Why Hiring Has Slowed Without Mass Layoffs
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
ABOUT THE EPISODE Peter Cappelli, Professor of Management and Director of the Center for Human Resources at The Wharton School, examines the cooling in white-collar job openings, the impact of investor-driven cost cutting, the concept of “AI washing,” and why economic uncertainty is keeping companies cautious about expanding their workforce.
ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.
#LaborMarket #FutureOfWork #AIandJobs #HiringInsights #JobMarket #HRManagement #JobMarketTrends ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- The US labor market has an interesting mix going on right now. You have hiring leveling off and not adding to what we've
- seen at the same levels in recent years, but we aren't seeing a lot of people being laid off either. It does seem
- like we are also seeing a bit of rightsizing, to a degree, for a variety of reasons. So what does this tell us about the state of
- the labor market right now? Peter Cappelli is a Professor of Management and Director of the Center for Human Resources at
- the Wharton School. Peter, great to catch up with you again. Thanks for your time. - Thank you, Dan.
- How are you reading the labor market right now and all that we are seeing go on?
- You know, it really depends who you're talking to. I've been talking to our Ph— to our MBA students, anyway. And you know,
- from their perspective, it doesn't look great. And I think the reason why, if you look at the job openings from the BLS
- data, they're really down for some segments of the economy, and mainly it's down for white collar jobs, especially finance-
- related jobs. It's fallen by about half since last year. If you're in construction, openings are actually up. So, you know,
- it does seem to depend where you are, quite a bit. I think, you know, there is just a ton of uncertainty about how things are
- going. And businesses hate uncertainty. So you know, they think they're kind of sitting on the sidelines.
- Which I guess then ties into the fact that we aren't seeing more layoffs or more job cuts, is that they're not certain
- we're going to be bad as an economy, but they're not certain we're going to be great either, and you still want to have some
- level of status quo. Yeah, no, I think that's right. There's also something quirky
- about the labor market that is important to understand. It's not new. But now, the current decades or so, when a vacancy
- occurs, it's much more likely that it's filled by somebody who already has a job someplace else. So that creates what
- researchers call vacancy chain problems. So you know, if Dan quits and Peter then takes Dan's job, it creates another vacancy
- over here, and then somebody takes that person's job, and then, bang, bang, bang, bang, bang, you could have a cascade
- of vacancies and a cascade of job openings, right? - Right. So when employers start hiring and creating a new position, it
- creates, in the data, several positions over time, right? Because people are moving from one to the other, it's kind of
- what we used to call frictional unemployment in those days. And then when they stop hiring, then not only is there not their
- initial job, but there's not that whole chain of vacancies that happen afterwards. So as soon as hiring and creating new
- positions stops, then it looks like things have really fallen off a cliff compared to the way they were before, right?
- And does that also mean that we're also not seeing the level of expansion within companies that maybe we're used to seeing?
- Companies adding— instead of having 10 people in a— in a segment and maybe raising that to 20 because business is good,
- they're not even doing that right now. Right. And that is the big puzzle, right?
- Because the economy seems to be doing pretty well in the fourth quarter. Way better than
- expected, 4% plus growth rate. And you would think you'd be hiring in that context. And I think this is the quirky thing.
- It doesn't fit usual modeling very well. And that is that business leaders, particularly in corporations, have in the
- back of their heads a kind of idea about what they should be doing with respect to hiring. And that is driven heavily by
- investors who really don't like hiring. They really don't like employment costs. They see them as fixed costs, even though you
- can lay people off and they're actually not fixed. So I think there has been a kind of resetting of their expectations,
- driven by investors who, for some reason— maybe it started in tech. Think that companies are overstaffed all over the place.
- - Right. - And when they start cutting jobs in tech, then everybody else in tech looks around and says— the boards say,
- why aren't we cutting? And then they cut, and then everybody else gets the same pressure. The cuts in white collar jobs are
- easier to make because you don't see the consequences immediately. If you cut a production worker and a
- frontline worker, you know, you don't have people to staff the restaurant. You don't have people to move stuff in the
- warehouse. You cut a white collar job, people, at least for a little while, try to cover the work, right? - Yeah.
- So you can imagine that it's not hurting you as much when you cut white collar jobs. But eventually it turns around and bites you too.
- How do you view the question of the impact of AI moving forward? And I'll ask you that from a couple perspectives,
- because recently we saw a company like Dow Chemical cut 4500 jobs. And they said it— directly said it was tied to AI
- adjustments. Then you have a company like Amazon that, you know, has been cutting over the last couple of years, just
- announced 16,000. Didn't use the same phraseology, but you got the sense that some of it was probably tied to that as well.
- Right. So I think— I didn't make up this phrase, but it is attributed to me now, and it's AI washing. And that means that they're claiming
- it's AI even when it's not AI. And the reason is they're under enormous pressure, from investors in particular, to show that
- they're using AI, because the hope is AI will allow you to cut jobs. Cut headcount. Immediately jumps your valuations. You look
- like a much more valuable company when that— when you can cut headcount. So they felt the pressure to claim they were
- doing it even when they weren't. There's actually some survey data from this from executives, where about a third of them
- claimed that they were reported anonymously, that they were doing this. That their AI stuff was really performative. It
- wasn't really doing very much. So there's a lot of claiming it's AI, even when it's probably not. You know, companies that
- are a little more honest like this, which includes Amazon, say— if you read what they actually say, they say they
- expect that the work of the people being cut will be taken over by AI. It hasn't yet, right? - Right. - You know, my
- looking at individual companies and when they introduce AI is that you just don't see headcount dropping. What you see
- is eventually able to take on more work with the same number of people. Now you might think that's the same thing, but it's
- really not. So if you think about computer programmers, for example, 30% of their time— only 30%— is writing code. So let's
- say AI takes over that whole task. They've still got 70% of their time doing other things, which is talking to clients and
- people in the organization, figuring out what our needs are, managing their expectations, getting budgets, all that stuff.
- So if you took that 30% away, you still have 70% of those— of that work that has to be done. So you're not, at least in the
- short term, cutting any of those people, nor can you just ram them together and cut one programmer, right?
- Well, and I guess it brings up an interesting point that you kind of led into before, is that there are many businesses out
- there that maybe are still trying to figure out what their future hiring levels longer term are going to look like.
- - Yeah. - Because they don't know exactly how AI is going to impact their productivity, and they don't want to make these
- moves just yet. Yeah, I think that's— you know, that's a charitable view. - Okay. All right. - Whatever— it might be,
- that they're just cutting because they feel they have to cut. And for sure, though, I think they're
- reluctant to staff up now. Part of it might be because they're not sure how AI will play out, but I would say more of it is
- just because of the uncertainty generated largely by the administration, trade policies, federal government contracts,
- all that kind of stuff. Where is it going? It changes day by day. And if you're a business person, you want to place big bets. Even
- medium bets, until you have a sense of where that's going. And it— you know, it hasn't settled down right? So not surprisingly,
- they're sitting on their hands a bit. So would it be safe to say then, at least maybe in the short term,
- that we're probably looking at more of the same, like this pattern that we've kind of been in for the last several months,
- that that's going to continue while all of this kind of works itself out? Yeah, I mean, I think the question is, will it
- settle down? And it's not clear it's going to settle down. But I think at some point employers have to decide, you know, we
- just can't do nothing. We just can't keep waiting, because it's not going to settle down. So maybe we have to start
- placing bets. You know, at the Wharton School and at other institutions with students graduating, we noticed this a
- lot, because college graduates take the first hit. The easiest thing to do if you want to shrink your workforce is to use
- attrition. That means just don't fill vacancies when they pop up. And if you're going to fill positions, the most challenging
- way to do it is to hire new graduates in and train them. It's a longer term, slightly longer term bet than just
- pulling somebody from someplace else and popping them in. So the hiring that does take place has shrunk down the most, I think,
- for new college graduates, right? Peter, always great to get your thoughts and your— and spend some
- time with you. I appreciate it. We will talk to you again very soon, sir. Thank you.
- Good. Thank you, Dan. Peter Cappelli, Professor of Management here at the Wharton School.
Brief Summary
Peter Cappelli discusses the US labor market's hiring trends, job openings, and AI's impact on employment.
Key points
- The Current Labor Market. Hiring is leveling off, but layoffs are not increasing, creating uncertainty.
- AI's Impact on Jobs. Companies are under pressure to claim AI is driving job cuts, even when it's not.
- Future Hiring Patterns. Employers are hesitant to hire due to uncertainty about AI and economic conditions.
Episode highlights
- The Current Labor MarketHiring is leveling off, but layoffs are not increasing, creating uncertainty.“Businesses hate uncertainty.”1:22Feb 18, 2026
- AI's Impact on JobsCompanies are under pressure to claim AI is driving job cuts, even when it's not.“It’s AI washing.”5:31Feb 18, 2026
- Future Hiring PatternsEmployers are hesitant to hire due to uncertainty about AI and economic conditions.“You just can’t do nothing.”9:06Feb 18, 2026





