Wharton's Franklin Allen on China's Currency Policies

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Wharton finance professor Franklin Allen discusses the dispute over exchange rates between China and Western countries, and why this conflict is so difficult to resolve. 📂 Finance & Accounting

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] China and Western countries been squabbling over exchange rates for years
  2. the United States and many other countries accused China buying dollars to keep China's currency weaker than it
  3. would be otherwise that makes Chinese Goods cheaper in other countries and it makes it more expensive for the Chinese
  4. to buy from foreigners in the United States politicians and Regulators say China's policy undermine exports costing
  5. American jobs knowledge at Wharton has invited Professor Franklin Allen professor of Finance to explain what's
  6. at stake and why this conflict is so hard to resolve the first thing I that I've
  7. noticed in this is that uh the China currency issue is one of the few things that Democrats and Republicans seem to
  8. agree on and I'm curious whether you believe that China's manipulating its currency so I think manipulation is an
  9. emotive word they're doing what many countries have done through much of History which is to fix their exchange
  10. rate relative to another currency and through much of the Breton Woods period of course this is what pretty much every
  11. country did it's what the Europeans are doing to an extreme degree in the Euro but it's not too much different than
  12. what they did in the exchange rate mechanism before the euro was introduced and it's not too much different from
  13. what the entrance into the Euro have to do before they actually enter properly and fix um the exchange rate so I I
  14. think manipulation is the wrong word they're fixing their exchange rate for sure and uh I gather that the the the
  15. intent is to keep the Chinese currency weaker uh in in in relation to the dollar or is that is that right and and
  16. what's the what's the reason for doing that how do they benefit so this is a complicated
  17. question originally I think it's for the same reason that European countries wanted the Euro if if you want to export
  18. it's good to have a fixed exchange rate and China thought that this was something that was beneficial for them
  19. some time ago over time we've evolved and I think we're now in in a rather different position so originally they
  20. didn't run big surpluses they didn't have big reserves but then what's happened over time is that particular
  21. after the Asian crisis many countries have built up big reserves so the Chinese are by no means the only ones if
  22. you look at the smaller countries like South Korea and countries like that they've also built up reserves I think
  23. there are many reasons for that part of it was that the way that the IMF treated
  24. Asian countries in the 1997 Asian crisis LED them to believe that because the governance structure is dominated by the
  25. Europeans and the Americans the Asians don't get a fair look in I think their response to that has been we need to
  26. have reserves instead and this is one big reason for the reserves I think for the Chinese in addition they've realized
  27. over time that reserves give them a very great deal of political power with respect to the US so when President
  28. Obama goes to visit he's very polite he doesn't mention too many things about human rights and so forth because we owe
  29. them two and a half trillion the other reason which is the one that's given a lot of play in The Press is
  30. that by doing this by keeping the exchange rate low they're making it easier for their exporters and I think
  31. there's some truth to that but I think that it's much more complicated than is usually presented and and just give us a
  32. couple examples of what are the complicating factors that we don't usually consider well I think when the
  33. us or the Europeans say what you need to do is to let it move it's not clear what the the the
  34. short-term rate would be or the medium-term rate or the long-term rate if they simply allowed it to float it's
  35. true that there's a deficit on the current account at the moment that's been there for a few years now but
  36. there's also the capital account and whereas I'm sure there's lots of money wanting to get into China because they
  37. perceive the R&B to be a strong currency I think that the reverse is also true there's a lot of money that wants to get
  38. out of China first of all Chinese people don't have many instruments to invest in
  39. and that would give them so many more if they could take their money out and also
  40. of course there's the political reason that if you want to hedge the risk if you think that we may have problems in
  41. China going forward then also they may want to take money out in the short run it's not clear which of those balances
  42. would Dominate and in the medium term the long run it's not so clear either given differences in inflation rates and
  43. so on so it's more complex than portrayed my own view is that probably in the long run the R&B will strengthen
  44. and it probably is a good long-term invest investment so I think the there would be differences
  45. from now if the Western View is is often overly simplified I'm just curious whether it's possible the Chinese view
  46. is overly simplified as well well the problem is now I think you know if you take the long run view
  47. it's ironically both countries are on the wrong side because what the Chinese essentially are doing is giving us Goods
  48. real things for pieces of paper in other words dollars we're getting to consume it they're getting pieces of paper whose
  49. value is very uncertain in the long run even if you think that there will be a revaluation of 20% given their reserves
  50. are now about 50% or more of GDP if it we had a 20% appreciation in the R&B they're
  51. going to lose about 10% of GMP this is an enormous loss for them it's about the same as trade for a year their
  52. net contribution of trade is about 10% of GDP so this is a sense in which they're running a big risk but it's also
  53. the sense in which when we say okay you need to let it float what we're doing is
  54. essentially going against our consumer interests people always talk about jobs and the necessity of saving jobs but
  55. these are relatively shortterm interest at least in normal times compared to these long run interests of them giving
  56. us Goods below price and us giving them dollars in in exchange now uh the the mechanics of
  57. influencing exchange rates is more complex than just saying this is what we want it to be uh can you just briefly
  58. give us a glimpse into how it's done it's purchasing us treasuries or whatever it is this process so
  59. essentially they go out and they put purchase us treasuries oh so what happens is there's either current
  60. account Surplus or some inflow of dollars into the into China so the Central Bank gets dollars and they give
  61. people who have exported say R&B in exchange they then go out and sterilize those which means they increase Bank
  62. Reserves or they sell government bonds so they don't have inflation in China and what the net result of all this is
  63. is that they end up with a lot of foreign reserves and they have offsetting debt now in the long run as I
  64. say this is not good for them it's very risky and what they need to do is to change it to get rid of this process and
  65. move towards having the R&B as a reserve currency we need the R&B to be like the
  66. Euro and the dollar and for them to be able to behave in the same way that the US and the EUR Europeans do they don't
  67. need reserves if they have a reserve currency and that will make everything much easier and avoid all these problems
  68. that we've been talking about and this process that you've described the the the result in the end is that it it
  69. affects the balance of supply and demand of dollars uh and and that that affects
  70. the exchange rate it does exactly this issue is is one of those things that that sort of comes up you hear about
  71. about it it's a big thing in the news there may be some meeting or some uh Us official will give a speech and there's
  72. a we're all in a tizzy for a while and then it kind of dies down and then it comes back again how important is it
  73. really so I think the exchange rate issue in itself is not that important in the medium term I think in
  74. the long run it's very important they move to being a reserve currency but the problem is we've now got politics
  75. involved and the Americans and the Europeans demanding that the Chinese change their policies is not a good way
  76. to go because the Chinese won't do it simply for the reason that we're asking them to do it I think they realize that
  77. in the long run they need to move towards having the R&B as a reserve currency they're doing many things in
  78. that direction for example they're beginning to clear trade in R&B they're allow owing R&B issues in Hong Kong by
  79. Foreign corporations like McDonald's these are all moves towards having the R&B as an international currency the one
  80. thing that remains is to have an open Capital account and a completely flexible exchange rate they know that
  81. they should do that but the more we tell them to do it the less likely they're going to do it a good example of
  82. how much they dislike being being told what to do was provided by the border dispute that they're having in the East
  83. China Sea in particular with Japan and the fact that they were so strident in cancelling the visit by the Thousand
  84. youths to shangai for the Expo by the Prime Minister making speeches after a very short time shows how willing they
  85. are to be aggressive in these kinds of issues and I think if we try and push them we won't be able to and our
  86. position is basically the weaker one because we're the ones that owe them the two and a half trillion if they start
  87. selling and moving money into Euros or into any of these other currencies we're quite vulnerable I think no nobody likes
  88. to be bullied right and the Chinese have 150 years of being bullied by the west and
  89. this is something that they feel very strongly about in the west I I sometimes wonder whether uh uh blaming China for
  90. for problems is just a convenient way of not admitting that you're causing your own problems is is that part of what's
  91. going on here I think that is part of what's going on here I think we don't save enough we rely too much on being
  92. able to issue issue dollars and borrow and this is a longrun problem we need to start being more like the Germans and
  93. being more fiscally responsible and hopefully these problems will then go away I I don't think we're doing our
  94. part we're trying to insist that the Chinese do there but I I think we've got into this very bad position now and what
  95. do you think are the prospects that this could escalate into a trade war and a protectionist era that that would be
  96. damaging to everybody I think it's quite likely that we will get into a situation not of trade Wars I think that
  97. the the the WTO is sufficiently strong that whereas we won't make much progress I don't think we'll go backwards but I
  98. do think it's quite likely that governments will start intervening as they already have done in Japan and many
  99. other Asian countries and that this is not a good thing we're already printing too much money with quantitative easing
  100. the last thing we need is for these Asian countries to also be printing money to keep currencies down down and
  101. if you were to look around the world and say this is the organization or the country or the head of state or whatever
  102. that is in a position to do something to break this Log Jam uh who would that be I
  103. think the Americans and Europeans need to back off on this issue I think the people who can solve it in the long term
  104. is the next generation of Chinese leaders so when the new president and the new prime minister come in I think
  105. that they will hopefully look very hard at this problem realize that having the R&B as a reserve currency is a very
  106. important thing in the long run for China and that they will then go about dismantling these exchange controls and
  107. having it float but we're a long way from there unfortunately we'll have to be very patient I guess thank you very
  108. much thank you Jeff

Brief Summary

Professor Franklin Allen discusses China's currency policies and the complexities of U.S.-China economic relations.

Key points

  • China's Currency Manipulation Debate. The U.S. accuses China of manipulating its currency to gain trade advantages.
  • The Risk of Trade Wars. Concerns arise over potential trade wars and government interventions in currency markets.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes