Discovery-driven Growth: The Only Plan Is to Learn as You Go
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
For companies planning to launch new initiatives during uncertain times, it's important "to know from the start that the plan is wrong," according to Wharton management professor Ian MacMillan. Assumptions are what get most companies into trouble, MacMillan and co-author Rita Gunther McGrath, a professor at the Columbia Business School, argue in their new book, Discovery-driven Growth: A Breakthrough Process to Reduce Risk and Seize Opportunity. In an interview with Knowledge@Wharton, McGrath and MacMillan describe how firms tend to approach growth in ways that hurt them, and what they can do to make the most of new opportunities, even during the current downturn. Transcript can be found at: http://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article.cfm?articleid=2226 📂 Management
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- [Music] uh Rita thank you so much for joining us today thank you for having me it's a
- pleasure well why don't we start with a basic question about why so many good companies fail at growth fail at growth
- and we see that a lot um we have a a file that we used when studying the book which I call it my flops file you have
- to lose your parent company at least 50 million dollars to get into my flops file and it's you know um and the big
- dilemma is that what they tend to do is use conventional approaches that work very well when you've got a lot of
- knowledge to try to get into new spaces and it sets in motion this really dysfunctional pattern of behavior so
- here's an example uh you want to get money for a project you put together you know a PowerPoint deck that's like 100
- slides with all this backup detail and all these spreadsheets and you go to whoever's got the resources and you make
- this big pitch right and then they say okay so now you set off and discover two or three months in gee you know the
- market wasn't exactly what you thought and the service delivery requirements aren't exactly what you thought and
- maybe the product needs to be tweaked well now you've got this huge commitment that you're supposed to live up to so I
- think the first dilemma that we see in companies that causes them to fail so systematically is this presumption that
- you can be right in a world of massive uncertainty uh and that leads to these kind of dysfunctional behaviors I think
- the second thing that companies do that gets in their own way is insisting on financial metrics that make no sense
- when you're looking at a new business so a typical company will insist on say a Net Present Value calculation or
- discounted cash flow calculation it's nice to be back here at Wharton talking with the prices like that um when in
- effect what you're doing is in many cases you're buying option value you're buying uh the right but not the
- obligation to continue to make further Investments and so using these present value internal rate of return kind of
- requirements almost sets you up for failure because they're build in in flexibility into the system so what I
- think I would argue is that it's not that planning for new businesses or planning for growth opportunities is
- undisciplined and that's where people go wrong they think it's undisciplined it's
- not it's just a very different kind of discipline it's the discipline that for example habitual entrepreneurs use or
- people that start multiple businesses involving a lot of learning a lot of change a lot of redirection and that's
- actually okay so so based on what you just said how should companies actually be thinking about growth at a time of
- uncertainty at a time of uncertainty and and and could you give any examples of companies that are doing it right oh
- sure um well I think at a time of uncertainty the first thing you need to do is stop panicking um I think the next
- thing is to take a look at your whole portfolio of activities when times are good to be honest people get a little
- sloppy companies get a little sloppy and it's easy for things that are not value
- added or things that really aren't going to be a root to your future to kind of hang out there because they're not doing
- anybody any harm and maybe we're historically affiliated with them and so on so I think the first thing I would do
- is take a look at where resources could be freed up so if you take some concrete
- examples a company like Verizon getting out of the directory business it's not that it's not a good business it's not
- that it doesn't have great cash flow but if they're going to make investments in
- the initiatives that will form their future they've got to get the resources from somewhere and that's one um there's
- some talk right now for example that Time Warner should be selling aol's dialup business because even though it's
- generating cash flow it's kind of distracting the company from the future it needs to create so I think the first
- question I would ask is are there places you can free up some resources not a lot
- necessarily some resources to um get into some of these growth spaces the next thing I would do is set up uh a
- small not very big but small or a couple of small groups to really go out and look at where you could find growth
- relatively soon so in a say 9 to 10 month Horizon start to get some things going which could take you in a path
- towards higher growth areas and recognize that if you don't make those Investments that it's basically setting
- in motion a long-term negative for your company it's a bit like having credit card debt at an early age you know it
- just sets in motion these um inabilities down the road to to do future things and
- then the last thing I would say in tough times what you want to be thinking about
- is am I creating enough option value to Merit um looking at these areas a little
- bit more so you want to really be thinking about that even as times are tough now who's doing it well and in the
- last few weeks I visited wonderful companies like General Electric uh IBM I'm giving a talk for them pretty soon
- and sure you know they're not happy with way their stock is being treated and they're not happy with the fact that um
- you know maybe sales that they were counting on haven't happened but that doesn't stop them they're not paralyzed
- by it um their basic position is you can't you can't change your whole strategy you can't throw everything over
- overboard because the year has been really bad um and so they're really looking more towards how do we build the
- best foundation we can going forward let's say a company uh wants to do exactly what you described and it
- wants to use Discovery driven growth uh and set up its own initiative how should
- it go about designing that initiative designing it um well different companies will do it differently uh but I think
- there are some principles in common I think the first principle is you can't allocate growth projects to people who
- are already just screamingly busy that just is dysfunctional uh and it won't get the attention it deserves so I think
- the first principle is you need some kind of dedicated resource now that can be associated with an established
- business it can be set somewhat aside but in general we found that it has to be a group probably a small group who's
- really just focused on the the new areas that's their main job um I think you also want to be thinking about um
- whether you know what kind of company culture are you are you a top- down kind of company or whatever the boss says
- goes and that's what we do in which case you know you better get the boss's blessing and this group is known to be
- supported by the boss and and so forth other companies not so much so in other companies what what we found is once you
- got this focal group set up that they actually work best by doing a lot of Coalition building and a lot of
- brokering with other parts of the firm in some companies they've actually restructured to a company uh to create
- growth opportunities at Dupont for example which we worked with a company we worked with for many years they had a
- almost religious dedication to the concept of the Strategic business unit and the Assets in the company and the
- revenues all went together in these strategic business units and what they found out was that a lot of their great
- growth opportunities were falling in between their conventional units so what they did was created this growth group
- and and and got people thinking about growth built the right toolkit for growth but then actually created these
- call them growth platforms which create that cross business uh connection necessary to get some of these growth
- drivers to occur so I think the principles you want to think about are dedicated resource clear line of sight
- to the top so that you've got that executive endorsement um and focus on a few key things that are going to be
- valuable possibly in the future I'm not a big believer in new business development or innovation groups being
- allowed to launch businesses themselves it tends to them becoming fums and people then want to make a career out of
- it and you don't want that what you ideally want is your Innovation group or whatever you call it uh to be a place
- where people come and spend a few great years learn a lot and then take that learning into your core businesses and
- then it's sort of a um an incubator of people as well as of business ideas I wonder if we could go back to to
- something what you that you said earlier when talking about GE and IBM uh obviously it's a tough business
- environment the stocks are being hammered sales are down uh would you implement uh a growth strategy
- differently during a downturn of the kind that we have today uh than you would say in a boom period could you
- could you help understand explain how how how how would you implement this strategy During a severe downturn well I
- think in a severe downturn the concept of discipline becomes more important than ever and in fact one of the
- benefits I think of this approach is it gets more attractive when you have less resources because you just don't have
- the money to do what I alluded to earlier spend a lot of money and get yourself way down uh a track before you
- know what you're doing so I think the differences are you would you would find this more attractive I think in a
- downturn than when there's a lot of money floating around the other interesting thing about downturns is
- that they do create a lot of discipline so what you'll have is less tendency for
- people to go off on efforts which are not going to be successful you're also going to see more discipline around
- shutting things down that need to get shut down and we're seeing that now even with companies like Google that are very
- successful on getting out of their radio ad business because they've feel they've
- given it long enough and uh they haven't really um broken through so I think the
- key message for a downturn is is is you know don't lose your head realize that this makes sense uh under uncertain
- conditions and don't be afraid to make some modest investments in exploring where your future might lie one other
- interesting wrinkle for downturns is one of the things we're seeing that's brand
- new is people's core businesses you know businesses where they thought they had a
- lot of predictability where they thought there was a lot they knew are kind of sliding over into that very uncertain
- space and so another suggestion I would make is don't assume you know what's going on in your core business be
- prepared to do what we say in the book which is stop write down your most significant
- assumptions and see how they're mapping against the changing realities that you're dealing with right now so it's a
- very useful discipline in both environments and during a boom how how would that change well in a boom it's
- easier to get resources and there are more segments of the economy that are fast growth so I think in a boom it's
- just it's easier the barriers are lower now the problem with booms is that they produce a lot of stupid Behavior know um
- companies can afford to make big mistakes so they go ahead and do it um and there's this sort of thought that oh
- we can just spend the money because who needs to worry and I won't name them but
- I have a client who just makes a lot of money and there's no discipline at all around their project process they just
- anybody that's senior enough can get their pet project funded and there's no kind of coherence in the corporation
- about what's going on so booms have their downsides uh too but of course it does it does make it easier to to uh to
- end I wonder if uh you know if in this room right now we had a few CEOs of Fortune 500 companies and they wanted to
- know uh from your book what are some of the things that they can Implement right
- away right away what what advice would you give them what advice would I give them I think I'd tell them first that a
- lot of strategy today is about learning it's not about sustainable competitive Advantage it's not about the sort of
- stable industry forces that we're used to thinking about when we're thinking about strategies so I would encourage
- them to think of strategy as a very Dynamic entity and that means changes behavior on their part they need to stop
- talking about being right all the time uh instead what we want to talk about is being disciplined um you need to stop
- talking about failures bad and instead you want to think about intelligent failures you know lowcost intelligent
- failures that are rich in learning and that tone can only be set from the top if you're the kind of CEO who you know
- Off With His Head the minute something doesn't work out the way somebody predicted I suspect you're going to have
- a lot of trouble in these incredibly Dynamic strategic environments Mac thank you so much for
- joining us today welcome could you explain the concept of Discovery driven growth and how it differs from
- traditional ways of thinking about growth um well let's start off with the current mess we're in
- economically the world's become a lot a lot more uncertain and managers really need to
- begin to be able to make decisions in the face of uncertainty and uh when things are
- uncertain you really don't know what the outcome is going to be so in convention
- planning what you do is you sort of project what the future should look like and then you build the plan with a fair
- level of confidence because you have a knowledge base that you can use to do your
- projections in uncertain environments you don't have knowledge you have to make assumptions and the uh key issue is
- uh I know when I start my plan that the plan's wrong that's the only thing I know about the plan is that it's wrong
- so how do I plan in such a way that I come out with the right solution but uh not necessarily know what it is at the
- outset and that's what Discovery driven planning is all about it's a plan to learn we don't know so what we're going
- to learn and uh what you really want to do is you want to learn cheap and you want to learn fast and if it's wrong you
- want to go and do something else or you want to redirect and that's the idea so could you uh explain the principal steps
- that a company needs to go through to create a growth framework the first thing that I think is important is to
- kind of set a fairly firm Target about what you'd like to accomplish you may come back later
- and change it but you start off with something that you think is worthwhile because if you're going to do
- something that's really uncertain then when you get to the end of the road you need to be able to look back and say all
- that energy and effort was worthwhile so you set a frame and the second thing to
- do is then sort of say if this is what I need to accomplish what is the scope of
- what needs to be done how much physically must happen so if I want to make a million dollars how many you know
- buckets of stuff must I sell uh in order to get that million dollars and that gives you a sense of what the physical
- challenges as well as the economic challenge step number two is to begin to sort of say well what are the activities
- that I must undertake in order for me to be able to deliver this plan how will people know that I have an offering how
- will people search for that offering how will they be able to uh buy whatever I'm
- doing what processes must be in place for them to be able to receive whatever I'm delivering how they're going to use
- it how do I need to service it each one of these items which we call a consumption chain is the consumer or the
- customer experiencing your offering and your company each one of those involves a cost or an asset commitment so you
- specify what we call a deliverable specification that says what are the physical things that need to be
- delivered in order for the financials to be delivered so step the Second Step the
- third step is to basically say well I'm making assumptions about what these costs are going to be or these assets
- are going to be how am I going to test them so I document all the assumptions that I'm making and then I test these
- assumptions I plan to test these assumptions at checkpoints and uh so for instance I
- might develop a model of the product if it's a product I'm making I might build a do a market test I might do some Focus
- Group but each one of these checkpoints what I do is I come back and test whether my assumptions are right or
- not uh to the extent that they right I continue to the extent that they're not right I shut down the project so I
- deliberately designed checkpoints where I can learn and now the last challenge is to creatively invest only as you
- learn so in the beginning you invest very little so you can afford to be wrong and as you get more and more
- confident in your in your assumptions which may change and as you redirect the project may make bigger and bigger
- investments in your book you also talk about creating reverse financials and an assump assumptions
- checklist could you explain those Concepts well typically what happens when somebody designs a conventional
- plan is they start off with the revenues they hope to get they estimate what the
- costs are they subtract the costs from the revenues and that tells them what the profits are going to
- be a reverse income statement starts with the profits I must make to make it worthwhile I can then calculate what the
- maximum cost can be in order for me to make those profits and then what the revenu should be in order for me to make
- the profits so you start with the income statement at the bottom and you work up
- instead of starting at the top and working down and that's what we mean by diverse financials because very rapidly
- you may find that uh in order for you to be able to make the numbers that you plan to make in terms of profits all you
- need is 5,000% market share at which stage you say oops let's go and do something else because you really don't
- know but it gives you a sense of what the scope is and then the next step is to do the deliverable specification that
- I spoke about before in order for this to happen for in order for me to get $1 one rupee you know one Rubble worth of
- revenues I need to put something in a customer's hand the customer needs to say yes I want it I'm going to pay for
- it what does it take to actually get the object into the customer's hands so that's your deliverable specification
- and then what we do is say in order for us to deliver this business and this consumption chain that we've designed
- what checkpoints are we going to use that allow us to drive down the cost of failure but can you give an example of a
- company that has gone through this process well the the company that I think has been the most successful would
- be Air Products and and what's interesting about Air Products and you know is is that um this is a company
- that's 60 years old uh was established a long long time ago and it built its uh its profit streams on on the basis of
- industrial gases selling things like oxygen nitrogen carbon dioxide really exciting interesting stuff and they
- elected to start to look at diversifying what they were doing so that they just didn't find themselves constantly in a
- place where they had to cut price below cost and make it up on volume and uh and so uh uh uh they uh
- they started to use Discovery driven planning to push into new spaces and some of the uh things that they're
- looking at now pretty aggressively is uh since we very good at being able to measure use Telemetry to find out what
- the stocks are of our various gases all over the country why don't we take our telemetric capabilities and begin to
- build businesses around that and so for instance one of the things they seriously looking at is to use it for
- tracking uh uh the status of uh uh uh patients with chronic illnesses so that you can constantly monitor what the uh
- what the level is of whatever thing you're kind trying to control and it's a very very new business and because it
- was so new and because it was so different conventional planning would just not have worked uh you also talk in
- your book about the art of disengagement could you explain what that means and why is that important for
- growth okay if we recog recognize that the world's getting more uncertain if we acknowledge that because it's getting
- more uncertain managers will have to make investment decisions in the face of much greater
- uncertainty if we recognize that because of that uncertainty the chances that you're
- right are very low that basically means that the normal condition is you're wrong and so what you need to stop doing
- is obsessing about being right because you can't be right or very rarely can you be right so the real issues then is
- is if I am likely to be wrong then how do I plan in such a way that the cost of being wrong is as low as
- possible what you also need to be thinking about is if I go out there and I try to build this new Enterprise or
- this new product or this new market um there will be people who are going to be disappointed so what I need
- to think about is as I Retreat if I find that I must and I can't redirect because
- the the most preferred alternative is to red direct the business to where there looks to be opportunity but let's say
- that doesn't work you need to plan ahead of time how are you going to disengage from that project if it doesn't work
- out and and so a a critical discipline and it's kind of like in a way let's plan our divorce case before we even get
- married uh uh a critical discipline is to recognize that you could be wrong and that basically means we may have to
- retreat and let's do it in such a way that the as few people are damaged as possible that we have really serious
- damage control and that means we need to plan how to disengage uh if we even begin to undertake
- it if we find that we can disengage unless at Great cost to people like customers or distributors or suppliers
- or employees don't go for it because the cost of being wrong is just too high and
- therefore you the the fundamental rule is that you want to fail cheap because you can fail fail often uh is is now
- betrayed and and and you find yourself failing expensive and that's what you don't want how would you implement
- Discovery driven growth During a severe downturn of the kind that we face today and how does that differ from how you
- would think about it in a booming economy okay in a downturn I think the fundamental problem is to is well here's
- the issue there there's a legal condition of a business that's called insolvency and as you move into
- insolvency all the rules change you know you're a very very different company if
- you've been declared insolvent so the most critical issue is to find ways of reducing the probability of
- insolvency the typical response of many companies and we see it right now is management comes in and says fire the
- left half of the building you know cut costs across the board by 30% it's just Mindless cost cutting and and and and
- and what you're doing in many cases is you're getting rid of people who very very valuable to
- you as uncertainty increases becomes more and more important to recognize that whatever moves you
- make are unlikely to be you know as successful as you would hope so the need to Discovery driven plan now starts to
- move towards what actions can we take to maximize cash inflow and minimize cash outflow and what Innovations can we do
- to the way that we run our operating business with the full knowledge that even as we try we might find three or
- four months in that it's not working and why God we better then do something to make sure that it does work otherwise we
- end up in the bankruptcy court so the focus here to me would be to focus on how do we use Discovery driven
- planning to uh take out costs that don't add value for customers uh to reduce expenses and
- assets that are unnecessary for the ongoing a part of the business yet at the same time take the people in the
- company who have time now freed up and use them as resources to be invested in building your position with your core
- customers and the definition of the core customer changes because today in this kind of environment the core customer is
- not the person who brings me lots and lots of revenues it's the person who brings me lots and lots of cash flow and
- they may not be the same so uh in this environment we're looking at enhancing cash flows uh and and
- putting in place projects that that significantly improve our cash flows and focusing on who the what we are starting
- to call the cash Darlings are the people that you know are most responsible for creating cash flow for us and pay our
- attention to them and not to the ones who just Place big orders and then don't pay you and in the boom how does this
- change well here what you're looking at is how do I expand my capacity to deliver to the customers who going to
- give me future streams of revenues with the associated profit streams so you build revenues but in the background is
- you know you don't your your your stocks value is not based on revenues your stocks value is
- based on on profit streams so I need to be thinking now about the customers who give me uh uh you know increased
- revenues with and and a fairly high level of confidence that that will be accompanied by by profit flows but here
- what I'm looking at now is how do I grow my my my asset base and how do I deploy
- and grow my employee base in such a way that I chase only the very best customers ma thank you so much for
- joining us today you're welcome [Music]
Brief Summary
Rita McGrath and Mac discuss growth strategies for companies facing uncertainty, emphasizing Discovery Driven Growth and learning from failures.
Key points
- The Dilemma of Growth. Many companies fail at growth due to conventional approaches and assumptions about certainty.
- Navigating Uncertainty. In tough times, companies must reassess their resources and focus on growth opportunities.
- Learning from Failures. Strategy should focus on intelligent failures that provide learning opportunities.
- Discovery Driven Planning. A company diversifies by using telemetry for new business opportunities, including patient monitoring.
- The Art of Disengagement. Planning for potential failure is crucial to minimize damage and costs.
- Navigating Economic Downturns. In a downturn, focus on maximizing cash inflow and minimizing outflow to avoid insolvency.
Episode highlights
- The Dilemma of GrowthMany companies fail at growth due to conventional approaches and assumptions about certainty.“You can’t be right in a world of massive uncertainty.”1:25Apr 27, 2009
- Navigating UncertaintyIn tough times, companies must reassess their resources and focus on growth opportunities.“Stop panicking and take a look at your whole portfolio.”2:47Apr 27, 2009
- Learning from FailuresStrategy should focus on intelligent failures that provide learning opportunities.“Strategy today is about learning, not sustainable competitive advantage.”10:40Apr 27, 2009
- Discovery Driven PlanningA company diversifies by using telemetry for new business opportunities, including patient monitoring.“Why don’t we take our telemetric capabilities and begin to build businesses around that?”18:17Apr 27, 2009
- The Art of DisengagementPlanning for potential failure is crucial to minimize damage and costs.“You need to plan ahead of time how are you going to disengage from that project if it doesn’t work out.”20:07Apr 27, 2009
- Navigating Economic DownturnsIn a downturn, focus on maximizing cash inflow and minimizing outflow to avoid insolvency.“The most critical issue is to find ways of reducing the probability of insolvency.”21:41Apr 27, 2009





