Capital One and Discover Merger Explained for Consumers

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Following the Capital One and Discover merger, Wharton professor Paul Nary discusses why Discover became a target, details of the stock transaction, and the operational challenges involved. He explains Discover’s market position, potential changes to Capital One’s card networks, and the expected impact on consumers and competition.

ABOUT THE PODCAST The Wharton Business Daily podcast features interviews with top business leaders, innovators, and renowned Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.

#CapitalOne #Discover #CreditCards #BankingMerger #ConsumerFinance #MergersAndAcquisitions ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Dan Loney: Well, the merger between Capital One and Discover has apparently been completed. So what does this deal mean for
  2. the consumers as well as the firms themselves? Pleasure to be joined by Paul Nary, who is Assistant Professor of
  3. Management here at the Wharton School. Paul, great to talk to you. How are you? Paul Nary: I'm doing great and really happy to be here chatting with you
  4. today. - Thank you. Look, this had been kind of in the mix for a while. But when you think about these two companies, I think a lot of
  5. people look at Discover as maybe the one that was kind of ripe to be the target. Fair to say?
  6. - Perhaps. They were definitely approached by other potential acquirers before. They were, you know, one of the smaller,
  7. quirkier competitors in the space. So certainly, there's been chatter about Discover being a potential target prior
  8. to this transaction. Now, based on the conversations that I've had with some insiders in the filing so far, it doesn't look
  9. like they took any of those prior potential transactions, you know, further than just casual talks. So this was really
  10. the first serious deal that they considered, at least in last couple of years. - So then which side then gains the most from a deal
  11. between Capital One and Discover? - Well, I think the shareholders of Discover because they're getting
  12. a nice, reasonably nice premium, although this was an interesting deal, in that it was a stock transaction where there wasn't a
  13. lock on the share, you know, in case the shares of one or the other companies moved too much. But overall, I think the
  14. shareholders are getting a nice premium, and Capital One is getting a really interesting asset that comes with a lot of
  15. opportunities, but also quite a few challenges for Capital One as it tries to put this transaction together. - Such as
  16. what? - Well, this is a huge transaction, and these are always highly idiosyncratic in both the opportunities and
  17. challenges that they offer, but also just the sheer complexity of integrating two companies that are worth tens of billions
  18. of dollars with all of their employees, assets, processes, systems, etcetera. So integration here is going to be
  19. critical for Capital One, because much of the benefits of this transaction that it foresees, whether they're real
  20. or not, are based on integrating the two companies together and making joint use of some of the shared assets that they have.
  21. - And I guess the area of payments networks in general is just a very interesting one to keep an eye on and see how it continues
  22. to develop as well. - Yes, absolutely. And again, it's an area with a lot of challenges and a lot of opportunities. From Discover's
  23. perspective, they're a small player and the payments networks are still below, I believe, four or five percent of the global payments
  24. volume. So they're a tiny player next to Visa, MasterCard, and American Express, all of which have more than -- each of which has
  25. more than 20 percent market share in the space. So they're a small player there. You don't hear a lot about Discover, but
  26. payments certainly, and vertical integration have been ongoing themes in the space, for better or worse. For example,
  27. you can look at the transaction just a few years ago of FIS acquiring World Pay, which was a payments company, a similar
  28. vertical integration move, that was a $43 billion transaction that failed within a few years. And if I remember correctly, FIS
  29. had to write off at least 17 or 18 billion dollars, not to mention other losses and costs associated with this transaction. So that was a
  30. $20 billion loss of shareholder value from a similar transaction. A financial services company trying to vertically integrate
  31. into the payment space. - Whenever you see a deal like this, usually the questions come
  32. from Capitol Hill about reducing competition. Does this deal significantly impact the consumer, especially of these
  33. two companies moving forward? - I think it's actually going to be great for the consumer. You
  34. know, it's not creating any kind of a monopoly in the space. And if anything, it's giving additional resources and support
  35. to the fourth player in the payment space, that is Discover. So if it actually strengthens the Discover network, it may
  36. create more opportunities for customers. It's probably going to spur some competition, from my perspective, because now
  37. there is going to be competition for, you know, both on the merchant side as well as the customer side. So if anything, I
  38. think for the customers, we'll see more promotions, more bonuses as not only Capital One tries to make the most of this
  39. transaction, but also as American Express, Visa, MasterCard, and other banks, Chase, of course, with their
  40. credit cards the largest player, try to compete with this newcomer. So there's going to be some reshuffling. And I think
  41. ultimately, the consumers will likely benefit. - And I read that, I guess if you're a consumer of Capital One
  42. and have a card with them, it sounds like Capital One wants to move their cards over into Discover space. So consumers
  43. probably do have to be aware of some potential changes that could be coming up in the future.
  44. - Yes, so this will be interesting. So as far as I know, Capital One will switch some of their cards to
  45. Discover, but not all there. From what I understand, they're planning to switch their debit cards for Capital One Bank
  46. customers to the Discover network, which will likely not create much change for the existing customers, you know,
  47. especially the US based customers. But from what I understand, they're planning -- and this is one of those
  48. idiosyncrasies and complexities of this deal. From what I understand, Capital One is planning to switch their lower
  49. end, or more sort of US centric cards to Discover. But from what I understand, they're planning to keep their higher
  50. value, sort of higher end cards that are used by international travelers, etcetera, they're planning to keep those on their existing
  51. network, primarily Visa, I believe, because as of right now, and this is another challenge for Capital One,
  52. Discover does not quite have the network of Visa, MasterCard, American Express overseas. So in order not to alienate those
  53. customers who are using their cards globally, who travel a lot, who need access, Capital One would need to keep those
  54. cards on the bigger payments networks, at least until they figure out a way to make Discover accepted more widely
  55. internationally. - Paul, great to have you with us today. Thanks very much for your
  56. time. All the best. - Yeah, it was great being here. Thank you. - Thank you. Paul Nary, who is Assistant Professor of
  57. Management here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Capital One's merger with Discover may enhance competition and benefit consumers, but integration challenges lie ahead.

Key points

  • Merger Completed: Capital One and Discover. The merger between Capital One and Discover has been completed, raising questions about its impact on consumers and competition.
  • Integration Challenges Ahead. Capital One faces significant challenges in integrating Discover, a complex process for both companies.
  • Consumer Benefits Expected. Experts believe the merger could lead to more competition and better offers for consumers.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes