A View From Above: Robert Saia Pratt & Whitney
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
An interview from the recent Wharton Aerospace Conference.
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- so I'm responsible for commercial you for commercial product development and it's really and in the commercial uh
- segment that I deal with is 70 pass 70 passengers up to to the 5 to 600 passengers so it's really all large uh
- commercial airliners and so my my Prime responsibility is technology de development and Readiness how that
- interfaces into product uh development and product uh product uh configuration or offerings as the airplane companies
- develop new products for this next generation of aircraft well as you know uh the airline industry
- is under a lot a lot of economic turmoil you know airlines are losing money there's an overc capacity uh that's
- driving low low C cost a low um air fars and there's very high cost High labor costs High product acquisition cost and
- certainly High fuel price so as we're looking at the next 2 to three years with Industries the oems are trying to
- do is improve product performance and capabilities like fuel or environmental factors without increasing cost so we
- can lower the airline overall operating cost you're right I mean we have made some significant gains over the last 20
- years if if you looked at commercial jet line you know passenger jetliner 20 years ago and the engines that powered
- that product vers versus what we've done today the airplane itself has improved by 20 20 to 25% in overall fuel
- efficiency The Bu bulk of that coming uh from the engine uh because of engine efficiency but and key characteristics
- are looking for thing know developing technologies that lower weight improve the uh the power
- efficiency we call it the propulsive efficiency of how an engine takes air and Fuel and converts that into power so
- it can be uh using new aerodynamic features using lighter weight materials that have more
- temperature capability or heat capability so the engine becomes more efficient as it uses fuel or heat to
- produce power and at the same time looking at emissions you know un unburned carbon uh participants are um
- fuel particles that or fuel emissions in terms of how the quality of air leaving
- the engine so so I find uh Prime Focus over the last 10 or 20 years have been making engines more fuel efficient by
- making them larger improving the overall AER aerodynamics of an engine going forward as we look at Future uh engine
- uh features or our Technologies it's how do we make a paradigm shift in leveraging technology to create that
- step function Improvement and one of the one of the areas that I've been involved
- in over the last several years at Pratt is working what we call a geared architecture that tries to work on some
- Innovative physics to make that step change versus continuing to to work in fine-tune um you know what I'll say
- sharpening the pencil to make small incremental improvements so over the last last
- several years where Pratt Whitney has really been focusing on is introducing this geared turbo fan and the and what
- we do is we introduce a gear between the first compressor that we call a fan and
- the power turbine that drives that fan and the and the key benefit of this introducing this gear is that these fans
- are quite large they can be anywhere from six to eight feet in diameter so they're lodged they Lo they move a lot
- of air and they can also be very heavy because of the their size now with with an
- introduction of a gear instead of the fan moving one revolution for every revolution in the turban we can now have
- the fan move one revolution for every three Revolutions in the turban so we so we change the Paradigm of how the fan
- and is connected to that power turbine so we can make the fan turn a lot slower now for a given turb turbine
- speed we can improve the efficiency of the turbine by it turning now much faster than what a
- conventional um engine architecture would be and at the and as we're doing that we make the efficiency of the
- engine double digit better so where we would normally introduce technology to improve fuel consumption by some amount
- by introducing the gear with those same series of Technologies we can almost double the effect efficiency Improvement
- of the engine for things like fuel consumption emissions and even the operating cost or
- the maintenance cost of keeping that engine in service it will do say 15% reduction in fuel consumption so it's
- not half in fuel but it's a significant amount most most um generate uh most product improvements from generation to
- generation improve fuel consumption 5 to 6% and our next step with the introduction of of a gear we're doing 12
- to 15% so we basically skip a generation but the other key factor here is with this gear because this fan is a key
- source for engine noise we drop engine noise 50% and with combuster technology we
- drop emissions emission Levels by 50% so a significant step for the a for this change and I'll
- say overall engine architecture we're now in product development of our first two models that we launched in 2007 and
- they will go the first will go into service at the end of 2013 the second will follow just a few
- months later um so the first product will be on the Bombardier C Series which is 110 to 150 passenger type aircraft uh
- jetliner and the second model is powering a new Regional Jet done by uh Mitch iishi in Japan that will be
- powering 70 to 90 passengers and uh so was was certainly very excited because this is uh a major
- a major step for the industry in terms of how we're driving our technology to lower you know Airline operator uh
- operating cost today we're focusing on new product certainly you could take this technology
- and retrofit an existing airplane but from the business economics that makes it very difficult you know because of of
- the uh amount of of uh cost it takes to develop a product what really makes most
- sense is if you're going to retrofit is retrofit into an existing airplane that's still in produ serial production
- so that you might do some of the existing Fleet if that makes sense but more importantly you're putting it on
- brand new equipment that's being purchased so you don't have the cost associated with removing a current
- engine and then having to modify the aircraft to allow the new engine to be suitable and and sometimes those costs
- will overpower the the fuel efficiency or the value of making the change because the
- air the aircraft already is aged if you have an automobile that's that's 10 years old but you could go put a Hybrid
- engine in it and save a lot of fuel if you're only going to keep that engine that automobile for 5 years you'll never
- get the resale value for making that big a change that big of investment for changing the engine but if you've got an
- automobile like some a some companies do today that are already in production with gas engines and now they've
- introduced that Hybrid engine for new uh for new automobiles for new uh customer
- purchases and as you put it into that existing airframe that's a brand new air a brand
- new automobile that's going to be uh used for the next 15 to 20 years right so you get full value of that investment
- because you're buying it new so that's how we're trying to leverage uh this Tech this geared technology as to what
- our next our next uh platform our next business opportunity would be you know as I said earlier the the
- industry the the whole airline industry is struggling because low airf fars high
- cost um and and with some of the economic pressures that the environment's bringing them like today
- we have pretty high Sur taxes on airplanes for a landing and takeoff for either noise or nitrix
- oxide future because of all the focus on global warming many uh government communities are looking at charging for
- the amount of carbon emissions and and they're talking like today a a typical gallon of jet fuel is about $2 a gallon
- and and as they're looking at what that Sur tax could be for carbon emissions they're talking in the order of 30 to 60
- cents a gallon as a Sur tax for operating that equipment and say in a given a given European country so when
- you look at that added cost on today's already stressed Airline Community it's hard for these companies to compete and
- still um be profitable you know at the bottom line so one of the challenges that we have certainly a company like
- Pratt Whitney is as we're bringing technology that typically cost us more cost a lot to develop and it costs us
- more to produce as we're manufacturing our engines is how do we do that smartly so that as we're offering this new
- engine or this new product to the airline community that we're really dropping their overall cost of ownership
- or operation of our engine so like with this new geared architecture if I look at today's Workhorse engines that power
- the the 100 to 250 passenger Market as we introduce this new geared engine you know we
- improve fuel consumption 15% we drop this nitrix oxide by 50% we drop Noise by 50% and we'll also drop carbon related
- emissions by 15 to 20% because it's you know for every gallon of fuel that an engine
- consumes it produces 20 lbs of carbon monoxide so so a fair Fairly large influence on the impact on um the the
- carbon emissions that one's producing so as we look at what does this new architecture provide our Target was to
- lower overall engine operating cost at the airline level by 20% and today with the technology work that we've done in
- the engine demonstrator that we just completed we're approaching actually 25% cost reduction that's the challenge
- we have as an oem to really Drive value to our to our you know End customer we're selling World worldwide we're
- selling right now we're on two two platforms that that Bombardier and and MIT Bish are actively uh uh campaigning
- or marketing their equipment and we hope that Within in the next several years the two major oems uh Airbus and Boeing
- will also be uh pursuing new product and gives us an opportunity to leverage our
- new geared architecture on those platforms certainly the the focus on global warming and this the s c tax or
- SE charge for the amount of carbons in that an airline operator will emit in that in that country that's a key
- element and I think the other element is the uncertainty in what's the cost of fuel you know it's today it's it's in
- that two $2 to $2.50 per gallon not that long ago about 15 months ago or 18 months ago you we were at 350 a gallon
- so the real question becomes as fuel starts to creep above you know $1 $100 a barrel or $150 a barrel that has a very
- significant uh impact on an airline operating cost
Brief Summary
Pratt & Whitney discusses new geared turbo fan technology improving fuel efficiency and reducing emissions in commercial aviation.
Key points
- Economic Turmoil in Airlines. The airline industry faces significant economic challenges, including high costs and low fares.
- Innovative Engine Technology. Pratt Whitney introduces geared turbo fan technology to improve efficiency and reduce emissions.
- Major Environmental Impact. New engine designs aim to significantly reduce emissions and noise levels.
Episode highlights
- Economic Turmoil in AirlinesThe airline industry faces significant economic challenges, including high costs and low fares.“The airline industry is under a lot of economic turmoil.”1:02Apr 6, 2010
- Innovative Engine TechnologyPratt Whitney introduces geared turbo fan technology to improve efficiency and reduce emissions.“We basically skip a generation in efficiency improvement.”6:05Apr 6, 2010
- Major Environmental ImpactNew engine designs aim to significantly reduce emissions and noise levels.“We drop engine noise by 50%.”6:12Apr 6, 2010
Episode quotes
Tension
40/ 100Low tension





