Daniel Pink & Adam Grant Interview on Why ‘To Sell is Human’: Using Sales Skills in Everyday Life

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

KNOWLEDGE@WHARTON ARCHIVES: Whether you are an educator, an art director or a project manager, you are in sales. So argues bestselling author Daniel Pink in his new book, To Sell Is Human: The Surprising Truth about Moving Others. Pink recently visited the University of Pennsylvania as a guest lecturer in the Authors@Wharton series. Wharton management professor Adam Grant interviewed Pink while he was there to learn more about the ideas in his book, including why consumers mistrust salespeople, what the new ABCs of selling are and why questions may be the greatest selling tool.

More on this interview: https://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article/daniel-pink-on-why-to-sell-is-human/ 📂 Marketing

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] dan welcome we're excited to have you here and talk about your new book to
  2. sell is human many many fascinating ideas in it could you start off by talking to us a little bit about why are
  3. we all in sales yeah well there are a couple animating ideas in the book Adam one of them is is that like it or not
  4. we're all in sales if you look at the labor data one in nine people in the economy today one of our workers makes a
  5. living selling stuff they're car dealers real estate agents but I had an instinct
  6. about those other eight and nine and when Adam did some survey research and found that those other eight and nine
  7. these are people who are not nominally in sales they are managers they are project team leaders they are teachers
  8. and art directors that they're spending an enormous amount of their time in what
  9. I call non sales selling their there they're selling their convincing you to make an exchange give me something you
  10. have in exchange for something that I have but it's denominated not in dollars it's nominated in time it's denominated
  11. in attention it's dominated in an effort and so I think if you look at how white-collar workers are spending their
  12. time whether they're in traditional sales or some other kind of function a lot of their time and effort is spent
  13. convincing persuading controlling influencing people and the truth is is that when you tell everybody you do tell
  14. people you're in sales a lot of people don't like it very much at all I don't want to be in sales no no one does I
  15. mean why am I in it well well well the reason well I think what's interesting is that why people
  16. don't want to be in there because they have this association that sales is sleazy slimy smarmy lowbrow low-rent
  17. it's about hoodwink are--and sleazebag are-- and all those kind of other great words that we use to describe it you
  18. know something is awesome when there's so many different synonyms to describe how duplicitous it is and my view is
  19. that that's a very outdated form of sales in all its dimensions so that is a view the view that sales this slimy
  20. smarmy sleazy duplicitous is a view to me about the conditions in which sales have taken place for a long time rather
  21. than the nature of sales itself and what I mean by that is that most of what we know about sales sales car sales real
  22. estate sales whatever I come from a world of information asymmetry where the seller always had for more information
  23. than the buyer when the seller has more information on the buyer the seller can rip you off period it
  24. is why we have the whole principle of caveat emptor buyer beware but now more and more and not everywhere but in a lot
  25. of markets that information asymmetry is becoming more like information parody and you see this in a you see this in
  26. sales sales business the consumer sales where people walk into a car dealer armed with information that in some
  27. cases not even the car dealer him or herself had twenty years ago you also see it in b2b sales where you talked to
  28. basically anybody in b2b sales and what they're telling what they'll tell you is
  29. that they are the customer the prospect is engaging in the sales process far far
  30. far later in the game because they're able to do their own due diligence their own information gathering and they have
  31. a set of ideas a set of options in mind when they engage the the salesperson so the animating ideas here are like it or
  32. not we're all in sales now but sales isn't what it used to be and so if sales is more about the highroad not
  33. everywhere but it's more about the highroad I said what are the qualities that matter most and there I plumb the
  34. research of social scientists like you and your colleagues all over the world to try to say you know let's not go
  35. based on books about eighteen ways to close the deal or you know the kind of books that populate the sales shelves
  36. let's look a little bit at what social scientists have told us about what's effective here so what is effective if
  37. granted I guess I am in sales and we all are if I want to get better at it what are some of your favorite well I mean I
  38. think that here's the thing I think that educators are in sales essentially what
  39. you're doing is you're at some level making an exchange with your class you're saying give me your attention in
  40. exchange I'll give you something else and now it's not the cash register that's not ringing it's not denominated
  41. in dollars or cents or euros but it is a form of sales in a way it is an exchange
  42. I think that that managers and organizations absolutely are doing this and if you look at some of the data that
  43. we have we we have a kind of a we had asked a question of how much times people are spending doing this sort of
  44. stuff we had a mean of 40% but at some level it masked what was else was going on because we had a lot of people up on
  45. the upper register 7080 percent and I think a lot of them were managers what are they doing they're trying to
  46. convince someone to join their team they're trying to get a current employee to do things a little bit differently or
  47. to do something else that's a little bit different they are dealing with their own bosses and trying to persuade them
  48. and so managers leaders inside of organizations are spending huge amounts of time doing this and I think the way
  49. to do it better the way to do it better in all senses of the word more effectively and more ethically is what I
  50. call the new ABCs attunement buoyancy and clarity tournament buoyancy and clarity a attunement perspective taking
  51. how do you understand someone else's perspective be buoyancy salespeople in general one of my favorite characters in
  52. this book was a guy named Norman Hall who's a soul full of brushes sales fuller brushes last Fuller Brush man in
  53. San Francisco and he said I love this phrase he said when you're in sales every day you face this is various an
  54. ocean of rejection so buoyancy is how do you remain buoyant on an ocean of rejection what do you do before what do
  55. you do during what do you do after and then clarity is I think this is really important for leaders and even business
  56. school students first of all we got a lot of information so accessing information doesn't give you much of an
  57. advantage what matters more is being able to curate the information filter the information make sense of it
  58. detect patterns in the information the second thing and not only through data analytics and things like that but just
  59. being able to sort of synthesize the information on your own the second thing is I think there's a premium now on
  60. premium problem-solving as a skill to problem finding that if a customer or prospect knows precisely what their
  61. problem is if I can articulate identify exactly what my problem is I can probably find a solution but you're more
  62. useful if I don't know what my problem is or if I'm wrong about my problem and so this move from problem-solving to
  63. problem finding is clarity so these are the new ABCs and there's some really interesting ways that I think managers
  64. leaders and organizations can get a lot better at them so if I think about these
  65. ABCs at least the a and the C it almost sounds like selling is a little bit more
  66. about advising or consulting than it is sort of influencing pushing persuading is that is that fair I think it's a very
  67. very fair comment and that's in fact one reason why I wanted to draw the chi mean
  68. one reason I wanted to draw the contrast ABC comes from always be closing which is the pushing steamroller
  69. drive drive drive and what I wanted to try to do is is in some ways take that on and one of the things that you see
  70. out there in sales sales is a move from even from selling solutions which was a idea that's been around for a while to
  71. selling insights one of my favorite examples is is a Perfetti Van Melle the confetti the candy company they say they
  72. make Mentos okay I happen to love Mentos and what they did is they their sales forces going into mom-and-pop shops
  73. convenience stores bodegas selling Mentos and they made a transition in their sales process and the way that
  74. they trained their salespeople in the way that their salespeople did their work they felt that they had a lot of
  75. data about candy of all sorts they were able to take that data with the each stores data put it together so they come
  76. in on a sales call and they say to that mom-and-pop shop we've looked at your data we've looked at our data here's our
  77. recommendations for the the sweet s you ite suite of products that you're that you should be selling and in some cases
  78. it'll mean selling we're only gonna recommend five kinds of Mentos for your store instead of seven even though in
  79. the short term seven is a better deal for us in some cases we're gonna recommend our competitors products which
  80. is you know heresy in the world of sales and so they say we're you know we're not
  81. only selling we're selling Mentos but we're really selling insights about the confections business and as a result of
  82. that so your point about advising this is this is a these are sales people who are actually welcomed when they arrive
  83. because there's they're there offering insights and not simply trying to push more candy on your on your store shelves
  84. and in the long run I think today that's much more effective that's an incredibly
  85. interesting example and I guess one of the questions it raises for me touches on one of the skills that you talked
  86. about in the book which is pitching yeah so it's easy to pitch a product how do you pitch an insight Oh interesting well
  87. I think the the the insight in that case would be think about an example for some
  88. reason this is an area that isn't that predisposed to mints mint flavors or something like that
  89. or there's a new emerging kind of more natural kind of product that's that's actually perking up in areas like yours
  90. and you can pitch basically that so it's an insight it ultimately is an insight about a product it's an insight about
  91. how to run your business but at the heart of it especially in the confections business it's about what
  92. group of products you actually offer great and let's come back then to the B in the ABC so buoyancy so we all face a
  93. lot of rejection as we try to achieve our goals what are some of the most effective strategies you've uncovered
  94. for maintaining that well well one of them one of my favorites because it's so counterintuitive comes from some work by
  95. some folks at Illinois actually one of them now here at Wharton and Mississippi State about a self talk and the
  96. conventional view on self talk is that we should pump ourselves up we're going into a sales call you can do it you got
  97. this you're an aunt you know even some of the hyper-masculine sort of you're an animal you're a monster that kind of
  98. stuff and what this research found is that you're better off deploying what they call interrogative self-talk not
  99. saying I can do it but asking yourself can you do this and it seems weird it seems you know like Stuart Smalley and
  100. Tony Robbins would start you know going crazy over this but when you unpack it it actually makes a lot of sense if I go
  101. into an encounter let's say let's say let's say I'm pitching ideas for a new book or let's say that I'm pitching
  102. ideas to assign pitching ideas for a new book if I go into that pitch meeting ahead of time and say Dan you can do
  103. this right that's sort of affirmative declarative pumping up I feel pretty good about that
  104. I mean I do I like hearing that I'm awesome I like telling myself it's fine I mean there is there is I mean again I
  105. don't know the research on this particular thing but there is at least in our human experience a kind of sort
  106. of a certain level of at least momentary buoyancy in that affirmation we feel good but if I say instead can you do
  107. this questions are active and that's the whole point the questions require even in self-talk questions elicit active
  108. response so if I say can you do this I say well yeah I can do this I've pitched books before can you do this yeah I can
  109. do this because this is a really great this is a really great idea and I've researched it
  110. really well and I can just I'm very confident in the contours of this idea can I do this
  111. you know every time I put your book Mariya over there she doesn't like it okay she's she's a total naysayer and
  112. but what I've done is I've done some research and figured out what really lights Maria's porch light and I will
  113. make sure I've got to make sure I mentioned that to get Maria so what am I doing there I'm preparing it's so so
  114. this thing that sort of nominally kind of even has a kind of fake muscularity to it this you can do it you got this
  115. but the real muscularity is in asking yourself the question and actively responding because then you actually
  116. begin to rehearse you begin to prepare you begin to summon your reasons for doing it and it ends up being far more
  117. effective and what I like about that is that anybody can do it and it doesn't cost you any extra money
  118. it just as a matter of changing yourself talk from affirmative and declarative to
  119. interrogative so I think this is one of the most powerful themes in the book is the idea of question yes so you've
  120. talked to us about about questions that you would record yourself yeah how did questions play into then moving other
  121. people there are a number of different there are a number different ways of there are no different ways about that
  122. one of my one of the interesting techniques again at the level of the level of tactics it goes to in some ways
  123. the clarity is some of the work in the therapeutic technique of motivational interviewing so let's say that I mean I
  124. think this works in all realms of our life so let's say that I've got I've got three kids and I got a 14 year old
  125. daughter 16 year old daughter neither one of them ever cleans their room okay the rooms are just total pigsty and
  126. so for a long time I you know as I you know my strategy was just to close the door okay so but you know again it ends
  127. up actually affecting me because someone can find something and hey Dad where's the baby okay so so let's say I want to
  128. convince my fourteen-year-old daughter Eliza to clean her room now I could try the parental command and control
  129. approach you got to clean your room I could try the carrot and stick approach I'll give you ten bucks to clean your
  130. room that's not gonna work I mean it might get some nominal cleaning in the short term but it's not sustained
  131. behavior I could do a stick approach you're gonna I'm gonna issue some punishment but
  132. those kinds of things don't have any enduring effect and so what this motivational interviewing techniques
  133. suggest us to do is this I say to my daughter Eliza Eliza on a scale of one to ten one meaning not ready at all 10
  134. meaning totally ready to do this scale of 1 to 10 how ready are you to clean up this mess of a room now so let's say
  135. that she says he's obviously not that ready to do it because it's still messy so let's say she says a3 on a scale of
  136. 10 all right this is where it gets interesting I say oh three okay great why isn't it lower and this is the
  137. really key point here in this therapeutic technique why isn't it lower if first of all the question is to
  138. surprise because the standard expectation it's three what do you mean it should be a nine this is really
  139. important a three okay why isn't it lower why isn't it - and so what she did she begins summoning her own reasons for
  140. doing something she's well sometimes hard to find stuff sometimes you and Mom aren't around so if I lose something I
  141. can't find it you know it actually feels a little bit better when my room is a little bit clean and so what she does is
  142. that the question again because it's active it's it's it's it's active and autonomous so she has to respond
  143. actively but she also summons her own autonomous intrinsically motivated reasons for for doing something and and
  144. that's generally a better path to sustained behavior I love the example I guess I'm wondering what happens when
  145. you repeat it yeah she learns and says oh yeah yeah no here's the thing on that one I think you have to deploy it very
  146. carefully you don't do it on everything it's like okay okay guys we're having dinner now
  147. and somebody's at the table I don't want us a table on a scale of 1 to 10 how right no I think you have to deploy it I
  148. didn't get to deploy it sparingly and for things that actually four things that actually matter but but again it
  149. goes back to this book drive that I wrote where one of the great social psychologists of our age Edward DC says
  150. you know repeatedly he says we have to think about motivation not as something one person does to another but as
  151. something people do for themselves and what you can do is you and I think questions have
  152. that kind of power there they're not directive they they're they're active they're engaging and if people respond
  153. to it they come up with their own reasons and that's you know the truth is if we have our own reasons for doing
  154. something reasons that we endorse we're more likely to do it more likely to stick with it I think that makes a lot
  155. of sense I guess one thing I'm curious about on that is if you think about sort of the more slick and manipulative types
  156. of sales yellow that your your debunking in this book yeah can they can they use this for evil in
  157. the sense of you know leading the witness I think that's possible I mean I think
  158. that's possible to use some of these tactics for for evil for instance you could have a evil is a strong word but
  159. so for for not good things rather than for for good things for instance there's some interesting research showing that
  160. when we hear rhymes things that rhyme if it doesn't fit you must have quit or the
  161. great studies showing that people tend to think if you take the aphorism woes unite foes versus woes unite enemies
  162. same substantively we can arm the linguist can argue whether or no they mean slightly different things but let's
  163. just say stipulate that substantively it means pretty much the same thing you give those two statements to people and
  164. they'll say woes unite foes is a much more accurate description of human character much more true principle about
  165. life and the reason is is that rhymes increase processing fluency and so it's possible to use a wrong I'm sure it's
  166. been there are histories where a rhyming pitch could be used for evil ends or nefarious ends same thing is true with
  167. cinta it's interesting question I bet sort of certain kind of far right far left facetious fascist or extreme
  168. totalitarian folks have probably used questions as a way to summon people's responses mm-hmm so I guess then if we
  169. can sort of take this toward your own application of these principles I know your identity has evolved a little bit
  170. as you worked on the book to see yourself as a salesman yeah that's true yeah so what implications has that had
  171. for how you do your own daily work it's actually had a lot and probably more than any other book that I've that I've
  172. written I found myself in the research and the reporting of this book saying wait a second I could actually so on so
  173. many different dimensions one of them is I rely mean it's a look I don't to say it's late in the game but but I realized
  174. that I wasn't very adept at listening and enjoy what were you saying I wasn't adept at listening and one of the things
  175. that I've tried to do is be at some level it's just simply to wait not to jump right in when people say something
  176. or so to make sure that I actually hear it to concentrate a little bit more on listening as a form of attunement the
  177. other thing I was very taken by the research on some of the research on perspective-taking as as something
  178. different from empathy that is not simply understanding people's feelings but understanding what they're thinking
  179. and what their interests are and I found myself in certain kinds of conflicts and
  180. negotiations really stopping and saying literally saying what are these person's
  181. interests what are what are they thinking I mean I want to be emotionally intelligent about it all I want to
  182. empathy see where they're coming from and that's more effective than doing nothing but I I think the muscularity of
  183. of perspective-taking as a kind of cognitive skill has been very useful to me I mean truly the interrogative
  184. self-talk has been the interrogative self-talk has been useful to me in preparing myself for things and even the
  185. even the you know some of the the information about about about pitches so that so there's some interesting
  186. research at Carnegie Mellon about how to your draft an email subject line and that has been really useful to me I
  187. realized how bad my email subject lines were there - they're too mushy and so that's helped me clarify that so a lot
  188. of things really at the tactical level that have made me say hey you know what I can get a little bit a little bit
  189. better at all this stuff very good well Dan thank you very much for joining us today thanks for having me and we look
  190. forward to continuing to dive in this to sell as human the surprising truth about
  191. moving others all right [Music] you

Brief Summary

Dan Pink discusses his book on sales, emphasizing that everyone is in sales and introducing new principles for effective selling.

Key points

  • We're All in Sales. Dan Pink discusses how everyone engages in selling, regardless of their job title.
  • The New ABCs of Sales. Pink introduces attunement, buoyancy, and clarity as essential qualities for modern sales.
  • Insights Over Products. Effective salespeople provide insights rather than just pushing products, leading to better relationships.
  • The Power of Listening. Learning to listen better can transform your daily interactions.
  • Perspective-Taking vs. Empathy. Understanding others' thoughts can enhance conflict resolution.
  • Improving Email Communication. Research shows how to craft better email subject lines.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

More from Knowledge at Wharton