Dishonesty's Slippery Slope

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Everyone cheats a little from time to time. But most major betrayals within organizations -- from accounting fraud to doping in sports -- start with a first step that crosses the line, according to Dan Ariely, a leading behavioral economist at Duke and author of The Honest Truth About Dishonesty: How We Lie to Everyone -- Especially Ourselves. That step can start people on a "slippery slope." In this interview with management professor Adam Grant, Ariely helps leaders understand how to prevent people from taking that first step, how to create a code of conduct that makes rules and expectations clear and why good rules are critical to organizations. πŸ“‚ Leadership

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I'm Adam Grant I'm here with Dan arieli leading behavioral Economist at Duke author of predictably irrational the
  2. upside of irrationality we're going to talk today about his newest book the honest truth about dishonesty Dan
  3. welcome my pleasure thanks thanks for inviting me Enlighten Us in organizations how common is
  4. dishonesty very common um but the the thing that is common is not big cheaters the common things are little
  5. cheaters and there's a couple of things that are special about organizations but
  6. but let's take one step back and ask the question about cheating um so what we find is that lots of people can cheat a
  7. little bit and what happens is that if we cheat a lot we face not being caught we Face the possibility that we will
  8. feel bad about ourselves so we play a game within ourselves you know sometimes we think about game theory is kind of a
  9. game between two parts is it's also a game within a person so you say to yourself I want to think of myself as
  10. good honest wonderful person and I selfishly want to benefit from this honesty and it turns out that you can
  11. cheat a little bit and still feel good about yourself so that is the general lesson that we find and just kind of to
  12. give you an estimation we ran experiments on cheating close to 50,000 people so far and we find a handful of
  13. big cheaters and we lost a few hundred dollars to Big cheaters and we we found more than 30,000 little cheaters and we
  14. lost tens of thousand 60 70,000 to the little cheaters so you know we think about the big cheaters but the reality
  15. is that the economic because there are few of them the economic activity that we need to worry about is all all the
  16. little cheaters okay so that's that's the first step now one of the things that happens in organization is that you
  17. get to observe bad behavior right and if you if you can think about there's something really asymmetrical about
  18. observing good behavior and observing bad Behavior so uh bad behavior uh when you see it it's incredibly Salient you
  19. see people behaving a certain way and then there's a chance that you would find that this is actually acceptable so
  20. imagine a consulting company that has a policy that says if you stay until 9:00 in the evening you get to order in
  21. dinner and get a black limo to come and pick you up to go home and and some people stay late and one person stays
  22. until orders food takes it with him at 9:01 he's downstairs this is incredibly sing to everybody that he waited 1
  23. minute he obeyed win the law and what happened in cases like this is very quickly everybody at 9:01 is gone it's
  24. clearly not fulfilling the goal of the organization it stays within the rules but really kind of abusing things and
  25. from there on you can see other deterioration so we see things like that happening all the time and in
  26. organization ations have this challenge of how flexible to make the rules so I've I've looked over the last few years
  27. at all kinds of code of conduct for different organization and I think they're all being put in place with good
  28. meaning but they're so fuzzy like we care about our customers we have fuci responsib you know they're so General
  29. then the range of gray zones within them allows good people to really uh misbehave by the way one of the
  30. interesting question is what is the role of leadership in all of that and to what
  31. extent can a leader change how people how people in the organization behave from from this
  32. perspective and I don't know um another interesting question is the question of whistleblowers um and I haven't studied
  33. whistleblower it's very tough and you know the US recently changed the regulation on whistleblowers so
  34. companies are now told to treat whistleblowers nicely and they also get a bigger share of what the US government
  35. recovers in in this new legislation but is this really what's going to to happen
  36. and I I get lots of emails from whistleblowers and with one exception they were all women and it's not that
  37. more women right to me than than men and and I think this is this will sound not
  38. nice but I think that it's easier for women to be whistleblowers because they don't start by being part of the boys
  39. club and everybody every whistleblower who wrote to me said that they basically become an outsider to society and they
  40. become an outsider to the people that they betrayed within the organization but also the regular friends stop
  41. trusting them and it's a really interesting thing right so I I I think of my kids I have two kids and when one
  42. of them come and say oh my brother or my sister did this I said I want you to solve the problem yourself right so even
  43. with didn't kids and I'm sure they might have legitimate concerns somehow appealing to a higher external Authority
  44. rather than solving things internally is offensive in terms of kind of how the system is created so so anyway um so I
  45. think businesses need to think about what is the code of conduct how specific versus General it is how is good
  46. behavior and bad behavior transmitted through Society to through their organization um and then what do we do
  47. with uh things like whistleblowers how do we how do we make it acceptable because you know whistleblowers come
  48. from time to time H but if they could come in earlier the organization might save themselves lots of trouble but by
  49. the time they everybody everything is waiting so long it could have be devastating now what's interesting about
  50. the whistleblowers actually is that they're sort of the CounterPoint in some ways to the little cheaters it would
  51. seem or are they in fact the same people so I don't know if they I don't know if
  52. those people who are uh whistleblowers are kind of pure people I doubt it uh right are they the people who never tell
  53. their spouse honey you look good in that dress or something like that or being socially polite and don't tell White
  54. Lies I don't think this is what what they are and um I'll tell you something else
  55. um we I've done lots of discussions with big cheaters inside trading accounting fraud people who've done um selling
  56. games in the NBA all kinds of things like that doping in sports and with one exception all of them were stories of
  57. slippery slopes all of them yeah you look you look at the sequence of the events you look at the end and you say
  58. my goodness what kind of monster would would do this but then you look at the first step they took and you say I can
  59. see myself under the right amount of pressure behaving badly and then they took another step another step another
  60. step um and I think most of organization go down a slippery slope rather than having some vicious vicious plan and the
  61. question is at that slippery slope at what point is it passing a threshold that somebody is saying something is
  62. really wrong here and in in some sense you have to not buy into the mindset of the slippery slope the
  63. question is how can you how can you actually get there how can you be an outsider to this so so I think that's
  64. probably the benefit the benefit is probably being an outsider and not not buying into this worldview of what's
  65. going on so so I'll give you one example um doping in sports think about cycling
  66. I talk to all kinds of cyclist who doped not Lance Armstrong um and and the story
  67. is basically one story was a guy who at some point got a an address for a physician from one of his team members
  68. and he went to that physician somebody with a white coat and a St scope and and that person gave him a prescription for
  69. the pharmacy and he went to the pharmacy and he got EPO which is a drug that increases the production of red blood
  70. cells it's a used for cancer treatment and his insurance paid for it and it because he got he had a prescription and
  71. he got the injections and he the first time he injected himself he was thinking about it but he said after that it just
  72. became part of his routine it was just one of the many many steps he was taking throughout the day vitamins do this do
  73. this do this but after he started doing that then he realized everybody was doing it
  74. and then they started doing it in public and then he moved to another team and in
  75. that team the people who were running the team were getting people to order what drugs they want in addition to EPO
  76. and moving from just EPO to another drug was very simple and then later on there
  77. was a shortage of epo but he knew some people from a Chinese his cycling team so they put him in touch with a factory
  78. that produces EPO and he imported it then he started selling drugs I mean you you could see how things go on
  79. eventually he was a drug dealer but but this is not how he started right and I think that's that's
  80. the issue and almost all the people I talked to again aside from one basically looked at the end and said how did they
  81. get there this is not me but when you're in it and if you remember when Lance Armstrong was in opra uh she asked him
  82. when you were in the middle of things did you feel you were cheating did you feel you were doing something wrong he
  83. said no and he sounded like a psychopath when he was saying that but from everything I know he was right he was
  84. truthful at that moment when you're in the midst of it you're in a very very different mindset and in your mind
  85. you're not a psychopath and you're not cheating you're doing what everybody else is doing and it's true that you
  86. don't talk about it but that's that's how things are getting done well that that slippery slope if you think about
  87. the idea of starting with a gate a drug and then falling down sort of this ladder of rationalization it if I'm a
  88. leader it makes me think a little bit differently about my role what I want to be doing is actually studying the cases
  89. where people have committed ethical or legal violations Looking Backward at where they started and then defining my
  90. code of conduct more clearly about those initial steps is that where you would come down I think exactly because you
  91. know if you think about that it means that the first step is incredibly dangerous because it's not just the
  92. first step and usually we say oh it's just a small step or it's just the beginning no it's it's not just the
  93. beginning it actually has tremendous ramification particularly if you think that it's an observable act so um as we
  94. were talking earlier I I recently came from a discussion of onor code in the military the Virginia Military Academy
  95. Navy and so on um and and there's a real tradeoff between a person is taking the
  96. wrong step how much do you punish them if you think about that person versus thinking about the organization and it's
  97. a very different story on actually you remember a Duke there was this big honor code violation so maybe seven years ago
  98. there was a big honor code violation at Duke lots of the students started the simulation from the same number so they
  99. ended up with the same results so they knew they were A coping from each other and at the time I was cheating I was
  100. cheating I was teaching just a little bit just a little and I was teaching at MIT uh and there was a story I think in
  101. the Wall Street Journal and and I I brought the story to the class and we were talking about the cheating Duke and
  102. the students said we do it all the time why why are you expelling those students
  103. and and I think they're probably right I think that the students I I don't know the case it was not I was not there at
  104. the time and also it's an owner code so it's a closed thing but I suspected those students did not understand and
  105. the seriousness of that what they were doing they were probably in a system where people were collaborating for a
  106. long time and there was deterioration and by creating this harsh punishment and eliminating lots of lots of students
  107. and you know giving them very very harsh punishment the students probably got a harsher punishment and they would
  108. deserve if you thought of them as individuals but for the organization it really helped because 6 years later it's
  109. really clear to the students what are the right and wrong levels and what do you step and don't
  110. step so I think there is this interesting tradeoff between the the benefit of the individual and what do we
  111. think about forgiveness versus what do we think about the cohesiveness of the organization and how clear the rules are
  112. yeah it's a classic question of of Retribution versus deterrence and it seems like in this case you're at least
  113. willing to air a little bit on the side of deterrence even if it unfairly punishes a few yeah I'm not sure I would
  114. call it deterrence but it would basically be for the strictness and Clarity of the rules for the clarity of
  115. what are the norms and what are the what's the right and wrong Behavior now this is this is a little bit frightening
  116. if we put together the different pieces of the puzzle that you've constructed if
  117. slippery slopes happen and most people are willing to cheat a little bit what do you do to prevent people from taking
  118. that first step yeah so so I think I think code of conduct are incredibly important for companies um but companies
  119. are wrong in how flexible they make these kind of code of conduct look like so um when you have a serious code it's
  120. easier to see if you're on the right or wrong side of it when you have something
  121. that is very fuzzy it's hard for us to see that we're violating it so think about something like Alcoholic Anonymous
  122. right the rule is very clear no drinking whatsoever what would happen if the rule
  123. was half a glass a day right we would get very big glasses you would drink today on account of tomorrow I mean
  124. there'll be all kinds of tradeoff and in general we don't like very clear-cut rules because we understand
  125. the exceptions we understand that we cannot create a good rule but good rules really help us and they help us to
  126. figure out for ourselves what's good and dieting by the way is the same thing if
  127. you have a clear rule about what you eat and don't eat it's really easy if every
  128. time you have to ask yourself about another Fork that's really really hard so if you think about the human brain as
  129. being a rationalization machine that is going to rationalize what's good for us in the short term not what's good for us
  130. in the long term and not what's good for the organization rules basically eliminate some of that ability to
  131. rationalize um and it's not that it's a Panacea right because if you create uh strict rules it it makes lots of things
  132. much more complex but I think we need those let's take a step back you're obviously widely admired for generating
  133. some fairly unusual and unconventional ideas mostly I'm admired by my mother and daughter those are the most
  134. important sources of AD admiration I would argue but where do your ideas come from so very infrequently from academic
  135. papers um mostly it's from uh talking to people and some some from reading the news and
  136. seeing something interesting but lots from talking talking to people and seeing what people are struggling with
  137. and what are some of the challenges and now um and you know in the last I don't know
  138. six years I'm also getting lots of emails from people who read stuff that I I wrote about and ask me question I'll
  139. give you one example um I got an email from a woman who told me that she was diagnosed with brain
  140. cancer and she asked me how to tell her kids so uh I I was a burn patient and I did studies on how to remove bandages
  141. remove them quickly remove them slowly and she made a connection and she said should she tell them all at once she
  142. tell them H over time now it's not exactly the same question as removing bandages so I didn't have an answer for
  143. this so I talked to all my physician friends nobody knew what is the right answer and I was in New York 10 days
  144. later so I met her for for coffee and we we discussed this because you know it's
  145. not something I feel comfortable and and eventually the conclusion was that if her kids ever found out that she
  146. was misleading them they'll be very hard to regain trust so maybe she should tell
  147. them all all at once but this question of how do you reveal bad news uh started started becoming very interesting for me
  148. this was about 3 years ago so now we have a big project in which we're following doctors around the hospital
  149. observing how they tell bad news to to patients really bad news cancer and the flight treatment stuff like that and
  150. trying to figure out what are the mistakes and what are the better ways uh to do that um so so things like that
  151. happened where you basically say my goodness this is a big question that people are struggling with we don't know
  152. the answer maybe we should try and figure it out and stuff like this is happening all the time well it sounds
  153. like paying attention then to the questions that come on your plate is is one source of ideas abolutely one
  154. question for me to close on uh behavioral economics has gained a lot of steam in the past decade it's I think
  155. one of the most probably popular scientific movements in history you are a behavioral economist yet you have two
  156. phds in Psychology and I've noticed frequently that my work get labeled as behavioral economics when in fact it's
  157. coming from a psychological perspective why is behavioral economics cooler than psychology when in fact often they're
  158. the same thing and what's the future of these two fields in your view yeah so so
  159. I'm not sure if it's cooler than psychology is the right is the right way um so here's the thing economics is both
  160. a descriptive and a prescriptive discipline it describes something about how people behave and
  161. then also tell policymaker and businesses how to conduct things and I think for a long time psychology has
  162. basically stayed on the descriptive side here's how people behave and economics has gained tremendous effect impact
  163. because of the prescriptive side of things and behavioral economics in my mind is basically a counteraction to
  164. that right so if if um economic uh academics would have stayed within the University
  165. I don't think anybody would want to attack them I mean everybody's entitled their own Theory right I mean why not
  166. attack people in philosophy or history I mean you can attack lots of other people
  167. and we're really not attacking economics in the disciplinary sense of you know economics is a beautiful field of study
  168. it explains maybe 30% of the human variant it's great but when you take this Theory and you say this is it and
  169. this is everything and now you should build Bridges and cities or you know the equivalent tax system and Health Care
  170. Systems and so on based on that now it becomes dangerous so behavioral economics in my mind is not against the
  171. economic discipline as much as the application of fa and I I'm actually hopeful that we're not going to debate
  172. each other because that's there's really no no much point in this we really need
  173. to be empirical so the point about behavioral economics is the truth is we have to be a bit more modest we don't
  174. know that much the world is much more complex and we should be open to admitting that we don't know and we
  175. should do experiments and I'm imagining a future in which every discipline does its own
  176. thing but when we come to policy No Child Left Behind taxes Healthcare whatever every discipline says here is
  177. what I think are the important things and here is how what I think is the right setup and together we build the
  178. right experiments and we see uh what's working so I I'm hoping that we'll get a field of
  179. experimental social science that will be used for government will be used for businesses and so on
  180. and the input for it could be everything right why why not have philosophy and why not have sociology and anthropology
  181. and psychology and economics it's all it's all perfectly fine so that's my U wishful thinking for the future I think
  182. it's an exciting Vision let's bring great thinkers together let them collaborate on the design of experiments
  183. agree on the outcomes in advance and then let the best policy win that's right thank you Dan my pleasure
  184. [Music]

Brief Summary

Dan Ariely discusses small cheating in organizations and the importance of clear conduct codes to prevent dishonesty.

Key points

  • The Honest Truth About Dishonesty. Dan Ariely discusses the prevalence of dishonesty in organizations and its implications.
  • Whistleblowers: Outsiders in Society. Ariely shares insights on the unique challenges faced by whistleblowers.
  • The Importance of Clear Codes of Conduct. Ariely highlights the need for specific rules to prevent unethical behavior.
  • The Slippery Slope of Cheating. Ariely explains how small unethical actions can lead to larger violations.
  • The Future of Experimental Social Science. Imagining a future where various disciplines collaborate on policy experiments.
  • Interdisciplinary Collaboration. Advocating for the inclusion of diverse fields in social science.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes