Reinventing Museums for the Digital Generation

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Leadership

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. our guest today is Julian sega's director of the University of Pennsylvania Museum of Archaeology and
  2. anthropology also known as the Penn Museum and we're going to talk to him today about reinventing museums for the
  3. 21st century Julian welcome thank you for joining us today in knowledge at Wharton it's my great pleasure I wonder
  4. if we could start with something that I've found quite paradoxical museums are institutions that are that excel at
  5. preserving the past but as a leader you have to focus on preparing the institution for the future so how do you
  6. as a leader how do you manage this balance between the past and the future right what do you think well it's a very
  7. interesting question I mean as you say this museum has around a million objects and it contains the whole past human
  8. story from you know two million years ago from the beginnings of the evolution of our species but really what we do as
  9. a museum is we bring that to life and we show the museum go earth through our exhibitions for a permanent galleries
  10. and pre-programming the relevance of the past to the present and that's something
  11. that's a sort of a lens that we filter everything through and you can you know you can see it particularly in our new
  12. galleries of the ancient Middle East where we we look at a story that seems to be a very distant one the first
  13. cities but as you go through this exhibition you see how in fact so much of what we're showing you is relevant to
  14. us today as city dwellers so it's that the ability to connect the past to the present is really what we're we're
  15. trying to achieve and so many of the different things that we do so that's really interesting so when you think
  16. about connecting the legacy of the past to the present one thing that becomes really important is how you engage with
  17. with your audience or audiences and increasingly it seems to me that a big challenge that many museums seem to face
  18. is how do you connect with younger generations who go beyond sort of the the cultural elite but who are the
  19. Millennials or Generation Z or whatever you know acronym you choose to call them
  20. would you say this is one of the biggest challenges that museums face today it's
  21. certainly one of the big challenges that we face and you know as as you look at what's available to Millennials I mean
  22. there is the marketplace for your time gets bigger and bigger every single year also the actual the notion of a museum
  23. has has changed then you know museums now not necessarily automatically considered to be a voice of authority
  24. and so in engaging younger audiences is a really important part of what we do but it actually often means we have to
  25. change how we work and how we program and it's usually a more consultative process where you're actually asking
  26. younger generations what do you want to get out of the museum experience you have to design galleries with them in
  27. mind I actually have a great deal of faith in Millennials I mean they are they're a very engaged generation and
  28. they're looking for content and they're looking for authenticity and of course that's really what we do so as you think
  29. about how museums are trying to cope with this challenge what are some of the more innovative strategies that you have
  30. found museums practicing in engaging with Millennials and younger audiences well I think even more diverse audiences
  31. right well I think the key thing to remember here is you just can't program for an audience without their
  32. involvement and so I think what museums are doing increasingly is being more aware of the communities that they want
  33. to serve and that means often partnerships of those communities where they become actively part of the
  34. programming process themselves you're essentially asking them what they would like and we're about to open a series of
  35. galleries that highlight our African collection and we have set up a steering committee of community members to
  36. actually get it what are the issues that you would like to explore in a gallery with content like that and I think I see
  37. that with museums all over the world now that it's no longer here's our content that we we've curated for you it's
  38. mr. joint curatorship but at the same time you know museums contain this enormous pool of intellectual capital
  39. which we want to give as an act of generosity almost to the people to which are some of the more innovative museums
  40. in your experience around the world that have figured out ways to overcome the limitations just of serving people in
  41. their immediate region but using say digital strategies to engage more broadly with other audiences the to the
  42. release prince mine the Brooklyn Museum has done some amazing work with their digital content they have a whole team
  43. of basically content producers much like yourselves and they actually program for
  44. a level of membership that's purely digital and so there's new programming there are podcasts there's you know deep
  45. dives into the collection and I think they've done an amazing job the British Museum did an interesting thing they
  46. want it to be the classroom to the world and so they put a great deal of their collection online and would put on a
  47. range of teaching resources that are really first-rate and that's one of the things that that we set out to do about
