Scale, Skill and Fund Returns
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
π Finance & Accounting π·οΈ Research
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- our paper is about scale and skill and active management we started with a simple idea which is that a mutual
- fund's performance depends not just on skill but also potentially on scale so in order for us to say anything about
- scale we need to make sure we first understand scale so the goal of this project is is to understand the nature
- of returns to scale an active mutual fund management we test two different ideas the first is
- decreasing returns to scale at the fund level there the idea is as a fund gets larger that causes the fund's
- performance to to drop for example because larger funds make larger trades that push prices more and that hurts
- performance that's the first idea the second idea is decreasing returns to scale at the industry level the idea
- here is as the overall mutual fund industry gets larger that makes all funds performance decrease and here the
- logic is as there are more mutual fund dollars out there competing and chasing after mispriced stocks that makes prices
- move and it makes harder for any mutual fund to find a a good trading opportunity our main result is strong
- evidence of decreasing returns at the industry level in contrast we find mixed evidence of decreasing returns at the
- fund level so more simply we find that it's the size of the mutual fund industry that's very important for
- performance the size of an individual fund is less important these results that we're finding on scale have some
- interesting implications for how we think about skill we offer a new way of measuring skill that adjusts for scale
- with this measure we show for example that uh skill has been trending upwards uh in the mutual fund industry over the
- last 30 years well an active mutual fund is U distinguished from a passive mutual fund
- in the sense that a passive mutual fund would just buy a basket of stocks that represent an overall investment in the
- stock market or segment of the stock market what we typically call an index fund uh an active fund deviates from
- that from that portfolio by overweighting stocks that it believes are underpriced and offer Superior
- returns and uh down weights or sells off the stocks that it believes are overpriced or or offer worse returns uh
- so an active fund will uh trade more than uh a passive fund and its return will have what we call tracking error
- relative to the passive uh uh Benchmark against which it's judged well the Surge and popularity of
- active mutual funds really coincides with the surge in mutual funds overall in in fact uh index funds or passive
- funds have actually had a somewhat higher rate of growth than active mutual funds but the overall mutual fund
- industry has grown so much uh over the decades that active funds too have become uh much bigger in the sense that
- they control a much bigger segment of the uh US Stock Market uh we believe that uh some the
- overall trend in mutual fund growth just coincides in general with the uh increasingly smaller fraction of the US
- Equity Market that's owned directly by individuals uh the growth in retirement plans such as uh you know defined
- contribution of 401K plans is is is one uh Big Driver of that growth and there other institutional factors that have
- been identified as leading to this surge in in mutual fund uh size as there more Mutual fund dollars
- out there uh competing with each other and looking for mispriced stocks then there's more trading on
- those ideas that pushes prices and that's going to make it harder for any mutual fund to find a mispriced stock so
- the analogy we like to use is that if there are more people fishing on the same Pond well that's going to make it
- harder for any individual person to catch fish on that pond well as Luke mentioned earlier in
- order to understand skill we have to understand what the role of scale or size of of industry in the fund is in in
- generating performance so we Define skill as the ability of a manager to perform relative to a benchmark uh
- abstracting from the effects of Industry size and his own fund size U so one way
- of thinking about that is we try to ask uh how much outperformance would this manager have if he were the only only
- one operating in the stock market and didn't have competition from all the other mutual funds and in fact didn't
- have to worry about how big his own fund got in some sense it's his ability to generate Returns on the first dollar
- you'd invest with that with that fund manager well we don't really know for sure but uh we do know that uh certainly
- the education of uh those entering the financial services industry has increased over time uh so the training
- has gone up um also uh over time new strategies get discovered uh we have uh for example quantitative approaches to
- Investment Management that exploit technology and Computing capabilities uh to much greater degrees than we could
- decades ago uh so we believe things like training and Technology uh lead to uh higher degrees
- of skill as well as uh the usual ual sort of learning on the job effects uh uh we believe that skill is uh increased
- for those reasons and possibly others we don't really know why for sure we show that skill has gone up over the last 30
- Years yet performance has not how is that possible our explanation combines two elements uh the first is the mutual
- fund industry has been growing steadily over the last 30 years the second element is decreasing returns to scale
- at the industry level and in other words funds are becoming more skilled but the
- industry is also growing and those two effects tend to offset each other in other words yes fund managers are more
- skilled today but they have to be more skilled just to uh keep up with the rest of the
- pack so as a fund gets larger it starts to make larger trades those larger trades push prices more against the fund
- which hurts the fund's profits yeah for examp example if you have a fund that uh
- thinks a given stock is underpriced and wants to buy 5,000 shares of that stock uh it has to go and uh find someone
- willing to sell that stock in the market if if another fund identifies a stock is
- under pric and wants to buy 50,000 shares of that stock it's got to find more potential sellers of that stock to
- do so it either has to offer a bigger concession willing to pay more for that stock to get it quickly or it has to try
- to parcel out it's its purchases over time and take longer and perhaps thereby miss out on some of the underpricing
- that would get corrected in the meantime I think we were surprised uh because some some of the uh the leading
- uh theory about mutual funds these days assigns a a central role to the notion that as a given fund gets bigger uh it
- should become become harder for it to perform um so I think we were somewhat surprised that even though our estimates
- uh pointed in the direction we were not able to get strong statistical Precision
- associated with those estimates uh so I think that was one aspect of our study we found somewhat
- surprising the logic for for why a fund Size Matters is compelling but there is a a different logic pointing in the
- other direction for example imagine two mutual funds that follow exactly the same strategy they make the same trades
- at the same times well you can see that their individual sizes may not matter instead what's going to matter is their
- combined size well again here's one of these findings we don't have a a a definitive
- answer for um but one one potential reason is that uh younger funds could also come with younger managers on
- average uh so we get back to this issue of uh increases in skill and and uh sort
- of technological prowess perhaps being associated uh with with age um the other thing is the younger funds could be
- exploiting newer strategies that the market has not sort of sort of caught on to and exploited to as significant a
- degree again this is one of those things like uh um Rising skill we don't we can't really say for sure why it's
- happened but but uh we think it's not implausible that uh that these factors could contribute to Superior performance
- for younger funds we find that there's also a second way in which fund age matters and uh that's a relation over
- time between performance and age we find that a fund's performance typically deteriorates as the fund ages uh if you
- take all these results together they're consistent with a simple story the story
- is that new funds entering the industry have more skill than the existing funds possibly because of better education or
- better grasp on technology because of this Superior skill the young funds outperform initially they outperform
- their benchmarks and they also outperformed the older funds but performance tends to deteriorate as a
- fund ages and the reason is that as a fund ages the mutual fund industry is getting larger and larger and that hurts
- everyone's performance investors should prefer newer active funds over older active FS
- funds uh each month we form a portfolio uh that contains all of the youngest funds say funds that are of age between
- Zer and three years we also form a portfolio of funds that are 10 years old and older and we find that the portfolio
- of very young funds significantly outperforms the portfolio of of older funds well here's sort of the bad news
- of this of this uh finding is that even though we find younger funds significantly outperform older funds in
- the active fund Universe uh active funds in general be they young or old uh on average have
- underperformed uh passive index funds so uh our message would be to someone who has decided to invest at least part of
- their money in active funds uh younger funds do seem to on average offer spr performance but uh the overall averages
- do favor index funds uh and potentially because of this finding that the uh industry Size Matters so uh
- you know as long as the industry is as big as it is the active fund industry is as big as it is uh index funds may offer
- a a better return uh you know were that industry to be smaller were it to shrink
- and indeed index funds are growing more rapidly uh there could come a time when active funds uh are able to keep Pace uh
- and perhaps even offer some prep performance but uh the evidence for now anyway would seem to be that uh index
- funds uh uh offer offer Superior average returns based on historical evidence well we are following up
- actually in fact we have a a uh a recent working paper that also explores the role of fund size in a somewhat
- different way we're looking at the uh the turnover of of funds how how much they trade and to what extent that
- turnover seems to be related to Performance do funds earn more after they after they trade more does a given
- fund when it trades more heavily produce Superior returns as a result and uh there we do find that that fund size
- does seem to play a role in particular small funds do seem to exhibit a stronger relation between their turnover
- and their performance suggesting they can more readily exploit these time varying opportunities to identify Mis
- pric see
Brief Summary
The episode analyzes how scale affects mutual fund performance, revealing younger funds outperform older ones but active funds lag behind passive options.
Key points
- Understanding Scale in Mutual Funds. The project aims to understand how scale affects mutual fund performance, revealing key insights about industry dynamics.
- Skill vs. Performance Paradox. Despite increasing skill among fund managers, overall performance has not improved due to industry growth.
- The Importance of Fund Age. Younger funds tend to outperform older funds, but all active funds underperform compared to passive funds.
Episode highlights
- Understanding Scale in Mutual FundsThe project aims to understand how scale affects mutual fund performance, revealing key insights about industry dynamics.βOur main result is strong evidence of decreasing returns at the industry level.β1:18May 14, 2015
- Skill vs. Performance ParadoxDespite increasing skill among fund managers, overall performance has not improved due to industry growth.βSkill has been trending upwards, yet performance has not. How is that possible?β6:15May 14, 2015
- The Importance of Fund AgeYounger funds tend to outperform older funds, but all active funds underperform compared to passive funds.βInvestors should prefer newer active funds over older active funds.β10:25May 14, 2015
Tension
45/ 100Some tension





