Why Retailers Are Trying to Escape Inventory Risk

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Retailers are taking a huge gamble every time they buy inventory. If consumers do not want the products, the retailer is left holding the loss.

John Zhang, Professor of Marketing at the Wharton School, explains why the traditional merchant model puts so much risk on retailers and why forecasting demand has become increasingly difficult. Zhang explores the store-in-store model, where manufacturers own the inventory while retailers focus on attracting customers and creating a strong shopping platform. He also explains how companies such as Amazon and Alibaba use similar approaches.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Well, we have certainly seen how the retail industry has had to change and adapt many
  2. of its dynamics in recent years. And this is playing out with businesses in that industry and how they're approaching a variety
  3. of things and how they can connect with the consumers so that they can continue to
  4. stay strong. According to our next guest, the problem may not necessarily be with the store, but how
  5. the company deals with the issue of risk. John Zhang is a marketing professor here at
  6. the Wharton School. He recently did research on this topic with his colleague, Tom Robertson, and he joins us
  7. now to discuss what they found out. Hi, John. Great to catch up with you again. How are you, sir?
  8. Good. Talk to you, Dan. Always great to have you with us. All right. So this involves a concept called the merchant
  9. model. Tell us exactly what that is in the scope of how retail has developed over the
  10. years. Well, merchant model is probably the most familiar model to us all. And essentially that if you are a big
  11. retailer and the first thing you want to do is to hire a professional buyer and the professional buyer would go out there and
  12. look into the marketplace, go to trade shows and go to the manufacturers and trying to
  13. pick the product they want to buy and then sell and then back home. And so in that particular model, essentially what
  14. you do is that you're going to pay a wholesale price and you can decide what quantity you want to order for a particular
  15. product. And once you have done that, you transport the product back to your retailer and then
  16. you charge a retail price. And if you can sell all the products at the retail price that you determine to
  17. be good for you, you're going to make money. And if it turned out that the consumer
  18. don't really want that particular product and you're not able to sell the product, but you
  19. already have taken the inventory, which means that you own the product, then of course, what
  20. you want to do is to run a lot of sales. And at the end of the season, you still cannot sell the product.
  21. You're going to have to swallow the cost or you're going to sell the product at a very low price to liquidators out there.
  22. And so the dynamics of the merchant model aren't necessarily right or working to a degree
  23. in what we're seeing play out now with the consumer and how they react and what they're looking for at the moment.
  24. The problem with the merchant model is that the retailers are taking most of the risk.
  25. Simply because you buy the product, you own the product, you're supposed to sell the product.
  26. If you cannot sell the product, of course, you're going to incur the loss. And you can imagine that for a retailer,
  27. for you to do well, you really should want to be able to forecast the demand really well.
  28. If the demand forecast is really well, you can sell all the product, everything is OK.
  29. And in today's business environment, with the e -commerce, with the omnichannel consumers and with all
  30. these young people who probably have very fickle preferences out there, you can imagine that task
  31. of forecasting the demand exactly is not an easy job for anybody. Right. And so you mentioned in the paper that
  32. as the decision processes are being made in terms of the types of products and how
  33. much, that maybe some of these decisions need to be made closer to the store level
  34. than rather up the corporate chain. You can imagine that in most cases that the buyers and the professional buyers, they would
  35. have to actually make that decision simply because there are so many different products you're going
  36. to have to buy. You can't really sort of go to the top level for management every time that you're
  37. buying something. And so given that, you can imagine that that decision making process may or may not
  38. be actually conducive to the forecasting the demand exactly. You can also imagine that some of the
  39. issues may actually come up simply because you can imagine as a professional buyer, you go
  40. to the manufacturer, the manufacturer treats you really well, they want you to buy more and
  41. pay a higher price. And in some cases, a bribery could happen and so on and so forth.
  42. So you can imagine that that whole process is pretty messy, it's not a clean process.
  43. So one of the things you suggest is a store in store model, which is what exactly?
  44. Well, store in store model essentially would help retailers to bypass owning the inventory.
  45. So essentially what you do is that you own the floor space, you invite the manufacturer
  46. to come in to sell their product and the manufacturer take on the responsibility of merchandising
  47. the product and charge the price, set the prices and do whatever is necessary to sell
  48. the product that manufacturer has produced. You can imagine that as a manufacturer, you
  49. produce the product, you must have done some marketing research. You probably know the product really well.
  50. You probably know your customers pretty well. And you would imagine that the decision making
  51. by the manufacturer in that case would be much better and for that particular product.
  52. So once you have done that as a retailer, what you want to do is to make sure that you build a good platform,
  53. you have a good delivery system, you also have a ability to generate as much traffic
  54. as possible. Are you curating and what manufacturer will come in to sell their product?
  55. If you do all that, you can imagine that as a retailer, you don't take as much risk.
  56. You don't own the inventory. The manufacturer owns the inventory. The worst that could happen is that you
  57. invite the wrong manufacturer to sell the product inside your store. And the point is that if they're not
  58. doing well, they will be gone. So you can actually invite some new manufacturers
  59. to come in. By the way, this is not a new model for the retailing. And if you look into the Asian countries
  60. for many, many, many years now and most of the retailers in Hong Kong, in China,
  61. in Japan, for instance. They are using this store in store model, which means that when you walk into a
  62. department store, you see that in fact that all the inventory inside the department store are
  63. not actually owned by the retailers, they are owned by the manufacturer who manufactured them.
  64. And they just rented the space inside the retailer and to sell their products. So how does this work when we're in
  65. a time right now where e-commerce is obviously playing such a bigger role in retail?
  66. By the way, e-commerce is using that particular model. If you look at the Amazon marketplace, in
  67. fact, that that's what they do. They invite a lot of vendors to come to their platform.
  68. Those vendors, in fact, own their own products. And Amazon just charges a certain percentage of
  69. the sales to let the vendors to use their platform. Of course, for Amazon, they are using a
  70. more hybrid model. And so part of the product, they actually own the inventory. Part of the product, they do the store
  71. in store. If you go to China, go to Alibaba, for instance, and they essentially use just about
  72. everything and based on the store in store model. What do you think this means then for
  73. retail moving forward? Going forward, if our retailers actually embrace this particular model, they will notice that in fact
  74. that they take on less risk and they're going to focus on the things they are good at, which is basically that to build
  75. the traffic for the store and to build a good delivery system and curating different manufacturers
  76. inside of the store. As a result of that, we're probably going to see less retail closing.
  77. And in fact, we're probably going to see less of the phenomenon of our so-called
  78. the will of our retailers, just recycle and come into the marketplace, eventually do badly and
  79. close the store and so on and so forth. What you would observe is really the will
  80. of manufacturing and especially manufacturers are going to essentially rotate through different retail outlets as their
  81. product becomes obsolete. John, great to talk to you today. Thanks very much for your time.
  82. So good to talk to you, Dan. Thank you, John Zhang, who is a professor of marketing here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

John Zhang discusses retail risk management and the store in store model for reducing inventory costs.

Key points

  • The Merchant Model's Risks. Retailers face significant risks with the traditional merchant model, often incurring losses from unsold inventory.
  • Introducing the Store in Store Model. A new approach where retailers invite manufacturers to sell their products, reducing risk for retailers.
  • E-commerce and Retail Evolution. E-commerce platforms like Amazon are adopting a hybrid model similar to the store in store concept.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes