whether or not it's really 4.5 billion years old there's another something else that gets a lot more attention and
  51. that's it ran for the last four to five years the entire economy of the world has
  52. in an uproar because all of the major nations have slapped an embargo on dealing with Iran because Iran is trying
  53. to build a nuclear weapon and they had to negotiate long and hard with Iran to negotiate I ran away from a posture
  54. where they could be capable of building the nuclear weapon that they were trying
  55. to build and this brought us a lot closer to allies like Saudi Arabia to whom we perhaps should not be close and
  56. it's caused no end to trouble throughout the entire world particularly the Middle
  57. East which is troubled enough well what's the underlying assumption here that Iran wants to build a nuclear
  58. weapon they kept saying that they didn't want to build a nuclear weapon why didn't we believe them well we have x
  59. y&z reasons why we didn't believe them but again it's a fundamental assumption the entire foreign policy in the Middle
  60. East of nearly the entire world was dictated by the underlying assumption that Iran wanted to build a nuclear
  61. device I personally wouldn't want to build a nuclear device I can't see why Iran would want a nuclear device nuclear
  62. bombs are so 20th century we've moved on I happen to think Iran didn't particularly want to build a nuclear
  63. bomb but everybody's fundamental assumption was that it did and I would go out on a limb and I'd say that even
  64. in spite of all the acrimony that we've had over Iran that it's quite possible that in 20 years Iran will be our
  65. closest ally in the Middle East and the reason for that is that Iran is the largest Persian nation on earth the
  66. United States is the second-largest Persian nation on earth and Canada is the fourth-largest Persian nation on
  67. earth there's a natural affinity there and as soon as that embargo is lifted the Persians are not going to start
  68. doing deals with the British or the Chinese or the Russians they're going to do business with their Persian American
  69. friends so I see business between Iran Persia and the United States particularly the Persian community
  70. building very quickly I think that could lead to good political relations as well
  71. that would be a major casualty of misunderstanding Iran's intentions with nuclear weapons
  72. I recommend that when you come to a new field about which you know nothing that you browse the literature talk to people
  73. if you can attend lectures if you can and listen for the totem words the words which either consciously or
  74. unconsciously people in the field give special meeting and I find that if you can figure out what those totem words
  75. are and then go away and figure out what they mean you'll find out at least one of the things that's very important to
  76. people in the field that they don't say is important to them necessarily but they give it importance by continually
  77. using these totem words or continually emphasizing them for instance last week I went to grand rounds at our regional
  78. hospital and there was a cardiologist giving a talk and he was giving a talk on the pharmaceutical management of
  79. cardiac patients who had circulatory problems problems with blockages problems leakages he would go through a
  80. series of example patients this patient comes in with these symptoms what do you
  81. do we immediately stent this patient how do we drug this patient for the stent we're going to use this compound and
  82. we're going to use this compound but we're going to stay away from that compound because it can cause bleeding
  83. and we don't want bleeding now this patient has got a partially occluded artery and is in a lot of pain we're
  84. going to give this patient warfarin because we need to dissolve that clot and prevent it from growing however
  85. we're not going to give this patient these other two drugs because they can lead to bleeding even worse than
  86. warfarin can lead to bleeding we give combinations of these drugs because it reduces bleeding bleeding this bleeding
  87. that what I came away from not knowing really that very much about how to treat cardiac patients was that if we can
  88. generalize from just this one talk what's most important is to keep the patient from bleeding no
  89. matter what you do and so if I was given a new drug and asked to predict whether
  90. or not it was going to be a success the first thing I look at is whether it causes uncontrolled bleeding or not what
  91. the likelihood is how it can be combined with other things all from a standpoint
  92. of does it cause bleeding now that doesn't give you the answer to how that new drug is going to do but it gives you
  93. a lead into it so that you can then begin to understand how things are going on so I'd say look for the totem words
  94. when you're reading an article look for the words that the author of the article
  95. seems to come back to over and over and then start by figuring out what those words mean
  96. I've been very insecure all my life for a variety of reasons and I never really thought very much of my own opinions I
  97. always figured well is the world crazy or is it me in the answer was I must be crazy I think the good judgment project
  98. has shown me that occasionally I'm right and other people are wrong which is not
  99. something that I expected going in I expected to be wrong all the time and curiously and I've seen this in Phil's
  100. book and I've heard it from other people the things about which I was most wrong
  101. with the things I was supposed to know something about namely the medical questions so I think the good judgment
  102. project has given me a little bit of confidence in myself that I didn't have before I went into it
  103. you

Brief Summary

Participants discuss forecasting, geopolitical analysis, and the importance of questioning assumptions in research.

Key points

  • The Good Judgment Project. A participant reflects on their journey and contributions to forecasting research.
  • Putin's Strategy in Syria. Exploring the geopolitical motivations behind Putin's actions in Syria.
  • Questioning Assumptions. The importance of questioning fundamental assumptions in various fields.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes