NFL Week 1 Review: Fourth Down Decisions, Super Bowl Odds, and Kickoff Returns
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
ABOUT THE EPISODE Wharton Moneyball features ESPN’s Brian Burke on the revamped Football Power Index (FPI), a Bayesian model that combines Vegas priors with play-by-play efficiency to track team strength. Early outputs place Green Bay among the top contenders and give the Chargers a temporary edge over Kansas City due to the weight of early wins in the simulation.
They revisit Baltimore’s costly 4th-down punt and explore clearer ways to convey uncertainty—whether through playoff brackets designed to reflect historical patterns or upset quartets structured so that probability indicates one underdog is likely to prevail.
They also cover the NFL’s dramatic spike in kickoff returns under new rules, the Alcaraz–Sinner rivalry framed as ceiling versus consistency, and MLB closing in on a rare milestone with four players on pace for 50-home-run seasons.
ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? The Moneyball podcast explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.
#SportsAnalytics #NFLWeek1 #FootballAnalytics #NFLHighlights #FootballAnalysis ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- Welcome, welcome to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to a full hour of sports analytics here on the Wharton podcast
- network. This is Kate Massie hosting this week with my longtime collaborators and friends, co-host, colleagues, Shane
- Jensen and Eric Bradlo. Our fourth co-host, Audi Winer, not in today, sadly. Audi out and about. Audi doing
- Audi things. Audi doing things the rest of us are jealous of. Audi's is not gonna be with us today, but he will be
- back. Some combination of us, y'all know this. Some combination of us are here almost every week of the year. 48, 49,
- 50 weeks of the year. We're here doing the show. Have been for more than 11 years now. Delighted to be back. We're
- recording on Tuesday afternoon as we usually do. Gonna do an hour. Gonna do the first half hour with guests. Going
- to roll into open lines, open topics in the second half hour. Got to start the show straight away with a guest and one
- of our regulars, one of our favorites, one of our long times, a family, practically families, Wharton Moneyball
- family, Brian Burke. Brian Burke is here from ESPN. Brian, thank you for making time.
- >> Yeah, thank you uh for having me. Uh always enjoy being on and I feel like uh
- like the fifth beetle kind of like uh I want to be a co-host and I feel like you watch like a show long enough like
- Seinfeld, right? And you're like, I could be in the part in the apartment with Jerry and Elaine and George and
- we'd all just get along. I Yeah. Here's what >> I think. I think Hold on. I think I
- think you're the Eric Clapton of the Beatles. I think I think that's the right role for you. I'm gonna give you
- the >> I was going to say, Brian, the next time I can offer for myself, the next time
- it's just me that's available, rather than me talking to myself for an hour on the radio, why don't you come join me
- and you can co-host with me and we'll we'll talk some sports for an hour. >> Yes. Oh, absolutely. I want to be the
- designated Audi. Um >> I don't That's tough, man. That's tough. >> Those are those are some big shoes to
- fill. Literally. >> I just He asks the toughest questions and I actually I appreciate that more
- than anything. Even when he's asking me the tough questions because you learn you learn that way.
- >> Yeah, he's uh we all aspire to more audience in our intellectual work. For sure. Brian, as most of y'all know, is
- at ESPN. He's a sports data scientist at ESPN. He's also the founder of the website advanced football analytics. He
- was one of the very first to step out um when football analytics started getting
- sophisticated. He was a Navy fighter pilot in a previous life. He moved from this black and white engineering world
- into the shades of gray probability big transformation midlife transformation and now he's right on the edge of all
- things all things football analytics. Brian, so much to talk about. Week one is in the books. Um, why don't we start
- there? We've got deeper topics for you, but you know, you're a football guy. You've been waiting all season for this
- to happen. Now that we've seen 16 games played, what's top of mind for you? >> Yeah. Um, a team that impresses me the
- most right now is Green Bay. Obviously, they they picked up a a superstar defender. Um, convincing win over a top
- uh conference and division opponent. Um, and so we actually have we we're looking
- at them with the fourth best chance to make a Super Bowl. So, um, yeah. >> So, talk real quickly about your fourth
- best chance. Is that one of these flat maxima situations? Because this seems like a pretty open year. So, what are
- the first three look like? And where are the pack? Where's the pack? >> Yeah. Yeah. So, you're you're absolutely
- right. It it pretty much always is is that way. It's a little flatter this year than than normal, but we have uh
- Baltimore, Buffalo, Philadelphia, and then Green Bay. Um actually, here's another one I'll throw
- out. I'm just looking at this. Uh Chargers have a better shot over Kansas City right now. Obviously, they have a
- win in hand over them. Um but I'm still really surprised to see that. Uh you know, we'll see if that comes to pass.
- I'm always prepared. One of the last questions sometimes is like what are you looking for, you know, in this upcoming
- season? And I'm I'm waiting for the Chiefs to kind of have have a down year. It they're way overdue, but this could
- be this could be that year. >> Brian, what would you what would you take as an early marker? It's easy to
- call a down year, you know, threequarters of the way through the season. If you want to call it early,
- being a good prognosticator, what would be a sign of this is going to be a bad year for the Chiefs?
- Gosh. Um, uh, Chris Jones not playing well. Yeah, just uh early injuries. Um, they've already got a suspended player.
- Um, so yeah, just depletion early on. Depletion early on and and just um, you know, losing a couple games that they
- they shouldn't. I mean, the the Brazil game, it's really weird. There's just a lot of travel. It's international. It's
- the first game of the year. you know, you can set that aside. But, um, that would be one thing to look at. They just
- they've been so good for so long. Um, maybe it is maybe it is time. Maybe it's just me wish casting as an AFC, you
- know, rival for him. >> But could be the thing to >> Exactly, Brian. I I put in my I lit my
- candles last week on this show, said my prayers, put put it out there as a long-suffering a not just one AFC team,
- but two AFC teams beating at the door behind the Chiefs. I'm ready for them to step aside. Eric's trying to jump in
- here. Speaking of uh Yeah, a little a little AFC ascia. It's a little bit. >> No, no, I'm staying with I'm staying
- with my question is more >> your answer to Kate's question. So, when Kate asked you like what caught your eye
- in week one, I could imagine a lot of things. One could be which teams are at the top. Two is which teams surprised
- you the most? Three, it could be which teams foot FBI move the most. um which teams exceeded the line the most which
- could be different than which teams m move the most. Um how did you think about answering Kate's question and what
- what was surprising to you? And I'm leaving surprising broadly defined here. >> I mean that's a good way to organize all
- those all those things. Um the Colts moved the most uh up um just because they the size of their victory was so
- big. Um, and the way FBI works is basically um, EPA uh, per play. Uh, so if you have big chunk EPA gains um, and
- your defense plays really well on top of that, then you're you're going to you're
- going to move up. And the priors are fairly weak um, on the NFL side. Uh, so it's easy for teams to move. They they
- bumped up almost three points on a per game basis. So, if we thought that they were, let's say, a three-point underdog
- against the average team on a neutral site, now we think, you know, they're they're probably just about average is
- where we are. >> This is great because you've answered my question because I was going to say
- you're not focused purely on the difference in their rank because they could be very bunched up and so they
- moved a little bit, but they jumped. You're actually focused on their underlying latent strength parameter,
- which is something that's continuous, which seems to me to be a better measure of strength.
- Uh yeah. Yeah. I mean you're you're you're absolutely correct. So in the NFL in particular, the the middle so like
- the middle 20 teams, let's say, um are bunched up together almost indistinguishable in in a certain way.
- Like yeah, we might have, you know, the the number 12 best team ranked as like a
- plus one over the average team, one point per game over the average team. And you know, the the 20th or 22nd best
- team might be, you know, minus one or 1.5 or something like that. But then there's this uncertainty around all of
- them and they're just kind of in this this muddied middle. Um so you can shoot up a bunch of rank point, you know, rank
- numbers pretty easily, especially early in the year. Uh the Bengals are one, they struggled against the Browns. Uh so
- they're they got moved down. So they're the second biggest mover. Um looks like Houston as well. They were they they
- dropped a few point few uh ranked points, but yeah, the Bengals just did not did not impress.
- Brian, can you talk a little bit more about FBI uh in general? How much do y'all revise that year-over-year? My
- sense is that some years it's minor tweaks, some years it's major tweaks. Where are we in the cycle? And what has
- been your role? How confident do you feel about that power ranking system? >> Um it's a really good question,
- especially in light of the college rankings last week. Uh we took some arrows. Um we can get into that if you
- like but uh the I I rebuilt this FBI model from the ground up uh starting last season. So last season was the
- first year with a new uh completely new revised model. It is it's not only rebuilt every year though as far as like
- the parameters go. It's rebuilt every every time we run it. it it re um relearns all the different parameters
- and how heavy the the prior should be weighted and all the other kind of hyperparameters within within the model.
- It's a basian regression. Um so everything is kind of relearned. It's always sort of up to date. It goes back
- about you uses about the past 10 seasons to kind of calibrate things. Um so I'm I'm really confident it did like
- embarrassingly well last year. uh so well that I I know we're just due for a horrible reversion to the mean uh this
- season. But yeah, really confident. Part part of the reason we're so confident is
- the priors are very solid. We we kind of cheat and we reverse engineer the Vegas
- overunder like win totals um as kind of our starting point for the prior. So we're always pretty chalk in the
- beginning of the year. Um >> Okay. Well, let's stay with that for a second because you you said is basian
- and of course this is a quite a basian podcast if only implicitly but the the hallmark I would say is as the only you
- know probably most outside basian person on the podcast I would say the hallmark
- is this whole idea that you have prior and that you update with as new information comes in that's kind of the
- hallmark of a basian system and so trick it's one thing to it's one thing to backwards engineer prior from the
- betting market that's fine lots of folks can do that But now you've got to decide
- how much weight to give those things. >> Yeah. >> And so can can you talk to us about what
- you find? What's the optimal weight? And we often talk about it in terms of I I think I I think I got this term
- somewhere fellas fictitious sample size. Like how many games worth of information
- is in the prior? Meaning after after how many games of the season is the rating that you have on the team half prior and
- half games? Shane, I'm sorry for staying in there for just a second. Yeah, and if
- I could just add a specific kind of thing, too. You you you talked earlier about how, you know, these teams after
- week one are moving quite a bit because the the these carefully designed priors,
- it sounds like you don't actually put much weight on to start the season. I'm a little surprised by that.
- >> Well, we don't decide the weight of the prior. The the model decides itself. So,
- we're looking at the past 10 seasons or so, and we're letting the model find the
- the way I term it is like the least unlikely. They're all unlikely. All these parameters are extremely unlikely.
- You know, we have the Ravens number one right now, like plus 6.1 points per game. The the the chance that they
- actually end up that way or that they are like, you know, sort of um you know, ground truth truly 6.1 are is extremely
- unlikely. It's just the least unlikely of all the different uh and then the weights of the prior basically the the
- width of the the the prior distributions the uncertainty around our estimates is
- what is basically what the weight is when we say weight of the priors and that is left for the model to learn on
- its own. Yeah, I was going to say this is a this is a specific term as you know Brian in basian inference that's why it
- also pays to be basian besides it's the only coherent form of inference it's called self-norming you don't have to
- decide the weight it decides the weight it's the ratio of of in some sense what K described the effective number of
- games in the prior in this case the effective number of games in the likelihood or the data but the data
- decides that and so >> with an extra loop where you cross valid I mean the model doesn't inherently a
- basing model does not decide that >> you're adding an extra loop over kind of like the you know cross validation kind
- of loop over over possible waitings of the prior and the likelihood I guess I'll rephrase my question I'm surprised
- that the priors are given by this process a small weight >> given he doesn't know he
- >> you might be exaggerating you might be overemphasizing his comment that things
- move >> it's smaller than college. I'll say that it's small. >> Well, the fact that you would move say
- the Chiefs, the Chargers over the Chiefs based on one game, I think shows that the data is maybe
- >> ranking that was the forecast. I was >> right. So, we we we think the Chiefs are
- slightly better than the Chargers still, but uh because of that win in hand and and the chance that they'll have the
- tiebreaker uh at the end of the year as well, just those those two things are enough to give them a better chance uh
- at the Super Bowl given at the current snapshot. I'm asking my question because I'm always trying to develop my own
- intuition, but also helping our listeners develop their intuition for how much weight we should have on prior
- because that's that's kind of the whole game is how much we're reacting to new information when it comes in. And there
- are lots of people who aren't doing this empirically and they're saying, "Well, at this point in the season, we
- shouldn't have any old information, so we're just kind of writing it down to zero." which we would oppose. But I
- think that is so wrong because I think if you let the model tell you what's optimal and what we're talk what we're
- saying is what's optimal for prediction. So when you say I let the model tell me
- what the weight should be that's because the model's looking historically over 10
- years if I wanted to predict as effectively as possible I would keep this weight. It would move like this.
- Great. Do you have any sense? I know that you didn't you weren't prepared for this question, but I'm asking you, you
- know, either h at the halfway point or at the end of the season, at the end of the season, what's the weight of the
- prior still? Because I think most people don't have good intuition. It >> I don't know. I I can exactly the way I
- can't give you a number. I know it's still there. It never goes away. Um and it probably shouldn't uh in in the vast
- majority of cases. One of the things I have been thinking of is that um before I get into that I will say one of
- the things I have studied in the past is how much luck is involved in observed outcomes. And I know that you get in the
- NFL I think you have to get past maybe 11 games before sort of the observed signal is as as strong as the the random
- um share the variance in in game outcome. So you can you can it's it's a pretty easy exercise to do with a
- binomial distribution. Um you know the variance of a a purely random binomial and then you have the variance of the
- actual game outcomes and you can just subtract the variances and you and so you you I think you have to get past the
- 11th game before you are just even just break even with the luck. So um everybody take a breath um take a couple
- breaths long. >> Yeah. And and the the thing I mentioned with the college um our college FBI is
- at the other end of its kind of life cycle. It is at the end of its life cycle. It is is not as modern as as the
- NFL model is. I'm not exactly sure. I don't work directly on that project. Um but we yeah we were criticized because
- uh Texas lost Ohio State um and they remained number one in in FBI and a lot of people don't quite uh fully
- understand what FBI is supposed doing combined with a lot of conspiracy thoughts and uh and and and other things
- and we we we took a lot of arrows for that but um I think the the prior are stronger on the college side and that
- that's probably why they stop. >> No, no, no, no. It wasn't even it wasn't even that the postgame expectancy was
- not only pro Texas, but it was like wildly pro Texas. Like the the signal in the game to the extent that there was
- signal in the game favored Texas like like I think Bill Connley said it was one of the biggest discrepancies. It was
- the biggest discrepancy of week one. It was one of the bigger ones you'll see. Yeah, we we took um I think we took
- solace. I think Bill had Texas like 15th or something after that. So, we're like,
- "Yeah, we know we maybe we're wrong, but um we're not alone." Uh but yeah, saying
- Bill dropped Bill dropped Texas to 15 after >> I don't think they started very high. I
- don't think they had nearly as high. We had them as a solid number one >> going into the season. I don't think he
- was as high, but I don't know. I don't >> Is Bill just putting his thumb on this
- scale? He He doesn't He doesn't like Texas. He's He's a Oklahoma guy at heart. I'm I'm joking, of course, but I
- I would take whether they're one or 15. I think that's interesting. Who you you moved too little, he moved too much, it
- seems. >> Yeah, we did move them down. I mean, they lost by one score on the road, you
- know, against a great team. And so, they're not going to move very much. So, it's just a a question of how tightly
- were they bunched kind of going in uh to that game. And and we we had, you know,
- our priors are unlike the NF on the NFL side, they're kind of purely um we don't
- cheat with them. They are built on top of how well you did last year. Uh how many returning starters do you have? Did
- your coach change? I think there's some special attention placed on a returning quarterback. Um and that's what drives
- Oh, and how many, you know, four or five star recruits do you have in the pipeline over the last I don't know,
- like two or three years or so. Um, and that used to work really, really well. And over the last, you know, two years
- or three years, the sport has completely changed. And so that no longer works as
- well. And we should probably have a lot less confidence in our in our preseason estimates of these teams.
- >> Well, it'll be fun. When the FBI, I first got to know it on the college scene, and when it first came out, I
- thought it was one of the best public models available. And it and we we found it really tracked massive body, which
- impressed us. And this is just speaking to how hard it is to keep up. I mean, the world evolves,
- you know, not only the world evolves, but other other people jump in, competition evolves, and you got to stay
- on top of things if you want to be a cutting edge power ranking system. And let me just say I mean this sounds it is
- of course the realm of the geeks and we and we are all geeks in this podcast but
- the claim is you you don't understand the game very well or you don't understand what you're
- looking at very well if you can't predict what's going to happen. It's almost the hallmark of how well you
- understand it if you can predict what happens next. And so I take it this is kind of performance evaluation. You know
- it's like do you understand? I mean can you really tell us who's good and why they're good? And if you could, then you
- could predict what's going to happen next. And that's really hard to do. So, let's all just compete on who can
- predict because it says something about how well we understand the game. >> Absolutely. Yeah. I mean, just and
- that's true of science in general. You have a theory and theories make predictions and you test the theory
- based on, you know, how how closely the observations uh track with with their predictions. And that um you know that
- basically what we're talking about is like a a science of football just applying the scientific method to to
- something. just yeah it's wildly you know hard to pin down of course there's so much that
- we don't understand yet and there's so much that we don't understand because we're not as deep in the game as the
- people who do it for a living and let's talk about a detail of the game another thing that you've done in your football
- life is build fourth down models and so I know you've you continually tweaked those as well because we think
- they're really good and then we find holes and we make them better we find some more holes we make them better but
- there was a a questionable fourth down call. The high-profile game, one of the highest profile games of the
- weekend was Baltimore going up to Buffalo. Lost a 15-point lead in the last four minutes of the game, including
- uh a decision to punt the ball away um late. Do you have a take on that decision? And how could how should we
- think about it? How are you thinking about it? >> Yeah, the model the model had I think
- 80% for go for it. The initial uh play by play I think had it a fourth and two and I think later they change it
- to a fourth and three which isn't going to change things very much because we had the punt at 70%. So I'm
- approximating. So I think it might have been like 81 versus 72 or something like
- that. So the order of magnitude of the error is like 10% like win probability which Brian you're you're going a little
- shortand some who may not be familiar including possibly me. 81 versus 72. >> Oh chance to win. So, if I go for it,
- your chance of winning in that situation would be about 81%. If you uh punted in that situation, we
- would estimate it's about 70 to 71, something like that. It was about 80 to 70. Um, which is a huge difference. Most
- even big sort of enormous obvious fourth down errors can be maybe like two percentage points of win or three
- percentage points of win probability. So when you get you get somebody like John
- Harbaugh with a 10% error, you know something something is up. Something something is off. Um and after the game,
- I think there there's reporting that uh Lamar Jackson had was cramping in that final series. So and he's integral
- obviously to any kind of short yardage. Um and they elected to punt. So I think that that played a part. I watched the
- play before. or if you watch very closely, Ed Oliver absolutely obliterates Lamar Jackson on the play
- before and I think that was probably there's some some you know that would cause some quote unquote cramping for
- sure. I think that must have played into it because the Ravens have really been the best at this for a long time. And in
- fact, there was almost an identical situation. I think it was 2021 week two against the Chiefs and they had a small
- lead, you know, within a field goal lead. And there's about two minutes left to play. They were faced with a fourth
- and two uh on their own side of the field about their own, you know, 39 38 yard line, exact same place spot on the
- field. They went for it, converted and kept kept the win. So, uh, very surprising, but I think the the answer
- lies with, uh, just a banged up quarterback. >> Something we don't know. Interesting.
- Really interesting. Shane, were you trying to get in? >> No, I mean, I I I I guess it is
- interesting to kind of hear that maybe that context uh that Brian just brought up just because, you know, I was going
- to kind of jump in and say like, you know, of all the teams to go forward on fourth and three, I think maybe only
- Philadelphia would be a higher chance of converting. I think in general the personnel that the Ravens have. But now
- you say that, you know, if Lamar was, you know, kind of banged up and very kind of locally right around that play
- that that that would that would help explain it. That would be the only thing in my mind that would
- >> Do the Bills know that though? >> Do the Bills know that? And and do do you have any other players on your team
- who can pick up three yards on the Ravens? Like so I And is and it's 10%. you know, and like so I I still would
- have probably gone for it if that were me. I'm I'm not trying to make excuses. I think they still should have gone for
- it and I'm on the record and I you know said so on on on Twitter but uh I mean that that probably explains and it
- probably you know we we when we look at the end of the season and we look back and do a complete sort of meta analysis
- of like fourth down trends and who are what which decisions were the biggest errors.
- Oftentimes we find the biggest errors are on the like the go for it side like which is very unexpected and the reason
- is like injured kickers or injured punters >> long snapper you is is in the locker
- room getting x-rays >> there's always there's usually some sort of context that we're the models aren't
- picking up. Isn't this isn't this literally the broken leg problem that people talk about with when you go with
- models and when you don't go with models? Like you you the one of the few times if you have a good algorithm, one
- of the few times that you don't go with the algorithm is if you know it's missing something. And the example
- people give is like if you're supposed to model who's going to win a race and you know the runner has a broken leg. So
- then you don't use the model and you're literally giving those examples from your from your review of Sports.
- >> So this is an interesting example. So I would assume Brian whether Baltimore won
- the game lost the game. Your estimate of their FBI or strength parameter wouldn't
- actually change that much. But what does change a lot is now their probability of
- let's say winning the AFC or going to the Super Bowl. So can you give us a sense of how big a magnitude of an
- effect you had there? It's not like if I if Baltimore I don't even know who they're playing next week. Whether they
- m went for it and won 38-37 or lost 40 to 38. The probability of win ain't going to change Buckus as we say now. I
- mean there's only I hate to say it there's only 16 games left and they got to catch up two games essentially on the
- Bills and that's not going to be easy. So how much is their let's call it go to the Super Bowl probability change?
- >> Yeah, I honestly Eric you asked the exact same question I was going to anyway. It's like can we kind of think
- about because you talked about this 10% on a game level being dramatic like can can we talk about season level kind of
- errors given the sort of the the tiebreaking consequences of this particular victory and stuff like that?
- >> Yeah, we don't I'm I'm trying to look at it right now. Um so we would say I think
- we had them 19.6 to make the Super Bowl percent. Right now it's gone up >> 24 down. probably lost too.
- >> They weren't, you know, that was a 50-50 game going into the season against Buffalo.
- >> So, we weren't banking on them winning as far as the model goes. So, um you know, all things considered, uh their
- percentage actually went up. I think let's be honest, >> their offense looked really good and
- offense right sticky and defense is like kind of like more about who you're playing off often times than uh and so
- given that the Buffalo Bills has have a great offense and a great quarterback, the the Ravens defense just doesn't take
- as big a hit as uh you might think. >> This lets me ask this is a perfect lead in Brian to the question I was going to
- ask just a few minutes ago, but now that we moved on to this game, I can talk about it here.
- Is FBI built to do well at predicting who's going to go to the Super Bowl or pred? No. That's
- what I assumed. The answer was no. Like you would build an entirely different model if you were trying to predict
- who's going to the Super Bowl versus strength parameters on a given week A is playing B, how much we expect them to
- win by. So, I just want to I was going to ask that earlier, but now I have a perfect leadin for that. um it wasn't
- built for super. So the fact that their if you'd like their um FBI didn't change
- very much, but their probability of winning the Super Bowl actually went up, that's not that surprising, right? It's
- not inconsistent. >> It's a bit surprising. I I'm personally surprised. Um >> but the yeah it's a combination of
- things that offense is gets a you know there's more confidence in an offense. There's it's um if you were given the
- choice between being the best team on offense and the best team in defense on the in the league. You would choose
- offense just because the distribution of offenses is is wider. The be the number
- one offense is always better than the number one defense. Um so it's it there there are some sort of intricacies
- uh whereas you know if you if it's like a basically a 40 to 40 game um and both the Bills and the Ravens offenses are um
- kind of bumped up more than their defenses are bumped down and we again we're looking for the
- differential of that particular play right so so you know really what we would be talking about is their change
- probability if they had won versus Yeah, I I I think for that particular uh situation, you know, you could imagine
- that yes, Baltimore still went up in Super Bowl odds even after losing, but they probably would have gone up even
- more if they had executed won and, you know, gone for it on fourth down, executed and won.
- >> Well, yes, if they had the win in hand, absolutely. just they're just sitting,
- you know, in a better perch. Um, but the FBI model doesn't take the the win isn't
- anything special. There's no bonus for actually winning. I I I've built models that that are hybrid that do both sort
- of EPA per play like an efficiency. >> But Brian, the Super Bowl prediction comes from a simulation, right? Like a
- forward simulation. So there it would definitely weight heavily the fact that they have a win when trying to do the
- project. and you presumably condition on the actual outcomes in that sim. >> Yeah.
- >> Yeah. They're completely separate enterprises. You're you're estimating power models and then you're putting
- them through a simulation and these are completely >> that's what you guys have talked about
- Kate for a long time about using the Massie Pbody. I forget the name of the platform you've talked about but uh you
- know >> yeah you can you can we we we there some sims are better than others and we've
- always massive people body always had I think an advantage of having a good sim because we we put a lot of uncertainty
- into it. Um, yes, and that's the key. That's the key, right? So, Brian Bryant does that, but he's saying within his
- power ranking model, it doesn't care if you actually put in more uncertainty than your It's kind of weird like if you
- I should say it's surprising because if you put in like the mathematically proper amount of uncertainty,
- then you get a result that's still overconfident. It's still under It's still overcalibrated to
- >> No. Yeah, that's right. You have to >> you actually have to fudge it to to you're kind of like where is this
- uncertainty extra uncertainty coming from? >> But your whole but your whole game is to
- match the historical spread, right? So you have to parameterize whatever you need. You got to get in there to match
- the historical spread. Hey, by the way, let me let's let's take a moment since we're talking about uncertainty and
- we're at the very end of this conversation with Brian. I want to I want to take a moment to to celebrate a
- few examples of c of of of of communicating uncertainty because it's so important and so hard and there just
- aren't good examples of it. So, we had um Russo on our show um last was it last week talking college football? Three,
- no, two weeks ago talking college football. >> And he did his um his his playoff picks
- a very particular way. And then I noticed that Barnwell did his playoff picks the same way,
- >> which was not like expected value maximizing, but rather it was representative. And so both of them, so
- Russo, when he went to his playoff picks, he said, "Look, I looked historically. I said, "In the preseason
- polls, how many how many of the top five usually make the playoffs?" He said, "Four out of five." So, I got to kick
- one of those guys out when I make my playoff picks. And then of the next five, how many make the playoffs? He
- said, "Two." So, I picked two. And then he goes on down. He says, "How many who are outside the top 25 historically make
- the playoff?" Three. So, I got to pick three teams. He says he has to just to be entertaining. He's This again is not
- an expected value maximizing bracket. This is a representative bracket which I want to celebrate because what he's
- doing is communicating to the reader how much uncertainty there is. It turns out
- Bill Barnwwell does his playoff picks exactly the same way I just read him. Before Brian answers that, what I'd
- rather him do, by the way, as being a pure basian here, is sample from that historical distribution, compute some
- sort of bracket, do it many, many times and average over that as opposed to just
- saying the mode is three or so. And I'm just saying what I would like him to do.
- Who cares what I want? I'm just telling you. >> I I'm just trying to celebrate the
- communication of uncertainty because his because it's really hard to do. And so anytime it happens, well, it's notable
- to me. I want to give you one other example. We talked about Connley. Bill Connley is doing a new thing this year
- which I think is freaking fantastic. We do a version of it on our show periodically, but he's nailed it. He's
- saying, "Look, let's pick four long shot games and construct the forsome such that in expectation one of the long
- shots is going to win." And so I think each week he's going to in his weekly column say here's four, here's the
- quartet or whatever he calls it. and he picks four. So that the expected probability of a long shot winning a
- game is 0.5. And it's fantastic because he says look you know any one of these you think no way but probability
- suggests that on I'm going to build it so that it's half and half that we'll actually get one. And again I think this
- is terrific communication of uncertainty which is a very hard thing to do. >> Yeah. No chalk is boring. Um
- uh you you you you know that you know one out of these top five teams is not going to make the playoffs on average.
- You just don't know which one and you don't know which team to replace them with. So if if you really want to kind
- of maximize Yeah. you you keep the the top five in there and that's no fun. That's not That's not interesting. As as
- dry as I am with all these FBIs and fourth down computations and just pure numbers and everything, I'm I'm a fan,
- too. And I completely endorse completely endorse that. It reminds me of a strategy you need when with uh
- brackets for the NCAA basketball tournament. If you you can maximize you can do just you can have the best model
- in the world like you know an FPI or BPI rather you know but but times a million
- with the smartest AI and all that stuff and you have the best bracket ever and you're you're going to come in second
- place because you know the the rando in the cubicle down the hall from you um at
- at the office is going to have a lucky one. there's just going to be one if your league is big enough there's going
- to be somebody out there that's just kind of a little bit lucky and so we used to enter the you know like the
- Kaggle basketball competition stuff the way we would do it we would have our BPI
- kind of chalk bracket and then we would pick a couple and maybe we would enter multiple of
- these brackets each time picking a different kind of upset and that was the way actually to win those competitions
- is but you got to be lucky too >> what Kade said is really interesting to me because I remember um both in a
- sports context and in in my dissertation case and a survey context, we did exactly what Kade did. We said when
- simulating data, what should I condition on? Like in other words, should I condition on
- there's going to be at least three upsets? Should I condition on there's going to be at least four out of the top
- five teams, but no more than that? Like it's a really interesting exercise to think about what features of the history
- do you want to bring in to your simulation. Those are priors, but they're priors of a different kind. And
- I really think that's a fascinating and I'm glad K brought that up. It brought back some fond memories. But it's an
- interesting question about what aspects of a picking from a as you said NCA pool
- or what if you're simulating future NFL outcomes. You know, we've always talked on this show, roughly half the teams in
- the NFL playoffs don't make it. Do you want to condition on that? What do you do? I I think that's fascinating.
- >> It's It's so hard. It's so It's It's something we come back to every football
- season this time of year. It's like what the that especially like consider, you know, we're going to have random teams
- in the college football playoffs. We're way too sure we know what teams are going to be in there. And we have to
- somehow we have to keep learning that lesson over and over. And hopefully if you're paying attention, you do learn a
- little bit over time. Hopefully at our best, we're walking away from these conversations a little bit more of the
- uncertainty in the world as a result of them. Hopefully. Brian, we're going to have to let you go, man. We've kept you
- longer than we expected to. Always a pleasure. Please let us get you back in here before the season goes away. We
- always enjoy talking to you. >> Yeah, thanks for having me. >> Absolutely. Brian Burke, longtime friend
- of the show. He is with ESPN. You can see his work there. He's behind the scenes on a lot of important work that
- they do. And every now and then we get him out in front get him front of house as well because he's always fun to talk
- to. Brian Burke, welcome back to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to the second half of
- this week's show. An open lines segment. What we used to call open lines, open topics. Just off the phone with Brian
- Bert from ESPN. Always catch Brian early in the season. Find out what his offseason project has been. find out how
- he's taken in the NFL. He's a diehard. He didn't he didn't come clear as much, but he's from the Northern Virginia,
- Annapolis area, and he's a diehard Ravens fan. Um, and uh, so he was talking dispassionately about something
- that is really kind of killing him, guys. Anything else coming out of that conversation or about the NFL in
- general, week one? Um, you know, we had we had the Eagles kicking us off with the Well, heck, Jaylen Carter kicked us
- off. That was a hell of a beginning to the season. Um then we had games like all weekend
- Chargers took down the Chiefs on Friday night. Um we had a big great Monday night game last night with Minnesota
- coming back. I mean what a debut from the QB out of Michigan for those guys. They go down big pick six even and then
- 21 points in the fourth quarter. I mean I completely everybody had given up on those guys. So exciting for Minnesota.
- Um what else jumps out to you about NFL week one? >> Just for me just a couple other things.
- um you know, under the right scheme and under look, Aaron Rogers can still play,
- right? I mean, threw four touchdown passes. I watched a lot of that game. He looked pretty good. Now, again, he's
- still immobile. If you rush him, he's still going to make some bad decisions. He's made that his whole career, even
- when he was more mobile than he is. But, you know, um I could see now why the I'll call it the conservatism of Mike
- Tomlin together with when you really need it from Aaron Rodgers. I'm upgrading my belief on the Steelers this
- year. The problem is they're in the AFC and I there's no chance to put them above Buffalo or Baltimore or really or
- Kansas City right now. But I can see now why the combination of Tomlin's coaching
- style and Rogers could work effectively. So that impressed me. I think I Oh, sorry. Let's stay with that one. Shane,
- you want to go ahead and >> Yeah. I just I was going to kind of ask you both whether you feel like, you
- know, because we're fresh off of Brian Burke talking about how offense is stickier maybe or more predictive
- retweet than defense. would concern me about the, you know, the Steelers kind of, I guess the Steelers like long-term
- chances is more that their defense led up that many, you know, this is supposed to be an elite defense and, you know,
- maybe Justin Fields just had a great game, etc. But, you know, >> if if if that, you know, if that was
- just kind of a a oneoff kind of performance from the Steelers defense, I think they really are a contender.
- If they've taken if they've taken a step back, even like a marginal improvement that Rogers brings is not going to be
- enough to really Yeah. as you said, push them into the conversation of real AFC contenders.
- >> No, I think you would agree, Shane, if it if I told you right now at the end of
- the season the Steelers end up with a top 10 offense, you'd be like, "Whoa, that team could do something."
- >> Cuz I'd be assuming a top 10 defense just cuz the Steelers Exactly. So, that was one team. Yeah, look, obviously, um,
- you know, with the Colts, wasn't it Danny Dimes, right? Played for the Colts and, you know,
- the thought was I didn't see a lot of the game. I saw some of it. I was watching on a lot of screens. Um, and
- so, um, he looked good. Now, it could be the team they were playing was bad, but all I'm commenting on is um
- you know, this idea that he can't play good football is just not true. Now, that doesn't mean he won't have 16 other
- bad games, but I'm a believer, you know, same way with academics when I evaluate
- people for tenure. Shane, if someone can run write one great paper, maybe you could do it again. So there's no reason
- for me to believe that Daniel Jones under the right circumstances can't have, you know, maybe he's a Sam
- Darnold like season. Why not Sam Darnold? >> I I don't think we can write off any
- quarterback based on kind of mediocre performance in a single system, especially if that system is a New York
- based system, it seems like, you know. So no, I agree. Sam Darnold, Eugino Smith, and we have countless examples of
- these of of quarterbacks kind of, you know, looking mid or worse, not really kind of being legitimate starters in
- their first goaround and and, you know, they get in a different system with different personnel and an offensive
- line. Um, and and and watch them do something. I I don't know, that's not really a statement about whether the
- Danny Danny Dimes and Indie is going to be a sustainable thing. Uh, or whether they're, you know, going to be at all a
- good team, but >> find out a little bit. Yeah, we'll find out. >> He's definitely behind a better
- offensive line. >> Just quickly, we'll find out a little bit this week. It's Broncos at Colts and
- the Broncos are at least a good team if nothing else. So, we'll find out something.
- >> A couple of the things about next weekend. Um the Philly KC game. I mean, that's exciting. Uh give us a Super Bowl
- rematch in case. >> Can't wait for the highlights. The highlights are going to be so fun to
- watch. >> Can we say if the Eagles beat the Chiefs that the Chiefs are in quotes whatever
- this means, trouble? Well, two games down. I mean, even if you're still a good team, that's a hole.
- >> Yeah, team teams dig out of it. I mean, I think Baltimore started 0 and2 last
- year and dug out of it. But, >> but still, that's you don't you it's not a great spot to be in. Other ones that
- jump out to me, um I'm really curious about Washington and Green Bay. I mean, Green Bay looked so good, but with
- Jaylen Daniels, I mean, it's a good test for Washington. And then here's a sneaky
- one, guys. I just noticed it. I was going through the schedule. Atlanta goes to Minnesota. Atlanta lost a
- heartbreaker to to to Eric's team last weekend. >> I was so upset about that. >> Yeah. Here's the thing about Atlanta
- Minnesota. The quarterbacks in that game are the quarterbacks from the NCAA final
- two years ago. So, Michael Penn was the Washington quarterback when Michigan's JJ McCarthy won the national
- championship in McCarthy's senior year. And those guys will be facing each other
- again in Minnesota Monday night. >> Monday night. >> I watched all >> I'm sorry. Sunday night.
- >> Sunday night. Sunday night. I watched all of the Bucks Falcons game just to let you know. And I'm going to say this
- right now. I'm going to say the same thing I said about Jaden Daniels last year when I watched Washington against
- the Eagles in week one. I'm sorry, the Bucks again, sorry, Washington against the Bucks in week one. You're not going
- to want to play Michael Pennock Jr. very soon cuz I'm going to tell you something, that guy can play football.
- He's got great decision making. He's got a great arm. I mean, he made some throws
- no more than five quarterbacks in the NFL can make. Michael Pennix Jr. can really play. Falcons were a good team.
- They were right there with the Bucks, man. I mean, it was a great football game.
- >> Well, Bjon scored on that first uh drive as well, which is like Oh, yeah. Remember, they've got Bjon Robinson,
- which is a good place to be as well. >> Don't they have the highest paid? They must have the highest paid backup in all
- of football, >> too, as well, right? I mean they, you know, >> right? >> Okay. So, um, real quickly, I just a
- note that ESPN put up today that is striking is how much kickoff returns are up. And it's fun. It really is fun. You
- forgot how much fun we lost with. So, guys, did you realize that we had dropped down at the low in 2023? The
- season was the average 22% of kicks were returned in 2023. Last year when they changed the rules, which is great, but
- they had the the the the you could get the ball at the 30 if you put it in the end zone. We only went from 22% to 33%.
- So, they got a lift, but only up to 33% this weekend when the penalty was bringing the ball out to the 35. We saw
- 70 76% of the kickoffs were >> Kate, I'm not You're not making me reflect. I watched 10 different games
- this weekend, maybe more. I don't remember what I'm not saying what didn't happen. I would have told you was 98%. I
- don't remember one ball kicked into the end zone and I watched every a as many games as I could. I don't remember one.
- >> Yeah. And they're they're even higher variance I think than they than they have been in the past. Um it's it's a
- it's an major props to the NFL for playing with the rules like that. really gives it gives kickers kind of I mean
- we're already seeing I feel like elite like like like kickers kicking 60 field yard field goals routinely and stuff
- like gives kickers another thing to like kind of become elite at to to kind of work up and land right on the one yard
- line >> drop it right at the five. >> Okay, one last note on football before we change football. We do have college
- football. It was a bit of a quiet weekend, fun weekend. It would no huge games except for Florida going down to
- South Florida. Um, but next weekend, got a couple notables just to kind of sell you guys. This is my weekly note to sell
- y'all on some college football. Clemson's going into Atlanta to play Georgia Tech. And they're only
- four-point favorites. And this is kind of a test on Clemson because they lost game one. And they looked bad last week
- against Troy. They were down like 16 nothing at halftime. They won. >> People are skeptical on Clemson. Georgia
- Tech's solid. They're only four-point favorites. That's going to be interesting. the big one. Um,
- Florida's going to LSU. People were more excited about that before Florida lost their nine-point dogs. But there's a big
- SEC game. Let's see if Florida can bounce back. Texas A&M going up to Notre Dame. A night game in South Bend. 6 and
- a half point underdog. >> You just skipped on. You put these on here. You just skipped the most
- interesting game in my mind. You know what it is. You know, USF at Miami, man. >> Well, it is USF Miami. Wait, wait, wait.
- Let's be clear. >> This is because USF beats Miami, you got to put them in the playoffs.
- >> No, they've beaten two ranked teams already, Shane. If they beat Miami, come on. They're in.
- >> No, I forgot about two or week three or whatever. >> Favorite saw is is Group of Five. Group
- of Five. I forgot about >> usually doesn't kick in until like November, but no, I I I like it. I like
- it. It can really jump. You're always ahead of the game, Eric. Yes. Well, so so undoubtedly USF is one of the stories
- of the season so far, but they are 16point underdogs against Miami. So let's let's keep our powder dry on that
- one. But it would be fun >> if they win. >> Yeah, it would be fun. Okay, that's it
- for football for the week. That's a lot of football. Of course, that's where we are early season working some things
- out. We had some other major sports in particular the fourth and final tennis championship, major championship, US
- Open, of course. um both sides of the bracket, but I I I didn't watch, but I have to say I was surprised. Not only
- did Alcarez beat center in the final, but he beat beat him in four sets, and they weren't even particularly close
- sets, at least some of them. So, Eric, give us the update here if he's how is it that center is the best player in the
- world, but Alcarz has beat him like six of the last seven or something. >> Seven of the last eight, actually.
- >> Seven of eight now. Okay. >> Yeah. So, in the last two years. So, well, first, Alcarez now is number one
- again in the world. So, let's just be clear about that. He took over the points lead. He is number one again. Um
- look >> well to be clear the way we talked about center all summer was that he was the
- next thing to freaking Jesus Christ. And so this is a little bit surprising to see to see this to see this go down.
- >> Yeah. Or I guess to kind of more contextualize it, how often do you see like two kind of players at their kind
- of elite Pete showing such an like an eight eight out of nine kind of imbalance in sort of matchup?
- >> Good. Yeah. So there is there's an imbalance there. Look, I think most people tennis experts, you know, I know
- uh one week we're trying to get them on. We had him on. We had to switch him off.
- We're trying to get Paul Anacone on. Would be great to talk about this. I think what's been shown over the last
- two years. For now, tennis is not is non-stationary, but for right now, Garez's top end game is better than S's
- top end game. It does not mean center can't beat him. It does not mean center doesn't have a better record against
- common opponents. He does because his game has much lower variance. But Alcarez knows the importance of every
- single match against Sinner and he's going to bring his top end game against S. And look, he's seven and one against
- S. That is an imbalance. Look, when we look back on their career, Shane, this is what we do right now. Even though
- their ears were a little different. Djokovic has a slightly winning record against Nadal. Djokovic has a slightly
- winning record against Federer. Djokovic has a winning record against the other big two. It matters when we look back on
- Sinner and Alcarez. I'm not saying S can't get there. It's now I it's either 10 and five or 11 and five. I don't
- remember which one it is. Alcarez has a 10 to5 lead I think it is over S. and he's got six majors and center has four.
- And if Alcarez wins the Australian, which he says is his number one goal for next year, he'll be 22 years old with
- the career grand slam. Do you uh when you think about kind of in in your kind of personal sort of rankings of kind of
- great going up against greats within a particular era, do you think more about total grand slam titles or do you think
- more about the personal head-to-head? I I think about I not I think about the peak. I think about when the person was
- at his best because here's the problem with comparing Federer to Nadal. >> It's they're not aligned exactly but not
- really. Federer is five six years older than Djokovic and so they're headto-head. I'm actually surprised I
- happen to know Federer's record against Djokovic. I'm surprised he's even he didn't have a winning record, but Feder
- Jookovic was 27 and 23 against Federer. And so that's a winning record, but it's
- not that winning a record. And for five of those years, Federra was definitely not at his prime. Um, I think of the I
- if you want to be and we know ELO has its problems. I tend to look at peak rating when the person was at their
- best. Could you beat them? And I say the same about center that I say about Djokovic. Djokovic was is not the
- greatest player I've ever seen. He's the GOAT. He's the most accomplished player.
- There's no debating it. But he's not the greatest player I've ever seen. If Feder
- has his best day, he won. If Nadal had his best day, he won. I saw Stan Roinka blow out Djokovic on his best day. But
- those best days come very very infrequently. And if you're not at your best day, you had no chance against
- Djokovic. >> Okay. So, I just want to note that you're you're you're making you're
- there's a distinction here between their peak EO ELO rating and what you're talking about their best day because
- you're saying even within an era when you'd have an ELO rating on a guy, you still have a distribution of performance
- and you're talking about that right tail that when the guy's at his best, how good is that? And we don't have a number
- around that. And it'd be nice to have it'd be nice to have that assessed in some way. But I I was struck in the I
- was recalling our summerlong conversations about center and Alcarez and this characterization that some
- quants some quants in tennis have put numbers around it and have validated this this there is a higher floor and a
- lower ceiling for center. But what but the way you talked about it Eric is that it's almost as if Alcarez he isn't
- taking a random draw from his distribution when he gets in in these matches against center. He's somehow
- able to shift his draws to the right side of the district. >> It's not symmetry isn't symmetric. He's
- somehow strategic in terms of when also the the I don't call it the rumors. Um >> Alcarazz's coach, Juan Carlos Ferrer,
- former number one in the world by the way, said that they worked the entire summer on making Alcarz more consistent
- and raising his floor. Alcarz lost only one set that was to sinner in the finals
- the entire US Open. Had he gone under had he won all three sets, he would have been the first person in the open era of
- men's tennis win the US Open without >> incredible that he lost one set to center and that happened. So he didn't
- go on. But just to let you know, I think we're going to see this is what's scary
- for men's tennis. I think we're going to see the same peak from Alcarez but a higher floor. And that's even scary.
- That's really scary. And by the way, the other stat that I found interesting is the last two years um Yannik Center
- against everybody else in tennis but Alcarz is 169 and4 and he's 1-7 against Alcare.
- >> I mean that is >> that's interesting. That's that's a separation of one two big separation.
- But this but and let me just say I think we'd also want is you know we're now at
- eight and what I mean by eight we're at eight straight majors >> where it's been Alcarz or Sinner. Let me
- just give them both credit. It's four to four. They both have four of them. Now how many in a row are we going to go
- where one of them wins? That's I mean could it be another I'm making it up is another five years.
- >> What's No, we won't go five more years. But what's the longest run we've seen
- with two guys taking all the slams? >> I think this is it now. >> Eight. >> Cuz remember there was the big three.
- >> Yeah. And how many? That was >> No, there was the big three and there was Snampis and Agassy and you know Jim
- Courier won one every now and then and there was Michael Chang won one and you know and even during the you know the
- Borg Mack andro Connor there was always you know more than two and so I think this is the longest. It would not
- surprise me if this grows at least to double digits like why next year would you predict anybody but one of the two
- of them? >> This is a good this is a good overunder. Eric, what do you give us an overhead or
- me and Shane will take? We we'll bet. Give us a number and we'll take >> Okay, we're at eight right now.
- >> Yeah, >> I am going to go 13 and a half. >> What do you want, Shane? So, that's
- another year and a half basically. >> Not basically. That's it. Next year and a half,
- >> I guess. >> Before you pick before you pick, let me say why I picked that number,
- >> Eric. 14 and a half would be a year and a half. No. >> Oh, yeah. I'm sorry. You're right. Six.
- 14. I meant four. Then I'll go with 14 and a half. Let me say why I'm going with that number.
- Like a lot of times you could say, well, you don't even know the set of potential
- players. I do. Like no one's coming up from the bottom. That's just like I don't know about now. There's no
- 17-year-old. Like it's gonna have to be someone like a Ben Shelton or it would have to be someone like a Felix Aliim.
- It's gonna have to be or is vera finally gets his act together for seven matches
- or Medvadev has some resurgence. Like they're so good. It can't be some random 17year-old that's now eight. It's just
- not it's not going. So it's it's within the set of players we have. So I'll go with 14 and a half. Thank you. 14 and a
- half. That's my overunder. That's my rationale. >> Shane, what do you got? What do you got,
- buddy? I guess I'll I'll I'll I'll >> I'll I'll take the under just to be interesting and because we just had a
- conversation with Brian Burke about uncertainty. Um good for you. >> And I guess and I guess you know what I
- what what what would make it happen? I my mechanism I guess is maybe you know all takes a one or two injuries and all
- of a sudden it's you know I mean that that's probably that's probably one of the biggest factors in this is both of
- these players or at least one of them staying healthy long enough to kind of keep this streak going. My viewers, they
- better both be injured because if you're playing one of them right now, you know,
- you it does sort of sound like you almost you need both an injury and an impressive right by
- I'll get this stat and I'll post it on W Moneyball. >> I think this is the largest gap in the
- history of men's tennis between number two and number three. S has like a 4,950 almost 5,000 point
- lead on the number three player, which I think is still Zerv. And just to let you
- know, you get 2,000 points for winning a major. And he has a 5,000 point lead on
- number three. So just to let you know how big the gap is to norm it, it's big. And Shane, which Kate, which one are you
- taking? >> I'm going to go under also. I think it's the only reasonable way to go. I think
- we're supposed to go that way. It's almost like, you know, in golf, Shane, I don't know if you play enough golf, but
- Eric, I think, does. There's the amateur side of the cup and the pro side of the
- cup. Amateurs tend to play too little break. They're often below the cup at the end of the putt. I feel like this,
- you know, we're supposed to be professional statisticians. Some of y'all actually are professional
- statisticians. I think you got to take uncertainty. The things that we're outside the model. And so, I'm I'm going
- to go I don't love it and it's not fun, but I'll go under as well. >> I'll tell you what, I don't This is a
- great discussion for statistical topic. I don't think we have as good enough intuition as to what I'll call the
- distribution of the maximum of multiple players cuz remember let's assume that let's eliminate changes for one second
- injuries. Now we have to talk about we have two people who have this much distance to number three. You're right
- there's variability but now I'm taking the maximum of the two cuz you know that I don't think we have really good
- intuition for. As a matter of fact, you could argue that's even a farther exceedence than we have intuition for,
- which was why I'm comfortable with my 14 and a half. >> You can imagine, Eric, to take that
- further, like if you put three in the set or four in the set, we probably have really bad intuition because you
- probably more of 68 majors going to the big three over a 17year period. >> Exactly. That kind of thing. So, it's a
- fun it's a fun little problem, actually. All right, guys. We're down to just a couple of minutes before we should wrap
- this thing up. But let's talk baseball. I mean, it's been a quiet week in my mind mentally because there's been so
- much football, but there have been baseball games being played. What's going on over there? What do we need to
- be paying attention to? >> Well, we had a couple uh It's worth noting that this is uh continued to be
- We haven't had a no hitter yet this year, but >> after average, we we've come so very
- close over the last couple weeks. This is I'm so I'm so glad you put this in the rundown because like I there have
- been no no hitters, but >> can we actually just basically then say that even if this year ends with none I
- mean we had what one to eight and two/3 innings was were they both to eight and two/3s innings? We should have like a no
- hitters in expectation or something extra stat that kind of like gives us like 0.98 of a no hitter or something
- >> or a distance metric like suppose I told you we have none this year but we had 10
- no hitters through 8 and 2/3 you'd be like oh all right that seems reasonable. So I like this hard cut right at zero
- hits like >> it. I understand what a no hitter is, but I'm just saying >> I know it's like weird it's a
- particularly weird discretetized >> consequence of what we're generally seeing across baseball is is increased
- offense um a little bit, you know, and and and so another kind of example of that kind of discretetized, you know,
- consequence of that is we still got uh four players now on track to hit over 50 home runs. And that's only happened
- twice before in MLB history. So, you know, if you know, Judge unfortunately has dropped off a bit because he's, you
- know, he hasn't been playing. Uh, but Rally, Schwarber, Otani, and Suarez are still all on pace for over 50 home runs.
- And if they hit that, that's something that also has not happened in a long time.
- >> When has that happened before? You said twice before. What era? >> It was uh n I looked up 2001. So, both
- were steroid era. >> That's what I figured. Okay. >> 1998 and 2001. The last time it
- happened, just to name the guys in 2001, it was Alex Rodriguez, Juan Gonzalez, Sosa, and Barry Bonds.
- >> That's all steroid. And how about 98? >> 98. Well, okay. So 98. Uh Boon, Ken Griffy Jr., Sosa, and
- Magguire. >> Steroids. >> Half Well, nobody nobody's Ken Griffy Jr. steroids here.
- >> Alleged. In case anyone's listening, alleged. >> But yes, this would be the this would be
- the first time outside of the steroid era. We could call that the peak that >> I prefer to think about that. That was
- that was my grad school Chicago grad school era. It was a good time to be a Cubs fan. It was a good time to be in
- Chicago. >> Oh, people people slam it down, but it was an exciting time to watch baseball.
- I mean, we got, you know, we got what we kind of like. >> It's another one of those interesting
- stats, by the way, cuz we've never had more than four, right? obviously and um you know there must have been many years
- in the 20s where I'll make it up Babe Ruth and Hack Wilson or Babe Ruth and this person but like Garrick never hit
- 50 in a season. People don't know this. Aaron never hit 50 in a season. >> That's what people criticize Aaron for.
- You know I consider him the home run leader but whatever. Um he never hit 50. May hit 50 in a season once in his
- career. So you know let's not make it seem like hitting 50 is that easy. It's not. I think it's notable. I think what
- we're seeing here is kind of the combination of in some rule changes that have increased offense and and and you
- know helped hitters over pitchers in general plus the fact that you know we've got like a generation of like kind
- of orientation towards home run hitting maybe you know the three outcomes whatever that I I think is kind of
- driving a lot of this. We have a lot more home run hitters now than we you know had in the early years of baseball.
- >> Yep. I'm I'm always All right, guys. Well, it's only going to get more interesting in baseball over
- the next couple of weeks as we come down to the wire, playoff races, etc. We'll look forward to it. All right. Uh, why
- don't we wrap it there? Been a full hour here on Wharton Moneyball for the whole
- crew. Shane Jensen been in here the whole time. Eric Bradlo been in here the whole time. Audi Winer in Absentia. This
- has been Kade Massie. Many thanks to Dion Simkins who I think we named the fifth Beatle today. D Patel, Boss Lady,
- and our producer, Marissa Rain. I appreciate all y'all do and thank you guys for listening. Come back and join
- us next time. Between now and then, enjoy your sports. [Music]
Brief Summary
Brian Burke discusses NFL analytics, team performances, and predictions for the season on Wharton Moneyball.
Key points
- Brian Burke Joins the Show. Brian Burke, a sports data scientist at ESPN, shares insights on football analytics.
- Chiefs' Down Year?. Discussion on whether the Chiefs might face a challenging season ahead.
- The Challenge of Prediction. Understanding football requires predicting outcomes, a true test of knowledge.
- Fourth Down Decisions. A questionable fourth down call leads to a heated discussion about strategy.
- Impact of Injuries. Injuries can dramatically affect game outcomes and decision-making.
- Super Bowl Predictions. Exploring how models predict Super Bowl chances and their implications.
Episode highlights
- Brian Burke Joins the ShowBrian Burke, a sports data scientist at ESPN, shares insights on football analytics.“Thank you for having me!”1:03Sep 19, 2025
- Chiefs' Down Year?Discussion on whether the Chiefs might face a challenging season ahead.“Maybe it is time.”5:09Sep 19, 2025
- The Challenge of PredictionUnderstanding football requires predicting outcomes, a true test of knowledge.“It’s almost the hallmark of how well you understand it if you can predict.”19:05Sep 19, 2025
- Fourth Down DecisionsA questionable fourth down call leads to a heated discussion about strategy.“The model had 80% for go for it.”20:40Sep 19, 2025
- Impact of InjuriesInjuries can dramatically affect game outcomes and decision-making.“Lamar Jackson was cramping in that final series.”21:52Sep 19, 2025
- Super Bowl PredictionsExploring how models predict Super Bowl chances and their implications.“Their probability of winning the Super Bowl actually went up.”27:40Sep 19, 2025
- Communication of UncertaintyDiscussing how uncertainty is communicated in sports predictions.“It’s really hard to do.”32:46Sep 19, 2025
- NFL Week One RecapExciting moments from NFL Week One, including surprising comebacks and standout performances.“What a debut from the QB out of Michigan!”38:22Sep 19, 2025





