Professor Ian MacMillan: Measuring Consumer Leverage Exposure

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

The heavy load of consumer debt today poses significant risks to organizations. Even those that dont sell to the consumer market likely have customers who do, creating indirect risk. And even a small rise in consumer defaults could cripple many enterprises that heavily depend on debt transactions. In this short video prepared by Knowledge@Wharton, Ian C. MacMillan, Wharton professor of innovation and director of the Sol C. Snider Entrepreneurial Research Center, offers a simple analytical tool to help managers segment customers into key consumer risk categories just as they segment by demographics, for example -- in order to contain potential losses. The concern is about assessing exposure to credit risk and thats what this tool is all about, MacMillan says. The tool is easy to use and will help enterprises of all kinds to anticipate something that is likely coming down the road fairly soon. This tool can be downloaded free below, or by going to the Discovery Driven Growth website discoverydrivengrowth.com and signing up for the software from the free resources offered there.

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. The tool that I'm going to talk about uh today is uh looking at what I call consumer leverage exposure. And we have
  2. developed a very simple little tool that you can use uh input data from your business and get a bit of a sense of
  3. just uh how concerned you might be for this thing called consumer leverage exposure. So here's the backdrop. If you
  4. look at the current level of consumer debt in relation to their earnings, um let's say people decided to pay off
  5. their debt. If they started paying off today and they did nothing else than pay off their debt, no food, no new
  6. clothes, no uh lattes at Starbucks, nothing except paying off their debt. It would take the average consumer 16
  7. months to pay off their debt. That's how horrendous this consumer debt is. From the point of view of business, uh the
  8. problem is that uh uh most of the growth that we've had in the last few years uh
  9. in the last decades has basically been being by persuading consumers to buy more and more on credit. And if you're
  10. in a business that where a large percentage of your revenues come from sales to consumers,
  11. uh, as people start to run out of their credit and as they start to tap out their credit, uh, as they in fact start
  12. to act responsibly and cut back on their purchases on credit, what they're doing
  13. is they're cutting back on purchases of your company. So, uh, even if people behave
  14. in a more responsible way, it's going to come back and it's going to impact companies. Now, not all companies are
  15. going to be equally impacted by this. If you happen to be somebody who sells furniture, for instance, and your
  16. strategy is to tell people to take the furniture and put it in their home and they don't have to pay you for the next
  17. 5 years, you know, you're in big trouble if people start to scale back because, you know, this is what's driving your
  18. business. If you happen to be selling uh you know uh let's say uh aircraft engines, there's a not a hell of a lot
  19. of consumers that are going to be able to uh you know come come use credit to buy aircraft engines from you. So this
  20. is tends to be industry specific. But there's another scary thing that's uh behind this and I won't talk about this
  21. today. we just don't have time. And that is if you're selling to somebody and they in turn are selling to consumers
  22. and those consumers start to cut back on their credit that means their sales will
  23. drop which means it's going to domino back to you. So this problem of consumer credit being reduced uh sales being
  24. reduced in consumer credit is going to impact a lot of people and uh you know what I'm concerned about here is firstly
  25. that firms should begin to assess just what their exposure is and that's what the tool is all about is to give them a
  26. sense of what the exposure is to it and then secondly to begin to start taking actions now uh before the tsunami hits
  27. uh to do something to limit the exposure or control the exposure to to reductions
  28. in consumer credit. So, that's what the little tool is all about. And once again, the idea is we want to be able to
  29. give you something that's u easy to use and and free. It's not going to cost anything. Uh in the hope that it'll help
  30. people who are in in businesses to begin to anticipate uh something that's coming, you know, down down the road.
  31. And my fear is that it will come down the road fairly soon. Um, I'm going to characterize what we're
  32. saying by by by hoping either that'd be wrong or that uh if we get the message out and people use it and they can be
  33. begin to take collective action uh it won't happen at all. Because to me the definition of a truly good prophet is is
  34. these are the people whose prophecies uh don't come true because they the prophecy itself uh created conditions
  35. for people who say something like man we can't let this happen so it doesn't happen. So here we see uh this little
  36. company has a consumer division that's selling about $60 million a year uh uh and that's credit sales of 40 and cash
  37. sales of 20. And we have a business division which has got about $40 million a year as well. But the key thing is the
  38. credit sales. And in addition to this, at the moment, the company's fat, fat, and happy because it's got zero consumer
  39. defaults. The credit crunch starts to bite. Uh, as we see already, credit companies are scaling back on the amount
  40. of credit they'll give people. Consumers are getting tapped out and have kind of used up as much credit
  41. as they possibly can get. And so now what's going to happen one of the big problems and this is on the second
  42. graphic we see here is uh that uh you're going to start to impact what we call the consumer leverage exposure CLLE the
  43. top of the chart sort of shows you the derivation if you wanted to go through this uh you could probably look in the
  44. Excel spreadsheet but it basically says is that this company the way that it credit structured credit sales is
  45. structured to consumers in relation to the overall sales is 50% % exposed to consumer
  46. leverage. That basically means that very small changes in consumer credit behavior is going to impact 50% of the
  47. operating income of this company. That's a lot of exposure. And uh if you look at the
  48. financial metrics uh which are going to change as credit changes, you see the company's currently got a gross profit
  49. of about 75% an operating profit of about 20% margin and total leverage of two times. So they're in a good position
  50. to keep on paying off the bank. But now what happens let's have a look at the next graphic is uh consumers cut back
  51. either because they tapped out of credit uh or because they can't get any more credit but the way it manifests you and
  52. your company is they stop buying from you. So maybe the credit companies are absorbing the risk but you're the one
  53. that's going to be losing the revenues because they're just not buying anymore. And so what we see when that happens on
  54. the next chart is that if you have a credit cut back and no defaults yet, just a credit cut back, uh you're going
  55. to see a 25% reduction of your operating income and a 33% increase in your leverage. So that means you're making
  56. less money. And not only that, but uh your capacity to pay paid back the bank is now starting to evaporate. So you're
  57. getting exposed by reductions in profits plus an increased exposure to the bank coming in and taking over your business
  58. and and you know this company needs to start to become seriously concerned. Now let's key in uh on the next chart uh
  59. suddenly people start defaulting and those people to whom you issued credit uh start to default and 10% of them do
  60. so. Well, what that does on the next chart is it shows you that the default rate of only 10% is going to mean you're
  61. going to make 20% less profits and it's going to increase your leverage once again exposing you to having the bank
  62. come in and take your business away from you. So, there's two sources of of danger from consumer leverage exposure.
  63. One is that you make less profits and less cash flows. And the secondary effect of that is you get more and more
  64. exposed to uh you know insolvency or bankruptcy yourself because you can't pay your debts. And uh so so run these
  65. numbers, put them in, see what happens. And if you start to get pretty big numbers, uh let me make uh make the
  66. observation that one of the key things that you should begin to do today is to resegment your customer base with
  67. respect to their capacity and their willingness to incur and pay off debt. So, you know, we're not just looking at
  68. gender and race and location and all the other dawn demographic things we normally do with customer segmentation,
  69. but start to look at whether people are going to pay their debt debt off or not.
  70. Let me give you an example of kind of three segments that pop out of this. One is a segment of customers who buy on
  71. credit. They're still going to keep their credit. They're going to be able to finance their credit and they're
  72. perfectly happy. You should be, you know, aggressively looking at what can I do to keep those people loyal to me
  73. because they're the ones that going to keep on paying your bills. The second is the group that are sort of what I would
  74. call honest Joe's and Jones. Uh these are people that would love to pay off their credit but they simply can't. we
  75. need to find ways of making it easier for them uh or uh to find ways of making sure
  76. that uh you know they just can't we we we don't have uh any further exposure to them and then the last group are the
  77. people that will keep on running up their credit as high as they can and then turn around one day and say well
  78. I'll see you in court and those are the last kind of people that you want. So, we need to begin to go beyond just
  79. simple demographics now and start to layer in the consumer debt behavior uh demographics, trying to find as many
  80. people as we can who willing to switch from credit to cash sales by giving them incentives and trying to find segments
  81. that uh will keep us alive and minimally impacted by the tsunami that's headed our way. Some of the incentives that uh
  82. one might try to follow is to say to someone when uh they come and try to use their credit card is to say well we can
  83. give you a discount you know if you're willing to pay cash because I'd rather give somebody a modest discount to pay
  84. for cash than have to see them in bankruptcy court when they bought from me on credit and now you know unable or
  85. unwilling to pay me. So that's one of the ways that you might want to do it is to migrate the u migrate purchases to
  86. cash. Uh the second as I've mentioned is to really spend some time deeply understanding uh the people who will
  87. continue to pay you because you know the if you go back to our original chart there what we had is a sort of generic
  88. 40% of the people are buying on credit. The question is which kinds of people are buying on credit? people who can or
  89. willing to pay the those who you know who can't and those who won't and and and and you know really begin to work
  90. strategies to go after the the most important ones for sustaining your cash flows. Find incentives for them to do
  91. it. U find ways of encouraging them even if they buy on credit and they can and will pay to you know to give them more
  92. credit. But you want to give the right people credit and not just everybody credit.
  93. [Music]

Brief Summary

Consumer leverage exposure threatens businesses reliant on credit sales; a new tool helps assess risk and encourages proactive strategies.

Key points

  • Consumer Debt Crisis. The average consumer would need 16 months to pay off their debt, highlighting a severe crisis.
  • Impact on Businesses. As consumers cut back on credit, businesses will feel the pinch, leading to reduced sales.
  • Introducing a New Tool. A simple tool to assess consumer leverage exposure, aimed at helping businesses prepare.

Related episodes