Are Labubus Popular Because They Are "So Bad They're Good?"

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW Why do we sometimes love things we know are “bad”? In this episode of The Ripple Effect, Wharton Executive Education Vice Dean and Marketing Professor Patti Williams unpacks the psychology behind the consumption of something that is “so bad it’s good." From cult films like The Room to fads like the pet rock or today’s Pop Mart Labubu collectibles, Patti Williams explains why people often prefer the extremes—great or terrible—over the forgettable middle. She shares how hedonic motives, curiosity, and even storytelling value make bad jokes, awful auditions, and offbeat products more entertaining than their mediocre counterparts. This conversation also explores how companies tap into that sweet spot of irony and sincerity, fueling virality and cultural moments that stick.

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

#ConsumerBehavior #MarketingInsights #SoBadItsGood #ConsumerPsychology #ViralProducts #MarketingPsychology ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Patti Williams:And so I do think there are organizations that understand that there's this desire for badness, that if they
  2. pitch it the right way, they can tap into it and find consumer demand and consumer fandom and maybe a little bit of virality too.
  3. Dan Loney: But using the Labubu doll example, when you think about retail, isn't there kind of like a historical
  4. pattern? Like, you will see companies come up with these items that, seemingly, you would think have no real connection,
  5. but for some reason, there's a virality to them, and it just connects with a group of consumers. - Yeah, and I think
  6. what you're also suggesting is that sometimes so bad it's good phenomena become fads, right? That they suddenly burst onto
  7. the scene. Everybody has to have one. They become social cultural capital as well. They create a sense of community, or, you
  8. know, sort of shared storytelling. Those kinds of things definitely happen. But I do think sometimes, you know, fads aren't always so bad
  9. they're good, right? There are lots of fads that are just good, not necessarily bad. And so I do think there's a long running
  10. history of these kinds of -- maybe even going back to my childhood with the pet rock, right? Which may be so bad it was good
  11. in the same way. Loney: Welcome to the Ripple Effect, the podcast that takes you on a journey through the minds of Wharton
  12. faculty. I'm your host, Dan Loney, and in each episode, we'll be diving deep into the inspiration behind the
  13. groundbreaking research that Wharton professors have conducted, and exploring how their findings resonate with the
  14. world today. - Why is it that we tend to like things that may be perceived to be bad for us, or maybe things that the public at
  15. large don't like, whether it be a TV show or a song that just doesn't resonate with the public? Well, some research has
  16. taken a look as to why that is, that there aren't times when we like things that maybe aren't the best. Patti Williams is a
  17. Marketing Professor and Vice Dean here at the Wharton School, and part of the research into this, and she joins us here in
  18. studio. This has got to be one of those fun research topics to look at, because it's so interesting that I think we
  19. perceive everything to be, yeah, we want to know why things are the best. This is why maybe they're not the best. - Yeah, it's
  20. such a fun project. Thank you for having me here to talk about it, Dan. And I'm going to just give a shout out. This work was
  21. done actually with two Wharton doctoral students who've now gone on, and they are Professors of Marketing on their own at USC,
  22. at the University of Colorado. And this project really came about because we were discussing, why do people like
  23. things like Tommy Wiseau's The Room? People aren't supposed to like bad things. They know it's bad. It's not like they think
  24. it's good. Everybody knows it's bad, and yet they still like it. And so we started thinking about this and looking into the
  25. research, and what we found is there really wasn't any research that articulated or even discovered that people might
  26. like things that they themselves objectively find poor quality, let alone explaining why that might happen. So we set about
  27. trying to understand what might be driving this. - So when you say bad for us, what exactly do you mean? - Yeah, so we really mean
  28. things that you yourself know are bad. Not things that maybe you think are bad, but I think are good, and so of course, I
  29. like them. But within my own sort of range of preferences, I could choose to, I don't know, hear a really good joke, I could
  30. choose to hear a mediocre joke, or I could choose to hear what is a really bad womp-womp joke. And what we find pretty
  31. consistently, we find what I'm going to call a J-shaped pattern. In general, people prefer the best things over
  32. mediocre or bad things. But what we find also is that, in general, people prefer bad things over mediocre things. So I'd rather
  33. hear a bad joke than just an in between joke. But of course, I'd rather hear a good joke most of all. - So there are elements of
  34. this then that you connect to the retail sector and in things that we like or maybe we shouldn't like? - Oh yeah,
  35. absolutely. In fact, one of the biggest trends right now I think is an example of so bad it's good. I don't know, do
  36. you have a Labubu doll? - I do not. I do not, but I have heard about them, yes. - I don't have one either, but I keep seeing
  37. them. And now that the students are back on campus, I've noticed several hanging from backpacks as they're walking through
  38. campus. I think Labubu is so bad it's good, right? They're these sort of slightly ugly, mischievous, but charming
  39. little things. And why do we like them? I don't know, just because they're a little bit crazy and a little bit out
  40. there, and they're just kind of fun to explore their eccentricities and maybe a little bit of the collector
  41. culture that comes into it. - How do you think then this type of attitude by the consumer then potentially impacts the
  42. companies that are involved in either producing this product or producing the song or bringing forth an item
  43. that maybe is not perceived by everybody to be the best? - Yeah, it's such a good question.
  44. I do think there are some organizations that understand that this is happening. I'll give you an example. One of the
  45. studies that's reported in the paper, and we ran many, many more studies that aren't actually reported in the paper,
  46. was looking at people's enjoyment of auditions from "So You Think You Can Dance."
  47. And what we found is that people really love the best auditions, and then they love the worst auditions. And
  48. I think shows like that really know that that's the case. They show you some really good ones, and they show you a few really,
  49. really bad ones, where the person who's auditioning is really trying, there's an earnest sincerity about it, but
  50. they're just not really good. And they tend not to show us very many mediocre ones. And so I do think there are
  51. organizations that understand that there's this desire for badness, that if they pitch it the right way, they can tap into
  52. it and find consumer demand and consumer fandom and maybe a little bit of virality too. - But using the Labubu doll
  53. example, when you think about retail, isn't there kind of like a historical pattern? Like, you will see companies
  54. come up with these items that, seemingly, you would think have no real connection, but for some reason, there's a virality to
  55. them, and it just connects with a group of consumers? - Yeah, and I think what you're also suggesting is that sometimes so
  56. bad it's good phenomena become fads, right? That they suddenly burst onto the scene. Everybody has to have one. They become
  57. social cultural capital as well. They create a sense of community, or, you know, sort of shared storytelling. Those kinds
  58. of things definitely happen. But I do think sometimes, you know, fads aren't always so bad they're good, right? There are
  59. lots of fads that are just good, not necessarily bad. And so I do think there's a long running history of these kinds of -- maybe
  60. even going back to my childhood with the pet rock, right? Which may be so bad it was good in the same way. - You
  61. talk in the paper about the importance of quality in making these decisions, and why that's important. Explain that. - Yeah,
  62. we really mean a couple of things. One is that we're not looking, again, at things that you might think are bad, but which I
  63. think are good. We're looking at my own objective sense of quality. I really am choosing something that I think is not
  64. very good, but consuming that not very good thing is pleasurable in and of itself. The other thing we look at in
  65. the paper is, you know, when and why might people make these kinds of choices? We don't always choose the bad thing. We
  66. often choose the good thing instead, right? And we find that you're more likely to choose something that's so bad it's
  67. good when you're consuming for hedonic motives, rather than utilitarian motives. You don't want a bad vacuum, you want a
  68. good vacuum, but you're willing to watch a bad movie maybe over a mediocre movie, right? And so a more hedonic motive, a more
  69. entertainment motive lends itself to this kind of consumption. - Is it safe to say then that the decision to like
  70. it is very individual to that person? It may be very different, depending on who you're talking to? - Yes and no.
  71. So we definitely found some things that we could reliably get everybody, or most everybody in the study, to
  72. think they were so bad they were good. We could find "So You Think You Can Dance" auditions that everybody
  73. agreed were bad, but deeply entertaining. We could find jokes that everybody said, "Man, that's the worst dad joke
  74. I've ever seen, but it still made me laugh." But it's also the case that one of the things we discovered is that the things
  75. that you think are so bad they're good might look different than the things that I think are so bad they're good.
  76. And so there is a lot of heterogeneity in what counts as so bad it's good. There's also -- it's not here in the paper, but
  77. we also think that there's a lot of social capital. So subgroups might decide that this is an example of something that's so
  78. bad it's good, whereas another subgroup really doesn't agree with that at all. "I just think it's bad. I don't think there's
  79. any goodness to it, right?" And so it's a little bit of an individual difference and a little bit of a sort of socio
  80. cultural difference that sits there too. - So you mentioned this in the scope of the entertainment industry. Is there
  81. something that kind of connects us to this mindset within entertainment? Obviously, there are other areas, but it seems
  82. like entertainment would have maybe the greatest opportunity to see this play out. - Yeah, absolutely. And I would say
  83. that's true, both intentionally and inadvertently, right? I think some of these things, like Rebecca Black's "Friday" was
  84. intended to be good, and it turned out that people were like, "Wow, this is bad, but I love it, right?" So I think it
  85. goes back to the motives that people bring to so bad it's good consumption that seems to align with entertainment related
  86. consumption. People are in a hedonic mindset versus a utilitarian mindset. Now we actually did, and we looked at
  87. this with something like a documentary. People don't want to watch a bad documentary. They'd rather watch
  88. a mediocre documentary than a bad one. A bad one is just bad. It's not so bad it's good for the most part. So when I have a
  89. more utilitarian motive versus a hedonic motive, I'm just more interested in goodness than badness. When I'm more
  90. interested in just pleasure or just having fun, and importantly, we find when the consumption of it is pretty
  91. inconsequential. It's not going to ruin my life, it's not going to cost me a lot of money. There's not a lot of risk
  92. associated with it. So I think that's why you see it in the realm of entertainment. It's an hour on TV or 10 minutes on
  93. YouTube, or, you know, a couple of days of reading a book. It's costless in some way. - I was going to say it's probably a
  94. minute on like Instagram or X or one of those platforms, because it kind of goes back to the virality of it, with us having
  95. such a connection on social media to all of these different things and posts being up there all the time, that it almost
  96. sees -- I would think that there's an opportunity to even see this it's so bad it's good expand even further as we move forward
  97. here. - Yeah, I think that's right. It won't surprise me to see that a lot of so bad it's good things are really viral,
  98. and I think they're also really relevant to the moment. I've been reading a lot about meta modernism, and I don't know if
  99. you've ever read about meta modernism. It's sort of a response to post modernism and sort of the cynicism of post
  100. modernism, and it's really, really relevant to our students at the moment. I find them walking in with what I will call
  101. a meta modern sort of perspective. Meta modernism is really this oscillation between hope and
  102. irony and a recognition that things can bring both of these things. It comes with this deep desire for
  103. authenticity, but also a little bit of that post modern cynicism that the world really isn't all that we thought it might have
  104. been. And I think that a lot of these so bad it's good things kind of sit right in this space, right? There's the irony of, "This
  105. thing is, man, it's terrible," but there's some earnest sincerity in its creation. It's got its own charm. And so I
  106. think that the idea of so bad it's good has a lot of cultural resonance at the moment, and is likely to be
  107. associated with things that just catch fire in culture. - I saw that you mentioned, after being involved with the research, that
  108. there were a few questions kind of left to be answered. What areas? - Oh gosh, many good questions.
  109. And I should say, this paper, you know, ultimately got published with just a handful of the studies and the kinds of
  110. mechanisms we looked at. Here, we look mostly at like entertainment value. We also had some studies where we looked at curiosity,
  111. and we definitely find that sometimes people are more curious about bad things. What is it that makes it bad? In what
  112. way is it bad? And so maybe there's a curiosity mechanism that sits here. We think that maybe there's some storytelling
  113. value with things that are bad. You know, what am I going to tell you a story about this mediocre hamburger that I just
  114. ate? What if there's a great story to tell about the worst hamburger I ever ate in my life, right? And so there might be
  115. other drivers besides sort of hedonic motives, or, you know, sort of entertainment value that drive this kind of
  116. behavior. And then I think there's some interesting questions around the role of irony. What does irony play
  117. here? Am I consuming something like a Labubu for its ironic factor, right? And there is a little bit of
  118. research on ironic consumption. And so how does this differ from just consuming the irony of this thing a little bit? So many, many
  119. other things that I hope other people might pick up and investigate. - Patti, great to see you again. Thanks very much.
  120. - Such a pleasure. - Thank you. Patti Williams, Marketing Professor and Vice Dean here at the Wharton School. - Thank you
  121. for listening to the Ripple Effect. We hope you found this episode informative and engaging. Don't forget to
  122. subscribe and leave us a review so that we can continue to bring you the best insight from the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Patti Williams discusses consumer attraction to bad products and the cultural significance of the so bad it's good phenomenon.

Key points

  • The Appeal of Badness. Patti Williams explores why we enjoy things that are objectively bad.
  • So Bad It's Good Fads. The phenomenon of 'so bad it's good' becoming viral fads is discussed.
  • Meta Modernism Explained. Patti Williams connects the concept of 'so bad it's good' to meta modernism.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes