The Many Meanings of Baseball: History, Data, and Fan Experience

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Professor David Henkin, a historian of American culture and author of Out of the Ballpark, joins the Wharton Moneyball team to examine how baseball’s history, statistical evolution, and fan engagement reveal a complex, ever-changing sport that defies any single interpretation. Cade, Eric, Shane, and Adi also discuss early data and strategy implications of the automated ball-strike system in Major League Baseball while also analyzing tournament dynamics and competitive balance in NCAA March Madness.

ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? Moneyball Highlights explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.

#baseballhistory #sportsanalytics #mlbnews #baseballnews #marchmadness ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Welcome. Welcome to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to a full hour of sports analytics here on the Wharton Podcast
  2. Network. This is Cade Massey hosting with the whole crew. I think it's been a while since we've had
  3. everybody in here. Eric Bradlow is here. Adi Wyner is here. Shane Jensen is here.
  4. Those three responsible adults are on campus being professors. I am in a long way from
  5. uh campus, but trying to be a responsible adult. Some combination of us are here
  6. almost every week of the year, 48, 49, times a year. We've been doing it for more than 12 years now. Just passed the
  7. 12-year anniversary at the top of March. We are recording on a Tuesday afternoon
  8. as we typically do. The show will go up in the wee hours of Wednesday. We're going to follow our usual format this
  9. week. We're going to start with the guest in the first half hour and open it up, open lines, open topics
  10. in the second half hour. Good time of year, lots of things going on. Glad to have the whole crew back. We are going
  11. to turn it over to Adi Wyner to introduce our guest and to lead the interview with that guest.
  12. Our guest being a long time friend of our friend Adi Wyner. Adi. Happy to introduce uh Professor David
  13. Henkin. Um David and I go back almost 40 years now. It's hard to believe that I've done anything in my life for almost
  14. 40 years, let alone known a human being starting as an adult. We were both at undergrads at Yale together. Um and then
  15. we were also um I guess technically colleagues at at Berkeley. You were You were just
  16. starting as a professor when I was uh finishing my post-doc at at Cal, but you stayed at Cal ever since as a professor
  17. of American history. He's the author of several books. I've read one of them. Um
  18. these are terrific books, but they have nothing to do with sports. You can go get them on your own time and look them
  19. up. But most recently and most interestingly to our group, David is the author of a recently um
  20. released book called Out of the Ballpark, a book about baseball, which is um so obviously something that's near and
  21. dear to all of our hearts, especially to uh the New Yorkers. And David is a New Yorker by by by birth, but he is
  22. actually a St. Louis Cardinals fan. I knew that about you, but I had actually no knowledge that you were how big a
  23. baseball fan you were. So, welcome to our show, Professor David Henkin. It's great to have you.
  24. It's lovely to be here. Um and for what it's worth, I was actually not I was born in France, which might have
  25. disposed me to root for a former former French to city instead of instead of the
  26. Yankees. That is a tidbit I did not know about you. So, there you go. Something that you learn. I'm going to actually
  27. before we actually begin the interview, I'm going to read a the my most favorite
  28. quote about baseball um that and because David's an author and he's a historian and he's a intellectual
  29. and he brings a a a view to baseball that's not what we typically bring. And so, I'm going to
  30. start with this quote. Um baseball breaks your heart. It's designed to break your heart. The
  31. game begins in the spring when everything else begins again and it blossoms in the summer, filling the
  32. afternoons and evenings. And then as soon as the chill rains come, it stops and leaves you to face the fall all
  33. alone. You can count on it. Rely on it to buffer the passage of time to keep the memory of sunshine and high skies
  34. alive. And just to end the days are all twilight when you need it most, it stops.
  35. Does anyone know who wrote that quote? I know I'm sure that David does, but anyone else?
  36. David, do you do you know who wrote that? It has echoes of Bart Giamatti, but >> That is Bart Giamatti and and I brought
  37. it in because it's the best baseball quote I've ever read. It captures I think everything that you one needs to
  38. know about the connection between baseball and I think in America's pastime. Um and of course, we were both at Yale
  39. at the same time when when Giamatti was our president. Um I think he left right around the same time you did and and I
  40. was stuck with Benno Schmidt for the for the last couple years. You missed those
  41. those seasons. Anyway, so David, you're an author of this great book which I did
  42. read and I'm going to start by just asking you a question about it. Um, one of the things that you talk about is
  43. that baseball isn't about one thing. What were you thinking when you were pushing back against the tradition of
  44. baseball as a, you know, a bunch of a story about teams, players, accomplishments, but as maybe is it a
  45. grand metaphor for America? Is it something else? Um, so tell me about how you came to write this book and what and
  46. and what's what is your take on the origin? >> I came to write the book because Oxford University Press asked me if I
  47. would do their very short introduction to baseball and it's not something that I had had had published on before that I
  48. do teach about baseball sometimes in the context of of of larger developments and I started to
  49. thinking about, well, you know, what is my take on baseball and I thought about all the things people have
  50. said about it including the quotation that you just read Audi and the contrarian
  51. you know, or the maybe the skeptic or at least the splitter in me. I'm I'm often
  52. interested in in differences within things that appear to to to be to be the same came to mind. So,
  53. so many of the things that people say about baseball as as as a whole draw my draw my suspicion.
  54. First of all, that has to do with the unique character of the United States in part because I'm not sure what there
  55. is a unique character to the the United States. But also because and I point this out in
  56. the book, a lot of the things that people say about baseball actually contradict one another. I mean, it
  57. doesn't mean that one of them couldn't be true, but but I've heard people say that baseball is about punctuality
  58. and and precision and I've also heard many more people say that it's about the opposite, it's about living off the
  59. clock, it's about leisure. Lots of claims about baseball are connected to pastoral settings and connected to the
  60. natural rhythms of an agrarian society. >> I will cornfield kind of like Exactly.
  61. Yeah, and and and that's sort of you know, that that flies in the in in the face not only of all the other
  62. cliches about baseball being city kids on the Lower East Side playing stickball, but also flies in the face of
  63. the actual history of the game as an urban as urban sport. I've heard people claim that it that
  64. baseball is American because it's about individualism and you know, one better at a time and
  65. everyone for themselves. And I've also heard people say that it's about America because it's about
  66. teamwork. So people disagree about what America is, they disagree about what baseball is, and they also ignore the
  67. fact that at this point in history baseball really is a multinational sport. It's not global in this in the
  68. way that soccer is, but of course but it is the it's the national team sport of Japan.
  69. It's at least as popular in the Spanish-speaking Caribbean as it is in in North America.
  70. You know, and and uh the World Series gets higher TV ratings in Japan than it does in the US. And
  71. we've a lot of us probably watched the recent World Baseball Classic and have been impressed not about the players but
  72. by more by the the fan cultures that have grown up outside the United States. So rather than look for the one thing
  73. that baseball is, I've tried in this book to think about many different things that baseball has been in in
  74. different settings over time. So that's one thing that I sort of wanted to push back on. The other thing
  75. I think I wanted to push back on is the idea that baseball is fundamentally different. Which is another one of those
  76. contradictory cliches. People always say that baseball is completely different from what it used to be, which would
  77. make it much harder to claim that baseball is about one thing or it's about the essence of timeless American
  78. national character. So they're actually going the other direction which I I'm you know, baseball
  79. obviously changes in many ways because society changes, but but baseball um uh uh
  80. I think a lot of what makes baseball interesting as a spectator sport has actually persisted. And the and the
  81. things that baseball fans and commentators and players and and owners have wrestled with over time have
  82. largely been the same sorts of struggles and same sorts of sorts of themes. So, those are some of the things I was
  83. looking to do in in in this book. Yeah. So, I have I have a bunch of follow-ups,
  84. but I'll go to Shane. Well, one I just cuz you talked about the fan experience and one thing that
  85. kind of really caught my attention reading your book is you talked about basically fan the
  86. I think your quote is the persistent and widespread practice of individual fans scoring by hand, which has no parallel
  87. among spectator sports. And I you know, it maybe kind of really like I you know, I I thought I started
  88. thinking about that. No, this I started thinking, oh, there must be some other sport that does hand kind of scoring
  89. this way and it and I I I couldn't come up with anything and I I I maybe could expand a little bit more about that. To
  90. me, it got me thinking that maybe baseball in this particular respect is this really nice it's it's
  91. it's complicated enough that it's not a trivial or tedious exercise to kind of score by hand, but it's not so
  92. complicated like that you can't kind of score it by hand in sort of a simple sheet format. Can you maybe talk about a
  93. little bit more about that? Sure. I remember when I was reading the proofs for this book and that was one of those
  94. lines I was like, uh, someone's going to like tell me that in fact in in Pakistan, people score cricket
  95. exactly with the with the same uh, but but but I left it in there cuz I I I I didn't know that it wasn't true. Um,
  96. and it it it does So, so, uh, I think that the practice of scoring a game captures a couple different things.
  97. It first of all, it it focuses on the fan as a crucial producer of the thing that is that is baseball as a spectator
  98. sport. And that's not unique to baseball, but I think baseball was really at the vanguard A lot of the
  99. things I point out in this book, um, are things about baseball that are at this point true of many other spectator
  100. sports, but appeared first and most prominently in baseball. So, that's one thing. But the other thing is the
  101. scoring. The they producing a record record that's ideally redundant with the public one, right? I mean it was it's
  102. not like if if I I don't sit in in the stands at you know at at Wrigley Field and produce an an an actual record.
  103. There isn't going to be one. So it serves no practical purpose. It inserts me into the game because scoring
  104. is such a huge and by scoring I don't mean scoring runs. I mean the act of recording
  105. the statistical achievement of the game is such a big part of the game. It's how
  106. you mark that you were there. There are people who will score a game that they're not attending. But the fact
  107. that that's a that's a somewhat I think it's a It's rare. It's a little perverse.
  108. It's even maybe a little bit I mean it's it's it's it's it's a little bit deceptive. I mean because you're
  109. claiming a relationship that again that you didn't have. So in the same way that people like to
  110. catch a foul ball as a as a kind of a a trophy or a token of their participation. The scorecard itself is a
  111. trophy or token of participation cuz you were there doing a crucial thing. The crucial thing of course wasn't throwing
  112. a ball or hitting a ball or pitching a ball or catching a ball. It was instead participating in the
  113. practice of keeping tabs. And notice how many of the tabs that we keep are not simply about whether a run was scored or
  114. a base was attained but also who should get credit for that because we're we need to
  115. record whether whether there was an error or whether it was a hit or whether it was a pass ball or a wild pitch.
  116. So we're participating in the discourse of assigning credit or blame for things that don't actually affect the outcome
  117. of of the game. I mean the play does but whether you call it a wild pitch or a pass ball
  118. has no bearing on on the on the outcome of the of the game. But we care very much that someone record it. And if
  119. we're at the game, we want to be participating in the in the in the practice of of
  120. of of registering that judgment. So, David, I'm going to just follow up with that. Something that you did touch a
  121. little bit on the book, but I think it's something that for all of us who grew up
  122. with baseball as a child really feel. I didn't learn to hit the ball or throw the ball from my parents,
  123. from my father. My dad taught me how to score it. And when I first went to a baseball
  124. game, he he sat down and we bought the scorecard at Yankee Stadium, which was not the yearbook. The scorecard was
  125. cheap. And we And he taught me how to fill it out. And we did that together. And
  126. today, every time I go to a baseball game, I'm sitting next to him. And that is something that I think in in many
  127. ways attracts people to baseball cuz you cuz of that connection, particularly in non-athletic families,
  128. right? So, we have that connection. But But just And I think that I think in some ways keeping score really is is is
  129. a unique thing. Although Dean Oliver, who essentially learned He did that for basketball.
  130. But he invented the the act of of doing that for basketball. And now it's done automatically, but but he realized there
  131. was a giant hole in assigning credit in a basketball that didn't exist. And he essentially created that phenomenon. And
  132. And we argued recently he should be the first analyst to go to the Basketball Hall of Fame, a non-player, because he
  133. did that. But you mentioned one thing that you think that is is also unique about baseball.
  134. For those of you who haven't read the book, baseball, unique to any sport, has the crack of a bat.
  135. The sound of that crack of the bat is is it's a it's an oral sound that I don't think any sport kind of has that that um
  136. that Well, hold on. Okay, let's let's quick round robin on a on let's just do quick quick quick quick quick. Fellas,
  137. quick. Other noises in other sports, Shane. Doink. Two different doinks. One doink is a
  138. field goal miss off the goal But what about what about a post in hockey? What about a post
  139. >> thinking the field goal or the double doink even. Yes. The double doink even.
  140. Very famous in Philadelphia, the double doink. What about the swish or the clip of a
  141. net on a real clean basketball shot? So, I'm not saying there's I'm not saying you've got a distinct sound, but there
  142. are a few other aural experiences. >> One's easier to hear around the world than the other though, for sure.
  143. I mean, I'll let David answer the the sound of crack of the bat also hugely differentiated, right? So, Hank
  144. Aaron's crack of the bat was allegedly something to behold and it it changes by the the type of the batter or the the
  145. contact, etc. etc. So, you learn a lot from the crack. >> It's it's also different in amateur
  146. amateur versus pro. Amateurs ding ding. The aluminum bat is not the same. The aluminum bat is not the same. So, I
  147. mean, you know, the crack of the bat is is loud. I I To to me, the interesting question is uh
  148. how these sounds register um on the radio because uh a lot of baseball's popularity grew with
  149. the radio. Uh people listened to boxing matches on on on the radio, too. So, it wasn't And people listened to horse
  150. races on on on the radio. But, this baseball was really the the first team sport that was popular in in in in
  151. radio. And uh the crack of the bat, both the real one and and and the simulated one. There's there's As you've seen the
  152. film Bull Durham, you know, when when the when the team goes on the road uh and then the broadcaster like bangs a
  153. like a bat in the in the studio instead. So, I I I think those became sort of hallmarks uh
  154. and the roar of the crowd. When you listen to football or basketball, the roar of of of the crowd is helpful. Um
  155. but the the the doink, I I I don't think it's really audible. The doink in hockey
  156. also is is is and the swish are not audible. The The crack of the bat often still is au- audible when you listen to
  157. baseball. People do listen to baseball quite quite a quite a bit. Baseball, I think,
  158. is a is a somewhat more radio-friendly sport than than uh than some of the others that that that we're talking
  159. about. So, the crack of the bat is a striking thing at the ballpark, but I'm especially interested in the in the
  160. crack of the bat and the roar of the crowd in terms of of how baseball was experienced during many decades where
  161. most fans were actually listening rather than I I think also David to build on what you just said, the thing about
  162. baseball that makes the radio valuable is it's one pitcher one batter. I understand there fielders and
  163. everything, but like you can picture what just happened and you can attribute credit or blame to what just happened.
  164. Much harder to do in other sports. Yeah, that's true. I I find for example hockey extremely difficult to listen to
  165. on the radio because I want to see where everyone is at all times. Um Yeah, so no I I totally agree with that
  166. Eric. Well good so that's good to segue. I mean I'll just we talk about all the differences. When I try to teach
  167. baseball to people who are who are coming in from abroad or never been to a game, I try to explain that it's
  168. fundamentally a team sport played by an individual um situations almost like an Olympic sport. Like we can we can judge
  169. the quality of a performance clearly individually um in a way that you can't so clearly do in any other sport. Um so
  170. it has that both of those things mixed together. And that kind of leads to the to the the chapter I guess we can focus
  171. on. This is a chapter you have called accounting which really is closest to our hearts. It's a it's not actually
  172. called statistics. You You chose deliberately to call it accounting which I think makes sense given our
  173. conversation about scoring. It's not just about statistics. It's also about how the statistics come to be. Um So my
  174. question is and and you make a point about this and it's I think it's something we've talked about on our show
  175. to some degree um which is that uh we like to think of the baseball's obsession with statistics, particularly
  176. advanced statistics, as something that's somewhat new to the say the Moneyball era. One of the things you point out is
  177. it's not new. It's in fact some of the major findings that we like to attribute to Moneyball that the idea of a base
  178. percentage mattering, um hitting home runs and and things like that and batting average and being such a
  179. particularly good metric. Those are know have been known for a very long time. So, why don't you can tell us about
  180. evolution of statistics, um how Moneyball really isn't new, and and just uh give us some thoughts on that on that
  181. area. Yes, I mean I mean uh there are some news I should say cuz I'm I'm still I'm about to say what you said I I say
  182. that cuz I'll I'll I'll the the disclaimer to be clear. Uh there are a lot of interesting things that are new
  183. about the way in which baseball is is discussed, played, um and accounted for uh in the so-called Moneyball era. But,
  184. one that's clearly not new is an obsession with statistical accuracy and a great faith that numbers, and
  185. especially large numbers, um uh can play an explanatory role in appreciation of the game. I mean that's
  186. essentially what what Moneyball is is about. I would say that goes back at the very least to to to know to the
  187. middle of 19th century and Henry Chadwick, who was a sort of a British-born um immigrant American uh journalist who
  188. played a large role in creating things like the box score and championing the batting average uh and talking about
  189. earned runs. Um and he had many he had many things on his agenda, but one of them is is the Moneyball
  190. project, which is uh great faith that large large numbers can explain meaningful things about game. Now,
  191. what's what's there a couple things that that that that are different. One is that uh um
  192. in-game strategy uh pays much more attention to the insights of those large numbers than they used to. I think the
  193. misconception is that we've gotten better at counting. Um and we've gotten faster at counting,
  194. obviously. But, I'm not sure we've gotten better at counting uh or more meticulous in our record-keeping
  195. uh as as a little larger culture. It's just that um in-game strategy been somewhat resistant to the insights
  196. of those. So, for example, Philip Roth's 1973 novel, The Great Great American Novel,
  197. features like a 7-year-old kid who has run the numbers as you're supposed to do when you're a 7-year-old kid. Like
  198. whether your father is scoring or whatever. He runs the numbers and he says, "No,
  199. our best hitter should actually be in the first or second spot in the lineup, not in the fourth."
  200. Uh bunting does not make sense. And he he said all all all all the all the all the click all the you know all all the
  201. clichés of the post-Bill James era. Um and you know and and and he's resisted in in in in the book. But but you know
  202. Philip Roth didn't make that up. These these were insights that a number of including the professors of of of
  203. statistics like like like yourselves and people in the in the military um had written about and published articles
  204. in in in scholarly journals. So, one difference is yes, it's it's it's much better reflected in the way that the
  205. managers manage and and even the way players play. Uh There also is I think an interesting to
  206. me difference in the way that these insights are deployed by fans, which is there are a number of statistics now
  207. that are interesting to me because they're actually not about the traditional goal of assigning credit or
  208. blame for the outcome of a game. So, what Chadwick wanted to do, this was like the classic model, is the game is
  209. complicated. Um a hit doesn't necessarily uh lead to a run. Many things have to go
  210. wrong or right to produce an outcome. But let's figure out whom we can praise or blame for their contribution to what
  211. actually happened. But now we have all these statistics that are much more interesting, especially to to teams,
  212. that are are trying to project and and assess the value of a player that are not about what happened. They're about
  213. what like screening out the noise. So, for example, fielding-independent pitching.
  214. Right? So, that's a that's a or uh or Babbitt, the batting average of balls balls in
  215. play. These are statistics that are designed to screen out the role that an individual contribution made to the
  216. outcome. Uh because the outcome is sort of noise, right? Uh the outcome might tell us something
  217. that's interesting to fans or to bettors or whatever, but but we want to know whether this player is likely to be able
  218. to do something good in the future, which we want to know in order to decide how to evaluate and assess this
  219. this player as as as as a commodity, we want to know the things that he had control over. We want to pay a lot of
  220. attention to to think like a pitcher's uh walk and strikeout rate. We want to pay a lot of attention to isolated power
  221. stat stats or even, you know, the exit velocity of a foul ball. Um uh we want to know sprint speed. We
  222. we we we we want to focus a lot on things that may or may not have contributed, and in order to isolate
  223. those things, we will often want to disregard things like whether the ball was a hit or not. So that is new, right?
  224. Before I before I go to Eric, I just want to a comment. I mean, in some levels historically, we were all historians.
  225. Statistics were helping us be historians. Like like you I mean not like you, but yeah, same idea. We always
  226. talked about what happened, and the assumption was the best predictor of the of the of the future is the past. And we
  227. now we're becoming actual statisticians. I mean, cuz what we realize is the past
  228. is a mixture of innate talent plus noise. And these statistics are there to screen out that noise, and we can get a
  229. better estimator. I can use statistical language to do that. And that's what it's great to listen to you say this,
  230. cuz what you're realizing is that the fans have become statisticians. Right? Yeah, and they've also become
  231. more like general managers. >> Mhm. Right? >> Yeah. Um in other words, they've got a
  232. little bit less uh Fans famously have liked to to play the usurp the role of umpire, but also they've liked to usurp
  233. the role of official scorer, and they've also of course like to usurp the role of
  234. manager, right? W- Why do we bring in this relief pitcher in that situation? Why do Why do Why do we let Pedro stay
  235. in the game kind of thing? Um Appreciate that, T Car. Yeah. Thank you very much.
  236. You know, now when when when when when we let fans We listen to fans speak, you can see
  237. them identifying with the general manager. And for And for that purpose, they want to talk
  238. about whether someone is likely to be good in the future not whether they've been good in in in the past. And that's
  239. part of the reason why they're drawn They're drawn to that kind of vocabulary. So, that that's that's
  240. that's my take on what is and what isn't new about about Moneyball's dizzy. Now,
  241. what is really new about about the larger culture of watching baseball and is technologically new is video
  242. capture. I mean, these are things we couldn't we couldn't talk We couldn't talk it We
  243. could talk about how fast a pitch was based on a radar gun, but we we couldn't talk about spin rate. We couldn't talk
  244. about hit probability or catch probability. And And the ability to to literally visualize bodies, balls, and bats in
  245. motion has changed so much not only about the way we talk about sports but even about the way the players play the
  246. way they train, the way they think about their own their own their own their own mechanics,
  247. the way they think about their own talent, the way they think about their own um uh uh capacity to develop and
  248. improve the way they sort of self-project their their own their own development. So, I think there are
  249. technological things that are really new. I think mostly I'm struck by the ones having to do with video capture not
  250. the ones having to do with conversation. All right, so we're going to go to Eric,
  251. then Cade, then Shane. So, Eric. Hey David, I just want to ask you, um let's think of all the major sports. I would
  252. make the argument, but I'd love to hear from your historical and thought perspective based on your book.
  253. Let's imagine you can only consume the game. So, you can watch the baseball game. You
  254. you watch the football game. You can watch the basketball game, you can watch the hockey game, whether in person or on
  255. TV, but I don't allow you to talk about the game. I would argue that baseball would suffer
  256. the most. Maybe because it's become ingrained in us to talk about the game. Maybe it's become ingrained in us to
  257. compare the history of the game. Like, "Wow, that's something I've never seen before in the history of the game." So,
  258. to me, would you agree with the premise that the narrative around baseball is just as important as the game itself?
  259. Yes, I agree with absolutely everything that that you said. You did lump together two things that are interesting
  260. to me to separate, which is being live at the game and watching it. In part because both of those actually
  261. can involve talking about the game. But the game broadcast, whether on radio or TV, are very much about talking about
  262. about the game. And so, um yeah, so what you say is true. I think what you say would be even more striking if you
  263. if you in the hypothetical you weren't allowed to to watch it on. I I happen to think that the sport that is most
  264. improved by live attendance is hockey. Um by by by by a long shot. Um I think basketball is very very
  265. legible on on on television much as it is live. Baseball is somewhat less legible in
  266. both cases and does require a lot more more talking. Hockey is barely legible uh
  267. TV and oddly it becomes more legible when you actually you appreciate things about it. I was also referring David to
  268. the fact that if Audie and I are at the game, part of the consumption utility is not the
  269. announcer, it's us talking to each other much more so than at other sporting events. Not that we wouldn't talk to
  270. each other. And maybe it's because of the cadence of baseball. Maybe it's because of the history of baseball. It's
  271. just that we're not going to miss anything in that 15 seconds where the pitcher So, we got plenty of time to
  272. talk. And we do. Yeah, I I I agree though. I mean, people have made some similar arguments about
  273. football. Uh you know, it it George Will's famous comment that football is this uh a classic American sport because it's
  274. spectacular bursts of violence uh punctuated by committee meetings. Uh so, that the committee meeting in football is
  275. also an opportunity for fans to talk about, you know, what what what the play ought to be. So, I'm not sure if it's
  276. unique to baseball's cadence, but baseball's cadence contributes to it for sure. Yeah.
  277. Cadence. David, uh I enjoy I read a few chapters and enjoyed them immensely and I learned
  278. a lot. And some things I wouldn't have expected to know, like the Chadwick history and scorekeeping and
  279. his philosophy and all that is phenomenal and fascinating. But I feel like I should have known the
  280. Curt Flood story. I did I didn't know the Curt Flood story. This This was the beginning of free agency, I gather,
  281. probably across all sports, but this is the according to David, the St. Louis Cardinals outfielder who got traded to
  282. the Philadelphia Phillies. Here comes Philly's rolling this thing. And sued MLB cuz he didn't want to go.
  283. And uh lost it went all the way to Supreme Court, loses. But becomes kind of a hero and it it
  284. prods the union movement, etc. etc. Anyway, this is a long way of saying I learned some things that I think I
  285. should have known and learned some things that I would never have expected myself to know, but found fascinating.
  286. I want to ask you, I think history does provide a great deal of signal in what's going to happen in the
  287. future and we're obviously should be paying attention to history for that reason.
  288. The chapter on capital and labor, union negotiations and how how much difference
  289. Marvin Miller made when he came in and ran the players association and how that you make this great point, you know,
  290. Shohei makes this huge salary now. That's due to what a great player he is, but it's also generations of union
  291. bargaining that got him there. This is all a set up to ask, given your read of history, what should we anticipate about
  292. this next round of bargaining, which feels like it's headed for a massive stoppage? And we can say we can argue
  293. Shane and I argued some of the show last week about whether this would be good or
  294. bad, but I'm just curious. What does history tell us is likely to happen union owner negotiations next year?
  295. I don't really have much much insight in this. I'm just going to just a disappointing answer. I mean, that the
  296. structure of the problem remains the same, which is, you know, the players are the only ones that fans really want
  297. to see. They don't want to see uh uh replacements. The players are uniquely talented, but nothing that they do has
  298. value uh not just without opponents, but without the structure of a league. Uh the struc- I I have a chapter in here
  299. about associations and leagues. I think that the league is is one of like the sort of mysterious and often underrated
  300. features of modern spectator sports. The league is what gives meaning to competition between two changing
  301. entities over time. And a lot of the appetite that people have uh for spectator sports has to do with the fact
  302. that they see uh continuity. So, the league has that power. Um uh and then the players obviously have
  303. have have have have the power that talented um entertainers al- always do, especially in competitive context. So, a
  304. little different from like the movies or a theater, where you know, you could have an idea that someone is uniquely
  305. talented at at singing or dancing or or or or or at at telling jokes, but because sports pit people against each
  306. other, uh the demand for the very best uh on the part of fans is is a little bit more
  307. non-negotiable. So, that's what the the players have a lot of power. Now, the tricky thing about the the current um uh
  308. labor conflict in Major League Baseball is that the the uh the collective bargaining agreement is
  309. in place has worked out very very well for the players. Not for minor leaguers, but for for
  310. Major League players worked out very well. It's worked out very well. It's argued in this book in part because
  311. Marvin Miller was very good at his job. And once certain victories were in place, they're very hard.
  312. The threat to baseball for Major League Baseball in this century is not never been the strike. It's it's been the
  313. lockout, right? It's it's it's it's owners who are dissatisfied. So, I can't predict what they're going to do. I
  314. can't also predict, um, you know, how how the the the change in leadership on the union side, which I
  315. think probably is going to strengthen the union's position, is is is going to play out.
  316. I can't predict how the recent flurry of long-term contracts to very young players.
  317. I mean, I think just this morning that the Mariners broke the record for the the the largest contract to a guy who
  318. has not had his Major League debut in Colt Emerson. So, there are a lot of things that are happening right now that
  319. more knowledgeable people can weigh in how how they think it's it's likely to to
  320. to affect the landscape, but the structure of the problem is the same. It's been the same, you know, for since
  321. the mid-19th century. And the power the particular power of the MLB Players Association is what it
  322. is, and that's what the owners are up against. It's a strong union with a good collective bargaining agreement in
  323. place. The owners would like to disrupt that to control their costs, but they can't all get on the same page and
  324. and and collude and and stop shelling out these high contracts. So, so, you know, I'm I'm I'm I guess I'm rooting
  325. for the Players Association, and I'm also, slightly bullish on their prospects of
  326. of either avoiding or or or or weathering a work stoppage, but that may just be the fan in me
  327. talking rather than this story. Just so you know, Kate, one of the most since as
  328. you know and our listeners know I go to Cooperstown every year for the induction
  329. ceremony. I was there when Marvin Miller, he was deceased but his family spoke and so did many players on his
  330. behalf about the impact he when he was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame. One of the more memorable and impactful
  331. speeches about his impact of anybody in the last last 50 years in baseball. Let's tag him with what David said,
  332. which is US Steel Workers Union negotiators. So they he was a prominent guy in industry, he stepped over to
  333. baseball, brought a lot of expertise over to baseball. I'm sorry to interrupt you, David. No, no, I'm just saying that
  334. that that that Cooperstown has done a pretty good job at canonizing both Miller and and Curt
  335. Flood. And if Flood's a more complicated story because I mean, he lost the case, he
  336. lost his career. His life kind of unraveled. It's not a happy story. But he isn't he isn't he's now a saint,
  337. right? I mean, you know, if he didn't have the same he didn't have the same numbers as
  338. Clemente, I bet some teams would retire it, right? It's funny because Bruce Meyer, who's
  339. now the head of the players union, when he was here at Penn he he told me that Flood lost his suit. I didn't even know
  340. that. I thought he had won but in your book explained that he lost the suit but I guess won the war essentially. Well,
  341. yeah, he he his side won the war but I don't know His side won the war but he personally did not. Uh we only have a
  342. couple minutes left. Shane, do you have time you have a short question? >> kind of quick one I guess. I I really
  343. enjoyed the kind of description of some of the experimentation in the 19th century that went into the modern game
  344. we see. And you had one line where you talked about the current distance between the pitcher and hitter. And you
  345. say say which some mythologists cite as the key to to game's perfection. And I I
  346. that line by the way. But But can you maybe talk a little bit more about cuz I never really thought I mean obviously
  347. distant you know, can can you talk a little bit about what people mean when they say baseball's perfect with that
  348. with regards to that? I mean the idea is that if you move the the the the the rubber, you know, 4 in
  349. or 6 I'd say 6 in that's the big number at 6 in closer or to to the plate or or or further, it would make all the
  350. difference in the world. There even are movies and and and and and novels that that that
  351. that take up that that that experiment. >> is that kind of a is that a thought experiment or did they
  352. actually like in the 1880s like like is it such a narrow band that if we did move it 6 in it would just completely
  353. throw it off? >> was it was it was moved frequently in in in in the 19th century and the mound was
  354. raised and and lowered famously after the 1968 season. So I mean baseball's always tinkering
  355. with with size of the base in in in in in and always tinkering with the rules to try to regulate the balance between
  356. hitter and pitcher which at least for let's say 130 140 years has been the dominant focus of tension in a baseball
  357. game. And that's the part that sort of sort of resembles boxing or chess, right? There there there there is there
  358. is the showdown. And and the idea that that there's something magical built into the game
  359. from the from the beginning that that that maintained that balance I think is wrong
  360. and I mean the most obvious evidence for that is that is that leagues are constantly trying to trying
  361. to to figure out what to do to preserve that balance. Yeah, I get I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I
  362. I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I
  363. I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I
  364. I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I
  365. I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I
  366. I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I
  367. I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I if we somehow were able to make a minor
  368. perturbation that got that close to say 0.5 or something like that, would that be That would be a Maybe maybe it's
  369. that, you know, you can't actually vary it so continuously. There's a real inflection point. You move it 12 like 12
  370. in closer and it goes down to zero or goes up to one. So, it could be that there's just that a very narrow range
  371. that can happen. I just kind of wonder how much kind of perfection different very ways of perfection we have to play
  372. with in terms of that distance. >> Well, I know attention we we tend to focus a lot on on on the the the mound
  373. to to plate relationship, but but uh over time, you know, offense offense has has risen or success rate of
  374. batters has also risen and fallen frequently. And most commonly leagues turn to the to the
  375. equipment, to the ball, or the bat in an attempt to regulate that balance. More recently they Major League Baseball
  376. has done other things. I mean, defensive positioning uh the shift, that's a big one, right? That
  377. That That That That That has a huge impact or it ought to. I think we will see over over over a long period of time
  378. what it amounts to. But that ought to have a huge impact on batter success rate. As to some of the other rule
  379. changes that we've had, you know, I don't expect the automatic ball strike system to to have a big
  380. effect on on regular in the balance since since both sides have have I think sort of fairly equal access to that to
  381. that challenge. But But yeah, baseball's always trying to do things to regulate that balance. And then and mystifying
  382. the the mound to plate relationship is is I think not a good way to think about it because yeah. We We've come to the to
  383. the end of the interview. It's It was It was spectacular, but I want to end it in
  384. actually sort of an interesting way. Each of you are going to ask a single I'm going to ask a question of all of
  385. you. You one word answer, yes or no. ABS? Yes or no? So, why don't we go around, Shane, yes
  386. or no? Yes. Yes. Cade? Yes. Eric? Definitely yes. And I'm a yes, and I'll I'll end with
  387. with David, what's your yes or no? >> Okay, let me just pivot the question. The question is ABS in its current form.
  388. Yeah, in its Well, in its current form, yes or no. Yes. Excellent. Um it cuz it's the biggest
  389. change that we've had in baseball in in in probably years, and it's and it's on everybody's minds right now. We can
  390. devote an entire show for that, but I know we have to let you go, and we have the second half of our show
  391. uh to to come right after the break. But thank you very much, It's nice to meet all of you, and it's great Audie to see
  392. you, and and happy holidays and happy early baseball season to everyone who celebrate. And uh may your Cardinals
  393. Happy Summer Worker's Day. Yes, and may may your Cardinals do very well, and uh of course not at the expense of my
  394. Yankees, but um but I hope at the expense of the Dodgers. That's definitely And then maybe maybe in the
  395. in the more immediate term at the expense of the Mets. At the expense of the Mets, yes. That'd be fun. That
  396. I figure that's something that should please both the Philly fans and the Yankee fans among us. All right, so
  397. thank you David, and please uh stick around and we'll join us we'll return right after the break. Welcome back.
  398. Welcome back to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to the second half of this week's show. We had a long interview
  399. actually first half, long interview with David Hinken, former classmate of Audie
  400. Weiners many lifetime ago essentially. Cal professor, new book on the history of baseball. He's a historian, proper
  401. historian, writes proper historical books, and wrote a proper historical book about baseball. Very cool, you
  402. learn something any chapter seems to me uh fun, interesting. Fellas, what about live sports? Um y'all are one
  403. weekend to the Major League Baseball season. If you missed Audie's reciting Giamatti's quote about baseball,
  404. probably worth going back and listening to the top of the show. That was a money
  405. quote, and this is a good time of year to do it. Okay, one week into the season. I think I'm about to get 10
  406. minutes of all ABS all the time, but I want to get reactions to what's going on around baseball.
  407. Well, I certainly can jump in, although we can devote a little time to NCAA March Madness. Um So, yeah, baseball's
  408. been great. Um Dodgers, Yankees starting off strong. Um but it's ABS all the time. I was surprised in the first game
  409. of the Yankees game, the first ABS challenge didn't happen till late in the game. Um they were and I I think they're
  410. trying to work out what's the optimal time to do it. Um and what the rules are. So, there's going to be lots of
  411. discussion about that. In fact, we analysts should probably try to get in on the game. Uh what are what are the
  412. best ways to handle this? Clearly, the catcher is calling it when it's way out. When it's they're just when there's a
  413. bad mistake, they're just they're just tapping their heads immediately. Uh the question is when the batter should be
  414. doing it. I've seen lots of bad calls. The batters are not protesting, and I've seen good ones that the batters are are
  415. protesting and getting and not They're getting it wrong less. Getting uh getting it wrong more often, the
  416. batters. So, I've got I got I've got I've got I've got I've got a few uh statistical breakdowns if you want on
  417. the first week. It's like So, so 54% success rate on challenges overall. When the catcher the catcher had the
  418. have the highest rate of overturn. So, they are they're successful 64% of the time on challenges. Batters are
  419. successful only 42% of the time on challenges. Pitchers are only successful 40% of the time, but
  420. that's only happened like five times. So, like the vast majority of challenges have come either from the batter or the
  421. catcher. And the catcher's saying The catchers, not surprisingly, are better at it. They've got the better view on
  422. it. But, I would also expect these numbers to get better over time, right? Like players will learn, catchers will
  423. learn. I would think that ideally ideally the umpires would also learn though, right, guys? Yeah, you know
  424. what? Well, are they I kind of are they past learning at this point? >> Hold on a second. I mean, let's let's
  425. just stand back. One of the things that's I've watched a whole bunch of these overturns get get overturned by a
  426. hair's breadth, which I'm really curious about cuz I know the accuracy of the system is point what is 1/6 of an inch.
  427. So, 0.135. That is not very much, right? So, uh No, I said that wrong. 0.16 >> 0.166, yeah. So, that's not very much.
  428. And in other words, I've seen them get overturned calls, but I don't blame the the umpires for those. We Our minds
  429. recall the bad ones, right? >> Well, yeah, that's really what the system is for. I mean, if if you wanted
  430. to kind of modify the system, place like a 1/6-in barrier like extra border around the around the like
  431. strike zone, feel free. I watched CB Bucknor miss like 20 calls in the Red Sox game. There was only They ran out of
  432. challenges in that one. There was eight total challenges >> How does the rule work? If you make a
  433. challenge and it's successful, >> limit of two wrong ones. Two wrong, but you can have an unlimited
  434. Yeah, so so so the Red Sox challenge had eight total challenges and six successful ones. But then there was like
  435. another six they could have challenged after that if they had, you know, I mean again,
  436. yeah. I mean, CB Bucknor should I don't shame not having a job, but anyway. Shane brought up something
  437. interesting. So, let me let me follow the logic of what you said, which I happen to agree with. Let's pretend for
  438. the moment that umpires get better. So, umpires now prune off the really bad calls. So, the only ones that are
  439. challenged are now the close ones, which means the success rate may not actually
  440. go up Yeah. because the only ones that'll be challenged are the knife-edge ones that already talked about. So, you
  441. could imagine the long-run equilibrium is that things do not improve. Yeah, and then like it could be just
  442. kind of guesswork where where you know, it's around 50% because we're like we're
  443. all the only kind of challenged ones are on the like very much the margins where
  444. literally >> that story does depend on the umpires continuing to get better, >> And I think it's an interesting
  445. >> there are there are but Shane, hold on. Shane, set aside like you know um pillorying these guys and just ask
  446. what's the limit of performance at this task. And and they are already doing quite
  447. well. The The average of them is already doing quite well. They've learned Whatever they came up with you know,
  448. stat Statcast or whatever the name of the system is a few years ago and they started training on these things. You
  449. can see the increase in the improvement right away. I'm curious. What's the limit of performance? I mean the
  450. perfection is probably unachievable. They're still human beings. And so there's going to be some limit to what
  451. they can do. Also >> Yeah, I know. What you also might find, Shane, is you might find uh an
  452. asymmetry. And what I mean by that is well, you'll just like you'll get um reads on players like don't pitch high
  453. and outside to this player. This umpire is more prone to errors in this zone versus that zone. And those laws, as you
  454. know, Shane, are out there already. But now we'll have that measure. I mean, this will be available. It's already
  455. measured and already it's gotten so much I mean so much better. I mean, I know we
  456. Yeah, and we ought to and we ought to I think they should replace the whole thing with the system. No, no, but what
  457. I mean what I meant, Kate, was just if I'm a batter and I'm thinking about challenging, I may be more likely to
  458. challenge one low from this umpire than high based on the data that I know. That's a possibility. Yeah, but I will
  459. point out, speaking of um Aaron Judge had was a tremendous beneficiary. He was uh he had a strike I'm not sure it was
  460. strike three, but it was definitely a strike uh and it was 2 in beneath his knee. And anyone who's been watching
  461. Judge for years knows that he has been get he's been consistently >> crushed by that pitch. But crushed by
  462. that call. And he then hit a home run in that at bat. We're expecting big things
  463. from from that strike zone change. Altuve four hits yesterday uh two homers >> Well, I I I I was hearing I was reading
  464. I mean, he's right. So, he's going to be a benefit from the the system because the system is is now tied to height.
  465. Now, I mean, the umpires have always been that way, but the the ABS system is tied to height and he's probably been
  466. getting all kinds of bad calls for years. So, hold on. Let's just say let's let's let's emphasize this. We talked
  467. about it a couple of weeks ago in advance. We we called out those two guys in particular because they're oddly
  468. shaped in different directions as probably getting disproportionate benefit of the new system and you're
  469. reporting that already in week one it seems like that's happening. That's interesting.
  470. >> I I I I heard a rumor that a bunch of players are are are kind of that have have edited their their height. Like the
  471. like players height players heights have systematically gone down across Major League Baseball because if they have a
  472. lower height they can get the high strike is no longer a high strike. But interestingly judges judges concern was
  473. the low strike because he had the opposite problem. Are you expecting a higher league batting average this year
  474. because players do not have to now worry as much about the ball outside the zone
  475. being called a strike cuz they can always challenge it. Therefore, I can be a more selective hitter. I mean, you
  476. could make an argument that this should lead to higher batting average. No matter what the effect size is going to
  477. be. I don't know. I I I mean, we're concentrating on the two hitters that are benefiting from the system. There's
  478. got to be other hitters that are are neutral to it and the and the negatives will will Yeah, I mean, I I mean the
  479. part I I think like probably at their level I would guess you know, the one thing I think is is is
  480. one of the positives of this is that you know, even though you know, the height thing is kind of weird and whatever.
  481. It's it's a consistent strike zone the entire game. It's the same strike zone regardless of umpire. I don't know I
  482. don't know if that kind of within game consistency necessarily argues for the hitters or the pitchers, but like in my
  483. mind maybe I'm just too hitter focused. Like if I'm a hitter, I feel like I would be helped by that in game
  484. consistency. I agree. The other thing is that we've already established well, one
  485. week's of stats one week of stats has established that catchers are are better at this than hitters. And so the
  486. defensive team is better than the offensive team. And so they're going to asymmetrically benefit. So that that
  487. pushes the opposite direction, Eric. That says the catchers proficiency at this is going to help the pitchers. And
  488. so that would lean against What's interesting is will there be a decision made by many teams to not let
  489. um the really because you remember you cost your your team on the on the defensive side if your offense makes a
  490. mistake. So if you let your batters screw up, which is they're doing at a substantially higher rate than the
  491. catchers, they cost their team a challenge that a catcher on the other side will not now have, right?
  492. >> Right. So why would you be I mean you could just say no hitters, you can't But then they're definitely going to
  493. >> ones. I mean you still want the hitter to have the challenge for obvious ones,
  494. but yeah, I I get that. >> obvious, like really tough ones. >> Maybe a culture will develop where the
  495. cat you know, the hitter has to be very sure if they're going to call Okay, we have to have a incentive
  496. alignment, have a fine jar. You know, you put it wrong, you got to throw a 20 into the old bucket when you get back
  497. into the locker room after the game. Come on, you guys decision making. Isn't there some incentive alignment? Wait,
  498. come on. >> I I don't know what the right incentive is for a guy who makes $60 million a
  499. year. This this Get creative Get creative on that one. You know, they're They're huge competitors, so
  500. they want to win more than anything else. So That's right. All right, let's let's talk a little bit about um NCAA's.
  501. Both the men and the women are into the Final Fours. We'll see that this coming weekend. Um we saw an all-timer of a
  502. buzzer beater in the Yukon-Duke game, an all-timer. Um you know, we get those every few years. We get buzzer beaters
  503. all the time, but that was way up there. Um any what reactions to the Final Four,
  504. guys? I'm Here's one thing I'm meant to do. I'm meant to This dead gummit, we need to do this. We've talked in past
  505. years about the total seeds of the Final Four being kind of an interesting sufficient statistic on how chalky a
  506. tournament was. We've got a low total this time around. I think it's two ones, a two and a three, so it's not minimum,
  507. but it's low. And I'd like to know where that falls in the distribution since the
  508. beginning of the 64-team tournament. >> Wasn't it four ones last year? Last year
  509. was low. >> that distribution over time as well. >> with the last two. Like, what's the
  510. probability of two years in a row coming in as extreme as these two are? And we already know the thing has shifted, but
  511. this is like a real clear way to see the shift. >> Mhm. Um and historically, we talk about
  512. this with brackets, you know, you're too inclined to pick you know, you got you don't want too
  513. chalky a final four, you don't want a crazy final four, but they there's a nice distribution, and we've seen two
  514. years in a row of very tight low distribution. Well, I'm going to uh point out that I've already won one
  515. bracket, a small family pool, with Arizona. It doesn't matter, I mean, cuz I'm no matter what happens now, I win it.
  516. And the other one was a bigger one, not huge, with our with our undergraduates in our seminar.
  517. If Connecticut, I'm the only one who picked Connecticut to win, cuz I figured with a bigger pool, you got to have a
  518. little bit of of non-chalk at the end to have a chance. Um and that is I mean, I've made so many
  519. mistakes, so the only way I'll win this is if my non-chalky uh guess goes >> Keep on going.
  520. And uh so it's interesting um how you play those two things against each other depending on the size of the pool that
  521. you're in. Small pools, you want to go chalk. Bigger pools, you got to take gambles. Because I'm never going to beat
  522. them if Arizona wins, there are too many people who picked Arizona, too many people picked Michigan, uh the Dukes are
  523. all out, and they're just going to get decided on that little noisy path to the final four um that is almost almost
  524. completely unpredictable. Yeah, what's interesting, Audie, from the Yukon perspective is, let's be honest, right
  525. now, they're on the weaker side of that draw. By every metric, Michigan and Arizona are the two best teams left, and
  526. they're playing each other. So, you know, right now, if this is one of those interesting calculations. I haven't
  527. looked at the betting odds. You could make an easy argument Yukon should be favored to win the title here
  528. because they've got a higher probability to win this game despite the fact that they're going to be an underdog in the
  529. other game. They've got to be the favorite at this point. Well, what are the odds? We should get that. That's a
  530. good I don't think they're even favored over Illinois. Right? Just straight up. >> Yeah, they may not be. Illinois has been
  531. on a good run. >> the lowest odds because Illinois is considered better. Oh, well, then okay.
  532. Well, then they wouldn't be. Um but and they're both underdogs against each other. I mean, the So, Arizona and
  533. Michigan have substantially higher odds jointly than the other bracket, the Illinois-Yukon. Substantially higher.
  534. Almost three to one, I think. Uh in fact >> let's take it let's take a quick note
  535. just on on on tournaments and tournament design and distribution of talent. In the wi- on the women's side, we have a
  536. minimum number of seeds in the Final Four. We all four >> four teams as last year. Is it the same
  537. four? Okay, so it's South Carolina and Yukon on one side, Texas-UCLA on the other side. All of these teams were
  538. number one seeds. And I don't I didn't I don't remember the final score of all the Elite Eight games, but I know a
  539. couple of them were pushing 30-40 points margin. >> they were minimum might have been like
  540. 20. It's extraordinary. So, it's interesting, isn't it, that in the NIL era where we see so much leveling
  541. out in some other sports, the women's basketball, which has always had this right tail that seems separate from the
  542. rest of the distribution, doesn't seem any smaller than it used to be. In fact, it might be it might be even further
  543. skewed. Is that possible? Wouldn't the argument be that there's a, you know, thinner distribution of talent in the
  544. women's game, and therefore there's not enough talent to support, you know, eight, 10, 12, 15 great teams, while in
  545. the men's game there is, and that's why, you know, in some cases >> Yeah. So, so yeah,
  546. now now interact that with NIL. So, I agree that's always been the case. Now, interact that with NIL, what do you get?
  547. The NIL gives us the power to consolidate the men's sport to a ways that would the women get just by the
  548. uh um by by you know having the sport now. >> Interesting, right? So, that's interesting. So, you're saying the men's
  549. game starts looking more like >> of consolidate the power on the power and the the more diverse power that we
  550. have in the perhaps in the men's sport in general in a small a small number of teams just like the women's naturally
  551. does. Well, but okay, we don't we argued in the last week or two about we don't know whether that
  552. right tail the far right tail of the men's game is going to benefit. We know that the mid-majors have been sucked up
  553. into a deeper field of the majors, but we don't know if the right tail continues to suck from the deeper field.
  554. But, here's the but what I'm saying is I hadn't thought about this until this conversation. Is it possible because of
  555. the thinness of the talent in the women's game that NIL actually makes concentration
  556. worse? It was already concentrated, but it could be that if you interact NIL with a
  557. thin talent pool, you get an even more skewed right tail. It's it's entirely possible that we
  558. could be >> possible. Um wow, okay. Well, that that is taking place in Phoenix on Friday and Monday. I
  559. was a No, no, Friday Sunday. Friday Sunday the men's will play Saturday Monday as they usually do do,
  560. of course. All right, guys, why don't we wrap it there? We've uh covered a little
  561. bit of the spring sports. We've got next time around we're going to be heading into Masters week, I think. We've got
  562. Masters, one of the most um one of the premier spring sports, and we're warming into basketball and hockey playoffs. So,
  563. lots to cover coming up. Um I want to note I don't know how explicit we've been about this, but Audi has lined up
  564. guests over the last few weeks and it's been a heck of a run. Audi Wyner, major props for programming help. I don't know
  565. what I'm going to do with the next time around cuz I I I went go whole hog this time.
  566. Well, well, I'm looking forward to what you do. All right, for the whole team here,
  567. Audie Wyner, Shane Jensen, Eric Bradlow, big thanks to Deion Simpkins making this
  568. thing happen, to our whole team out there, our producer Marissa Renda, the big boss Dia Patel, D Patel. Thank you
  569. guys for listening. Come back and join us next time. Between now and then, enjoy your sports.

Brief Summary

Professor David Henkin discusses his book on baseball's cultural significance and the evolution of its statistics and fan engagement.

Key points

  • Introduction of Professor David Henkin. Cade Massey introduces Professor David Henkin, a long-time friend and author of a new baseball book.
  • Baseball's Heartbreak. A poignant quote captures the emotional connection fans have with baseball.
  • Baseball's Global Reach. Discussion on how baseball transcends borders and is popular worldwide.
  • The Evolution of Baseball Statistics. Moneyball isn't a new concept; it reflects a long-standing obsession with statistical accuracy.
  • Curt Flood's Impact on Free Agency. Curt Flood's legal battle paved the way for free agency in sports, despite his personal losses.
  • The Balance of Baseball. Baseball constantly adjusts rules to maintain the balance between hitters and pitchers.

Episode highlights

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes