Brandon Copeland on How NIL Is Reshaping the Power Structure in College Sports
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
ABOUT THE EPISODE Brandon Copeland joins the Wharton Moneyball podcast to talk about his path from Penn to the NFL and his work with Athletes.org, a new players association for college athletes. He shares stories of injury, motivation, and proving himself as an Ivy League player in a league dominated by big programs. The conversation covers NIL reform, collective bargaining, and what it means for the future of college sports.
ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? Moneyball Highlights explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.
#CollegeAthletes #NIL #NFL #SportsAnalytics #CollegeFootball #SportsBusiness ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- Welcome everyone to the podcast edition of Wharton Moneyball here on the Wharton
- podcast network. This is Eric Bradlau, professor of marketing, statistics, and data science here at the Wharton School.
- Uh I'm joined every week by some combination of my co-host Kate Massie, Audi Winer, who should be joining me for
- a part of this show, and Shane Jensen. 11 plus years we're here on Morton Moneyball. if you'd like a statistician
- reads the sports pages and u you know I've always said the best part of the show and there's Audi Winer joining in
- the best part of the show is that we get to uh interview people who have lived in
- the world of sports who are trying to make a difference in the world of sports and AI today is no exception. Uh we're
- joined by Wharton alum NFL alum founder of athletes.org Brandon Copelan who prefers to go by COPE. So, Cope, welcome
- to Wharton Moneyball. >> Thank you for having me. I appreciate you. It's always a a dream come true,
- literally to be um I guess deemed quote unquote important enough to speak on a Wharton platform because I know when I
- came in, I was like, "Wow." You know, I I didn't know what I got myself into and
- I've been blessed. >> Oh, Pope, you're a lifetime Wharton alum. That never goes away. You get the
- Wharton brand forever. >> Amen. >> That's spoken from another Wharton alum or penal.
- >> That's me. Well, now I'm a Wharton alum and a pen too. A pen parent as I cope
- and I spoke about off the air and the parent of a D1 athlete as Audi knows. You just saw my middle son out in San
- Francisco. >> I did and my wife is a Wharton alum as well. So, we have a lot of Wharton alums
- and >> in the group. >> Well, co there's so many things I'd like to talk to you about. Let me kind of go
- timewise forward. Um, can you talk about your time here? As I'm sure a lot of our
- listeners on Wharton Moneyball would just like to know, what was it like to be a D1 athlete here at the University
- of Pennsylvania? And, you know, how does someone from Penn make it all the way to
- the NFL? Because most of the time, I mean, there's some of us, but you know, most of the time people don't think
- about it that way. So, what was your time like here? And then tell us about your transition to the NFL.
- >> Absolutely. Well, when I came to Penn, I started there in 2009. July 25th, 2009
- was actually my first day on campus and I started in this program called Africana um to get out to campus early,
- start taking some classes, start getting adjusted, knowing where this building was and that building was and all of
- those types of things. And summer in Philadelphia is a great great place to be even as a a wideeyed freshman who has
- no idea what he's doing, frankly. >> Although, if I read correctly, you went to Gilman, right?
- >> Yes. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. So, I mean, obviously an extremely I assume that means you grew up in the Baltimore area
- somewhere. >> Yep. Yeah. So, I grew up in Oinks Mills, moved out to Sykesville, which is
- further away from Baltimore, and then my mom saw the opportunity we had to go to
- school like Gilman, and we ended up commuting every day back into Baltimore. But, um, my mother and and grandparents,
- they were, uh, and father were always about academics. And literally if if you know I tell young athletes this all the
- time if I did not have A's and B's I was not able to play right and it wasn't something I enjoy school I enjoy
- learning I enjoy growing my brain but it also my mom I always say my mama I don't
- play that. So um I I got to give her an incredible amount of of um praise for sticking to that and prioritizing that
- over everything. My grandfather, he played for 11 years in the NFL as well too with the Baltimore Colts. Won a
- Super Bowl um lost a Super Bowl to Joe Nameoth and the Jets. Won a Super Bowl against the Dallas Cowboys. But when
- your hero uh is also a former NFL player and he preaches grades and the fact that
- no one can ever take your brain away from you and things of that nature, um it makes it easy to go all in when it
- comes to learning, frankly. And so um again he actually was one of the people who made me feel comfortable and
- confident coming to a school like Penn. I remember being a junior at Gilman and walked into we had college counselors
- and uh I walked into that college counselor, Mr. Chris office for the first time and he said um hey I cope I
- think you I think you can consider a Ivy League school. And I was like Ivy League
- that's that's funny. I just want to play football. I want to go to a big-time school and play some football and things
- of that nature. And um my grandfather once he heard that, he imparted his wisdom on me and said, "Hey, listen um
- you're good enough to play in the NFL." And he always said this. He's he passed away January 6, 2019. But um I always
- remember he said, "You're good enough to play in the NFL, and I would never lie to you. Lying to you would be like lying
- to myself, and there's no point in ever doing that. Don't ever do that because you can't face your problems. You're
- good enough to play. Um, there's three things that can stop you and derail you because I've seen that derail most
- people's careers. Two of them are in your control and one of them is out of your control. It's women, it's drugs,
- and it's injuries. Okay? You have two of those three that you can control yourself. Injuries you can't necessarily
- do. But ultimately, he's the one who made me feel comfortable and confident going to a school like Penn, trying my
- best to become a quote unquote um big fish in a small pond, so to speak. And um he said, "If you're good enough,
- they'll come find you, and I believe you're good enough." And so that's what made me take the leap. And also, you
- know, not to get too longwinded here, my third to last game of my high school season, we played a team called Lyola.
- And for those in the Maryland area, you you know you know what that means. Um and ultimately a a teammate of mine got
- hurt. I was a captain of the team and they put me in on kick return, which I hadn't done kick return or special teams
- since seventh grade. Um and that was my first time doing it. And the next time I
- ever did it was actually in the NFL to fight for a job, oddly enough. But um I was in the kick return. I was on the
- wedge. Coach asked me to do it at halftime. I'm like, "Of course I'm captain. Let's do this." and one of my
- own teammates falls on the back of my leg and my ankle and it pops and I'm limping around for the rest of the
- season. It was third to last game of the season and ultimately um that's when I realized that everyone was right with
- that notion of you're one play away from having your entire career ripped away from you. So that also cemented the
- mindset of like let's go I have an opportunity to go to the Wharton School of Business. I have an opportunity to go
- to Penn. Let's go do it. And if I'm good enough, they'll come find me. >> And they did find you.
- >> Yeah, they did. Fortunately, >> how did that process work for you coming out of pen?
- >> Yeah. So, um, what a process. Um, I I I've never had a major injury while in college and while training for the pro
- day. Again, you will tell I can remember things pretty vividly, but January 21st,
- 2013, I'm doing I'm squatting and I'm preparing for my pro day, six weeks before it, I'm squatting and I'm doing
- five sets of two of I had 545 pounds on the bar or 445 pounds on the bar and I'm
- trying to get big and strong, all that type of stuff. And literally on my last rep, last set, I come up and my knee
- just pops. And I'm at the pen weight room, we have mirrors, and my punter was spotting me. His name is Scott Leano,
- also my classmate. He ended up trying out with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. But literally, my knee pops and it starts to
- cave in and everything just slows up and I'm just like, "Wow." Well, that's the end of this story. And I'm thinking this
- whole weight is going to come down on me. And then I look up and I see the punter spot me out of everybody that
- could have been spotting me. I'm like, I got the the skinniest guy. Fortunately, Fortunately, I was able to
- get it up, but um I literally had to have surgery. I had to have I tore my meniscus. That was what that pop was. I
- had to have my first knee surgery on February 1st, 2013. It was actually the same day of our football banquet. So, I
- had to I was a solo captain that year. I had to get up and do a speech. So, that
- morning, I get surgery. Dr. Brian sent it. um of the uh University of Pennsylvania uh sports medicine
- department uh operates on my knee and then later that evening we have the banquet. I do a speech and um I just
- remember with my crutches getting up there. I literally had six weeks to get prepared to have the best interview of
- my life and the fastest I've ever ran. Benched the most I've ever benched. And you know, technically a meniscus tear is
- a six week long rehab process. I mean, you see JJ McCarthy, who's, you know, a different caliber of athlete than I was,
- but he tore his meniscus before the season started and he sat out the whole NFL season. I had to get ready to run a
- fast 40 six weeks later on March 18th. Um, took three weeks of just doing upper body stuff and rehabbing and trying to
- do upper body crossfit to stay in shape. Took three weeks to try to run again and
- learn how to run again with, you know, less cushion in between my knees and joints and stuff like that. And
- fortunately, I went out there. We went to Villanova to do the pro day and um went out there and and I had a a good
- interview. I won't say it was the best of my life. It was still nervous. A lot of the things I was doing for the first
- time um full speed since the injury and fortunately scouts that came out there thought that I did well enough to
- warrant seeing more tape and more film. So, um, from that pro day on March 18th,
- then you go on a circuit of just doing workouts for different teams. I worked out with the Eagles. I worked out with
- the Ravens. And frankly, what you're just trying to do just for, you know, the the God's honest truth, for those on
- the outside looking in, you before you go into that process, you kind of understand where you're projected to go.
- And so if you're a first round draft pick projection, your job is don't mess this thing up, right? Don't don't run
- slow. Don't throw the ball all over the place and ruin your chances. You're undrafted projection like me. Your job
- is to, hey, how can I create some buzz and demand about myself that makes people feel like, again, the draft is
- all marketing. I I I want the Ravens to feel like the Browns may pick me one pick earlier, and then the the Bengals
- to feel like, well, I want them, too. and and so let's pick them in this round. And and so that was what we were
- trying to do. And you know, fortunately, uh before that draft, we had a lot of teams calling us, the Packers, the
- Colts, uh the Chiefs, the Ravens, and saying that, you know, they were interested, but ultimately on that day,
- no one was interested enough to actually pull the trigger and draft me. Um I remember having the family at the house.
- I lived at 3928 Sansom Street. Um, and you know, we had the family and friends at the house watching it and everything
- like that. And, uh, I remember being pissed that day, honestly. And I think that, frankly, that's that's my nature
- and character. Um, not not that I'm a pissed-off individual, but more so chip on the shoulder. it it's what fueled me
- to 10 years in the NFL because um although I was projected to be undrafted and dealt with some adversity, I felt in
- my heart that I even with a bum knee at the time outperformed some folks at the combine
- that they were drafting in the first, second, and third round. And so now that put me in a place where the chip was on
- my shoulder of like I am going to prove you wrong. I am going to prove you wrong.
- >> So Audi, go ahead and then I want to move on to his NFL days. I have some questions about analytics and his role
- in >> Yeah. So, so one of the things that and from the analytics perspective, we have
- a very hard time in across sports when trying to judge athletic performance when there's very strong levels of
- leagues. So in soccer, you have 42 different leagues. Very hard to figure out, you know, who you can get. Um I
- would imagine they're sort of similar when you're trying to deal with sort of player who's played at Penn. you didn't
- really get to see you at the top level of uh performance. So, how does an NFL approach a a player coming from the Ivy
- Leagues? What are they doing to decide that they can play in the NFL? Is there is there measurements or is there I mean
- this is really this is a fascinating kind of analytic question. They can do combine like stuff but that seems to be
- rather incomplete. How do they how do you judge such a thing? Yeah, I think it's the toughest thing for those folks
- in those scouting departments because as my Dline coach told me before preparing
- for that, he said, "Listen, um, if you're a athlete at Bama, at the time Bama was killing it, right? Um, if
- you're an athlete at Bama, you and there's certain boxes you need to check to get into the NFL, right? You need to
- have good film. You need to have uh good testing at the combine. Run a good 40. Jump a good height. And you also need to
- be a good person off the field, right? Like we need to know that you're going to be available to play. Those are the
- three boxes. Um if you go to Bama, you may have good film and you may have a bad 40 and the NFL is more likely to
- say, "Okay, he doesn't have to check that box, right?" Or, you know, some combination of of of the three. Ivy
- League athlete, you better check every single box, right? Like there's no room for error. And so from their
- perspective, you know, I I talked to some of the scouts. I never really got super detailed in the analytics,
- although I did um I did get to see what I would like to try to do as many times as possible, see the other team scouting
- report of me, which not not isn't really analytical of like what he does on third
- down and this that and this. It's more so what you say about me as an athlete and a player. Um,
- but what they always said was, you know, it was so tough to judge you because you
- only played against, I think, two tackles that made it in the NFL. Two or three tackles that made it in the NFL.
- And, um, JC Tredder was one. Uh, Ben Eelana, who's a second round draft pick from Villanova, was another. and um Greg
- Van Roen who he hadn't panned out until later on but he's now 12 or 13 years in the NFL um you know with I think the
- Giants now but anyway that was always the toughest thing and I think that from an analytical perspective you know what
- analytics can fail to see at times is the heart and the mind of an athlete and for me that was one thing where I knew I
- was always going to beat people out and it it's not just in the pros but also in
- college. I used to always tell athletes like there is always going to be a time where there's adversity and the cream
- will rise to the top. There's some people who can't deal with it. You get hurt. Coach isn't playing you. some play
- goes the wrong way and some athletes I've seen time and time again will make excuses for why they're not playing or
- will try to use it as an excuse to oh I'm not going to work as hard coach doesn't care so I'm not going to work as
- hard and I'm like you're only hurting yourself and I always told myself year after year even in the NFL because it
- happens in the NFL there's some athletes who get there and they've never been told no they've never been told you're
- not good enough they've never had somebody like hem them up on a bull rush. Just got to stay the course. Stay
- the course. Stay the course. And I think that if analytics, and I'm not saying, you know, you guys have your own, they
- have their own process that clearly works to build a multi-billion dollar industry, but I would say how do you
- look at how an athlete has dealt with adversity to determine will they last in this beast of a game? Because this thing
- is literally mental. Like the NFL is a when they say 90% mental, 10% physical, that is what it is. I've watched grown
- men quit in the middle of not only games but also a season. You're like, you made
- it. You done all the hard work. Why are you quitting now? But mentally, you can go insane just dealing with the politics
- and the business and the money of of of the NFL. So that would be my suggestion.
- >> So co, before we talk about athletes.org, I want to talk about your time in the NFL since you were there for
- 10 years since, you know, we can only hope that analytics plays a role and continues to play a role within the NFL.
- Certainly, it's one of the sports that, you know, lots of things can be measured. You know, lots of things have,
- you know, AI and lots of others have worked on things like, you know, now going for it on fourth down and, you
- know, etc. Can you tell us in your career what you saw the major roles of analytics within your NFL career?
- Whether it was in your own training, whether it was in onfield decisions, whether you know h how did you see it
- being used? >> Yeah. For game planning and and preparation. So every single week we
- come in and different teams structured in different ways, but on Wednesday, you know, if we come in and I'm on the
- Patriots or the Jets or anybody, you know, we're typically because on Wednesday we're on P we're in pads,
- we're typically going over first, second down, some of the rundowns and short yardage we do later in the week, but
- we're starting to talk about what their favorite runs are, right? Um, look, ultimately you're using those analytics
- and those statistics to start to figure out, hey, on second and short, there's some teams on second and short that 73%
- of the time they're going to try to take that as a a chance to to throw a deep ball or to take a shot. There's some
- teams on second and short, San Francisco 49ers in certain years, would say, "Hey,
- we're just going to go get the first down." Patriots sometimes we're just going to go get the first down. Um, but
- ultimately you're using those analytics to help you play faster. You're trying to figure out the tendencies not only
- of, you know, there there's the onetoone battle of, hey, I'm Brandon Copeland. I'm the outside linebacker typically on
- the left side. So this week I'm going against Trent Williams or or Laramie Tonsel and his tendency on third down is
- to get out fast, right? there are certain tendencies that that individual player may have. But I also want to know
- the tendencies that the offensive coordinator may have. So in third and short, is he doing play actions? Is he
- doing crossing routes? Is he trying to pick route me? Right? Like if they put the running back out wide, what is that
- running back likely to do? And and Greg Williams was one of my deep coordinators, and I love the way he put
- it. He said, "Your job as a football player is to use your instincts to guess before
- the snap whether it's run or pass." And then once that ball is So I'm using my instincts. Um, hey, the wide receiver
- just did this on their gloves. Every time Odell Beckham does that, it's a pass. He doesn't do this to block,
- right? or there's certain running backs who would literally always look around whenever it was a run trying to throw
- you off, but they're really trying to scan to see where they're going to be doing certain things, right? So, I'm
- using those tendencies to determine whether it's a run or pass, but then I'm also using the statistics that we
- learned during the week before the before we say ready break, right? I'm looking at is third and two. I know
- third and two they like crossing routes and I'm using those statistics to understand how can I play faster and
- assume where the ball is going because as a I think let me culminate in all this Greg Williams would say anyone can
- learn in statistics I pay you as a football player to be an athlete and react but before the snap you shouldn't
- be playing both run and pass you should be playing one so you think it's a run go play run and then be an NFL player,
- elite athlete, and react to pass if you're wrong. And that's what will make you special as a player.
- >> That's really an interesting philosophy. And obviously, Greg Williams has earned
- his right to uh to have that opinion. So tell us about your NFL career ends. H tell us about athletes.org. First, tell
- us tell our listeners here on Morton Moneyball, what is athletes.org? Um how did you make the transition from the NFL
- to a co-founder of it? tell us about its financial literacy aspects, its player advocacy aspects. We we'd just love to
- hear all about it in your own words. >> Yeah, so uh first and foremost, what athletes.org is is it's a players
- association for college athletes. And if you are following anything about the college athletic space right now, you're
- seeing a lot of chaos, what people will say, or the wild wild west, so to speak.
- Um, and what that wild wild west is, and frankly some of it I think is a little overblown to a certain extent, but the
- wild wild west is because there are no rules that can be enforced over college athletes without violating antitrust,
- right? So for years, the NCAA in 1959, they created a term name called student athlete. 1959 there was a football
- player named Ray Dennison who played for the Fort Lagus Fort Lewis Aggies um who
- had a brain injury and he died and he had a wife and three children. His wife came to the NCAA trying to get workers
- compensation to help cover for at that time especially the male was the bread winner of the family the worker of the
- family and the NCAA came up with the term student athlete. Walter Walter Buyers was their leader then and student
- athlete allowed for them to keep and maintain amateurist an amateur status for athletes and not workers
- compensation like they would for an employee. That term which we all use and I use now
- we at athletes.org call them college athletes simply because of what that term was born through. It's been used
- other times to again have the NCAA avoid doing what's right in my opinion for um
- the people who help them generate billions of dollars. Um but but ultimately that term is similar to a
- term in my opinion like NIL or name, image, and likeness that has been created to now finally pay college
- athletes money. name image likeness came about July 1st 2021 but it really came from a Oannon versus NCAA case back in
- 2015 2016 is when it was decided I think he started suit in 2012 to >> be clear do you separate out you know
- Eric Bradlow the booster giving cope money from the university giving cope money and how do you perceive like where
- the money's coming from and what role athletes.org or might play in that. >> Yeah. So, I think what I'm giving you is
- some context of how it's gotten here. And I I'll answer that question, but I think that basically be because athletes
- are generating money now and right now they're generating NIL money, money off their name, image, and likeness, which
- in every other field is a marketing deal. Right? The way I tell people, Patrick Mahomes, let's do Philly. All
- right? I'm sorry, not Pat Mahomes. Jaylen Herz. Okay, Jaylen Herz. We would look at Jaylen Herz like he was crazy if
- he did not make money from the Eagles for throwing touchdowns to AJ Brown. Right now, Jaylen Herz can make money
- from the Eagles for performing on the field, but then he can also go make money from Beats by Dre and from Nike
- and from Gatorade. And that's using his name, image, and likeness to go get marketing deals. Right now, what schools
- have done since July 1st, 2021 is tried to say, "Hey, athletes are still amateurs. They're not paying for
- performance because they're afraid that would trigger employment status, but we're paying them for their name, image,
- and likeness. And so, they've been up until this point recently, they've been raising money from donors and
- collectives to do marketing deals with athletes, but really it's to play quarterback and to play tight end and to
- play outside linebacker, right? With that being said, that has also been a house of cards
- because one, when athletes get hurt, some schools aren't paying them. When athletes aren't performing well, some
- schools aren't paying them. >> So, just to be clear, if if COPE has a deal with Nike from his for his name,
- image, and likeness, the money is filtered through the University of Pennsylvania. At least it has been
- historically. Nike pays Penn and Penn pays COPE, >> right? That's what it's been since July
- 1st, 2021. >> Now, because of the House settlement, House v NCAA settlement, um, that just
- was agreed upon and approved by Judge Claudia Wilin in July. Now, for the first time in history,
- schools can pay cope directly. They couldn't do that up until this point, but now schools will literally
- University of Maryland, University of Pennsylvania, Georgia will be able to pay an athlete directly for their name,
- image, and likeness. Okay? So now the money that they used to push to collectives will now be coming through
- the school to an athlete up until for some schools $20.5 million for the year. So that's like where we are today. What
- is athletes.org's role in this right now? One, there's no protection. Actually, let me the easier way to say
- this or explain it because it's easier in NFL terms. The NFL negotiates with the NFL players association and they are
- partners in a multi-billion dollar business. And because the NFL PA represents all of the NFL players and
- negotiates on things like what the minimum compensation should be and what the fine schedule is and hey if uh
- practice can only be this amount of time and our offseason has to be this length
- and all these different rules and we as players agree to that in a collectively bargained agreement. Now you are able to
- give the NFL antitrust exemption, so to speak, right? Where now we're agreeing to the rules that we play within and
- we're agreeing to free agency. Anything less than that without a CBA, the NFL will be getting sued like the NCAA has
- been because you're limiting my earning potential by colluding to create some rules of when I can transfer, when I
- can't transfer, how much money I can take, a salary cap, and things of that nature. You're
- >> This is an equivalent, but for college players, does it cover >> all schools, D1 schools, all sports, or
- how how does athletes.org or work and how does it how does who is the collective? How about that?
- >> Yeah. Yeah. So, right now we have 4,831 college athletes, current college athletes in our organization.
- 700 of them over 2,700 are P4 men's basketball, women's basketball, and football players. Um the let me we're
- we're on the Wharton podcast, so let's talk business and talk money. And some people don't like this, right? But I'm I
- I want to be clear as I say this. I was a University of Pennsylvania football player. uh the the issues that I have
- and the amount of money I earned pen, which was probably nothing, uh is totally different than what an Alabama
- football player earns for his university and the issues that an Alabama football
- player has. And although we all deserve to be treated fair, I'd be lying to you all if I said that I was equally as
- valuable as a University of Georgia, University of Alabama football player to their university. there different media
- deals, different contracts and things like that. And what people need to understand is um the NFL is the most
- popular sport in this country. The second most popular is college football. It is not the NBA. It is not the MLB. If
- you look at the ratings list, the analytics on the ratings, it's NFL college football, period.
- after that and and and because of that the NCAA has been able to generate over 13 billion dollars of revenue every
- single year and that is largely driven by football. Okay. So I say all that to say athletes.org we right now represent
- all college athletes. We give them benefits like pro bono legal services. We got over 100 lawyers that literally
- will review contracts for college athletes for free right now. free background checks, free mental wellness
- resources, actors, >> any individual can choose to be part of your collective. It's not It's literally
- individual by individual chooses to be part of athletes.org. >> Absolutely. 100%. Right now, it's 100%
- free. We understand that as the market evolves, there are different realities out there where it may just be football
- and men's basketball. Danny White, the University of Tennessee AD, has a public proposal out there that's saying that
- football and men's basketball should split split from the universities or or become employees themselves and do a CBA
- by themselves because that's where the money is and it'll still provide enough money for the other Olympic sports and
- non-revenue generating sports to exist, right? Athletes.org, Frankly, we have to
- serve whomever that top tier athlete is because they need to have a representative, a real representative in
- the multi-billion dollar negotiations that exist. But we like to say, if you don't have a seat at the table, you will
- end up on the menu. And athletes ending up on the menu has been what has caused lawsuit after lawsuit after lawsuit
- after lawsuit, which is unsustainable for college athletics. and frankly a waste of taxpayer dollars. A lot of the
- money is going to these billion dollar settlements for public institutions and that money is coming from a lot of
- federal funding as well too. >> AI, you wanted to jump in? >> Uh yeah. So one of my kind of uh pending
- questions is really a prediction. So much of the energy behind college football is because of people attached
- to the colleges, right? So if you think about you mentioned a few other sports um I I'll add a a quick correction. Um
- one of the reasons why football is so popular is there's so few games. So on the on the per game basis football just
- dominates. But if you actually add up the number of people go to a major league baseball game. It's way more than
- go to a a football game just because it's 162 of them in in a season. But but take baseball from it. No one cares
- about the minors. It's just like whatever. I mean, it's it's fun for the people who
- go and they're they make money and they're I don't want to totally belittle them, but imagine what's a world look
- like where college is essentially almost disconnected and professionalized. Are people going to care about it as much as
- they do now because of the connection to the the athletes as students? I mean, somehow there's something that allows us
- to relate to the students when they're students that I wonder whether will be lost when they are fully professional.
- >> Yeah. I think you have to look at the status quo, right? And and you know, while my job isn't necessarily to try to
- make it so that this is an attractive product for the future to the fan, I do believe that there's a win-winwin
- in for all parties and and I think the status quo right now, you have athletes who are able to transfer every single
- year if they want to. Um, you also have athletes who So, you know, what loyalty and affinity do they have? You also have
- athletes. We just did a a meeting with 24 general managers of P4 schools, some of the top 10, top 20 teams, and one of
- the general managers in the room stated, you know, he just got a transfer to his
- university that's been in college for three years and has never taken an in-person class. And at their
- university, they're going to make you take an in-person class. So, I think that, you know, for so long, you know, I
- think the NCAA and schools have used the whole, well, this is about academics and
- education and developing the athlete mantra as a shield when really I I don't think at certain levels it's ever really
- been about that. And and that is not me, my opinion. That's like there's a number
- of athletes who want to take a certain major and the school won't let them or the the team won't let them because it
- conflicts with too many games or classes. There's a number of athletes who I know personally who wanted to hey
- I wanted to be an engineer. I wanted to take cyber security. I'd love to take sports management but post made me take
- sociology right or communications because that fit with the schedule. what value am I actually getting from this
- degree I if this is what you're making me do so that I can be prepared for March Madness or whatever, right? Um so
- that's one thing. Two, I you take as recent as University of Florida men's basketball team. Um there was a video
- right after they won the national championship this year and someone went around the locker room said, "Hey, what
- class is it went viral? What what class do you have on Monday? What class do you
- have tomorrow?" Right? or or tomorrow when you get back to campus and literally the answers it's kind of
- disheartening. I don't know. I haven't been to class in such and such online. I I can't remember. Right. And while the
- comments and the fans were laughing and joking, you know, honestly, >> I think with a true CBA, I think you can
- incentivize and create rules and frameworks that incentivize high academic performance. And that's
- something that we talked about this weekend with the GMs in the room that actually still care about that as well
- too. I think that, you know, for for the world out there, some folks believe that
- it should be 100% focused on the academics, but we have to also keep in mind that for years, again, over 13
- billion dollars generated annually. It it's your AD can change their life forever.
- your coach can change their life forever. It's okay for an athlete to be able to financially change their life
- forever early. And some people don't like that. I, you know, I understand, well, I don't understand why some people
- don't like that, but I can understand that it's new. It's different. But my thought process has always been,
- it's not my job to block your blessing. You know, if you're very talented at this, you also understand that
- especially a sport like football, I can't do it forever. I'm 30. I retired at 32, right? Like, so if I could have
- the extra four years of earning power and potential, let me do it. And final thing I'll say, and I'll give it back to
- you, Audi, is is a lot of these athletes in college, I mean, I'm on CNBC's Global
- Financial Wellness Council. And what that means is there was a lot of times where I was doing conversations and
- interviews about money and athletes with their money and so many times people said, "Hey, how come a lot of athletes
- are going broke? How come, you know, what about being an overnight millionaire?" Well, if you look at some
- of the teams I was on, you know, there's people who played in bigger stadiums in
- college and they do in the pros and they sold out bigger stadiums in college than
- we did. I remember look the Atlanta Falcons. We never sold out a game, but if you had that Bama, Georgia game, you
- know, and Calvin Ridley is playing wide receiver, that game is sold out. That stadium is sold out. And so it is just
- because he's in college doesn't mean he's not able to earn money. That could be a valuable lesson for them and stuff
- like that. So again, I know that that's not what you're saying, Audi, but that's
- just me. Some of the things I hear in the market sometimes. >> Well, Cope, we'd like to thank you for
- joining us today on Morton Moneyball. We've been talking to Brandon Copelan, uh, proud former Wharton School alum,
- proud 10-year NFL alum, and maybe the greatest chapter he's going to play in his life, uh, which is as co-founder of
- athletes.org. So, Brandon Formati and myself, obviously, we're proud of everything you've accomplished. Uh, keep
- fighting for the college athlete. They're they're worth it. And the the way you talked about the impact on
- people and their lives and their communities is really inspiring to all of us. So, thank you for joining us here
- and thank you for the work that you're doing. >> Thank you guys so much for having me. I
- appreciate you. >> So, that's been Brandon Copelan. Uh, please stay with us after the break and
- still listen to us here on the Wharton podcast network and Wharton Moneyball. Welcome back to the remainder of our
- show here on the Wharton podcast network. This is Eric Bradlo, professor of marketing, statistics, and data
- science. I'm joined today with my colleague, friend, longtime friend and collaborator Audi Winer, professor of
- statistics and data science. some combination of the two of us, Shane Jensen and Cade Massie are here every
- week on the podcast edition of Wharton Moneyball. Obviously, a great conversation with Brandon Copeland Cop
- about his both his pen days, his NFL days, and athletes.org. Lots to talk to him about. Um, there's some quick issues
- I wanted to raise Audi that I've been thinking about in the world of analytics and wanted to get your reaction to them
- in the like few minutes we have left of the show. First, um, today's an interesting day for the Yankees and I
- wanted to get your take on it. So Aaron Judge is coming off the DL today or IIL today, 10day ILIL and they're going to
- have him play DH. The problem is is that uh Aaron Boon has already said Stanton's
- not playing the outfield. So the problem is that means Stanton cannot be the DH and he's been crushing the ball lately.
- So my my ask to you is can you tell our listeners on Moneyball? If you were purely making an analytics decision,
- maybe he does cost you something in the field, but maybe he gains you a lot more
- with his bat. How would you think about playing them both? Matter of fact, you can imagine interaction effects with
- Judge and Stanton in the lineup. Judge is better, Stanton is better, and the whole team is better. So, how would you
- even think about it? Forget forget whether Stanton can play the field. He can play the field. We know he can play
- the field, but how would you even think about that as a decision from an analytics perspective? Cuz I think he
- should damn play Stanton the way he's hitting the ball right now. >> Well, the real issue is, I mean, why is
- he not going to put Judge out in the field? If Judge can't throw, then he can't be in the field and maybe he's not
- ready to come back yet. Um, the the thing the difficulty with Stan is if Stan is very streaky, right? So the no
- the the the mean value of judge is substantially higher at bat than the mean value of Stanton. So
- >> no one's saying Judge shouldn't Stanton should play instead of Judge. >> Right. Right. The question is you're
- saying is should we get him out there and be in the field and just hobble. >> Yeah.
- >> That the difficulty is that we're not really sure how costly that is because we don't put someone out there with legs
- as poor as as Stanton out in say left field, right? >> Yeah. He'd have to be in left. you have
- to be in left and you wonder what that can cost you. I mean, if if he makes an out, an extra out a game, that's
- terrible in in the field and that probably doesn't overwhelm what would replace him at left field and at the
- bat. Remember, the Yankees do have a little bit of depth there. But I do like your point about interaction. I think
- one of the the the the sneakiest and most overlooked aspect of baseball is the interaction of players within a
- lineup. And we're so used to just adding a player's value, just the war or the sum. Everything sums because no other
- sport does that, right? You you can't do that with basketball. You can't do that
- with football. Everything is interactive. And we we've gone so far the other way that we just add up. You
- know, we don't recognize that there's interaction. And so you can have three players who have the same kind of value
- to a mean team, but in a different lineup, they have tremendous um interactions, which can create either
- less value or more value. And I think Stanton adds a lot of a lot to a Yankee lineup with Judge in it. So I would
- actually I think that I'm I'm kind of agreeing with you. I'd rather see Stanton out there in left hobbling
- rather than or Judge hobbling. I'm not sure who's worse. >> Judge will get to the ball. He may not
- be able to throw the guy out once he catches the ball. >> Right. I mean, I wonder do you know how
- how bad his his his throwing arm is? >> They don't really know. They just said he's going to start besides hitting
- today. He's going to play DH. They're going to have him play catch in the outfield. They actually don't know cuz
- he hasn't thrown in the last 10 days. They don't know if he can play the field. >> The other thing is is that you do have
- Stanton as a pinch hitter which is and you put him in every game so it's not quite nothing, right? And that's and
- that's the other thing I think that's been undervalued in baseball as we shift to this post um analytics world where
- you have 13 pitchers and and um everything is done sort of programmatically with with these short
- stints for the starters and the relievers. Um, I think that we've missed the value of having bench players um and
- and having potentially Stanton not to run but to pinch hit in in in a key situation. So remember, think about that
- now. You you're you're trading Stanton's kind of random atbat for putting Stanton
- in when you kind of need him, right? Potentially that you can do that. And so that has a little value as well.
- >> That's a great point. You could play if if he needs to bat for the number eight
- spot or nine spot because that's where he's valuable. you put him in and it's a high leverage situation,
- >> right? That could be the sixth inning if you if you need to be or fifth inning.
- >> I know you've spoken many times about no need to save him for the ninth. If that
- high leverage situation's in the sixth, you bat him in the sixth. >> But we since we're since it is the two
- of us, we can talk about the Yankees failures and and I I mean pin it fundamentally on on the relief.
- >> It's just terrible. No, it's just it's just absolutely terrible and it's g, you
- know, I'm not sure the Yankees I mean there's a good story they don't make the playoffs even as a wild card team.
- >> Oh, I think they're they're third. I think the Red Sox have passed them in the East.
- >> Red Sox have passed them >> and and the thing is is that you watch these games and I mean so Neil Payne,
- you know, the incredibly versible, prolific, insightful. He wrote this beautiful article ranking a major league
- baseball players teams based on their deviation from Pythagoras and the Yankees were laugh. Just remind people
- what that is, which is we compute runs scored. We compute runs against. You square them. Runs scored over runs
- scored. Runs scored squared divided by runs scored squared plus runs against squared. And that's a prediction of your
- winning percentage. And so teams that are neutral, meaning they score the same as they uh give up, uh that's 50/50. And
- then you know so the Yankees what you're saying is the Yankees have a a plus p a
- plus you know let's call it maybe they score have scored 400 runs they've given up 350 Pythagorean uh score would say
- they should be winning 60% of their games but they're winning 53%. So it's that deviation that you're talking about
- and typically a lot of that is attributed to bad closing. >> That's right or bad luck usually say. So
- years ago, I remember that when I was first teaching my first Moneyball class, do you remember that season in I think
- it was 2015 and by about twothirds of the season, the Yankees had a a a comfortable but but not tight le not not
- large lead over Toronto and the Yankees had a were performing exactly as predicted. Their performance on the
- field and winning percentage exactly matched what would be predicted by their Pythagorean. But the Blue Jays were way
- underperforming in terms of their winning percentage. And going forward, it was it was a scary thought because
- the Blue Jays were really clearly the better team and they actually did win the the division that that that year. So
- you're looking at the Yankees and usually you would say when you're underperforming your Pythagorean, you
- can expect better in the future progression to the mean. But with the Yankees, I somehow feel that the fact
- that they're losing these close games time after time after the game is the hole in their entire organization is
- just the the bullpen, the bullpen management. And and of course, we listen to Cope for a moment.
- >> The the the winning drive. I don't know. I've never been one to argue that that's
- something that matters, right? >> But watching this team lose lead after lead, >> you have to wonder.
- >> Yeah. All right. Let me go to another baseball player. I just Is he a Hall of
- Famer? And I'm about to say who I am. Is Schwarber a Hall of Famer? I mean, this
- year now, he's got 40 and 94 right now. 40 home runs, 94 RBI. He has a world champion. He was on that he was a rookie
- on the Cubs team that won the title. I've got to look I mean, maybe you could look up his stats while we're talking
- here. I mean, he he could easily end up being a 500 home run guy. No, >> he's got what 315 right now. Um, how
- many has he got exactly? But in the low threes. How many years does he have left? I mean that that's the real
- question. >> He's actually he's only 32. >> He's 32. Um so he's roughly the same age
- as Harper Judge. >> He's a year younger than Judge. He has 324 home runs and 746 RBI's. So it's not
- great. >> So I would say his odds are poor. Um but not undoable. I mean, if he continues to
- perform at a high level for three to five years like this, hitting 30, 40 home runs, he'll be 500
- and then if he hits 500, game in, man. >> He gets 500 and500 RBI's, he's in the home field.
- >> For sure. Absolutely. I mean, that's 16 years of, you know, solid top of the league home run.
- >> You have to you have to average, you know, if he you have to basically average 30 and 100 over a 15ear span.
- That's Hall of Fame. >> I remember Shane wrote that little research note about having the cut off
- and he'd be over that cutoff pretty easily. >> Yeah, I think so. So, let me ask you a
- sport. I know you don't follow a lot, but how would you analytically think about this? So, NovakJokovic we know is
- 38. >> He lost to Wimbledon in the semi-finals. >> The US Open's coming up in a couple
- weeks. NovakJokovic is not playing at all between the two tournaments. And so, the rest people say, well, that's what
- an older guy needs to do. the other people are saying, you know, he's not going to have any match readiness coming
- into the US Open. Forget whether I mean, you're not an expert in tennis. I'm not.
- I mean, I I pretend to be an expert in tennis, but how would you even think about addressing that issue like which
- is better, rest or match readiness? I mean, you could just do a simple empirical analysis, right, which is you
- could measure all kinds of things, but you know, I I would >> that would be a that would be a
- difficult study. This would be an exact, you know, some some particular causal inference type study.
- >> That's the problem is that >> can we do an instrumental variable or something that predicts
- >> not just that, but it's self- selected. There's a reason he's choosing not to
- play. And so the X's are not random and correlated with some unobservable, which
- is the standard problem that we have in causal inference. And so, you know, what's causing him to perform worse or
- better? Who knows if it is? So, I think we can only look back at at the macro level and see the longevity of today's
- superstars is monumental compared to what they were when we were kids. Come on. >> I mean, think about Connors playing at
- 31. He was he was a grandfather in in the >> I know, but Connor's Connors Connors
- made the semi-finals of the US Open at age 39. He's the one exception. >> He's the exception, but most of them
- were done. >> Empress was retired at 31. Y remember retired at 26. Menroe never won a major after age 28. I mean guys
- were done by their early 30s. >> Absolutely done. And and I think most people attribute
- the longevity to the rest the stretching it out and of course nutrition and the trainers and the the vast amount of
- money that they make relative to what they used to which allows them to skip tournaments. I mean, they had to they
- had to do all those tournaments in years past just to make the living they needed
- to make. Um, so I would I would say that that if I had to just toss a coin based
- on not knowledge, um, the rest is what he needs and the readiness he can get by volleying with his coaches and and
- >> not just that, maybe the first two or three matches are his readiness. He should be able to beat me and you in the
- first couple of rounds. >> He can beat me and you playing doubles against him. >> All right. So, one last thing was about
- the NBA. So, I didn't put this in a run. I wanted you to guess. So, OKC obviously
- is the defending champs, right, in basketball. >> I just recently looked today at their
- odds of making the NBA Finals. So, not winning, but going to the finals in the Western Conference. Remember, Clippers
- are in the Western Conference. The Mavs are in the Western Conference. The Nuggets are in the Western Conference.
- The Lakers are in the Western Conference. The Timberwolves are in the Western Conference. What do you think
- the betting odds are right now for OKC to make the finals? So, just for our listeners, if Audi thinks it's a third,
- he would guess plus 200 roughly. If he thought it was a quarter, he'd go plus 300. If he thought it was 20%, he would
- go plus 400. What do you think the odds are right now? >> Them making the finals.
- >> Making the finals. >> Be the Western champion. >> Western. >> Um, I'd say plus 300.
- >> Yeah. So, you're not that far off. I would have guessed higher than it's plus
- 240. Um, how about who do you think is the favorite in the East? Uh, oh, by the way, I should say it's
- plus 240 because they're giving they're shorting you the odds. Remember, my odds
- are what I would call fair. >> Yeah. So, yours might actually equate to a betting of plus 240 cuz they're not
- even if the truth is plus 300, they're not giving you plus 300. They give you plus 240.
- >> 240. So, so I think we're roughly in the bulk part. So, what was your second question?
- >> Who's the uh Eastern Conference? Who do you think the favorite is? And what's
- their odds? >> God, is it not the Celtics? Well, remember Jason Tatum's out for the
- season. Tornado. >> He's out for the season >> and they traded Porzingis, >> right? Uh
- >> so it's Jaylen Brown and me and you is on the team right now. >> Is it Knicks? No, it could be the
- Knicks. It's the Knicks. Oh my god. >> 700. >> Yes. Yes. Exactly. >> No. No. Just to show you
- >> the Eastern Conference is essentially a uniform distribution over the Cavs, the
- Knicks, the Bucks, maybe the Celtics. You know, who knows if the Sixers can get their act together. you know, they
- have some talent. Um, I just think it's going to be I I was just interested by that contrast. OKC in the stronger
- Western Conference plus 240 and the Knicks plus 700 in the weaker Eastern Conference. It It seems
- >> I love I love looking at betting odds before the season starts. This is really
- pretty far away because it's the season just ended. Um, we should be talking about the betting odds in football. I
- did see a very interesting there was a um betting odds on which team is most likely to get the first round draft pick
- and do you want to guess what the team is? >> I mean the first pick in the draft.
- >> So basically the the >> Yeah. Yeah. The team with the worst record. >> Yeah. >> I've got to believe Cleveland's up
- there. >> So I don't remember the order but I just noticed that that it was the Panthers.
- So I was surprised at that given had they had a great they had a great draft. Um,
- >> they had a great draft and they're in a weakish division. I mean, the Bucks are
- fine, the Falcons are fine, the Saints are fine, but, you know, they're not in the, you know, they're not playing the
- Steelers, the Ravens, the, you know, they're not in the, you know, I agree with. And the Steelers, I agree with
- that. Well, that's been another show here on the Wharton podcast network of Wharton Moneyball. Like to thank my
- co-host today, Audi Winer. I'm Eric Bradlo. Some combination of us, Shane Jensen and Cade Massie are here every
- week. Like to thank our producer, Marissa Rener, our associate producer and sound engineer, Dion Simkins.
- Between now and next week, enjoy your sports, enjoy your statistics, and we'll see you next week here on Morton
- Moneyball. [Music]
Brief Summary
Brandon Copelan discusses his journey from D1 athlete to NFL player and co-founding athletes.org for college athlete advocacy.
Key points
- Brandon Copelan's Journey to the NFL. Brandon shares his inspiring journey from being a D1 athlete at Penn to the NFL, emphasizing the importance of education and resilience.
- The Fragility of an Athlete's Career. Brandon discusses the moment he realized how quickly an injury can end a career.
- Mental Challenges in the NFL. Brandon highlights the mental toughness required to succeed in the NFL, stating it's 90% mental.
- Greg Williams' Philosophy. Greg Williams emphasizes the importance of instincts in football, urging players to react decisively.
- The Role of Athletes.org. Brandon Copeland explains the mission of athletes.org in advocating for college athletes' rights and financial literacy.
- Financial Opportunities for Athletes. Copeland highlights the importance of financial empowerment for college athletes in today's landscape.
Episode highlights
- Brandon Copelan's Journey to the NFLBrandon shares his inspiring journey from being a D1 athlete at Penn to the NFL, emphasizing the importance of education and resilience.“If you're good enough, they'll come find you.”5:32Aug 8, 2025
- The Fragility of an Athlete's CareerBrandon discusses the moment he realized how quickly an injury can end a career.“You're one play away from having your entire career ripped away from you.”6:30Aug 8, 2025
- Mental Challenges in the NFLBrandon highlights the mental toughness required to succeed in the NFL, stating it's 90% mental.“The NFL is literally mental. 90% mental, 10% physical.”16:18Aug 8, 2025
- Greg Williams' PhilosophyGreg Williams emphasizes the importance of instincts in football, urging players to react decisively.“Your job as a football player is to use your instincts.”19:02Aug 8, 2025
- The Role of Athletes.orgBrandon Copeland explains the mission of athletes.org in advocating for college athletes' rights and financial literacy.“If you don't have a seat at the table, you will end up on the menu.”30:09Aug 8, 2025
- Financial Opportunities for AthletesCopeland highlights the importance of financial empowerment for college athletes in today's landscape.“It's okay for an athlete to be able to financially change their life forever early.”34:52Aug 8, 2025
- Stanton's Lineup DilemmaShould Stanton play despite fielding concerns? His hitting might outweigh the risks.“I think he should damn play Stanton the way he's hitting the ball right now.”38:50Aug 8, 2025
- Yankees' UnderperformanceThe Yankees are underperforming based on their Pythagorean expectation, raising concerns about their bullpen.“The Yankees have a hole in their entire organization just the bullpen management.”44:34Aug 8, 2025





