A View From Above: Michael Langman, Merrill Advisory Group

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

An interview from the recent Wharton Aerospace Conference.

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] meril Advisory Group is a a boutique bank that uh that was founded by uh all
  2. the principles are our combat veterans uh uh almost all of them are alumni of West Point or the Air Force Academy uh
  3. they graduated from Top tier Business Schools and joined the the ranks of the airspace and defense practices of the
  4. large bulge bracket Wall Street firms uh they recognized that that the lower Middle Market companies are relatively
  5. very under represented in the space when they get acquired by uh large large aerospace companies so they decided to
  6. go ahead and and bring that big bulge bracket experience to to their lower Middle Market clients I'm also the
  7. founder and co-president of of Wharton Aerospace Wharton Aerospace is an association of senior Executives uh who
  8. have a shared tie or shared ties and commitments are to the Aerospace and defense Industries W and Aerospace is is
  9. is our initiative to Foster closer ties and relationships between the Wharton School our Warton Aerospace participants
  10. who are alumni of Wharton business school whether through the full-time program or the many executive education
  11. programs and the industrial Base today we we actually conducted a a best practices panel on best practices
  12. in m&a and and a common theme was all the different ways that that that companies can can fail in in their deal
  13. process and and the quote that was in the back of my mind during during these whole discussions was the quote from
  14. Tolstoy to roughly paraphrase all happy companies are happy the same families are happy the same way but all unhappy
  15. families are unhappy in their own way and and and to abstract I think what tsto meant is that you know you know m&a
  16. is a process and if you're going to do it right everything has to be right and that's why the successful companies are
  17. all happy in the same way whereas there's so many ways that you can be unsuccessful in in your deal process so
  18. you know to get this to get the strategy formulation incorrectly to have a poor strategic fit to overpay for the company
  19. to to fail in the post mer integration planning and th those are very high level sources of failure but you can
  20. decompose you know to overpay for a company what does that really mean to overpay for a company you know it may be
  21. that that you you didn't have you didn't appropriately value the company in terms
  22. of the discount rate that you use or you know you failed to model in the the the
  23. the success rates that you going to have on on the programs so it's not just the
  24. financials but how you operationalized the financials or it may be the fact that you didn't know how to quantifi how
  25. to identify quantify and capture the revenue synergies which is a very very elusive thing and these were the sorts
  26. of things that we had very rich discussions on today during during our our Wharton airospace
  27. panel as as as the leader of the panel the the point that I drove home is that no no deal gets done just because of how
  28. brilliant the Strategic rationale was or how sharply modeled the financial analysis was those are hard enough to do
  29. just to begin with but the real key to success of the transaction is the ability of that that internal m&a or
  30. corporate development executive to provide the alignment and get everybody saying yes to his deal because uh a lot
  31. of companies look at many many they kiss a lot of frogs before one of the frogs becomes the prince and you know how do
  32. you how do you compress that Gant chart and go after the deals that are successful and and the key to the
  33. successful deals is providing purpose Direction and motivation in these large complex highly cross matric
  34. organizations where they hear that most deals fail and and these are risky and they may be CER limiting moves how does
  35. that m&a guy go ahead and get everybody to go in front of the CEO or the board and say yes we want to go ahead and
  36. pursue something that we he typically fails and at the end of the day that's all about emotional intelligence
  37. understanding organizational Dynamics and behavior you politics it's it's really the the soft side
  38. of of the deal typically when a when a company is looking to to acquire another company
  39. they're using merges and Acquisitions as an adjunct um to to fill a gap it could
  40. be on their business development side in terms of being able to penetrate a market or a channel such as the
  41. Aerospace company that now wants to get into clean energy or Healthcare it um or
  42. it could be a technology Gap in terms of a more engineering Focus that they're looking for a company that has a
  43. technology embedded within them that uh you know this is this the acquisition is
  44. a substitute for internal research and development so many airospace and defense companies will actually
  45. formalize and codify their their their Gap filling process whereas part of the pursuit order capture process they will
  46. actually list as part of their color team reviews or their go noo decisions you know what are the gaps or on the
  47. tech technological side as they come up with Capital budgeting and capital allocation
  48. plans and they link that to the Strategic plan they will actually identify the gaps but what's very in
  49. very Insidious about this is they formalize the process should be easy but there there dozens and dozens of m&a
  50. Executives that'll go ahead and lament my company doesn't get it they they just don't get m&a there're just a bunch of
  51. process oriented Engineers that don't get it and we talk talk about that during whorton Aerospace and you see
  52. everybody chuckling but you know what I suggest to you not suggest but I tell you is that that is the lement of the
  53. unsuccessful m&a executive because it's not that it's not that the company didn't get m&a it's that that m&a
  54. executive did not get the company that he failed to appreciate or understand you know the culture of his company and
  55. and how to get things done in his company so to go back to the example of uh the the the Gap filler you know the
  56. typical approach of the m&a deal deal guy is to go up to the head of engineering say hey here's the company
  57. and it fills the Gap and we know this fills the Gap and let's go forward and the the head of engineering says oh well
  58. it doesn't really fill a gap because we could do that on our own the GU thy yes that's the not invented ha syndrome and
  59. the thing is you know what when we talk about being disrespectful or having a lack of of of emotional intelligence
  60. it's that you know what that that engineering guy can develop this thing but the thing is he hasn't gotten the
  61. money for it that's why he's requesting money in his irat or internal research and development plan to do these things
  62. so let's get this straight you want this senior executive to go up in front of the CEO of the company and number one
  63. talk about buying a company that's doing something that he can't do that he may not look good he wants you know makes
  64. him puts him in a position off the bat that he doesn't look good never mind that well it's because the other company
  65. put in this money was a priority for them when we when this target this other company was doing things
  66. in advance uh the second thing is if he's going to go forward on this thing he's not going to get the money he's
  67. asking for he's not going to get the money he's not going to get the people he's not going to get all the things all
  68. the cures that come with the fact that he's going to get this big chunk of money so uh this is uh you know this is
  69. this is a non-starter and this is the example of how the m&a guy doesn't get it you know the the the know a perhap a
  70. more a more thoughtful approach would be to approach that to reframe this discussion with the VP of engineering
  71. and discuss with him look here's a company they they don't you know they're doing something we don't do and I know
  72. that we can do better can you would you be willing to take a look at this company and tell me how if we owned it
  73. you would be able to take them to the next level because they do something that we don't do and I I know that
  74. you've asked for X millions of dollars to do the sort of thing but it would be really nice if we could have this
  75. company you know in three months instead of three years because there's this big
  76. multi-billion dollar program we could win that program if we had this technology you know the thing is you
  77. know all I ask of you is to go up in front of our board and talk to them about how if you own this thing you
  78. could take it to the next level and embed it in our our business and make it as great as the rest of us and and and
  79. by the way I know you're asking for all that money but I I don't I don't know if
  80. you're going to get it because you know the the the budgets are being highly scrutinized because these things affect
  81. net income and EPs and that's an important metric that is that is difficult to fill in
  82. this current I don't want to use the cliche this current environment but it's cliches are cliches because they're so
  83. true however there's a lot of money on the balance sheet it's a different color of money the past seven years have been
  84. so successful for airspace companies that they've been paying down debt buying back shares cautiously cautiously
  85. increasing dividends uh but none of these things prepare them for the tougher and tougher environment we're
  86. going to see whether it's on the commercial Aerospace side or on the defense side and and you know the CFOs
  87. are looking for ways to to judiciously deploy that money so to to explain to the engineering VP that this
  88. kind of money is available for you and by the way to do the things you want to do we can work that into the plan in
  89. terms of the cost to achieve those synergies that's money that that'll be safer um than the money that even if you
  90. did did get it and the CFO will will like that too because it helps us lower the purchase price of the company so
  91. when you reframe the argument this way you're really providing a line it's it's it's not being disingenuous
  92. it's thinking about how can you make the engineering VP successful how can you make the CFO successful how can you make
  93. everybody successful so that ultimately you're able to do something to support the war Fighters because uh you know the
  94. world is still a dangerous place we have infinite requirements um to help Warf Fighters you know for example the ISR
  95. surge in Afghanistan and you know just just the the way money is going to be tight with with with the government
  96. there's not enough money to fund all these programs so uh the ability to go ahead and get these deals right is
  97. important for war Fighters it's important for our national security

Brief Summary

M&A challenges in aerospace are discussed, emphasizing emotional intelligence and stakeholder alignment for success.

Key points

  • M&A Insights from Wharton Aerospace. A panel discussion on best practices in mergers and acquisitions, emphasizing the importance of emotional intelligence and strategic alignment.

Related episodes