Why Venture Capital Likes Modular Farming

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Modular farming, which is growing crops in self-contained, movable units so they can thrive in difficult climates, is becoming more than just a sustainability goal for social impact organizations. It is also becoming a big business that’s increasingly being backed by venture capitalists and private equity firms. New startups in this market are sometimes models for not only how to make profits while contributing to the social good, but also how such profits can lead to innovation that goes on to create additional social good.

In this podcast interview, Sherryl Kuhlman, managing director of Wharton Social Impact Initiative (WSII), interviews Joey Hundert, founder and CEO of Sustainitech, about these developments and where the whole movement is heading. 📂 ESG

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. hello I'm Cheryl Coleman I'm the managing director of the warden social impact initiative and I'm here in studio
  2. with Joey hundred who's the founder and CEO of sustained attack welcome Joey oh thank you tell us about
  3. sustained attack what is it okay sustained attack is a company that produces indoor agriculture facilities
  4. and spaces so we build modular indoor farms to produce crops in places where it's very hard to grow crops so think
  5. really harsh winters dry arid regions really hot places we build indoor farms typically inside of shipping containers
  6. that can be put anywhere to grow crops successfully where it can be hard to grow crops the clients and consumers of
  7. these crops yeah you got it so in Canada we grow lettuces and fresh herbs and the
  8. clients are the everyday consumer we're partnered with food companies whom we grow on behalf of we package up the
  9. produce ship it to them and they ship it to the consumer and then one of our customers is actually an ethnic group in
  10. Manhattan who requires produce a specific way and so we grow the produce and ship it to them and they ship it to
  11. people who eat it so what are the latest trends in indoor container farming I mean is it I know there's been a lot of
  12. discussion about how to make it work different approaches etc what are you seeing so what I'm seeing is trends in
  13. indoor farming writ large is it's attracted a lot of capital to the space because the idea is so interesting it's
  14. true the idea is unfortunately sexy and the reason I say that is I think it's it's whipped up a bit of a frenzy of
  15. interest in international media and in the capital markets and it's chased a lot of money into the space now you
  16. might say well that sounds great and I am happy about that I'm not I'm not worried that's not the part I don't like
  17. it's I think that there's unrealistic expectations of the companies in the space I think some of the money's coming
  18. in from Silicon Valley where there's a there's a belief that industries can be cornered and that a winner-take-all
  19. approach can be had but when you when it comes to fresh food in agriculture it is
  20. a hopelessly fractionated and diverse space for a reason and so I think some of the trends that I
  21. that I'm can turned about with the arrival of so much money his companies are trying to scale
  22. into the hundreds of millions so that they can drive out the others pretty much and which looks silly but beyond
  23. that I see core flaws in their technology in their whole approach and I just worry what happens when you hit
  24. Carbon Copy 300 million times on something and I worry about what the failure of some of these larger startups
  25. is going to mean for the rest of the market and so we've been building our company in it while keeping in mind that
  26. this is happening in the market and we've been offered like most other of our competitors a lot of cash we've been
  27. very conservative about what we will receive and what we will do with it trying to build a more durable company
  28. that's going to last until the market economics are proven and that's the real critique yeah and I know that even here
  29. in Philadelphia there's a lot of interest in urban farming right just sort of adjust the food deserts and I
  30. think also then the fresh and healthy food right it's how nice to get it from your neighborhood contain your farm
  31. rather than shipped from California indeed local food is probably what drove the initial interest in indoor farming
  32. however the further you get into farming especially in the most developed nations
  33. in the world if you look past the first 1/3 a few hands into the food system you
  34. find a massive industrial scale mechanized complex of farms and processors whose unit economics are
  35. amazingly low you know we're talking pennies per pound when you know if you take a new york city a manhattan based
  36. urban farm they need five to ten dollars per pound just to turn the lights on and
  37. so I'm worried that those farms that need ten times the amount per unit are going to have trouble and and I think
  38. that the industry has chased a few ideas firstly the vertical approach from Japan
  39. we've built vertical farms I've built non vertical farms the non vertical farms are much more capital efficient
