How Understanding Customer Segments Helps Brands Grow Stronger

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW Wharton marketing lecturer Annie Wilson explains how brands face challenges when different customer segments have incompatible expectations. In her and Tyler Wry's book, The Growth Dilemma, they highlight how segmentation, identity signaling, and brand architecture affect long-term growth. The conversation explores frameworks for managing segment relationships, the risks of ignoring value-based segmentation, and how AI can assist in identifying emerging conflicts.

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect.

#GrowthMarketing #MarketingStrategy #BrandGrowth #Segmentation #BrandBuilding ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Annie Wilson: I think AI could be a useful way of testing whether there's a likelihood of conflict. First, it's a great
  2. way to measure and test the values different segments get from your brand, which segments exist, what values do they care
  3. about? How are they talking about you on social media? You could pick up on conflict sooner, do scenario planning
  4. with it, create separate messaging with it for different segments. I think it could be a really useful tool for
  5. preventing and managing conflict if it does occur, for sure. Welcome to <i>The Ripple Effect</i>,
  6. the podcast that takes you on a journey through the minds of Wharton faculty. I'm your host, Dan
  7. Loney, and in each episode, we'll be diving deep into the inspiration behind the groundbreaking research that
  8. Wharton professors have conducted and exploring how their findings resonate with the world today.
  9. There has been an increasing importance on brand companies are thinking about more and more these days. And part of that focus comes from a
  10. wide range of needs by consumers. That means that different people are wanting different things from their
  11. brands. So how do you ensure the necessary level of growth as a company, with so many kind of chefs in the kitchen? Pleasure
  12. to be joined right now by Annie Wilson. She is a co-author of a new book about this topic. The book is titled <i>The Growth</i>
  13. <i>Dilemma: Managing Your Brand When Different Customers Want</i> <i>Different Things</i>. Annie, along with her colleague Ryan
  14. Hamilton, wrote this book. Annie is a Senior Lecturer in Marketing here at the Wharton School. Annie, great to talk to
  15. you today. How are you? I'm good. Thank you so much for having me. How are you? I'm doing very well. And I've kind of sensed this change and felt more
  16. of a greater focus on brand as well, with some of the things that we've seen go on. But you take it from a very unique
  17. perspective of how companies are trying to assess a lot of this because of what the consumers want. Give us more.
  18. Yeah, absolutely. I mean, I think the— the sort of conversation between, should we focus on brand or sales or performance
  19. marketing, as it's sometimes called, has been a long conversation in marketing and in business in general. But I think
  20. recently, we've seen this greater imperative to focus on brand because of how big brands are struggling as a result of
  21. kind of taking their focus off of brand for a while. We see this with Nike. We see this with Starbucks. Kohl's might be
  22. another recent example. And so the approach we're taking is also focusing on brand at the segment level. So not just
  23. thinking of your brand as this monolithic thing that all consumers are going to want the same thing from it and think of
  24. it in the same way, but that actually, different segments might care about different things from the brand, and that
  25. might be one of the drivers of fragmentation or brand dilution. So what are these specific segments? Because you have
  26. four of them, I believe, in the book. So the segments are different for every brand. But we talk
  27. about four different relationships between segments. So segments can relate to each other by what we refer to as
  28. separate communities. So they want different things from the brand, but they're fine with the other community also using the
  29. brand. If you think about Timberlands, for example, you have hip-hop fans and you have workers. They both know that
  30. each other uses Timberlands, and they're totally fine coexisting in the Tim space. You could have an example at—
  31. - at Wharton. You have students who go to Wharton and students who go to the college in various majors. They know
  32. about each other, they don't care about each other. They coexist, even though they want different things from the
  33. university. We then have connected communities. So this is when segments rely on each other to create value, but they
  34. don't really care about who each other are. So think about if you're on LinkedIn, there may be people from different
  35. industries. There are different people on LinkedIn that you're not connected to. You don't necessarily care about. They use
  36. it for different purposes, but the fact that more people are on it is still better for you. So you're connected in this
  37. interdependent way. You then have leader-follower. So which is, one segment uses the brand, which attracts another segment
  38. to it. So the fact that this cooler, smarter, more athletic, professional, wealthier segment uses the brand makes everybody
  39. else who wants to be like them use it. This happens a lot in luxury and in sports, too. And then you have incompatible
  40. segments, which is the fact that one segment's using the brand doesn't work with another one. They either want to use it in a
  41. different way. They think of the brand differently. There's something that— they cannot coexist within the brand
  42. ecosystem. And that's where that growth dilemma happens, when there's that incompatibility.
  43. And so for the companies that are dealing with this, I don't think this is a relatively new concept that they've had to deal with,
  44. but obviously there's a great deal more focus on a lot of these components, correct? - Absolutely.
  45. and it's— you're right. It's not a new concept. But you see, as the pressures to grow and grow quickly are increasing, that the
  46. problem is presenting itself sooner in the— in the corporate history. And because consumers come and go between brands a lot
  47. faster than ever before, and there's more and more competition, there's lower barriers to entry across
  48. virtually all industries, it makes the problems more consequential for brands. So you mentioned about Timberland, where you can have a
  49. product where two totally different segments will use the product, and they'll get along, and there's really not a
  50. competition. There are instances where there are— there is competition within the brand, and maybe the two sides don't
  51. like it, that one side is using it over the other, correct? Yeah, absolutely. And that can be for different reasons. So one of the
  52. most famous examples is with Starbucks, with the "third placers" and the "on-the-go's", or the commuters. If I use
  53. Starbucks because I want coffee quickly and I want to place my mobile order and get in and out, that doesn't create a nice
  54. environment for the third placers. So they have to find a way for them to coexist. Another example, sort of like Tim's,
  55. could be Supreme, where if skaters want to use Supreme to signal their skater identity, and then all of a sudden, a
  56. bunch of wannabe hypebeasts and fashion followers use it, that erodes the brand for the skater community. So it actually takes
  57. something away from them for them to use it. So how does a company then balance all of these things going on
  58. when that level of growth, that bottom line growth, is the most important thing that the company is looking for, and obviously
  59. the board of directors and in many cases the investors is looking for? - Yeah. I mean, that's— that's the big challenge. And I think you see
  60. that with these big companies now that are struggling with this, is that, in all likelihood, it's going to take
  61. some stepping back to move forward. I actually see—what I've observed is the companies that handle the growth dilemma
  62. very well are those that are not under this intense pressure to grow quickly. Berkshire Hathaway companies, for example, do a
  63. great job of growing within kind of a latitude of acceptance slowly over time to attract different types of customers.
  64. For those who do want to grow more quickly, it's about being more selective about the segments you grow to, knowing
  65. your brand, understanding what customers value and whether those values are compatible with each other or not, and being
  66. smart of knowing when to attract a customer and when to let them go in terms of segments. Or orchestrating them in creative
  67. ways. So with Timberlands, they keep the different groups separate from each other. They have different social media
  68. handles, different marketing, different product lines. You see that with Starbucks and the— you know, the drive-throughs and
  69. then the roastery or reserve coffee shops designed for the third placers. You're sort of separating them. Or you create
  70. hierarchy. So you say, "This segment is wealthier and higher status, so they're going to have access to certain products that
  71. this segment doesn't." And then that makes— keeps everybody kind of happy when those segments come in.
  72. So it sounds like the recognition of a lot of these dynamics is one of the important keys to try and find that growth longer term.
  73. Absolutely. And I think the problem has many origins, but one of the common origins is just not engaging in proper segmentation as a brand,
  74. or not using value-based segmentation. So thinking, "Okay, we're going to target Gen Z," and then not foreseeing how they
  75. might conflict with another segment, because that's not a useful way to think about the segment. Because it's really
  76. about whether the values or what they want from the brand are compatible or not.
  77. You mentioned the leader- follower, which caught my attention. I wanted to bring that up as well. And I guess to
  78. a dynamic, is that part and parcel with what we're seeing kind of in our world right now, with kind of the influencer
  79. community? Influencers are obviously connecting with different products. Then their followers see it, and that's
  80. where you're seeing some of that growth come from. So it's interesting, because influencers are— can be a leader
  81. segment or not. So if someone is clearly paid to endorse or use a product, or they're really representing just themselves,
  82. they usually don't represent a full leader segment. But when it feels like a segment of celebrities or athletes or
  83. wealthy people use a brand—so Beats headphones is a good example. Yes, some of the athletes are paid to use Beats,
  84. but it also is a whole segment of professional athletes that love Beats, which makes people like me, who want to feel like
  85. Tom Brady before I go into teach, want to use Beats headphones. And so it does have to feel like a true segment. It
  86. can't just be, "Oh, Tom Brady was paid to tell me he likes these." How does a company then deal with the scenario you also lay out
  87. where you have incompatible segments? That— I would think that would be the— that would be the largest challenge for them.
  88. Yes, always better— you know, an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. That's true in marketing too. I think, yeah, in
  89. that case, you have to find ways to separate them, create that hierarchy, or potentially fire a customer segment. Which can feel
  90. scary, but sometimes the best thing to do is say "We have to choose the segment we're for and the segment we're not for." A big
  91. mistake I see brands make over and over again is they find themselves in conflict, and so they try to just serve both. You
  92. saw this with Bud Light a couple years ago. You see this with Target right now, where they got themselves in a political
  93. conflict between segments, and they responded with a— sort of, "Well, we don't know which side we're gonna pick." So then
  94. both segments said, "Okay, well, you're not for us." And then they're— they're leaving in droves. Usually you have to pick one.
  95. But seemingly this is a new norm, then, larger scale, for a lot of companies as we move forward. This is not something
  96. that is kind of in this moment in time. This is kind of here. Companies are going to have to continue to work with it in
  97. order to find that growth. We're not going to go back, you know, maybe several decades, to before we saw a lot of these segments
  98. coming— coming to the forefront. - Absolutely, and that's driven by a few things. I mean, first is the
  99. information channels we use are more porous than ever. So you can't put something in a special interest magazine and assume no
  100. other segment will see it. If you put it on social media, it could surface in anyone's algorithm, and then it can be
  101. reposted and shared and, you know, made into a bigger deal much more easily. We use brands and products more as identity
  102. signals than ever before, whether it's to reflect my skater identity or my, you know, cool athlete identity or my
  103. political affiliation, so that's going to increase the risk of incompatibilities. And as I said, the barriers to entry are
  104. pretty low across a lot of industries now, which means one brand's conflict could be another brand's opportunity. I
  105. see you're ignoring a segment, or you've done something that's bothering one. Well, I'm going to then pick them off, because I
  106. can actually serve them better and more clearly. Does artificial intelligence start to come into the conversation here
  107. with this because of— I mean, certainly AI is in so many different things right now. But you would think about the
  108. influence that it could potentially have with potentially having a connection with the consumer or not as we
  109. move forward. - Yeah, absolutely. I think AI could be a useful way of testing whether
  110. there's a likelihood of conflict. First, it's a great way to measure and test the values different segments get
  111. from your brand. Which segments exist? What values do they care about? How are they talking about you on social media? You
  112. could pick up on conflict sooner. Do scenario planning with it. Create separate messaging with it for different
  113. segments. I think it could be a really useful tool for preventing and managing conflict if it does occur, for sure.
  114. What do you hope that— that will come forward from this book that you and Ryan have put to— put forward? What's the message that
  115. you would like to send out? Our hope is that brand managers will focus more specifically on
  116. managing brands at the segment level, rather than across the whole customer ecosystem, or thinking about the brand and the
  117. customer relationship, but also recognizing that customer groups relate to each other in unique ways, and those dynamics between
  118. customers are essential to pay attention to. That's been a pretty overlooked gap in a lot of marketing research, and it's
  119. something we're hoping to draw more attention to. And to offer the tools to do it. - Which becomes
  120. important because of how much there has been a focus on the relationship with the customer, especially in the last several years.
  121. Yeah, absolutely. And so part of that customer relationship management is— we call it segment relationship management. So you
  122. have to manage the relationship between the brand and the customer, but also between the customers as well.
  123. Annie, great to have you with us today. Thanks very much for your time. Thank you. - Annie Wilson,
  124. who is a co-author of the new book <i>The Growth Dilemma, Managing Your Brand When</i>
  125. <i>Different Customers Want Different Things.</i> Thank you for listening to <i>The Ripple Effect</i>.
  126. If you enjoyed this episode, you can find more insightful conversations by subscribing to
  127. the Wharton School's <i>Ripple Effect</i> podcast on your favorite podcast platform.

Brief Summary

Annie Wilson discusses brand management and consumer segmentation in her book <i>The Growth Dilemma</i> and the role of AI in conflict prevention.

Key points

  • AI in Brand Management. Annie Wilson highlights how AI can help brands anticipate and manage conflicts among consumer segments.
  • The Growth Dilemma. Annie Wilson discusses her new book on managing brand expectations across diverse consumer segments.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes