Wharton's Mauro Guillen: China and the WTO

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Ten years after China joined the World Trade Organization (WTO), the country has become the world's largest exporter and accounts for some 10% of global trade. The International Monetary Fund predicts that by 2016, China will overtake the U.S. to become the world's largest economy. How did membership in the WTO help transform China? What will the next decade mean for China and its trading partners? To discuss these questions and others, Knowledge@Wharton spoke with Wharton management professor Mauro Guillen.

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] moru thank you so much for joining us today thank you for inviting me so we're
  2. talking about the fact that China has just completed 10 years of WTO uh membership and in this decade that has
  3. gone by China has just become an export Powerhouse uh I think according to numbers I had its share of global
  4. exports was just about 4% 10 years ago and now it's not only the world's top exporter uh it has a global share of 10%
  5. uh how has this change come about and how has Chinese business been transformed as a result of this change
  6. well the reasons for this change are very uh straightforward which is that U as part of of WTO membership China uh
  7. got uh access um to uh the big Global markets including the US and Europe and and other countries in exchange of
  8. course for reducing its own trade protectionism in the Chinese market which hasn't always happened but it has
  9. happened to a very large extent so that's the main driver now the other important driver of course is that
  10. Chinese companies have become very competitive uh over the last 10 years they were already where in the 1990s uh
  11. but that they have entered new Industries they have uh uh you know invested in their uh Capital Equipment
  12. uh they have created new distribution channels uh we already see the first Chinese multinationals like uh Lenovo or
  13. like hire um making progress in in global markets in fact higher has become the the largest uh household appliances
  14. company in the world uh so that's the the re the uh you know the the reasons why um WTO membership has essentially
  15. made China the world's largest um exporting Nation as you just mentioned now the consequences are are massive
  16. both for you know the global economy as a whole and uh for the receiving markets
  17. meaning the US and Europe and uh and also for China let's go back to the point you
  18. just made very interesting about the emergence of Chinese multinationals it's absolutely right H higher uh and and the
  19. Lenovo and others have become Global players do you see a difference between the way these Chinese multinationals
  20. have emerged and say previous generations of Asian companies like say the Japanese companies like Sony and
  21. others or the Korean companies like Samsung has there been a difference in the strategy growth strategy and
  22. globalization strategy of the Chinese multinationals relative to the others and what can other aspiring Global
  23. multinationals from company countries like Brazil and India learn from China's experience that's a great question and
  24. of course it's a very complex question so there are some common patterns so the Japanese and the South Korean and now
  25. the Chinese companies had one very big Advantage going their way which was they had a protected domestic Market while
  26. they were still learning how to compete right so for many years Chinese firms have had a captive domestic market and
  27. uh they learned how to uh you know make things and uh they could sell and then of course they started to pursue foreign
  28. opportunities this was the case of hire hire uh grew first in the domestic market and then it started to pursue
  29. foreign markets first by uh selling uh their products to uh Walmart or to uh uh other American brands so they would make
  30. the washing machines for them and then they started to launch their own brand so that's the common pattern that also
  31. happened to the Japanese firms in the 50s and 60s the same with the Korean firms in the 70s and 80s I think the big
  32. difference with China of course is ownership many of these firms in China uh have at some point at least been
  33. state-owned uh that wasn't the case of the uh Japanese firms uh that was not the case of most of the Korean firms
  34. with the exception of maybe posco in steel right so so that I think is the biggest difference that is to say that
  35. in China what we see is a very important uh influence of a government owned state-owned Enterprises in you know the
  36. rise in this process of uh of internationalization of the Chinese companies that's the big difference and
  37. what imp lessons can say companies in Brazil or India which are aspiring multinational learn from China well I
  38. think also multinationals in the US and in Europe can learn I think one of the biggest lessons is of course the
  39. importance of scale that is to say higher Lenovo uh byd which is one of the largest uh makers of rechargeable
  40. batteries in the world and you know there's like five or 10 other very good examples of Chinese multinational firms
  41. that uh are making uh great inroads into the global economy by themselves right um the the big lesson I think is is a
  42. scale uh the other big lesson is uh uh learn the ropes don't try to accomplish everything at once so again first start
  43. in the domestic market then sell your products for somebody else to put their brand name on them right in Europe and
  44. the US that way you uh reach a scale that way you establish relationships and then once you're ready then you launch
  45. your own brand and then you try to conquer markets with your own uh resources and with your own reputation
  46. it's a hard thing to do obviously because you're facing uh stiff competition by established players from
  47. Japan from Europe from the United States but hey at least 20 or 30 multinational
  48. firms from China so far have made it you know 10 years from now uh there will be
  49. 100 or 150 what would you think will be the implications for the incumbents in those fields well they're going to have
  50. to wake up uh many of them of course will be acquired by Chinese firms um or they will have to sell some of their
  51. divisions to Chinese firms Lenovo of course became a big Global player after acquiring the PC business from I BM uh
  52. hire has also made some Acquisitions even though you know most of the action there has been um organic growth uh and
  53. so on so I think they need to wake up they need to realize that China is no longer just a lowcost manufacturing site
  54. China is a big economy big domestic Market uh but it's also the home base for many firms that are becoming
  55. increasingly more technologically sophisticated and uh they're also Lear learning how to Market how to sell their
  56. products uh so the world of uh um you know competition is changing very very quickly in large measure because of the
  57. Chinese firms the Indian firms the Mexican firms the Brazilian firms essentially getting out of their
  58. domestic markets so if you were to identify the most critical Industries in which uh companies are likely to be
  59. acquired by Chinese multinationals which would you consider to be the prime target uh I think the number one
  60. category will be commodified Industries um so anything that is a commodity right now the Chinese
  61. companies Brazilian firms also Indian firms will have an interest in buying why because uh they like scale and they
  62. know how to operate at larg scales and when margins are very low in a commodity industry uh whoever is bigger wins so
  63. this has happened in personal computers which is a commodity I this is starting to happen in many categories of
  64. electronics which have also become very commodified and and uh I think this is going to happen also in the lower
  65. segments of the automobile industry which are also very low margin very commodified um I think a little bit
  66. later we will start seeing u in high-tech Fields right um aircraft um biotech uh possibly even Pharmaceuticals
  67. we will see more activity not not necessarily only in the form of Acquisitions it could also be alliances
  68. but certainly there will be Chinese firms Indian firms Brazilian firms that would like to get into those Industries
  69. and they're going to be you know targeting uh I uh you know European or American firms either as partners or as
  70. acquisition uh possibilities now uh stepping back from the role of Enterprises now to the
  71. Chinese economy as a whole during the past decade that China has been in the WTO which areas do you think have seen
  72. the most growth and and and success and which areas have been relative losers within the Chinese economy yeah that's
  73. great question also so clearly the manufacturing and the Assembly of uh uh Goods has been a major engine of growth
  74. in China and Chinese companies and uh Chinese manufacturing facilities just more broadly regardless of ownership
  75. have become very sophisticated they know how to set up a plant how to run it efficiently um how to turn out very high
  76. quality products so that's a major area in which uh you know the Chinese economy
  77. I think has clearly uh succeeded I think they've also become very very good at building infrastructure and they're
  78. doing this obviously in China right but they're also doing this increasingly in Latin America in Africa and other places
  79. around the world so Chinese companies uh the Chinese economy I think has become very Adept at um uh building uh
  80. infrastructure now heavy industry of course steel uh cement all of the things that are required for building
  81. infrastructure or for building factories that's another um part of the Chinese economy that has made a lot of progress
  82. I think by far the two areas where Chinese firms are still lagging behind are consumer products meaning not so
  83. much manufacturing of the consumer products but rather how to uh sell them and also the services that go together
  84. with those products and then of course financial services so Financial Services commercial banks in China are still
  85. relatively backward and uh it is if if they don't address that problem I think it's going to be a bottleneck uh because
  86. I know of no Advanced economy in the world that has a backward Financial system you need a financial system that