  40. than the vertical ones if we were building in Hong Kong I would totally go vertical but the places in the world
  41. where you need to go vertical are not many and then the other piece is everybody chased lettuce because lettuce
  42. and leafy greens grow so fast but it's also created a flood of product and still competing with the produce
  43. from the field and from the greenhouses is incredibly hard so I think those two things vertical growth and chasing
  44. greens have steered indoor agriculture companies after some unattainable goals well and you know you're talking about
  45. them the financing we're on this you know yeah venture capital chasing this pushing it how else can an entrepreneur
  46. get the funding to make these these ideas happen you got it for farming and for other kinds of initiatives yeah so
  47. you know Silicon Valley has created the the well paved smooth running highway of
  48. capital available to technology-based ventures in globally but certainly in North America and that is nothing to
  49. complain about it's made it much more affordable for ventures like mine to go after capital the agreements are
  50. standardized the investment tools are standardized the lawyers know what they're doing and there's many many
  51. investment shops and that is super cool so I think that we've benefitted from that will continue to benefit from it
  52. and I'm glad it's there I'll but I also built my company differently before heading for equity financing you know
  53. indoor farming is a very high capital cost industry if I was to have sold equity from day one I would have three
  54. percentage points in the company left I would have been diluted right out of it and so we found other ways of financing
  55. the company one was we would we the first thing we did was sell an entire indoor farm on contract so we found a
  56. buyer of a very specific kind of indoor farm and we sold that farm and that injected cash into the company and led
  57. us the first two two and a half years of the company were built on just that contract and it said let me get into the
  58. game and really see what was going on then we scored a contract to ship produce to a company and it you can
  59. finance contracts if you know what your cost of production is if you know you can make money at it it may be hard to
  60. go find a buyer of this produce but is it any less hard than going and chasing capital when you have no value I found
  61. it easier to go find a customer for the produce that was willing to pay a really
  62. high price for the quality and we grew off for three years on that and so we didn't even open up our cap table
  63. until year five and then we started raising equity capital with evaluation I could stomach and I and I want
  64. entrepreneurs out there to know there's other types of capital out there sometimes countries will fund technology
  65. companies to make sales in other countries sometimes they do that because they want the export revenue countries
  66. love export revenue it's awesome for GDP and a lot of countries in the advanced world have a terrible imbalance in
  67. imports and exports and so there are funds available to assist in export of technology and crops and you know I
  68. think for me what I would have done differently and what I encourage entrepreneurs to do I would have gone to
  69. the major major trade shows sooner to find out how specialized a lot of these buyers are and that you can get forward
  70. contracts on a lot of this stuff there's it's a different way of going about it but I would rather build value and
  71. ultimately build more equity before approaching VC especially in a high capital you know high capital
  72. expenditure business yeah that's such an interesting approach because I think a lot of the student entrepreneurs were
  73. seeing and then even the ones we're reading about they're going after the venture capital right away they're
  74. meeting like they're sort of thinking that that's the you know it's it's a long shot but if you get that quick hit
  75. you're set right you know one of our competitors raised a hundred and twenty eight million dollars a month and a half
  76. ago in a series B there was a competitor last year that raised 200 million in a series d man does that change life you
  77. know what what life was like before that round and after that kind of around that
  78. is a way different existence and again if the unit economics were there great but I think an entrepreneur has to ask
  79. themselves what are they in it for did they do it for that to become instantly corporate a board filled with very
  80. serious people and specific goals and KPIs that if you don't hit you don't have that much time to mess around when
  81. there's a couple hundred million at play whereas you know a twenty to sixty million in play I think there's more
  82. flexibility to go after more profitable ends and niches in the market it's a global market agriculture fresh produce
  83. is massive and you can even process the produce making in the central oil or a tea or a dried herb or a nutraceutical
  84. it opens up global markets so the further I've gone the more happy I am with the choice not to play in the
  85. commodities of these farms well and I think you've been come visiting us as the Nazarian innovator-in-residence this
  86. year it's official but you've been with us for seven times yes yes so we've seen
  87. your development along the way and the one thing I know about you is you are at your core somebody who likes to make
  88. improvements right so the last thing I could see why you would say I'd rather have the freedom to continue to change
  89. explore and develop rather than get the money that forces me to scale in a ways that I'm not I'm not comfortable exactly
  90. right if I if I had an opportunity a year ago to take on lots of capital and scale
  91. massively if I had scaled with those ideas I'm sure we could have pulled out the win of some kind
  92. what we broke through to technically in the last nine months even the last six months it is amazing what we've done and
  93. I'm some thank gosh I can head after those opportunities now we're already writing contracts on them the margins
  94. eclipsed that which we were doing before it also embeds more of a purpose piece and what we were doing it's it's
  95. continued to change the nature of the company and we're in the millions it's not like they're small opportunities
  96. it's that if I like some of my competitors had to just scale what I was doing a year ago I wouldn't be anywhere
  97. near as confident as I am today that the profitability is really there and that gives you a great deal of flexibility in
  98. thinking about what you're gonna do next who you're gonna approach and and how you're going to structure your next you
  99. next rounds absolutely right and it changes the type of investors that we're approaching and making sure that we're
  100. you know as exciting to those investors as we've ever been but if anything our investors are
  101. feeding back that they get confident with the more clarity that we're seeing the global market with it so what kinds
  102. of trends are you seeing in investors I mean you've I know you've funded your first initiative the sustainable
  103. carnival through more traditional nonprofit grants and kind of sponsorships right and so how are you
  104. seeing that transition going is there more blended capital more venture capital yeah so I would say that
  105. Capital is incredibly mature at this point it's also a great time to be raising money a lot of these funds are
  106. flush sure there's there's a concern out there about a coming recession however there's funds that have just
  107. closed their rounds they have three and four and five years of dry powder to spend so I'm seeing lots of capital I'm
  108. seeing new private equity shops pop up every day that I didn't know about a lot of them are getting even more
  109. purpose-built for food for robotics for tech for pharmaceuticals like they're there or even the venture arms of big
  110. corporates there they're going at a purpose and there they've got these sidecar funds of 50 100 million dollars
  111. to go at a purpose the the the ecosystem is so differentiated and flush and but beyond that I think that some investors
  112. are wary of the companies that say we're gonna lose money for 15 years and you're
  113. gonna need to pour in 10 billion dollars but then boy are we gonna boil the ocean
  114. I even seeing some skepticism about that now there's no question that some of these unicorns have blit scaled to the
  115. 50 billion dollar mark and everybody looks at uber and looks at Airbnb and looks at Amazon and says see you can do
  116. it right but what about the 30,000 ventures that didn't get anywhere close to that and and what's wrong with a 10x
  117. or a 30x why does it have to be a 700 X I'm seeing some skepticism in the capital markets about companies that say
  118. what we're tackling is so huge and fundamental for society some day we're gonna make money and just bet on us and
  119. keep betting on us I'm seeing the preference for some investors to see some business savviness along the way
  120. can you cash flow the venture is it profitable when are you going to reach profitability can you do it a bit sooner
  121. can you access traditional bank financing these are questions that are being asked to us and something that
  122. I've been seriously considering because for a high capital cost business if I can get bank financing that's the
  123. cheapest non-dilutive capital that I could ever hope for so I've been working with banks to start to line that up
  124. because every dollar I borrow for our systems is a dollar I didn't have to raise your equity capital so I think
  125. that the high of we'll make money someday is actually behind us and I'm seeing more value consciousness amongst
  126. certain VC shops institutional VC shops well I'd like the point you made about purpose oh yeah and more entrepreneurs
  127. and investments going towards that we have a radio show on Sirius XM dollars and change and we've been doing it for
  128. about five years and one of the things that we continue to see and our hypothesis is that the more funding that
  129. can go towards these purpose companies the more likely entrepreneurs are to think about that as an opportunity you
  130. know it proves that the concept that you can have a business that has a purpose you know makes it positive social impact
  131. and can still make money and as you show that that's possible I think that inspires more the entrepreneurs to think
  132. about how to make that happen it's more fun to solve problems oh yeah it is I think it's in the heart of people and
  133. when I come to Wharton I always like to take the pulse on what I'm hearing around here what's clear is the concept
  134. of impact investing itself has matured here people are looking at Wharton and looking at W SII they're coming here for
  135. that I've talked with a couple dozen students that came here because of W SII and I love hearing that it's amazing you
  136. know I didn't use to hear that and they came here to learn about impact investing I've even heard students say
  137. I'm going into X big firm big banking big consulting firm and I want to take these methodologies with me I want to
  138. promulgate these ideas instead of large global firms and that's exciting and you
  139. know Wharton's one of those schools where that can actually come from and and students can carry it into those
  140. industries I also yes I'm hearing a lot of the desire to blend purpose into venture more and more and but more
  141. sophisticated than I did in the past it's more concrete and they in our company yes we've had purpose on our
  142. minds the entire time and there's that terrible tension between making the company work and float and staying at
  143. the purpose and one needs the other and sometimes you prioritize one of the other and I admit much of the last six
  144. years was just making this thing technically work so that I could again point back more directly at purpose when
  145. we could afford it but most importantly when the purpose made money to focus at and to me that's the most virtuous blend
  146. if you can get the purpose to make money and actually be inspiring from a profitability standpoint that's Maximus
  147. right that's that's the best collision and so when one isn't taking away from the other I admit that is very hard
  148. and we've done things just for profitability while I've had some purpose on my mind and this year we've
  149. begun to redevelop those programs and they're global in nature they're big it's a big lift
  150. but we've restarted those programs that have purpose and profitability baked right into them it's great to hear so
  151. what kind of closing advice would you give to an entrepreneur in this exciting you know innovative flush time for them
  152. to think about how to be most successful yeah I would actually report on something I've seen here at Wharton
  153. which I'm inspired by I've been coming for eight years and I would say this year I'm hearing the most likely
  154. candidates for success in venture than I've heard in years past specifically because somewhere somehow feedback came
  155. back to the cohort of students here get more specific niche out pick a niche and
  156. pick a product that is specifically built for something I used to come in here it's the uber for this
  157. it's the Airbnb for that and while there was lots of passion and energy that would concern me because they you cannot
  158. boil the ocean and make your way this year I'm hearing about b2b plays on the most obscure things switches in and and
  159. SAS services for categories I didn't even know existed how students are finding this within weeks and months it
  160. tells me something's train them to look at the problem more carefully and to look deeper into the market to find real
  161. problems instead of reading Fast Company being like I want to be like that I'm heartened to see this shift towards more
  162. specific niche high-growth opportunities and that's my advice back to entrepreneurs that might listen to this
  163. pick Anish pick it carefully you're not expected to know right away go deeper into the field deeper into the market
  164. meet players at trade shows stay curious ask tons of questions eventually those apertures of real pure opportunity are
  165. going to open up and they may had not have been visible to you in the beginning they may even be totally
  166. uninteresting to the general population but they could be super profitable and easier to build a moat around and easier
  167. to capitalize and I like that movement I like the movement towards specificity niche based high profit opportunities
  168. instead of trying to boil the ocean well thank you so much joy it's been a pleasure having you here
  169. thank you guys for more insight from knowledge at Wharton please visit knowledge Wharton you pengie d you
  170. [Music] you you

Brief Summary

Joey Hundred discusses indoor agriculture, funding strategies, and market trends with Cheryl Coleman, emphasizing niche opportunities and sustainable growth.

Key points

  • Sustained Attack's Mission. Joey explains how his company builds modular indoor farms to grow crops in challenging environments.
  • Trends in Indoor Farming. Joey discusses the influx of capital into indoor farming and the unrealistic expectations that come with it.
  • Alternative Funding Strategies. Joey shares how he financed his company without relying solely on venture capital.
  • Advice for Entrepreneurs. Joey encourages entrepreneurs to focus on niche markets for better success.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes