Why NFL Coaching Diversity Remains a Challenge

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Why does the NFL continue to struggle with diversity in coaching and leadership positions? Ken Shropshire, Wharton Emeritus Professor of Legal Studies & Business Ethics and Strategic Advisor to 76 Capital, examines the NFL’s history of racial equity, the impact and limitations of the Rooney Rule, Brian Flores’ discrimination lawsuit, and the broader challenges facing hiring practices across professional sports. He discusses whether the current system is working, how owners can improve decision-making, and what meaningful progress could look like for the future of the league.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. The National Football League has quite a checkered past when it comes to the issues of race and hiring. There have
  2. been several instances of coaches being fired in circumstances that probably did
  3. not warrant that person being let go. The Rooney rule was set up back in 2002 because of the concern of a lack of
  4. black head coaches and general managers in the league. And the latest fight deals with a former head coach, Brian
  5. Flores, who was fired from his team, the Miami Dolphins, after back-to-back winning seasons. So, how should we view
  6. the background of the NFL around race? Pleasure to be joined by Ken Shropshshire who's professor ameritus
  7. here at the Wharton School. He is also a strategic adviser to 76 Capital. He has
  8. a long background working with the world of sport on many of these issues. Ken, great to see you again. How are you,
  9. sir? >> Great, Dan. All is good. Good to see you. >> Let me start right there with the
  10. broader question of the NFL's history around opportunity for people of color. Give us your thoughts.
  11. Well, it's it's varied and you cannot say the NFL has not uh taken a lot of the positive steps to try to make things
  12. better. It it starts with players on the field. It actually integrated before Major League Baseball. Most people don't
  13. don't know that in 1946, so a year before Jackie Robinson. The the big problem in two areas, and today we'll
  14. focus on coaches, but there's also the issue with ownership, which is is a whole whole another show.
  15. So in the year where the the sole black coaches were Tony Dunie and and Dennis Green, the NFL said, "Well, let's take
  16. some action to try to make this better." That's when the Rudy Wolf came in force,
  17. as you as you note. And there was this positive flow from uh the early 2000s up until uh there were some setback years
  18. that came maybe a decade or so later. He hit a peak of of eight African-American
  19. head coaches influenced by this this hiring technique, the strategy. I should said hiring, I should say interview. I
  20. mean, the whole idea of the Rooney rule is to make sure that diverse coaches were interviewed, specifically black
  21. coaches were interviewed. The rule speaks more broadly, but the effort is focused on on black coaches. Big setback
  22. in this last hiring cycle. uh 10 openings, not a single African-American hired. So, so that's really why this
  23. this new level of attention came coupled with this lawsuit that had been filed previously by Brian Flores that he had
  24. been discriminated against in the hiring process. And then the the final layer is
  25. this this effort that's in place uh in the White House today to end any effort that has inklings of what they label as
  26. DEI. And so with the NFL specifically and the Rooney rule, what is it about the rule
  27. itself? Because you hear a lot of people say that, you know, it just does not fulfill kind of what I think a lot of
  28. people believe that it should. Are there specifics that you have seen that really
  29. there are areas where it just has not done the job, the rule itself? >> Well, yeah. Ultimately, you think about
  30. any kind of law, any kind of legislation is only as good as the enforcement and people following it. But also, you know,
  31. as we know with taxes, it's kind of easy to follow the letter of law, but also do
  32. something that that may not be what the law intended that there are these tax evasion is a is a is a legitimate
  33. phrase. So, the idea of evading the the meaning of this rule. >> Yeah. Yeah. we'll do a pro for
  34. interview, but we've already decided who we want to hire. So maybe not to even focus on who this this person is they
  35. never even considered could be. Are they the right one? Are they the next um Tomlin or are they the next you back in
  36. the day Ray Roads? Yeah. That you had thought about that got gets hired because you encountered them in the
  37. interview process. So So that that's been the main flaw that's there. I I for one have after this last over 10 cycle I
  38. kind of abruptly said ah I'm just end the ruining rule let's see how things operate without it and and let's go to
  39. another path that that we um penalize teams or owners that do discriminate that we can can prove discrimination
  40. overtly in some other kind of way as opposed to going through this this activity that the the Rooney rule
  41. imposes. I don't know if if that's right or wrong. I'm I'm I'm still kind of on the fence about whether or not we should
  42. push to continue the Rooney rule. Um it it should exist in some way, but obviously the form that it's in now has
  43. been problematic. >> What does the case then of Brian Flores, and this is a case that actually was
  44. taken up to the Supreme Court for potential review. The court said it would not. So that basically the lower
  45. court ruling would stand. What does that case really potentially do to the structure of hiring and opportunity for
  46. uh for coaches of color in the league right now? >> Yeah. You know, I want to step back.
  47. Brian Flores is is definitely uh a men among men in terms of I'm going to take this step because I think there's a real
  48. problem here. Here's a here's a guy who had been a head coach. Yeah. uh with the
  49. Miami Dolphins, got fired, was engaged in the hiring process to to get a new job, and as modern day warning, um uh
  50. was texted incorrectly uh by someone involved in the hiring process congratulating him. Turned out he was
  51. the wrong Brian. Didn't get the job. And Brian Flores said, "Let me look a little
  52. bit more deeply and see what's going on here." and he decided that for a couple of reasons he should bring in action
  53. against uh his former team against teams that he was involved in the hiring process and he brought in um other pls
  54. other coaches black coaches who had gone through similar processes and said let's
  55. let this whole process see the light of day let's let's let the court the the light of justice shine on this and let's
  56. see what's going on here let people see this so that's what becomes important with the Supreme Court ruling
  57. The NFL wanted the process to be more secretive in a sense >> and go through the arbitration process
  58. with Commissioner uh Goodell. Uh and not all elements would have to be exposed. But in the court, there's depositions
  59. there. There's the interrogatories. all the all this exposure will take place and we would get a better vision of
  60. what's going on here because what we know in this this modern era and and where the laws tend to be pointing to is
  61. that you need a a smoking gun to successfully bring a case of discrimination in any kind of way and
  62. people give everyone credit people are more sophisticated today than to say uh we're not going to hire any black people
  63. or I've already decided that I want to hire this person without interviewing anyone
  64. So, we have to go more deeply and that that's what a real court analysis would allow to occur to to see the light of
  65. day to see what's really going on here. And and by the way, Flores really did risk his career in doing this. He was
  66. fortunate to get hired by Pittsburgh and then later Minnesota and and he kind of
  67. seems to have gotten his footing back into the business, but ultimately will he get get hired again as a head coach
  68. having brought this action against the National Football League. How much of this is also beyond the issue of race,
  69. just the structure of the hiring and firing process within the league? And I say that because you talk about the
  70. arbitration component that could have been uh in play with Brian Flores. We're hearing the same thing with former coach
  71. John Gruden, who's obviously white, in terms of, you know, the firing that occurred with him with the Las Vegas
  72. Raiders. It seems like there is a a structure element in place that is really a challenge against some of these
  73. coaches when these situations occur. >> No, for sure. And interestingly, you know, we often say that sport leads
  74. the way in society and all this sort of stuff. This this these leagues are very unique in terms of the way that they
  75. operate. I mean even even more deeply I mean the analysis that that a lot of people have been doing more more
  76. recently is the the level and this kind of relates to what you're saying of nepotism that relates in in terms of
  77. hiring the num the family names uh that exist in terms of the coaching family Shanahan the Ryan family
  78. the Phillips family Kubak family the Belich family all those their sons and and and and fathers and and and now
  79. grandsons starting to come into play that that they get access in that kind of way. So that's just oldfashioned.
  80. Not to it just happens that there's there are no blacks families like that, but but that's going on as well. So So
  81. there's so much that goes on that the league uh and and it's a a private enterprise that has this this kind of
  82. huge public trust kind of element. Yeah. >> Um well, in some ways we can't look into
  83. businesses and don't have the interest in looking into the businesses the way that we do in sports. So, so the the
  84. gruden kind of exposure I mean one thing one thing that's that's become you know
  85. society should take note of already you know these texts and these emails and all these things become public and they
  86. be they can become problematic. >> You've consulted with NFL owners over the years. What then from your
  87. perspective is missing in the process that would make hiring in the league for these positions more equitable?
  88. Well, the the great Tony Dunie, the the the the first Super Bowlinning head coach African-American in in the
  89. National Football League, has offered himself up and has engaged in helping in the hiring process over the years. And
  90. and he says the first question when a an owner asks him to help is when they say, "What what candidates are
  91. there?" Tony's question is, "Well, what do you want? What do you want in a head coach?" And if if you tell me that, I
  92. can I can give you the candidates of of whatever race. I'll give you the best candidates and we can go from there. So,
  93. so the idea of of being even more defined, I always refer to it at that that that that inflection moment, that
  94. that hiring moment, not just to here's a list, but to to really have someone and
  95. this is the whole problem, the issue exists and and the value of this this kind of battleworn diversity issue is
  96. it's important to have a diverse group of people in the room to make better decisions,
  97. >> right? And and that's what Tonyy's trying to figure out. How can I help you to make that decision and it could turn
  98. out you go 0 for 10 in a hiring season. You've hired the best people, but you've
  99. also done the process the right way. That that I think that's where we all want to get to in terms of society. And
  100. I think some people are anxious uh about getting there. But we as a society, football as a sport is is not yet there.
  101. >> Ken, always great to talk with you. Thanks very much for your time today. >> Thank you, Dan. I appreciate it. You got
  102. it. Ken Shropshshire who is a professor emeritus at the Wharton School and strategic adviser to 76 capital.

Brief Summary

Ken Shropshire discusses the NFL's racial hiring practices and the impact of Brian Flores' lawsuit on diversity in coaching.

Key points

  • The Rooney Rule's Impact. The Rooney Rule was established to increase diversity among NFL coaches, but has faced criticism.
  • Brian Flores' Lawsuit. Brian Flores filed a lawsuit against the NFL, claiming discrimination in hiring practices.

Tension

50/ 100Some tension

Related episodes