How Is AI Changing the Auto Industry? – Wharton Professor John Paul MacDuffie | AI in Focus Series

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW Wharton professor John Paul MacDuffie joins Eric Bradlow, vice dean of Analytics at Wharton, to discuss AI’s impact on the auto industry, including the latest frictions between automotive and tech companies, potential for open source software, and more. This interview is part of a special 10-part series called "AI in Focus."

Topics and questions covered: 00:00 - Introductions 0:50 - What is the Program on Vehicle Mobility and Innovation? 3:35 - Understanding Level 4 automation 7:12 - Is AI in automotive a prediction problem? 10:39 - The future of vehicle automation 13:02 - Who wins: legacy automakers or big tech? 16:35 - Analyzing barriers for advanced automation 21:06 - Potential frontiers for AI

SERIES OVERVIEW The artificial intelligence revolution is officially upon us. Hear from host Eric Bradlow, Vice Dean of Analytics at Wharton, as he meets with Wharton faculty experts across a wide range of business domains – from healthcare and neuroscience to sports and the auto industry – to learn how AI will impact these fields moving forward, and what we can do to stay ahead of the curve.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU 📂 Technology;AI 🏷️ Research;AI in Focus

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. welcome to the next episode of the analytics at Wharton and AI at Wharton series on artificial intelligence um
  2. this series is or this episode is probably one of the topics that we should be spending a lot more time
  3. thinking about which is AI and Automotive in a lot of ways it's really Where it All Began I'm honored to have
  4. my friend and colleague John Paul McDuffy speaking to us today uh John Paul is a professor in the management
  5. department he's Al the also the director of the program on vehicle and mo IL Innovation I'm going to want to ask him
  6. what that is as part of the Mac Institute of innovation management here at the Wharton School uh so John Paul
  7. Welcome to our podcast today thank you glad to be here yeah so why don't before we get into Ai and Automotive which is
  8. the big topic of today why don't you tell us I I mean I've always thought of you as our innovation in automobiles guy
  9. so what is the program on vehicle and Mobility Innovation and what kind of things do you guys
  10. doing probably the best shorthand for our research agenda is is the so-called case technologies that are transforming
  11. Mobility c c for connected a for autonomous s for shared Mobility business models and E
  12. for electric and understanding each of those Technologies and their implications but also how they combine
  13. because they certainly combine in some cases and in other cases not um we for example think that most autonomous
  14. vehicles going forward are likely to be electric but obviously not all electric vehicles are fully autonomous and uh
  15. it's a fascinating competitive space we have not only the Legacy incumbents we have newcomers like Tesla we have a lot
  16. of other newcomers you may not have heard of and then we have big Tech hovering on the edges you know apple and
  17. and Google slwo um uh foxcon you know Apple's manufacturer wants to get into the
  18. autonomous vehicle business and uh you know run an entirely different you know iPhone type model for how this industry
  19. evolves so there's just uh a lot of fascinating things going on another thing to say about um the history of
  20. this program on vehicle Mobility Innovation I got my start on all this at MIT as a doctoral student with something
  21. called the international motor vehicle program at the time it was trying to understand the transformation from
  22. traditional mass production which had dominated most of the 20th century starting with Henry Ford to um Toyota
  23. production system which uh our program gave the name lean production to so why was lean production supplanting mass
  24. production why did it have competitive advantages and everything from manufacturing and product development to
  25. Supply Chain management and the like and when I came to Wharton um I continued an
  26. affiliation with MIT for a long time uh even was co-directing that program from down here uh at a certain point that
  27. program was about to close down at MIT and I actually asked if I could move it to
  28. Wharton and they said sure because uh at this point the program was really a network of Automotive researchers all
  29. over the world that we kept kind of loosely coordinated sometimes we would simply get together and share knowledge
  30. sometimes we would do joint Global research projects together and so to move kind of the network Hub to Wharton
  31. from MIT was not such a big deal and uh program on vehicle Mobility Innovation pvmi is the opposite set of uh order the
  32. initials of imvp that's a little in joke for those of us in the program I like that one so let me ask you um when I
  33. think when I say historically I don't mean back 20 years when I think over the last s to 10 years I really do as I
  34. opened up our podcast about I think of AI and Automotive as being like that was the flagship like that was going to
  35. demonstrate the ability of AI to you know self-driving cars I guess as you may call it you put in your notes level
  36. four where do things stand today like is that dream are we going to be having driverless cars all over the place soon
  37. is level four autonomy even the goal anymore yeah these are great questions and I think anybody who's followed this
  38. technology and has had as in in interest in it knows about the hype in the sort of 2016 17 maybe even a little earlier
  39. phase and how it's been kind of disappointing since then uh and yet these days you hear about uh Cruz and
  40. weo and Zo operating you know on call Robo taxis in San Francisco on a limited basis um you may also hear about some of
  41. the controversy with uh fire truck collisions and the regulation that's on the books in California to limit this
  42. one of the things I always think about is like you know I used to work for a large I could say dupond large
  43. International Chemical Company and like an error rate of one in a thousand one and 100,000 one and a million might be
  44. fine what could possibly be an acceptable error rate for a product and service like this like do you have to be
  45. like 10 standard deviations out on the safety scale like how do you even launch a product where one in 100,000 error
  46. rate which is great for most products and service would be totally unacceptable here I mean I think the the
  47. right answer the candid answer is we really don't know and it of course depends partly on public perception and
  48. what people feel is safe it depends on what how Regulators think of this issue and of course on the progress of the
  49. technology you know the proponents uh who say this is already a much safer technology would say you know 40,000
  50. people a year die in car accidents in the US those are all cars driven by humans right and that after about 50
  51. years of that rate going down in the last four or five years it's gone up despite all the new safety technology um
  52. probably distracted driving in phones is is one of the big reasons there seem to
  53. be two things going on at the same time when a user consumer has a first experience of a driverless car they're
  54. like nervous for a little while then they ask a lot of questions and then pretty soon they get bored and they
  55. start looking at their phone in other words people adapt to the experience very quickly and once they decide it's
  56. basically looks like it's driving normally they don't worry about it but whenever there's a big visible accident
  57. and the biggest one was the 2018 death of a pedestrian Wheeling a bike by an Uber car which actually had a human
  58. operator there to keep an eye on the autonomous vehicle she was actually looking at a phone at the time um that
  59. had a dramatic impact on how the public felt and then suddenly you had a spike and people who said I would never even
  60. get in and try one of those and it put a chill on many other aspects so I think it's still true of a lot of Technologies
  61. we accept less error from a automated systems than we do from humans because we feel like we kind of understand the
  62. sources of human error and particularly with AI you know behind the choices that
  63. are being made with automated driving we don't feel like we understand those choices well let me ask something that
  64. our listeners may be interested so we all know today generative AI is the next big thing or at least people are talking
  65. about it chat GPT Etc if you if I think about it as a statistician which I am um
  66. I think it's just a extremely high-dimensional prediction problem isn't Ai and Automotive just a very
  67. high-dimensional prediction problem and so is there any reason why the I'll call
  68. it General advances in AI today which tend to be focused right now on prompt engineering and chat GPT won't those
  69. advances eventually help Ai and Automotive as well or do you see them as different problems you know I always say
  70. what we do as academics is while the jargon changes and ones like what does John Paul McDuffy type into a chat box
  71. and what comes back and the other is what does weo build into some automated AI driven vehicle to me they're both
  72. high-dimensional prediction problems or do you see it differently no I I think the underlying technology affects both
  73. and the progress of the underlying technology affects both um they obviously you know where where words is
  74. the primary uh you know coin of the realm as it is with gen versus driving decisions there there's there's some
  75. differences but you know I think part of what happened with autonomous driving is
  76. the progress was remarkably rapid at first it started with Google competing successfully in a DARPA you know a
  77. government defense department I teach that DARPA challenge in my MBA class it's a great example and it was everyone
  78. was astounded at how well the Google software combined with about half a million dollars of hardware on the
  79. vehicle did and so that fueled the the VC and all the other funding and and everyone getting into it let's imagine
  80. progress that was rapid up to 90% of handling driving situations 95% 97% wow this thing is going to be
  81. everywhere in no time at all you hit that last couple of percent you know I can't say exactly what it is the
  82. so-called Corner cases the very rare combination of events that are really hard to you know either teach with
  83. traditional programming here's what may happen and here's what you have to do or
  84. even teach with the more inductive you know way of of machine learning which is you have a lot of data that you train it
  85. on right these very rare events by definition don't happen very often and how do you how do you train them you can
  86. write simulations and that's what these companies are doing okay let's imagine a
  87. weird situation or let's find a freak accident that happened in the real world and let's create a create a simulation
  88. for that their confidence that they've figured out how to handle all those simulated situations as part of where
  89. they say yeah we're going to be able to conquer it all but for the public and for regulators and all of us who think
  90. about you know climbing into these vehicles uh every time one of those weird situations is not handled well it
  91. adds doubt to that side of the ledger so um and I don't know that anybody ever feels that AI is going to solve
  92. everything 100% we're on warning right that there's hallucination and there's all these problems with Gen that means
  93. we have to really be alert this is Eric bradow professor of marketing statistics
  94. and data science here at the Wharton School and also Vice dean of analytics and we're here as part of our analytics
  95. at Wharton and AI series uh we're talking to professor John Paul McDuffy we're talking about Ai and automation
  96. today so let me ask you do you think the future is that maybe Ai and automation will be more widespread but it might not
  97. be what your just what you call level four like probably the next step for there to get more mass adoption is I I
  98. guess it would be level three which would be yes self-driving but there might also be a steering steing wheel or
  99. there might be the opportunity for human intervention or what do you see is going
  100. to take it from let's call it what it is now which is really a niche market to something that might be more widespread
  101. yeah a brief background on those levels it's um something the Society of Automotive Engineers came up with to
  102. describe different levels of autonomy uh level there's actually a fifth level which is can go anywhere at any time in
  103. any circumstances without being able to connect to the internet um that's even further out but level four is basically
  104. in most operating conditions can operate autonomously you're right level three involves some handing back of control
  105. between a human driver and an automated system level two is stuff that we already see in a lot of modern vehicles
  106. Lane control selfing L control even automatic braking I mean some of it's becoming becoming pretty Advanced so one
  107. kind of strategic I don't know if it's a full divide but it's something you can see the level for Stuff got all the
  108. headlines and that's what weo is investing on and that's what Cruz some of the other prominent startups that's
  109. what Tesla with Alon musk has been promising for years with his you know optimistically or misleadingly named
  110. autopilot system um the Legacy automakers and all the suppliers who feed in the technologies have been
  111. slowly adding the level two advanced stuff and even experimenting a little with level three and they can say we're
  112. making a safer car they can usually charge extra money for it although increasingly a little bit following
  113. toa's lead there's a tendency to bundle all the safety stuff together and just say this is the right thing to do buy it
  114. you know you get it all at once basic prospect theory you you bundle prices together and
  115. so it's kind of a question of whether the slow moving up from the lower levels ends up affecting more people's
  116. Driving Experience sooner than the promise of level four which may stay a niche until it satisfies a lot of the
  117. questions we have about it so who's going to be you know I've thought about this matter of fact I teach an
  118. automotive cases I mentioned in my in the NBA Corp because I I think it's such a fascinating industry who's going to be
  119. the winner here and let me even put on my so besides being Vice of analytics I am the chair of the market I'll put on
  120. my marketing department hat here who would I trust more to get into an autonomous AI driven vehicle would I
  121. trust Ford or would I trust Google and to me I'm thinking I want a data company I want a company
  122. that's really good in Ai and Predictive Analytics I mean like another way to frame it is do you ever see a day where
  123. the Legacy automakers actually turn out to be the big winners in this or is it likely to
  124. be a tech company that just happens to also do work in automotive well I mean that's a great
  125. and big question and so we may want to spend a little time on it yeah well that's what we're doing here on the AI
  126. series Ai and we're talking about big questions the um weo which is the Google subsidiary doing this uh they've said
  127. pretty clearly we are not going to build a vehicle we're not going to have a vehicle we're making a software driver
  128. which we're going to sell to license to the people who make the vehicles so you could have a wayo driver in a Ford
  129. vehicle maybe that would be a sweet spot for you if you like uh or or any other Legacy automaker um you have other
  130. companies who are taking a different approach Tesla obviously being one but zuk's is a company that is now owned by
  131. Amazon which is building the vehicle hardware and the software and the business model for they have a robo taxi
  132. and also a automated Trucking like like small Trucking almost delivery makes sense if they're own owned by Amazon um
  133. so you have all these different combinations I've been increasingly feeling like even though the Automotive
  134. companies and the tech companies don't really like each other and don't really want to work together that they may have
  135. to there's something about Mastery of the physical realities of a vehicle that the digital Giants really don't have and
  136. obviously the auto companies are not good at digital stuff anybody who has tried the the company provided you know
  137. interface in their car knows knows that for sure and I I think you know we instinctively think that the the the the
  138. data Giants will be better at something that involves so much data that involves
  139. Co connectivity and the like um and they've handled the control of physical systems braking and steering and the
  140. basic stuff really quite well but um I think uh another aspect of this is the computer industry It generally has been
  141. a quite a modular industry you have kind of clear interfaces you have Innovation
  142. that's possible when people simply know the the specs the interface specs the apis of the people they're working with
  143. the automotive industry has remained a very integrated industry there's a lot of interdependencies in this complex
  144. multi-technology vehicle that can't be predefined away it requires a lot of interaction to work it through and and
  145. this maybe is a clue to what you know autonomous vehicles but also autonomous and electric and all the other stuff
  146. together it will require combining that knowledge of the physical with the knowledge of the digital and will force
  147. some collaboration that maybe the parties wouldn't choose otherwise so what's I don't use the word preventing
  148. but let's use that what's preventing things from getting to even level five autonomy is it um it would just cost too
  149. much to build that's one possibility like you could build it but at that price just there would be such a small
  150. Market another possibility is you know I'll say it we can't process like it's our Computing like we can't process like
  151. something in a vehicle can't process that much information at that quick a speed it could be um we don't know
  152. enough math it could be our algorithms aren't good enough yet what is the big stumbling block given you said 95 plus
  153. percent was done in the first couple years what's preventing this last 3% cuz I think I'm ready like I'm ready for
  154. level five no I'm saying I'd get into level five sure I would yeah um there are new Chips coming along you
  155. know Tesla's designing it own chip Nvidia it turns out the video processing chips are very good for the so-called
  156. Sensor Fusion Sensor Fusion is what they call where you take the camera data the
  157. regular radar data and the lar the laser laser radar data and you combine them to
  158. get that 360 picture of what's really going on you have to have both accurate information about distance things are
  159. away from you and what they are right you need to know is this a car is this a bike is this a person is this a a
  160. traffic you know piece of construction equipment whatever see when you say that I have to admit if this wasn't professor
  161. John Paul McDuffy of the Wharton Management Department this was just a general AI lecture I'd say so this could
  162. be a store using facial recognition or this could be I mean just if you even think about the language you just use
  163. this is the problem of AI engines today and it just happens the application area
  164. in me in my view in automotive is really interesting and cool and possibly lifechanging yeah so you know and and
  165. you were asking the various constraints on it yeah they're making progress on the technical constraints um for sure
  166. there's the regulatory issue of how much testing in real life to allow so as I said there's a lot of simulated testing
  167. going on uh most of the testing is on a rather small scale so far it's rolling out kind of state-by-state City by city
  168. for the robo taxis um there's also people working on automated Trucking and uh trucks are much bigger which
  169. potentially a I mean people don't know this I teach this also in this same lecture maybe you'll correct me wrong
  170. I've made the claim that the trucking industry is the biggest industry in the US
  171. today um that's interesting you're obviously combining every everything that moves Goods at any levela I don't
  172. know if if uh but what I've also commented on is let's imagine level five automated truck driving happens I also
  173. think about all the ancillary Industries like you know truck drivers gener a lot
  174. of income for hotels and restaurants and everything else so we have a long conversation about let's call it related
  175. Industries like if Ai and Automotive takes off there's so many other industries that would be impacted some
  176. positively some not yeah you know there's a company named Aurora that's working um it it it took over the
  177. autonomous vehicle stuff that Uber was doing it's working closer with Toyota they're focusing on trucks right now and
  178. they're focusing on Long Haul uh distances I think most people imagine that that is the part of trucking that's
  179. the best application the local stuff which is the delivery where you're in cities and you're having to stop and put
  180. things on people's doorsteps or put it you know in a in a some kind of box that's actually a lot more complex to do
  181. right um and those those are also the jobs that are more local I mean they're huge shortages of truck drivers the Long
  182. Haul truck driving life is not a very desirable occupation in terms of being away from home and and health and the
  183. like and so but it it it reminds me of another distinction I wanted to make you know we don't know if the autonomous
  184. vehicle is going to be a individual ownership model or it's only going to be a Fleet model yeah that's what that get
  185. to affordability and that gets to you know how do you manage the upkeep and maintenance uh you know Uber famously
  186. under its founding CEO Travis clonic said you know this is existential for us to have to be able to move to a
  187. autonomous vehicles because we can't afford to do the human driver model and achieve all the goals we want what's
  188. your what's your forecast am I am I going to be owning an autonomous driving vehicle or is there just going to be a
  189. fleet of vehicles out there that drive up to my home anytime I want it yeah I I think the the full autonomy model
  190. probably works economically best as a Fleet model um you know remember though we
  191. talked about the automation creeping up from level two through level three so level three is probably still a
  192. personally owned vehicle right so um so then is there a niche for somebody who really wants their own vehicle that they
  193. can then not drive or or or or not or will or will it all be or will it all be supplied now
  194. there's also the economics of density and so if you live in a place where you can guarantee relatively rapid service
  195. from a robot taxi you would need to but if if you're way out the country you're probably not going to have that ready
  196. service available so then maybe you are a candidate to be the one who owns it maybe you have to be really wealthy to
  197. afford it because the scale is not in the personal ownership it's in the it's in the fleet um so you know the the the
  198. the there's some other issues about Fleet the companies that are doing the software for these vehicles they don't
  199. know from running fleets and and repairing vehicles and dealing with Duty Cycles and cleaning up after the last
  200. user and stuff like this so the minute they contract that out that's a chunk of their profits but that's uh that's
  201. another story so in the last like two or three minutes we have let me ask you um
  202. first it's a two-part question but it's really the same question what are the open research
  203. questions from you as an academic in this area and secondly um maybe we'll make a date 10 years from now you and I
  204. are sitting here what are we going to talk about has happened over the last 10 years in the AI and a Automotive space
  205. one of the big research questions I'm looking at is really about the the organization and structure of
  206. the industry and of competition in this in this space so it's clearly expanding Beyond Automotive to be a Mobility kind
  207. of space it's clearly Beyond just firm competition to be ecosystems and what's going on with ecosystem
  208. competition uh there is a vision of where this Mobility stuff goes which is around uh very modul systems uh open
  209. source software uh we haven't talked a lot about it because it hasn't shown up so much yet but um for example I
  210. mentioned foxcon before uh they've organized a Consortium of firms suppliers and the
  211. like they want to have uh open source software for autonomous vehicles they want a contract manufacturing model for
  212. making the vehicles they want a completely commoditize vehicle design where you start with a basic skateboard
  213. and then you put different kinds of and it's it's right out of the digital Playbook of what we've seen happen in it
  214. uh there are people who fervently believe in that and part of what they say is it's too damn expensive for every
  215. single company to come up with its own vehicle its own software for you to have a competition even between wh Mo's
  216. software and Apple's software for example is just a lot of why not have one open source that can also maybe be
  217. vetted and and and that we can have more oversight than we would from a private big tech company um my basic skepticism
  218. around this big research question is this fundamental fact that the architecture of both the product and the
  219. industry has been up until now much more integrated because of all these kind of
  220. interdependencies some of which are really based in physics and and physical realities I don't expect that to change
  221. so much that this modular Vision really has the potential to happen that some of
  222. its it or big Tech proponents would would like so that's kind of one big research question I'm looking at I guess
  223. in 10 years we might be looking to see what the outcome is because there are some people who think that even if what
  224. I said is true the brains are going to be somebody's software right somebody's software is going to be so good that it
  225. wins yep and it's either a monopoly or maybe it's an oligopoly you know maybe we end up with Android versus iOS you
  226. know maybe there's just two autonomous driving you know and and electric and everything uh competitors in the world
  227. and everyone else just has to bow down and you know uh oh yes you know I used to be BMW but now I'll make your car you
  228. know oh oh oh oh big Tech Overlord um who knows that uh may be possible remember that this is a super
  229. competitive super Global and super low margin industry and these big tech companies are not used to that and I
  230. sort of question when I think about Apple having an Apple car are not whether they could do it and do a very
  231. good job at it but whether they really want to be in that business right and even if they pull back to say we just
  232. want to do the software um even that is a big Challenge and we'll pull them away
  233. from a lot of the other things that they're doing way Mo's committed to it I think weo will will stay in you've got
  234. to be well financed so we may have a couple winners but it wouldn't surprise me given what I've said before that
  235. you've got a couple of um essentially alliances between y Auto and big Tech some of those alliances Thrive and win
  236. some of them fail and lose so we have kind of a ShakeOut that leaves a few Legacy automakers and big Tech
  237. contenders on the floor and a few winners that have figured out how to combine their uh complimentary
  238. capabilities let's say well John Paul I'd like to thank you for joining me today on the analytics at Wharton AI at
  239. Wharton sirusxm podcast series obviously we've been talking about AI in autom in
  240. Automation and automotive and what's amazing to me was was I'm sure there were times in your career where you've
  241. thought I'm in this old Legacy industry but now's not one of them it's got to be
  242. a great let's be honest it's got to be a great time to be you right now come on it's a great time to be me I'll say it
  243. I'll agree well thank you for joining us and this uh again this has been Eric bradow professor of marketing and
  244. statistics and data science byen here of analytics at the Wharton School uh please stay with us and join us for our
  245. next episode of the analytics at Warden AI at Warden AI series

Brief Summary

John Paul McDuffy discusses AI's impact on automotive innovation and the challenges of achieving fully autonomous vehicles.

Key points

  • AI and Automotive: The Future. Exploring the intersection of AI and the automotive industry, and its implications for the future.
  • The Challenge of Autonomous Vehicles. Discussing the complexities and public perception surrounding the safety of autonomous vehicles.
  • The Future of Autonomous Vehicles. Discussion on whether autonomous vehicles will be individually owned or part of a fleet.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes