Can an NFL Team Win Without Its Starting QB?
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
ABOUT THE EPISODE A quarterback injury can derail an NFL season. But some teams are built to survive it.
Neil Paine, sports writer and data analyst, explains why teams such as the Vikings and Seahawks can remain competitive without their starting quarterbacks. He explores the importance of defense, coaching, supporting talent, and backup-quarterback strategy in an NFL increasingly defined by quarterback injuries.
The conversation also examines MLB's playoff-seeding format and whether division winners should receive automatic advantages over stronger wild card teams, plus why the Florida Panthers could rebound after an injury-filled season.
ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? Moneyball Highlights explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.
----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- Welcome, welcome to Wharton Money Ball. Welcome to a full hour of sports analytics
- here on the Wharton Podcast Network. This is Cade Massey hosting on Tuesday, September
- 22nd with two thirds of my usual cohort. Eric Braddell is here from his office in
- Huntsman Hall and Shane Jensen from his home office in Center City, Philadelphia.
- Adi Weiner making his way back from parts away, a little stuck. Logistics aren't friendly right now in the Northeast
- quarter. He will be back. Some combination, as you guys know, some combination is here almost every week of the year,
- 48, 50 weeks of the year and have been for 12 and a half years now. We are going to follow our usual format
- this week. We're going to talk with a guest in the first half hour and then roll into
- open lines in the second half hour. If I was in the forecasting business, if that's what I did, I would forecast that
- that first half hour might be a little long because our guest today is longtime friend
- of the show, perhaps the longest time friend of the show, sports analyst, extraordinaire, sports writer
- extraordinaire, both analyst and writer. He was the original words and numbers, really
- Neil Payne, words and numbers. Neil Payne is back with us. Neil, good afternoon to you.
- Hey, it's great to be back with you guys. You know, I was jealous that you guys had a powwow in Philly together.
- Um, I think last episode. So I was, uh, you know, anytime you guys want to do that with me, let
- me know. We have to rewarm up the idea that you're local. Neil was in Philly when we started umpteen
- years ago, and then he's been away for a long time and very recently moved back.
- So we got Neil back in the fold. We will in fact need to do a full reunion of some kind sometime soon.
- I'm going to be up more, um, later this fall, teaching Neil. So that's going to be a good window.
- We need to look at that for sure. Neil's sporting local colors, got the Phillies sweatshirt
- on. The, the, the wall of caps is gone. This is, this is a change. He had a wall of caps, like unbelievable
- caps collection. It must exist somewhere, but it's no longer in view. It's it's in storage, unfortunately.
- So I was wearing my old Roy Halladay, uh, t-shirt, uh, and you know, RIP Roy. Okay.
- RIP Roy. All right. Well, Neil, we, we could go, the thing about Neil is you can go a lot
- of different directions. We're going to start with pro football. We want to wander into baseball for sure.
- And frankly, we're only a week away from kicking off the NHL season. Neil's not beyond writing about the NHL.
- In fact, he wrote last week provocatively about the F in Florida Panthers. So maybe we'll talk, we'll talk NHL with
- Neil as well. Neil, let's start with football though. Bad weekend on, in the NFL for quarterbacks.
- You wrote a piece. Neil has a great sub stack, by the way. It is called creatively resourcefully.
- It's called Neil's sub stack. It's very easy to remember Neil Payne's sub stack.
- I strongly recommend a subscription and a follow there. He, his most recent piece is about a
- couple of NFL teams who seem to be doing quite fine to a no at the very least, but seemingly fine despite not having
- their starting quarterback, this in an era where everybody's obsessed with not only having a good
- starting quarterback, but the franchise starting quarterback. Somehow the Seahawks and the Vikings are doing
- okay without it. Other teams ringing their phone. Now other teams reading Neil's sub stack because
- other teams have lost their starting quarterback. Neil, bring us up to speed, man.
- Yeah. One of the things that stood out to me, and this was like, I wrote this maybe like two significant injuries ago, like they're,
- they're coming so fast and furious. You, you mentioned Jackson dart that happened last
- night. I had to kind of furiously update a line in the story about that. So really this is pertinent.
- The question of like, what's the right balance between the conventional wisdom, which is build around
- a quarterback, find a franchise quarterback, whatever you have to do, that's the guiding North star
- for every team in the NFL, and I think that's right, you know, if you find a Josh Allen that sort of puts you
- in perma contention or my homes or anyone on that tier for a decade or more if you play your cards.
- Right. But there's also these weird counterexamples and I was drawn to the Seahawks and the Vikings.
- And now the Vikings, I think are going to have Kyler Murray back. They had they had Carson Wentz, another former
- Philly quarterback who's had an interesting career for the first two games, basically.
- And the Seahawks lost Sam Darnold like, I think it was like three plays into the
- opening game and yet both those teams are two and oh, they've kind of won ugly at different times as part of that.
- But I think that's also sort of how you win. If you are, what was that Minnesota Chicago
- score? This week is nine to three, nine, three, nine to three. But against this is, you know, Chicago had
- put up 59 points. They obviously were one of the teams that lost a quarterback as well.
- Caleb Williams, but they weren't doing great offensively. And yeah, it was rainy and it was,
- you know, kind of a gross day overall, but also the Brian Flores Vikings defense did
- a great job of sort of shutting down this offense that everybody was so breathlessly talking,
- oh my God, they're the, you know, going to break the scoring record. Oh, seven Patriots or 99 Rams or whoever.
- And they were held to a field goal. And you know, the majority of that game was spent with Caleb Williams.
- We should point that out. I think the Bears had the biggest or second biggest week over week, like first week
- to second week drop-off in total points scored of any team in post merger history,
- how can that only be the second largest? Yeah. So the Falcons, I forget which year, but
- they went from winning 62 to seven to losing 31, nothing between weeks one and two.
- I'd love to know what happened there. I just, yeah, it just did like a database query.
- I'd love to deep dive into what happened there. I, it was some year in the seventies.
- I don't even remember what year. But the point is, is that if you're going to have two teams that sort of
- can survive, it would be Seattle and Minnesota because they combine really good defenses and also
- like not a particular reliance on quarterbacking over the past, like since the start of last
- season and including this season, they were among the teams that had the lowest share of
- their total yards coming from passing yards. And with Seattle, some of that was like
- Kenneth Walker, you know, carrying the ball and we're seeing that in Kansas city as well.
- You might not think of Kansas city as being a team that would want to downplay the value of a quarterback, but you've got
- Mahomes coming back from injury. Uh, some of the other targets like a Kelsey may be slowing down a little bit,
- although he looked pretty good the other night. And so you've got Kenneth Walker, uh, accounting
- for almost 40% of the offensive yards for Kansas city, which is the most by a running back for the chiefs since, uh,
- 2016 with Spencer Ware in the first two games of a season. And then the second most since Larry Johnson,
- who's kind of a, um, uh, interesting name from the past, a great fantasy football legend,
- Larry Johnson. So you've kind of got the, this undercurrent of how do we win without having to
- be so reliant on a quarterback in a world where it's very possible that our quarterback
- could get injured. And you've got all these counterexamples now of, you know, we didn't even mention Jaden Daniels.
- He's been hurt what feels like kind of ever since his rookie season, but he had another one this past weekend, Jackson Dart, who
- started so great to the season and has shown so much flashes of potential, he might
- be out for the year, like you mentioned. And those teams kind of don't have the fallback gear the same way that Minnesota and
- Seattle do. Because these are not good defensive teams. It, you know, the bears, um, ranked 23rd
- in points allowed last year. The giants were 26th and Washington was 27th. Uh, this is like inverted.
- So, uh, higher ranking needs more points allowed. Um, and so you've got those teams that
- maybe they don't have the formula that, that the, um, teams like the Vikings and Seahawks
- did to survive without their starting quarterback. Now everybody wants to have their starter.
- Yeah. Let me ask. Well, go ahead, Shane. I'll, I'll ask my question. I guess I'm kind of, you know, since
- you mentioned a formula, like, I mean, obviously there is not actually a formula, but if,
- if you were to construct a formula, do you think I could imagine at least three different terms?
- One being coaching being the big difference for kind of transcending this kind of like an
- injury defense, I guess, you know, or I guess you could kind of talk, call it compensated Tory parks of the other of the,
- of the team and then also like, I kind of, uh, a big latent variable here is kind of the difference between the backup
- and the starter, like in Minnesota, Kyler Murray versus Carson Wentz. It's like, you know, I, like, that's not
- like, I don't think a gigantic difference anyway, in terms of necessarily quality, Sam Darnold to
- drew lock is a, is, is a, is a larger difference, but if Patrick Mahomes goes down or, you know, Caleb Williams goes down,
- I think that's, that's probably a much larger kind of different drop-off basically.
- And so I don't know what, which of those kind of three things do you think is like the most important for kind of
- predicting whether or not a team, whether it's a QB injury. Yeah. If you somehow could know that your defense
- was going to be good, that would probably be the one. I think one of the confounding things that
- I know you guys have talked about, and I've done a lot of stuff on is like, defense is pretty unpredictable in the NFL
- compared to offense as well. And it's not exogenous too, right? It's like, you know, like, yeah, the giants
- last night, for example, their defense struggled in part because their offense was really struggling.
- Yes, exactly. And so I think that, but it is also sort of an optimization problem, right?
- Where you're trying to figure out how much do I allocate in the quarterback bucket, how
- much do I allocate in the rushing game or sort of receiver supporting talent bucket, how
- much do I put into, you know, coaching is part of that, it's not against the salary cap, but it's also a factor where,
- and I'm glad you mentioned coaching because those three teams that are trying to survive the
- early season injuries have really good coaches, you've got Ben Johnson, you've got John Harbaugh, even
- Dan Quinn has, you know, had a good reputation at different times in his career.
- So I think that that's also maybe part of the escape hatch when you lose a quarterback is trying to figure out like, can,
- like Andy Reid could probably scheme around, maybe we didn't see that much of it at
- the end of last season because everything had fallen apart and they had fallen out of
- it anyway, but you know, if Mahomes goes down, maybe you could find ways to scheme
- around that more readily than some other coach that's not as talented. So let me ask you a question to
- this, this question I was going to ask you, Neil, well, I was gonna ask you a two-part question, but they're related.
- It relates to the quarterback. So I, once I saw that Jackson Darter got injured, Caleb Williams, Jane Daniels, I just
- did this very simple query. What over the last 10 years, what fraction of quarterbacks play at least 16 games in
- a season? So not even all of them, 16 out of 17. Anyone want to guess what that percentage is?
- I think all quarterbacks are fraction of starting quarter. It would be our starting quarterback.
- What fraction of starting quarterbacks play at least 16 games in a season? I just, the denominator here is like, like
- kind of 32, 32 quarterbacks times 10 seasons out of the 30, 320 quarterback seasons.
- How many of them does the starting quarterback play at least 16 games? I mean, I think it's very low.
- I would, I might even want to put it in like single digits or teens or something like that in terms of percentage.
- It's more than that, but it's about a little less than 30%. So my point is, let's assume that statistic
- is known. Let's assume that general managers aren't morons. So back to Shane's point, like should many
- teams go for the, I'll call it Kyler Murray-Carson-Wench strategy, as opposed to the,
- let's see if we get lucky and get the, you know, um, Josh Allen and Eric Bradlow strategy.
- It's great as long as Josh Allen's on the field, but if Eric Bradlow's throwing the
- ball, we got a problem here. So no one's going to, let's start with, let's reject the first option.
- Everybody's going to take Josh Allen, Pat Mahomes, that category top tier, no matter what.
- And that's, that's, let's take that one off the table. The question is like, if you can't get
- that. That's what I meant. Yeah. Because I mean, there's a different, we should also define like there's a different objective function
- to be trying behind like winning the next few games versus winning the Superbowl.
- No. And like, if one of the, if you're, if one of the big guys goes down, you know, you can still wheel and deal
- in the next few games, but you're very, very, your, your probability of winning the Superbowl
- goes essentially to zero. Well, this is the thing we're talking about robustness.
- I mean, you just can't, you can't pay a free agent, top tier quarterback and build
- in a lot of robustness, right? You're just, you got your chips on that guy, presumably.
- But if you don't have that guy and most teams don't, so that's, that's a very, very relevant question.
- Most teams don't have the tier one. That's, that was my question. And there's also that distinction.
- I think you guys were hinting at of like the, the difference between surviving until the
- backup comes back. And I think that's where most teams, you know, if they have among that group of
- teams, the large share of teams that don't have their starter for at least one, two,
- however many games of the season, they're in that position where for the most part, I
- think they hope or feel like their starter is coming back at some point and they
- just have to cruise along and maybe they employ different lower, you know, variants and sort
- of, you know, ball control, like let's put the game less in the quarterback's hands.
- Let's rely on the defense strategies in those games. So there was also ways that you could
- almost sort of game plan to mute the effect of your quarterback. If you have a great quarterback, you're not
- going to mute their effect. You want to accentuate it. But then if you have a bad one,
- you want that quarterback to play as little apart in the outcome of a game, uh, in any direction as possible.
- I think backups too are kind of an interesting kind of data, data problem or, or,
- or, or, or estimation problem. Because, you know, I, I've been hearing a lot of commentary, you know, like, like with
- Jameis Winston, for example, last night looked like the worst version of Jameis Winston we've ever
- seen perhaps, you know, but he has also not played much in the last, say three or four years.
- You get like one game a season or here and there type of thing, you know, with a starting quarterback, you can kind of
- track like, you know, as they age, you know, they're like maybe, you know, degrade kind
- of relatively closely because you're getting lots of data. A backup's probably going to that same age
- related degrade, but it's kind of mostly hidden from us because we're not actually seeing them
- perform. Right. And so Jameis has always been all over the place. I feel like maybe his team has actually
- been moving down over the last couple of years. Yeah. It all accelerated into one game, but there's
- a flip side of that too, in the sense that I've heard people talk about, and I don't know if I've seen a study
- on this, maybe you guys have, but the idea that especially mid game, and maybe this
- is a little different than what these other, at least now going forward, these other teams
- are dealing with is that if you're game planning for the starter and then the backup
- comes in, it might actually be a little difficult defensively, even relative to like, not, not
- such a great quarterback. If they offer a different look or they have a different skillset, they may be able
- to catch someone by surprise in the middle of a game, but then once that tape from the second half comes in the next
- week, it falls off. And so you have to maybe manage around that as well, which is not easy.
- Let me ask you a question, just that Kay brought up the first, the, you know, couple of two and O teams, let's talk
- about them. So here's a team that's interesting to me. Is there any chance that the Raiders are
- at least decent? Uh, I mean, at two and O, first of all, those wins get banked. So in some ways they've kind of, yeah,
- right. They've vaulted themselves into some playoff probability, uh, just on the virtue of putting two of
- the 17 wins. And I think they're around 30% to make the playoffs. Like if you look at the models or
- the prediction markets or so forth, um, that's higher than we thought there would be in
- preseason maybe. And so I think that that is maybe the biggest benefit to it, but also, um,
- the Raiders, like, I don't know. Cousins has been maybe better than people expected.
- And now they're not asking the question as much about like, when does Mendoza come in
- and all that. And so then I was going to ask you, when do you think Mendoza, do you
- think if Cousin Keith, I don't mean winning every game, but is there any chance Mendoza
- sits the whole season now? Well, that's kind of opens up an interesting strategic question of, uh, if you, if you
- win those games, can you put in a guy in a situation where, um, it maybe would be more of a developmental situation than
- actively trying to win in the moment, nothing against Mendoza, because, you know, he was a
- great player in college and he'll presumably be a great NFL quarterback, but, uh, I'm not
- sure I can think of examples like maybe you guys can of situations where a team maybe didn't have the number one pick or
- a high pick start right away, because usually that does happen, right? Especially for a team that doesn't necessarily have
- aspirations for anything. They're like, just throw them in there, see what happens.
- It's so valuable to get a quarterback on that rookie contract doing well right away.
- We got to start this process. Raiders didn't do that. And then like they win more than expected.
- And so now you suddenly have almost the opposite problem than you had in the preseason,
- uh, of like, can we, do we put this guy in and throw him in here and have him potentially make mistakes and have
- the rookie learning curve in a high leverage moment of the season where losses can actually
- cost us a playoff spot? That's an interesting conundrum, man. I think it's a good problem to have
- in some ways. I know people like Eric Eager have dug into this and it's, you know, there aren't
- that, there's not that much data, so we shouldn't be too sure, but I still carry
- the intuitive sense that when a quarterback, a highly high prospect out of the college, out
- of college, gets himself in a situation where he doesn't have to play straight away, that
- it's net positive. Um, it's not a situation where he's not good enough to play. It's that he doesn't have to play straight
- away, you know, like, um, love in the back, the Packers have had a series of these, the Packers have had, like, this is
- a practically they're Aaron Rodgers, Jordan Love. Um, so I just, again, I know there's
- not, I know I have, this isn't analytical answer, I'm asking y'all's impression.
- So my impression is no man, if you don't have to put Mendoza, I don't want that.
- I don't want the, I don't need the real live bullets reps in his rookie year necessarily.
- I'm happy for him to grow and not face that pressure and then take it up later. But what do you, what do y'all
- think? I'll just give my quick impression, but it would be good to hear others. Um, Raiders aren't winning the Superbowl this year.
- 0% chance of that. I think what would be great would be if I'm making this up, if by the
- halfway part of the season, maybe the Raiders are five and seven, five and eight, and
- then you say, well, it's Mendoza time and you know what, he plays three or four games at the back end of this season,
- you get some experience, et cetera, I would think that would be optimal from a maximizing
- probability of figuring out what you have with Mendoza, giving him the experience he needs, and
- by the way, as we know, since Jameis Winston was the number one pick also in the draft, I forget if he was one
- or two, I think he was one, but he was one, he was one. So Mariotta was two that year.
- Yeah, Mariotta. That's right. That was the win. That was the Buck's year to pick Winston
- or Mariotta. We know there's no guarantee that the number one pick is a great quarterback.
- So at some point you need to, I don't want to say it's that time now, but you need to find out if Mendoza
- is good. Because by the way, at least all the reviews from his practice, I understand it's just
- practice, but he hasn't been that great. What I like about that strategy is it is live bullets, but they're just not like,
- they're not death creating bullets. You know, they're like, they're live, but it's
- not going to shatter him psychologically. But you're right. That last point, especially teams are trying to
- assess even their number one picks all the time. I'm sorry, Shane. Yeah, I mean, I think, Cade, just to
- follow up on that, I think it's like, I mean, by late season, you'll have the data to know that it's not going to
- be a confidence shattering kind of scenario or a body shattering kind of scenario.
- You'll have enough observation that this is an offensive line that can protect the quarterback and
- you know, that they have enough skilled players where he's in a good enough situation to
- succeed. And if not, you could make that same decision late season, if they're truly kind of
- have regressed to terrible, they could just kind of ride it out and get the really
- high draft pick and he starts with a clean slate next year. And I wonder if this is an argument
- for almost sort of looking at the schedule and circling games where we know that rookie
- quarterbacks making their first start really struggle, no matter how good they are, you know, that
- learning curve is really fast, you know, steep at first. And then if they're really good, they can
- kind of improve quickly off of that. But maybe you have him play against the Titans at home on December 27th or something.
- You know, you kind of circle games where you, you strategically put him in maybe right.
- Yeah, exactly. There's a trip to the Browns on November 29th, you know, get them a little road
- experience against a terrible team. Sorry to the Bucks. They lost to them, but I still don't
- think the Browns are any good. I don't think that's controversial. So yeah, I think that that's something you
- can do as well. If you really want to, now you need cousins to buy in on that, right?
- You know, that's, that's the thing is the media and, and everybody else will jump all
- over and be like, you know, they've, they've made this change and cousins has had that
- happen before with Michael Pennix, you know, middle of a season. They pulled him.
- Now he wasn't playing well and maybe that will happen as well. I don't think he's been, you know, incredible
- so far. I think he's been kind of like fine enough to, to win. Uh, so if he regresses some, uh, and
- becomes that cousins from Atlanta a few years ago, then maybe it solves your problem for
- you. Let's change gears to Major League Baseball. Now we are in the final week of
- the season. We've only got a few days of regular season, I believe left. And, um, I'd like an update from the
- baseball crowd in general, but Neil is as deep on baseball as he is on football.
- Um, and I know Dale's got some real consternation about division winners, this year's division winners.
- So first, just kind of set the landscape for us in this last week. I know the, what are the, what are
- the big issues that have to be sorted still? Yeah. So right now in the national league, we
- pretty much know who the, well, we do know who the division winners are. It's the Brewers.
- It's the Dodgers and it's the Braves. And then we also basically know, and we're
- recording this. Yes. They clinch. They clinch. No. Okay. Yeah. Uh, and we, we, uh, basically know, barring
- something really crazy happening, who the wildcard teams will be in the NL as well.
- We just don't know what order they're going to be. Yes. I know the diamondbacks are lurking.
- Neil, I'm not talking about the NL. Oh, I thought you said the AL, sorry. No, no, no.
- We know who those three, uh, wildcard teams are for the most part. There could be something crazy with the diamondbacks,
- but, um, uh, it's going to be probably the Cubs, Phillies and Padres in some configuration.
- We just don't necessarily fully know the order, which matters in terms of who's playing who.
- And then in the AL, yeah, the, the, um, the Rays have put themselves in a strong position to win the East.
- The Yankees could catch them. Uh, it's statistically possible. It's just not likely they are playing each
- other as well. So that's, this, this could be out of date. I believe the Rays won the first game
- of a doubleheader today. Okay. Yeah. The Rays, I think need maybe one win. Uh, uh, I don't, I'm not fully sure
- what their magic number is. The magic number is two. They have to beat the Yankees one of
- the games. The only reason I'm still hiding hope is the next three Yankee pitchers against the Rays
- are Freed, Cole and Schlittler. So you can't tell me the Yankees can't win those three games, which they could, and
- then all of a sudden we're down the magic number that is three games left in the season and we're one game back.
- So all I'm commenting is I like the Yankees big three horses going. I was worried about Rodan today against Rasmussen
- and Yanks won two nothing. So I'm feeling, I'm not feeling good, but I'm not feeling it's over.
- I know Shane thinks it's over. I do not. Well, it's a good, uh, it's a good thing to have as a fallback.
- We're talking about fallbacks burn as many of those pictures through before they get to that
- wild card series against the Red Sox. I know you do. Yeah. Then that's, that's the one is that those
- two teams are likely going to play each other as the four versus the five seed. And so then you've got the situation where
- there are two other divisions. Those two are pretty much up for grabs as we're kind of talking right now.
- And they also will produce two of the worst division winners. One will probably be, uh, or has a
- good chance to be the worst division winner of all time, or at least in that conversation, that's the AL West, uh, battle between
- the Rangers and Astros. Both teams are, um, uh, one, uh, going into today, the Rangers were 500.
- Astros were a couple of games under 500. Uh, and then, uh, in the AL Central, it's the White Sox and the Guardians.
- And they're above 500, but they're still on pace for maybe 84 wins by end of season.
- The worst division winner of all time were the 2005 Padres at 82 wins. So we're going to get two of the
- worst division winners of all time. And then we're going to get wildcard teams that at least two of them, the Yankees
- and Red Sox, most likely that have won somewhere between like eight to 10 more games
- than the, um, the worst division winner. And yet, uh, or the, the second worst division winner, this is my bigger problem is
- that, um, that team that, so like the second best and second worst division winner, uh,
- probably the AL Central winner is going to have a top two seed because they've guaranteed
- that the top three seeds must go to division winners in the playoff format, uh, uh,
- in baseball. And so that team is going to get a first round by the top two seeds
- get first round buys. And, uh, that the team that gets a buy will be significantly worse than the top
- two wildcard teams. So, uh, but that's kind of what I wrote about in the piece that you're alluding
- to Cade is this kind of many questions around like the primacy of the division. Do we still need to care about the
- division as much as we used to? Obviously in the past, especially starting in 1969,
- the divisions were what determined who went to the national league and American league championship series.
- You win your division, you go on to that. That changed in 1995 when they added the
- wildcard and they've been progressively adding wildcards since then. And really, uh, I'm not sure if we've
- ever talked about this, but it's, uh, one of the things I've harped on for a long time is that when you have these
- wildcards, uh, in, in your playoff format, the best wildcard team is very likely going to
- be better than the worst division winner, uh, just by virtue of selecting from a larger
- pool of teams. And especially since like, it's the worst pool of teams. I know you didn't even mention another bad
- part of the design, which is they don't re-seed in baseball. So no, they don't. They don't.
- So for example, the six seed may beat the three seed and that's not who the Rays, if the Rays end up number one,
- that's not who they're going to play. My opinion is, I mean, I think the division still has value and you can celebrate
- that for its separate achievement, but it should not factor into the seedings. Like it should just be based on regular
- season record one to six. They still have the qualification be, you know, division winners are automatically in or something like
- that. But like they have to re, I think they have to, they have to start seeding
- by regular season. Right now, whoever that second best division winner is, let's say it's going to be, uh,
- who is it? Whoever wins the guardians or the White Sox, whoever wins that one. I'd much rather be them than the Rays.
- Much. The Rays are going to have to play. It looks like the Yankee Red Sox winner
- and the guardians are going to play whoever they're going to play that bad AL West
- winner or the number six seed. The two is better than the one by far right now. Yeah.
- And it's totally backwards to have that. And just one last note on the divisions
- is divisions matter less in the schedule than they used to, uh, throughout the, you know,
- two thousands and into the 2010s, uh, and really only up until a couple of years
- ago, teams would play almost half of their games against division opponents, but now divisional games
- only make up 32% of games after they went to the more balanced schedule in 2023.
- So that's another way in which you're sort of the, these teams, I want to tell you the, uh, the per one 62 records
- for these, um, divisions like against all other divisions, uh, in, in baseball. So the AL West has played at a
- 68.8 win pace per one 62 against the rest of baseball. So take all the AL West teams in
- games. They played against every other division. They're inflated because they're playing each other.
- So they're even worse than the 79 or 80 wins that the leader's going to get. They're even worse.
- Exactly. And then the AL central, which is the kind of good of the two, you know,
- bad divisions and we'll get a top, uh, we'll get a top two seed and a buy they against cumulatively against all other divisions
- played at a pace of 76.1 wins per one 62. And remember 81 wins is a 500 record. So these are just really, really bad divisions.
- And we've kind of compounded this many different ways, this problem of kind of giving them
- rewards for, for winning these arbitrary groupings of teams that don't matter as much anymore.
- They're doing badly against all the other arbitrary groupings of teams and it will adversely affect
- all the good teams in the playoffs, uh, by and large. Yeah. Let me jump in just to say a
- few things. One, I was, I kinda, you kinda had me until you added a little rhetoric at
- the end about arbitrary groupings of teams. I mean, come on, these are divisions still
- do have meaning. That's where the rivalries are strongest. They still, a 30, a third of your
- games against division rivals is still a significantly higher rate than any other than against any
- other division by design. Right. So, I mean, look, you can chuck it. Sure. But then, I mean, why, why even have
- divisions at that point? They must play some role. They geographically, they play a role.
- They do capture some of the historical relationships. So just, I'm just pushing on the last
- little bit of rhetoric, you know, because mostly you had me and I came in a little bit skeptical.
- I want to say a couple of things. One, they're small samples. These are four teams per division.
- I mean, you're going to have these big swings from good divisions and bad divisions over
- time, only from a small sample. The 32 games, 32% versus half move, there's a real tension there, right?
- Because 50% against your division means that if you're in a soft division, you just
- get inflated unfair advantage. And so bringing it down makes sense. Taking it, you're still leaving it concentrated versus
- just open play, but you brought it down off of that unfair number. And the last observation I want to make
- is college football dealt with this problem for exactly one year before they realized this sucks.
- We're not going to do this anymore. Last year, they had the, was last year the first of the 12?
- I forget how many years we've been in 12-team format. Maybe last year was the first of the
- 12 or second of the 12. But in the beginning, the 12-team format, the top four seeds went to the best
- four conference winners, but you had to be a conference winner to have those seeds.
- And then last year, we ended up with like SMU or whatever it was, a really bad conference-winning team getting the buy and
- college football being new to this expanded playoff format, not having 100 years of history, constraining
- what it can do said, yeah, we're not going to do that anymore. And so the conference winners do not have,
- they still get, the conference winners get automatic playoff bids, but they don't get the seeds
- and the buys. I mean, I guess it's a baseball, I think can solve this. I, you know, we can still, again, the
- division winners can be kind of the regular season trophies of baseball. And we can kind of, you know, you
- can put up a little flag at your stadium for the division winners, but that's, that's
- the extent to which that achievement factors into what happens in the playoffs. Then it's just on your regular season record
- as far as I'm concerned. Neil, we've kept you already more than half the show. We've got to do a little bit more
- with you. The hockey season is going to kick off next week. It's going to kick off in September, I
- think for the first time, one of the very first times, early. You write about hockey on occasion, and I
- saw a piece that you wrote recently about the Panthers are possibly re-emerging.
- We thought we were done with them. They won a couple back to back. They, they, they didn't even make the playoffs
- last year. They are one of the betting market favorites this year. I think it's with Colorado and Carolina.
- And you're saying, yeah, they're a little bit like the Chiefs who also terrorized us for
- six or eight years and have disappeared beautifully, gave us a season off last year.
- And unfortunately for some of us, they might be back. So it's an interesting analogy you're drawing between.
- Can I just throw in this negative framing? The Panthers saved us from back to back
- Oilers season. I mean, I understand why most people don't like the Panthers, but honestly, they kind of
- have a soft spot in my heart. I don't think I don't like the Patriots either. All right, go ahead, Neil.
- Yeah. Well, I wanted to, yeah, I would like to see Canada win a Stanley cup. Sorry.
- You know, I, I do, I do think the Sunbelt trend in, in hockey has kind of gone out of control, but no, those,
- those Panthers teams are great teams. They suffered, I think the most injuries by
- far. I think it's called NHLInjuryViz.blogspot.com. Bringing back the old blog spot, but they
- have a useful tracker. They basically track like how much cap space was devoted to players who were on injured
- reserve in a season. And if you look at their kind of top line chart, the Panthers bar is just
- way above anybody else, even Vegas. I think they were second in most injured teams.
- So it's somewhat similar. It struck me as similar to a team like the Chiefs where you have a dynasty.
- They suffer serious injuries and a down season in general. And then, you know, in the past, I
- think sometimes teams like that might fade away there or they might, you know, not reemerge
- at least as among the favorites right away coming back, but this is both teams have
- the ingredients that were there. Maybe we would discount them a little bit and kind of regress them more to the
- mean than we would normally if they hadn't had this down season because injuries, it's difficult
- to predict how people are coming back, but I think the medical technology is in a
- much better place than it has been in the past and previous eras of the sport where you can bounce back from that.
- And I think the canonical example of this is the Steph Curry Warriors. That was a team that came to mind
- to me as being one of these gap year champion teams, and people didn't think that
- they could do it. Well, at the time, people being me, people being you guys, probably everybody that, you know,
- it seemed like when they lost Kevin Durant, who was hurt anyway, and then Klay Thompson
- was out and Curry was hurt and they bottomed out and they just had, you know, these these terrible seasons that it's like, OK,
- their dynasty is done. We're not going to see them come back and win a championship again.
- And then they immediately did that in 2022. And I think that that just opened up
- the possibilities for all teams that were dynasties and still have functioning members of that that
- are not too old and still capable of playing at a high level. It's like, why not run it back?
- Why not? Why not just pretend that that didn't happen? And I went back and I looked as
- part of the story of like, how rare is this? Can I find examples of it from in history?
- And a lot of the ones, you know, my search was for teams that had won a championship and then bottomed out and then
- came back and won another one or at least went to the finals, I think, within five years.
- And almost all of those were teams that really turned over their core in some substantial
- way between the two seasons, like the Red Sox in 2013 win the championship. They come back and win it in 2018.
- But a lot of the players were not the same players that had driven the 2013 team.
- Maybe the closest you could get is like the Eli Manning Giants. Those teams, they won in 2007.
- They didn't ever have like as bad of a bottoming out as like the Chiefs or Panthers or certainly the Warriors.
- But then they come back, they win it again a few years later. But that was more of like, I think
- we see that as a historical anomaly that Eli Manning would win two championship teams against
- the Patriots. Sorry, Shane, in that. And there were other teams like the 2010 San Francisco Giants, where it's like they bottomed
- out every other year, but then they won championships every other year. That one just defies sort of explanation.
- Maybe the closest is one of the kind of earliest dynasties or superstar driven dynasties that
- we could think of in all of sports, which were the New York Yankees in the 1920s.
- They won their first championship in 1923, first of 27. It's kind of interesting that it took them
- that. You know, it's like they were a quarter century into the 20th century before they won
- one. And then they went 69 and 85 in 1925. And Babe Ruth missed a substantial part of
- the year. They said he had a bellyache. I think subsequent reports have maybe said that
- it was something else on that. But then within a few years of that, they won 110 games with the Murderers Row
- team. So that is an example of like you still have Babe Ruth and you still have kind of the core to build around.
- And then you took a gap year. You're coming back as strong as ever. If we had prediction markets in 1927, maybe
- they would have picked the Yankees that year to come back and win the championship.
- Neil, I can't believe you just use that example when Adi's not here. A hundred-year-old Yankees example.
- I'm fine with it. It was perfect for Eric. But Adi's the one who kind of likes to live in 1950s and before Yankees history.
- That's his preferred mental space. So you just robbed him of a moment. Neil, thanks, man.
- We need to cut you loose, but we appreciate, as always, you're taking time to visit
- with us. You guys need to follow Neil. Terrific substack. Neil's substack for all things sports analytics.
- He writes much better than the rest of us numbers hackers over here, and he hacks
- numbers better than most writers. He's a good person to follow for any number of sports.
- Neil Payne. Thanks, guys. Always a pleasure to be on here. Absolutely. That is the first half of this week's
- Wharton Money Ball. We have another half to go. Come back and join us after the break.
- Welcome back. Welcome back to Wharton Money Ball. Welcome to the second half of this week's
- show. Just off the lines with Neil Payne, longtime friend of the show, writer, analyst, Neil Payne.
- You know, having him on the show this close to the elections, he used to be with 538.
- Nate Silver and that crew always has great election models and forecast, and we're rolling into
- that. We'll have to have him or somebody come back and talk with us about the election.
- By the way, for a substack, Silver Bulletin, which is Nate Silver's, is really good.
- And so it's still a great read. Even though it's not 538 anymore, it's a lot of the models and, you know, still
- there. He takes his modeling and forecasting seriously. He continues to refine and iterate.
- And so, guys, this is Cade hosting with Shane and Eric. Adi is out and about. He'll be back.
- We've got a little bit left in this week's show. We talked a lot of professional football, some
- baseball, and a little bit of hockey with Neil, but there's any number of things floating
- around. So why don't we do a quick round or two, see how it goes, of what caught your eye.
- Who has something, wants to start? What caught your eye in the world of sports? Like, I guess I'll start.
- I'll throw a shout out to Christian McCaffrey, who became, so he just got his 100th
- touchdown, which already puts him, I think, in top 30 all time. But what puts him top three, or he's
- only the third NFL player in history to ever do this, is he scored 50 or more touchdowns with two different teams, with multiple
- teams. And I think that's kind of, I mean, it speaks to, I guess, move, you know,
- that these kind of elite players don't necessarily move, have mid-career moves as often.
- But also, just like, you know, the kind of longevity, especially at running back, is very
- impressive. Who are the other two? Randy Moss is one of the other ones, and Marshall Falk.
- Okay. How many players in the history of the NFL have 100 or more touchdowns? About 30.
- Like, he's tied at 26 with four other players, so about 30 or so. Okay, so there's not many at that level.
- It's a little company already to get to that total, but to have them kind of split between, you know, kind of across a
- career is, or split between teams is kind of especially unique. I mean, that was a big move.
- 28, by the way, you're exactly right. 28 is the number of non-quarterbacks that have 100 or more touchdowns.
- So maybe he's in 26, tied for 27, 28. Yeah, yeah. I mean, I remember the move, you know,
- it was, was it even a mid-season move when they grabbed him? And it was at kind of the height
- of the running backs don't matter rhetoric. And also his injury history, and he has
- had injuries in San Francisco, as does everybody who plays for San Francisco. But like, I mean, he's still, I would
- regard this as kind of like, he really kind of, I feel like, revived his career or, you know, took his career from somebody
- where he's an exceptional player to now a Hall of Fame level career based on that
- kind of, you know, based on his time in San Francisco and kind of the equal success he had there versus elsewhere.
- I wonder, it'd be interesting to know how much credit he would give to his training
- regimen. And I wonder how much, if those who know him and others in his position, how
- they'd compare his training regimen to others. It just seems to perform at that level,
- at that age, requires incredible off-season work and discipline. How old is he? Is he like 30, 31?
- Oh, that's a good question, I think. How many great NFL running backs exist at age 31?
- He's 30. Well, I'll give you one right now. King Henry's still kicking butt and taking names.
- Oh, yeah. No, I mean, Gary Henry's doing longevity-wise is almost more impressive.
- It didn't come up in this particular stat, but oh my goodness, he's on record. Yeah, but he works really hard at it.
- He invests, he's on record on how much money he spends just on like diet and fitness in the off-season.
- I mean, it's just, that's what I'm saying. Those guys that do that at that age, at that position.
- He only needs like 5,000 more yards to break Emmitt Smith's record. No, but Emmitt Smith is actually on record.
- I just watched it this weekend, as a matter of fact. Emmitt Smith is on record saying he thinks
- that Gary Henry may well break his record. Oh my gosh. That's, it seems unlikely.
- Yeah. Talking about different running backs. It's certainly more likely to do that than
- break the touchdown, Jerry Rice's touchdown record. Yeah, he's not getting to 200 and whatever
- number now. All right, Eric, what do you got? So, there's an interesting thing about baseball.
- I always like to look at this time of year of World Series odds, especially given
- the Shane Jensen coin flipping model. It's going to be real tough this year. Without looking at the rundown, maybe you guys
- already looked. What do you think are the relative odds of the Brewers winning the World Series versus
- the Dodgers according to the betting lines? Now, just remember, they're both in the NL.
- The Brewers have the better record right now by two games. Let's assume they have the same record.
- I understand the Dodgers are the two times. This is the classic thing I asked you.
- Suppose I just told you, forget all the past. The Brewers and the Dodgers have equal records.
- They're both going to get the buys as well, right? They'll both get the buys. Yeah.
- But what do you think are the relative odds of the Dodgers winning the World Series
- to the Brewers winning the World Series right now? You're saying on paper, if you didn't know
- anything else. On paper, yeah, the betting odds. Well, you would think, you're saying you'd think
- they'd be more or less even given they have more or less even record, equal position
- in the- And I'm just asking you what you think it is, the ratio. I mean, if as a better, I'm allowed
- to remember what happened last year, I might - Of course you are. By the fact that the Dodgers swept up.
- All right, so take all of that into account, Shane. What do you think the relative odds are,
- Mr. Coin Flipping Man? What do you think it is? Well, what they should be is a half,
- but what they are is probably like three to two or something like that. It's three to one.
- Wow. Three to one? That's crazy. That's what I'm saying. We're on a statistics show.
- We got to call this out. The Dodgers are plus 195 and the Brewers, depending on which betting line, are between plus
- 550 and plus 650. Wow. That doesn't make sense to me. I'm sorry, Shane. You agree with that.
- I mean, I know you agree. Yeah, I don't know if that's, it's hard to know how, I mean, I'm kind of
- intrigued as to how much that is kind of specific memory of what happened last year
- between those two specific teams and kind of a head-to-head kind of thought in the bettors' minds versus just kind of Dodger,
- you know, the Dodgers. Not only that, Shane, but if you listen to what Neil Payne said in the first
- part of the show, the Brewers are likely to play a worse division winner than the
- wild card team is. Yeah, right. So they may actually be in better shape. Yeah, that's interesting.
- That's a silly format. Oh, baseball, get it together. Dodgers, they do. I mean, no, sorry.
- It's the other way around this year. Sorry, I forgot. No, no, maybe it's not part of it.
- It doesn't explain three to one. The Dodgers are going to be the two seat. So actually, let me just say, by the
- way, if they play each other in the NL championship, the Brewers, whatever it's worth or
- something, Brewers will have home field. Yeah, did they last year too? I can't remember who had the better record
- last year. They did, they did. Brewers have had the potentially the best record in baseball for the second consecutive Regular season
- record doesn't matter at all. Even though it should be used to seed. Y'all have told me that.
- I'm not sure predictably it has much quality. Y'all have told me that it's all about the number of high-end pitchers you
- have when it gets to the playoffs, right? And do I have that right? And is that why we don't expect them
- to do very well versus the Dodgers if it comes to it? Yeah, I think that's, I think the Dodgers
- are stacked with, you know, three or four number one pitchers. Just like I said, look, I don't know
- if the Yankees are going to win the World Series. Now, Judge, it looks like he's going to
- be out for the first round, but whatever. Unbelievable. If you have, yeah, not good.
- But if you have Schlittler, Cole, Freed, you got a chance to beat anybody. I'm not saying they're going to be, but
- you've got a chance. And I'm not even counting Rodon, who's decent. But I'm just saying the Dodgers have the
- best starting pitching and they have great hitting. So that's the thing. I mean, do the Yankees have equal pitching
- to the Dodgers? Maybe, maybe. They don't have equal hitting to the Dodgers. And that's the thing.
- The Dodgers have both halves covered extraordinarily well. That's what makes them the favorite.
- But let's also remember, we talked about it, I think it was last week or the week before.
- The Dodgers were one bad hitter out away from losing the World Series last year to
- the Blue Jays. They were going to lose the World Series. Their number nine hitter hit a home run
- or whatever the hell it was. I mean, so let's not make it seem like, yeah, wow. They dominated the playoffs.
- They just blew everybody out. They're about 100 outs away from losing that series to the Brewers, though.
- Yeah, right. Well, I want to say this is the kind of sports story that I am ready
- for and I can get on the bus for because it's classic David and Goliath. It's small market, big market.
- It happens to be for me, there's a family connection to Milwaukee. But also, I don't care that much.
- It's a team I can pull against the Dodgers. I can pull for the Brewers. I can engage.
- I can get excited about it and I can walk away without having my evening ruined,
- much less my week if it doesn't happen. So perfect. Sign me up. Oh, yeah. No, I mean, let me give you something
- equally. Shane, you'll like this too. What do you think are the Yankees and the Rays relative odds?
- Now, let's remember three to one. No, no, no. Wait a second here. Well, it has to be two to one,
- right? The Rays are going to have a bye. The Yankees do not. And they have them as equal.
- Yeah, but I mean, the betters are all about the betters. It doesn't make any sense to me.
- How can the Yankees be equal to the Rays? If the Yankees were not the better team
- in the regular season, they're going to have to play an extra round. They're going to have to play at the
- Rays. I understand these are betting odds. These are not model probability odds.
- Still, to me, it just screams out in the same way three to one Dodgers Brewers doesn't make sense to me.
- I mean, you've talked about this, Shane. A bye essentially doubles your probability.
- So what you're telling me is if you got rid of the fact that the Yankees have to play a round against the Red
- Sox, who you can't tell me you know who's going to win that series. You do not. Even taking that into account, the Yankees are
- equal to the Rays. That makes no sense. Yeah, I mean, I think it's partly because
- the Rays haven't crunched out and everything. Yeah, this probably is somewhat factored in.
- But like, but yeah, I mean, I agree totally. I agree totally. I was going to say that, like, if
- you're kind of a fan of a small market and you're and you, you know, you also kind of want to see a compelling
- matchup between two teams that have never won it all. Rays versus Brewers. That's what you should be cheering for.
- Rays versus Brewers for the World Series. Well, the Brewers have won it all. They won it all in 83.
- Oh, yeah, I guess that's right. I'm sorry. I haven't won it all in a long time. Yeah, Brewers got one.
- Brewers got one. It's not quite as fun as pulling for the Canadian Stanley Cup, but it's in that
- direction. So this is the time of year we start signing up for those things. All right, let me give you one.
- College football. Small update. We're trying to run some kind of college football update for Wharton Moneyball every week, and
- we post it every week. We're working with Andrew Percival's, what he calls the metric consensus.
- It's an ensemble of 10 highly regarded power rankings. So we work with Andrew's metric consensus, his
- power rankings, and we run it through Unabated Sim. We've been using Unabated Sim for a while.
- We have that up now. Andrew's getting me stuff early so we can get stuff up early in the week.
- So some things that jump out about that. We have it up when I say up on Twitter, I mean.
- The main thing that jumps out to me is the championship probabilities at the top.
- Two things about it. The four teams with the greatest are very close to each other, and I don't remember
- four teams being this evenly spread in college football a long time. So according to this Sim, this Andrew Percival
- plus Unabated Championship Sim Notre Dame. The one you post in the rundown is to playoff probability, but you're saying a different
- thing that's the actual winning of the championship. Well, that's right. You see also in the rundown, I gave
- you just the Sim result, which is Notre Dame at 13 and a half percent. Oh, there it is.
- Yeah, yeah, I see. Ohio State 12 and a half percent to win at Texas 12 and Georgia at 11
- and a half. That's the four top teams within two percentage points of each other.
- So that's nice to have four. It's not the Ohio State Alabama days where one team is running away from everybody else
- in the field. The other thing that jumps out, and by the way, the market probabilities, just to kind
- of make sure we're not too crazy. Market probabilities are very similar. Top four in the call sheet prediction markets,
- again, Texas, Notre Dame, Ohio State, Georgia spreading for 15 to 12. So similar spread in either place, either model
- or market. Those four teams make up more or less exactly 50 percent. That's what I was going to ask you.
- So you're the college football guy. I'll give you those four teams or you have the rest.
- What are you doing? I mean, it's so hard not to take those four teams, Texas, Notre Dame, Ohio State,
- Georgia or the field. Let's unpack the field. Psychologically, people don't tend to give enough probability
- to things that aren't unpacked. That's a little support theory for our listener,
- Yuval Rotenstreich. Miami, Florida, Indiana, Ole Miss, who just won a big game against LSU, LSU, Alabama, who
- the Percival unabated model really likes Alabama, Oregon, who has disappointed this year but came in
- as one of the big favorites, Florida, who has looked fantastic. So you get all of those teams and
- the residual beyond it for against the big four. I'm taking the four. That's a nice discussion, but I'm still taking
- those four. I'll take the field. I'll take the field. Shane wants the field. Shane, you should keep us to that because
- we're not talking about VIG. We're not talking about mispriced markets. We're saying this is the model probabilities and
- this is the market price without VIG. It's 50 percent for those top four or the field.
- All right, guys, do you have another quick round in you? Where are we on time? Let's do another quick round.
- We're going to do about five minutes around the block here. Okay. So one other quick, I was going to
- say baseball, and I will just say this is the first time since 1963 that we may have two Cy Young Award winners with
- an ERA below two. Schlittler's at 1.94 and Mizrowski, if that's how you pronounce his name, is at 1
- .86. The last time that happened was actually 1963. Wow. That was Sandy Koufax who merely gave out
- one Cy Young Award. But since they split it to an NNAL, it's never happened in a full season.
- It happened during the shortened strike season. But except for that season, this is a
- historic season with two pitchers below two. I want to talk about something that's totally
- off everybody's radar but mine. So just quickly, something caught my eye. This is what caught our eye.
- That's the segment. Zach Johnson, the golfer, just turned 50. And just went to the senior tour.
- Okay. He could be playing against Bernard Longer, who's 68, Ernie Ells, 64, Fred Koppel, 67.
- Apparently there's a big difference in golf between 50 and 60 or 50 and 65. I'm not saying Zach Johnson wasn't good.
- He did win the Masters. He's won six of 11 senior events since he joined the senior tour.
- Now, he was never that good on the regular tour. He never had that period that Freddy Koppel's
- had that one stretch of really clumpy, you know, behavior where he was just winning everything
- in sight. Six of 11 tells me that we, and we should get someone on to talk about
- this, about age curves in golf. But there's something like, I'm not saying 50 is different than 51.
- I'm not trying to imply there's a discontinuity, but 50 has to be a lot different
- than 60. But Eric, how do you explain that? Why doesn't this happen every time a decent
- PGA golfer turns 50? Yeah. So here's the thing I don't know is that, um, are there a lot of people
- that have like, let's agree that Zach Johnson is a very accomplished golfer. He's won a major.
- He's a very accomplished golfer. Maybe there weren't that many people that just turned 50.
- I mean, the other person is cohort, of course, is Tiger Woods. Who's out for other reasons, right?
- It could also be that there's been a gap this last couple of years. There have not been a bunch of great
- 50 year olds. We would have to unpack that. That's all. I think that's exactly right.
- Because I think we've seen things like, maybe not six out of 10, but I think we've seen, you know, when Phil rolled into
- the fifties, he won a bunch. We've had, when, who was the guy who was the first one to have accounting endorsement
- sponsorship? He was like a boring, but really good golfer with an accounting sponsorship that somehow fit
- his brand. When that guy hit 50, he won a bunch. I think the, maybe the guy, the lefty
- from Canada might've won. Maybe he won some. So I think we've seen some of this.
- I'm not discounting the age curve thing, because I think you're right. Um, it's a little daunting beyond the other
- end of 50. Yep. Anyway, that caught my eye. Yeah. Well, I mean, I guess one thing, uh,
- I guess if we're going to do one final kind of, uh, caught my eye, I was just, I was checking out lowest EPA.
- I would buy quarterbacks so far this season, you know, kind of overreacting to, and do
- you know who the lowest EPA by, uh, in a game by a quarterback so far this season is among all these terrible quarterbacks
- performances we've watched? You mean in a single game performance? Yeah. Yeah. Worst, uh, so far by EPA.
- Oh, there was some, I remember seeing something that was real. Oh, I know why. Cause I was paying attention.
- I know, I don't know what, this is the answer, but Aaron Rodgers had a horrific game for the Steelers.
- I mean, horrific. Yeah. It was the one for the series. And in fact, I think I heard some
- subsidiary stat that the Steelers, you know, basically have had maybe one or two drives longer
- than 40 to 50 yards so far this season. I mean, we did not expect that off. And again, this is perhaps overreaction, but I
- think the Steelers, uh, D offense could be far more anemic than we expected. Do we know Shane, who is their backup
- quarterback back to our discussion with Neil Payne? Are we, how soon are we still Mason
- Rudolph? Like 15 years ago. I don't know how old that guy is now. Yeah. So the Steelers, unless there's a third person
- on the team, that's like a draft pick that they want to evaluate. They're stuck in no man's land because Rodgers
- can't do it anymore. And by the way, it gives you even greater appreciation for Tom Brady winning the Super
- Bowl with the box at that age. They chose, they chose to re-up him. This is a bet of their own making.
- They're in a trap because they've got such a good defense. It's like you want to kind of.
- No, but my comment was, they're not in a situation like we talked about with Neil
- Payne. Like you've got, I'll call it Kirk Cousins and Fernando Mendoza. We got to bring him in and find
- out. We don't have to find out who Mason Rudolph is. We know who that is. So they don't have anybody unless they're third
- string or someone, I don't know. I'm going to look it up, but I mean, they don't have a pipeline right now.
- If they wanted to turn it around as quickly as possible, it involved, I think trading
- T.J. Watt for some number one picks or for some, sorry, not number one, T .J. Watt for like a first rounder or
- two. I don't know what you'd get for him. And then basically hoping that the current coaching
- situation does not carry you to one of your classic seven and nine seasons, but that
- carries you to like a three and 13 kind of season where you actually can grab the next quarter.
- Let me ask you, is it, it, could it be you, this, you would know these guys, uh, Cade from college.
- I'm just looking, they do have Will Howard and Drew Eller. Could it be either one of those guys?
- Give one of them a shot. They somehow draft the same college quarterback year after year.
- They're all the same guys. I mean, they're not the same guys in style, but they're kind of the same guys
- in expectation. Like Tool Z could be good, but they're, they didn't really perform up to that level
- in college. I mean, really, it's amazing. Just remarkable. I'm so sorry to hear it from the
- Steelers franchise. I really am. But there will be a time they might turn it to Cade's point, to Shane's point.
- There could be a time they turned to Howard or Eller. Why not? Yeah. Why not? Exactly.
- Well, this is, I mean, you know, Tomlin helped them stick. Tomlin helped them get stuck because he could
- coach a team of Wharton Moneyball co-host to a decent record. I mean, he can coach you out of
- a top 10 pick basically every year. Yeah, that's exactly right. I don't mean to sound negative.
- It is very much a credit to him, but like. Yeah. All right. Last one. I just want to point out that we
- complain a lot about the changing college football landscape, and there is real downsides here and
- there. But one of the upsides of the bigger conferences and kind of the big two conferences
- is that we get more, and the nine -game SEC conference slate, we get more high -end games.
- And week four, this is week four of the season, is the first of that. And this is the first year of the
- nine-game season in the SEC. We have six games between top 25 teams, four of them in the SEC, two in
- the big 10. And it's just an unbelievable slate. Texas, Tennessee, Ole Miss, Florida, NMLSU, and Missouri,
- Mississippi State. Mississippi State is like the surprise of the season with one of the most exciting quarterbacks
- out there. There's four top 25 matchups in the SEC. In the big 10, we have Iowa-Michigan,
- both kind of dark horses for the playoff, and in the mix. And Oregon-USC, even more competitively in the
- mix. So a phenomenal slate this weekend. I can't believe it. I'm so excited for that Texas-Tennessee game.
- I think that's a hell of a football game. Eric, they've either played once or never.
- I mean, it's unbelievable that Texas and Tennessee, UTs, orange UTs have never played, or if
- they have played, it's been more than 100 years. It's going to be fun. We'll see if Florida's real.
- That's the other thing I'm interested in seeing. I think they are with that running back.
- But Texas is an early game, by the way. It's unusually early for one of those big
- SEC games. All right, guys. Why don't we wrap it there? Many thanks to our guest, Neil Payne, for
- coming in the first half of the show. For Eric Bradlow, for Shane Jensen, for Audie
- Weiner. In absentia, this is Cade Massey. Big thanks to Jacob Grodnick on the board
- and Dee Patel, the boss lady. Also to you guys for listening. Come back and join us next time.
- Between now and then, enjoy your sports.
Brief Summary
Neil Payne discusses NFL quarterback injuries, MLB playoff predictions, and NHL season previews with Wharton Money Ball hosts.
Key points
- Neil Payne Returns. Neil Payne rejoins the show after a long absence, bringing fresh insights.
- Quarterback Injuries and Team Strategies. Discussion on how teams are coping with quarterback injuries and alternative strategies.
- Raiders' Surprising Start. The Raiders are 2-0, raising questions about their quarterback situation and future.
- Quarterback Development Strategy. The discussion revolves around the optimal timing for rookie quarterback Mendoza to start playing.
- Baseball's Worst Division Winners. A conversation about the likelihood of getting historically poor division winners this season.
- Changing Nature of Divisions. The significance of divisions in baseball is diminishing with the new scheduling format.
Episode highlights
- Neil Payne ReturnsNeil Payne rejoins the show after a long absence, bringing fresh insights.“Hey, it's great to be back with you guys.”1:21Sep 23, 2026
- Quarterback Injuries and Team StrategiesDiscussion on how teams are coping with quarterback injuries and alternative strategies.“How do we win without having to be so reliant on a quarterback?”7:17Sep 23, 2026
- Raiders' Surprising StartThe Raiders are 2-0, raising questions about their quarterback situation and future.“Is there any chance that the Raiders are at least decent?”15:56Sep 23, 2026
- Quarterback Development StrategyThe discussion revolves around the optimal timing for rookie quarterback Mendoza to start playing.“If you don't have to put Mendoza in, I don't want that.”18:51Sep 23, 2026
- Baseball's Worst Division WinnersA conversation about the likelihood of getting historically poor division winners this season.“We're going to get two of the worst division winners of all time.”25:52Sep 23, 2026
- Changing Nature of DivisionsThe significance of divisions in baseball is diminishing with the new scheduling format.“Divisions matter less in the schedule than they used to.”28:49Sep 23, 2026
- Warriors' Dynasty DeclineAfter losing key players, the Warriors faced a tough period, leading to doubts about their future.“Their dynasty is done.”36:16Sep 23, 2026
- Christian McCaffrey's MilestoneMcCaffrey becomes the third NFL player to score 50+ touchdowns with two teams.“He's only the third NFL player in history to ever do this.”41:11Sep 23, 2026