  87. is also developed that is sophisticated uh if you want to be a rich country so let's stick to this point a little bit
  88. about uh some of the the financial challenges uh what do you see as the biggest risks uh especially of of a of a
  89. financial SE sector that's kind of lagging behind a little bit uh you know as as the Chinese economy seeks to grow
  90. uh and and it it's a matter of time before or it overtakes the us as as as the world's largest econ probably in the
  91. next six or S what the biggest risks you see Mar well the problem is there's twofold one is the uh um uh large
  92. amounts of bad loans that some parts of the banking system in China has accumulated over the last 30 years and
  93. again it's being a time of Boom in China but that doesn't mean that everybody has
  94. done well that doesn't mean that all of the people who borrowed money are now in
  95. a position to return all of that money so there's that problem and then the second problem is just more the
  96. nitty-gritty day-to-day operational details about how you run a bank a bank that takes deposits and then uh extends
  97. loans to families and to uh businesses right and does other types of uh commercial activity uh here what you see
  98. very clearly is that Chinese Banks just don't have the experience they don't have the sophistication uh they don't
  99. have the management systems the information systems the Marketing Systems the risk assessment systems in
  100. place in order to you know be uh profitable and be sustainable and uh they're uh working very hard to develop
  101. those systems right uh but it takes a takes a while uh you know China didn't have any banks really other than state
  102. owned Banks up until 20 years ago it takes a long time China's transformation is just so quick and I don't think the
  103. financial sector has been able to uh to um you know stay on top of all of the developments do you see any political
  104. risks uh over the next you know decade well in China as a whole of course I mean China is after all a country that
  105. faces many challenges uh it's right now an economy that keeps on growing but they face uh issues such as for example
  106. the uh pollution air pollution and water pollution uh they face problem with uh problems with
  107. desertification um they certainly face problems uh with their neighbors uh I think that's also part of iCal risk that
  108. is to say China unlike the United States or unlike the United Kingdom right this
  109. is China's huge disadvantage is surrounded by you know more than 15 countries and neither one of them has
  110. historically been a friend of China um um I have here in mind uh Korea Japan Russia India uh the Central Asian
  111. republics and then Vietnam Cambodia and so on and so forth neither one of these countries is a friend of China and also
  112. keep in mind that all of them have a territorial dispute with China all of them every one of them either you know a
  113. land border or they're fighting over some islands right uh so the issue is China is a uh you know resurging country
  114. certainly very powerful economically and financially uh but geopolitically right
  115. in terms of geopolitical risk it is in a neighborhood located in a neighborhood that is a very tough one it's a very
  116. complicated one so what does China's uh emergence mean for the rest of the global economy and the global governance
  117. system well it's huge and I think the best way to um assess that is by looking at the FI the uh numbers right Financial
  118. numbers so China right now as you know has a huge Surplus trading Surplus with rest of the world so in the year 2010
  119. they accumulated reserves uh for a total of about $450 billion doar that's more than1 billion do a day
  120. right uh Reserve accumulation now at the same time that means that some other countries in the world are running
  121. deficits right because if we don't have any trade let's say between planet Earth
  122. and Mars or Venus then if somebody's running a uh Surplus like China there's got to be somebody in the world who's
  123. running a deficit and that's the US that's some European countries and so on and so forth so this gives China
  124. Financial Cloud also gives it power because China uses those reserves of course to help the countries that have
  125. def you know make it through the year they buy US government securities now the Europeans are trying to persuade China
  126. to buy European government bonds and so on and so forth so this gives China cloud and of course the problem is that
  127. China 20 years ago 30 years ago didn't have this financial strength so they're underrepresented in all of the important
  128. uh institutions in the world the IMF right is one of them all of the development Banks um in the world uh
  129. China has a lot of resources they could have more voting power they have more voice but they don't yet have it so we
  130. do need to reform those International institutions now that China has become such big Power and you know all of the
  131. problems right now in the global economy catch us at a time at a time at which we
  132. haven't made that change so the governance structures are still those from 20 years ago right but the problems
  133. are entirely new and we have all of these economies China India Brazil Russia which didn't used to be very uh
  134. important from a financial point of view the world but now they are and we have no way of uh you know using them as a
  135. source of um funds and as a source of support to overcome the problems that we're facing right now in the global
  136. economy no that's a very great point so let let's take just one of those multilateral institutions which is the
  137. one we began with which is the WTO as we know during the past decade there have been any number of trade disputes that
  138. China has been involved with over issues like subsidies and so forth how is how do you expect this to play out over the
  139. next 10 years say within the WTO context well China has been um as you just said
  140. like other countries right the US and Europe are also taken uh to task right sometimes for subsidizing certain uh you
  141. know companies or certain products and uh protecting others and so on but China of course as the developing country that
  142. it still is has uh you know more of these um mechanisms of protection in place so naturally you know uh they they
  143. get more attention and then of course there's also the problem with the overvaluation of the currency but you
  144. see China has been pretty good actually at um when whenever they're taken to a court so to speak right they're accused
  145. of doing something uh at the WTO they've been pretty good at trying to address the problem and uh most of the time they
  146. have um accepted you know that they were in violation of some part of the agreement now remember again that uh
  147. China is a developing country and it is categorized that the WTO is a developing
  148. country country meaning that it's easier to actually accuse it of all of these uh
  149. you know transgressions one of the things that China was mentioning u a month ago when the Europeans were trying
  150. to uh get the Chinese to buy some government bonds was we'll buy the bonds but in exchange for that we want you to
  151. make us a developed market economy at the WTO and that means that it's going to be much harder to uh accuse China and
  152. to make it change its ways right so there's a lot of things you know at play here uh seemingly you know the Chinese
  153. obviously want to uh play a constructive role in the global economy they don't want to destroy the global economy
  154. because that would be devastating for them they want the global economy to grow uh they want Europe and the United
  155. States to be in a position such that they can buy all of these Chinese made Goods uh but at the same time they're
  156. asserting themselves and they want to um be more influential they want to be participants in the big decisions and in
  157. in the face of Chinese assertions do you see protectionism becoming a big risk going forward or not really no not at
  158. all I mean first of all in many Industries China doesn't need to protect because they're very competitive and I
  159. think as time passes I meant more the rest of the world becoming more the rest of the world certainly there could be
  160. Temptations keep in mind that China among developing countries and certainly among the bricks is not the most
  161. protectionist country so both Brazil and India are way more protectionist than China uh both in goods and in Services
  162. uh India if you remember there was this big uproar just a couple of weeks ago Walmart uh being able to operate there
  163. more freely than in the past uh so so China is not the biggest off is not the worst offender um but you're right uh
  164. not only in other emerging economies but also in Europe and the United States there could be Temptations now that
  165. would be a very very bad outcome very bad outcome that would you know in the short run protect some workers or some
  166. companies in Europe or the United States or in Brazil for that matter but you know 10 or 20 or 15 uh years down the
  167. road we would regret having protected those Industries because the only thing that you accomplish when you're
  168. protecting right just because somebody's not competitive right the only thing that you accomplish is you're buying
  169. time right and you are essentially making it possible for bad habits to perpetuate themselves right so the only
  170. reason that I see for protecting is what the Japanese did in the 50s or the 60s or what the Koreans did in the 7s and we
  171. were talking about that earlier that is to say you want to protect your companies until they're ready
  172. to become Global players that's a different issue you can still make mistakes and overprotect them right but
  173. that's a different issue you're not protecting just because you want to save them from collapse you're protecting
  174. because you want to help them be more competitive that's a different proposition just the last uh couple of
  175. points Maro uh you referred to the uh valuation of the Chinese currency it's a very important issue but one of the
  176. really interesting Trends going on is the efforts that China has been making to globalize the RM be uh do you believe
  177. that over the next 10 years that the Chinese Zan could become as influential a currency as the US dollar or the Euro
  178. what what's your no I don't think that's going to happen and I'll give you the reason so first of all let's say if the
  179. Chinese currency is over I'm Sorry undervalued by 10% that's the same as imposing a 10% tariff on imported goods
  180. or the same as uh giving a 10% subsidy to Chinese exporters so you accomplish exactly the effects are exactly the same
  181. and of the same magnitude right so this is highly distortive right I think the uh controversy right now is as to you
  182. know we know the uh remin b or the Yan is overvalued I'm sorry undervalued the problem is by how much right now China
  183. has been letting it gain in value over the last three or four years and that's a good sign right uh China at the same
  184. time of course uh we all know still controls the currency it's non-con convertiable that is to say you cannot
  185. go to the market and buy Remy be or Yuans and the reason for that is is very simple which is that the Chinese economy
  186. and especially the banking sector uh neither one of them are ready to have a convertible currency Chinese Banks would
  187. just you know collapse if the reming be uh you know were made convertible which means that you have to liberalize
  188. Capital flows and you have to to do a number of things so that's not something that's going to happen in the next five
  189. years I don't think or 10 years what China is doing is they are coming to swap uh agreements with uh certain
  190. countries around the world so that uh when export or when they import from those countries uh they don't have to
  191. use the dollar or the Euro as the uh as the currency so that they can make the the deal they go directly from reming
  192. bees to the local currency in those countries so this is happening in some countries in with some countries in Asia
  193. in ltin America and in Africa but it's still very small now they could expand those swap agreements uh but you see the
  194. Europeans or the Americans would never want to get into that so I think the time at which you know the REM me or the
  195. Yan is going to play as as such as a currence a big role in global financial affairs is at least I would say 10 15 20
  196. years away uh something very dramatic would need to change in the Chinese Financial system and banking sector for
  197. that to happen earlier I just don't think it's going to happen earlier great one final question Mar
  198. what advice would you give CEOs around the world about how they should navigate the future especially as it concerns
  199. China well I think uh you need to read uh as much as you can about China uh I think the uh Power transition such as
  200. the one that is going to be happening in the next few months in China are going to be very important we have to pay
  201. attention to that I think it is uh very important uh to see what happens with the uh you know 1 billion people in
  202. China who are still relatively poor because uh Economic Development and wealth has only reached the top 300
  203. million that's a huge accomplishment but it's uh you know only about 1/4th right
  204. of the entire country from the point of view of population and I think you've got to watch the uh environmental issue
  205. in China very uh very uh carefully and uh see how you know they they manage to play a bigger role in decision- making
  206. at Global institutions such as the lto the IMF uh all of the International Development Banks and all of that so I
  207. think uh the best piece of advice is keep an eye on what the Chinese are doing and also read not only the
  208. analysis that uh the um American journalist or Scholars or Consultants are producing about it also read what
  209. the Chinese themselves are writing many of the reports that the uh think tanks in China publish are translated into
  210. English I think it's also important to you know see the other perspective how the Chinese themselves uh are thinking
  211. about their own you know rise as a as a major economic power in the world Mar thank you so much it's a pleasure as
  212. always thank you for having me [Music]

Brief Summary

China's WTO membership transformed its economy, boosting exports and creating competitive multinationals like Lenovo and Haier.

Key points

  • China's WTO Membership Impact. China's entry into the WTO transformed it into the world's largest exporter, increasing its global share from 4% to 10%.
  • Emergence of Chinese Multinationals. Chinese companies like Lenovo and Haier have become global players, changing the landscape of international business.
  • Financial Sector Challenges. China's financial sector lags behind, facing risks from bad loans and operational inefficiencies.
  • Geopolitical Risks for China. China faces significant geopolitical risks due to territorial disputes with neighboring countries.
  • Protectionism as a Risk. Protectionism could emerge as a risk, but China is not the most protectionist country among developing nations.
  • The Future of the Chinese Currency. Experts discuss the potential of the Chinese Yuan becoming a global currency.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes