What’s Next for Self-Checkout? Tech, Theft, and Tradeoffs

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Retailers like Target and Walmart have embraced self-checkout as a cost-saving convenience, but growing concerns over theft and customer frustration are leading to a strategic recalibration. Santiago Gallino, Professor at the Wharton School, explores the operational challenges and evolving technologies shaping the future of self-checkout. From unintended errors to shrinkage and AI-enhanced monitoring, this conversation unpacks the trade-offs between automation and human interaction in modern retail environments.

ABOUT THE PODCAST The Wharton Business Daily podcast features interviews with top business leaders, innovators, and renowned Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.

#SelfCheckout #RetailTechnology #Shrinkage #RetailInnovation #AIinRetail #RetailManagement ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Dan Loney: Well, no doubt, if you've been to your local grocery store or a Target or a Walmart in recent months, you have seen the rise
  2. in the use of self checkout. Companies have been mixing in this technology because they believe it to be cheaper but
  3. also more effective for their consumers. But it appears that there are some issues out there with self checkout, and in fact,
  4. in some cases, retailers are cutting back due to rising levels of theft. So what does this mean for the technology?
  5. Pleasure to be joined by Santiago Gallino, who is an Associate Professor of Operations, Information, and
  6. Decisions here at the Wharton School. He's also an Associate Professor of Marketing. Santiago, great to talk to you again. How
  7. are you, sir? Santiago Gallino: I'm doing well. Doing well. Thank you very much for
  8. having me. - Okay, so this is an interesting dynamic at play here, because of what was believed to be just the absolute ease at which
  9. technology was going to help the process of people getting in and out of stores. But I guess, did we have to maybe see something
  10. like this coming when you have to factor in the human component with the shoppers as well?
  11. - Yeah, so I think this is interesting, and as you are hinting to, is probably also expected to some degree. If
  12. we think like, what are the retailers thinking when they decide to bring a technology into the store, self checkout
  13. being one of them, they try to weigh the pros and cons. And I think that in the early days, it was very clear
  14. that there was a potential labor saving component that was to compensate for the investment in the technology, also allowing for
  15. mediating the peak demand times and making everyone happier with lower wait times in the lines and whatnot. Now, the unknowns of
  16. that process are, on the one hand, to what extent customers are going to be frustrated that now they need to do the part of
  17. the job. And the other one, which is what you mentioned earlier, is like, to what extent we're going to see intended or
  18. unintended errors in the checkout point. And that's what we're seeing now, that once the retailers are starting to
  19. actually observe those unknowns, they are kind of recalibrating that decision. - It's been mentioned that, I guess with some retailers, they
  20. are limiting the number of items that people can purchase when they go through self checkout. And I guess the retailers see
  21. this as a way to maybe mitigate some of the potential problems. - That's right. And I think that this limitation on the number of
  22. items speaks to this dual problem. On the one side, the complexity of the task itself, like we are customers, not
  23. expert cashiers. And although the task is simple, you can make mistakes, and these mistakes can increase with more items. At the
  24. same time, if you want to assign one employee to monitor multiple self checkout or you're going to do it with a video camera, it's
  25. more accurate and simple to do if you limit the number of items. So I think that the simplification of the task, it's
  26. helping the customer, and it's helping the retailer to monitor that step too. - And this is not an instance where companies are going to
  27. rethink having the technology in their mix. They're still going to have it. It's just -- and this falls right in line with
  28. your work. It's an operational process that they have to kind of work through to see how they can best run this now.
  29. - Yeah, so I think you're right, that for most retailers, this is a question of kind of recalibrating, not
  30. taking the technology away. The ones I've seen that have kind of pushed into removing the technology altogether, it's more
  31. of an argument of missing the connection with the customer, missing that kind of opportunity of interaction with the
  32. customer, making the whole experience too detached from an environment where the customer feel embraced. And so it is more
  33. like, if you want like a more of a strategic reason with the companies that see these still in the space of, okay, we can
  34. make this work, is trying to mitigate the problem by reducing the hours of operation, reducing the number of items, updating
  35. the technology. I think over the last few years, we've seen new technologies like, now, sometimes you have the possibility to
  36. weight the product after you scan it, and that itself as a reinforcement mechanism, and things like that.
  37. - You mention about the adding in of workers in and around a self checkout area to kind of help monitor it. You
  38. also talked about the use of cameras. I've seen it go as far as my local Target here in the Philadelphia area, to actually
  39. have a security person just outside the self checkout area so that if there is a problem. So the problem of shrink has
  40. been one that retailers know has been there, and now they see this as a way to try and mitigate shrink, at least in
  41. this arena. - Yes, no, absolutely. And shrink is not a new problem in retail. I mean, retailers for years has been dealing with these problem
  42. both from customers, their own employees, and this is something, that it's been embedded in processes over the years. I
  43. think that now, because of the level that this issue has, the level that we are seeing of this issue is where
  44. the retailers are making additional investment once the technology is in place. But to your point, I mean, if you have
  45. one employee monitoring two self checkouts, then you start to question, like, to what extent this trade off of labor
  46. for the equipment is actually making sense, right? - So then, do we look then to advancing the technology even
  47. further to be able to try and help this process out? - To some extent, yes, and that's why I think there are now companies
  48. that are offering some integration with an AI video monitoring tool that will kind of politely suggest that you
  49. made a mistake, that there is an item that you forgot, that these are the organic tomato, not the regular tomato,
  50. and so you're kind of making those savings on the checkout step. And I think that that is something we're
  51. going to see, in the same way we saw the companies incorporating in the weight of the product at the end as an additional
  52. checkpoint. I think we're going to see more and more refinements. But I mean, you don't need to be too creative to
  53. think ways around if your intent is to cause the shrink, right? - So now, some people would say the easiest way to get around this
  54. is add more human beings to the mix, but companies are probably not going to do that.
  55. - Well, that's probably part of the story. And I think that that's why I mentioned that
  56. companies that have not gone down that path are retailers that see the value of that interaction, as something that
  57. adds value to the customer, to the shopping experience, and that, I think, is why there are good reasons to stick to your
  58. strategy and not necessarily jump on every opportunity of a new technology coming to the store. - But it
  59. does seem like that the use of this technology will remain, you know, somewhat under control in terms of the amount that they
  60. use it. You will still have checkout lines that have human beings behind them in the cash registers, because you don't
  61. want to -- in many cases, retailers, I guess, don't feel secure enough to have totally, you know, self checkout
  62. operations in place. - No, absolutely. And what definitely is going to happen, and it is happening, is for those retailers
  63. that have started to make investment, remember, these are companies that has, like, thousands of stores. So to what extent
  64. they continue to roll this out, expand. I mean, now that they're seeing the numbers that are coming up for those
  65. components that they didn't know before making the investments are now reasons why they will probably think twice before
  66. jumping in, assuming that shrink is going to be of a level that it turns out not to be, benefit from the
  67. customer side, from the employee side, are not as high as they thought. So I think you're right, that we are going to definitely
  68. continue to see the technology in place, but I don't think we're going to completely remove the workers from the
  69. checkout line anytime soon. - Santiago, great to have you with us today. Thanks very much.
  70. - Thank you for having me. - Thank you. Santiago Gallino, Associate Professor of Operations, Information and Decisions, and of
  71. Marketing here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Santiago Gallino discusses self-checkout technology, theft issues, and retailers' operational adjustments to improve customer experience.

Key points

  • The Rise of Self Checkout. Self checkout technology is becoming more common, but is it effective?
  • Recalibrating Retail Strategies. Retailers are adjusting their use of self checkout technology amid rising theft concerns.
  • The Ongoing Issue of Shrink. Shrinkage in retail is a long-standing problem that continues to challenge retailers.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes