Profiting from The Data Deluge
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
In a new paper titled, "Closing the Marketing Capabilities Gap," Wharton professor George Day addresses the gap between the demands of markets and the ability of firms, especially their marketing functions, to meet those demands. Such a gap, he points out, is "costing firms profitability now and competitiveness in the future." Using Day's paper -- and also a new IBM study -- Day and colleague David Reibstein talked with Knowledge@Wharton about the growing flood of data, new knowledge sharing technology, the socially networked and ever demanding consumer, and how some companies are successfully building their customer base, among other topics. π Marketing
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- [Music] [Music] we're here today with marketing Professor George day to talk about his
- new paper closing the marketing capabilities Gap and which he discusses the Deluge of data that companies are
- faced with as they try to meet the challenges of marketing over the next decade joining us in this discussion is
- marketing Professor David rebstein Dave and George thanks for joining us George your paper is called closing the
- marketing capabilities Gap what exactly is that Gap and why is it so important that companies address it you know as I
- reflected on the title I'm beginning to think a better title would be narrowing the uh Market capabilities Gap the Gap
- is a uh consequence of two things what you might call the data Deluge the information explosion where we have a
- doubling of the amount of data not information necessarily or wisdom but the amount of data stored every 18
- months and so this is an exponential increase in the data available to companies at the same time is our best
- guess on the ability of companies to actually use this data converted into information then act on it is growing at
- about 2% a year so that's the Gap that uh I'm looking at here so we're we're overwhelmed uh we're confused with uh uh
- the consequences of term I love which is the Splinter net uh and the fragmenting
- media the tremendous uh decomposition of mass markets into little niches and of course media choices uh are
- proliferating rapidly it's all quite overwhelming to companies and and and by the way individuals we're all I think uh
- struggling with this uh tremendous overload Dave what are what are the traps that companies fall into trying to
- manage all this data well one of the things that I think is really interesting is thinking about the
- history of of how this Gap happened because what George was just referring to which is absolutely right is this
- huge proliferation of choices that customers have options that companies have and then the abundance of data but
- let's back up just a little bit and think about who was in marketing and who's been sort of doing this in the
- past and many of much of it has been people that have risen up through sales and have a sales orientation they were
- very good interpersonally very good at sort of working and talking to customers um or they were people that sort of
- could identify and feel what the customer felt but what's happened is we don't need to rely on sort of the the
- pearls of the tongue um or the empathy that the marketer needs it really is we have
- information and so the new marketer today is very different than the marketer of the past and I think you
- know one of the traps is sort of falling into doing things the old way and trying
- to unlearn the way that uh that we used to doing marketing and today it is so much more just data
- driven so there both there there's so many new developments in in knowledge sharing technology like microt targeting
- and communities of users and all the social networking tools what are the best examples of these Technologies and
- who is using them in the most advantageous ways George you might want to answer that well uh let let me set
- the uh the frame for uh a broader way of thinking about how companies cope and then see how they're a able to take
- these Technologies I think two ideas one is that technology is creating the problem it's also going to be the
- solution to the problem so social networking knowledge sharing many Googles that companies are creating for
- their own databases are obviously the path to the solution but it'll only work if the organization is inclined to use
- them and prepared to use them so I uh am am looking at three different capabilities
- that companies will need in order to effectively use all this new technology for sorting through sharing and
- interpreting data uh first one is uh what I call Vigilant Market learning that is the ability to uh see things
- sooner to capture the right information as opposed to uh being a treating all information as equally important sorting
- out which signals are you really should pay attention to that's a significant capability requires
- very curious leadership highly networked and so forth second uh is the Adaptive notion of adaptive Market
- experimentation this is a capability companies have to master and uh whether it's B2B B Toc it's companies like
- Quicken doing 600 experiments every year with their customers and learning system atically
- from it so uh we we have a lot of interesting tools on Predictive Analytics and so forth uh that our
- colleagues uh uh Pete fader and Eric bradow are working on here to to try to unlock that uh the lessons from those
- experiments uh but the other thing that uh I think is important about companies that use these tools well is that they
- don't try to do it all themselves and uh what I've been fascinated with is what I'm now calling open marketing which is
- uh a direct lift from open Innovation and this is the notion that if you want to do search engine optimization or
- Predictive Analytics it's probably not a good idea to try to build that capability inhouse
- rather you find a really good partner who is able to help you with this to apply this and and by the way has the
- right kind of talent because the reason I think that you have to partner in is that the talent is very hard to find um
- so in an era of high unemployment there's a desperate need for qualified creative analytical people kind of the
- two ideas coming together but we have we have a talent crisis and companies are struggling to find people to do that the
- answer I think is to find the right Partners but where do you who are these partners are they other companies are
- they individuals that you that you hire they will array from uh and and the the IBM study that you talked about uh asked
- about potential partner R so there's 12 kinds of Partners at least uh anywhere from Specialists one two three four
- person uh specialists in Predictive Analytics all the way to one of the big three integrated advertising agencies
- which has got a host of creative shops marketing research firms and with the with the specialized Talent built into
- them that they can spread across and build experience in lots of different situations yeah so you asked uh Robbie
- specifically who's doing a good job of trying to use you know the new tools and trying to take advantage of it and
- George mentioned Quicken um let me add to that um I would say Amazon Falls in that category of they're constantly
- experimenting and the web page that you get and the web page that I get are uh might be very very different not just
- based on our history but because we're coming in and they're going to try something different and it's it's a
- whole test and learn mentality I'm going to test something out see what works deploy it and that could happen all
- within the same day and in fact you could be doing hundreds of these every day where I'm going to test so you buy a
- blue sweater I buy a blue sweater you come back and they're going to give you a yellow sweater and see if
- you're going to do it and that's what it is that sort of is being featured and for me they're going to give me you
- know a uh what would go well with the blue sweater black slacks and they're going to see so which works better
- quickly do that with a couple thousand people learn from that deploy in fact in your in your paper George you quote Jeff
- Bezos as saying rather than ask what we're good at what else can we do with that skill you ask who are our customers
- what do they need and then you say we're going to give that to them regardless of
- whether we have the skills to do to to do so and we will learn those skills but Amazon has the luxury of being able to
- do these millions of tests to find out what consumers need even before consumers know what they need other
- companies don't have there there's an interesting property that Amazon has and other companies have that that are
- taking advantage of this ability which is dealing with customers individually so there's lots of companies that sell
- through Distributors who sell to other Distributors and are not really in touch with the End
- customer um Amazon is in touch with exactly who their ultimate customer is and and there's lots of businesses
- certainly online businesses have that ability but actually if you think about it cellular companies have that ability
- um because they know exactly who that individual customer is banks have that so companies that have the individual
- level data which take back to the earlier problem the problem is this abundance of data right and the question
- is who's able to really take advantage of it now let me go to The Other Extreme which is take a company like
- Unilever Unilever sells through distributors or for the big retailer sells directly to retailers so either
- Distributors to retailers or directly to retailers who end up selling then to Consumers and they don't have that
- individual consumer level data but what they have started doing and doing it I think very effectively is working on a
- lot of social media so the whole Dove campaign that got tons of publicity and everything was all something that was
- primarily created online and they created ads that were never shown on broadcast television and it was really
- for this spread through YouTube and through other social media that really allowed them to reach a
- massive audience and it been very clever for a company that doesn't have that individual level data well let me ask
- George let me there's a follow-up question to that so consumers are obviously increasingly vocal chatty uh
- they get online and they're constantly spreading their opinions about products and services how can companies figure
- out which comments are important and need immediate action and which are just noise there's a lot of interesting
- technology uh to first of all capture these blog comments and then edit them and see if there's patterns so
- if if you go on to Google you you can see patterns of recurring use of a term and what you're looking for is literally
- clearing out all of the noise and concentrating on what's the what's the signal that we really want to look at
- and it might be a uh a complaint about product performance I remember one of the very earliest ones uh was a an
- experience Proctor and Gamble had is they brought out remember fabr yes so everybody knows for Breeze almost failed
- because early in its launch a woman got on blogged and said FaZe killed both of my
- canaries and uh you know this spread through the uh the internet uh Proctor had a very good uh way of capturing that
- they figured out who she was because they sent an email said can what can we do uh they rushed A team out talked to
- her and uh after a while discovered and she agreed the carries just canaries died of old age coincidentally so but
- that uh meant that they were able to stop that uh really threatening uh message going out over the toxic effects
- of deze and they actually turned it into an opportunity on the internet and and it's it's that ability to capture these
- signals understand them and act on them quickly uh but we've had lots of examples
- of uh blog messages that have been ignored for way too long and just just go viral and it doesn't take very long
- which which takes me back to your question I want to build on what George said Rel related to your question you
- said how do you determine which ones to respond to and I think part of the message ends up becoming every customer
- becomes important in part because today every customer has has a microphone or megaphone I guess I should say because
- it is easier to broadcast your message and you know you could have said there's not a massive number of people
- that are claiming their canaries are dying from fre Breeze Let's ignore it yeah but it a as George points out it
- goes viral right and suddenly it starts becoming this big publicity and if we ignore it then it could be very very
- dangerous so every customer starts becoming important and you need to be addressing all of them and that and that
- requires a whole different skill set as well right so this is back to the issue oh how do you build the skill set the
- technology so most companies would be ill advised to try to do it themselves it's uh extremely uh sophisticated kind
- of analysis so that's where Partners come in right and finding the right Partners building a relationship with
- them those are difficult management challenges and the good companies will do it uh so broadly this leads us into
- the question of how do you then think about this marketing capabilities Gap the answer is most
- companies are not going to be able to close it all their aspiration should be is to close it faster than their
- competitors get ahead line up the right Partners build a capability to do these kind of learn test and learn experiments
- and stay ahead of the competition okay by the way uh just a sidebar to this one of the things that I'm fascinated in is
- that there only so many good partners out there so I think what we're going to see in this open marketing Arena that uh
- the Smart Companies are going to get there first they're going to lock up the good partners in the later entrance who
- say oh this is a good idea won't have the pick of the partners should we worry about uh consumer short attention spans
- I mean they're trying to absorb these thousands of messages thrown at them aren't at some point consumers has tune
- you out so how do companies avoid that how do they avoid being ignored by by customers by potential consumers so that
- is always a threat it's been a threat for a long time but if nothing else because we have so many different
- channels to try and reach customers it's become more of a threat the responsiveness to banner ads is down
- yeah just because you know the the number of them have uh have gone up and so I think part of the answer goes back
- to really customizing messages and your Communications to the individual customer so that what it is that you're
- saying resonates with them historically we're going to post it out there for a large number of people our
- message is sort of comes from the history again of mass media we're going to put out a mass message versus Talking
- specifically to Robbie or talking specifically to uh an individual about what it is that they might need okay and
- but at the extreme uh not only the message is tailored but the whole product offering absolutely so you get
- exactly what you want now customers will pay attention because they understand that you're solving precisely their
- problem uh let's ask why zapus does so well in a otherwise uh crowded category because they are very good at customer
- service and they give the customer exactly what they want customers can solve their problems very easily on
- zapas right weren they one of the first to offer free shipping back and forth yes big big point for people who love
- shoes you can order three pairs of shoes to get the one that you really want to keep not pay any penalty uh George you
- sent me a study um from IBM called from stretched to strengthened in which IBM actually talked to 17 more than 1700
- Chief marketing officers around the globe and at one point um you can tell me what you felt was most interesting
- about that study but one point they the study advises CMOS to understand individ
- uals as well as markets to establish customer intimacy to focus on relationships not just transactions how
- do you do that in such a huge Global Online Marketplace well that's where technology becomes our friend and uh so
- we can uh build deep insights into customers if they choose to let us I mean they may not they may want a
- transactional relationship but by and large uh if let's just take zapus because it's a very familiar example uh
- zapus knows a lot about its customers and it reaches out to them let's take another company which I think has done a
- masterful job of uh addressing that and that's Tesco with their uh Club card in the UK they have 14 million customers
- who have given Tesco permission to capture all the data about every transaction all their demographics
- background information and so Tesco knows an enormous amount about these people it can then tailor messages
- offers precisely to their geographic area and to them individually so a newly uh wed couple gets a certain set of
- offerings a uh U family with a new baby uh it gets offers but at some point don't you think customers are going to
- stop giving that permission I mean there's just actually so there's this concern about you know too much uh
- intrusion I want to guard my privacy I think we're going to go through some waves of people saying no I want to be
- private and other people saying wait a minute I'm being better served by companies knowing some information about
- me my belief is that the only people who who should receive you know coupons for
- baby diapers are people with babies right yeah um that that and you could go through the whole list of you know the
- only people who are going to get spe specific offers are ones that are in need of it um we see the phenomena of
- Groupon going on right now and the number of sort of promotions that I get for Brazilian Blowouts is just amazing
- you know and for tooth whitening and for things that I'm not particularly interested in right now and that's just
- wasted messaging that's going on and I wish they knew more about me so that I wouldn't get all the noise so would you
- give them about you so they would know more about so I think as I said we're going to see these waves of people
- discovering I want to be private but on the otherand I am much better served I get much less of this noise if people
- know more about me and so I think there's going to be a bifurcation of those who say bring it on and others
- that say I want to protect and th those that are asking for you know protection of their information are going to be
- observing the others and and I think we will see an evolution towards more disclosure not less disclosure so uh
- just to to maybe put a wrapper around this uh what's what's a relationship it's a perception of mutual
- understanding and mutual benefits so the customer will only give the company permission if they think it's in their
- best interest they have control over this they have control and so why does Tesco get permission to uh collect all
- this information and to use it to Target as Dave was suggesting very specific messages and the answer is a rebate so
- what's neat about Tesco is that every uh quarter they get a rebate based upon a percentage of all of the uh uh the value
- of the purchases theyve made in that quarter so that's a reminder you know this is a very good two-way relationship
- okay um I have two more questions uh Dave the IBM study also quotes CMOS as saying that return on marke investment
- is the primary measure of Effectiveness this is nothing new it's something you you've talked about a lot but how do you
- prove that value how do you come up with some numbers or numbers not the answer so people are sort of stuck on this
- return on marketing investment and they do that in part because it sort of integrates with the rest of the
- financial Communications of the company because you've got an Roi right that is measured in all sorts of Investments
- um and so it's a basis for comparison across um but I think what it is that we need to do and what our current
- accounting systems are not very good at doing right now is sort of capturing the
- long-term contributions of marketing so we have things like a brand which only shows up on our books if we acquire a
- brand if we build it it it doesn't show up officially on our books but that doesn't mean that we can't measure it
- and we can't measure what the value of that particular brand is and again there are partners and there are various
- companies that assist in helping with that particular measurement of it but maybe even better than brand is looking
- at the long-term value of a customer and that's not saying just what is it that they bought right now and how much did I
- make in that transaction but I want to think about that relationship and that relationship
- that I have with that customer that's today and hopefully out into the future so when someone buys a
- BMW what's the value of that customer that bought the BMW is not what I just sell them right now and the service that
- they're going to have but it's also what's the probability that they're going to buy a BMW out into the future
- so I think what it is that companies are going to move more towards is looking at
- that longer term and and I raise this in the context I haven't forgotten your question the return on marketing
- investment which is sort of looking backwards how much did I make from that and it's not looking enough forward
- towards what's that future Revenue stream that's going to come by having gotten this customer solidified my
- relationship increased the probability that they're going to be buying out into the Future Okay uh George maybe I'll
- throw this out at you the IBM report at one point uses a very strong image for me it says quote just as x-rays
- transform Medicine by letting doctors see through human tissue so the new information and communication
- Technologies are revolutionizing business by letting customers and citizens peer through corporate walls so
- what is the one single best thing a company can do to turn consumers ability to see through corporate walls into a
- competitive advantage to essentially create transparency uh so I will focus on largely the building of of relationships
- uh based upon mutual benefits Mutual understanding so the company has to really invest to understand those
- customers and then create offers that are exactly tailored to their requirements so that uh they thought
- they're being listened to and that their requirements are being met so this is this notion of uh Mutual commitment
- based upon Mutual rewards now I don't mind you getting a benefit from this but it's got to be worth my
- while thank you both for coming thank you thanks Robbie [Music]
Brief Summary
Marketing experts discuss the data overload challenge and strategies to close the marketing capabilities gap.
Key points
- Closing the Marketing Capabilities Gap. George discusses the importance of addressing the marketing capabilities gap due to data overload.
- The Role of Technology in Marketing. George and Dave explore how technology can both create and solve marketing challenges.
- The Importance of Customer Data. The conversation shifts to how companies can effectively use customer data for marketing.
- Transforming Business with Technology. New information and communication technologies allow customers to see through corporate walls.
- Building Mutual Relationships. Companies need to invest in understanding customers to create tailored offers that meet their needs.
Episode highlights
- Closing the Marketing Capabilities GapGeorge discusses the importance of addressing the marketing capabilities gap due to data overload.βWhat exactly is that gap and why is it so important?β0:48Nov 4, 2011
- The Role of Technology in MarketingGeorge and Dave explore how technology can both create and solve marketing challenges.βTechnology is creating the problem; it's also going to be the solution.β4:06Nov 4, 2011
- The Importance of Customer DataThe conversation shifts to how companies can effectively use customer data for marketing.βCompanies that have individual level data can take advantage of it.β10:00Nov 4, 2011
- Transforming Business with TechnologyNew information and communication technologies allow customers to see through corporate walls.βJust as x-rays transform medicine, new technologies revolutionize business.β23:51Nov 4, 2011
- Building Mutual RelationshipsCompanies need to invest in understanding customers to create tailored offers that meet their needs.βCompanies must invest to understand customers and create tailored offers.β24:31Nov 4, 2011





