How U.S. Companies Legally Cut Tariffs Through Supply Chain Strategy

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Wharton professor David Zaring explains the "First Sale Rule," a legal method for U.S. importers to reduce tariffs by paying duties on the initial transaction in a global supply chain. With rising tariffs, companies are revisiting this long-standing rule, which allows importers—like major retailers sourcing products abroad—to reduce costs when transactions are well-documented and structured through intermediaries. Zaring highlights challenges like transparency between middlemen and importers, the rule’s legal foundation since the 1980s, and how complex global supply chains open the door to tariff-saving strategies.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week. Subscribe on Apple Podcasts: https://whr.tn/3EdpB5X Subscribe on Spotify: https://whr.tn/4ihHaiT

#Tariffs #SupplyChain #GlobalTrade #ImportExport #InternationalBusiness ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Dan Loney: Well, as you hear companies report their quarterly earnings statements, you're hearing them talk quite a bit
  2. about the impact of tariffs, but there may be a workaround that some companies are focused on. It's called first sale rule, and
  3. it is helping to ease some of the financial impact for firms. David Zaring is a Professor of Legal Studies and Business
  4. Ethics here at the Wharton School. David, great to talk to you again. How are you, sir? David Zaring: I'm doing well. How are you?
  5. - I'm doing well. Thank you for doing this. This is obviously a very unique time for so many businesses because of the
  6. tariffs and how they are impacting, but this idea of this first sale rule was something that I hadn't heard about. It's
  7. being brought up more and more by companies. Kind of give us an idea as to what exactly it is.
  8. - The first sale rule basically provides that, for certain kinds of transactions, you can only pay a tariff on the first sale
  9. in the supply chain, rather than on the amount that is paid when the product is imported. So, you know, an example might be a t
  10. shirt manufactured in China and then sold to a Hong Kong middleman, and then the Hong Kong middleman sells it to an
  11. American retailer, and the retailer sells it in the store. And the first sale rule provides that the tariff need only be
  12. paid on the sale between the Chinese manufacturer and the Hong Kong middleman, rather than the sale of the Hong Kong -- from
  13. the Hong Kong middlemen to the importer in the United States. - And that's the trick of it, that you have to have that third
  14. entity kind of involved in the process. - Yep, you need to be well documented, and you need a
  15. supply chain. You need multiple sales and you need the product to be made for sale in the United States.
  16. - So you mentioned the documentation. Is that kind of a challenge, or, you know, an element that could be a trip up
  17. for some of these companies if they don't have that real good documentation to be able to, you know, claim that lower cost
  18. number so that they don't have to pay more on the tariff side? - Yep, that is an issue. It's sort of bureaucratically simpler to
  19. just pay the tariff on the basis of what the end user pays for it to get it into the United States. And the first sale rule
  20. requires those end users to sort of keep their supply chains open, clear, and documented, so that they can instead pay the
  21. tariff on the basis of the sale from China into Hong Kong in our example. And you know, that can present some challenges. Maybe
  22. the Hong Kong middleman doesn't want to tell you how much they paid for the t shirt in China. You can see business
  23. reasons why they may not want to share that information with their customers, but they have to if the customer is going to
  24. take advantage of the first sale rule. - But from the business perspective here in the United
  25. States, this process is legal as long as you kind of follow along a lot of these processes that we've just laid out here.
  26. - Yep, it's legal. It's been legal since the early '80s, and some people went to court to try to clarify that the first sale rule
  27. was an accurate interpretation of American customs laws. They won that legal challenge, and so the first sale rule's
  28. been around ever since, and that's how it sort of works. It's this sort of interpretation of Congress's
  29. basic tariff statute. And since then, importers have been able to take advantage of the first sale rule, you know, given
  30. that documentation and everything else. - And so right now, when you're talking about a time where
  31. tariffs are seemingly at the forefront of a lot of conversations, this can be a very important cost savings for
  32. a lot of firms, especially if they're doing it this way. And even if they're not, maybe this is a new path for them to think
  33. about, you know, ways to import product. - Yeah, I think that's right. There's two ways in which
  34. importers can really benefit from the first sale rule. For starters, the really big tariffs that are being imposed on the
  35. nation's borders, those are going to be reduced if you only have to pay tariff on the first sale. It's also a way of maybe,
  36. if your supply chain is set up this way and is bona fide, works this way, to pay a lower tariff. So, you know, there's very high
  37. tariffs in China for stuff that comes into China, and there may be lower tariffs for stuff that comes from other countries. And
  38. so if a Chinese manufacturer sells to a, you know, Vietnamese middleman or something like that, then the American retailer
  39. who eventually ends up importing the good may pay a much lower tariff because they're paying the -- they're not
  40. paying the Chinese tariff. - Right, right. And that's the other thing, is that, in terms of
  41. those supply chains, this seemingly has the opportunity not to force companies to have to maybe change how they
  42. are getting product. They are able to work through this kind of path to be able to still get the products that they need.
  43. - That's right. And, you know, companies that can sort of document the supply chain sales carefully can take advantage of
  44. this to, you know, lower their tariff payments, you know, in an era of higher tariff payments.
  45. - Do we know how frequent this type of of path is used by companies, and is this something that we may see more of,
  46. especially if we're in more of a tariff environment, especially over the next several years?
  47. - Yeah, I think there's increasing interest in this sort of thing. And I was looking around to see, there's been a few law firm
  48. memos that have been sort of -- you know, firms are like, "We can work with you on trying to make sure that you can take advantage
  49. of this rule to the extent you possibly can." So I predict we'll see more of this in the future. It's generally something that I
  50. think has been really interesting about American companies, is the supply chains are often
  51. really long and involve lots of different countries and different aspects of, you know, the manufacturing process. And
  52. so if you can get to the bottom of what's going on in your supply chain, there's all these things you can do. You can worry
  53. a little bit about the climate impact of your supply chain. That's been controversial. You can sort of end up dealing with
  54. different kinds of rules about countries of origin in your supply chain, depending on where things come from. And then you
  55. may be able to take advantage of this for sale rule to lower your overall tax compliance. And all of this is a function, I think,
  56. of the fact that supply chains have gotten so global. And, you know, goods that are ultimately manufactured, it's almost hard
  57. to say where it is they were made because of the way -- you know, we hear this about cars as so much of it, the value added
  58. comes from Canada, Mexico, and the United States, and all pulled together and then involving the assembly of parts
  59. made all over the world. - You mentioned t shirts, but are there -- just off the top of your
  60. head, are there products that seemingly, like potentially card, that are maybe even built for a process like this? - Yeah,
  61. if anything, I think for sale rule, might be Walmart's closest, you know, that might be the company that
  62. might be able to take the most advantage of it. What you're kind of looking for is a consumer product designed for
  63. sale in the United States, assembled somewhere else, with a middleman involved. And so that's what you're really
  64. looking for. And so it's those retailers, in particular, that are selling consumer goods and that were
  65. made for the American market, but made somewhere else. If their supply chain has a couple of links in it, they can take
  66. advantage of the first sale rule. And I think those are the companies that might be most able to take advantage of this
  67. kind of rule. - David, great to talk to you and get your insight. Thank you, sir. - Happy to do it. - You got it. David Zaring, Professor
  68. of Legal Studies and Business Ethics here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

David Zaring explains how the first sale rule helps companies reduce tariffs by paying only on the initial sale in the supply chain.

Key points

  • Understanding the First Sale Rule. The first sale rule allows tariffs to be paid only on the initial sale in the supply chain, potentially saving companies significant costs.
  • Legal and Financial Implications. The first sale rule has been legal since the early '80s, allowing importers to reduce tariff payments if they follow proper documentation.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes