NBA Analytics, Tanking, and the Future of Team Building
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
ABOUT THE EPISODE Ben Alamar—former NBA analytics executive with the Oklahoma City Thunder and Cleveland Cavaliers, and author of Sports Analytics: A Guide for Coaches, Managers, and Other Decision Makers—joins Wharton Moneyball to break down emerging NBA storylines, the unintended consequences of draft lottery reform, bold alternatives to tanking, and the case for analytics trailblazer Dean Oliver’s induction into the Basketball Hall of Fame. Cade, Eric, and Adi also explore statistical evidence of Olympic figure skating bias, debate event proliferation in skiing and speed skating, unpack the Los Angeles Lakers’ Pythagorean paradox, and assess historic performance runs by athletes such as Mikaela Shiffrin and Scottie Scheffler.
ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? Moneyball Highlights explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.
#sportsanalytics #basketballanalytics #nbadraft #nbaanalysis #figureskating #olympicjudging ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- Welcome, welcome to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to a full hour of sports analytics here on the Wharton podcast
- network. This is Kade Massie hosting this week with my two longtime collaborators, friends, colleagues here
- at Wharton, Eric Bradlo, and Audi Winer. Our fourth co-host, Shane Jensen, is out
- this week. He's teaching. He'll be back. He and Audi are juggling teaching schedules this quarter, but we've got
- three of us in here for the duration. We are coming up on 12 years. We've been doing this virtually every week uh for
- 12 years. Some combination of us in here. We're going to hit our anniversary in March. We're recording on Tuesday
- afternoon as we typically do. Show will go up on Wednesday. We are going to run our regular format this week, which
- means in the first half the show, bring a guest in here who's already here. And second half, we'll do open lines, kick
- things around a little bit, see what the boys have been thinking about over the last week. Guest this week, longtime
- friend of the show, old friend of the show. I don't mean old man, I mean oldtime friend, Ben Alamar. You probably
- know him from his involvement in sports analytics. Really one of the first guys in working in the NBA. One must have
- been one of the very first full-time guys in the NBA. He's worked with the Spurs, the Cavs. It's been a good
- stretch at ESPN working with people like Dean Oliver building out really kind of
- building out the sports analytics prof platform there at ESPN internally and externally that has had a profound
- influence on the world of sports. He teaches in various places. He's teaching right now at the University of Texas.
- He's taught in universities around the country teaching a sports analytics class. Has a has a book out on sports
- analytics done well enough to be in second edition. and Ben Alamar, good to see you. Thanks for making time for us.
- >> Oh, pleasure to be here again. Uh, it's been uh, you know, as I say, old oldtime
- uh, participant here, but always glad to join in the discussion. >> Thanks, man. Good to see you. Um,
- fellas, uh, Audi is going to be up at the MIT conference in a couple of weeks, the Sloan MIT Sloan Sports Analytics
- Conference, 20th annual. Those guys run up there every year. Audi will be up there. Ben's Ben's a a
- frequent host of some platform event session. Ben's got a session this spring on academic collaborations, I believe,
- or academic research. So, uh, do y'all need to cross paths while they're running around Boston?
- >> I hope I'll be able to attend. >> Yeah, absolutely. >> We're slowly tearing our attention away
- from the football world and casting around for other things to um to to attend to. Um Audi Audi of course is
- already excited about whatever meager offerings baseball has right now. They're they're up and running, but
- really there are two sports underway and we're trying to get deeper on both of them. Setting aside for the moment
- Olympics, um basketball and hockey and you you've been you're you're you're good across all sports, but I think
- you're especially deep in basketball. So, can you help us get to up to speed on the NBA and what do you as you look
- around, as you dig in, as you pay attention, what do you think's interested in the NBA this year?
- >> Yeah, I mean, the the NBA has been really pretty exciting this year. I think, you know, there's always some
- some issues folks have and uh with with tanking and such and we'll get to that at some point, but um I think what's
- great about this year is we're seeing, you know, for one, the Spurs, the rise of women really starting to fulfill the
- promise that everybody had expected. We're seeing some real surprises as well that you have these the young Detroit
- team um really leading the league now in a lot of ways and um uh in a great position to make a a strong run in in
- the postseason. And you also have these this other surprise the Boston Celtics who you know during the offseason they
- were you know tearing their team down you know sent a lot of salary off a lot of good players off um but have been
- able to put together a a really strong team that is competing well in in the east uh which not as strong as the west
- but the still uh they've been against New York and and Detroit they've been really good uh despite not having uh
- Jason Tatum uh and the idea that Tatum is getting ready to perhaps join them for a playoff run makes that a really
- scary team when you know nobody was really counting on the Celtics. They saw them as much like the Pacers sort of
- taking a gap year here while they their their best player was on the bench. Uh >> then can I jump in there real quick? Um
- the four franchises that you just pointed out I you pointed out San Antonio actually maybe you didn't point
- out Oklahoma City but I can't help but think about Oklahoma City. So you didn't. So, San Antonio,
- Detroit, and Boston. San Antonio and Boston, I think anybody would call two of the bestrun franchises in the NBA.
- Famously good front offices. And of course, OKC is floating around in the background as well. I don't know
- anything about Detroit's front office. Are they thought of in the are they thought of as an upand cominging? What
- is it that's going on around there that allowed them to kind of surprise with a young team here? Yeah. So they're so
- they a couple years ago uh they brought in uh Tjan Langden and um uh uh Michael Blackstone. Uh both the guys have been
- they they were working together in New Orleans before. Uh I worked with with Blackstone in Cleveland. Um he's really
- sort of a negotiation salary cap expert. Trejan's just been um you know come in and really worked his way up in the
- league in the front office is very well respected generally speaking and they've
- done you know they they had some young talent there already when they got there uh that the old regime had put in place
- but they also had a lot of you know contracts that they needed to move and and turn into valuable assets which they
- they they've done a great job of combining sort of creating uh a platform for their young players to uh
- demonstrate that they they can uh play while uh not um you know uh by the same time adding some some valuable pieces
- that can help them uh you know win games as those young guys develop and get a little bit more experience. So, uh, I
- think they've done a really nice job over the last couple years, uh, you know, transitioning that team from what
- it was, which was, you know, u sort of mired in, uh, not being able to move forward too much. Uh, created some
- flexibility for themselves and really has, um, you know, obviously, uh, put together a really talented roster that
- that's doing a great job. >> Cool to hear. Um, Trajan Lane done uh Duke Colomb. Yeah, see the guy played
- Alaska, drifted down from Alaska, played ball at Duke for a while. >> That's perfect.
- >> Interesting. I I don't Has anyone ever tried to map the influence from various
- collegiate programs into the NBA? Some They've got a number of former players and successful front offices, don't
- they? >> Yeah, Duke. Duke certainly does. Um, but uh it's it's hard to track. So, the
- front office guys are so varied in in in their experiences. I mean, you take San
- Sam Prey, he is, you know, from D3 school at uh and and >> you know, has obviously is really
- thought of as the top the best run franchise right now in the league. So, >> Right. Right. Was he I assume he was
- there when you were there back in the early 2000s. So, how early in Sam's regime was your time with him?
- >> Well, so Sam got hired in SE you know, it was the SuperSonics at the time. uh
- he got hired um and then you know his his first decision was to draft Kevin Durant. Um and then that he hired me. So
- it was a really big summer for the uh we we we got going. So yeah, I started working with Sam right after his first
- draft. Um >> okay, >> you know, suffered through a couple of tough years as we were building that
- team, but um turned it turned it around with some brilliant draft work from Sam.
- This >> this is a a big a bigger question than we have time for, but I'm curious to get
- just a first taste from you on this. What do you think Sam had to learn? Like what are some of the fir what what's one
- of the first things he had to learn as he moved into that position? Presumably he kept on learning for a long time.
- He's gotten so good at it, but what's something that you saw him work through and you think he learned early on in his
- time? >> Um so I think that you know one of the things was um sort of how to you know
- use it. He had come from the Spurs where you they were one of the early teams that had done anything in this in the
- area of data analytics u and he knew that he really wanted it but he didn't really um have a you know full grasp of
- what was possible or how to incorporate it you know really into decision-m uh you know how to trust and then but you
- know he's he's so smart he's really good at just asking questions and asking questions which is sort of the key piece
- that you need in that position to to to grow and learn how to utilize things well and so he really developed from
- sort of like, all right, here's a spreadsheet that we can provide for you every, you know, week that's updated to
- really understanding how to build a system within the team, uh, and not just a one-off guy, but like a how do we have
- this all this information really permeate through uh, everything that we're we're working on.
- >> Yeah, that's so interesting. I think Eric was trying to jump in. >> No, no. I wanted to go back just for a
- second to yourself comment. I'm just wondering, Ben, if you think that >> um in some sense, if they were in the
- West, >> I think you would agree the Celtics would not be the favorites in the West.
- >> Oh, no. >> But the fact that they're in the East also, which gives them, let's call it, a
- round or two to get Tatum back in the flow. >> Yeah. >> You could make an argument that they
- could be higher than Let me make an argument. You just tell me I'm wrong. >> Sure.
- >> They're high because of the weakness of the East. >> Yeah. the openness of the East. They're
- higher than any team in the West because in the West it could be the Spurs, could
- be the Nuggets, it could be the Thunder, >> but out of the East, they might be the
- favorite with Tatum back and so they have a higher probability of making it to the finals even though they have a
- lower probability of of winning the finals. What What do you is if you had to guess right now, would they be your
- favorite based on that argument or is that not right? >> Uh I I I I think it's it's it's a it's a
- fair argument. I'm not sure that they're the total favorites just because we don't know what Tatum is like. Is he
- coming back and how he meshes with how the team is playing this season? Uh, you know, Jaylen Brown there has been the
- guy making that team work. And while Brown and Tatum have obviously played together a lot, not in this particular
- situation and not in the case where Jaylen's gotten the the taste of really being the lead of the team. And so how
- those guys as Tatum works his way back, you know, he's not gonna he's gonna be he's way back into basketball shape,
- got, you know, get everything going again. Um having that their how they work together in this new uh you know,
- takes some time. Um I mean we just when players get traded that it takes time for them to settle into the
- new environment. Um, I think Tatum will take some time to settle into these this
- new Celtics environment in similar ways. Um, if and they figure that stuff out quickly, then yeah, they're probably
- favorites. Um, but, uh, you know, Detroit and New York are are are still really good. They will give them a
- strong run for money in the playoffs. But um certainly not the stumbling blocks that uh exists in the west- w
- with OKC San Antonio Denver as >> Ben let's talk about the west. You mentioned women coming on the team
- really coming on. OKC was such a force last year and they seem just stocked for years to come. How does that rivalry
- shape up and and why is it if if San Antonio is kind of surprisingly competitive in that rivalry? Why is
- that? Yeah, it's it's really interesting because the um the Spurs are are are you
- know look like Thunder killers right now. They are the ones who are have figured out how to beat them. Uh they
- you know they've won they've handed the Thunder four of their 13 losses uh this season. Um you know so clearly they've
- got something going there. Um and so you know it you can see the impact in a couple of ways. Um, first, you know, on
- the offense, like the Thunder overall have the fourth ranked offense in the league when in terms of efficiency. Um,
- but against the Spurs, they would be like the 26th ranked offense. You know, they, you know, dropping from 120 points
- per possession to 112. Um, they they shoot less efficiently. Uh, they get fewer fouls. They just they don't
- >> Okay, but does doesn't everybody look worse against the Spurs? Are they not just that that
- >> the Thunder are so good that I mean it's a dramatic drop off, right? Like they
- they they I mean this is a team that we expect to uh you know potentially be a perennial champion, you know, and really
- put together a a run here. And you know, they're only you know scoring like again
- like the um the 26th best offense in the league when they're playing the Spurs. >> Yeah. They're not regressing to the
- mean. They're reg they're regressing beyond the mean to the bottom. It's polar opposite what's going on
- there. >> Let me ask him, Ben, how much weight do you put in the regular season record of
- the Thunder right now? Actually, by the way, they have 14 losses. I didn't even realize this. The Pistons now have the
- best record in basketball. I actually did not know that the Thunder had uh passed them for the best record. Is it
- does it mean anything to the Thunder? I mean, yeah, they'd like to hold off the Spurs. Trust me, they'd love to have
- homecourt advantage in that round. Yeah, that does mean something. But whether they win 60 games, 63 games, 58 games,
- you know, does it really mean anything? >> Um, it's it's I think it it depends a
- little bit. I think as early on the season when this the Thunder were just like they were on pace for, you know, 70
- plus games. >> Yeah. >> Like then then it was like, well against that, by the way,
- >> what >> I bet it against that mean is a powerful force. >> It is. They're really good though. Um,
- but as like at that point there there is a you know uh a decision you have to make as a team like do we care about
- this? Should we fundamentally care about doing this? Um you know a few years ago
- the Warriors decided that they did and they went for it uh hard. Um the this year the the Thunder you know they've
- >> I think they've had enough injuries and things that uh you guys have missed games where it became clear like that's
- not going to be uh going to happen for them this year. They're not going after a win record this year. So, generally,
- no, they want the they want the one seat. They'll they'll play for it. They don't they don't like the Spurs. So,
- they there is a you know, a a rivalry there was fun to see. It makes the games, you know, gives it a little extra
- edge because they clearly don't like each other. Um so, you know, in general, yeah, they don't care between
- that's not an issue. One seed and Spurs do matter to them. So I on the other end of the spectrum,
- we're hearing talk about tanking. I think the NBA just fined. Was it Utah? Somebody got fined for taking out
- players in a competitive game. >> It it you know, it's been a few years since everybody was up in arms about
- tanking with the NBA, but it seems to be back kind of in force. What's going on?
- And what do you think, Ben, could be done about it, if anything? >> Yeah. So, I think this what two two
- dynamics have sort of led to the the the level of tang we're seeing right now, which is, you know, the Jazz not playing
- their starters in the fourth quarter. Um, you know, like that's that's that's beyond some of the things that we've
- seen in the past in terms of tang like that's pretty uh extreme uh situation. >> Well, Ben, let me jump in real quickly.
- This is maybe cheap, but I don't know what Danny Ang's role is out there in Utah. You probably have. Can you tell us
- something about the role? When Danny Ames was a player, he would take any edge he could find. It wouldn't be
- surprising at his organization would be Am I Is that unfair to say? Probably unfair.
- >> Oh, I just want to interject. As a Knicks fan growing up, you put me with Larry Bird, Kevin McCale, Parish, and
- DJ, and I'm a winner, too. Sorry. >> Oh, no. >> I'm not I'm not And so, I'm not giving
- Danny A credit for anything on that. But Ben, please go ahead. I Danny H like he's he has regardless of how you think
- about him as a player as an executive he what he did in Boston >> you cut you cut out there for just a
- second Danny A as executive what >> as executive has been incredibly successful you know he built the team in
- Boston did an excellent job you know bringing talent in there has won championships as an executive um moved
- to you know to Utah now has this a similar role there uh you know sort of re trying to build that team and he is
- you believes and and that it's hard for Utah to acquire players other than through
- the draft to high level top level players other than through the draft and so he has to feel like um you know we
- have to do it through the draft and tang is the way to do it and so >> is that is that because people won't
- come out to Utah is that >> that's that's that's the you know one of the concerns is that you free agents
- don't look at at Salt Lake City as a uh destination um both from desiraability of the city and also just from the the
- the the sponsorship opportunities are not the same as they are in places like LA and New York. So small markets are
- always at this kind of disadvantage. Um and Utah I think is sort of an extra disadvantage
- >> but um so >> I mean it sounds like you can't win at all out there. I mean winning only
- through the I mean how long do you get to hold on to a player? Usually they're not
- >> they have to free a player once you have a player through the the way that you
- know through a few cont through the first contract you're the one who gets to pay them the most afterwards. So you
- have a chance to to what OKC is doing right now. Uh I mean that's how they they they through the through a one very
- smart trade which helped them accumulate a lot of draft assets and some other trades even more draft assets. They've
- you know really built a uh a juggernaut without free agents. Um they've done it through you know they acquired Shay
- through a trade. Everything else is is draft. Um, >> but everybody would have said, everybody
- thought Prey was greatly disadvantaged operating out of Oklahoma City for the same,
- >> but also they ended up with Shay. I mean, almost that's crazy, right? >> Yeah. Yeah. They the the Clippers were
- put in a position by by Quai Leonard where they basically had to acquire Paul George if they wanted Quai. And so uh
- you know Sam knew that he had that the leverage to do that and and he insisted on including Shay in that trade. now
- should clearly exceed the expectations of everybody. Uh but yeah, he's been you know uh like that that that was been a
- real thing. Um but overall in terms of tanking like you know we've had a flattening of the the odds in the in the
- lottery. So you know that if you have the worst record in the the league you know you don't it's hard your odds of
- getting the number one pick are are are less than they used to be. And so you so
- more teams have, you know, in that, you know, one to six range have a shot at a top four pick, uh, a reasonable shot.
- And this particular draft coming up is thought to be one of a a really, really strong draft with at least three guys
- who are thought to be significant, you know, uh, franchise level players in in the future. And so you have those two
- dynamics coming together to really push teams incentives to want to tank and make sure they're in that bottom six,
- bottom eight at least to have a reasonable shot at keeping at getting one of those guys uh in the draft. Ben,
- has there been any evidence that you've seen or looked at that suggests that um like I understand like you know, let's
- say obviously LeBron James was number one and there were a lot of great players number one, but also there were
- some number one players that didn't work out as well. Like >> how much information is there really to
- say, well, number three is so much better than number seven or eight. Is there any evidence to suggest that's
- really true? >> Oh, yeah, for sure. I mean we you can look at the the at draft you know uh you
- know uh uh win probability added over by draft's position and there's a real curve there's a definitely a decline
- curve now that's that how steep we that curve is varies significantly by the draft um because as you point out like I
- was in Cleveland when we drafted Anthony Bennett number one overall like and if you don't know who Anthony Bennett is
- it's not your fault it like that that happens like there are busts. It's not a but um some drafts are
- stocked with players that everybody believes great and some most of them a lot often turn out to be great.
- Sometimes it's stocked with players that people think are going to be great and they're fine. Andrew Wiggins is a great
- example of that. Um, and then you have guys that we totally miss on, uh, like Giannis, you know, was not a, you know,
- when we were thinking in that, you know, 2013 14 draft, um, you know, uh, I guess
- 2013 draft, Giannis wasn't on our board for one of the top five with the top pick. Um, because we just didn't have
- the information we needed to to to believe he was at that level. But, you know, obviously he was the by far the
- best player in that draft >> because international scouting wasn't then fully developed. Is that is that
- what was going on? >> Yeah. And you know, we we had some international scouting, but we did not
- have good international data uh at that. >> Okay. >> Yeah. >> Okay. So, Ben, you said this thing. You
- said the odds have been flattened at the top of the lottery, and that was by design. And the design was to decrease
- the incentive to have the top pick. But you're saying ironically in a deep draft, it gives exactly the wrong
- incentives because if you can get into the top three or four, then you're have e even chances at relatively even
- chances at a at one of the great players. Is that is that the >> more So it means that if you're you know
- you know if you finish with the fifth, sixth, seventh record, you now your odds of getting that first pick are higher
- than they used to be. So, you just want to get down into that range. You don't have to get down to the bottom, but you
- want to get down that range to have a reasonable shot at that pick. >> Um, >> well, so these guys in the NBA front
- office are having a tough time, you know, tweaking these numbers exactly uh in the way that would give the
- incentives to play throughout the season. What do you think if if they they've made their best effort to get
- those the slope of those odds right, it's still not working. What other levers can they pull? Well, I mean the
- so the there are there's one very clear and then there's a second even more radical way to do this. The the the
- obvious way to do this to eliminate this the the problem the incentive problem here is to just eliminate the draft. Um
- and you you have to you let all the players coming in are they're all free agents and you go sign teams that want
- them can go sign them. Uh and you eliminate the rookie scale contracts so players you know so teams are allowed to
- differentiate their offers. You'd have to have a hard cap if you did that, right?
- >> Well, you you you can have a hard cap and not um and not have a rookie scale.
- Like that's fine. There's no reason those two things don't have to go together, >> right?
- >> Um and so you can still have the hard cap and uh it, you know, unlikely that the owners would get rid of that, but
- the the rookie scale um which you know would eliminate the use the value of the going to the free agency. Once you have
- you eliminate the rookie scale, then teens can go and say, "All right, yeah, I'm Utah. Uh, you may not want to come
- here, but I'm going to offer you a million dollars more than LA is going to." So now I there there's way to
- differentiate my offer from other teams. Uh, you know, or, you know, I'm going to
- book, you know, invest in you to be the, you know, the franchise, the center of my franchise, whereas you if you go to
- OKC, yeah, you're gonna you're going to be on the team, but, you know, you're not going to be uh, you know, getting a
- lot of playing time right away. So, >> but Ben, in general that it is true though that all the regional effects we
- were talking about before would would just be exacerbated, would they not? Given that it's now now they have to
- compete also for the rookies in the same way that they're disadvantaged when competing for free agents
- >> to to some extent except that uh one there are only so much so many uh uh of these guys that teams are going to
- invest significantly in. So, if LA decides that they want player X uh and and player Y, then that's it. Like,
- they're going to go after those guys, they're not going to bid on every single player that in in the draft. Um they
- can't. And or if you take a team that like, you know, if Boston is really good, uh then they're not going to spend
- a lot on rookies, no matter how much people want to go there. They're just not going to because it's not worth it
- to them. They need to save their cap for their existing star players. >> Um >> that makes that that makes sense. But
- also you get the you get the intertemporal um effects as well. I think I think because you're saying some
- drafts are much deeper than others. So this upcoming draft anticipated being deep if in this in the world you're
- describing in the current world because of the rookie cap the the slots are kind
- of fixed. The same amount is going to be spent on the top 10 players regardless of whether they're great or whether
- they're lousy. >> Exactly. >> In the world you're describing some years could be a lot more rookie pay
- essentially than others according to what that's interesting. That alone sounds like a big inefficiency though.
- >> So, but let me ask you a question. Let's imagine you're the you're the NBA. >> Yeah.
- >> And Ben Alamar works for the NBA and suggests eliminating the draft. >> Yeah.
- >> Is there any way you could kind of simulate or have a prediction of what might happen if you got rid of the draft
- given it's never happened before? And so I'm just wondering like could all hell break loose? Like how would you even
- think about evaluating a concept like that? Yeah, I so I mean I think that what would happen and this is you know
- anytime there's a significant rule change or you know this the the the uh the cap rules change significantly for
- whatever reason the smart teams figure it out first. They figure out their strategy they they have a clear strategy
- that they execute around whatever the new rules are. Um and the teams that aren't as as sophisticated or you know
- as as smart in the front office you know they sort of like assume it's going to work exactly like free agency works now
- for example. Um and and you know whatever the dynamics are they might there there's going to be some
- interesting dynamics. We don't really know what they are. The closest thing we have to this would be you know NIL and
- college basketball right now. Um where you know we are not seeing you know all the players flocking to you know the
- biggest cities. They're flocking to the teams that are going to pay them. Um there there's there's no cap there. you
- know, all so it's it it's it's a little bit different obviously, but um you know, team reputation, strength of the
- organization, >> all that opportunity for the player, all those things are going to matter in that
- world. Um whereas, you know, right now in the draft, they don't because the player gets no choice.
- >> By the way, guys, quick quick aside, uh in the WNBA, they've got this craziness
- that's about to happen about something that's never happened before. They're negotiating a new CBA right now. And for
- years, the agents have known that they're going to have a new CBA this year. So, they've expired a lot of
- contracts now. >> And so, basically, almost every player in the league is a free agent. As soon
- as they close the CBA, it's just going to be a free-for-all. It's a complete free-for-all. And just as Ben says, the
- advantage goes to the sharper teams, the teams that have been thinking about this
- ahead of time. No one knows exactly what's going to happen, but can you prepare yourself for all the
- contingencies so that you have an advantage in this new world? >> Ben, can I just have a counterargument
- to yours? So, let's suppose I'm a player where I certainly care about money. I mean, no doubt players care about money
- deeply, >> but they also care about winning. >> So, if there's no draft and I'm I don't
- even know is one of the three players one of the boozers. I don't even know. I know they is is are they one of the
- players that you're talking about that's coming out? >> No, he's they've fallen out of the top
- three. They're they're they're part of the high quality of this draft, but they're not top they're not top.
- >> So, let's just say one of the top three players says, you know, I care about money, but I do really care about
- winning. You know what? I'm gonna go to OKC, San Antonio, those are my teams that I'm gonna go Denver. That's it.
- Boston, maybe Detroit, New York. Six. Those are the six. Other 26 teams don't even bother contacting me. Why wouldn't
- the rich get richer under this scenario where you I'll just call it it's a multi- objective function where there's
- some weight on winning and that's going to force possibly the over team the other teams to overpay
- >> in uncertainty which could actually lead to their demise. >> Yeah. So I I mean so there there a
- couple things there. One you've just named OKC and San Antonio is getting you know the rich getting richer which is
- true but they're also pretty small market teams. So the small market big market thing you know we it seems like
- that that's counter. The other sort of part of that is like yeah if you're not if if you know winning is if if we
- assume that consistent winning is a product of you know a strong smart organization
- um then that gives you know smart organizations an advantage that players will want to
- go to those kinds of organization. Of course, if you're if you're not a smart good organization that can't figure out
- how to win, you're going to be at a disadvantage. And the only way to to to do it is you had to spend more. That's
- the way to do it. Now, I while money matters, winning matters, opportunity matters also for these guys because
- particularly the guys who are haven't, you know, proven may not have be off the huge rookie uh offers. um they're going
- to have to prove themselves. And so if they don't have opportunity to play going to OKC, Boston, uh you know,
- Denver, like if they're not going to have an opportunity to play there, then they're not going to have an opportunity
- to get their next contract, you know, right? And brilliant. >> So lots of dimensions going to come into
- the position. >> Let me AI AI has a question. I have a followup on this topic as well. Audi, so
- in the draft um you you're talking about uh or replacing it or something similar.
- How much does the quality drop from the top three, top four and and that must make an enormous difference on this kind
- of calculation? So I mean this is something that that uh we we've always talked about a moneyball. Um, and
- basketball is clearly the most rapidly decaying function among all sports. And I'm not sure it's it actually is because
- they really get that much worse or just because a team only has five players and
- there's only one ball. And >> by the way, a do you mean a priori a posterior? >> Uh, I mean, okay. I mean a priori. I
- mean basically I've just it's a great question but I'm I'm essentially asking can you really build a team
- >> without having regular access to the top X where X is what three five nine 20 um
- generally my understanding about the draft is after the first round is just it's just you're just nothing there
- maybe you get a you know a generation you get a player of any value every now and then but
- >> can you really build it without access to the real Um, I mean, you you can build a team
- without access to the top, but you're going >> winning team, right? >> You can build a team without access to
- the very top of the draft, provided that you have other avenues to acquire, you know, high level talent. um you know,
- you can't uh if if you don't if you can't bring players in through free agency or trade that are of that
- caliber, the most likely place to get those kinds of players is at the very top of the draft. They're not they don't
- all exist there. You can get them like you go was, you know, and he's the exception that proves the rule on some
- level. I mean, you know, these these players do exist and they happen, but they tend to be in the at least in the
- top 10 of the draft, uh, if not top five. Uh, and so that doesn't it's really hard to compete
- without a couple of guys that are that that good. >> Guys, let me real quick observation and
- then we need to change to a final question for Ben before we go, but I just want to observe a specific thing
- about what Ben said before. If you did go to the system, the the advantage to the sharp clubs essentially, if you
- think about it right now, the challenge with a draft primarily is to order the players. And if you go
- to free agency model, the challenge is to value every player. And the second task is much harder than the first task.
- And so that the advantage you if you're a sharp club, you want a more complicated, more challenging task
- because you can separate more. And so you might claim that that would be an advantage to the Sharp Club. Um Ben, I I
- saw you recently and you mentioned that you've taken up a a cause. You're you're
- evangelical about a new cause. Yes. >> That I think we'd probably be sympathetic to. So tell tell us about
- this cause. Now Audi, you this is going to tickle you, I think. >> Okay. It it is my very strong belief that uh
- that Dean Oliver belongs in the Basketball Hall of Fame. Uh I think I think the case is a slam dunk no
- problem. Uh his qualifications and background, his impact on the game are so deep and obvious that um he he
- absolutely uh belongs in in the Basketball Hall of Fame. Um Dean obviously wrote basketball on paper.
- >> So hold on, Ben. Hold on. First tell us by what avenue do you get him in here?
- We think about Will Chamberlain and Magic Johnson and Dean Oliver. Come on. >> Yeah.
- >> Yeah. So, Dino, so there's a there's a a category in the Hall of Fame of contributors, people who have had an
- positive impact on the game. Um, you know, and so those are the the that's the avenue the the the lane in which
- Dean gets added to the Hall of Fame. >> And who are some examples from that? >> I mean, there there there are variety of
- guys, but uh Dell Harris, Rod Thorne, Rick Weltz, Doug Collins. Um, so these are and so you can get in multiple
- times. So, you know, uh, Doug Collins can get in as a coach but also as a a contributor through his media work or,
- you know, and Del Harris has been a real ambassador for the game overseas, for example. Um, uh, Rick Weltz has been
- really innovative on the business side of of basketball and really contributes to the game. Um, Dean obviously has
- contributed to how teams think about basketball and really changed that significantly. Um, so that that's why as
- a contributor, he really belongs in the Hall of Fame. So, so Ben, tell us. So, you're you're we're analysts and so we
- think Dean Dean speaks our language and so yes, he helps us understand it. He gives us a lens to understand the game.
- You're from that same world. You have a PhD in economics. What's the evidence that you would muster for his having
- changed the way actual basketball people who run teams and play the game think differently because of Dean?
- >> Um the the whole concept of of efficiency and the four factors of basketball uh are have permeated
- throughout the league. So Dean brought these concepts in basketball on paper which is uh to me the the starting point
- of modern basketball analytics uh when he published that book. Um and so that that I mean you find that book on on
- most you know in most front office on a bookshelf somewhere uh at least one copy
- in every team building somewhere um and but so if you take the the four factors for example which is sort of a you know
- clear way to think about a team uh you have their shooting efficiency, rebound efficiency, turnovers and ability to get
- to the line. These are the four factors uh that that we can measure and you know
- we know that we take those how a team performs on those things on offense and defense
- 90 plus percent correlation to to their point differential. >> Let me just point out because we I do
- this with my my my senior uh students. I teach a sports analytics uh capstone and
- it's uh remarkable because it works almost as well basically as well as point differential
- >> just to show you. So, in other words, you're basically taking a bunch of peripherals and you're using them to to
- predict winning percentage and it does it as well as the score differential. What does this well, Audi? Not quite. It
- can't be exactly as well, but really incredibly close. I mean, in fairness, shooting efficiency is one of them. And
- of course, that that's that's the biggest factor. And it's not like and that doesn't that has a lot to do with
- your score differential. >> So, real quickly to remind us what shooting efficiency is. And you
- mentioned efficiency right off the top and if you want to give Dean credit for one thing it's probably this notion of
- efficiency but to remind us what it is. >> So efficiency overall is points per possession. That's how we think about
- and that that is a a a paradigm shift in in basketball significantly. And shooting efficiency typically we think
- about effective field goal percentage which says all right we're going to give you more credit for making a three-point
- shot than a two-point shot because it's harder to make and it's worth more. Um that's the the effective field goal
- percentage basically, you know, weights twos and threes more reasonably uh and gives us a better sense of how well a
- team is shooting given these two different kinds of shots. >> Well, Ben, by the way, if it makes you
- feel any better, I asked the Oracle chat GPT what his odds are of making the Hall
- of Fame >> and it said actually it's pretty moderate. It gave it 40% chance. Now,
- >> I could ask it on what basis and all kinds of things, but it said he's an extraordinarily strong contributor, but
- in a what people consider a niche area, but either way, >> but but your your Oracle doesn't know
- that Ben Alamar is on the job. It hasn't picked up yet on the fact that there's an evangelist out there. Who do you have
- to convince, Ben? And how and how long a campaign are you geared up to wage? >> Yeah, so I'm I'm going to keep fighting
- this one until uh I get uh get some traction. I fir I first rolled this out at Sloan a couple of years ago in a
- history of basketball analytics panel uh that Dean was on, but I asked Mike Zaren, you know, when we were going to
- get Dean in the Hall of Fame. Um and and Xarin uh acknowledged that that he belongs there. Uh
- >> Xarn front office with the Boston Celtics. >> Absolutely. Yes. >> And call the Bill James of basketball.
- So >> is Bill Bill James is not in the in the the baseball hall of fame? There's no
- avenue for that, right? >> Yeah. I that that's you know >> if this avenue existed in baseball
- >> I don't know how you do it but I don't >> he could be I mean Bill James would he
- be cons I guess he wouldn't be considered a writer at all because there was obviously a writer's
- >> I mean he's he he was a writer obviously >> he should be considered a writer and he
- should be in the Hall of Fame. Absolutely why like they've got if there's not a reason for Bill for Bill
- James be in the baseball hall of fame they got to figure that out because that's that doesn't seem right. By the
- way, just so you know, um I asked Jot GPT if Ben Alamar really pushes for it. You added 10 to 15%.
- >> I if I'm Ben, I'm not >> here's a better question, Eric. We're out of control.
- >> I'm going to ask it pushes for it. Is that >> That's what I'm about to do. A I'm not
- going to use me. I'm gonna use me. If Eric Bradloan says, "All right, now we're down to 25."
- >> Yeah, we're losing. We're losing points. >> But Ben, you're worth 10 out of it. Hey,
- hey, I want >> value ad. >> We are getting the uh baseball hall of fame, the head of the baseball hall of
- fame on the show in the next month and we're going to start the Bill James we're going to start the Bill James
- campaign. >> There you go. Somebody needs to lead that charge. That's the I I I can't take
- that one on, but I I'll uh >> actually, let me just say, Kade, I will ask um I will we're having Josh Trowick,
- who's the president of the National Baseball Hall of Fame, on next week, Ben, and I'm going to ask him, do you
- ever see a path where someone that's trains the game of baseball through analytics? Like, you could argue, why
- not Billy Bean at some level, too? I mean, why doesn't he get why isn't he in the Baseball Hall of Fame?
- >> What are you talking about? How about Theo Epstein? >> Yeah. Well, that's another name.
- >> Championships, right? Theo will get there, right? So, I mean, I to me I I mean, those guys like there's clear ways
- for them to do it and and the the impact that they had are sort of advancing, you
- know, using these things, you know, think about the front office in a new and interesting way with the tools. But,
- you know, Bill James created the tools like Dean Oliver changed the way we, you know, make decisions in basketball. Um,
- and and that's >> it's a great cause. It's a great cause. Keep beating that drum. We'll we'll
- start we'll start going along with you. Ben, we've kept you longer than we meant
- to. Thank you very much. Always a delight to talk to you. >> My pleasure. Thanks, guys.
- >> Ben Alamar, longtime sports analytics. He has got a book on sports analytics.
- He is teaching a program on teach on sports analytics at the University of Texas at the moment. He will be at the
- Sloan Sports Analytics Conference hosting a panel in just about a month's time. All right, guys. That has been the
- first half of Orton Moneyball. Come back and join us after the break. Welcome back.
- Welcome back to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to the second half or you might say the last quarter. We went long that
- first first half with Ben Alamar. Delightful conversation. Could have gone on for a while. Ben's always a fun
- conversation. We're we got to go about 15 minutes. Audi has to get the classroom. So, let's do a quick What
- caught your eye. There are obviously interesting things floating around. I think Audi might want to jump in here
- first. gentlemen around the world. >> I will jump in because because it's something that I've studied in general
- though not in specifics. It's the it's the judging fiasco in skating at the Olympics.
- >> Okay. >> And uh so I won't fill in all the details but suffice it to say the French
- judge um gave a very high score to the French competitors and importantly gave an extremely low score to the American
- competitors and it essentially completely reversed the order of the the competition. Which competition was this?
- >> And of course, this was the this is the doubles the mixed doubles skating competition. Um I forget exactly which
- version. And as you know, Shane's not here to scream and yell, but he'll he'll tell you that real sports aren't
- subjective, right? Um but of course, skating is a real sport and it's has judges and they have a format and
- typically you have a set of judges. each each make a score and then there's a then there's a a compet some sort of
- summary of the usually >> don't they trimmed uh >> No, I know they do that in diving. Um
- I'm not sure they do it in in skating. >> I thought they did it in skating. I thought they
- >> I think I think this I I I think this might be a niche skating competition, not the main skating competition. And I
- feel like they've really ironed out the main skating competition in a way that I
- mean I can tell you that uh >> it's like ice dancing or something instead of the actual Well, I think the
- ice danders would disagree whether or not it's niche or not. May not be the historically the most famous of the
- >> But Audi, there were full-on like communist block almost battles over this back years ago. I mean, the whole the
- whole meme of the Russian judge comes from that, right? >> Yeah. But this they ironed it out in
- some way. So, this must be >> Well, clearly they haven't because there's a controversy over this and I
- haven't looked at the data. But one of the things that I think as a statistician is interesting is the idea
- that you can essentially um establish an enormous bias you um I don't know what you want to call it other than that
- a if without having much data um if the delta is ex is exceptionally large relative to historical standards and I
- believe that is what happened here. I see. Well, let me just say I did look. They do prune. They prune the highest
- and the lowest. There's nine judges for both technical and whatever they call the other one aesthetics or whatever.
- They do prune the highest and lowest. So, one judge, even a French judge on a French team could not actually lift
- them, although it does remove margin of error if you want. It means, you know, that means the second score is going to
- count in some way much more than otherwise. So I'm not >> what would have been the max now becomes
- the second and that gets >> that's what I'm saying the distribution and score is different than the max.
- >> You're saying the delta you're saying between the top rated and lowest rating
- is that the delta you're talking about what delta >> delta delta is between the top and the
- bottom compared to the the overall panel average >> of the delta the panel average
- >> that's what I would call the delta. So there's a, you know, one of the one of
- the exercises that I've done with students is you can find a judge that only has two or three uh measurements
- where the he has a nationality match with his compatriate during the competition. And you can still
- nevertheless demonstrate pretty clearly that there is bias because he had he might have judged 40 or 50 skaters or
- divers or whatever competition you're looking at and his two highest differentials or delta are for when he
- made the match and that just has astoundingly small probability. >> Why don't they just knock out the judges
- rating their own nation? Why is that? That would be an interesting Well, you can't that easily because the nations
- with the largest competitors, United States or China, France, whatever it is, probably have more than one. And that
- would would um >> Well, don't give them more than one. There's plenty of nations with figure
- skating going on to have one per >> right from different >> Anyway, it's not done. At least not yet.
- >> Interesting. >> All right, Eric, what you got? >> Well, I got a brief one and then I I
- still want to emphasize again. I'm a big fan because I used to ski a lot. I'm a big fan of skiing and I want to say it
- again. So now Michaela Shiffren, the most celebrated women's downhill skier in the history of skiing. Matter of
- fact, of male or female, is now 0 and8 in her last eight Olympic races. And I just want to be clear, I don't mean 0
- and8 not winning the gold. I mean 0 and8 not even medlin. And so, look, I the good news is, let me say for her, she
- has two golds and a silver from the first three races she ever did in the Olympics. That's great. That's an
- extraordinarily accomplished career, but it's starting to get to the point where
- it is going to detract from her overall accomplishments as a skier. It's just going to This is
- about to be She has one race left. It's about to be the third straight Olympics where she will not win a medal. And
- >> so so in bet so the race is tomorrow's Wednesday slalom I believe her best >> her best event. So what is your bet?
- What probability do you give that she medals? >> I would say one/3. >> Okay. So it's distinctly below what her
- world ranking would suggest. below what her world ranking is, but still high enough that reflects that that is her
- best event and she's the best slalom women's slalom racer of all time. >> Uh, do you go you want you want above or
- below 33%. Who's you want to be above >> winning? Is this winning or meddling meddling? Mattling
- >> meddling. I want above it. >> I want to I want above it, too. So, you and I neither one are going as far to
- the to the >> I'm not Well, you know, we are not momentum guys. >> I'm a momentum person. I mean, let's
- just get a meme going here. >> Yeah, let's go. But let me talk about the topic I really wanted to talk about.
- >> So, no, no, hold on. We're real quickly on this point. Um, you guys are hardcore
- statisticians. Do you believe people that practice like performance coaches are a thing? Do you think that's
- a real Do you think they can Do you think they can substantively shift an athletes performance? A performance
- coach, a mental coach? God, you know what? I have nothing substantive to say on that on that
- statement. >> I I I don't know. >> Well done, Audi. Well done. That's good awareness.
- >> Do I think a performance coach can help someone perform at their maximum >> given also understanding there is
- interday variation and all of those things? Yes, I do. I I I do. I believe I didn't say that they can make them
- necessarily perform better, but can they make someone perform near their maximum
- maybe more consistently? Yes, >> that's that's yeah, that that's that's really well defined. You you
- operationalized it better. >> Yes, I think we should we should find we should find someone to come on and talk
- to us about that. You're hearing lots of between what's happened with Shiffron and the figure skater Ilia, what's his
- name? There's lots of talking about that. Eric, I've got to sneak mine in here before Audi goes away. Okay. So, if
- you want to linger for a minute, I'll get your second one. Let me let me put one in there that I that that I have for
- y'all in particular. >> I want to hire y'all. Y'all y'all do speaking, y'all do statistical
- consulting on occasion. I want to hire y'all. I run the Olympics and I'm worried about the the I think it's been
- kind of willy-nilly uh when events when when we get multiple versions of the same event and it's not clear to me why
- we should have multiple versions or maybe we should have more, maybe we should have fewer. So I want to know
- like is four the right number of downhill events to have. We have a downhill on one end, we have slalom on
- the other, but now we have a giant slalom, we have a super G. So we have four variations and I don't know I run
- the Olympics. Is four the right number? I mean is four too much? Should it be five? Okay, different var different
- question. Speed skating and this is this goes back to something Audi's complained
- about in the in the summer Olympics. How many different events there are with swimming. So speed skating, what is the
- right number of links to have? Not forget short track, just traditional speed skating. There's 500, there's
- thousand, there's 1500, 5,000, 10,000. And I I run the Olympics. I don't know. Are these speed skaters giving us all
- these extra races because they want more medals? Is it does it make sense? Or maybe we need even more. Maybe we need a
- 750 meter. I need y'all as statisticians to tell me how I should think about this,
- >> bro. So I can start with one way to think about it which which uh I know has is similar in track and it's certainly
- true in swimming is that there's a huge difference between the training the body
- type the skill of being distance to sprint and and the middle is also essentially its own it its own
- centroidid now and the reason why that's fascinating is that basically you have the elite in each of those three
- categories and they're almost always distinctly different people except for an occasional superstar can dominate in
- two over you know two adjacent uh lengths. So in swimming you can have someone who's good at the 400 and maybe
- the 800 >> Katy Leiddki >> Katy Leiddki is the only one who really comes to mind. Um, for example, uh, even
- in >> Okay, so now I I understand the theory. >> I've got a >> Okay, I understand that I I understand
- the >> I have a different I'm sorry. Let me just jump in quickly about different
- measure. A different measure would be let's imagine you could measure ability at different
- >> uh lengths. And let's imagine I'm just trying to operationalize this. Let's imagine the correlation between theta j
- and theta j + one where j indicates the length of the race was extraordinarily high. So that in some sense you might as
- well call it one winner because the ability is so correlated between the to me that would suggest a redundancy in
- races. >> So your what you did with your theta was the underlying ability it's theta j is
- that right? So it's all the different thetas for the the >> it's your theta was the underlying
- ability. You're going to estimate the underlying ability, but it's theta i. You're going to do underlying thetas for
- all the different skiers. And then you're going to do it for each of the different races. And you're going to ask
- how correlated the theta i's are across J's. So for for each skier, what their theta in an event, how is it
- correlate with their theta in another event? Do I have that right? That's that's a very clear
- That's what that's what my suggestion was. >> Okay. Okay. So So take take downhill. So
- um Audi, are you happy with that? And by the way, what what what would your criteria be? How how how would we know
- what's high or what's low? Like take the four downhill events and so how are we going to judge whether that's do we
- really need Super G or is it like you know the giant slalom is enough? That's the middle race. Super G was I think the
- last last comer. I'm just statistically or >> so now you want me to come up with a
- cutoff score you're saying? >> Well, I just want I'm asking Audi, I like the way you did that, but I want to
- know Audi, are you satisfied with that? I thought there might be a clust is clustering any different really than
- what Eric just suggested. >> I don't think so. I mean, it's complicated issue because there's also
- the marketing side of this. people want to see more events because it's just more fun, more opportunity
- >> and that really giant giantly competes. I mean I mean speed skating you might
- say is over is overly overly divided too many because think about Eric Heiden I think he won seven gold medals in um
- >> but he was making that many >> that was 46 years ago and one of the things they have said about this
- Wisconsin kid is that he was the first only the second ever to win both the 500 and the 1000. So that's Eric's
- correlation not being very high the 500 and 1000. So apparently that's a distinction between the short and the
- middle that's substantive. Okay, I'll let that go. I want to get your quick thoughts and we should probably cut odd
- out while >> Eric is going to give us another what he really want to talk about.
- >> Stay and I'll talk to you next week. Have fun in class. >> So I just had one more. So this number
- this statistic has been on my mind for weeks now because it's been true. So I'll have you guess for a second. So the
- Lakers by the way this year it's in the NBA of course have a very good record. They're 33 and 21. I think we'd agree
- that's a good record, right? >> Good. >> It's good. I didn't say it's great. I said it's good. It's a good record.
- They're actually winning I mean 54 games. Uh they're winning well more than 60% of their games. So they're playing
- well. >> Do you know what their point differential is, Kate? >> I'm guessing not very much.
- >> It's zero. >> This Okay. >> So I compare that to teams around them like the Nuggets,
- the Rockets, etc. their differential is like plus five. So over 50s something games those
- teams have more than a 300 like a 300 point differential and the Lakers have zero.
- >> So you're saying the average the average differential is.5. >> Yeah. The average per game. The average
- Yeah. per game. >> Well, this is this is Pythagorean. This is the Pythagorean. >> That's what I'm saying. This to me seems
- like a a significant deviation from Pythagorean where literally they're at zero, but somehow whether you could
- argue they're I mean there's two things that could cause us, right? They're winning a lot of close games and LeBron
- James is going to help you do that >> or they're getting blown out a lot in games, which is when they lose, they
- lose real bad. And by the way, that's cuz Luca hasn't played a lot of games. LeBron's injured. But all I'm commenting
- on is this is something actually next time I speak to you know Ben Alamar or you know Dean Oliver or somebody else on
- I'm going to I I'm going to ask him like how much does because again OKC let me just say by the way despite them having
- played 500 ball over the last 20 games. If we look over the almost 60 games of the season so far the season ended right
- now they would break the record their own record of last year for the greatest point differential in NBA history.
- per game. So at some level that has to say something. Just in the same way to me the Lakers being at zero means
- >> they're really 500ish but they just happen to be 33 and 21 unless someone tells me otherwise.
- >> One one version of this question would be is the Pythagorean theorem which comes out of Bill James. We talked about
- Bill in the first half the show is a Bill James thing but then it gets applied across all sports. It's
- basically just asking >> to what extent it's saying in a big sample your point differential is going
- to relate to your win record. And so we we kind of know whether someone's underperforming or under overperforming
- their um their um point differential. Um here's one version of the question, Eric. Might it mean less in basketball
- than other sports? I guess that's you've already hypothesized on why the Lakers might
- have a worse differential than their record would suggest because they've got a couple of players that are key and
- those players aren't playing as regularly and so they have these disproportionate negative point
- differentials when those guys are out. Might that be just kind of a hallmark of basketball these the load issues and the
- impact of a single player and stars? might all that suggest that Pythagorean would be less predicted than
- >> that's by the way that's an answerable uh empirical question and it's a good one. It's also one related to the topic
- we talked to Ben Alamar about in the first half. You you have a league with tanking and a team with resting players.
- You even mentioned resting players and you're you're going to get situations like here's here's you know here's an
- argument. What we're observing for the Lakers is a mixture distribution between the 80% of games they're trying, the 20%
- of games they're not. That leads to a breakage of the Pythagorean formula and it leads to a point differential of
- zero, but a massively winning record. >> Okay? And that that to me suggests that
- baseball I mean basketball needs these mixture distributions more than other sports do. Like you're not
- gonna get discreetly different distributions of team performance in the NFL like you will in basketball and
- you're certainly not going to get it in baseball either, right? So mixed distribut.
- >> Okay. So if that's the case then for sure it will be less meaningful a Pythagorean. It's almost like you need
- you need to have a mixture of your Pythagoreans. >> I order I like it actually. you in some
- sense you could fit you could imagine fitting a latent class or a mixture model unless you want to say for
- basketball you can kind of tell based on who they play which are the real games and which are the tank games you then
- fit a model separately or fit the formula separately to those two and then see what would happen. I think that
- would be a that would be something interesting. >> Well, it calls to mind uh when Nate
- Silver was publishing at 538, they had a basketball model. He probably still publishes a basketball model, but they
- had um a basketball power ranking and they had two versions of it, Eric. They had regular season and playoff. And they
- were re that's that's essentially the mixture distribution we're talking about. They're recognizing that there
- are there's a full strength team in the NBA and then there's some non full strength team and you need to understand
- them and model them separately. >> And just I know we're going to run out of time, but just one last thing to give
- a shout out for your Texas boy Scotty Sheffller. I mean this I don't care that he didn't win. It was great theater.
- This is the greatest in golf since Tiger Woods in like 2001. He's now got 18 top
- 10s in a row. I mean, come on. >> I mean, unbelievable. And you know, um, and it's amazing how great a golfer this
- man is. I just I and I was very happy to see Colin Maro win his first tournament
- in almost three years. you know, he won >> by age 24 and hasn't even won since then
- essentially. I was thrilled to see more win. But watching Sheffller blow three putts 5 feet or less and still shot a 63
- by the way, including making three Eagles. I don't think in my whole life of watching golf I've ever seen a golfer
- make three Eagles before in one single round of golf. I'm sure it's happened, but I'm just commenting that
- >> I think we we should appreciate Scotty Sheffller for who he is. And I'm gonna
- tell you, he's he's not Tiger Woods yet. Not even close. Let him do it for another five years. But I have no reason
- to believe he won't do it for another five years. And look, I don't know if he's getting to 15 majors. That's not
- fair. But he could easily get into the Gary Player, uh Tom Watson, you know, that that league of 8 to 10 majors. And
- I'm going to tell you something, this is a top 10 golfer of all time. He's great.
- that I I don't I don't disagree with any of that, Eric. It reminds me it makes me
- wonder about what other comparisons we can come up with. Um like we let's let's let's move beyond Tiger because Tiger is
- well within our adult memory and we lived that we lived it. We understand what that's like. There were a handful
- of great golfers in our lifetime, but we probably weren't paying enough attention
- and the metrics weren't there yet. And then there are a number of them before our lifetime. If what's if you go back
- and ask what's the best five-year run of golf in PGA history, like nine of the top 10 are Tiger. So, let's not do it
- that way. Let's do it. Let's do it at a golfer level and ask peak five years of the best 10 or 12 golfers in the history
- of golf and ask what does Scotty need to do or where to pick three years. Pick three years like Nicholas at his best,
- Watson at his best. How is Sheffer comparing to that? And let's let's let's stack up the historical golfers again.
- Tiger's going to be number one. And if we let him have multiple observations, he'd be the top 10. Yeah. But let's not
- do that. And let's just ask because we're not I want the next comparison. >> Yeah. I I'm going to give you that. But
- just one last thing. I think the thing that's amazing about Schoffler, besides he has 20 wins already in his career, he
- had his first one only four years ago. So let's just be clear. He's had a four-year run. That's incredible. I
- think it's fair to compare him to the three-ear stretch. Let's talk about recent golf. The four the 3 to four year
- stretch that Rory Maroy had when he piled up all those majors but hadn't still yet won the Masters. Remember he
- went 11 years without winning a major between ages 21 and 24. Rory Maroy cleaned up. Let's even say Jordan.
- >> How many wins How many wins did he have? >> That I don't know. But I'm guessing
- didn't come close to it's not close to 20. He might have had as many majors but I'm not even sure of that.
- >> No, no, we want we want the other as well. Well, this is a question like what's the criteria?
- >> Yeah, but you ask who are the other stretches? I would compare it to Rory Mroy during that stretch. Jordan speed
- that stretch. Those would be the >> he's going to be speed. No, no, it's going to be he's going to beat those
- guys. So, but it's it's not Tiger, but it's I want to know how he compares to Nicholas's best to Palmer's best and
- going further back like Hogan's best like what? >> I have that for you and I will announce
- it. Not next week. Maybe I will in the open segment, but I'm so excited about the Baseball Hall of Fame guy next week.
- But I will I will produce that analysis on request. >> Let's have a moment on the criteria and
- then we'll let it go. >> Um we've already decided it can't just be majors and it can't just be wins. It
- could be wins. It could be number of top tens, but we like wins and that's what they care about is wins. Um I don't
- know. We could have we could have the actual, you know, um uh scoring average below the PGA average.
- >> We're going to need multiple dimensions. >> Yeah. >> Um wins would be the easiest like the
- the probability of winning like the like the six month probability of winning. Um
- something like that. But anyway, fun conversation. We need to push beyond the tiger comparison. Um, I just want to
- know how and we have to we can't do it from memory is one of the things that my sense is. So, let's let's ask about
- Nicholas and Watson in their prime and a few others like that. Okay, why don't we
- wrap it there? That has been a full more than a full hour of sports analytics here on Wharton Moneyball for the whole
- team. Eric Bradloow who's been in here for the whole run. Audi Winer was here for almost all of it. Shane Jensen in
- Absentia, our friend and associate producer Dion Simkins who makes things happen around here, Marissa Raina, our
- producer, and Deep Patel, the boss lady. Many thanks to you guys for listening as
- well. Come back and join us next time between now and then. Enjoy your sports.
Brief Summary
Ben Alamar discusses NBA analytics, team performances, tanking strategies, and advocates for Dean Oliver's Hall of Fame induction.
Key points
- Exciting NBA Season. Ben Alamar discusses the thrilling developments in the NBA this year.
- Celtics' Surprising Strength. The Celtics are competing well despite injuries, making them a playoff threat.
- The Rise of a Juggernaut. A team built a powerhouse without free agents, relying solely on smart trades and drafts.
- Draft Dynamics Shift. Changes in lottery odds have altered team strategies, pushing more teams to tank for better picks.
- Eliminating the Draft. A radical proposal suggests eliminating the draft entirely to change player acquisition dynamics.
- Dean Oliver's Hall of Fame Case. A strong argument is made for Dean Oliver's induction into the Basketball Hall of Fame.
Episode highlights
- Exciting NBA SeasonBen Alamar discusses the thrilling developments in the NBA this year.“The NBA has been really pretty exciting this year!”3:11Feb 19, 2026
- Celtics' Surprising StrengthThe Celtics are competing well despite injuries, making them a playoff threat.“The Celtics could be a scary team with Tatum back!”4:19Feb 19, 2026
- The Rise of a JuggernautA team built a powerhouse without free agents, relying solely on smart trades and drafts.“They've built a juggernaut without free agents.”17:53Feb 19, 2026
- Draft Dynamics ShiftChanges in lottery odds have altered team strategies, pushing more teams to tank for better picks.“The odds have been flattened at the top of the lottery.”21:23Feb 19, 2026
- Eliminating the DraftA radical proposal suggests eliminating the draft entirely to change player acquisition dynamics.“The obvious way to eliminate the incentive problem is to just eliminate the draft.”22:30Feb 19, 2026
- Dean Oliver's Hall of Fame CaseA strong argument is made for Dean Oliver's induction into the Basketball Hall of Fame.“Dean Oliver belongs in the Basketball Hall of Fame.”32:54Feb 19, 2026
- Dean's Influence on Basketball AnalyticsDean Oliver's concepts revolutionized how teams analyze performance in basketball.“Dean brought these concepts in basketball on paper.”34:52Feb 19, 2026
- The Importance of EfficiencyUnderstanding shooting efficiency as a key metric in basketball performance.“Efficiency overall is points per possession.”36:32Feb 19, 2026





