Inside the Numbers: The U.S. Open & Player Performance

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Jeff Sackmann, founder of Tennis Abstract, joins Cade Massey, Eric Bradlow, and Adi Wyner to discuss his data-driven forecasts for the U.S. Open, the statistical dominance of Jannik Sinner and Carlos Alcaraz, and how tennis analytics is reshaping the way we understand player performance and strategy. Cade, Eric & Adi also discuss Tommy Fleetwood’s long-awaited PGA victory, the statistical challenges of measuring golf performance, rising MLB fastball velocities, and the excitement surrounding one of the strongest opening weekends in college football history. In a bonus overtime interview, Cade speaks with Ralph Russo, national college football writer at The Athletic, about how data-driven insights are shaping the narratives around college football.

ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? The Moneyball podcast explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.

#usopen #tennis #sportsanalytics #statistics#collegesports ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Welcome, welcome to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to another full hour of sports analytics here on the Wharton podcast
  2. network. This is Kade Massie hosting today with my longtime friend, colleague, collaborator, co-host Eric
  3. Bradlo, Audi Winer, we're expecting at some point in the next hour. Shane Jensen, we are not expecting this week.
  4. Our fourth colleague is out and about doing Shane Jensen things as he has want to do this time of year, but he will be
  5. back some combination of us are here almost every week of the year. And by that we mean I don't know 48 49 weeks of
  6. the year and for pushing 11 and a half years now. Delighted to be here on this Tuesday afternoon. Late summer Tuesday
  7. afternoon. In fact, this is the last Tuesday of the summer months. If you wrap it up in August, it is very much
  8. late summer. That means a few things, guys. That means that football's about to start. We're going to spend some time
  9. on that. It means baseball is getting more interesting. But it also means that some significant tennis is being played
  10. in the New York City area. And for that topic, we wanted to bring in Jeff Sackman. Some of y'all who've been
  11. listening know that we have Jeff on here a time or two a year and have for a long
  12. time. Sackman is as good as it gets in the world of tennis analytics. jumped off the page at us early in our time. I
  13. think we're reading like some of these economist articles without byel lines and like we're thinking who the heck is
  14. this writing all this great stuff on tennis analytics and we find out that it's Jeff Sackman. Jeff does a lot of
  15. stuff. He's the founder of tennis abstract. It's an online encyclopedia of sorts covering much of the history of
  16. tennis. But within that site he also writes a blog heavy top spin. Heavy top spin looking at players and trends. and
  17. that's where you see some of the stuff that catches our eye. We're always delighted for chance to talk with you,
  18. Jeff. Thanks for making time for us. >> Absolutely. Glad to be here, guys. >> Glad to have you. Um, in the meantime,
  19. while I rambled around there in the beginning, Audi Winer showed up. Audi is back. Audi is no longer on sabbatical.
  20. Audi's kind of supposed to be here every week now. It's gonna be it's gonna be fun to have him back around. He is the
  21. best traveler, I think, of the four of us. Audi, great to see you. >> Be here, >> Jeff. In a minute. uh you and Eric can
  22. dive into all things US Open, but maybe just as a starting place, you can tell us as the tournament starts, as you pull
  23. your head out of whatever data you've been looking at lately, what is on your mind around tennis right now? How are
  24. you thinking about this tournament or what player are you especially interested? Or is there any analytics
  25. project that's especially had you consumed recently? Well, one thing that I was looking at
  26. this week is the big story in men's tennis for I mean more than a year now is that we we can pretty much forget
  27. about the big four. We can pretty much like let NovakJokovic ride into the sunset. It's the Yanuk Center and Carlos
  28. Ocar show and the numbers are starting to put up are starting to be a bit mindboggling even though they are so
  29. young. So, one thing that I do with every Grand Slam is I I I throw the the draw and my ELO ratings into a into a
  30. formula and generate a pre-ournament forecast. And typically over the years, the number one seed, the top player in
  31. the draw, not always the same player, whoever the my favorite is in the in the draw will end up with around a 35% 40%
  32. chance of winning the tournament. And then there'll be maybe a half dozen guys who are in the 5 to 10% range. Now,
  33. coming into this tournament, Yannik Center was at 45%. Not the highest he's ever been, but that's that's very high
  34. for someone to be at 45%. But the shocking thing is not that. The shocking thing is that Carlos Alcarez is at 35%.
  35. >> So that's that's an 80% chance of these top two guys winning. Just I mean that
  36. that's before a single ball is struck. So your number three normally I've got a number three at least in double digits.
  37. Alexander Zerv is pulling up the number three spot at six whole percent which you know if you follow Alexander Zerv
  38. that might even sound generous but that that's the state of men's tennis right now. I mean even I don't think Federer
  39. and Nadal ever managed to pose numbers like that partly because like they were half of the big four and the rest of the
  40. big four was pretty good too. But I mean that's how dominant these two guys are right now. That's astounding and it's a
  41. great top line and it's it's exactly the kind of thing that we often ask about before a big competition. We'll ask it
  42. about a golf tournament. We'll ask it about a tennis tournament and I don't think we've ever heard anything quite
  43. that stacked up. Is >> just ask a followup if I could just ask you quickly a follow-up to that. We're
  44. one point away from sinner having the sinner slam at the French. So, um, how like is it even really like I'm an
  45. Alcarass fan just to get to make sure everybody knows everybody knows this. Is it really even the big two? I mean,
  46. Sinner is one point away from holding all four majors. >> Yeah, I mean, he's pretty dominant. On
  47. the other hand, my overall ELO ratings, which are not not the surface specific ones, they actually give Alcarez a
  48. slight edge right now. They they say Alcaras is the number one player in the world. not on hard courts. Sinner has
  49. the edge on hard courts. But what I always think about is there there's two ways to be to win a
  50. slam. One way is to take down the top dog, which is what it seems like someone's going to have to do. The other
  51. way to win a slam is let somebody else take down the top dog. And if uh Grigor Deitrov hadn't gotten injured two sets
  52. in his match against Wimbledon, then it would have been an absolute breeze for Alcarez to coast to that title. So
  53. whether it's Alexander Bublick having another big day like he had on grass uh running up to Wimbledon or whether it's
  54. somebody like Dimitro having a career best day or who knows what could happen. Grand slams mean you got to win seven
  55. matches. Sometimes in the late rounds it's going to be somebody like maybe it's Thafo in New York who's going to
  56. play the best tennis he's ever played. Sinners got to run through those hurdles. So if we do get to the point
  57. where it's a mono ono final in two weeks then yeah the edge goes to center. But there's there's just too many hurdles in
  58. just in the structure of tennis. There's too many hurdles to to annoy somebody the the big one unless he's unless he's
  59. really ahead of the pack. Uh before his uh his suspension earlier this year, I think he was getting there. Uh he posted
  60. a careerhigh elo rating in the 2300s, which is like top 20 of all time. Um he hasn't gotten back to that level since,
  61. but maybe maybe I I can give you an update after this tournament. We'll find that he is back there. I mean, he he
  62. could he could accomplish that, but just not quite yet. >> Jeeoff, that was getting close to one of
  63. the questions I was going to ask about the two dominating the probability of winning. How can you decompose that at
  64. least at least casually between there being unusually good versus the rest of the field being a little bit weaker? Can
  65. you give us some way of comparing those two things? >> That's a really, really hard question to
  66. answer and I've never come up with a satisfactory way of answering it. Partly because my intuition is that you
  67. basically never have a weak field in the tennis world because the tennis world is
  68. always getting better. I mean, you have the same coaches working for generations. You have the same
  69. nutritional insights, training insights, all that stuff is is gradually getting better over the
  70. years. uh the the population of players that the tennis world is drawing on, the
  71. number of countries with developmental programs, like every force there is is should be making the whether it's the
  72. top 100, the top 50, or even the top 1,000 should be making it gradually a little bit better. So if if you agree
  73. with me up to that point, I mean I I agree you can argue some of those points, but if you agree with me up to
  74. that point, then if somebody is head and shoulders ahead of the pack, they're actually head and shoulders ahead of an
  75. even better pack than Federer and Nadal etc was or Rod Lever was 50 years ago. So that that's my my first level take.
  76. Okay. >> I don't know how you work out other than just a little bit from year to year
  77. whether the pack is is getting worse. >> So Jeeoff, let me ask you a question. Let's just quickly if let's imagine
  78. everyone gets 30 40 50 ELO points better um since the ELO model isn't a linear model would that make it so that the
  79. other let's call it top 100 the other 98 players in the draw it's really 126 but
  80. let's say the other 98 players in the drawer does that make it less likely then that
  81. one person can be as dominant because it's a nonlinear model the top person's 30 points better now in simply models
  82. just the difference in ELO ratings. So if everyone goes up linearly, the difference cancels out. But what are
  83. your thoughts about kind of the nonlinearity that you know now you have to beat 98 better players and how do you
  84. think about that? >> Well, I think that's exactly what we've seen the last decade or so in the
  85. women's game. Uh before Sabalinka and Fionek have emerged as the their own top two. I mean, and even EGA struggling
  86. this year. Um, we had a run of like 12 slams in a row where different women won the title. I think I think that's the
  87. number. And it Yeah, you have you have players climbing the rankings when they're number 37 knocking out Fiontech
  88. on hardcourts or somebody beating Koko Goth because Koko Goth has an off day serving and they take advantage of that.
  89. Like, every single match is a contest. I mean, there's no there's no easy matches
  90. in in women's tennis anymore. There aren't very many easy matches in men's tennis. I think the only thing that's
  91. keeping the possibility of a top two or a dominant top player is just the structure of tennis that you don't have
  92. to win 58% of points to be dominant. You got to consistently win like 53 and a half%.
  93. >> So, if you can figure out how to do that um or even 52% and be better in the clutch. If you can figure out how to do
  94. that against a stronger field, then you'll still be dominant. I mean, not to say that's easy. That's not easy at all.
  95. But, uh but that's all you have to do. If if you if you had to win 58% then I think we would see Yeah, we would see
  96. that the that strength at the top start to weaken. >> Audi, why don't you jump in here?
  97. >> Yeah, I mean the observation of course that the field always gets better is true, but really
  98. that's an average observation. The extreme values um can have an enormous amount of variability and that's what
  99. we're discussing. And so it's not um so it's it's so what you're talking about is the difference between one and two
  100. and three, four, five, six, seven, not between what not what the whole average field is doing which can can continue to
  101. elevate yet you can still not have um elevation at the extremes. That's that's that's a kind of a different
  102. mathematical question that it behaves differently mathematically. So the and tennis is actually an interesting sport
  103. because it's one of the few one of the sports that has huge numbers of what I would call ladders of of of levels. So
  104. uh being on two different levels of the ladder means you you consistently beat one level below it. In in a sport like
  105. baseball, there aren't very many ladders. I mean obviously there are differences, but any even the worst
  106. team, we talked about this last week, even the worst team could be the best team on any given day. It's not even uh
  107. it's not it's not even that lopsided. But in tennis you go from like one to what what 20 or what rank? I mean
  108. typically I mean you right now we have the top two beating three four five with nearly nearly 90% probability and that
  109. continues to shift all the way down. You don't you have these you know a 15 I mean I it's not an it's really like an
  110. average but number the the fifth best player will beat the 10th place best player pretty handily. Um at least we're
  111. seeing that in >> that's just not that's not true though. I stop you there. You're absolutely
  112. right about one two against number five. >> The number five beats what number with
  113. what consistency? Like the same the same one two beats five at some consistency and five has to play X to have the same
  114. dominance. >> I see. >> Okay, so I'm looking at my ELO ratings now. Alcarz is 2270. Taylor Fritz is
  115. number five at 2030. So there's a 240 point gap between number one and number five. go down 240 from a 2030. 2030 and
  116. you're at 1790. Is my math right on that? >> Yep. >> So, for the same gap, 1790, scroll down.
  117. Scroll down. You get down, you're out of the top 50 now. Um, you're down to 53 or
  118. 54. That's So, anybody in the top 50 has a better chance of beating number five than number five Taylor Fritz has of
  119. beating number one. And is that the kind of difference we typically see with a with a one, two,
  120. three compared to five or this is extraordinary? I think so. >> Yeah. >> No, I think that's I think that's pretty
  121. typical. I mean, you there have been times where one through five have been more tightly clustered like in the big
  122. four plus Vanka era. Maybe there was a couple years where that was the case, but no, I think that's um that's pretty
  123. close. >> This is an interesting general topic, Audi. We've talked about it here and
  124. there, but it's it's an interaction between the distribution of quality and the and the and the sport, the game
  125. design of the sport itself. >> And that combination gives you these changes and it really says a lot about
  126. what we should expect. Let me ask a different kind of question. >> There's a lot of points in tennis,
  127. right? So, um it's hard to it's what's actually kind of incredible that I'm surprised about is that five takes 50 to
  128. get to get that gap. By the way, I think Jeff, you could ask Jeff the same question, by the way, Audi, but say not
  129. for the majors, but how would that change potentially for shorter matches like the Masters 1000, which are best of
  130. three? Well, the So, the the numbers I gave you are for best of three, but I think the ELO stratification is the
  131. same. It's just the the uh the probabilities those work out to. So, let's see. 240 should be
  132. >> it'll shift both of them but it'll shift them the same way. It'll sit from the
  133. same amount is what you're suggesting. >> Yeah. >> The conversion of the delta into a
  134. probability is going to have a different constant if it's a shorter match. So that's what's
  135. >> that's my point. Right. Exactly. That was my question is that but I think audience by design I mean that is you're
  136. right or not by that is a design. Longer matches favor the better player. >> Oh yeah. So Jeff, you've been writing I
  137. think you know pushing 15 years now. Tennis analytics has advanced a lot in that stretch of time. How would what
  138. would you say is the way it's affected the game if it's affected the game? So if someone watched the US Open this next
  139. couple of weeks and they hadn't watched tennis in 10 or 15 years and they remembered what style of play they saw
  140. 10 or 15 years ago, would they see differences? Do has the analytics changed the game? Do you think in some
  141. way? >> Um, yes and no. And I think what it has what it has changed for players and
  142. coaches is the awareness that the average point is a short point. Um, there were lots of short points before.
  143. I mean, if you go back 50 years, you have a tour full of servant volers. Even a lot of successful women were serving
  144. volleying. Um, which you virtually never see now. So, those were very short points. lots of serves, aces winning the
  145. points, returns not coming back, first volleys winning the point. I don't know what the average point point length is,
  146. but it's like three and a half strokes even back then. Um, still now it's three to four strokes is your typical point.
  147. Now, that's pretty much always been true. If we go back 20 years outside of the time frame you suggest, you get a
  148. lot of big servers. You have like Richard Krychek and Greg Greg Rosski and Mark Filipus and those guys who are who
  149. are giving you short points because that's just the game they played and it worked. Um what you have now instead is
  150. everyone is aware of the fact that even if you don't have like the Mark Philipus
  151. Scut serve that you should be playing with that in mind. You should be setting up your serve for a plus one. You on the
  152. women's side there's a huge shift towards um swinging big on the return just taking your chances hitting a big
  153. return and maybe ending the point there. Uh so what it has done statistically hasn't really shortened points so much
  154. as it h the game has selected for players who will who are always looking to end the point if you're that's one of
  155. the big flaws for Alexander Zerv is he's very good at hanging in long points maybe as good as anybody else on tour.
  156. He can keep himself alive. He can make you a little uncomfortable and he he'll give you these highlight reel like 4050
  157. shot rallies and you know what a 40 or 50 shot rally gets you? it gets you one point and then you're gassed after that.
  158. Like it's it's not worth it. And anyway, I I wrote something about this earlier this year that you do that and you still
  159. don't have a great chance of winning. The very best players at long rallies win like maybe twothirds of long
  160. rallies. So if you're, you know, Alexander Verv playing Riley Opelka, monster server, bad groundstroke guy,
  161. Riley Opela is still going to win one out of three of those points. So that's it's not the strategy. It's not a
  162. strategy that wins tennis matches. and it wasn't ever dominant, but it was always present in that you'd find
  163. players who who played with an eye on stretching out points, defense, and that's it's not gone, but especially on
  164. hard courts, it's basically gone. >> Okay, Jeff, I was in I happened to be in France when Michael Chang had his big
  165. French Open blow up in like 1989 or whatever that was, and he's the first person that comes to mind. It's just
  166. kind of the long rally, get the ball back, he's not going to win any big shots, but he's going to stay on the
  167. court forever. But that was 1989, and even that was a kind of a short moment in time.
  168. >> And that was that was clay court tennis. And if if you watch court tennis now,
  169. you'll see some people who are still playing that way. But it's fascinating to watch even the the grindiest like
  170. small underpowered claycourt guys. They are swinging big. like they'll hit these
  171. spin serves out wide to open up the court and then they just wind up for the biggest forehand they can hit. It won't
  172. usually be a winner because you know these guys are 5 foot nine and they don't hit that hard. It's all just spin
  173. spin spin spin spin but they're trying. Like the goal is still the same. Shorten
  174. points, force the guy out wide, create an opening, get it over with. >> Okay. All right. Well, listen, uh Eric,
  175. what what are you thinking about as you go into the US Open and are you going out there this year? You often make it
  176. out to watch a little tennis. Um, I' I'd be curious to hear any specific storylines you're curious about.
  177. >> Well, I am going next week to the US Open. I'm going on Wednesday, which is Wednesday evening, which is men's and
  178. women's quarterfinal, which should be interesting. Um, but you know, Jeeoff, I'd love your thoughts on for some
  179. reason, at least at these rounds, I find the women's game much more interesting.
  180. I mean, the match, I'm sure you watched it last night. The match between Venus Williams and Mukova was incredible. I
  181. mean, the fact that Venus played that well at 45. Um, I mean, in that second set, she looked great. How do you think
  182. about the women's game right now where I could literally list certainly the top seven or eight players I could list at
  183. least seven or eight players that could win it on the women's side and it might be even more than that if you include
  184. Andre Evva you know certainly Rabbakina can win certainly the big three of Sabalena Goff and Swante I mean there's
  185. at least five six seven eight 10 players that could win it how it's the women's game that's got me much more because of
  186. the variety and diversity how do you think about it. >> Yeah, I I think the women's game has a
  187. reputation for that variety and diversity. I'm not sure whether I buy that narrative anymore. I don't disagree
  188. with your main point that it's more interesting game. Uh like I was just uh talking about with the in the broader
  189. trend, points are getting shorter. Someone like Mukaba is super interesting. She can play an allcourt
  190. game. She can grind it out from the baseline. She can do a lot of different things. She is a dying breed. I think uh
  191. more likely you have you're going to see somebody who's sort of a mini Sabalanka
  192. um who will swing big on return, hit big serves. There's a a lot of women like that. Um I mean one
  193. >> Anna Samova as Anna Samova as an example. >> Anna Samova is a great example. Yeah,
  194. huge hitter. I mean she's a little more interesting in the sense that she doesn't if you saw her walking down the
  195. street you wouldn't think, oh she scares me the way that Sabalena might. Uh but yeah, she hits a Oapeno. I mean there's
  196. lot I mean there's lots of these big hitter on every ball. >> Yep. Absolutely. Um so the so there's
  197. variety in the sense that there's some women like that and there's women who aren't quite as extreme. I mean
  198. certainly Shantek balls in that category. Uh but yeah I mean I think there's it's less likely that the serve
  199. itself is going to end the point. It's it's more likely you're going to have a player who's who's going to end it on
  200. the second ball. You don't see that as much in men's tennis. Whereas with people like Osta Peno or Anosimova that
  201. you mentioned, you are going to see players who who are really geared to ending the point or forcing the issue on
  202. the second ball. Uh and then yeah, you get you get the the Mukova, someone like Koko Goff can rally with the best of
  203. them. Shriant can rally with best of them. So there's certainly some some diversity there. What you're never going
  204. to see like you'll see in the men's game is you two people who are just ace ace ace ace ace. And that's always been the
  205. knock on the men's game even if it wasn't true of everybody. uh you won't get a match like that. So, you're spared
  206. that in the quarterfinals. Uh you just might get a lot of return winners, which I'd argue maybe not much more
  207. interesting, but uh but it is a different strategy. >> Let me ask a question. What role do you
  208. think it's a follow on Kate's previous question, what role do you think analytics plays in tennis? And here's
  209. what I mean. Like, I don't need advanced analytics to go maybe I should hit more
  210. balls to Federer's backhand. Like, they knew that back then. And I don't need advanced analytics and ball tracking to
  211. know that. So let's call it, you know, from a statistical perspective, let's assume that they could assess main
  212. effects like, wow, the first serve really matters. Wow, this person's got a weaker backhand. Wow, let's try to, you
  213. know, hit more slices. This person has trouble getting the low ball. Let's assume all of that was known even in the
  214. McEnroe, Borg, Connor's days and all that. What impact do you think analytics has had once we take away I'll call it
  215. the main effects? Yeah, those that's a good point. I'm I am quite skeptical over the of the
  216. overall influence of analytics. I find it all very interesting from a a postfacto kind of perspective. But but
  217. yeah, if I if I were a coach, there would be a lot of information I would not pass on to the on to players. And
  218. for as long as I've been doing this, I' I've been struck by how little coaches tell to players when they have the
  219. opportunity. There was a span of time in the women's game where they would do encore coaching by having the the coach
  220. come down and and talk to the player uh on the sideline. So you'd get some insight into that and they'd come down
  221. with, you know, two really basic points and like you say, everybody knows hit to
  222. Feder's backhand, but the coach would come down and say, you know, just focus on getting your serve deep, hit to their
  223. backhand. Like are you serious? Like that I heard that stuff when I was getting coached when I was what, like 13
  224. years old. Is this really >> what it is? But I mean, one perspective on that is tennis is hard. I mean, it's
  225. all coming at you fast. You don't have a lot of time on every ball to sit there and think like you're not like a
  226. basketball defender who's thinking like how can I edge this guy, you know, one foot to the left or into this zone or
  227. that zone. Like that would be nice if you could do that. But if you're facing a 120 mph serve in the corner, you're
  228. not thinking how do I edge her back into that corner. You're thinking, how the heck am I going to put this in play? So
  229. I think that's the issue with virtually ev every question like that. Some of it you can build into training and I think
  230. that's what coaches do is they they structure their training around analytical insights but in match I think
  231. you you you fight with the tools you come in with. >> Uh we want to go to Audi but real quick
  232. followup that I was going to go that direction. The self scouting has to be a part of it right because even if you
  233. knew you we've heard we've heard this across sports actually. Even if you knew that you needed to, you know, rotate
  234. your hips a little bit more when you're swinging a baseball bat, to be able to be told precisely where you are and
  235. where the average person is and where the best people are, that really helps on the coaching side. It's got it must
  236. be the case that in tennis there's that kind of self scouting and say, "Well, you're much stronger in this part of the
  237. court than that, or this stroke is better than that, just for your own development in the training regimen."
  238. And then Audi's going to jump in here. >> Yeah, absolutely. And and yeah, I think
  239. that's where most of it's happening like I say on the on the coaching side and and more self- scouting because yeah,
  240. you have maybe maybe one full day to prepare for an opponent that your your coach can can scout a player and prepare
  241. a game plan. Sometimes not even a full day, maybe not even a chance to practice with that in mind. So I mean the self
  242. scouting is certainly the the biggest place where there's an opportunity to exploit.
  243. >> So sometimes even the most obvious things are missed. So, for example, like in baseball, analytics told told um most
  244. base dealers to cut it to don't do it. It was negative. Um and and that only certain players should do it into
  245. certain times. We're undoing that slightly because of the way they've changed the rules. Um it also showed
  246. people that they're standing in the wrong spot. For 100 years, they stood in the wrong spot and and and the fielders
  247. are now standing in the wrong spot and the correct spot and it's just just changed the game. So going back to
  248. tennis, I've had I run um research seminars atmies over the summer and every now and then a student wants to do
  249. a tennis project and they they ask questions and it most of those have fallen down pretty hard because it's
  250. hard to get the data and it's and the analysis is hard. But I I'll I'll throw out one of them which I wonder whether
  251. or not um analytics could potentially answer if you had the right data. So there's obviously a there's some
  252. trade-off between first serve um and second serve max velocity, right? Um and has that been analyzed? Like if you're
  253. if you treat your second serve like it's a first serve, obviously giving up more
  254. double faults, but maybe getting more second serve aces, what's the optimum? that's some seems to be something that
  255. that is a hard question that that I would imagine isn't known or would take some serious analytics to solve. Um is
  256. that a problem that is worth considering because I have some students trying to do this couldn't actually get the good
  257. data but but um that would be like a problem that I would imagine could potentially have some impact or no?
  258. >> Well, there's the the yeah the I mean the simplest version of that question is
  259. should players hit two first serves? Um, and that question has that that question
  260. has an answer and the answer is no. Um, it's it's it's not a huge difference to to the typical uh typical approach, but
  261. you you'd lose maybe like 1% or one and a half% of the points you win if you >> Let me ask a question, Jeeoff. Would you
  262. add variance, which could be good for the weaker player? So, you lose mean but gain variance. And I want to gain
  263. variance. >> Um, you gain double faults. That's the problem. I mean, aces. >> Yeah, you gain aces and you gain double
  264. foil. This is the if you're if you're if the if you're the severe underdog, and we've just learned from from our from
  265. our discussion that most players are severe underdogs, um they've got to take chances, which means they're going to
  266. lose badly a lot more often. Um but they might also be more competitive a little
  267. bit more often, too. Yeah, I think I think that's why you see players swinging away on return because
  268. where you want variance is on return. On the serve, at least in the men's game, especially true in the women's game, but
  269. more so in the men's game, even if you're playing Alcarez or center, if you're a pretty good player, you're
  270. going to hold serve most of the time. >> Um, that's not your concern. You know, you can have a you can have a good day
  271. and you're going to hold serve every single game against Senator Alice. You'll still probably lose in the tie
  272. breaks, but you will you could you'll hold serve most of the time on the return. That's where you want to add
  273. variance. If the classic example is Dustin Brown knocking out Raphael Nadal I think 10 years ago now. I mean he he
  274. just went went crazy on the return. Uh he I mean Chip in charge came in behind everything he could hit big like and it
  275. worked. It probably n out of 10 times. This is a great this a great analytics point which is you know you focus your
  276. efforts and ROI on the dimensions that matter and even you know it's the problem that Fritz has against Alcarass
  277. isn't holding serve it's just that he's not going to get breakings he's not going to break the serve that often and
  278. so you might as well add the variance to the dimension where you have more to gain that's a great point great general
  279. business point let me just comment >> Jeff you're about to make some point nine out of 10 times what they're going
  280. to be humiliated >> it's not going to work Oh yeah, but I mean you are going to be
  281. but that doesn't matter. You're I mean you're going to lose anyway if you if you're like Vit Copa just lost to Yannik
  282. Center one and one and one. I think that that was just a couple hours ago. So So
  283. yeah, that's the alternative. If you go in big with a wacky game plan, then yeah, maybe you will knock out Yanik.
  284. Maybe it's one in a thousand for Capria versus Ser. But yeah, the alternative is
  285. you play your game, you are gone in 80 minutes and you won three whole games in in three sets. So yeah, I mean that's
  286. not that great either. You might look stupid, but if you I mean I'd rather I'd rather win. But to go back to your u
  287. your question auding the serves is I think the hardest thing about that question is knowing how practical it is.
  288. So I mean what I think that presupposes is that a player can have like a first and a half serve.
  289. >> Uh and in in theory, yes. So there's a couple researchers whose names are escaping me at the moment who have
  290. looked at this at least from a purely theoretical perspective. They looked at every match and what they what they
  291. basically tried to do was figure out how effective each player serve was based on
  292. how hard they were hitting it in that match. So they would say, you know, when when they were hitting at 123, they
  293. would win 73%. 122 they would win, you know, whatever percent and work out a curve based on that relationship. So
  294. they could say, you know, we don't want to go all first serves, but if we could go first serve and we could go 1.7
  295. serve, then that's your optimum. So you can you can work it out mathematically, but what I don't know and what I what I
  296. doubt, frankly, is that you can take that information to Taylor Fritz and say, "Okay, now give me your 1.7 serve."
  297. >> He doesn't know what that is. He's been he's been hitting the same first and second serves for over a decade of his
  298. life. He's perfected those deliveries. So, so let me let me counter that though. Taking another page from
  299. baseball is they have these high uh speed cameras and immediate feedback. I can imagine and they've used this to to
  300. essentially tailor design pitches for individuals. I can imagine if you sat with the with the player and say, "Okay,
  301. your first serve is 125, right? And your second serve is I don't know what the right number is. Uh I don't even know
  302. what it is. 80. >> Say 105. >> 100 105. I want to develop a 115 and we're going to sit there with the
  303. equipment until you can do it. And and is that is that is that an outrageous proposition? I mean, or or is it with
  304. with the >> Yeah, >> I would say in the state world of Tennessee that >> I keep thinking of that Andre Agassi. I
  305. don't know if it's commercial or show where it's him versus Feder and he goes, "Now I'm going to give you a 113. Now
  306. I'm going to give you a 109." And Agassi is like hitting the gun on every single
  307. number he just said. Like he knows what a 113 is. He knows how hard to hit. Now maybe that's Agassi just fooling around
  308. or cuz he's Andre Agassi and you know Taylor Fritz ain't Andre Agassy. >> Yeah. I mean there's only one Andre
  309. Agassi for sure. I would doubt even Federer could do that and Federer would be the second guy I'd think of who might
  310. be able to do that. Um it would be a pretty out there thing to suggest to a player. Um,
  311. and >> but it's a it's a neat idea because it adopts probably the biggest revolution
  312. we've seen in baseball in the last five or six years. It's player development using a lot of technology and it's
  313. transformed some players careers. Now, one question might be whether it's valuable enough to be worth the effort,
  314. but it's a neat hypothesis. borrowing from another sport into into this sport >> would be the
  315. >> absolutely I mean I I would love to know that someone was out there trying it. Uh
  316. and maybe maybe it just needs to take a little more time because I think when players are really developing es
  317. especially well I'm not sure whether I'm going to pick a gender on that but when players
  318. are really developing their adult game there I mean they're they're 12 or 13 years old. I mean there are exceptions
  319. to that rule but they're figuring things out when they're pretty small. So even prospects we're seeing now like they
  320. >> their game has been pretty much in place for a long time. They're not going to
  321. >> their tennis schedule doesn't allow them to take 6 months and you know work out
  322. their 113 serve >> uh the way that a baseball player could or they're certainly not going to take a
  323. year off tour because you know they got cut the way that a baseball player might.
  324. >> So it might and we might see it when you know the developmental period catches up
  325. with the uh with the length of time we've known this stuff. We're gonna need to let Jeff go. Eric is
  326. asking for one more question. Eric, is it gonna be a quick one? Can you jump in here?
  327. >> It is. It's a quick question. So, Jeeoff, I would also imagine that the answer has to be what was called a mix
  328. strategy. And what I mean by that is if I knew your second serve was always 115,
  329. that isn't doing squat either. So now I'd have to have the first serve. And sometimes I hit it 105 in the corner.
  330. Sometimes they hit it 115 cuz if everybody knew Jeff Sackman was the 125 115 guy, they can return 115. So it
  331. would have to be I mean there'd have to be a mixture no matter what you do. >> Yeah. And I mean to some extent there
  332. already is. I mean I I was simplifying to say that you know Taylor Fritz has a first serve and a second serve. Taylor
  333. Fritz can hit a whole ton of serves and they are all pretty consistent and they're all pretty reliable but it's a
  334. it is still a limited number. So I mean it it might be four different first serves and the real magic comes from the
  335. guys like Federer or Ashardy who can completely disguise them. So it's like a pitcher throwing four different pitchers
  336. out of the same arm slot. >> Uh but but that's rare and even even then that that's enough variety. I mean,
  337. and going back to tennis just being freaking hard if you're facing Taylor Fritz from the line, then if if your
  338. opport your options are, you know, 125 that way, 118 that way, 106 with slice that way. I mean, good luck, man. We we
  339. don't need much strategy to just to say you're probably not breaking that guy today,
  340. >> right? All right, Jeff. Thanks. Always a always a pleasure to talk to you. um
  341. wish you the best with the work that you're doing and wish you um good fun for the next couple weeks with the with
  342. the US Open. >> Thanks very much. Thanks for having me, guys. >> Absolutely. Jeff Sackman, the best in
  343. the business in tennis analytics. You can read his stuff. His blog is called Heavy Top Spin and you can find it at
  344. Tennis Abstract. Tennis Abstract is an organization that he founded. Jeff Sackman. That has been the first half of
  345. Wharton Rainbow. Come back and join us after the break for the second half. Welcome back. Welcome back to Wharton
  346. Moneyball. Welcome back to the second half of this week's show. Second half of a full hour of sports analytics here on
  347. the Wharton podcast network. This is Kade Massie hosting this week along with Eric Bradlo and Audi Winer, two
  348. longstanding co-hosts and colleagues of mine. Shane Jensen is out this week. Shane is out doing Shane things here in
  349. late August. We are just off the line with Jeff Sackman. Always a pleasure to talk to Jeff. It's as much of a pleasure
  350. to read him. If you have any interest in sports analytics, you should be looking
  351. at his work on tennis analytics. It's as good as there is and it has been. He was
  352. kind he was one of the first real sharp quants in tennis. Guys, late summer, um,
  353. we've got football dead ahead. We've got college football week one, a full slate.
  354. We'll talk a little bit about that. And then we're going to have an overtime segment, an extra segment with Ralph
  355. Russo to talk in more depth on college football after this regularly scheduled show. We've got some other big stuff
  356. going on though. Golf. We've been talking golf off and on this summer. It's a writer cup year, which makes it
  357. all a little more interesting. And then we've just come through the I Eric, you have to remind me what they call these
  358. things. The the FedEx or whatever it is these days. >> FedEx Cup. Y >> the the FedEx Cup. But but the tour
  359. championship, it's really it's not a major, but it's one of the bigger non- majors. And amazingly and finally, the
  360. long national nightmare, long international nightmare is over over Tommy Fleetwood won a PGA event. Eric,
  361. were you watching this thing? This was the thing that they cut down to 30 golfers. The last round is the last
  362. tournament is just 30 golfers. Fleetwood got the lead, I think, on day three and
  363. then he closed the day on closed the deal on day four. >> Yeah, I mean, I watched almost all of
  364. it. Um, I thought it was great sports, great TV. Um, the good news is, you know, all the golfers and so, you know,
  365. as you said, it is the top 30 and, uh, it was a tough course, an interesting course. Um, and the thing that's
  366. interesting is maybe this is, you know, it would be interesting to talk or, you know, maybe I'll message something
  367. towards Rufus because this is one of those situations where I felt like if you looked at Tommy Fleetwood's, whether
  368. it's an ELO rating or world ranking, he was probably his chances of winning were
  369. probably downgraded too much because, well, he had only come in second seven times in the last year. All right, find
  370. me another golfer other than Sheffler that's had as many top five finishes as Tommy Fleewood. So, because he didn't
  371. get the number one, all of a sudden, we're downgrading him so much. I mean, to me, it was almost not certain. It's
  372. never certain in golf, but I'm not surprised he was in the top five. And if he's in the top five, why can't he win
  373. it? And so I I almost feel it was like an outcome bias because he hadn't won even though his world ranking was so
  374. high and he was in good form that all of a sudden he's not winning. >> Well, that's a that's a that's great.
  375. That's a great question whether people overb the the story. The narrative was he can't get it done. But let's be clear
  376. about a couple of the stats right now. Now this is post tournament, but it wouldn't have been that different before
  377. the tournament. Data Golf, which has the most predictive publicly available world
  378. rankings, much better for predicting performance than the world golf rankings. Data Golf has him number three
  379. in the world. All right, so just behind Rory, who's obviously just behind Shuffer, a stroke behind Shuffler. Um,
  380. the other thing is he has 30 career top fives on the PGA without a win before this tournament, which is the most in
  381. 100 years. And so that's where the narrative has traction and you're questioning whether okay fine but did it
  382. get overb essentially. And here's my empirical question for y'all. Do y'all think we could model
  383. whether someone plays better with the lead after having won a tournament than before having won a tournament or do you
  384. think there's not enough data to do so? This is like career level modeling as opposed to you know any given
  385. tournament. Do you think do you think we could observe a difference? Can we test
  386. and if there is a difference, find it that they perform better or differently with a lead after having ever clinched a
  387. tournament? >> Yes, I do. I mean, but it depends how far you're willing to assume
  388. stationarity. And I mean by, you know, there's basically almost a golf tourn let's say 40 weeks of the year and then
  389. let's say we take the last 8 to 10 years of golf tournaments. So now there's 300
  390. and something observations where we've had a winner. And again, if you only want to model the probability of
  391. winning, that's different. We could also say, does the person perform better, which is, you know, their world golf
  392. ranking or their, you know, their data golf ranking would have been the person should have come in seventh. Like it
  393. could be exceedences of their ranking. We don't have to look just at do they win more often. Do they play better once
  394. they've won? Is it like a change point model kind of thing? But I think the answer is yes. I think there's enough
  395. data. If let me just say though this is probably your all other point and Audi will I'm sure be happy to jump in on
  396. this the effect size is probably smallalish. So your question is it's not can we model it of course we can model
  397. it but is the effect big enough that we'll see it >> right I mean this goes Audi's one of
  398. Audi's great lines early in our show and then we kind of learned it is that he's
  399. not saying that the effect doesn't exist it's just too small to observe. So, he's
  400. talking about a clubhouse effect, some momentum. Like, sometimes these things might be there, but they're just too
  401. small to this. >> I wasn't even thinking this is momentum, but sure. >> Since we're on golf, guys, since we're
  402. on golf, it's time to point out that even something which we know is important like putting is nevertheless
  403. the effect is too small to to I would say know with strong statistical confidence who is better and who's
  404. worse. That's an that's an in golf even something that we can measure is is uh nevertheless doesn't vary that much
  405. among the players. So when you get to Fleetwood in particular and you look at those 30 tournaments, what did he what
  406. did he come short in? I mean what was I mean what aspect of his game because I can imagine someone not closing because
  407. you know putting just didn't come through. >> I love it. That's great. So this so we I
  408. don't know how much we've talked about this. We need to do a full segment on it, but Audi has some research just over
  409. the summer, I think, finally. >> Yeah. >> How random putting is and therefore how
  410. difficult it is to say some guys are actually better or worse putters. And I think I mean, you could give us a quick
  411. empirical observation. It's some very small number of guys that you can reliably say are better.
  412. >> Yeah. So what so what happened with with putting is that you get we get we did
  413. what's called empirical bay shrinkage which doesn't impose um a knowledge of a standard deviation on talent but doesn't
  414. we did impose a normal distribution on the distribution of talent um which we could we could we could argue about
  415. right particularly the tales of that distribution but what ends up happening is that we do have in any given season
  416. we we do have uh players who putt better and butt worse but when we do our shrinkage or empirical based shrinkage
  417. those differences get really small and among the golfers in any given you know two or 30 hund of them we do what's
  418. called an FDR which was uh we essentially try to control the number of falsely discovered Good.

Brief Summary

Jeff Sackman discusses tennis analytics, the US Open, and player performance trends in men's and women's tennis.

Key points

  • Tennis Analytics with Jeff Sackman. Kade Massie and Eric Bradlo welcome tennis analytics expert Jeff Sackman to discuss the upcoming US Open and current player dynamics.
  • Dominance of Young Players. Jeff Sackman reveals shocking analytics showing the dominance of Yannik Sinner and Carlos Alcaraz in men's tennis.
  • Venus Williams' Remarkable Performance. At 45, Venus Williams showcased an incredible performance that left fans in awe.
  • The Women's Game's Diversity. The discussion highlights the increasing variety and competitiveness in women's tennis.
  • Analytics in Tennis. A debate on the role of analytics in tennis and its influence on player performance.
  • Tommy Fleetwood's Breakthrough Win. After numerous near-wins, Tommy Fleetwood finally clinches a PGA event victory.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes