Inside the NBA’s New Era of Analytics and Talent w/ Dean Oliver
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
ABOUT THE EPISODE On this episode of Wharton Moneyball, hosts Adi Wyner, Shane Jensen, and Cade Massey talk with Dean Oliver of ESPN about what makes Victor Wembanyama such a unique force and how analytics helps teams understand his impact. They dig into how fast top draft picks really develop, how teams prepare for stars like Wembanyama, and how data is reshaping player evaluation. In the second half, the hosts cover standout stories across sports, including Yamamoto’s World Series performance and NFL trade moves, and what they reveal about decision-making and analytics in modern sports.
ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? The Moneyball podcast explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.
#BasketballAnalytics #Wembanyama #NBATalk #NBANews #NBATrends #SportsAnalytics ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- Welcome to Wharton Moneyball, our sports show where we talk about statistics and everything that's
- happened this week. We have in the remote locations uh Shane Jensen and soon we'll be joined by Kade Massie um
- professor Audi Winer of the Department of Statistics and Data Science as is Shane and Kade of course is in a
- different department oid operation information decisions. we never get the full thing listed out. And uh we're
- joined by Dean Oliver, which is always exciting. He's a regular guest on our show. Dean is a sports analyst at ESPN
- right now, and he's gone through lots of iterations and different work for different teams and has uh written
- several fantastic books on basketball and is definitely our go-to guy for all things basketball. Um which is now our
- transition because uh baseball season is over. We're sad about that. I don't know, Dean, did you catch any baseball
- or are you still Are you all in on basketball? >> I am pretty much all in on basketball. I
- I knew what was going on in baseball, but I I could watch the highlights. I couldn't really take the time to watch
- the games. >> Yeah. Well, you're in you're in Hawaii, so you were sort of out out of the time
- zone, but you know. >> No. So, first of all, I'm not in Hawaii anymore. >> You're not in Hawaii anymore.
- >> Second of all, Hawaii is like one of the greatest places to watch sports because
- they end at a reasonable time. You could actually watch the whole thing. They're
- not ending it at at three in the morning. Like, wasn't there one? Yeah, there was a game there.
- >> There was there was an 18 in game. I didn't actually stay up for that. I would have, of course, it involved a
- team that I was rooting for, but I did stay up till, you know, the nearly one:00 ending of the of the of the
- series, which was a fantastic game. Well, we don't have to talk about it with you. You didn't watch it. That's
- not your thing. We're talking about basketball. So, we're excited for you to tell us about all kinds of uh things
- basketball. Do you have a a quick summary summary of what we should be thinking about in the opening, you know,
- couple weeks of the season? >> Uh, I think uh Victor Wmanyama is a very very frightening player at this point.
- He is so big and he is quick. Uh, and I I think he can beat himself, but it's not clear exactly what you do to to take
- him away. So now, so VMY is this is his third season now in this in >> Yeah, it's his third season and and I
- think one of the things his last season was injury shortened and I think that's one thing you always worry about with
- the big guys. >> So just tell me a little bit about, you know, how long does it take for a a
- first round draft pick, basically a number one pick, to turn into something extremely good? Is that something you
- expect in the right away, second year, third year? Um, and how is he tracking roughly versus that?
- >> It takes a little bit longer when they're young like women like most of the the recent ones have been. Uh, of
- course, because uh they may be talented and everything, but when they're coming in and you're only 19 and you you're
- going on this growth curve where you're playing high school kids and you could just dominate them. You go to college
- and even if you're playing some of the best competition, they are several inches shorter, several
- inches maybe a foot, not they're not as wide as long. And so the adjustment, you're definitely going to have an
- adjustment period of at least two years. And I think that's what we're seeing with Guanyama right now is we're seeing
- we're seeing him offensive growth still in process. his defensive impact. It's It's hard to find
- a comparison for him because he is just so big, so mobile, so able to just intimidate everything.
- His block rate, I think I looked at he's basically blocking 10% of all all two-point shots. Um,
- >> good. >> And and Keem one, I think, was like at seven or eight peak. And they're not.
- Yeah. What what he's doing is crazy. Especially when you couple it with all the other things that he's doing,
- >> which are what exactly? >> Uh so he can handle the ball. He can bring the ball up court. There was there
- was a highlight play where he blocked someone at the rim, got the defensive rebound, and then brought it back up
- court and then and made a shot and just all in I think it was like three strides
- after we got the the defensive board, too. He's just he's just you don't know exactly what to do. He's got some of the
- elements of of Giannis in the incredibly long stride and ball handling. Not quite
- as shifty as as Giannis is yet, but Giannis wasn't that way initially. So, he's he doesn't have his three-point shot
- fully dialed in yet, but you kind of wonder how are you going to defend that, especially when you can go by you on the
- dribble at the same time. I think these are he's got John Wooden said that quickness was more important than
- height. I don't know if I ever believed that, but people always put those two one and two in terms of kind of basic
- physical skills and he's got both of them. It's just scary to think about. >> Yeah, I mean it kind of sounds like he's
- got like he's kind of a nightmare matchup right now. could be that teams haven't I don't know if you've seen yet
- in in kind of the matchups he's faced whether there is you know like is some like whether there's going to be
- strategies that come out for dealing with his kind of physical dominance and his physical skill set whether you can
- look back in history for any kind of strategy or whether he's kind of a one and one and they're just going to have
- to you know uh learn on the fly I don't know if you you mentioned some historical precedent already for him do
- you think there is some kind of you know somewhere in base basketball history we
- come look back and sort of see like how how do you kind of strategize against somebody with this kind of physical
- skill? >> You know, I think teams are going to end up using trial and error more than they
- are going to use history. I I think people try to think back to the things that are kind of close, but he is he's
- unique. He is he is um as much as people called and say Chris Tataps Porzing is the unicorn at some point and and KP is
- he's tall and he can shoot I mean he's got a great defensive presence you add another couple inches to him and you add
- uh quicker feet and better ball handling then you've got Wimmanyama so what are you going to learn from the comparison
- to KP? Um, probably not anywhere near as much as you need to. >> So, I mean, what do you think this means
- for the Spurs? Are they going to just dominate? What's it going to How does that set out?
- >> You know, it's I I think coming into this season, most projections were that they were going to be about 500.
- >> 500. Okay. >> And they started off undefeated. They now have a loss. They look pretty bad
- actually in their loss to Phoenix recently. what we saw was just so dominant. I'm betting the that the over on the the
- win total is now quite a bit higher than your 500. >> Well, that's actually an interesting
- question because usually I mean we don't have Kade here right now. He would start
- talking about overreaction and that what can you say after six games that you should be shrunk pretty heavily towards
- your preseason forecast. >> Yep. something I think in what you're observing in Webmanyama seems to be so
- radically different almost as if we the prece just got it wrong and we just need
- to toss it and and replace it is >> plus because of his injury you kind of had I guess more additional kind of
- prior uncertainty in what you know in that kind of preseason >> there there's a few factors that end up
- relevant here is yeah you kind of forget what they were um last year and they they were not particularly good he got
- perk the end of the season. Stefan Castle won rookie of the year, but you know, he wasn't great. He was he was a
- rookie himself. >> Um, he is definitely better now. They drafted Dylan Harper, who started off
- the year quite good. Uh, he just got hurt though now too, so they could running into the injury book. And
- Harper's going to be out for a while. Uh, so, but they they have a number of of good pieces. Um, and as long as I
- think WebMan, one of the things you notice is you look at the individual numbers for a lot of the players, the
- Spurs, how much better they get when he is on the floor. Uh, it's it's like this
- whole division of credit. How much credit do you give Wyama for making it easier for the other guys to actually
- defend uh versus >> So is he is he just attracting attention this so-called gravity or is he making
- >> it's funny what >> you call him gravity what I would say is the most relevant aspect of him is his
- anti-gravity in some his def he has defensive anti-gravity no one wants to get close to this guy
- >> because he's so long and so big if we have gra we have this gravity metric on
- the offensive side or how much people stay with Steph for instance when he's out at 30 ft.
- On the defensive side, you want to almost characterize anti-gravity because no one wants to go near this guy. And uh
- what that does is it makes it a lot easier to put pressure on a ball handler, for instance, because you don't
- have help responsive. You don't have to help as much. You don't have to help in the middle because you've got this guy
- who covers so much space. um you can guard your man a lot better, >> right? So you don't have that strange uh
- strange sort of game theoretic problem where someone's driving down the middle. You have one person there blocking him.
- That's not enough for an ordinary human being to block and then so that someone else comes help leaving someone in the
- corner wide open pop it in and then they get the shot with you're saying he doesn't need help. You can keep
- everybody guarded and that's just a huge offensive just crush >> that. I I love the fact that you Yeah.
- you say game theory aspect of it too because yes it does it changes the the dynamic of that game theory so
- >> or I mean another perspective I wasn't really thinking game theory I was kind
- of thinking you know it kind of fundamentally points to like a m a massive endeavor of offensive strategy
- is to create space in the offensive zone and he inherently is a is is a space restricting you know is probably the
- most powerful space restricting force you could have as a in the def uh you know from the defensive side so it's
- kind of you know he's He's really anti, you know, kind of optimally antitheical to one of the main goals of offensive
- possession, >> right? So, so I guess that means that so most of the space comes on the outside,
- right? That's where volume grows or space grows, you know, much much rapidly rather than inside. But what he does is
- he takes away that that inside shot, forcing everyone back and make it much more difficult to shoot from three. Is
- that what what's actually happening? He he's allowing all his perimeter teammates to take up the space out on
- the perimeter because they don't need to come in and help him. He's just he goes
- puts his arms out and he's got pretty much the entire covered. >> So, is there any particular offense that
- would be more successful against a team with Wimyama with the Spurs or is it they're all kind of
- >> elite Golden State where they're just launching threes from like, you know, the distance and still being successful?
- I don't I don't know. This is kind of what I was trying to get at with the previous matchup question, whether there
- is sort of like some combination that at least matches up as well as you can against something somebody like women.
- >> I don't think we know um particularly well yet. I think one of the ways you can create a little bit of space on the
- perimeter is when you have defensive guards and stuff that are putting pressure is is you can basically set
- screen and roll and then you get to about the mid-range before Webyama's impact is actually all that big and you
- take some of those shots. Now, I didn't watch the Phoenix game in entirety the other night. I actually caught it after
- they were well ahead. Um, but Devin Booker is one of those guys and Phoenix has him. He he definitely is willing to
- put the ball on the floor and take the mid-range and not only willing to, he can make them. And so sometimes
- you almost have to go counter rule of thumb analytics wise to beat these people who are just so good at at doing
- what analytics says. >> So let me ask a question specific uh to like an analyst. So what does an analyst
- analyst do like during the week to help prepare their team to face a particular upcoming opponent? Is do they try to
- invent things to I mean how does that work? And I'm speaking almost because we have all these people who have these
- jobs now. I'm curious what do they do? >> Uh when you're working for a team in in
- the regular season it's it's very tough. Um because first of all you can sit there and say we're preparing preparing
- for when like this coming Saturday or something between Tuesday and Saturday you may have two other games
- >> and so you can't really put in a whole lot and especially early in the season
- like now it's you're trying to perfect who you are rather than trying to adapt too much
- to him. Now that being said, what you what teens will probably do if you do have a day off or two days off before
- you face him is you you will watch more and then you will put in like, "All right, guys, these are this is what
- we're thinking of doing." And it will be a combination of what an analyst uh and
- coaches are kind of thinking of doing. The statistical analyst, they're trying to look for data for what
- has particularly worked. Um, and so they may have a history. You may go back and
- look at all the games where when Myama's defensive numbers were not very good and
- the opponent actually burned them. You would probably, the coaches would probably be looking back at that Phoenix
- game and what did Phoenix do? And then you're going to try to mesh those numbers that what you have over the
- first three years, two plus years of WBY's career with what they've seen in the tape. and then you come up with
- suggestions and you you may still fail but uh you try a number of things over the course of the year and and hopefully
- you find something. >> So So before we change topics because I want to talk about the rookie class
- >> quick overunder on Spurs wins over the season. What do you got? >> 50 >> 50. So that's substantially better than
- than 41 or whatever the preseason. You don't expect them to dominate. I have no insight, so I can't disagree.
- All right. While we're on basketball overunders, our our sixers, what do you think of them?
- >> Yeah. I wanted to ask you, Dean, if if we should be getting excited. I don't know. I mean, I bet you if Eric was
- here, he would not be excited. Yeah, >> I am excited on the one hand in that I think uh like it's actually good to see
- Philly win without Embiid paying playing playing a significant role. >> When you've got um Tyrese Max and Frank
- playing so much better than we've seen him play and he was he was good before. Um the fact that someone else behind
- Embiid can carry the team I think is uh it's kind of what they need. Um, and I always worried about Embiid um being
- kind of the leader on that on that team. Uh, I think Maxi can probably be the more democratic leader. I mean, make
- everybody happy. Uh, whereas it can be tough when you just have someone like Embiid who can score. So, um, I think
- this is a nice change. I am a little worried that maybe Maxi is playing a was a bit over his head, but I do think it's
- there's a real improvement, just not quite as good as what we've seen. >> Well, Edcom is also like obviously you
- get a nice cheap rookie like him, that's a good sum. And they got Jared McCain comes back.
- >> It's actually very interesting because when is doing exactly what we projected,
- right? We projected him to be this good in his third year. So, we don't doubt his success.
- >> Yes. >> But, uh, I think with Maxi, we never we don't expect it. So, I think it's I
- think regression of the mean is probably in the cards. Um, which means that that's your f my fancy way of saying
- Sixers fans don't get too excited. [laughter] Yeah. All right. All right. So, let's
- talk about the rookie class. We have, of course, the lead rookie, uh, Cooper Flag, and others. Tell tell us what you
- think about what how they they're faring out. So, uh, one of the things that we did at
- ESPN is we, uh, we put together kind of a preview of the year. And, uh, Dallas didn't project particularly well. And
- part of it was that Kyrie is not coming back until January or so like that. Anthony Davis is is good, but he's not
- he's not going to carry you. And then, yeah, you have a bunch of guys who are what my old GM used to say, just guys.
- It's not that they're bad. They're just they're guys. They help you a little bit. They're they're better than
- replacement level. Um and then we kind of did a simulation. How good would they be if Cooper Flag was as good as the
- hype? Um basically one of the best rookies that we've seen in the last 10 to 20 years. Then they then they're
- pretty good. Uh they end up being like a a top four to top six seed in the West,
- which is not easy to do. Now that being said, Cooper Flag has not been that guy so far. He has not been He has been um
- kind of a typical rookie struggling with a lot of things. Uh one of the things that we've seen with him is that uh he
- actually a very key breakdown a key split and how well he plays versus when he's playing
- well versus poorly is whether they actually have a point guard on the floor. If they have D'Angelo Russell on
- the floor, they have Brandon Williams on the floor. Cooper Flag is actually kind of close to
- what we were simulating what what he could be as a rookie, but he's played more than half his possessions, I
- believe, without those guys. And he has been awful. >> Genuinely awful. Wow. >> He's uh without those guys, he's
- shooting 31%. um more turnovers and less time than um when he's playing with those guys. So,
- it's uh yeah, he's he needs someone to kind of carry the offense. People talked in the preseason. There were there was
- one highlight play where he brought the ball all the way up the floor, backed down a really good defender and and made
- it look easy. And I think that kind of stuck with people. Oh, he can be our 6'10 point guard and he's not really
- been able. >> Well, you know, the thing is we just talked about this with me. Rookies
- generally are not they do they ever live up to their hype? I mean, think about it
- is that I mean historically, do the great players of today did they have good rookie seasons? I mean, maybe
- that's not the right that's really not the that's the post hawk. I'm cheating, right? You look at the great Yeah.
- Right. But how I mean, go look forward looking and backwards looking. So, start with back with forward-looking. Um, how
- many of the of our great of our, you know, really excited first picks turn into something? Maybe I'm jaded because
- of Philly. They never do, right? But, um, but how often do they hit their their max and then go backwards and say,
- "Look at the great players of today. Were they rookie rookie sensation?" Usually not.
- >> So, there are two players that always come to mind when we talk about rookies
- for me. One is one is Chris Paul because I remember doing an analysis of him when
- he was in college. And one of the ways I looked at it is I wanted to see how much
- he dropped off really when he played against good competition uh when he was in college to make some sort of
- projection of okay now you're going to be playing really good competition and he really didn't drop off. Um and so he
- ended up having a very good rookie season. Uh he was obviously not an NBA all firstteamer or anything but he was
- very good. Um, but probably the best rookie that I know of, the best rookie performance
- was by a guy we all know was a second round pick, but is the best player in basketball. Go
- >> was outstanding as a rookie, but people just didn't pay attention to him because
- he was still slow. He had all those things that people remembered like like what you were talking about their
- priors and stuff. People's prior on him was he's a second round pick and so people didn't kind of recognize that he
- was doing all the things he he was his numbers legitimately were all NBA as a rookie. And so it's it's not
- necessarily a number one pick. Obviously LeBron lived up to it. LeBron lived had
- a had a great rookie year. He was very good. It wasn't all NBA level, but it was it was good. Uh you have the
- failures. You have guys who fail for different reasons like Zion Williamson who fails because of injuries.
- >> Right. Right. Kade, good to have you. >> Glad to be here. Glad to be here. More
- technology challenges. I'm trying not to get fired. Y'all Y'all should just fire
- me. 11 years in. still having technology challenges. Dean, you said this thing about your analysis of Chris Paul
- splitting his college performance as a function of the quality of the opponent. And I'm curious how often we do that in
- basketball. Is that a common way to look at players? And is it is it is it is it
- revealing? Do we often see people who don't degrade as you go? I would think that'd be a great analysis and yet I
- haven't heard of it. >> Um, most of the time you don't get a lot of significance with it. you know. Uh so
- back then of course players played usually more than one year which kind of limits your statistical significance.
- >> So Chris Paul played two um which gave you more of a chance and the fact that
- like whoa okay this is it's not usual to see this. >> Uh so you do try I I do look for this I
- do look for this uh whether there's there's some there are some players who go off a cliff. they basically if they
- start playing the really good teams they play much worse. Um but there's a s there's a number of those that you just
- don't have enough statistical significance to buy it um when you're talking about prospects who are coming
- in who are joining the NBA after one year. So it gets tough to use that. It's an indicator if you put it with other
- things, but it's not as strong as as you would like. >> All right. Well, let's hear about the
- Lakers. They they have this uh all-star trio for real. Are we looking at something interesting over there?
- >> Yeah, I think we are. Uh I think one of the things that was in the last book,
- Basketball Beyond Paper, is there was it was almost a footnote about Austin Reeds. Um and that was when he was a
- rookie, I believe. Um there are players who there are not very many players who are what I was calling four level
- scorers. Basically, they can finish at the rim, they can finish in the paint away from the rim, they can make
- mid-range shots, and they can make threes. And Ros Austin Ree was was one of those. Uh,
- >> Dean, real quickly, can you clarify the distinction between finishing in the paint and mid-range shots?
- >> So, mid-range, uh, what I'm calling mid-range here is everything outside the paint, but inside of the three-point
- shot. And then there's within the paint, there's two different shots. There's at
- the rim and then there's like floaters like 15 foot just inside the foul line. >> Yeah. And so we've like Austin Reeves is
- has not necessarily fully duplicated what he did as a rookie, but he's been very close. and these players who
- actually can shoot from all these distances well and actually create. That's the other thing that's about this
- this trio in the in LA is that they all not only can shoot but they can create for other people and that ability those
- that combination of abilities makes it very difficult for a team to for a defense to really deal with that.
- So ultimately you're thinking the Lakers are very good. >> You know, um some of my skepticism
- actually relies is is align with LeBron now. >> LeBron Well, Braun is like 100 years
- old, right? I mean, >> and that's big part of the reason is is what we saw with LeBron last year is we
- definitely saw a decline. We've seen him coming down and his mountain was so high. He his peak was so incredibly
- high. uh he's come down quite a lot and I'm wondering whether he's going to mentally be able to deal with
- his body not doing all it could before. >> Well, you know, it's interesting. So,
- so, so, so Eric isn't here, but this is what he would say. He would say that that K that um that LeBron can't be
- LeBron of yester year all the time, but he can put it on when he really needs to. That would be my question for you.
- Can he even still do that? I don't think so. No. [laughter] I mean, Audi, great job channeling Eric. That's
- really That's really good. >> I know. I think I've got all of our specialties down.
- >> Yeah, we can we can chat GPT each other pretty decently, I think, at this point.
- One other question while we're in the West. Um, I got to ask about Durant and Houston.
- >> Ah, one of my favorite teams. Yeah, I I really like watching those guys. Um, I
- really like him in part because Alparan Shenun was kind of under the radar and um, great passer. Another guy who like
- Joic has this ability to see the floor. He's not in Yokic, not anyone's really in Joic's category, but uh, I think uh,
- Durant said something about loving to play with Shenun because Shenun sees all the options so quickly. And I I did an
- analysis. This is a few days old at this point, but basically Durant is dominant
- with Shangun on the floor and not very good with Shangun off the floor. Uh I I expect that to regress a little bit to
- the norm, but I it it was significant enough that I expect it to persist. Uh just not to that same magnitude. Um and
- and Shenun, just kind of look at it. Shenun knows how to make the right reads. He take puts so much pressure on
- every defender to keep track of their guy. So, uh, it was fun last night. Like, Shingun was called on to to go to
- basically decide what play they were going to run and go one-on-one with Durant off the ball last night to win
- the game basically. >> Wow. So, let's let's K, you want to >> I want to follow up. This is probably
- where you want to go, Audi. I'm curious. So because I know Dean has been interested in the last year, especially
- his whole life, but especially in the last year on this kind of partiallying credit um on the NBA court and this is a
- question that's of deep interest to us across sports of course and I think even beyond sports because so many uh so much
- of production in groups is interdependent and so it's hard to figure out who's dragging the group down
- or who's elevating the group. So to what extent have you made progress on this? And you can even take Shangon as an an
- example in Houston. How is it you're figuring out how much credit to give him given that it often happens through
- other players. It shows up through other players. >> Uh yeah, I mean fundamentally this this
- question of how much credit do you give and this is one of the demonstrations I actually do when I'm doing division of
- credit is basically the pass and the catch. That is a fundamentally team exercise, right? Like that those two
- people their success is based upon whether you toss it well and you catch it well. You complete both of those
- things. And so each of those things has a a difficulty. But say if you throw it a little bit offtarget, it makes the
- catch harder. So people in implicitly want to uh give a little bit more credit to the person who caught it if it if
- it's a bit offt target. But if um if they miss it, they get less blame, right? If it's a if it's offtarget, they
- may have still had a chance. And those are those that's giving you an idea for what are the parameters that you can use
- to kind of divide that credit. How hard were the initial events? And so if we extend it more, when you have a player
- who's moving, the catcher is moving, that makes the thrower's job a little bit harder, right? because they have to
- time it, they have to lead the the player and stuff like that. So all of these there are the these factors that
- make each thing harder. So to the degree that I can, which is far less than what
- I've just talked about, you put that into into basketball and you identify the passes and how difficult were some
- of the passes that had to be made, how difficult were the corresponding shots, it's a lot easier to make a shot at the
- rim than to make a three-point shot, >> right? And it's it's correspondingly it's
- difficult to make the pass to someone at the rim because the defense is usually taking care of that first.
- >> Right. So just to point out uh Dean came to Moneyball Academy over the summer and
- we did a live demo with passing basketball. Um which illuminates those differences. My question is I I imagine
- you can relatively easily do that by watching. Um you can if you're good at it, you can score a pass and a and a
- catch. Is it is the technology and the analysis of the data good enough to do that automatically yet or is that
- something that is still being worked on? >> Uh I believe the technology is act is
- pretty good to do a lot of this now. Uh the matter of time to for me to kind of dive in and and get everything all the
- details. I've done some of it before but not at the full scope. So you take approximations from what you have at the
- time for now. >> But yeah, the the data >> uh for passes for instance, it tells you
- whether you kicked it out to someone who made it three, but you passed it at their ankles and they had to really get
- down and get it before. So your pass wasn't as good um in order to get uh but they still made the shot.
- >> Wait, so the the tracking data has that annotated or you have to build that yourself with XYZ coordinates?
- >> Oh, no. the tracking the tracking data has has the passes has the height of the
- passes when it reaches players all of that kind of thing. Yes, it is there. >> I see. So, it it's not it's actually
- annotated um data. It's not just XYZ time. You deal with it. It's much it's already been processed.
- >> Uh all of the stuff that I've had to work with [laughter] is like that. I don't want to deal with the XYZ time.
- >> Yes, I know that. That is that is a a grueling endeavor and it eats up analysts. I mean, I I imagine that's
- what analysts are doing on a day-to-day basis, dealing with this monstrosity of a data set.
- >> So, for the most part, uh, one company, um, what's now called Genius IQ, I believe, does a lot of that processing.
- The NBA itself internally is doing a lot of its own processing with that as well.
- So you have two kind of parties that are doing some of the same things, some things that are a little bit different.
- But yeah, they are doing a lot of that annotation, which is >> we at Wharton and I imagine universities
- are all over are anxiously hoping that the NBA mimics the the NFL in their big datable competition in which it releases
- a lot of this great data to the public um and inspires us to want to work on it. So hopefully that'll happen. Um,
- [clears throat] I know that's I know the MLB is has tons of data, but they don't release the the
- good stuff to the public. Um, much of it already is good. In fairness, MLB is way
- out in front of all the other leagues in terms of releasing um, high quality um,
- you know, advanced data. All right, so one maybe one final question we can take before we wrap up our first segment. Um,
- analytics has changed, you know, basketball a lot. We all talk about that. um what's the frontier in these
- let's just pick one one quick domain like player acquisition what's the role of analytics in that
- >> and player acquisition the good thing about working in management is you have
- a lot of time to to deal with player acquisition how much you have to pay how good are they going how good are they
- now how good are they going to be in the future and to some degree uh you can look at some of this question for are
- they going to fit with our guys are our guys going to make them better uh or are
- guys potentially going to make them worse. That that definitely happens. And so you definitely have time to go into
- all of this when you are evaluating prospects from college or trade prospects, all of that. And the the
- metrics for a lot of these things definitely exist in in in my world like um you look at these components. So
- things like rebounding, shooting, passing, um getting to the foul line, putting the ball on the floor and being
- able to make a decision whether to pass or shoot, those kind of things. We have metrics for a lot of this stuff. And
- ideally, I haven't done this. Uh ideally, you make some sort of simulator where you put all your players together,
- you determine whether they can complement each other. But we aren't quite there yet. Uh maybe maybe some
- team is but >> yeah I was going to ask is anybody of the of the 30 NBA teams do we have
- anybody doing that advanced work? >> You know I I wouldn't doubt that there's some
- farreaching soul in one of these teams doing something like that but has their stuff actually made a difference in
- decision making? I'm doubting it at this. [laughter] >> That's a tough problem. I will say that
- we had a team of students here in our sports analytics lab led by Ryan Bril who's now working for the Utah Jazz
- >> and they uh they tried to build um the way they kind of handled it was they create different clusters of offenses
- and defenses and then they imagined you adding a player based on that player type into a particular cluster and so
- essentially they had different regression coefficients um with determined exactly by the combination.
- So that's that was a a highlevel approach to uh to sol sketching out a solution to that very
- complex problem. >> Is it good enough to be trustworthy in making decisions and >> that's that's yeah that's the pro that's
- really the key issue and I want and how to get past all the you know the the upper level management who can they
- >> we need to make Audi a GM and to test this thing out. >> Yeah. Yeah. Right. >> You gonna go take over for Danny Age
- there in Utah there. Not taking if if I do any sport, it isn't basketball though, unfortunately.
- >> Only need to watch him. We'll only need to watch him for 20 years before we can
- draw a conclusion. >> 20 years. Anyway, le Dean, thank you once again for joining us on Wharton
- Moneyball. It's been a pleasure to have you. Uh Dean is of course analyst for ESPN. He's also the author, I didn't
- mention this, of uh basketball on paper and the new version, Basketball Beyond Paper, the really analytics bible to the
- analysis of uh of basketball. So, thank you, Dean, and we'll look forward to you
- joining us again in the future. >> Thank you, guys. Good seeing you. >> Welcome back. Welcome back to Wharton
- Moneyball. Welcome back to the second half of this week's show. Kade Massie back on host duties with a supposedly
- functional laptop joined by Audi Winer. Thank you, Odd, for running the show first half. And Shane Jensen, the the
- the the workhorse here. He's he's done he's done so much research this week carrying the carrying the load.
- Appreciate it. Eric Bradlo in absentia. Eric out doing Eric Bradloow things. Glad to be here on Tuesday afternoon
- just off the line with Dean Oliver. Dean one of our longest standing guests. Um he's an example of one of these people
- that we now have a thicker relationship with. Comes around school, does some things, teaches a little bit. Um I've
- had him out to a conference or two. Um, it's been one of the fun things about doing the show for 11 years is that we
- have not just online relationships from our online interviews. Um, we've got some other ones as well and Dena is a
- good example. Good to get caught up a little bit on basketball, huh? I mean, you know, here we, you know, we wrap up
- baseball and we now we have a little more capacity, just a little extra capacity on top of football. Let's turn
- our eyes elsewhere. We're doing basketball now. We'll do hockey at some point. Um, I can talk a little hockey
- this week. We'll Why don't we do this, fellas? Open lines of course. Lots going on. We still haven't debriefed the
- baseball season wrapping game seven ridiculousness. So planning to talk about. We could go
- for a while. Let's do a couple of rounds of what caught your eye. We've only got
- three of us, but let's see how many we can do. Fellas around the world of sports in this hot hot fall season.
- What's caught your eye? >> Oh, come on. Can I start? Can I >> I want to end we have to end the
- baseball season with a little attention. >> Oh yeah. >> So many dramatic things that happened in
- that series that deserve our attention and caught our eye. But as someone who's thought about this topic, this
- particular topic a lot. Definitely what caught my eye was Yamamoto pitching basically nearly a complete game and
- coming back the next day and throwing two plus innings. >> Three wins, three wins in the series.
- >> That's like that's oldfashioned. That's 147 back in the old day and just I mean
- this is crazy, right? So that particular performance and I wonder not only was it
- actually amazing but are we missing something about what a pitcher is capable of doing that this and that
- would be the can we learn anything from this or is this so oneoff that we just can't learn anything analytically that
- maybe how we manage pitching staffs going forward and that would be the the open question for you guys.
- >> Yeah I mean I've thought about this too. It's like because I think there's been a
- lot of articles written about kind of oh this is the return of the elite p elite
- pitcher in the playoff. Like if you have a lead pitcher in the playoffs, the strength of that has never really gone
- away. It just is I I think it's kind of syncratic. >> Being able to do something like that. I
- mean I think the last Madison Bumgardner I guess and you know decade ago was the
- same thing. Like if you if you happen to get a guy who is just so shut down he can give you like 20 innings of like one
- or two run ball. Yeah. just throw that guy out there as much and you know and I guess the other unprecedented thing is
- Yamoto's ability slashwill willingness to just like do it day after day on zero rest or one day rest or two day rest or
- whatever. >> Yeah. I mean listen we did that listen I think that Arizona did that to the to
- the Yankees in 2001. They had two superstar pitchers. They just kept using them.
- >> Yeah. Randy Johnson I think is the last time before this year that we had a three win pitch. got a well pitcher got
- three wins in the World Series, >> right? And they also had Schilling at the same time. So you had Schilling and
- Johnston uh uh Johnson and Schilling and like what are you going to do? And that's how the playoffs kind of turned
- its way against the Yankees. >> Yeah, those guys I think picked about 80% of their innings.
- >> Yes. I'm still smart. By the way, it's 25 years later and I'm still upset about
- that fifth seventh game loss against Rivera when Oh god, don't start me off. >> I mean honestly I'm so glad you're still
- upset about that. >> Yeah. I mean, it's like we talk regularly about what is your worst
- sporting moment in your entire life and that seventh game loss in the ninth inning was my loss. I've still I'm still
- unable to sit in the room where I watched it at my friend's house because it gives me you know PSD
- >> you know think about the Jay's feelings for the next 25 years about this one this game.
- >> Yeah. >> I mean just I mean that was a real >> so many ways. I mean just >> inches away and that's that's that's
- play I mean that's like what an amazing series in general. I do just kind of one
- more sort of observation on whether this is kind of an idiosyncratic thing or whatever. I thought it was kind of
- interesting that somebody did analysis of the last 20 World Series winners and the this year's Dodgers scored the least
- runs out of all the last 20 World Series winners. Last year's Dodgers scored like
- the second most runs out of all the all the last year's like 20 basically the same team, right? So, it's like we'll
- remember this World Series because of Yamamoto and this shutdown pitching. You know, I see it's not like that that that
- I think is, you know, this World Series is narrative, but I I would be hesitant to extrapolate it to be like, oh, that's
- going to be the Dodgers strength next year even necessarily. >> Correct. Well, speaking of like, you
- know, the the arc of these things over time, I I my memory is that the Dodgers didn't start this season out
- particularly strong. We had high priors on them, but they were underperforming for the first half of the season. It's
- just such a long season. It seems obvious, maybe that this has to be something that's well known, but I'm
- just curious how much teams work on it that when you peak matters dramatically. I mean, you don't really need to worry
- about how well you're performing in April, May, June, unless you're building toward performing in July, really
- August, September, October. It's really all about those last three months. Do do
- teams do things with that in mind? They must, but what what kinds of things could you do if that was your
- orientation? Because the I mean, the Dodgers came in as a as the wild card. Now, they had to get lucky to win these
- short wild card series, but it's not the first time we've seen it. It just seems
- with such a long season, it seems obvious that it kind of has to be terrifically backloaded if you can do
- such a thing strategically. >> Well, the Dodgers were incredibly injuryprone with their starting starting
- staff for the most of the season. remember what they how they started with like 13 wins in a row or some ridiculous
- number and we thought they were going to run away with 100 wins, 110 wins and they didn't even come close to that. You
- know, injury makes a big difference, particularly their starting starting staff and they have terrific starting
- staff, you know, and they have key hitters. I mean, I just don't understand how those hitters who came out of
- nowhere who were just were like awful for the last month of the season have these ridiculous homers, but that's how
- you that's how it make it happen. I mean, it's it it's extreme events make things happen. Um, but I don't think
- they manage it that way. I don't >> Yeah, I don't know. I mean I mean again you know the nar one of the narratives
- we would have maybe created in about this last year is that certain organizations like the do like they they
- either through player acquisition or through development are more focused on kind of the fundamental kind of like
- bang bang sort of stuff in baseball which we you know post hawk always attribute wins and lo like world series
- victories and defeats to. So, you know, IF not taking like a lead when Muki would have taken a lead and all this
- type of stuff. Or last year, you know, is all the kind of fielding errors, you know, you know, we talked about the
- fielding rows the Yankees made last year. We talked about the base running gaffs that the Blue Jays made this year.
- I feel like another kind of narrative one could make. I'm not sure how big it really is is that, you know, the Dodgers
- seem to kind of like either through development or player acquisition get guys that like do the kind of
- fundamentals well, don't screw up in the big moments, you know, kind of like maintain their composure in those big
- sort of plays. But again, I I I I I made that story up just now. But, you know, it's it's kind of it is a post hawk
- story where a couple of those bangplang plays go a little different and you know, it it's not a very robust story, I
- guess, or it's not necessarily I'm not sure how empirical it is of a story beyond the ad
- hoc nature of how I'm describing it. >> These things are so close. These series are so close. I mean, they're just knife
- edge. And the Dodgers made it through a couple of them, but nothing more knifeedge than this one. That it has to
- be chance that separates it. And yet, we're going to instantly turn it into these narratives.
- >> Yeah. Exactly. >> I mean, when a when a when a very different narrative was readily
- available, but for a matter of inches on multiple occasions, then you ought to you ought to go pretty easy on the
- narrative, right? >> Okay. That's odds. That's odds. What caught his eye? Shane Jensen, what cut
- your eye? >> Well, okay, let's let's let's start talking. There it is. I want to do a
- shout out. Let's u we already covered baseball. I want to do a shout out in uh football. I want to do a shout out to
- Eric Eager and whatever he's doing down with the Carolina Panthers there. >> Yeah,
- >> they're at five. They have the same record as the Kansas City Chiefs right now. Five and four. That's pretty It's
- halfway point in the season, so it's not like, you know, we're looking at this after two games or something.
- >> How about it? Well, I just I texted him before the show to congratulate him on
- his five and four and he responded. I said, "Terrific job." He goes, "Yep." >> That was it.
- >> Humble as always. You know, they don't he doesn't travel every game. Most front
- office folks don't travel to every game. And um but I saw on the schedule when I
- when Sunday morning came around, I saw that they were going to be in Green like, "Oh, Eager's going to be up
- there." And sure enough, he was there. He was on the sidelines for it. He texted his uh tweet. He tweeted this
- picture of his phone with the, you know, the icon of your messages, how many text
- messages you had, and it said, it says 54, little red 54 up there, text messages right after the game in it. So,
- people were blowing him up to give him love for that for that game up there in Wisconsin.
- >> The only the only downside I can see is I'm sorry he had to endure those Packers
- throwbacks so close up, [laughter] you know? I mean, I think those might have challenged like dealers throwbacks for
- ugliest kind of it makes me happy we're not in the 1940s anymore in terms of football with a low point. Shane, I just
- I'm just I'm I'm glad you're with me on these uniform analytics we're trying to make a little more rigor. Yeah, we're
- trying to bring >> Yeah. I mean, honestly, analytics has gotten too into the meat of it. Like,
- let's get [laughter] superficial stuff, right? Come on. >> Come on. We got to we got to got to f
- focus on some shallow stuff. Yeah. Come on. >> Yeah. Yeah. >> Now, now let me Can we talk about the
- Carolina Panthers for a moment? Do they actually have a good quarterback? I don't think so. Is that So, how how are
- they doing this? >> I mean, I think I think they've had a decent run. I mean, I I mean, a I think,
- you know, it's it's a lot of expectation. I mean, Rico Dao, for example, I'm not sure, you know, he was
- kind of somebody the Cowboys essentially discarded. And I mean, we can probably fill a whole show talking about Cowboys
- personnel moves and the questions behind them, but like my god, >> you know, this guy was like a throwaway
- essentially from the Cowboys and, you know, he's running for, you know, 150 yard, whatever he's averaging right now,
- over 100 yards a game, I'm pretty sure. So, I think they've found a couple diamonds in the rough and I think, you
- know, I I have to actually look a little bit more closely at their schedule to sort of see who they've played as well.
- Well, I do know the I mean, I've been paying attention to the Pats, another interesting strength of schedule kind of
- team, but uh the Pats completely destroyed them when they played them a few weeks ago. But
- >> yeah, that's the only observation I have beyond yesterday's game or >> but it's just it's an interesting idea
- of, you know, we don't we have no idea how much credit Eric should get for any of this. So, we don't want to act it
- like it's Eric's saying he's like, you know, he's like number three down there and he's he's involved, but we don't
- know. There's a lot of factors, zillion factor, but what's true is we worry about analytics not having a seat at the
- table. And a lot of organizations have analysts, but the analysts don't influence decision- making. We can be
- pretty sure that at at least there's a some level of influence by analytics in the Carolina decision-m just by who's
- over there and why and and why they brought them in. And whenever you go at it, as as we know, Eric goes at things,
- they're going to know players around the league in real fine detail. They're not
- going to they're not people aren't going to they're not going to be diamonds in the rough that other teams know that
- they don't have some indication on and they're not going to get real enthusiastic about guys who aren't worth
- some enthusiast. They're going to miss a lot of guys by a lot. And I think you can't be quite that sure of most NFL
- organizations. >> Yeah. Yeah, I think it really it would be kind of like where I mean again it's
- Eric's been better a couple you're you know I think grading draft somebody somebody with more sort of savvy and
- like domain knowledge than I would you know you can do things like I I think grading the last couple drafts is
- probably somewhat valuable but of course the real grade of those last couple drafts will see in actuality in like two
- or three four years right it's beyond expectation now >> undoubtedly but we're we I think we
- sometimes worry too much about the draft and not enough about the pro personnel scouting, the pro personnel side. And
- look at >> Speaking of pro personnel, I know it's it's Shane, but I'll stay with football.
- Uh the Jets seem to have unloaded their superstar. >> It's a fire style today. >> And uh I mean, what what's the what's
- the relative value of two first round picks relative to a proven star quarterback? I
- >> I don't know that did that make sense or what? I >> mean, I I'm I'm real skeptical. Um those
- those picks are you have to pay full ride for a I don't know the deal details of the contract. Okay. So I I haven't
- looked at Sauce Gardener contracts, >> but you're generally paying full ride for someone who's off past their first
- contract where on the first contract, this is the deal. They're set in a way that in expectation there's positive
- value. And that's more true about first round picks than subsequent picks. So you're giving away in expectation a lot
- of value. Whereas for a free agent, an expectation is you're paying full right. You're not getting value. Now, that's
- setting aside the impact they have on the rest of the team if you believe that kind of thing. But lots of teams have
- made those trades expecting there to be these kinds of synergies that don't ever
- pan out. I think interesting to see this a team, the Colts make this play. You know, they're obviously playing with the
- Rams playbook from a few years ago where it's like, we're not going to try to hoard picks. we're going to go all in
- right now and it's a risky risky proposition. >> It is. I mean I I guess the one thing
- kind of that you just didn't mention Kade that like is part of at least the calculus from the Colts perspective is
- you know this is it's a win now move but it's also you know they're unlikely that
- that first round pick that they just trade away at least for next year is likely to be right at the it's
- essentially like the tail right at the tail end of the first round. Okay. And again, if they, you know, if if if again
- sauce continues to help them be a good team, the the trade that the pick they traded for, you know, 2027 will also be
- at the tail end of the first round. So, these are not, you know, under most expectations, these are not high first
- round picks. I don't know how much Yeah. I mean, >> the other thing you have to look at does
- it matter. >> I mean, Tus Gardner is a genuine superstar. He's a first two in three
- seasons, he's been twice a Pro Bowl first team quarterback. I mean, this is a this is a differencemaking.
- >> Williams, their defensive tackle that they just traded as the same thing. He was an all pro and like pro
- >> boy a first I mean in expectation a first round draft pick is fine but in probability of being a superstar
- I don't see it. Well, I guess they're paying the extra first rounder because they're basically
- getting a first, you know, kind of a realized first round talent as opposed to the expectation of one in Sauce
- Godner. A realized one plus and they're paying an extra first rounder for that realization as opposed to the the
- expectation of it. >> Well, Gardner's position was what what was he in the first round? Do do any
- guys remember? >> He was like mid wasn't first round. Um, yeah, he was pretty he was he the first
- quarterback taken? I think he might have been the first quarter. He might have been, but I don't know if he was top 10
- or anything like that. >> I I I hear you. I agree. I agree with that. You know, it goes to these
- questions of roster construction and the it all of it always goes back to one issue that's essentially immeasurable in
- the NFL and that is are there externalities? Are guys worth more because they make other guys better? And
- how can we value that? >> And we have a sense that that's true for some positions in particular, but it's
- really hard to put a number on it. I I did, speaking of putting a number on it, I I was reading a little bit about
- um about quarterback valuation, and I I gather the way they they value them is how many uh snaps are there before they
- there's a successful completion. So, they get credit when the people they're guarding are not targeted.
- >> I thought that was clever. You don't see that all the time. >> That we used to get that wrong, right?
- >> All the time instead of a cumulative measure or something like that. >> People aren't throwing out. That's a
- nice way to get at is it survival? Is there a survival curve? >> Right. And sauce garden is excellent,
- right? So he doesn't have many interceptions, but that's because nobody throws at the person he's covering.
- >> It's spectacular. And then what that doesn't capture odd is that if he can do
- that when he's manned up one-on-one, that frees up some of the defensive backs to go pay more attention to the
- other guys. So that's just that's underestimating the impact, right? Because he's having a positive impact on
- the on the on his teammates as well. >> Really good. Really really good. And I and I think it does say that like I mean
- just on the kind of cold side it does see it's a further indication they like really believe that this Indiana Jones
- thing is legit and that that's just kind of who they're because they basically tra they're trading away their ability
- to get a new quarterback essentially for the next two or three years at least via
- via the usual convention. So it's not even just this season they're going in on this guy because they're not going to
- with another that's interesting. Remind me what their division's like. Is part of their deal this year that they don't
- have anybody like they they come out of a weak division. I I mean we know Tennessee is
- >> well the Jagu I mean the Jaguars are I think at the Jaguars actually have a pretty decent record whether you again
- believe that or not you know I mean we're we're I've always I've always been hesitant to say too much consequential
- at the south of either of the two conferences right aren't those usually it's usually like chaos divisions but um
- but yeah I I mean the Jaguars are just a game behind them basically or loss behind them they're at five and three um
- and that's I mean the Texans are one of the worst teams in football and the Tex I mean sorry not the Texans the Titans
- >> the Titans and then the Texans >> Texans are not record but are not a good team
- >> if I'm just looking at the standings that Jaguars are a negative point differential which means they if
- anything they've overperformed >> yeah are actually quite good and have thoroughly underperformed at least by by
- score differential uh they're plus 47 yet they're three and five so I think you know in some level Indianapolis just
- doesn't have too much in their division that they're that worried about Yeah, right.
- >> We got to lose out on the number one seed to the Patriots obviously, but I mean that what getting ahead of
- ourselves here. Shane is back. >> Yeah, he is back and we're going to ignore it as much as possible. I am
- literally averting my eyes from the Patriots. I just can't yet accept that the Patriots are back and I'm not going
- >> You're not you're not ready for that Kansas City, New England uh AFC Championship game.
- >> No. And thank God [laughter] >> I mean thank god the Bills took the Chiefs down a notch on Sunday. That's
- good. But also just on the division race, one thing that I I realized kind of belatedly as the as the Ravens run
- off a couple of wins, you know, if you if you're pulling for the Ravens to do well this year, all you got to do is get
- them to the playoffs. And all you got to do for them to get to the playoffs is for them to win their division. Like
- that's that's one of the nice things about the NFL structure. It's it's weird in some ways because lame divisions can
- produce lame playoff contenders, but in this case, great. But now they got to beat the Steelers. So they've got the
- weak bigals and the weaker Browns and the middle middling Steelers that somehow always finish over 500 and Aaron
- Rogers, damn him, is having at least a reasonable season. But that's kind of the thing now is can we get the Ravens
- over the Steelers? That's like the now the race for the in the second half of the season is can we
- >> I mean the Steelers have locked into nine and eight, so that's really the [laughter] target,
- >> right? I mean >> um Yeah. No, I I mean I agree. I I I I think the market buys your story, Kate,
- because I mean, I feel like even at their nater, I don't think the Ravens stopped being like the favorite to win
- that division. And certainly now that they've rattled, you know, Lamar's back and everything, they got to be
- >> and and they made a trade. They gave away a, you know, fifth round pick or something
- conditional, maybe a fourth um to get a pass rusher in there. So, they're they're active. And hell, we I don't
- know. This is the day is not over. We haven't hit the trade deadline yet. Is it is this a different world, though?
- Right. This is the way baseball is. Football used to not be like this. We didn't
- >> Well, and again, we I think it just actually passed like literally a half hour ago, I think. So, I think we are
- past the trade deadline. But I I agree, Kate. I wanted to kind of note this if you didn't, that I feel like I mean,
- basically what the Jets did, I think, is unusual. Yeah. >> Like, you don't usually see NFL teams
- kind of fires sailing. I mean, B this was a very baseball move where they just kind of like recognized they were out of
- it and fires sailed their team. And I I think it's that's kind of unique. Maybe maybe you don't usually have bad really,
- you know, obviously, you know, one in seven teams that still have elite talent worth trading or something. I I don't
- know. Maybe maybe they had the unique unique potential to fire a sale more than most teams, but I still think their
- behavior today is unusual relative to what most trade deadlines happen at, you know.
- >> Um the and they learned they learned from baseball. This is learning across sports. This is this is you know you
- know I don't know if analytics analytics going to get blamed or credited for this. I don't know. It's just learning.
- It's just plain old learning. Um guys, I'll give you one open um caught my eye. A conversation I had with an NHL team in
- the last couple weeks that a concept I hadn't thought about before. I think y'all will be curious about it. How
- difficult do you think it is for these front offices, say a sport like the NHL, which is relatively late to the
- analytics game. Okay. So they're not advanced as as as the MLB and certainly certainly not MLB probably the least
- advanced of the four leagues in the major American sports. >> Office of the NHL, what are the chances
- they know how to hire good analysts? And so the the the hypothesis that this person put out there was that you can't
- really judge how how good how sharp how analytics forward a team is by how many analysts they have because the
- essentially the quality of the analysts vary dramatically because the people hiring them aren't analysts
- >> and it's they don't know whether they have someone good or not. And that's an
- intriguing idea and I hadn't considered it before. >> Yeah. I mean, I've sort of thought,
- again, I mostly thought about this in the context of baseball because, you know, I mean, you know, the not to pick
- again on on on the Yankees, but they have like I think one of the second or third largest like analytics department.
- They seem to invest a large amount of kind of attention and and and and money and and all that stuff into analytics.
- They seem to just do it wrong though or something. You know, I mean, like it's I'm not on the inside, so I don't know
- >> based on out they're doing it kind of wrong. Well, more than that of like that's just one example of something
- where it's like, you know, >> you throw a bunch of money at something, it won't necessarily
- improve it unless you actually have some vision there. And I, you know, I'm again, that's only the one example I can
- think of. >> AI, I remember getting a text from Audi at a conference not so long ago
- reporting about firsthand conversations with the members of some team that will go unnamed and he wasn't depending on
- seasonlong outcomes. He was talking about the process of the inputs and it wasn't favored.
- Well, you know, it's amazing because you you do recognize that there's enormous variability in the in the actual
- analysts themselves. Um, you know, I think the Dodgers spend the most. I mean, they're they just seem to be crazy
- and and I I think now that, you know, Ryan's now working for the for the uh Utah Jazz, the Dodgers hired him just
- and they said, "Here's some money. Just do whatever you like." >> That is that entire raid like baseball
- country as their farm system. >> Yeah. I mean, they just were like and and they're and they just they just
- invested in just trying to squeeze out and just throw, you know, the cast the net wide and you're going to get some
- great stuff just guaranteed, right? And um and and I do think the process >> but hold on. They chose Ryan. They
- didn't do that was a good choice based on our understanding of Ryan relative to talent in the world. That's they they
- could have thrown that money at poor peo poor Joyce as well, >> you know. And I have to say I I mean I
- so Sam Andre Cohen is now he's uh he's with the Marlins and the Marlins had a you know really unexpectedly great good
- season uh last year. Um and they they he the first thing that that Sam did is he
- hired someone a PhD out of Florida. Excellent. Told him you're running the analytics department. In other words, he
- didn't try to when he was with the Nationals he was out there doing his own hiring and he confessed to me I'm not an
- analyst. I'm happy using it, but you I can't judge this person from that person. And the first thing he did was
- get someone that he could trust, and he's excellent. His name is Bryant. Um to to really run the analytics show. Um
- I just think and he would call me up and and Sam would say, "I don't want to I I'm only interested in talking to your
- number ones. I'm not interested in two, three, four, and five." And I'd sometimes say, "But our two, three,
- four, and fives are excellent." >> Yeah. Yeah. >> This is this is this is a really
- interesting idea. And it's a source of variation that I hadn't considered before. Um, and apparently it explains
- some variation in the NHL. By the way, this person was hand he said hands down I trust this person's judgment. Hands
- down the sharpest most analytics forward team in the NHL is the Hurricanes. Um, so it's kind of them and then it's like
- a everybody else kind of thing. So just for what it's worth. Okay fellas, that was a quick uh do we want to do quick
- ones? I know we've spent our time but we haven't covered very much territory. real quick like 30 seconds to 60
- seconds. One more round of what caught your eye. Shane Jensen. >> Joe Flaco passing for 448 yards. The
- most ever by a player in his 40s. Obviously pick a breaking Tom Tom Brady record from a few years ago. 448 yards
- in a loss. >> Jojo man, >> am I up? Uh I watched the entirety of the Chiefs Bills and those two
- quarterbacks are unbelievable. >> Yeah, they are. They are. And there's a God in heaven. There's a God in heaven
- that Casey did not win that game again. Um, mine [laughter] will be, did y'all know there's a site where you can find
- the most expensive college football tickets of a weekend? Of a weekend and it's just a way of looking at, man, our
- buddy, our our our frequent listener, you've all wrote strike. You really ought to get assistant producer credit.
- He's been giving us so many good ideas over the years. He text me some weekends like who thinks most expensive this
- weekend. this weekend. Y'all don't know these things, but Texas Tech BYU, Texas Tech BYU, a Big 12 game, is the most
- expensive ticket in the country. It's a noon game, which means it's an 11 game in Lach. And this is going to be one of
- the bigger games in the Big 12. Both >> how much? >> 48 or something like that, which is a
- big ticket in Lock, Texas. the but these teams are both going to be by the way college football's first playoff you
- know 12 are going to come out right now like in a few hours doesn't mean anything but it's the first official one
- of the season both Tech and BYU are going to be in the top 12 but the amazing thing about this is BYU's
- undefeated they're going to be probably above Tech in the ratings they are 10point underdogs going into love it to
- play Texas Tech just absurd these are like the best two teams in the Big 12 and it's a 10-point spread really odd
- but that's a that's a big game a fun game and early game on Saturday to keep your eyes on.
- All right, guys. Let's wrap it there then. Good fun. Good fun. Always good to visit Tuesday afternoon here. The show
- will go up on Wednesday. Thank you for listening. Thank you to the whole team here. Marissa Raina, our producer, Dion
- Simkins, our everything, our Uber, our Uber, everything. And Deep Patel, the big boss lady. Eric Bradley and Abbencio
- for Audi Winer for Shane Jensen. This has been Kade Massie for our friend Dean Oliver guest in the first half of the
- show. Thank you guys for listening. Come back and join us next time between now and then. Enjoy your reports.
Brief Summary
Dean Oliver analyzes Victor Wembanyama's impact on the Spurs and discusses rookie performance in the NBA.
Key points
- Victor Wmanyama's Impact. Victor Wmanyama is making waves in his third season, showcasing frightening skills on the court.
- Spurs' Surprising Start. The Spurs began the season undefeated, raising expectations for their performance.
- Cooper Flag's Rookie Struggles. Cooper Flag, highly anticipated rookie, is facing challenges adjusting to the NBA.
- The Rookie Hype. Do rookies ever live up to their hype? A deep dive into rookie performances.
- LeBron's Decline. Discussing LeBron's performance and whether he can still deliver at his peak.
- The Role of Analytics. Exploring how analytics has transformed basketball and what the future holds.
Episode highlights
- Victor Wmanyama's ImpactVictor Wmanyama is making waves in his third season, showcasing frightening skills on the court.“He is so big and he is quick.”1:57Nov 10, 2025
- Spurs' Surprising StartThe Spurs began the season undefeated, raising expectations for their performance.“They started off undefeated. They now have a loss.”6:38Nov 10, 2025
- Cooper Flag's Rookie StrugglesCooper Flag, highly anticipated rookie, is facing challenges adjusting to the NBA.“He has been kind of a typical rookie struggling with a lot of things.”17:10Nov 10, 2025
- The Rookie HypeDo rookies ever live up to their hype? A deep dive into rookie performances.“Rookies generally are not they do they ever live up to their hype?”18:31Nov 10, 2025
- LeBron's DeclineDiscussing LeBron's performance and whether he can still deliver at his peak.“LeBron can’t be LeBron of yesteryear all the time, but can he still do it?”24:54Nov 10, 2025
- The Role of AnalyticsExploring how analytics has transformed basketball and what the future holds.“Analytics has changed basketball a lot. What’s the frontier?”31:59Nov 10, 2025
- Yamamoto's Unprecedented PerformanceYamamoto's pitching in the series raises questions about modern pitching strategies.“Are we missing something about what a pitcher is capable of?”37:39Nov 10, 2025
- Dodgers' World Series NarrativeThe Dodgers scored the least runs among the last 20 World Series winners, yet won.“This World Series is narrative, but I would be hesitant to extrapolate it.”40:16Nov 10, 2025