  48. eight years ago is we have these million objects most of them aren't on display but now we've digitized around 700,000
  49. of those and we also put all of our contents lectures we filmed them and we put them on our YouTube channel and it's
  50. it's amazing I mean so we can have a lecture in you know one of our lecture halls it could be on something that's
  51. reasonably esoteric like the early cities of of Mesopotamia and we found that you know within a year that lecture
  52. has had in thirty thousand views from all over the world and you know we get we get contacted by people in Australia
  53. who are using there are content in their classrooms as well as for their own personal edification some of the lessons
  54. you think other museums can learn from some of the strategies you described well Mike Khan def who's the head of our
  55. website his strategy is more is more and er the more material that you put up the better and it just it tends to build
  56. on itself and so I think this idea of like record everything have everything available to everyone everywhere and
  57. also make it free and that's something that I think a lot of museums are realizing we used to you know charge for
  58. images of our collections we used to actually not let people take photographs in our gallery but in fact what you're
  59. doing is you're missing this potential advocate to go and post your material on social media download your images from
  60. your website and use them in ways that you couldn't have even figured out and it's a wonderful marketing and free
  61. marketing for for museums and getting our message out so as you think about implementing some of these digital
  62. strategies what would you think are some of the biggest obstacles that museums face in trying to implement digital
  63. transformation it's not easy and and and so any thoughts on what are the biggest
  64. challenges well a couple of thoughts being putting material online is is time consuming and it's costly but it really
  65. does pay dividends but it needs a concerted focus from the top down to do it the bigger challenge is actually the
  66. digital realm in galleries and to get back to your earlier points about you know how do how do young generations
  67. learn so much or how they learn now is through a digital interface and so they expect that to be in the galleries but
  68. the thing about digital technology is it dates very quickly and it's very expensive and so you're always trying to
  69. find that careful balance with having technology that allows visitors to drill down into the information that they have
  70. but that won't become obsolete I mean that we can never compete with you know the video game world but so that's
  71. that's how balance we have to tread and also you don't want the digital technology to take away from the
  72. integrity the object that's right in front him you don't want it to overwhelm it right now
  73. in addition to the display and the many educational institutions are experiencing disruption at three three
  74. levels with may as a result of digital transformation one is on the research front so secondly there's the teaching
  75. and thirdly is the engagement with the public do you see the same thing happening at the Museum and if so what
  76. has what has been so well have been some of the things you've done to address these issues
  77. hmm well those three realms are very interesting one for a museum like ours because they're at our heart where a a
  78. research and teaching institution but in many ways that's what makes us the most
  79. interesting now we all live digitally all of our researchers are students who come visit us and the public and so the
  80. key is is how do you unite all of these different digital arenas so they're all informing each other so for example you
  81. know in our galleries I've often said you know the most interesting thing about archaeology is archeologists and
  82. so we actually update what our field archeologists have been doing in the field in the galleries and so the
  83. research angle comes through and you through to the public so they know that all of these different areas are all
  84. sort of working to together to sort of cross fertilize each other that's great now I was talking the other day to to a
  85. colleague of mine who works with a lot of different companies on their digital strategies and she was telling me that
  86. one of the biggest mistakes that she has found people make when they are trying to go through this digital
  87. transformation journey is that they just hire a chief digital officer and they expect that one person to change
  88. everything and and of course it doesn't work and then you know after some time the chief digital officer is out and
  89. they try something else I was wondering if you have encountered similar thinking
  90. it museums around the world and and what do you think might be a good way to implement digital strategies if
  91. don't think this is the right way right well many museums have actually employed
  92. a chief digital officer I think the Met is probably the most famous example that
  93. we've seen in recent years and they do sort of think well that'll be the Silver Bullet that will cure everything I think
  94. that there is potential for a chief digital officer for this reason is they can find ways of uniting the different
  95. platforms that are happening digitally anyway in the museum and bring some sort of order to chaos from the research
  96. angle they can all be somebody who can you know look at a researcher who saves working in Egypt with a with a the
  97. projects out there and he could basically help inform them of digital tools that they didn't really know about
  98. but it's certainly in and of itself not going to solve your problems but I think
  99. museums are sort of feeling their way with this one but it's certainly in the last few years many museums have gone
  100. down this route and not always successfully know you've been at the pennmen since July 2012 if I have seems
  101. like yesterday and before that you were at museums in Toronto and in London and I was wondering you know what the
  102. lessons that you learned early on any of career that that were helpful to you in
  103. in what you are doing today and what some of those lessons might have been well I think when the lessons I learned
  104. very early on was that the best way to communicate with anybody is with storytelling and that really doesn't
  105. matter which museum you are in but that's really that's really at the core of what we do you're trying to transform
  106. somebody's understanding of themselves by stories of the past or whatever your discipline was I've always known that in
  107. fact nothing is more powerful than actually meeting the people who are doing the research and finding ways to
  108. get them out in front is is paramount you know everybody responds to a person and that is always a challenge for a
  109. museum because we're often galleries with nobody in them there's one thing I've really learned from being at the
  110. Penn Museum though which I didn't know I mean the other museums I've worked at have been very large fairly hierarchical
  111. mostly government-funded so Penn has is a university environment and so you have to have a much more
  112. consultative approach to leadership which is of course the Academy's way and you know I mean initially I thought well
  113. that'll probably slow things down a bit but in fact I think it makes things a lot a lot more effective and it's a it's
  114. a part of my own leadership thing that I that I really whose great to discover it
  115. and I think it it leads to more substantive change and of course the other big difference is from coming from
  116. a you know government-funded institutions to institutionally Penn is of course fundraising is a huge part of
  117. leadership here I mean if you want to do something you have to fundraise for and
  118. Penn is enormous ly supportive in that process well I wonder since and you've been at Penn for six years what has been
  119. the biggest leadership challenge I have faced in your time here how did you overcome the challenge and what did you
  120. learn from it well the biggest challenge has been a building transformation project so this
  121. museum is a really remarkable and unique one you could never create a museum like
  122. the Penn Museum today and our focus has been teaching and research but we have collections that some of which are in
  123. like every single textbook of the whole of the history of art I mean these are incredibly important objects but we sort
  124. of let our public spaces go some of those galleries have been around for 70 80 years in some cases and so this was
  125. an enormous opportunity and an enormous challenge was to basically redo 44 thousand square feet of the museum so we
  126. embarked through our strategic plan of the largest project we've ever done but of course it comes with a fairly hefty
  127. price tag of over a hundred million dollars so that our biggest challenge has been
  128. been adopting a fundraising strategy that can help us meet our goals and luckily were at Penn which you know
  129. which gets very excited by big ideas and so we are we're well over 60% of that of
  130. that total so far but you know that is and will always be there that the heaviest lift that I have as a leader
  131. here serve is to meet those goals and we will thinking about the future now how would you like Penn museum to be
  132. positioned for the future and how would you measure its success right well right
  133. now anybody who's an archaeologist or not historian deals of the ancient world knows about our Museum when these
  134. galleries are reopened and with the marketing campaign go with it my gauge of success will be bought public facing
  135. and I would like any visitor to Philadelphia to be very upset if they don't have an opportunity to come to the
  136. Penn Museum it has to be an absolute must see for coming to Philadelphia and I mean there there are sort of obvious
  137. ways to measure that success and one of them will be which we we are around 200,000 people come and visit us a year
  138. and I'd like to double that and I think it's imminently possible I mean where else in the world outside of Egypt will
  139. you be able to see a Egyptian veronik Palace at full height it's going to be spectacular well Julian thank you so
  140. much for speaking with knowledge at work and it's been great speaking with my absolute pleasure
  141. you

Brief Summary

Julian Sega discusses reinventing museums for modern audiences and the challenges of digital transformation.

Key points

  • Reinventing Museums for the Future. Julian Sega discusses how museums can connect the past to the present and engage younger audiences.
  • Engaging Younger Generations. Julian highlights the challenge of connecting with Millennials and Generation Z.
  • Digital Transformation Challenges. Julian shares insights on the obstacles museums face in implementing digital strategies.
  • Fundraising for Museum Transformation. Julian discusses the challenges of fundraising for a major building project.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes