Richard Ward, CEO Lloyd's: Learning from Crises at Lloyd's of London
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
Lloyds of London has been covering complicated and unusual risks including a wine tasters nose and a coffee tasters tongue for more than 300 years. But twice since 1990, it has faced crises that threatened its very existence. In a Wharton Leadership Lecture, chief executive Richard Ward describes the lessons it learned.
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- [Music] [Music] now we're not actually insurance company Lloyds of London we're in Insurance
- Market Market we're the largest Insurance Market in the world we're actually the only Insurance Market in
- the world if you want to Ure a very unusual risk you come into the Lloyd's Market you go to one underwriter to get
- a bit of a policy go to another underwriter to get another bit of the policy put them together and you have a
- policy that will cover the risk that you're wanting to ensure now inside the Lloyd's Marketplace we actually have 50
- companies operating companies that are corporate entities in their own right that are either listed on the London
- Stock Exchange or quite often are a subsidiary of an overseas entity such as a liberty in Boston or an ace in Bermuda
- or whatever but we've got these 50 companies operating inside the Lloyd's marketplace with their Underwriters
- actually sitting inside the Lloyd's building so it is a market we have over 5,000 Brokers wandering into our
- building every day with suit cases like this one sometimes actually my only prop
- for today full of information about a risk that they might might want to actually cover and you say why would you
- need so much information well we need so much information cu the risks that we cover are so complex so for instance I
- have been sitting on a box where um the underwriter was uh covering the Sultan of oman's private fleet of aircraft he's
- got a few trip 7s a few 747s few Gulf streams and Etc and to actually cover that risk the underwriter wanted to know
- the age of every airplane where it was serviced the uh um destinations that the airplane would go
- to the surface of the runways then he wanted to know about the crew and the age of the crew and where they were
- trained and it was an enormous amount of information the underwriter actually required to be able to underwrite that
- risk when the um Underwriters actually write an insurance policy however what they issue is a Lloyd's policy and that
- is quite a unique structure we're a mutual market and so anyone operating inside the Lloyd's Marketplace even
- though they might work for their own company they will work for their own company the policy they issue is a
- Lloyd's policy and therefore it has Lloyd's security behind it and Lloyd security is very important because we
- have never defaulted on a claim we've paid all our claims in the 321 years that we've been operating that has been
- a challenge for us because in certain periods in our history it's been quite difficult to find the funds to pay those
- claims and I'll share some of those experiences with you um what sort of things do we uh ensure apart from uh
- what was her name Dion's vocal cord um Ugly Betty smile have you seen Ugly Betty on television well we cover her
- smile for the uh for the older people in the audience uh Betty grable's legs we've ensured her legs we actually do a
- lot of legs American footballers legs uh European soccer players kneecaps so Beckham's kneecaps Ronaldo's kneecaps so
- we do a lot of body parts someone's chest hair we actually ured their chest hair um I I don't know what the claim
- would have looked like on that chest air claim but you know give some modities we
- we've insured a coffee Taster's uh tongue for $5 million and we've insured a wine Taster's nose for tulip wines for
- $10 million that's the uh the odd stuff but it is important because frankly if you are an American football player and
- you break your leg and you're unable to play a again you've got faced with loss of earnings you're faced with
- Rehabilitation and so the insurance policy is very important because that kicks in to start to enable that person
- to get back into training or whatever and rehabilitate and if necessary pay for loss of earnings so these are quite
- important policies but we also do other stuff I mean we were the first uh insurer to offer insurance for Aviation
- 1911 was the first uh commercial flight and we insured that flight we also insured the first commercial space
- flight in 2004 we Ure oil rigs we ensure Bridges we ensure buildings we ensure workers workers comp we provide d o
- cover directors and officers liability we provide terrorism cover we ensure against political risk a very large uh
- and Vari varied um range of activities that we get get involved in basically I suppose what we do is ensure things
- other people that can't or won't ensure and I'd just like to share with you two crises that Lloyds has weathered
- two storms that Lloyds has weathered that are very relevant very pertinent to the uh economic crisis that we find
- ourselves faced with today um they're quite well documented but let me spend a few minutes just sharing them with you
- the first crisis we had to weather was it back in the '90s and in the middle of the '90s so around about
- 9394 Lloyd suddenly found itself faced with enormous losses we were faced with 34,000 people who invested in Lloyds and
- we're faced with uh ruinous claims that they were having to pay these $15 billion worth of claims
- as a result of the problems that uh uh we' found ourselves faced with so was an extraordinary period um in our history
- where were these $15 billion worth of claims coming from a variety of things we were faced with a bit of a perfect
- storm um asbestos I'm sure you're all familiar with asbestos asbestosis loyds uh wrote a lot of the policies here in
- the US back in the 60s 50s and 60s providing cover to workers for asbestos the problem we faced though is we wrote
- those policies in the 60s and the claims didn't come through until the ' 80s and
- '90s how can you write a risk how can you price a risk in the 60s where you don't pay out the claim until the '90s
- pricing was completely shot to Pieces so the claims coming from asbestos were far
- greater than any of the premiums would ever taken in for those policies and it wasn't just asbestos we were also faced
- with claim coming from Piper Alpha an oil rig that uh um exploded Exon Valdes that leaked oil up in Alaska hurcan
- Andrew 1992 um and probably quite a few other things lead paint we having to deal with
- the environmental problem of lead paint and uh lead paint poisoning people how we dealt with that problem in the '90s
- was very simple we took well it required a lot of effort But ultimately it was a
- simple solution and the solution was really sort of based on the good bank bad Bank model and we took the decision
- along with the support of government to take all those liabilities that $15 billion worth of claims put all the
- assets we had against those liabilities and put them off into a completely separate vehicle and that vehicle was
- called equitas so we sold the building we sold Lloyd's list of publisher we sold Lloyd's Register we sold absolutely
- everything except for the silver if you come into the ly's building today you'll
- still see we kept the silver that's the one thing we kept we we sold everything to put it into this vehicle called
- equitas so we had some assets that we could put against those liabilities now you would have thought we would have
- leared from that experience said let's do things a little bit differently the only thing that we did differently going
- forward was to move from an unlimited liability basis to a limited liability basis uh prior to um this this issue
- anyone participating in Lloyds providing Capital would do it on an unlimited liability basis so if you had a claim
- you paid it and if the claim just grew and grew you continued to pay and pay and what happened to these 34,000 people
- that were providing Capital they were faced with ruin and a lot of suicides and the such like as a result of having
- to meet those liabilities so we took the decision to say right stop no more unlimited liability you can only write
- on a limited liability basis but we didn't change anything else I'm sure you've heard that story before when you
- look at what the banks are doing at the moment nothing else changed so of course
- we were then faced with our second storm and that storm happened in 2001 the tragic events of uh the World Trade
- Center where we found ourselves being the largest insurer of the World Trade Center and we ended up with liabilities
- claims coming out of the World Trade Center of 11 billion out of the total $40 billion claim so less than eight
- years later one day after the World Trade Center sitting in a room 24 hours after the event you had the same people
- sitting there saying we're about to go bankrupt we can't pay this 11 billion quite extraordinary that so soon after
- the problems of the '90s we were faced with a similar problem the problem we had um with the World Trade Center was a
- simple liquidity problem a funding problem the US authorities wanted us to fund our liabil growth here in the US
- and we didn't have the cash and so we had to Scrabble around strike a few deals and finally we were able to come
- to an arrangement whereby we would cut a little bit of slack a few days here and
- there there and we're able to then find the cash to fund those liabilities from the World Trade
- Center Lloyd said hold on we're going to have to completely overhaul the way this
- Market is operated and so we Chang management of businesses we Chang the governance of Lloyds and we put in a
- completely new structure and the structure we put in um I would call it the McDonald's of Lloyds we put in a
- franchise structure uh very similar to McDonald's there's nothing new in this world you know if you go to uh the
- McDonald's in Tokyo and ask for a Big Mac and large fries you know what's exactly going to be in that Big Mac
- where the girkin is going to be and how many fries you're going to get in your your bucket of fries just as if you go
- to um McDonald's here and Philadelphia and ask for Big Mac and Fries you'll get exactly the same so what's his name
- Ronald McDonald he's able to impose standards across the whole of the McDonald's franchise and get everyone to
- do the same thing and that's exactly what we had to do in Lloyds we said right we're going to operate a franchise
- model whereby anyone who wants to write business inside the Lloyd's Market does it according to the standards we set and
- they have to meet those standards and the standards are very clearly around risk management and around Capital
- setting um if I talk about risk management because that was the real lesson that we learned from the World
- Trade Center we've now introduced a very structured and disciplined approach to the risks that businesses are allowed to
- write in the Lloyd's Marketplace so we look at two things so if you're company a that is writing risks inside Lloyds we
- look at the risks that you're writing and then we look at how your risks plus everyone else's risks adds up together
- what the aggregate exposure is to ensure that firstly the capital you have is sufficient to support your business but
- secondly that the capital the market has is sufficient to support the risks across the whole market so it's a very
- dis disciplined approach to risk management and it's a very disciplined approach to uh Capital setting we have
- other standards around claims around business processing and the such like but the imposition of Standards on our
- Market has been a life-changing experience for us and the the use of a very discipline risk management approach
- Linked In with capital setting has been uh life-changing for us how life changing well 2001 was the World Trade
- Center 2005 Katrina Rita Wilmer bigger than the World Trade Center the losses from the World Trade Center were 40
- billion the losses from Katrina Rita Wilmer were $60 billion and our share of Katrina Rita wmer was $16 billion just
- to remind you our share of the World Trade Center was $ 11 billion when uh we had the World Trade
- Center and we looked at the results for the market at the end of the year the market loss in total was5 billion which
- is why we were close to bankrupt coming out of 2005 I took over in 2006 just on the back of paying out $16 billion for
- Katrina rmer and the loss for the overall Market was $160 million so it's complete reversal in
- fortunes and that was a direct result of our approach to to risk management um that's the sort of potted history of
- Lloyds and where we've got to how how is that serving us uh in today's crisis because we seem to have a lot of Crisis
- literally every 3 or four years in the Lloyd's market and the most recent one yes is a subprime crisis the the
- recession the economic crisis that we now found ourselves in in 2009 well as a result of all the changes that we have
- instigated over recent years we've actually weathered the recent storm pretty well um I'm reminded when talking
- about the recent storm of AIG I'm not here to knock a government own competitor uncomfortable though it may
- be to have a competitor that's owned by the government but when talking to someone about AIG they said to me the
- problem with AIG is when you look at their balance sheet on the left side of the balance sheet nothing is right and
- on the right side of the balance sheet nothing is left okay that's that that was yeah you're absolutely right we must
- never mix up both sides of the balance sheet so the way we Lloyds have weathered the storm is to keep the two
- separate and by the two separate I mean the liability that the risks we write we keep in one
- bucket and manage those and the assets the capital that we have to offset against those risks we keep in a
- completely separate bucket now the assets we have in the Lloyd's Market roughly $60 billion at the moment to
- support the risks that we write to support the $33 billion worth of Premium that we write every year that 60 billion
- we manage very very conser conservatively so over the past two years our EXP exposure to equities and
- exotic instruments and Structured Products has been less than 5% so looking at our 60 billion we've got
- roughly a third in corporate bonds third in government bonds and a third in cash
- what that means is we don't make spectacular returns from our assets but we also don't make spectacular losses
- and that's very important because those assets are there to support the liabilities where we do want to take
- risk so we don't take risks with our assets and we do take risks on the liability side but when taking risk on
- the liability side we're actually now quite selective and when we don't like a risk we don't write it and that also is
- a very important lesson if you don't like the risk you don't like the business don't do it and particularly if
- you don't understand it certainly don't do it so in the past in Lloyds we used to write a lot of financial institution
- business and we provided a lot of cover to two great names Enron and Worldcom and as a result of that we paid out some
- pretty large claims but also as a result of that we took a conscious decision to
- scale back our exposure to financial to financial institutions because we were just uncomfortable with that type of
- risk we didn't really understand it that well so if you don't understand it that
- well don't do it so we scaled it right back to the extent that now with the subprime problem with the Madoff problem
- with the Stamford problem we find very little exposure to those institutions those organizations and Alo also to
- subprime claims so all the problems arising out of the financial crisis we will be able to deal with as uh business
- as usual so it's quite an important uh lesson for us don't mix up assets and liabilities be selective on your risks
- and when you don't understand it you don't like it just don't do it walk away [Music]
Brief Summary
Lloyd's of London discusses unique insurance practices and historical crises, emphasizing risk management and underwriting complexities.





