Borrowing from the Future: 401(k) Loans

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

In a new paper titled, "Borrowing from the Future: 401(k) Plan Loans and Loan Defaults," Olivia S. Mitchell, Wharton professor of business economics and public policy, analyzes the loans people take from their 401(k) pension plans, why they take these loans and what happens when these borrowers leave their jobs. The paper was co-authored by Timothy (Jun) Lu from Peking University, HSBC Business School, and Stephen P. Utkus and Jean A. Young, both from Vanguard Center for Retirement Research.

Knowledge@Wharton asked Mitchell to summarize her research and talk about its implications for business practitioners, consumers and regulators.

Read the full story: http://knlg.net/1mZbcad 📂 Finance & Accounting 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. my research in this area has been focusing on loans that people take from their 401K pension
  2. plans uh it's quite common for employers to allow loans from the pensions and in
  3. fact we find that at any given time about oneth of all workers have taken a loan over a 5-year period as many as 40%
  4. take loans so it is a common practice we've investigated why people take loans what happens when they do and in
  5. particular what happens when they terminate their jobs at that point they have to pay back their loans in full or
  6. incur a big tax penalty plus a 10% penalty so we're concerned about whether people are you using their 401ks as
  7. piggy banks what we found was that that planed loans are very widespread many people
  8. take multiple loans that the loans are usually repaid except in the event of people terminating their jobs so we
  9. conclude from this that 401K plans obviously are intended to support retirement saving but they're also used
  10. as a form of support for pre-retirement consumption the key takeaways of the research have
  11. to do with the way 401K plans are designed and how plan sponsors construct them so it's very common for plans to
  12. allow loans in fact I didn't even know that our own company allows plan loans before I started the research um
  13. employers need not permit the loans but if they do they have to think carefully about constructing the environment in
  14. which people do take the loans for example um what's the interest rate people have to pay back to themselves
  15. the loans plus interest what is the potential for taking out multiple loans what we found was that if people are
  16. permitted to take multiple loans they are more likely to borrow and they borrow double the amount
  17. all those decisions are up to plan sponsors who need to think carefully how they structure the 401K environment for
  18. their employees when I started on this research I had no idea that 401k loans were so
  19. widespread um what didn't surprise me was that people most likely to borrow from their retirement accounts are young
  20. people low paid people people who are likely to be liquidity constrained uh what didn't what did
  21. surprise me was that so many people default on their loans at the point of job termination and it's expensive to
  22. default you have to pay income tax plus the tax penalty I think most people don't realize how big uh a burden that
  23. can be so we need to get the word out in terms of the cost of defaulting on the loans
  24. some in policy circles have suggested that loans should be completely outlawed that is that workers should be
  25. encouraged to save in their 401K plans but they should be prohibited from borrowing at all I think that's the
  26. wrong message because employers understand if they're going to encourage the workers to contribute to their plans
  27. and the workers are low paid they need to have the confidence and the flexibility to be able to borrow if they
  28. get into a pinch I think the right message is that loans can be structured judiciously and
  29. thoughtfully um and that the way they're structured makes a big difference to employee
  30. Behavior as a result of my research several conclusions follow uh plan sponsors need to think carefully about
  31. how they're allowing access to the plans for example instead of allowing multiple
  32. loans which seems to be taken by the employees as an opportunity to borrow maybe allow one loan at a time and maybe
  33. potentially cap the amount that can be borrowed at a time um so that people have the access in the event of hardship
  34. and and need but they're not necessarily seeing it as a revolving credit card there's been a lot of attention
  35. especially since the financial crisis about Americans need to save more their need to set aside more for retirement
  36. and I think my research falls directly into this uh interest area there has been substantial policy attention to
  37. encouraging saving through 401ks tax qualified accounts there's been a lot of attention to automatic
  38. enrollment and automatic escalation where people boost their saving rates over time there's been very little
  39. attention to what we call the decumulation phase that is how people manage the money on the way out of their
  40. pensions loans are part of it and also payouts at retirement so that's I think the real crying need for additional
  41. analysis there have been a number of research studies recently arguing that people are
  42. taking loans willy-nilly without paying attention to the consequences and I do believe that people need to be educated
  43. much more about the fact that they pay themselves back which is good but they also forgo the opportunity to earn
  44. investment earnings on the money that they had borrowed along the way also people are not particularly aware of the
  45. financial consequences of taking that alone particularly if they become unemployed so both of those topics need
  46. a lot more attention in the workplace as well as in policy circles we've been very fortunate over
  47. the last many years to have a research collaborator with the Vanguard group which is a senior partner here at the
  48. Wharton School Steve utkus who's A Wharton grad by the way is the head of the Retirement Research Center at
  49. Vanguard and he and I have been working on 401K plans and investment behavior for several years This research was made
  50. possible only because of the collaboration with Vanguard which gave us access under restricted conditions to
  51. the 401K plans that they administer retirement savings is a passion of mine and retirement Security in particular We
  52. are continuing to do research with Vanguard on the 401K plan Marketplace looking at for example um what happens
  53. when companies introduce Target date plans as investment options how do people change their portfolios what
  54. impact will this have on their future returns and risks [Music]

Brief Summary

The episode covers the implications of 401K loans and the need for better structuring and education around them.

Key points

  • The Widespread Use of 401K Loans. Research shows that many employees take loans from their 401K plans, often without realizing the consequences.
  • The Cost of Defaulting on Loans. Defaulting on 401K loans can lead to significant financial penalties, yet many are unaware.
  • Rethinking 401K Loan Policies. Experts suggest that loan policies should be structured to prevent misuse while providing necessary support.

Related episodes