Why More Dating Options Can Lead to Fewer Matches

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Wharton professor Pinar Yildirim explains how online dating platforms—especially mobile apps—have transformed how people meet, match, and form relationships. She discusses why expanding the pool of potential partners can sometimes reduce match quality and how limited information and low effort change behavior. Yildirim also shares research on how these shifts are linked to changing marriage patterns and declining marriage and divorce rates.

ABOUT THE PODCAST Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

#OnlineDating #MarriageTrends #BehavioralEconomics #DatingApps #DatingApp ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. expanding the number of people that you can meet that um just creates the opportunity of meeting someone you might
  2. like who's not necessarily in your immediate social circle. But as we start to increase the the pool size even
  3. further especially in the mobile world where we have um virtually endless number of potential candidates that we
  4. can meet that's going to to effectively ultimately uh reflect on the the likelihood of a match likelihood of you
  5. meeting someone who will also meet you and and like you back and as a result actually increasing the pool size can
  6. have a negative impact on the on the match likelihood or the likelihood um finding or and and forming a positive
  7. relationship. >> Welcome to the Ripple Effect, the podcast that takes you on a journey
  8. through the minds of Wharton faculty. I'm your host, Dan Looney, and in each episode, we'll be diving deep into the
  9. inspiration behind the groundbreaking research that Wharton professors have conducted and exploring how their
  10. findings resonate with the world today. In the digital age that we live in, even
  11. dating has found its place with various websites for people to potentially connect in a way different than maybe
  12. historically we know that it has been the case. But how have those sites impacted things like marriages and the
  13. outcomes of those unions? Wharton professor Pinar Yilderum has been part of a group researching these components
  14. in a brand new study just released and she joins us right now. Penar, great to talk to you again. How are you?
  15. >> I'm great then. Thanks for having me. >> Just in general, these sites are obviously growing in usage. So
  16. understanding the types of impact that they are having, that's a very important component, a kind of a logical next step
  17. to understand just how much impact they're having. Yes, absolutely. The the impact of
  18. online dating apps, online dating platforms have been massive. If we look at the the technologies through which
  19. people meet. In fact, uh if you were to just go back about 20 years ago, online dating apps would be considered pretty
  20. much a stigma. Uh fast forward another 10 11 years around 2011 online dating platforms have uh taken over as the the
  21. majority way through which people meet and couples are formed. In fact in United States today about 50% of couples
  22. are formed through online dating platforms. So it's important to understand the the effects of these
  23. platforms on especially how relationships are formed and how the relationships uh might come to an end.
  24. So take us through the research and how you kind of went about it. >> So yeah, I mean we got curious naturally
  25. about the effects of these platforms on what kind of relationships are formed, what uh its impacts these the platforms
  26. impacts are on marriage and divorce rates as well as some health outcomes. We collected data from majority of the
  27. online dating platforms going back to about uh 2002. again focusing first on the the
  28. platforms that might have primarily operated through desktop and then later on focusing on the the mobile uh
  29. platforms, mobile apps. >> How important is it to make that differentiation between what we saw
  30. maybe two decades ago when we were basically living on our computers but it was a desktop to now where we are where
  31. the digital our smartphones uh are so important to us in our lives. It's important because we have uh seen
  32. significant changes as we went from the desktop platforms to to mobile phones where we have a very limited small
  33. screen. And I think the important question one needs to ask is especially compared to the offline methods of
  34. dating. How did these new technologies change the the way people interact with each other? And how does the desktop
  35. version of desktop technology of meeting others differ from the the mobile uh technology of of meeting romantic
  36. partners? And uh from an economic perspective, we have decided we have identified at least three ways through
  37. which we can think of these technologies to differ from the offline world. Of course, one is the the sort of the size
  38. of the pool of individuals that you might be able to reach out to through these platforms relative to the offline
  39. world. If you're only constrained in terms of meeting others um in in real world, that's going to reduce the number
  40. of people that you could interact with and the types of people that you can interact. You typically will be uh or
  41. you'll be more much more likely to meet individuals who might be nearby you and who might be much more similar to you.
  42. Whereas of course with the desktop platforms first and later on with the mobile apps we have dramatically
  43. expanded the pool size of whom we can meet and the number of people we can meet and and that has both positive and
  44. and negative effects. On the one hand of course expanding the number of people that you can meet that um just creates
  45. the opportunity of meeting someone you might like who's not necessarily in your immediate social circle. But as we start
  46. to increase the the pool size even further especially in the mobile world where we have um virtually endless
  47. number of potential candidates that we can meet that's going to to effectively ultimately uh reflect on the the
  48. likelihood of a match likelihood of you meeting someone who will also meet you and and invite you back. And as a
  49. result, actually increasing the pool size can have a negative impact on the on the match likelihood or the
  50. likelihood of um binding or and and forming a a positive relationship. Um it second factor is of course the the the
  51. noise or the uh potential information that you can identify about the individuals that you are meeting with.
  52. Even though we could meet endless number of people, the amount of information, the amount of true information that we
  53. can gather about these individuals is going to be fairly limited, especially because um in the the mobile world where
  54. we have very limited short profiles, the number of information pieces, the the amount of information that you can
  55. consume about a single individual is quite limited. So as we went from the the offline world into a desktop world,
  56. even though we could gather potentially more information about individuals in a short period of time, as we moved back
  57. to the mobile world, that information has significantly shrunk. So now we're looking at a potentially noisier world
  58. in terms of gathering information about people. At the same time a third factor this is how much time or how much effort
  59. we have to put into when it comes to trying to to g information about individuals or trying to source the
  60. profiles in real life if you wanted to meet I don't know 10 20 people in a single day that would be a very costly
  61. thing to do going meeting exerting effort to to get to learn about these individuals in uh the desktop world as
  62. well as the mobile world this has dramatically gone down the cost and effort uh in in fact in mobile world of course
  63. the test simply became a finger act just a simple swipe of trying to to interact
  64. and and learn about robots. So those factors um play a role when it comes to shaping relationships and that's one of
  65. the the things that we try to to address in our >> and so it's important obviously when
  66. you're trying to meet somebody is you want to get to know them as well as you can and part of getting to know them are
  67. kind of their behaviors and I'm wondering if if people's behaviors when you go from the desktop to the mobile
  68. have kind of advanced or adjusted as we've moved through the years as well. So people's behaviors might have changed
  69. and it might have changed in response to a number of different factors. Of course
  70. the design of these these uh platforms have changed as we moved from desktop to mobile. In the desktop era we have seen
  71. uh much uh much more information. When you looked at the profiles, typically you had uh many different pieces of
  72. information where people could write long essays about themselves, go into details about their personality, what
  73. they are looking for, and that created a perhaps um a a more informationful environment
  74. that might have changed how you interact with someone. If you can read and if you
  75. can learn a lot about somebody, of course, you might be much more likely to go into a maybe an interaction because
  76. you feel more comfortable in the mobile world. Now, our our attention was simply
  77. complying to this small screen that we have and whatever we could consume in that small screen um was practically the
  78. information that these apps demanded from us. they did not uh give the opportunity to to consumers or they did
  79. not necessarily ask consumers to fill in these very long profiles about themselves. They made it easier for
  80. people to to easily look at profiles but at the same time that reduce the amount
  81. of information that one can present about about themselves. So as a result of that you will anti you will expect
  82. it's normal to anticipate that the interactions between individuals are are naturally going to change and in the
  83. mobile world it might have disproportionately focused on some of the small pieces of information that
  84. became a little more salient maybe for instance the the image of the person or the educational background of the
  85. individual or the the job profile of the individual as these are commonly the type of information that are made a
  86. little more salient compared compared to some of the other therapists. I >> Is there a difference then in the
  87. behaviors when you're talking about who you're connected with, the the sex of the person you're connecting with, male
  88. versus female? >> Um, in terms of the the behaviors or the interactions, the outcomes that we can
  89. observe, we do not have data on the the the gender of the individuals. What we know is that when we look at just purely
  90. usage, we are able to observe that there are disproportionately more males on dating platforms compared to to females
  91. almost an 80 20% ratio. And this is something that again when you look at at least the anecdotal uh studies and and
  92. evidence you will typically see uh these these statistics um also confirm. But what we have seen at least uh or what
  93. one of the outcomes that we looked at was how relationship formation or the type of couples that are formed uh look
  94. like as online dating or dating platforms become more prevalent. So we looked at for instance um the the idea
  95. of uh a a female and a male again in a heterosexual couple how the characteristics of the the husband and
  96. how the character characteristics of the wife look like um in in regions where online dating was much more prevalent.
  97. And one of the things that we have seen was that um despite the fact that over many many decades we have seen
  98. increasing examples increasing evidence of sorting in uh marriage formation. What do I mean by that? We have seen
  99. over the years um more and more marriages where the wife and the husband would have similar educational profiles.
  100. >> They would have also more similar uh employment profiles. for instance, more and more couples would be both employed.
  101. We've seen actually that with online dating, the this trend is not necessarily followed or a a defying
  102. trend emerges uh from the couples that seem to be formed more likely to coming from the online dating environment. What
  103. do I mean by that? We have seen um lesser sorting in education where women seem to now be more comfortable marrying
  104. uh individuals who have lesser education that lower uh maybe a degree lower and we have seen also uh more and more
  105. formation of couples where both parties are not necessarily in labor force. We do see fewer uh dual earner couples
  106. coming out of the the dating profile. So that reflects a degree of asymmetry between the experiences of men and
  107. women. Um even though we do not observe exactly how these differences are reflected when individuals are engaging
  108. uh with with others on the dating platform. >> So having done this research now is
  109. there kind of a next logical step that you would like to take this research going down the road?
  110. >> So there are many questions that we still don't have answers to. We have answers to some questions about
  111. marriage. We have answers to some questions about the the sort of potential health outcomes. For instance,
  112. we observe that um especially in the mobile era. Marriages are are declining regions where online dating has become
  113. more prevalent and partially as a result of the declining marriages. We also know
  114. that we've also seen that divorces are declining. Um that was not necessarily the case when we looked at online dating
  115. in the desktop era. in the online in the early days of online dating seems like there are disproportionately more older
  116. users who seem to be driving higher levels of divorce. So what we would like to understand in some sense is this for
  117. instance uh decomposing this effect of declining marriages. What does that really mean? Do they mean um do we see
  118. potentially a delay in the marriage? Do we see uh couples becoming maybe more uh
  119. skeptical of of getting into a marriage or or forming relationships that may not
  120. necessarily result in a marriage and then also the implications of this. Just because marriages are declining that
  121. doesn't mean people are are less happy or they are not necessarily feeling good about their relationship outcomes. We
  122. don't unfortunately have right now a data to be able to link the the marriage and divorce outcomes to to people's
  123. well-being and how they feel about themselves, how they feel about their uh relationship status. We would love to be
  124. able to to also um have additional evidence, additional information, additional findings related to how uh
  125. the marriage and divorce outcomes are reflecting on people's status. >> Great PR, great to talk to you. Thanks
  126. very much. All the best. >> Thank you. Thank you as well. >> You You got it. Pinar Yodum who is a
  127. professor here at the Wharton School. >> Thank you for listening to the ripple effect. We hope you found this episode
  128. informative and engaging. Don't forget to subscribe and leave us a review so that we can continue to bring you the
  129. best insight from the Warden School.

Brief Summary

Wharton professor Pinar Yilderum discusses online dating's impact on relationships and marriage trends in the digital age.

Key points

  • The Ripple Effect Podcast. Join host Dan Looney as he explores groundbreaking research from Wharton faculty.
  • Impact of Online Dating. Wharton professor Pinar Yilderum discusses the significant effects of online dating platforms.
  • Changing Marriage Trends. Research shows declining marriages and changing dynamics in couples formed through online dating.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes