Microsoft's Game-Changing Buy of Activision Blizzard – Wharton Professor Harbir Singh Interview

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Harbir Singh, Wharton Professor of Management and co-director of the Mack Institute for Innovation Management, joins host Dan Loney on Wharton Business Daily to discuss Microsoft’s acquisition of video game company Activision Blizzard. In this interview, Singh discusses the potential impact of the deal, from reactions from competitors to shifts in consumer engagement.

Wharton Business Daily airs Monday-Friday from 10 AM - 12 PM ET on SiriusXM Channel 132, featuring emerging trends, top business leaders & Wharton’s renowned professors. Learn more: http://whr.tn/businessdaily

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. well the closing of the Activision Microsoft deal is a big step forward for the two companies themselves the next
  2. question is how the two sides come together and the impact that they may provide on the video game industry
  3. pleasure to be joined by harier Singh who's a management Professor here at the Wharton School he is also co-director of
  4. the Mac Institute for Innovation management harb great to talk to you again yes thanks for inviting me thank
  5. you all right so obviously this is a deal that's been talked about for a while it's now starting to move forward
  6. what was your reaction to the deal itself and the potential impact of these two companies well it was actually quite a
  7. remarkable deal it was the largest deal that Microsoft had made and at 68.7 billion it was a very very large step uh
  8. it was also truly transformative and you could see that in the impact on Sony when the stock price
  9. of Sony on that particular period went down by 1% so it was a significant impact on the what people saw as the the
  10. PlayStation oriented gaming business um but also it was a way for Microsoft to really get time to Market this was
  11. something that uh they had kind of been envisioning and they had several offerings based on the Xbox and
  12. applications on the Xbox but um activation brizard gave them uh you know large numbers of users with Candy Crush
  13. and Call of Duty and other such uh uh games and also multiple platforms including the mobile the cloud um and
  14. and many others uh so I think this is truly a transformative deal and the other point that's worth making is that
  15. uh tech companies have been growing through acquisition at a remarkable Pace um and so in the just a few years ago
  16. they were relatively skittish about making Acquisitions because worrying about loss of talent which is is a real
  17. issue and also about organizational culture differences and so on but they have gone into this with both feet so
  18. then is the expectation that maybe we will continue to see even more types of Acquisitions in this Tech space as we
  19. move forward because especially if if these two companies are able to come together uh re relatively
  20. seamlessly I think that's exactly right the question is what is the competitive reaction from other players and uh they
  21. will also uh need to sort of access this Market which is moving very very fast uh
  22. it's a source of Revenue but there's also platform sharing people are working across platforms users are working
  23. across platforms um and I think the key issue which is tied to my uh interest in
  24. technology and Innovation is uh that firms are recognizing that uh internal development is a bit slow and therefore
  25. even though you might have fewer cultural differences sometimes you don't win with your internal products
  26. uh Partnerships are useful alliances are useful but then there's a question of you know the end game and when it comes
  27. to in the end game as in how do we share the returns over time and is there an opportunity where in fact uh one player
  28. needs to take charge and I think that's the issue with this gaming industry that
  29. uh there's you cannot have Microsoft and Activision being offered as a as a pair
  30. over the long run so you really have to sort of decide whether you want to access control but then you have to
  31. manage the relationship why then does a company like Microsoft go ahead and make an
  32. acquisition like this of Activision when they certainly have the resources to probably build out a lot of
  33. their own aspects of what they're going to be getting from Activision right um well you can think about you know uh
  34. Google buying YouTube right even though they had tremendous resources to do so and it was because YouTube was a
  35. platform that actually was you know had users and was was already integrated fully as a platform uh they also
  36. invested in Android which became a huge ecosystem uh so these companies have recognized unlike previous years where
  37. you had previous decades really where you had companies getting disrupted by the startups they're still getting
  38. disrupted but what they're seeing is maybe I should buy the startup or partner with the startup that's actually
  39. winning in their space now you're going to make some mistakes but then um those mistakes are small in relation to the
  40. payoff if you get some of these right Sati Nadella after this deal was announced mentioned that he felt that
  41. this allowed Microsoft to make a real contribution to Consumer markets and I found that interesting because I think
  42. of Microsoft and all the different products that they bring to Market as one that has already connected with the
  43. consumer I guess he didn't feel that way and that activ Vision really gave him that path to be able to do
  44. so yes uh and it's fascinating you mention that because uh you know Steve bomber who preceded Satya did a
  45. phenomenal job in many many ways but his idea was to focus really on the office platform right and uh those kinds of
  46. applications and so they did well with that and they never really had enough of a strength in the entertainment area and
  47. I think Apple kind of showed that you can be seamless across on the on the mobile device
  48. um and Xbox you know in a sense was always a little uh you know it was a hardware based second platform right
  49. whereas Apple had this digital Hub across all platforms so and in fact Satya was um when he came in he had to
  50. resar to the mobile business now that meant that there were developers already there but to sort of give them the
  51. visibility and the resources and this is sort of a step where you're getting to the entertainment desktop but it's no
  52. longer a desktop it's the mobile PL platform it's the cloud it's streaming it's all those
  53. possibilities how much does Microsoft need to put its own fingerprint on Activision as it moves forward or is it
  54. easier just to I mean obviously Activision has been a very successful company do you leave it run primarily
  55. the way it has run maybe with just some minor touches here and there I think that's an excellent question and that's
  56. the core issue um what Microsoft did with LinkedIn perhaps is uh the way they need to manage Activision uh which is
  57. they left LinkedIn largely alone and this was the fear when they bought LinkedIn that they might actually lose
  58. the community because you know Microsoft still has this complex image right of being kind of a you know more a business
  59. application kind of firm and now you're in a territory of individual users of all ages in the case of Activision so um
  60. they have a template with their acquisition of LinkedIn which they would be you know
  61. it'll be advised to pursue that uh in other words autonomy to the unit giving it the complimentary resources it needs
  62. um and also sort of ensuring that the that the culture of Activision uh remains um what brought it to this point
  63. you know you might actually manage the you might may disrupt the culture through this acquisition that was going
  64. to be my next question because you obviously want this to be as successful a deal as possible and for Microsoft
  65. they probably have to be aware of not trying to overdo it as as they kind of bring all these elements on board
  66. absolutely and you know there's a real danger of this is where Tech firms have had a long history of failures where uh
  67. they send in you know armies of people who have good intentions but they're saying you have to adopt this system you
  68. have to up this way of doing things this is our process for making decisions um and you know immediately you're imposing
  69. bureaucracy on the other side um and I think that is a real danger that they have um they seem to have done well with
  70. many of the more recent acquisitions so but this is something that they have to continue to follow and the reason why
  71. I'm bringing this up is that culture really is about shared Norms values and beliefs and those are already all set in
  72. activism it's a big big organ $69 billion in value yeah it's it's got revenue it's got you know developers
  73. it's got It's got lots of Assets in place and the first question they would have is is this a penalty for Success
  74. you know we did well and now we being bought by this company luckily Microsoft's image is
  75. positive and and can actually be helpful but that's not enough you know you need
  76. to ensure that the Innovation engine remains intact so then look at this from the other side from Activision side and
  77. and where do they see the the the best paths to success and adding on to the success they've already had as they move
  78. forward so on that front this is a great transaction uh because uh they can get the scale of Microsoft uh they can get
  79. the complimentary resources um they have long-term durability in their strategy uh and I
  80. think a way to manage this and there are some templates actually going quite a quite far back IBM bought Lotus for
  81. networking software and actually the way it was managed was Lotus was accessing the resource so they were asking them to
  82. use the parent as a uh as a as a menu of possible resources and you kind of cherry pick what you want so that would
  83. be an ideal kind of situation if Activision kind of uh drives the uh the the the choice of complimentary
  84. resources for Microsoft uh capital of course is easy but the rest of it uh you know how to how to seamlessly connect to
  85. the platforms Microsoft also has the cloud for example those are important issues to think about how do you think
  86. then the the uh the remainder of the tech sector looks at this at this acquisition as it's gone through and
  87. obviously the other side to it is also the process that it went through uh with all the regulatory hurdles that it had
  88. to clear both here in the US and and abroad as well how does the industry as a whole look at this deal this is a
  89. transformative deal it is changing uh you know you can almost think about the ecosystems you know of users and the now
  90. Microsoft has a position as um into a major player and actually providing their ecosystem in addition to that of
  91. Activision so um players in the industry uh now need to recognize that there are
  92. Deep Pockets that is uh there is a long-term perspective um and so um how do how do the sort of the relationships
  93. among different players with long-term connections between them how do those relationships change within their own
  94. ecosystem so that's the first point the second point is speaking to the antitrust issue which is I think a a
  95. really really important issue uh it was a real surprise to many that because the
  96. antitrust authorities had actually mentioned that they're going to take a very hard look at there lots of scrutiny
  97. uh but the European side actually um you know the British Authority in particular
  98. the competition markets Authority um sort of indicated that they were willing to go along with this and I think that
  99. was the the signal that uh other players kind of saw as indicative of uh how this
  100. will go forward because the very thing that we say is a good deal for Microsoft can be seen as anti-competitive from an
  101. anti point of view you mentioned the word ecosystem a moment ago you mentioned a couple of times in the
  102. interview and I guess from Microsoft's perspective there's an element of of what Sati nadela and the company wanted
  103. to kind of reach looking at as you said what Apple has kind of set up yes and I guess to degree Amazon is is kind of in
  104. that same boat as well they have both built ecosystems that allow people to come in
  105. maybe at One Touch point but also be able to benefit from so many other touch points and and I guess that's what
  106. Microsoft's looking to try and build as well yes I think the complimentary resources the complimentary activities
  107. uh and users have kind of you know there was a the thought kind of just a few years ago that an ecosystem has to be
  108. open but the Apple evil ecosystem is kind of partially open it's also very proprietary the iOS and people have been
  109. willing to live with that for now this is always a question um I think Microsoft has had traditionally a more
  110. you know open ecosystem uh and the seamlessness of you know these kinds of applications like games and the other
  111. activities that you can get from other parts of the ecosystem that Microsoft has uh is potentially a real a real
  112. asset and by the way it's all about time to Market and the other concept for you
  113. that's interesting in this discussion is market value versus replacement value okay so $69 billion what it would take
  114. to actually replace activism through Microsoft's own activities whether it's internal or through Partnerships and
  115. without doing proper calculations there aren't you know these are not tradable assets you have to buy them you can't
  116. sort of if they don't want to partner with you there's no other choice yeah yeah you're talking about
  117. the investment that it would take for for Microsoft to build out each of the components that they would need to get
  118. to where Activision is right now and they have tried of course they've had the xbo ecosystem and so on and you know
  119. the the user base is not as strong I mean this happens you know you you realize you're not winning a particular
  120. race um but you have complimentary asset there's value on both sides here it's not as they're just buying into it and
  121. and holding let me finish up by asking you one of the questions that's obviously been out there a lot around Ai
  122. and and thinking about this deal and thinking about tech in general how AI will be impacting these companies and
  123. these types of deals moving forward right I think that's a also a very very important question we are so early in
  124. the evolution of AI you know it's almost like the early stages of uh you know microprocessor chips and look how far
  125. they came and this is not even Hardware based so the possibilities are still emerging uh but there's no doubt that
  126. there will be an impact uh in many many ways including how users uh end up using
  127. AI U but also how developers use AI so I think that from the development side you
  128. might see uh dramatic changes uh within um The Gaming Arena you know and and also in applications harbe always great
  129. to get your Insight thank you very much thank you so much thank you harbe sing man management Professor here at the
  130. Wharton School also co-director of the Mac Institute for Innovation management

Brief Summary

Harbir Singh discusses the Microsoft-Activision deal's impact on gaming and tech acquisitions, emphasizing cultural integration and future AI developments.

Key points

  • Microsoft's Transformative Acquisition. The Microsoft-Activision deal marks a significant shift in the gaming industry landscape.
  • Cultural Integration Challenges. Managing Activision's culture post-acquisition is crucial for success.
  • AI's Future Impact. The evolution of AI will dramatically change the gaming industry and tech deals.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes