Women & Work: Will Power Protect You From Retaliation? | Nancy Rothbard – Ripple Effect Podcast
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
EPISODE OVERVIEW: Employees who voice ethical concerns in the workplace often run the risk of retaliation, and that risk is much higher for women. In this episode of the Ripple Effect podcast, Wharton Deputy Dean Nancy Rothbard explains why and what organizations can do to lower the burden for moral objectors.
Topics and questions covered: 00:00 - Introductions 1:06 - What inspired Prof. Rothbard’s research? 5:27 - Gender stereotypes in the workplace 7:13 - When does retaliation occur? 12:12 - Testing responses to moral objection 15:08 - Recommendations for organizations
PODCAST OVERVIEW: Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research — but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.
Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect
----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- we're at a place where we know a lot about the problems but what we need more work on are solutions to those problems
- one of the things I'm most proud about in this work is that we identify a solution a practical actionable solution
- that we can start to make a difference in people's lives welcome to the ripple effect the podcast
- that takes you on a journey through the minds of work and faculty I'm your host Dan Loney and in each episode we'll be
- diving deep into the inspiration behind the groundbreaking research that Wharton
- professors have conducted and exploring how their findings resonate with the world today we'll be covering a diverse
- range of topics bringing you the latest insights and knowledge that you can apply to your life into work so get
- ready to dive into new ideas with the ripple effect so Nancy you've done a lot of research
- on gender in the workplace how did it come about that the topic of female moral objectors ended up on your radar
- well Dan I've done a lot of work as you said over the years on both gender and on voicing issues in organizations in
- fact actually my first academic publication was called out on a limb and it was about women who were raising
- gender Equity issues in their organizations and what made them more willing to do so
- and we found that the the role that they were in actually conferred legitimacy for raising these issues so being in HR
- made more women more willing to raise gender Equity issues because they felt like that was part of their role
- and what happened was my student and co-author you know Flash Forward to 2020. uh my student and co-author Tim
- was interested in Morality In organizations and when he came to talk to me about this project it was really a
- fabulous intersection of our interests my interests on gender and voice and his on uh moral objection
- and so you also found out that women in power are more likely to face retaliation when they voice ethical
- concerns more so than men in power can you break down that finding and what you believe accounts for the difference here
- sure um as you said we found that high-powered women when they raised ethical concerns experienced more
- retaliation than their their male counterparts and the reason that we found for this is that they were
- perceived as being out of control and what was really interesting about this for us is that a lot of the past
- research on gender assumes that one of the reasons that women get backlash is because they're they're perceived as not
- warm and friendly but we found actually it wasn't warmth perceptions that was the problem it was self-control and the
- reason for that is frankly people don't like moral objectors they they whether they're male
- or female people people think that moral objectors are seen as rocking the boat as violating expectations as disrupting
- things um and one of the things that's really interesting is that people think that
- moral objectors are often selfish actually um and and it's kind of interesting they
- feel like they're selfishly demonstrating their own moral superiority or you know putting their
- own ideological preferences onto other people or the organization in this case and you know actually a lot of
- the literature talks about how moral objectors are sometimes viewed as self-righteous or arrogant
- um and the perception is exacerbated by the idea that it somehow seems seen as morally inappropriate socially
- inappropriate that you are raising these objections right you're disrupting things you're you're making waves and so
- when moral objectors violate Expectations by by raising these concerns other people often think that
- they're they're doing this to advance their own moral agenda and there's something selfish about that
- um that costs uh the group something so let's take a moment and talk about this idea of perceived self-control what
- does it really mean in in this context yeah so self-control is uh what we mean by self-control is that it's either the
- ability or the lack of self-control is the inability to restrain those selfish or anti-social impulses right for the
- sake of what's perceived as best for the group so the kinds of things that we would ask is you know
- um does does Dan lack self-discipline is Dan bad at resisting temptation you know
- does Dan Act without thinking through Alternatives uh and what we find is that lower self-control we we actually did
- some supplementary analyzes where we find that lower self-control is is associated with perceptions of self more
- higher selfishness and lower other orientedness so you're you're not as concerned about others if you're seen as
- having low self-control so there seemed to be a variety of gender stereotypes at play here based on
- the work that you've done what are some of the strongest ones that tend to influence how women are perceived in the
- workplace yeah that's a really important question Dan I I think that some of the gender
- stereotypes that are really important when we think about women in the workplace or stereotypes around around
- other orientedness around communality right are we doing things on behalf of the group are we pro-social are we
- um you know are we uh you know in it for everyone and that plays out here as well in that
- it's related to perceptions of of self-control um but what what also you often see in
- many other uh types of work on gender at in the workplace is are the perceptions
- of warmth that women need to be warm and friendly you know you've seen or you've
- heard about how women need to smile more um and and that's sort of an expectation
- of women that they are that they are um uh more um more connected to others in the
- workplace and and that's really very hard oftentimes because it's it's an additional uh layer of responsibility
- that women have to really um engage with other people while they're having to be highly competent at
- their jobs at the same time and so what we had in this paper is is actually this additional expectation around
- self-control uh that that plays out I think in important ways uh how does retaliation show up in this
- context as well and can it tend to be subtle yeah so um retaliation was the dependent
- variable we looked at so we were looking at the consequences of raising moral concerns and how do people react to you
- and retaliation was the was what we looked at and retaliation can be it can take a lot of different forms it can be
- work related um you you could be demoted you know if if it's at an extreme case but it can
- also take less extreme forms and and you know social kind of Norm uh types of uh
- functions like you know people spreading gossip or rumors uh about the person or
- what have you um it also is important because retaliation occurs when people want to either
- silence discredit or discourage people from behaving the way that they're behaving in the future right so it's
- it's it's trying to maintain order and compliance in the face of um a behavior that's seen as problematic
- and so when we looked at retaliation in this paper and in this study we looked it in a couple of different ways so we
- we had a couple of studies where we which which were archival studies that were done in the field and they they
- asked people if they had experienced retaliation in a lot of different forms right so they it asked them about you
- know did you if you've ever experienced retaliation um you know because you raise health or
- safety concerns right or you raised issues around fraud um or you um you know engage in any kind
- of whistleblowing or or whether you uh you know you raise issues around equal opportunity or
- um you know some some of the items were around whether people had raised uh issues around sexual uh harassment or
- even disagreeing with management decisions right so it was even as broad as that and so in one of the the studies
- we we kind of we looked at those types of issues in some of the other studies we asked people whether so that study
- actually looked at whether you experienced retaliation we turned it around in some of our other studies and
- we asked people have you ever retaliated against somebody else right and so uh in
- the in those studies we asked things like did you retaliate again we gave them a scenario and we said did you
- retaliate against that that person or did you suggest that they were out of line or did you spread rumors or did you
- discourage this Behavior or did you indicate that that behavior was inappropriate so those are the types of
- of ways that we operationalized retaliation in in some of the other studies can you walk us through the
- Kevin and Kate experiment sure um so so one our fourth study in the paper that we published was uh as
- you say the Kevin and Kate experiment where we um we uh gave a um we gave participants
- uh a task where we asked them to brainstorm different ideas independently uh and we could said they could use the
- internet to Source ideas and then they would they were they were supposed to interact with a team a set of teammates
- to develop the ideas um and what happened was when they went to to interact with the teammates we had
- a um an artificial teammate Kevin or Kate uh and Kevin or Kate then um was either a high power person or an
- average power person and then um we we had Kevin or Kate say either I must point out that the moral problem
- a moral problem with this task and I can't complete it um asking users to use the internet to
- look up ideas could lead to plagiarism and this is a serious moral issue and and Must Be Stopped right so in one
- version Kevin or Kate said that in the other version Kevin or Kate said because it might come back to hurt uh
- the the platform and any participants in the study I have to point out there's a
- moral problem with the task and I can't complete it asking users to use the internet to look up ideas could lead to
- plagiarism which could put people on the platform at risk and and and this is a serious problem and must negatively it
- might negatively impact the platform and the workers or get us in trouble and it
- has to be stopped in order to protect the platform and its workers from unfair retribution so so as you see we had sort
- of this a moral objection in both cases but in the one case it was sort of what we call the standard frame and in the
- other case it was what we call the organizational frame where we're giving much more explanation and rationale
- about how it could hurt the organization and the people in the organization if we
- were to proceed with this problematic Behavior right and so um what we then did is we had coders we
- then had peop the the participants who received Kevin or Kate's moral objection we had them then respond
- um to Kevin or Kate and we coded their responses for whether they were they were retaliatory or not right and so
- um retaliatory messages were ones where they ended up scolding or disparaging or
- criticizing Kevin or Kate uh for their behavior um and and so like an example of one of
- our favorite quotes from the uh the responses was um you are a petulant little child you need
- to grow up and get a grip um so that was an example of a negative retaliers response
- uh a pause and then you know we also got we coded positive responses so some of the responses that that the uh Kevin or
- Kate received were ones that thanked them or condoned their their behavior um you know one of an example that was
- this is a really important Point Kevin or Kate thanks for bringing it up so you know we you know we we had a variety of
- ways people responded based on who the person was what their level of power was and whether they used an organizational
- frame or not and so that that interaction between those factors really led to quite a disparity in how people
- responded and are there ways where you can even reduce the potential for retaliation in
- some of these circumstances things that we found that was really important was when participant or when
- when Kevin or Kate used the organizational frame or uh where they kind of gave more of an explanation
- about the benefits to the organization and to the group retaliation was lowered across the board
- for men and for women the only people who did not experience higher levels of retaliation when they used a standard
- frame were the high-powered men so the high-powered men were able to just do the the sort of this is wrong
- and we shouldn't do it right lower powered men and women and even and even high power women needed to use the
- uh the organizational frame in order for them to experience lower levels of retaliation and be and and be more
- accepted in terms of what they were saying what particular recommendations then would you have for organizations
- themselves around that type of a remedy so Dan I think it's really important that when we find things like this that
- we don't put all of the burden on low-powered individuals or in this or in in this case certain groups of
- individuals like women um and so our recommendations actually are more um broad so what we would say
- is we encourage all moral objectors regardless of their gender or structural power to use an organizational frame
- when when raising moral objections it's going to make everybody uh sound more in
- control and it is going to really help ensure that gendered outcomes are reduced uh and and it really increases
- people's receptivity to your moral objection you know from you know across all all ends of the continuum
- the second thing I sorry I would suggest I would suggest uh is that we we train people with how to do this right we need
- to provide examples for uh employees to with how to how to frame set these types
- of moral objections and and to really um I guess third is to help employees really recognize their own bias and
- learn to reframe moral objections that they encounter right I mean I think we need to raise awareness that we are all
- doing this men and women are doing this right women were retaliating as as much as men were against high-powered women
- uh when they were framing things in this way right or not framing things uh with
- with an organizational frame and so you know we really need to um to kind of raise that awareness to
- help with debiasing um and and then again I I think that the last thing is just highlighting the
- benefits that moral objections can provide to organizations because as I started with you know people don't like
- moral objectors they feel like they're rocking the boat they feel like you know this is just
- um you know they're a sticky wheel and how do we how do we make people understand that raising moral objections
- is not just about pursuing you know a selfish agenda it's often about pursuing a selfless agenda and one that does
- benefit the organization as a whole so when you're thinking more broader scale when it comes to correcting these
- types of imbalances do you think it's better to focus on changing the system or changing the individual Behavior
- yeah that's a really tough one because I think that we have more leverage over individual behaviors often as individual
- actors right so you know as as a as a woman who is in a power position it's important to know that this is a tool
- that you can use right to level the playing field but again I think that to make systemic change we really need to
- do more and we need to raise that awareness at a broader level uh and so I think I think that it's both
- end quite frankly so what are some of the the other big questions that we need to look at right
- now around the topic of women in leadership so I actually think um there's a really interesting opportunity
- here Dan because what we we're at a place in our scholarship where we know a lot about the problems we've documented
- the problems lack of representation The Leaky pipeline the glass ceiling the glass cliff
- subtle forms of bias benevolent sexism lack of mentorship and sponsorship right like all of those are things that we
- know are problems but what we need more work on is or are solutions to those problems one of the
- things I'm most proud about uh in this work is that we we identify a solution a practical actionable solution that we
- can start to make a difference in people's lives and their effectiveness in organizations and so you know more
- work that examines women's careers more work that examines how we can get both men and women to be allies in addressing
- these types of issues I think that those are the opportunities that we have to really make a difference in terms of
- women's leadership Nancy thank you very much for your time today all the best thanks so much Dan always a pleasure
- thank you for listening listen to the ripple effect we hope you found this episode informative and engaging don't
- forget to subscribe and leave us a review so that we can continue to bring you the best Insight from the Wharton
- School
Brief Summary
Nancy Rothbard discusses gender equity and moral objections in the workplace, highlighting retaliation against women in power and solutions for organizations.
Key points
- The Ripple Effect Podcast. Join Dan Loney as he explores groundbreaking research from Wharton professors.
- Gender and Moral Objections. Research shows high-powered women face more retaliation for voicing ethical concerns.
- Recommendations for Organizations. Encouraging moral objectors to use an organizational frame to reduce retaliation.
Episode highlights
- The Ripple Effect PodcastJoin Dan Loney as he explores groundbreaking research from Wharton professors.“Welcome to the ripple effect, the podcast that takes you on a journey.”0:21Mar 7, 2023
- Gender and Moral ObjectionsResearch shows high-powered women face more retaliation for voicing ethical concerns.“High-powered women experience more retaliation than their male counterparts.”2:24Mar 7, 2023
- Recommendations for OrganizationsEncouraging moral objectors to use an organizational frame to reduce retaliation.“We encourage all moral objectors to use an organizational frame.”15:35Mar 7, 2023




