Wharton's Marshall Meyer: China and the WTO
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
Ten years after China joined the World Trade Organization (WTO), the country has become the world's largest exporter and accounts for some 10% of global trade. The International Monetary Fund predicts that by 2016, China will overtake the U.S. to become the world's largest economy. How did membership in the WTO help transform China? What will the next decade mean for China and its trading partners? To discuss these questions and others, Knowledge@Wharton spoke with Wharton management professor Marshall Meyer. 📂 Public Policy
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- [Music] [Music] Marshall, thank you so much for joining us today. My pleasure to be with you as
- always. Well, as you know, uh, November 2011 was the 10th anniversary of, uh, China joining the World Trade
- Organization or the WTO. So, why don't we start with a very simple question. What has joining the WTO meant for
- China? The short answer is everything. The changes in China have been quite dramatic. You can see the inflections in
- virtually every plot of the economy that you lay out. Um the obvious changes uh trade has gone up as a consequence of
- trade. GDP has gone up um as a consequence of uh the concentration of trade uh in the coastal cities of China,
- especially the special economic zones. The migration of uh peasant workers from countryside to city and back has
- increased enormously. Um one thing that uh another small inflection point interestingly is that
- the rural urban income gap um it didn't decrease but it stopped increasing rapidly about the time of WTO
- I assume as the result of wages remittances uh to the migrant workers. So overall this has had an enormous
- impact uh on China probably far greater than anybody anticipated. That that leads to the the next logical question
- is are there some sectors in China that benefited more uh than than others as a result of China joining the WTO? And
- were there actually other areas of the economy that may have suffered because of it? Yeah, there are actually some
- losers in this. There are some spectacular winners. The the big winner of course we know is manufacturing.
- Within manufacturing the big winner is electronics. China's biggest export is um electronic goods, computers and the
- like. Um uh not needle goods uh anymore. Uh these industries have burgeoned. Um much of the work of course is assembly
- work like Foxcon is doing for Apple and others. uh but uh but a lot of the work is uh manufacturer of of components and
- modules things like power transformers, electric cords, so on and so forth. So the manufacturing sector in general
- electronics in particular has benefited uh the next sector that's benefited actually is the automotive sector. Huge
- numbers of huge quantities of automotive components are coming out of China as a
- consequence of the development of this component infrastructure. Auto assembly has burgeoned in China. Some could argue
- that um the center of the auto industry has moved from Detroit to Shanghai. Um uh all of this I think is a
- consequence of uh WTO. Um, where have there been fewer benefits or even negative
- benefits? Uh, the answer quickly is the countryside of China. The migration has depleted the countryside um of many
- working age people. Uh, we talked a moment ago about the movie The Last Train Home. the couple the protagonists
- in the movie uh they leave their children with the grandparents behind in Sichuan province as they migrate uh to
- Shenzhen. I also think that Chinese agricultures in a bind as a consequence of WTO. Uh China's had a number of
- experiments with land reform. The first in 78 under Dang Xiaoping was pretty successful. Uh the household
- responsibility system they got productivity up. Uh, China's not had a great starvation since. They're very
- worried about that given the experience in the 60s. Today, however, they're still struggling with further land
- reform. uh there were some initiatives 2002 2008 to give the peasants control over their
- land but it's they've not really succeeded in assembling large enough pla plots of land to produce efficiently
- even given the low labor cost. So for example two crops in China are uh very much at risk. One of those crops I just
- read the article before I came down here is the cotton crop. They cannot find enough people to harvest the
- cotton. As a consequence, some of that cotton is going to stay unh harvested. They'll try mechanization, but
- mechanization doesn't work too well because the quality of the harvest is not nearly as good. Ultimately, they'll
- move to mechanization, but then who knows how price competitive uh the crop will be. Interestingly, the tomato crops
- in the same situation. This is a very delicate fruit. um and uh still uh grown on very small plots with hand harvesting
- and the the companies that are uh manufacturing the tomato paste which is the base ingredient in ketchup and other
- condiments uh aren't doing very well. In fact, they're losing money uh end of last year and this year again because of
- labor shortages and um raw material costs going on going up. And how how is China coping with these disruptions in
- the in the rural area? What solutions are they putting in place? It it's it's really interesting
- because um you have to go back and read uh what's called central document number
- one. The last four or five years until this year until 2011 central document number one focused on rural land reform
- and later rural subsidization market adjustment they call it. uh trying to take a lot of initiatives to subsidize
- agriculture with certain certain key crops and to incentivize people to stay on the land. Okay. Still however they've
- not gone quite as far as India as far as best I understand India where uh it's Indian government policy to keep the
- rural population which is the large majority of India it's only 50% in China now um to keep the rural population on
- the land by guaranteeing everybody for example what is it 100 hours of work a month and providing other subsidies to
- make rural life attractive. Uh China's not yet done that. Um the uh interestingly central document number
- one this year has a slightly different focus and it's a critical issue for China as well. It's called
- water. Uh they were very much worried about drought in Shandong province. The beginning of the year the rains finally
- came but it was it was pretty bad for a while. And you know, if you look at a map of China, it turns out the most
- agriculturally intensive areas are in that center area of China um uh above Jang Su province uh below Beijing, Hub
- so forth. Um and uh they they were going without water for a long long time. The
- Yellow River was running dry and water will be a perennial problem for China uh as well. And of course the water supply
- and the crops are closely related to each other. Now coming back to the earlier point about the the way the
- manufacturing uh sector especially electronic manufacturing is has been one of the winners. U how what has this
- meant membership in the WTO? What has it meant for the competitiveness of Chinese
- firms? How have they had to transform themselves into global producers? And what can other companies uh in other
- parts of the world learn from China's experience in this respect? Well, I I think we got to separate two parts of
- the Chinese uh economy. Um there's the foreigninvested assembly economy. Again, Foxcon, even think of
- Samsung has huge investment in China. By some measures, Samsung's the largest manufacturing firm in China.
- Um uh these firms have entered China um drawn on a lowcost uh labor labor supply
- uh and a labor supply that at least until recently has been uh very very reliable um and um uh you know pursued
- lowcost manufacturing for export. Um their competitive advantage again is cost. The margins are razor thin.
- and they're a bit at risk uh because the cost pressures are coming from two sides. We're still seeing some
- appreciation of the R&B, although if you read the recent columns in the in the business press, there's some questions
- as to whether the R&B will continue to appreciate near-term. Long-term, everyone's confident it will. So, they
- the pressure R&B appreciation plus wage increases. Okay, the wage increases are c are are are driven by
- supply and demand. So let's go back to the inflection point we talked about at the beginning. One of the interesting
- and I think very significant inflection points which we didn't understand until about a year ago was rural wages.
- Um this is called um u the uh the the Lewis turn the Lewis transition where um u uh where
- uh as a economy moves toward industrialization um uh wages labor supply shrinks first
- in the countryside then in the city and wages consequently increase. Well what did we see? We saw as early as 2003,
- this is only two years after WTO, wages in the deep interior provinces of China like Gansu begin to go up dramatically.
- uh agricultural wages uh on the rate of 10 15% a year sometimes more than that wages harvest season offseason the uh
- folks who acquired these data the at the Gansu Agricultural University looked at
- it every way came to the conclusion that this Lewis turn um occurred uh about in
- 2003 again only two years uh after WTO now the migrant laborers wages began in in the cities began and increasing
- dramatically 2005 2006 a couple of years later and so by 2007 wages were going up 20%.
- And in fact, the labor shortages provoked a a a new labor law in China. And the 2008 uh labor law, labor
- contract law, LCL, um gave workers on in principle, not in fact, but in principle, on paper, some
- of the same rights as tenure professors. Two, three-year contracts. After that, your employment was permanent, discharge
- only for cause, etc., etc. It's quite remarkable when you read this document. I'm not sure that it's honored more in
- fact in the breach, but uh it's a remarkable document to read. But that's a response to the labor shortages,
- right? So um 08 was an interruption in this a dramatic interruption because as you know WTO
- notwithstanding exports virtually stopped in some industries for lack of letters of
- credit. The government resuscitated the economy with a massive stimulus package.
- Don't need to go into details of it but it's again another turning point in China but some the the the man the
- assembly economy I talked about is being hit hard R&B appreciation their manufacturing for export and increases
- in labor costs and so parts of that economy are at risk. Yeah, I mean that that's actually a very good um segue to
- the the point I wanted to raise next which is uh clearly China has grown dramatically during the past decade
- during after its uh participation in the WTO. Yeah, it has uh it it its exports were you know 4% of the global economy
- or or so 10 years ago. Now China has become the world's biggest exporter. Uh how how sustainable do you think is this
- growth? Well, that that follows exactly. Um the export economy uh in my judgment
- um is unlikely to continue to grow at the same rate. And why is that? U again we talked about the cost squeeze on the
- exporters. Um uh and of course economic conditions in their principal markets whether it's the EU or the US are soft.
- That's a nice term. Uh so as a consequence um their ability to sell unlimited uh amounts of of relatively
- lowcost goods in these markets is going to be crimped somewhat. And there are lots of reports now of plants closing
- particularly in Guangong province and finally the numbers are beginning to show a slowing of exports.
- They didn't for a while leading to the inference that it was the Chinese domestic economy slowing
- down. I think it actually is a little bit or the rate of growth is slowing down. Um but um uh it's pretty clear now
- that this export model is not sustainable. Now that said um uh the Chinese economy has other places to grow
- and here's the irony. The place to grow is in the countryside of China. And so I think in fact I've
- observed firsthand and I'm writing about the development of rural distribution and the sudden profusion of rural
- markets in China. Finally at long last the traditional marketing system, the traditional distribution channels in
- rural China are giving way to much more modern systems. And as the large firms in China begin to
- penetrate the countryside, which for a long time they ignored, that'll give a little further headroom to China, but
- not nearly as much headroom as we've seen under in the last 10 years. So do you think that the growth of the
- domestic market will be uh fast enough and deep enough to offset the shrinking of the export demand as uh you know
- Europe and US uh you know slow down uh and and their consumption slows down? I don't know. And here's why. There's yet
- another competing force called population. Okay, China's aging. uh last year 2010 the dependency ratio non-working to
- working population reversed um it had been going down through 2010 and beginning last year it started going up
- um China has made some small modifications but hasn't fundamentally changed the one child policy even if
- they did it wouldn't make any difference for 15 20 years at least Um the best projections I see um suggest
- that China is going to have an upside down population pyramid very very quickly. And uh I sometimes describe it
- as as a pagota uh looking very much like like Japan today. uh uh the EU is not going to suffer this
- to the same extent the US provided we still have some immigration is not going to suffer it at all and what happens
- when the population ages there's a reluctance to spend money at least on consumer
- goods and uh we see this and actually in marketing surveys in China that uh many
- people though they have money are are reluctant to spend so the question is what steps can be taken to unleash the
- the buying power of of of domestic consumers. Now again, there's a group in the countryside, very large group, not
- the wealthiest in China, but not poor, um, who have untapped spending power and simply haven't had access to goods,
- which they'll now have. But how much more spending is going to take place in the urban populations uh, as they think
- about getting older, requiring social security, support if they can get it, medical services, etc. I don't know. I
- think that's the big question mark for China. So if you look to the next 10 years by
- uh 2021, what other inflection points do you see coming down the pike? That's an interesting question. Um
- uh the the there are a couple of inflection points. One's next year the government
- will change. We have no idea what the policies of Xiinping are going to be. We we simply
- don't know. He's been very careful. Will he be another who Hu Jun Tao? Will he be
- another Jew? Jurong J. Nobody knows. Um that's probably the most fundamental inflection point coming up
- soon. uh it will take a few years to know what direction China uh uh China takes. I think continuation of the
- present policies will alone or slow or cap economic growth a bit because um under Huenta
- um there's been a resurgence of the wealth and to some extent the power of the state enterprises uh in China um
- fewer are employed by the state the s so s so s so s so s so s so s so s so s so
- s so ses um uh are responsible for you know less and less of overall output in GDP but
- still their centrality in the economy uh has gone up and the question is whether
- there's going to be a second and vigorous wave of privatization in China turning toward a more capitalist system.
- We don't know the answer to this question and I think that's a very very fundamental question. Um a second
- inflection point will would will occur if under lower growth scenario different provinces go in
- different ways. Um you've maybe read about you've perhaps read about uh uh Bilai who is the party secretary of
- Chongqing. um uh he's advocating uh a very domestic centric uh set of policies. We should produce for the
- people's needs here in China. Okay. There's also a little bit of Mauism associated uh with Mr. Bo uh which
- people have seen in Time magazine and other places. Uh so his policies are very inward-looking. Take care of the
- people. If you go down to Guangdong um which has been the export engine of China um you'll see a different
- scenario. The government there I sat at an economic forum actually keynoted economic forum Guangdong uh in June the
- conversation was entirely about building and rebuilding our export industry. So the second turning point would be
- this kind of internal conversation if you will between uh a policy of focusing on the home market and f focusing on the
- needs of the people versus maintaining the export machine and um uh how that would play out politically I have no
- idea but clearly uh something like that uh is is coming along. Um third inflection point um
- innovation. China has a set of policies uh designed to promote innovation. Whether they'll have the effect, no one
- knows yet. Among other policies, um just like their targets for GDP growth, their
- targets for patents. The rate of patenting in China far exceeds patenting in the US. Um, and uh, although many
- many of the patents are so-called service patents of short duration, uh, many of them are not renewed because
- they're of no economic value. The number of patents of economic value is hard to
- determine, but in any case, there is a commitment to patenting and political advancement depends on GDP, but for some
- officials, it also depends on patenting and patenting. There's also a policy of indigenous
- innovation and it's been around for a while and the government asserts it and then you know last June or so said well
- we withdraw part of it but basically in government purchasing the policy is or was to favor locally developed products
- products developed not necessarily by Chinese-owned companies but by reg Chinese registered business entities
- they could be foreignowned And of course um many of the MNC's other western businesses have objected to this
- exactly where the policy stands a little unclear. Uh as always the rule in China
- is it's going to vary by province. So it it's hard to tell but that that that innovation inflection point if it works
- as anticipated could counteract some of the other forces I'm describing. Right. uh uh since we were talking a little
- earlier about uh you know the the export market and one there's also of course this financial aspect to it. Uh China
- has been trying so hard to globalize the R&B and I was wondering uh how you see that playing out over the next 10 years
- or so. The R&B that's an interesting question. Um uh f first I will confess even on camera
- that this is not my expertise. Uh having said that um I think they're in a bit of a bind and
- here's why. By globalizing the R&B you mean rendering the R&B convertible on the capital side, capital accounts and
- that would allow bond markets to open up so on and so forth. If you don't have convertability, it's very hard to get
- global investors in there to purchase bonds. Precisely. Okay, here's the rub. Look at M2 in China. The money supply,
- it's like a rocket. It's going up a lot faster than their GDP. You know, you're looking at numbers
- in the vicinity of 20% a year. And the question is, what's the source of it? And can
- they reverse this at the source? And um this and and the source ironically in my
- judgment lies um in their currency policy. Why is that? Uh when the Chinese government when I take to the Chinese
- government, the people's bank of China a dollar, I'm an investor. Okay, I need R&B. Okay, they give me the R&B,
- although in decreasing amounts. I think we're at about 6.4 right now, something like that. Um, they hold on to the
- dollar, they don't sell that dollar because they want to keep the country export
- competitive. So rather than selling the dollar, um, uh, they, uh, they they hold the
- dollar and the central bank reimbures the commercial bank where I exchange the money. um effectively not with fresh
- RMBB but rather with what are called sterilization bills long-term low interest notes.
- Okay? And the banks are required to hold them in their reserves. That's one of the reasons the reserves are so high.
- And um the consequence of this is that um uh on the one hand you've got all this currency around. On the other hand
- uh banks are finding it harder and harder to loan money because the reserve requirements go up. That's a that's a a
- check on inflation. If those bills do somehow circulate, I'm not confident that they don't circulate. That's a
- double negative. I really don't understand the intricacies of the system. I'm not sure anyone here does.
- Right. Uh but if they circulate, they create inflation because there's so much money around. Um if they don't
- circulate, they crimp they crimp loans, they crimp industry. And so China's in a
- bit of a bind because imagine imagine what would happen if suddenly the the R&B were fully
- convertible. Okay? What would happen is people are going to wake up and see what
- we've seen anyway but aren't fully taking into account and that is prices are very high in China. I have a slide
- I'm going to use tomorrow in class on food prices in China. Supermarket prices in China. Sure
- rice is cheap, cabbage is cheap compared to the US. Uh but if you look at the price of pork, not a lot different.
- actually milk not a lot different and Chinese incomes at least by the official statistics are a lot
- lower than ours. So there there are there there are a lot of um there'll be a lot of unanticipated consequences of
- freeing up the R&B and yet there's no alternative to it because basically the people of China are paying the price of
- uh an RMB that's uh uh pegged uh you know at a fairly low level uh at this point. So let let me ask with end with
- one final question. Hypothetically, let's assume that you were invited by the Chinese government to give them some
- advice on how they should navigate the next 10 years uh of uh participation in the WTO so as to maximize the benefit to
- the Chinese economy and the world economy. Uh what would you what advice could you give them? Oh, it would be
- unequivocal. I would they wouldn't listen to it, but it would be unequivocal. I mean that is like if if
- if you know the the people of China have as everyone has aspiration to become middle class right and um uh uh and yet
- some sense the uh the the the business model China's been using under WTO has run its course. Costs have gone up.
- Labor's labor is tight. Population's aging. Okay. What's the solution to the problem?
- Well, um, the solution doesn't lie in pouring more concrete, which is what they did in response to 2008. The fixed
- asset investment just blew through the ceiling. No, the solution lies in the quality of your people.
- And as a consequence to move up the value chain um you've got to upgrade the skills of your folks
- which means a huge investment in people. So I'd stimulate the demand side by trying to provide modest social
- safety nets where none now exist. It's very important so that the aging population, the aging consumer class
- willing to spend a little more, but at the same time, given that there's going to be a shortage of people, that you're
- going to be substituting sophisticated equipment for people. Um, you're going to have to upgrade the skills of people.
- Um, probably at all levels, including managerial. Um, so one recommendation is they send their most promising people
- here to Wharton. Okay. I know seriously so they learn the skills that are needed to run
- very complex very sophisticated enterprises u but more generally that they try to take some of the folks whose
- experience is in manual labor and train them to be sophisticated technicians so that China is able to continue to grow
- relying on higher value added industries and sheds the lower value added industries again like the needle trades
- clothing stuff like that. So that that that would be the recommendation. Marshall, thank you so much for joining
- us today. As always, it's a pleasure to be here. Thank you very much. [Music]
Brief Summary
China's WTO membership transformed its economy, boosting manufacturing but creating rural challenges and future uncertainties.
Key points
- Impact of WTO on China. Marshall explains how joining the WTO transformed China's economy dramatically.
- Winners and Losers in the Economy. Some sectors thrived post-WTO while others struggled, particularly in rural areas.
- Challenges in Agriculture. Labor shortages are threatening key crops like cotton and tomatoes in China.
- China's Export Growth. China has become the world's biggest exporter, but is this growth sustainable?
- China's Aging Population. The aging population poses significant challenges for future economic growth.
- Navigating China's Economic Future. Advice on how China can maximize benefits in the next decade of WTO participation.
Episode highlights
- Impact of WTO on ChinaMarshall explains how joining the WTO transformed China's economy dramatically.“The short answer is everything.”0:39Dec 15, 2011
- Winners and Losers in the EconomySome sectors thrived post-WTO while others struggled, particularly in rural areas.“There are some spectacular winners and some losers.”2:06Dec 15, 2011
- Challenges in AgricultureLabor shortages are threatening key crops like cotton and tomatoes in China.“The cotton crop is at risk because they cannot find enough people to harvest it.”4:47Dec 15, 2011
- China's Export GrowthChina has become the world's biggest exporter, but is this growth sustainable?“The export economy is unlikely to continue to grow at the same rate.”13:14Dec 15, 2011
- China's Aging PopulationThe aging population poses significant challenges for future economic growth.“China's aging population is a big question mark for its economy.”15:39Dec 15, 2011
- Navigating China's Economic FutureAdvice on how China can maximize benefits in the next decade of WTO participation.“I would they wouldn’t listen to it, but it would be unequivocal.”27:35Dec 15, 2011
Tension
45/ 100Some tension

