How Safe Are Your Retirement Savings, Really?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE What happens to your retirement savings if the stock market drops 25%?

Wharton finance professor Nikolai Roussanov breaks down the real risks behind 401(k) investing, why volatility is part of the system, and whether the government would step in during a major crash.

Using past crises like 1987, the dot-com bust, and COVID, we explore how markets recover, why investors often make costly mistakes, and why bailouts are more likely to support companies—not individual portfolios.

If you rely on a 401(k), understanding these risks is key to protecting your financial future.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#StockMarket #401k #RetirementPlanning #MarketCrash #Investing #PersonalFinance #FinancialCrisis #EconomicRisk #WealthBuilding ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Millions of Americans have their retirement savings linked to 401k accounts. We know that
  2. those accounts obviously grow over time and provide older Americans with a level of retirement savings
  3. that help them get through their latter years. But what if there was a significant shock to the
  4. markets? Not a correction, like around 10%, but something even more significant, like 25%.
  5. Would the government step in and support those retirement accounts similar to what they did with
  6. companies during the 2008 financial crisis? Pleasure to ask that question and more of Nick
  7. Roussanov, who is a finance professor here at the Wharton School. Nick, great to catch up with you.
  8. How are you, sir? Hi, Dan. I'm well. Thanks for having me. Always a pleasure. Yeah, it's an
  9. interesting question because I think we assume that our retirement savings are fairly safe,
  10. but then again, they are not backed like traditional bank accounts, like with the FDIC.
  11. Of course, but that's kind of the nature of the beast, right? Because the whole idea for
  12. owning stocks is that you earn the equity premium, which is a compensation for bearing risk, right?
  13. So you get that extra return because you are facing that risk. And over the long run, as we
  14. know from our esteemed colleague, Jeremy Siegel, over the long run, that compensation is sufficient
  15. to kind of overcome much of the fluctuations. But there is always, of course, uncertainty,
  16. and there is a short run volatility. But also, there is, of course, always uncertainty about
  17. the state of the economy and where the market will go. All right. So if we were to have a
  18. scenario where we saw a significant shock, and knowing what we know of what the federal government
  19. did during not only the financial crisis, but the coronavirus pandemic, would there be a path
  20. for the federal government to consider something like a bailout? So it's an interesting question because the importance of the stock market has grown
  21. in providing for the retirement, as you mentioned, right? Because in the past, if we go back to
  22. the 20th century retirement system, most of the retirement plans were so-called defined benefit,
  23. right? For people who were working in companies, and to this day, to some extent, in state
  24. governments and so on, the employer would provide them with a pension that was based on their
  25. lifetime earnings. But over time, we have moved away from that towards what is called defined
  26. contribution. So that's, of course, the 401k and similar types of plans where the employer
  27. puts something in the plan, the employee puts something in the plan, and that is invested.
  28. And for the last 25 years, the dominant vehicles for those investments have been equity market
  29. funds or target date funds, which have a mix of equity and bonds that kind of shifts over time,
  30. right? So the reason we're talking about this is that because now we have a much larger fraction
  31. of retirement savings, in particular, tied directly or almost directly to stocks,
  32. whereas they were kind of very indirectly related to the stock market through those defined benefit
  33. plans that were themselves backed by the companies. So now to your question, it's of course,
  34. you know, something that we have not had experience with. And so we can only speculate
  35. over what would happen. But if we look at the past, past crises or past market crashes, right? 1987 crash was a very sharp, big, you know, over 20% drop in the stock market
  36. in one day, after which, of course, markets recovered over the subsequent months and years.
  37. And of course, there was no government intervention directly to prop up the markets,
  38. even though the term Greenspan put was derived later, based on the idea that Alan Greenspan's
  39. Federal Reserve would cut rates at the signs of market stress and then market drawdowns,
  40. like in 1998, for example, crisis with LTCM hedge fund going on under and the Asian financial crisis
  41. and so on. And that's what we saw, by the way, following the NASDAQ, NASDAQ boom and bust,
  42. where we did see a really major crash in NASDAQ drop more than 80%. And even the S&P 500 and
  43. broad stock market fell over the several years, in fact, was in a deep bear market territory. So
  44. we had a long, long bear market from 2000 to 2002. And then, of course, subsequently, again,
  45. the markets recovered. And we know that at the bottom of these deep drawdowns, the expected
  46. returns going forward for investors are actually the highest. So investors who stick with us and
  47. keep invested over time, recover and grow their wealth. And that's why I think in the past,
  48. there wasn't much impetus for the government to intervene. But part of the reason was that
  49. we didn't have as widespread of stock market participation. Yes, we had over 50% of population
  50. invested in stocks, at least a little bit at the kind of the peak of the dotcom boom.
  51. Since then, that number went down for a while. And that's because after the markets crashed,
  52. a lot of people got discouraged and pulled out. And that's exactly the wrong thing to do,
  53. of course. And that's kind of the danger that that's what happens. But then that number
  54. recovered in part because people went back into the stock market. And also, as I said,
  55. the defined contribution plans have grown quite, quite substantially. Now, more recently, we saw
  56. over 20% drawdown in 2022. Again, we had a fairly rapid recovery from that. And of course, as you
  57. mentioned, COVID, during COVID, we had over 40% drop in the market in a very, very short period
  58. of time, and after which we saw a tremendous, tremendous returns both in the short term and
  59. over the last five, six years. So a given fairly rapid recoveries that we have experienced,
  60. it doesn't seem like there would be a reason for concern. Now, we do know that during COVID,
  61. the Fed did intervene, not in the equity markets, but in the bond markets. And it besides buying
  62. treasury bonds, like they had done over the QE period following the financial crisis,
  63. they can have reinstituted the QE, the quantitative easing, buying basically treasuries and mortgages.
  64. But they also put together a facility for buying corporate bonds, of which very little was actually
  65. used. It has $750 billion facility to buy corporate bonds. They only spend maybe $14 billion of that
  66. buying investment grade corporate bonds and ETFs. And that was already highly unusual,
  67. because in the kind of recent history, or really any history of the Federal Reserve,
  68. we don't have them buying private securities. We either have them buy US government securities,
  69. treasury bonds, or mortgages that are already backed by the US government in terms of the
  70. credit risks through Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. So that was already kind of unusual. And it was
  71. seen as an extraordinary emergency measure to prevent kind of market dysfunction and total
  72. collapse of the corporate bond market, which is important for corporations to finance themselves
  73. and for their ongoing operations. Again, the Fed mandate is part of it is full employment,
  74. as well as price stability. Employment depends on companies to be able to pay their bills
  75. and keep their employees employed. And that was perhaps, to some extent, the impetus.
  76. Now, one could say that, well, why not stocks? If stock market crashes, that will also hurt
  77. employment. So I can see the argument being made, but that would be highly unusual.
  78. So the Federal Reserve obviously has tools that it can use as somewhat backstops
  79. to have some level of protection in these situations. And it seems like there's not
  80. necessarily the need to go into the equity markets as much, although we're seeing with
  81. the current administration them wanting to buy into companies. And it's not necessarily buying
  82. the debt, but it's at least seeing the potential path of growth of some of these companies
  83. in very important sectors for our government and our country to make sure that our country is safe.
  84. Right. So we've seen kind of a grown appetite recently for the government investment
  85. in the corporate sector, which is kind of unusual, given our spirit of capitalism
  86. in the United States, right, that the government and private business are kind of separate.
  87. And with Intel in particular, the idea was we have to preserve this company that is kind of
  88. important, as you kind of mentioned, for national security reasons, maybe, if nothing else.
  89. Turned out that worked very well, that investment for the government that was made in Intel,
  90. given that Intel has, in fact, recovered quite strongly with the semiconductor boom,
  91. with all the AI-driven demand. So in the end, we kind of see that, oh, well, government participated in this great upside. And in fact, you could say that the
  92. government takeovers of some of the failed companies in the financial crisis, Freddie May and Freddie Mac being the most obvious, but also AIG,
  93. to some extent was kind of exposed, actually not a bad investment for the Treasury.
  94. So you could see the Treasury maybe intervening in some maybe key sectors of the economy where
  95. it sees that we have to have these companies, we cannot afford them to go under, and we will
  96. bail them out. Again, anything is possible. It would be, I think, highly unusual for the Fed to
  97. just buy all of the S&P 500 companies, right, or even more broadly if there is a major crash.
  98. But I could see kind of targeted interventions in some sectors that were deemed kind of
  99. critical in some way. Now, again, what is critical, right? We had automakers that were
  100. bailed out in a way, although equity holders were wiped out in those cases, and most bondholders as
  101. well, the companies were allowed to survive, again, in the 2008 recession. So it's not really,
  102. the idea is not to kind of prop up the stock prices. The idea is not to support the investors.
  103. The idea is support the firms to some extent, support them as employers of workers to some
  104. extent to support them, maybe their industrial capacity or some other kind of important function
  105. that those companies play, not necessarily support the equity holders. So that's what
  106. would be kind of unprecedented for the Fed or the Treasury to buy stocks just so that
  107. people don't lose too much in their retirement accounts. And then I think that would be quite
  108. fraught. So because we have so many people that are connected to 401ks in this country,
  109. do we need to, I guess, continue to look at the system and think about potentially new,
  110. innovative ways that we can look at what is best for retirees down the road? Absolutely. And I think that is where the industry will increasingly go, but it's not something that
  111. necessarily requires too much government oversight. The government role was allowing
  112. target date retirement funds as a default in the 401k plans. That was done in the early 2000s.
  113. And that was extremely successful because prior to that reform, 401k plans defaulted people into
  114. basically money market funds, which earned a safe and steady return, but don't give them
  115. participation in the stock market. Of course, people could choose to invest their savings into
  116. an index fund or even in some plans, individual companies, but many didn't bother. And there
  117. was kind of a lot of inertia and just generally a lot of inertia. A lot of people don't do anything
  118. beyond what the default is. And so switching the default to the target date fund was extremely
  119. successful in increasing stock market participation and driving the tremendous gains that
  120. investors have experienced over the last 20 years in the financial markets. And so many retirees
  121. actually now enjoying a sizable NASDAQ thanks to that. But of course, we have to think about
  122. kind of the downsides of that. So the target date funds, they have the so-called glide paths, which
  123. is the allocation to stocks versus bonds that changes over time, starting with a fairly high
  124. allocation to stocks when the workers are young. So ranging between 60 to 80 or even 90 percent,
  125. and then gradually declining to something that is almost entirely or mostly bonds by the time
  126. that people retire. Now, this is where, you know, the retirees who are, or people approaching
  127. retirement who are in these target date funds, they are already protected from a kind of a crash
  128. because they're mostly in bonds, unless the crash also affects the bond market, which is what
  129. we saw in 2022. In 2022, in fact, the mixed equity bond allocation did just as better, even
  130. more poorly than 100 percent equity because, of course, bonds got crushed by the rising inflation
  131. and interest rates. There is obviously that risk. But in general, figuring out a better, safer
  132. glide path, a glide path that includes some kind of allocation to inflation index bonds in
  133. particular, given that inflation now is a concern that provides retirees with a steady stream of
  134. real payouts, right, that are indexed to inflation would be a good idea. And I think
  135. some research in that direction is ongoing. Nick, great to talk to you as always. Thanks very much
  136. for your time today. Of course. Thank you. You got it. Nick Roussanov, finance professor here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Nick Roussanov discusses 401k risks, government intervention, and retirement savings strategies amid market shocks.

Key points

  • The Risk of Market Shocks. What happens to 401k accounts during a significant market downturn?
  • Government Intervention in Crises. Could the government bail out retirement accounts like it did in 2008?
  • The Shift to Target Date Funds. Target date funds have increased stock market participation for retirees.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes