The 3 Traits That Propel Success

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

In Amy Chua's new book, the bestselling author studies eight cultural groups in the United States and identifies the characteristics that account for their success. 📂 Leadership

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I'm Adam grant I'm here with Amy Chua the yale law professor who wrote the Battle Hymn of the tiger mother now
  2. she's the co-author of the triple package with her husband Jed Rubenfeld Amy welcome thanks so much for having me
  3. Adam tell us about the triple package what's it about well the triple package refers to three qualities that basically
  4. propel individuals and groups to high achievement and disproportionate success the first element is what we call a
  5. superiority complex that is a kind of sense of your specialness or exceptionality the second is kind of the
  6. opposite of that that's a sense of insecurity a feeling that you were what you've done is not good enough and the
  7. third is impulse control by which we mean self-discipline self-control the ability to resist temptation and it's
  8. really the combination of the first two elements that I think is so unusual and an interesting you know I mean how does
  9. somebody simultaneously feel superior and insecure and yet that's really the key that's what generates drive this
  10. feeling like I'm not respected enough you know I need to show everybody I need to work harder than everybody else so I
  11. can get this recognition that I deserve so I was actually wondering that when I read the book how do you hold these two
  12. beliefs simultaneously where does the sense of superiority and inferiority come from and how do they how do they
  13. hang together well actually if you interview or just read the bios of very successful people
  14. it's amazing how often it just comes up over and over from henry's Kissinger to Alexander Hamilton I mean their BIOS are
  15. they you know have this enormous sense of that they could change the world that they were brilliant or confident you
  16. know great things that can be instilled by a parent you know actually that's what Sonia Sotomayor on the Supreme
  17. Court said is she said it was her grandmother that gave her this sense that she was destined for great things
  18. but if you just have the sense of superiority then you could be complacent you're much more likely to be hey yeah
  19. I'm great so it's only when that sense of superiority is combined with the sense of hey I'm not being respected
  20. enough you know I don't quite fit in and that sense of insecurity can in the case
  21. of groups come from being an immigrant you know if you're an immigrant that's almost class
  22. being insecure here that you're the quintessential outsider people are making fun of my accent I'm insecure
  23. about whether I can make it in this country I'm insecure about whether I can be accepted so that combination of maybe
  24. very feeling very proud about it could be your group it could be you know you're just proud about yourself you
  25. have a strong sense of self but when you combine that with a little edge like I just a dash of insecurity then that's
  26. when you kind of get this goading the catalyst that makes people you know motivates people and you use that lens
  27. to explain the rise of some cultural groups how did you end up connecting these qualities to culture well we
  28. actually work the other way we started looking at the most successful groups in America again by just very conventional
  29. metrics income professional and educational attainment without saying that that's the best way to live your
  30. life but whose doing really really well and kind of using straight census data and we isolated you know big methodology
  31. but we isolated eight groups that seem to be really hitting it out of the park right now and they include two non
  32. immigrant groups Jews and Mormons but then Indian Iranian of Lebanese Americans Chinese Americans and then
  33. Nigerian and Cuban Americans so then we were studying them like you know we thought we were gonna write about maybe
  34. different cultural pathways and instead once we put together this research team it took us like three years we found
  35. something surprising basically a really remarkable pattern which is that all these groups actually share these three
  36. qualities a deep sense of their own exceptionality whether it's a chosen people narrative or you know Mormons
  37. have a very powerful sense of both religious and moral superiority or you know my own group Chinese Americans my
  38. mother always said we come from the greatest oldest most ancient civilization we invented everything you
  39. know and there are other sources too and in many of those cases the insecurity comes from being an outsider whether it
  40. from up being a persecuted minority or you know again being an immigrant how much does it matter if the sense of
  41. superiority is at the group level or the individual level so do I have to be part
  42. of some larger narrative or can it just be I think I have the potential to be really great
  43. it's absolutely at the individual level and I think that's the biggest misunderstanding about the book because
  44. people are focused on these oops but at the end of the day any individual of any background you know
  45. it's can have the triple package and again if you look at Barack Obama you know almost by his own language he
  46. almost describes this insecurity and chip-on-the-shoulder that pushed him and his mother who actually made have given
  47. at 5:00 in the morning a lot of self-discipline actually but that's what's so interesting about the book is
  48. I actually think the most exciting applications are for America's poorest groups because the triple package it's
  49. very very fluid one of the things we found is that groups rise and they fall very predictably you know so after
  50. immigrants usually after the second generation you see a very sharp fall-off with the Jews being the only exception
  51. and I think the triple package explains that that persisting insecurity from a long history of persecution and then the
  52. Holocaust but what we are hearing from educators around the world including two of the country's largest inner city
  53. charter networks is I can't believe it these three triple package qualities are exactly what we are trying to instill in
  54. our underprivileged kids you know we're trying to do much more impulse control self-discipline sit down be able to do
  55. this Saturday hours in security the sense of higher expectations you're amazing but you can do better you
  56. haven't done you're better than you think you are and I think the most interesting thing is where does that
  57. sense of exceptionality come from it's it's the best kind it is a sense of exceptionality that these schools are
  58. trying to instill that it's not based on belonging to a certain group or a certain religion but rather a sense of
  59. pride that any individual can take from hard work and persevering and kind of beating the odds and you know overcoming
  60. life's challenges and and that's actually you know what you see a lot of these schools trying to do and they're
  61. having great success with a you know incredible graduation rates so I think the impulse control part is probably the
  62. least controversial piece of the triple package right I think the the superiority and insecurity piece is the
  63. the trickier part of the equation and I'm reminded of some research on self-esteem that psychologists have been
  64. doing over the last few decades and Android by my sirnas colleagues had this great review where they asked
  65. essentially is high self esteem associated with anything good not really maybe a little
  66. bit with happiness but it doesn't buy you a lot for success interpersonal relationships or much else and I guess I
  67. worry a little bit about you know if we combine superiority and insecurity do we
  68. get people who not only have high self-esteem but unstable or fragile self-esteem where they're constantly
  69. protecting themselves in shielding themselves from the slings and arrows of life as opposed to just developing a
  70. realistic sense of obligation or duty to try to do something meaningful with their lives well yeah actually this this
  71. captures one of the I think the most important parts of the triple package we have a whole chapter exploring the
  72. underside so I think the book isn't just the celebration of success in the triple
  73. package because we deliberately chose these terms you know we could have called it you just need confidence and
  74. grit and big dreams but we chose a superiority complex that's a kind of a negative concept shades into intolerance
  75. insecurities you know that's that's clearly a negative term but I think a couple of important points first all the
  76. studies show now that actually the students who have the lowest self-esteem you know reported self-esteem in these
  77. big high schools you know how do you feel about yourself do you are Asian Americans they have the lowest reported
  78. self-esteem but they have the highest achievement in terms of at least grades and test scores and I think what that
  79. shows is that if you feel that you're just perfect you're amazing there's nothing more you need to prove you're
  80. not gonna work hard right you you you need that little edge but the dark side is so important right like that feeling
  81. like I'm not good enough yet I have to prove myself whether to society or to my parents can be
  82. incredibly unpleasant and we have all these interviews and quotes in the book from you know Amy Tan the famous
  83. novelist said I I mean she's incredibly successful but she said I was miserable all my childhood I felt I could never
  84. ever please my parents said there were times I wanted to die and she had to break free from the triple package that
  85. as her parents want to do the typical academic things and she had to break free of them only the director said the
  86. same thing his dad kept wanting him to be a professor you know he wasn't even happy when he won the Academy Award so I
  87. think there are downsides because this kind of need to prove yourself to society or to your family or the Kim
  88. tends to channel people into kind of conventional forms of success now that's not necessarily bad if it makes you
  89. happy but if it's not what you want to do with your life it can be very imprisoning I think that's a totally
  90. fair point I guess is the last word on this you've mentioned parenting a few times I
  91. can't ask or I have to ask I should say you know what about what is the role of Tiger mothers and maybe also a Lombardi
  92. dads in the triple package well it's definitely the triple package is definitely not a parenting book but
  93. there are some overlaps I mean in some ways both books are about how do you motivate your children how do you
  94. inspire your children and you know it battled him with the tiger mother that was supposed to be a self-parody memoir
  95. so it's be funny just kind of my own story but I ran up against this you know individual
  96. personalities a second daughter who just didn't want to do what I wanted her to do and the lesson the book in some ways
  97. is you have to find how to harness her strengths and her confidence but allow her to apply it in a way that fits her
  98. personality and fits her dreams and it's still a work in progress actually I mean
  99. we're really good friends but you know it's never easy it's never easy and I think that's the
  100. thing about the triple package I think it's ultimately an attempt to present it's a book that tries to be honest
  101. about what it takes to be successful even in a conventional way you know what it takes to have drives because if you
  102. think about it to be driven something has to be missing something has to be pushing you I think you know I mean if
  103. you just feel completely perfectly fine everything is you don't need anything more I think we'd all love to feel that
  104. way but your why would you then wake up at 6:00 in the morning why would you work till 7 why do you write another
  105. book I think something has to be pushing you and we're trying to figure out that
  106. balance and how can we combine that in a way that you know allows this person to
  107. thrive and be happy and be healthy and have meaning in their lives but also you know also of you know basically achieve
  108. your goals I mean if you were to ask me what is the definition of success it's very simple it's to achieve your goals
  109. whatever those goals may be you know whether it's writing a novel or making a film or or becoming a doctor and I do
  110. think that proper titrated and kind of combined with friendship and and generosity would you
  111. write about the triple package actually can help people achieve their goals well
  112. I hope you're right about that thank you for joining us today thanks for having me
  113. you

Brief Summary

Amy Chua discusses her book The Triple Package, highlighting how superiority, insecurity, and impulse control drive success in individuals and cultural groups.

Key points

  • The Triple Package Explained. Adam Grant and Amy Chua discuss the three qualities that lead to success: superiority complex, insecurity, and impulse control.
  • Cultural Pathways to Success. They explore how different cultural groups embody the triple package qualities and achieve success.
  • The Dark Side of Success. The conversation touches on the downsides of the triple package, including pressure and mental health issues.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

More from Knowledge at Wharton