Olivia Mitchell on Her Career in Economics and Retirement Policy

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

The die was cast early for Wharton professor of business economics and public policy Olivia Mitchell to become an economist. Both her parents were economists, and her father’s career as a diplomat brought her to several developing countries including Peru and Chile. Subliminal reinforcement came from the clock on the kitchen table with the words “Time is money.” That has guided her work over a career spanning more than four-and-a-half decades, especially in her role as executive director of Wharton’s Pension Research Council. In a conversation with Wharton Dean Erika James, Mitchell discusses her career path, her research, and how we can make better decisions about retirement, among other topics.

This talk is part of the series “What I’ve Learned,” which puts the spotlight on Wharton faculty who have made a lasting impact on their fields.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU 📂 Finance & Accounting;Markets & The Economy;Public Policy 🏷️ Research;What I've Learned

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] Olivia welcome I'm so so excited to talk with you about your research but before
  2. we get into your research I'm very eager to learn about you your background your
  3. journey to Wharton and how let us get to know you the person before we get to dive in to you the professional well
  4. it's a great pleasure to be with you and thank you Erica for all you do for the school and the world I was really doomed
  5. to become an economist both of my parents are economists or were they've now passed and over the kitchen table in
  6. our house there was a clock which read time is money so with that in my environment what else could I do but
  7. become an economist so I went to high school in Lima Peru in Santiago Chile my father was posted there as a diplomat
  8. and and um after that I taught kindergarten decided that wasn't my cup of tea and then I went on to teach
  9. literacy to the slum dwellers that lived around Lima who didn't know how to read
  10. and therefore couldn't even take a bus because they didn't know what it said on the bus when I went to college in the US
  11. I continued working on development topics um I wrote a senior thesis on uh the difficulties and challenges of
  12. worker self-managed firms in Peru then I went on to graduate school where I decided to diversify a little bit and
  13. start to study Public Finance and um my first job right out of school was teaching at Cornell
  14. University where my department chair said to me please teach a course on pensions and health insurance well I was
  15. 25 years old I had no clue so I read the book quickly and I thought this is an interesting topic then I came to Wharton
  16. hired to continue studying pensions and issues of retirement security and here I
  17. am I've never deviated from that path did you always know that you were going to pursue a career in Academia no I had
  18. no idea I was going to become an academic I always had a five-year plan so when I finished graduate school I
  19. interviewed with the World Bank of the Foreign Service some other companies and I thought well I'll give it five years
  20. in Academia and then another five and here I am 41 years later still say I'll give it another five uh and so you've
  21. been at Wharton for how long 30 years and um it's been terrific I was brought in to work on directing the pension
  22. research Council uh but I've also been teaching I teach a course now um open to all undergraduates at Penn called con
  23. consumer financial decision making and it's all about the kinds of things you need to know as an adult moving into the
  24. financial world and you created that course Nick rusanov and I created it it's always completely booked up it's a
  25. ton of fun and the students write to me later saying oh can you help me with my 401k
  26. Choice things like that so other than retirement planning what are some of the other consumer choices that you discuss
  27. in the class oh we talked about everything from student loans whether you should rent or buy a car take a
  28. lease or buy a car whether credit card problems whether you should pay only the minimum every month which too many
  29. people do and then we go through the life cycle so at some point you might think about trying to buy a house or an
  30. apartment at some point you probably early you should think about disability insurance life insurance starting a
  31. family um all the things that get 529 plans that are tied up with that and then of course we need to think about
  32. saving for retirement from a very young age because if you don't you're going to
  33. not wish that you had a little bit later well let's dive into your research a little bit I want to take it back to the
  34. beginning because your research actually as you've illuminated spans decades and
  35. covers a variety of different topics in both finance and economics what Drew you
  36. to those topics I know you said you were doomed to study stud but what was it about that those fields that resonated
  37. with you so much well I got involved back in 1992 with a uh great study called the
  38. health and retirement survey and this is a dashly representative study of people
  39. over the age of 50 financed by the National Institute on aging and we surveyed 20,000 people every two years
  40. from when they enter until they pass away and we also have merged with their permission their Social Security
  41. earnings records benefit records Medicare records and so forth so we can see what are the factors driving their
  42. retirement saving when they claim their benefits and what happens to them in later Life along the way I decided to
  43. launch a short module on financial literacy trying to find out answers to very simple questions one on inflation
  44. one on interest rates and one on risk diversification and I was shocked to find out that fewer than half of the
  45. older American population 50 and over could answer all three questions right so if they can't do that how are they
  46. going to decide if they've saved enough or invested enough or maybe they'll withdraw their money too quickly from
  47. their retirement pot in in later life so that led to a a big effort to try to enhance financial literacy our survey
  48. has now been delivered in over 150 countries it's part of the high school test that they do in Europe to examine
  49. students financial literacy and it's just been a fascinating effort that is um again so important done reflecting
  50. all of the things that I didn't know when I was coming of age and even into adulthood until it's almost too late to
  51. make good choices your research Del was into the intersection of Behavioral economics and
  52. retirement planning so tell us more how you think about be the concept of Behavioral economics and what does that
  53. actually mean well the whole behavioral area has been one of enormous growth over the past 20 years um and as it
  54. pertains particularly to the retirement age plus population what I focused on is
  55. the kinds of things that people don't know about their own future life livelihoods so um in one very
  56. interesting example a colleague from Microsoft research showed people a picture of their current face and then
  57. with software aged the face and there was a slider button at the bottom and as you slid the button to the right you
  58. save more for retirement the face at the right your future self became happier and happier as you slid the slider to
  59. the left the current phase became very cheerful and the the guy on the right was morose and so this is the kind of
  60. thing that you realize people need to visualize their future selves and in fact I've recently been talking to
  61. people about trying to design an avatar to try to go through alternative retirement scenarios to get a sense of
  62. what it would be like if I didn't save what would happen if I quit like my daughter wanted to at age 45 and retire
  63. and so on and I think that really is helpful and it's it teaches us the kinds of Behavioral obstacles people face when
  64. they try to visualize themselves in the future so as I get closer and closer to retirement we hope not not not anytime
  65. soon but every year I'm closer and closer I think about you know it sometimes it can be daunting to think
  66. about all of the options and all the considerations and because for most of us it's not something that we were
  67. taught earlier in life do you find that as you're interacting with people of different Dem
  68. graic ages that they are either more or less receptive to learning and changing behaviors in a way that would prepare
  69. them for their future retirement well one of the things we've been looking at recently is the concept of longevity
  70. risk not only people not have to have a sense of on average how long they'll live but also what's the tail of the
  71. distribution what are the chances you'll survived to 85 995 105 and so forth and
  72. so what we see is there are big differences demographic differences interestingly enough in the US the black
  73. population seems to think it will live longer than it will given the objective survival table women tend to
  74. underestimate how long they will live so all those factors shape how much you save whether you claim your Social
  75. Security benefits too early and whether you spend your money too quickly and run
  76. out of money in later life so what we've been doing is trying to come up with simple
  77. explanations did you realize someone a male let's say 65 has a 35% chance of living to age 90 and higher for women
  78. and that kind of very simple explanation actually gets people to step and say oh
  79. number one I regret I didn't save enough number two I regret claiming my social security benefits too early and number
  80. three I wish I had bought long-term care insurance and an annuity so there are ways that we're trying to bring these
  81. subjects to people in a way that makes it very concrete and very individual and helps them make better financial
  82. decisions your work has influenced policy decisions globally can you share particular instances where your research
  83. directly impacted retirement policies either here or somewhere outside of the US and how did it shape your Notions for
  84. what to study going forward I had the Good Fortune to work on President George W Bush's commission to strengthen Social
  85. Security this was 20 plus years ago it was a bipartisan commission eight democraty Republicans co-chaired by
  86. Senator Daniel Patrick boan and Richard Parsons and it was an amazingly wonderful group hardworking
  87. really devoted to try to help fix Social Security before we reach the situation we're in now um so we had a good plan
  88. which was basically to reduce the growth rate of benefits but not cut benefits and then the second piece was to allow
  89. people if they wanted to set aside part of their social security taxes in a personal account long and short of it
  90. due to political opposition and also the fact that that year was 911 the plan was dead in the water
  91. it's currently estimated that Social Security will become insolvent by 2033 and Medicare as well shortly
  92. thereafter and at that point the benefits will have to be cut by 25 to 30% for everybody or taxes will have to
  93. be increased by about 30% around the world the issue is very consistent populations are aging fertility rates
  94. are declining and so there simply isn't the demographic mass of workers that can
  95. help support people in later life to the extent that they become accustom and people are living longer and people are
  96. living longer exactly so what that says to me is that we're all going to have to
  97. work a lot longer it's not a popular View and especially in countries like France where the the prospect of raising
  98. the retirement age from 62 to 64 and Drew out math demonstration in the street I'm curious whether you think AI
  99. has any influence or any role to play in the future of well very interesting topic everyone is obviously speculating
  100. like crazy I do think that artificial intelligence can help us do a better job tailoring our our life cycle saving and
  101. investment and withdrawal profile uh right now the in the US at least we tend to have
  102. one siiz fits-all Solutions so Target date funds are very popular in retirement plan they say okay how old
  103. are you what's the year you're going to turn 65 boom we're going to put you in that Target date fund and the rest is is
  104. not necessary to be discussed but obviously people are different right now if you put in simple questions to AI you
  105. know they tell you well 6040 is a good stock Bond allocation it's still very simple
  106. so there's some and the other problem is that at the payout phase things get much
  107. more complicated so there's progress there's optimism um and I can't wait to see what
  108. happens I think that's true for for many of this what do you find has been the most challenging thing to convey to
  109. either organizations or to individuals to help them understand the urgency of of needing to find solutions for our
  110. current problems with the pension and social security systems probably the most difficult
  111. concept is a deepr rooted one which is that people simply have a hard time thinking into the
  112. future way back when when I started working with the Social Security Administration they only used a 10-year
  113. projection period to see if the system was solvent well 10 years years is nothing for people that are just
  114. starting their work lives or even age 55 or 60 so over time Congress induced Social Security to take a 75-year window
  115. so now they do their Pro projections for that period and their their logic is that well the baby born today will
  116. probably live to age 75 but there are a lot of more babies who are going to live
  117. beyond that and so now we need to take a much longer perspective their answer and
  118. somewhat credibly is that well who knows what's going to happen in the future we
  119. may all get covid again or we may cure cancer and live to be 2,000 but the point is if you're putting in place one
  120. of the biggest government expenditure programs in the world and you're not making long-term projections then you
  121. really have a hard time making tweaks as you go along and as the world changes so
  122. future Focus I think is really one of the bigger more difficult things to convey so one of the things that I have
  123. appreciated about the way you have navigated your career at Wharton is that you've been very engaged with the public
  124. sector you've been very engaged with the corporate sector uh including TIAA can you tell us a little bit about
  125. the work that you've done or the partnership that you've created with Tia so Tia has been an amazing supporter of
  126. the pension research Council I've actually been a participant in Tia since I was 25 years old so I'm a long-term
  127. supporter one of the reasons that I think it's such an interesting partner is that they are not only interested you
  128. know seriously doing a good job providing people with retirement saving and payouts but they're also devoted to
  129. the research and um way back when the pens research Council published a book that its CEO uh had written called it's
  130. my retirement money take good care of it and we've consistently partnered with their various people through the years
  131. so over about the last eight years Tia and the pension research Council have combined forces to issue calls for
  132. proposals to any researcher in the US at a government nonprofit or academic institution we've sponsored numerous
  133. different research studies including I'm happy to say some of mine one of their very interesting products that they
  134. provide is something called a participating annuity no other us company has these because it was allowed
  135. by Congress back in the Stone Age and essentially what this is is it's an insurance product which guarantees you a
  136. payout the rest of your life no matter how long or short you live but the insurance company doesn't have
  137. to bear the risk of surprises to the mortality table so if all of a sudden everybody lives 10 years longer or covid
  138. comes along the participants in the pool share that risk so what it means is their product is much less expensive
  139. than any other annuity on the market it's quite prevalent in Europe you see it elsewhere how can we do better
  140. integrating lifetime income streams in into the 401K world the Define contribution world so I'd like to switch
  141. gears a little bit and talk about your time specifically at Wharton you've been here for 30 years how have you seen the
  142. school evolve in that time particularly with respect to the department that you're in and the nature of the research
  143. and the students over those 30 years when I would joined Wharton I joined a department called the department of
  144. insurance and risk management and my predecessor Dan McGill had founded the pension research Council to bring
  145. greater knowledge and integration into the field of Retirement Research so he brought in actuaries he brought in
  146. Insurance folk um when I came in the world had changed somewhat instead of everybody having defined benefit
  147. pensions like in the Auto industry and um so forth which was the old Norm the new Norm is Define contribution plan so
  148. I broadened our perspective to be able to include plan design discussions uh studies of participant
  149. behavior and so forth and now I'm delighted to say we've celebrated our 70th Anniversary for the pension
  150. research Council I have a wonderful Advisory Board many of them Warton grads I'm happy to say and the nice
  151. conversation we have within our board spans academic and Industry and policy problems and issues and challenges so
  152. it's a great way for me as a faculty member in our academic colleagues to get grounded to really say what's coming up
  153. what's the ne Next Issue how can we help policy makers solve some of the problems
  154. and Industry as well and I think it's very opportun to say in this world of global aging I am excited to see what
  155. the pension research Council can accomplish in the next 70 years so as we think about the future uh I want to
  156. again sort of ground Us in the Wharton context or actually higher education and Academia in general as a senior
  157. stateswoman in your field and as a senior uh scholar what advice do you have for
  158. future current and future young scholars in this field I see the area of Pensions
  159. or retirement as a microcosm of almost everything it's got consumer Behavior it's got industry structure it's got
  160. macro and microeconomics it's got psychology and so when I first started down this path there was some
  161. discouragement because it was so multidisciplinary and that's often something that in the rest of the world
  162. in other academic institutions is frowned on one of the great things about Wharton is it does encourage
  163. multidisciplinary research and collaboration and so that's been wonderful of course good scholarship of
  164. any type Demands a strong foundation so um I always tell my students do what's difficult when you're in school because
  165. you have to force your I did have to force myself to really learn statistics and econometrics and the things that I
  166. couldn't sit down with a book under a tree and read and learn and then with that edifice you can do all sorts of
  167. things the rest of your life so on top of that strong foundation in my field it would be finance and economics and
  168. econometrics and statistics I think it's also important to read widely and talk to people so understanding that we're
  169. all different our Solutions are different our problems are very similar um but we can learn from each other and
  170. that has been a real Joy here at Warden wonderful so one of the first actually the first person that we interviewed for
  171. this series what I've learned was Anita Summers she was one of the first uh female faculty members at the Wharton
  172. School in economics and policy and and she talked about the experience early in her career of being a woman in a field
  173. that was not necessarily considered to be the domain of women have you found any challenge either earlier on in your
  174. career or in modern day of studying this or unique things that you bring to the understanding of this field because of
  175. your gender well my mother actually um applied to a PhD program at Harvard in economics and the only reason they let
  176. her in is she agreed to type the department Chairman's papers so you know that goes back um I
  177. think sure 30 40 years ago I would be in a room with a hundred other economists and I'd be the only female I would say
  178. that being in a school with yourself as Dean with very prominent women that was what attracted
  179. me to Wharton actually when I did make the move um there were very strong women presidents of Penn over the years um and
  180. that makes a difference it makes the environment more more friendly of course over the years um one also figures out
  181. how to speak and wh whom to speak with and what top and when to speak that's the most important thing um but I
  182. believe that it's been a very nurturing environment and it continues to be so and so for that I thank you and your
  183. predecessors that have done such a great job it is an incredible culture here at
  184. the Wharton School so final question this series is called what I've learned oh so if we were to end with your
  185. greatest piece of advice uh with what you've learned over the years what would that be and it may not have have
  186. anything to do with pension research I would say just don't give up in fact my dearly departed mother used to say
  187. overcome dear overcome and um that that Mantra really stands what in good stead I had a number of brilliant friends and
  188. co-students in graduate school some of whom never went anywhere because they got discouraged they got a rejection
  189. letter from a journal and put it in the drawer and never looked at it again um and it's not like we haven't had our
  190. challenges over the the years but um usually there's a different path if you can't go over over it or under it go
  191. around it and that's the advice I try to give my students I also try to tell them
  192. try to think of questions such that no matter what the answer is it's always interesting so you know you don't want
  193. to say is X true and then find out it's not and then what do you do you want to say why is X true or not true or what
  194. can I learn from that so part of what I try to do in teaching is try to help people ask interesting
  195. questions well Olivia I've learned a lot from you and I know that you have generations of students who have
  196. benefited from your engagement with them in the classroom and we're really thrilled that you have chosen Wharton to
  197. be your academic home and will continue to be here hopefully for quite some time
  198. thank you so so much for joining us thank you ma'am it's a pleasure

Brief Summary

Olivia S. Watson discusses retirement planning, financial literacy, and her academic journey at Wharton, emphasizing the importance of understanding financial concepts.

Key points

  • Olivia's Journey to Economics. Olivia shares her path to becoming an economist, influenced by her parents' careers.
  • The Importance of Financial Literacy. Olivia discusses her research on financial literacy and its global impact.
  • Behavioral Economics and Retirement. Exploring how behavioral economics affects retirement planning and decision-making.
  • Nurturing Environment at Wharton. She reflects on the supportive culture at Wharton and its impact on her career.
  • Overcoming Challenges. She emphasizes the importance of resilience in the face of rejection.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes