Richard Ward, CEO Lloyd's: Learning from Crises at Lloyd's of London

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Lloyds of London has been covering complicated and unusual risks including a wine tasters nose and a coffee tasters tongue for more than 300 years. But twice since 1990, it has faced crises that threatened its very existence. In a Wharton Leadership Lecture, chief executive Richard Ward describes the lessons it learned.

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] now we're not actually insurance company Lloyds of London we're in Insurance
  2. Market Market we're the largest Insurance Market in the world we're actually the only Insurance Market in
  3. the world if you want to Ure a very unusual risk you come into the Lloyd's Market you go to one underwriter to get
  4. a bit of a policy go to another underwriter to get another bit of the policy put them together and you have a
  5. policy that will cover the risk that you're wanting to ensure now inside the Lloyd's Marketplace we actually have 50
  6. companies operating companies that are corporate entities in their own right that are either listed on the London
  7. Stock Exchange or quite often are a subsidiary of an overseas entity such as a liberty in Boston or an ace in Bermuda
  8. or whatever but we've got these 50 companies operating inside the Lloyd's marketplace with their Underwriters
  9. actually sitting inside the Lloyd's building so it is a market we have over 5,000 Brokers wandering into our
  10. building every day with suit cases like this one sometimes actually my only prop
  11. for today full of information about a risk that they might might want to actually cover and you say why would you
  12. need so much information well we need so much information cu the risks that we cover are so complex so for instance I
  13. have been sitting on a box where um the underwriter was uh covering the Sultan of oman's private fleet of aircraft he's
  14. got a few trip 7s a few 747s few Gulf streams and Etc and to actually cover that risk the underwriter wanted to know
  15. the age of every airplane where it was serviced the uh um destinations that the airplane would go
  16. to the surface of the runways then he wanted to know about the crew and the age of the crew and where they were
  17. trained and it was an enormous amount of information the underwriter actually required to be able to underwrite that
  18. risk when the um Underwriters actually write an insurance policy however what they issue is a Lloyd's policy and that
  19. is quite a unique structure we're a mutual market and so anyone operating inside the Lloyd's Marketplace even
  20. though they might work for their own company they will work for their own company the policy they issue is a
  21. Lloyd's policy and therefore it has Lloyd's security behind it and Lloyd security is very important because we
  22. have never defaulted on a claim we've paid all our claims in the 321 years that we've been operating that has been
  23. a challenge for us because in certain periods in our history it's been quite difficult to find the funds to pay those
  24. claims and I'll share some of those experiences with you um what sort of things do we uh ensure apart from uh
  25. what was her name Dion's vocal cord um Ugly Betty smile have you seen Ugly Betty on television well we cover her
  26. smile for the uh for the older people in the audience uh Betty grable's legs we've ensured her legs we actually do a
  27. lot of legs American footballers legs uh European soccer players kneecaps so Beckham's kneecaps Ronaldo's kneecaps so
  28. we do a lot of body parts someone's chest hair we actually ured their chest hair um I I don't know what the claim
  29. would have looked like on that chest air claim but you know give some modities we
  30. we've insured a coffee Taster's uh tongue for $5 million and we've insured a wine Taster's nose for tulip wines for
  31. $10 million that's the uh the odd stuff but it is important because frankly if you are an American football player and
  32. you break your leg and you're unable to play a again you've got faced with loss of earnings you're faced with
  33. Rehabilitation and so the insurance policy is very important because that kicks in to start to enable that person
  34. to get back into training or whatever and rehabilitate and if necessary pay for loss of earnings so these are quite
  35. important policies but we also do other stuff I mean we were the first uh insurer to offer insurance for Aviation
  36. 1911 was the first uh commercial flight and we insured that flight we also insured the first commercial space
  37. flight in 2004 we Ure oil rigs we ensure Bridges we ensure buildings we ensure workers workers comp we provide d o
  38. cover directors and officers liability we provide terrorism cover we ensure against political risk a very large uh
  39. and Vari varied um range of activities that we get get involved in basically I suppose what we do is ensure things
  40. other people that can't or won't ensure and I'd just like to share with you two crises that Lloyds has weathered
  41. two storms that Lloyds has weathered that are very relevant very pertinent to the uh economic crisis that we find
  42. ourselves faced with today um they're quite well documented but let me spend a few minutes just sharing them with you
  43. the first crisis we had to weather was it back in the '90s and in the middle of the '90s so around about
  44. 9394 Lloyd suddenly found itself faced with enormous losses we were faced with 34,000 people who invested in Lloyds and
  45. we're faced with uh ruinous claims that they were having to pay these $15 billion worth of claims
  46. as a result of the problems that uh uh we' found ourselves faced with so was an extraordinary period um in our history
  47. where were these $15 billion worth of claims coming from a variety of things we were faced with a bit of a perfect
  48. storm um asbestos I'm sure you're all familiar with asbestos asbestosis loyds uh wrote a lot of the policies here in
  49. the US back in the 60s 50s and 60s providing cover to workers for asbestos the problem we faced though is we wrote
  50. those policies in the 60s and the claims didn't come through until the ' 80s and
  51. '90s how can you write a risk how can you price a risk in the 60s where you don't pay out the claim until the '90s
  52. pricing was completely shot to Pieces so the claims coming from asbestos were far
  53. greater than any of the premiums would ever taken in for those policies and it wasn't just asbestos we were also faced
  54. with claim coming from Piper Alpha an oil rig that uh um exploded Exon Valdes that leaked oil up in Alaska hurcan
  55. Andrew 1992 um and probably quite a few other things lead paint we having to deal with
  56. the environmental problem of lead paint and uh lead paint poisoning people how we dealt with that problem in the '90s
  57. was very simple we took well it required a lot of effort But ultimately it was a
  58. simple solution and the solution was really sort of based on the good bank bad Bank model and we took the decision
  59. along with the support of government to take all those liabilities that $15 billion worth of claims put all the
  60. assets we had against those liabilities and put them off into a completely separate vehicle and that vehicle was
  61. called equitas so we sold the building we sold Lloyd's list of publisher we sold Lloyd's Register we sold absolutely
  62. everything except for the silver if you come into the ly's building today you'll
  63. still see we kept the silver that's the one thing we kept we we sold everything to put it into this vehicle called
  64. equitas so we had some assets that we could put against those liabilities now you would have thought we would have
  65. leared from that experience said let's do things a little bit differently the only thing that we did differently going
  66. forward was to move from an unlimited liability basis to a limited liability basis uh prior to um this this issue
  67. anyone participating in Lloyds providing Capital would do it on an unlimited liability basis so if you had a claim
  68. you paid it and if the claim just grew and grew you continued to pay and pay and what happened to these 34,000 people
  69. that were providing Capital they were faced with ruin and a lot of suicides and the such like as a result of having
  70. to meet those liabilities so we took the decision to say right stop no more unlimited liability you can only write
  71. on a limited liability basis but we didn't change anything else I'm sure you've heard that story before when you
  72. look at what the banks are doing at the moment nothing else changed so of course
  73. we were then faced with our second storm and that storm happened in 2001 the tragic events of uh the World Trade
  74. Center where we found ourselves being the largest insurer of the World Trade Center and we ended up with liabilities
  75. claims coming out of the World Trade Center of 11 billion out of the total $40 billion claim so less than eight
  76. years later one day after the World Trade Center sitting in a room 24 hours after the event you had the same people
  77. sitting there saying we're about to go bankrupt we can't pay this 11 billion quite extraordinary that so soon after
  78. the problems of the '90s we were faced with a similar problem the problem we had um with the World Trade Center was a
  79. simple liquidity problem a funding problem the US authorities wanted us to fund our liabil growth here in the US
  80. and we didn't have the cash and so we had to Scrabble around strike a few deals and finally we were able to come
  81. to an arrangement whereby we would cut a little bit of slack a few days here and
  82. there there and we're able to then find the cash to fund those liabilities from the World Trade
  83. Center Lloyd said hold on we're going to have to completely overhaul the way this
  84. Market is operated and so we Chang management of businesses we Chang the governance of Lloyds and we put in a
  85. completely new structure and the structure we put in um I would call it the McDonald's of Lloyds we put in a
  86. franchise structure uh very similar to McDonald's there's nothing new in this world you know if you go to uh the
  87. McDonald's in Tokyo and ask for a Big Mac and large fries you know what's exactly going to be in that Big Mac
  88. where the girkin is going to be and how many fries you're going to get in your your bucket of fries just as if you go
  89. to um McDonald's here and Philadelphia and ask for Big Mac and Fries you'll get exactly the same so what's his name
  90. Ronald McDonald he's able to impose standards across the whole of the McDonald's franchise and get everyone to
  91. do the same thing and that's exactly what we had to do in Lloyds we said right we're going to operate a franchise
  92. model whereby anyone who wants to write business inside the Lloyd's Market does it according to the standards we set and
  93. they have to meet those standards and the standards are very clearly around risk management and around Capital
  94. setting um if I talk about risk management because that was the real lesson that we learned from the World
  95. Trade Center we've now introduced a very structured and disciplined approach to the risks that businesses are allowed to
  96. write in the Lloyd's Marketplace so we look at two things so if you're company a that is writing risks inside Lloyds we
  97. look at the risks that you're writing and then we look at how your risks plus everyone else's risks adds up together
  98. what the aggregate exposure is to ensure that firstly the capital you have is sufficient to support your business but
  99. secondly that the capital the market has is sufficient to support the risks across the whole market so it's a very
  100. dis disciplined approach to risk management and it's a very disciplined approach to uh Capital setting we have
  101. other standards around claims around business processing and the such like but the imposition of Standards on our
  102. Market has been a life-changing experience for us and the the use of a very discipline risk management approach
  103. Linked In with capital setting has been uh life-changing for us how life changing well 2001 was the World Trade
  104. Center 2005 Katrina Rita Wilmer bigger than the World Trade Center the losses from the World Trade Center were 40
  105. billion the losses from Katrina Rita Wilmer were $60 billion and our share of Katrina Rita wmer was $16 billion just
  106. to remind you our share of the World Trade Center was $ 11 billion when uh we had the World Trade
  107. Center and we looked at the results for the market at the end of the year the market loss in total was5 billion which
  108. is why we were close to bankrupt coming out of 2005 I took over in 2006 just on the back of paying out $16 billion for
  109. Katrina rmer and the loss for the overall Market was $160 million so it's complete reversal in
  110. fortunes and that was a direct result of our approach to to risk management um that's the sort of potted history of
  111. Lloyds and where we've got to how how is that serving us uh in today's crisis because we seem to have a lot of Crisis
  112. literally every 3 or four years in the Lloyd's market and the most recent one yes is a subprime crisis the the
  113. recession the economic crisis that we now found ourselves in in 2009 well as a result of all the changes that we have
  114. instigated over recent years we've actually weathered the recent storm pretty well um I'm reminded when talking
  115. about the recent storm of AIG I'm not here to knock a government own competitor uncomfortable though it may
  116. be to have a competitor that's owned by the government but when talking to someone about AIG they said to me the
  117. problem with AIG is when you look at their balance sheet on the left side of the balance sheet nothing is right and
  118. on the right side of the balance sheet nothing is left okay that's that that was yeah you're absolutely right we must
  119. never mix up both sides of the balance sheet so the way we Lloyds have weathered the storm is to keep the two
  120. separate and by the two separate I mean the liability that the risks we write we keep in one
  121. bucket and manage those and the assets the capital that we have to offset against those risks we keep in a
  122. completely separate bucket now the assets we have in the Lloyd's Market roughly $60 billion at the moment to
  123. support the risks that we write to support the $33 billion worth of Premium that we write every year that 60 billion
  124. we manage very very conser conservatively so over the past two years our EXP exposure to equities and
  125. exotic instruments and Structured Products has been less than 5% so looking at our 60 billion we've got
  126. roughly a third in corporate bonds third in government bonds and a third in cash
  127. what that means is we don't make spectacular returns from our assets but we also don't make spectacular losses
  128. and that's very important because those assets are there to support the liabilities where we do want to take
  129. risk so we don't take risks with our assets and we do take risks on the liability side but when taking risk on
  130. the liability side we're actually now quite selective and when we don't like a risk we don't write it and that also is
  131. a very important lesson if you don't like the risk you don't like the business don't do it and particularly if
  132. you don't understand it certainly don't do it so in the past in Lloyds we used to write a lot of financial institution
  133. business and we provided a lot of cover to two great names Enron and Worldcom and as a result of that we paid out some
  134. pretty large claims but also as a result of that we took a conscious decision to
  135. scale back our exposure to financial to financial institutions because we were just uncomfortable with that type of
  136. risk we didn't really understand it that well so if you don't understand it that
  137. well don't do it so we scaled it right back to the extent that now with the subprime problem with the Madoff problem
  138. with the Stamford problem we find very little exposure to those institutions those organizations and Alo also to
  139. subprime claims so all the problems arising out of the financial crisis we will be able to deal with as uh business
  140. as usual so it's quite an important uh lesson for us don't mix up assets and liabilities be selective on your risks
  141. and when you don't understand it you don't like it just don't do it walk away [Music]

Brief Summary

Lloyd's of London discusses unique insurance practices and historical crises, emphasizing risk management and underwriting complexities.

Related episodes