Marketplace Dignity Is Transforming Engagement Across Customer Journey

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW Wharton’s Cait Lamberton talks about her new book, Marketplace Dignity: Transforming How We Engage with Customers Across Their Journey, which explains why customers want firms to treat them with respect and dignity above anything else. This episode is part of the “Meet the Authors” series. Learn more about Lamberton's book: https://whr.tn/4bJGcJR

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect.

#marketing #customerjourney #customerfeedback #consumerbehavior ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Cait Lamberton: Dignity always comes in second. It comes in second to the objective value that you get from your interaction with a
  2. firm. But what falls way down the list are the things that we talk about all the time, like whether the firm is sustainable,
  3. whether the firm aligns with my political values. Dan Loney: Welcome to The Ripple Effect,
  4. the podcast that takes you on a journey through the minds of Wharton faculty. I'm your host,
  5. Dan Loney. And in each episode, we'll be diving deep into the inspiration behind the groundbreaking research that
  6. Wharton professors have conducted, and exploring how their findings resonate with the world today. Well, it seems like
  7. brands are in a bit of a unique time right now, where they're being called on by their consumers, and in many cases
  8. the public at large, to make a positive impact on society. Not that they haven't done it before, but maybe even more so
  9. now here in this time and age. But according to a new book, co-authored by our next guest, companies may not truly
  10. understand about how to go about in that process. Great to be joined here by Cait Lamberton, who's a Professor of Marketing
  11. here at the Wharton School. The book, by the way, is titled <i>Marketplace Dignity: Transforming How We Engage With</i>
  12. <i>Customers Across Their Journey</i>, which by the way, is published by Wharton School Press. Cait, great to talk to you. Thanks
  13. very much for joining us today. So happy to be here. I guess let's start out with what is happening, and why it's
  14. happening, and why this issue of marketplace dignity is so important right now. There are a lot of large-scale factors that make this
  15. particularly salient to people. So we know that when people, for example, feel that their choice is constrained in the
  16. marketplace, they're going to do everything they can to get it back. If they feel that they are not treated fairly compared to
  17. others, they're going to do everything they can to restore that. And because the marketplace is so transparent
  18. right now, it's easy to know whether somebody is getting something better than you. And the likelihood is they're gonna
  19. brag about it on social media. So people become very sensitive to disparate treatment, to a loss of agency, and perhaps even to a
  20. loss of voice, because we live in a marketplace where now everyone has a megaphone. If everyone has a megaphone, you're just
  21. shouting with everyone else. And so I'm sure we'll talk about this later. But when those three things are threatened, when your
  22. agency and your voice and your sense of fairness are threatened, it's absolutely reasonable to want to restore
  23. them. - And so how much— - Yeah, go ahead. How much of a challenge is it for companies right now to be
  24. able to kind of be in this mix? Because I would think there are elements of this that they've probably dealt with in the past.
  25. But having all of them together kind of adds to the— adds to the pressure that they have to deal with.
  26. Yeah. I think it is a uniquely challenging time in some senses, but they also have new tools to address them, if they want to do
  27. it. And I think— you know, it's interesting. If you— if you Google something like "Which companies treat— treat their
  28. employees or the customers with dignity," you'll find a lot of reports about single issues. So they'll say, "Okay, this is a
  29. company that supports people in the LGBTQ community." "This is a company that is, you know, a strong ally for another group."
  30. "This is a company that affirms older employees." But as a systematic approach, I don't think— I don't think we actually
  31. see that very often. So they have— you have multi-level threats to dignity, but then they tend to have these sort of
  32. ad hoc responses. And I think that they do have— yes, it's a unique challenge. But there's also a unique set of
  33. opportunities that they can take advantage of. You talked about that megaphone that— that a lot of consumers
  34. have. I'm guessing part of that takes shape in the form of social media, but obviously other platforms that are out
  35. there as well. Yeah, I mean, I think social media is the dominant platform right now. But that doesn't mean that consumers don't sometimes
  36. at least feel empowered to grab the megaphone in person, to— to take the attention that they want to. And it's— again, it's a
  37. fundamental human need to feel heard and seen. And the more frustrated people become, the more they're going to find a way
  38. to— to force you to see them and force you to hear them. Is this becoming kind of a "must- have" more so than a "potentially-
  39. have" for a lot of companies? That you have to have this thought process, this kind of formula in your mix?
  40. I think that if they don't, they— they're in danger. And I think they're missing out on a differentiator. And to the extent
  41. that any differentiator is a "must have", then yes. And I— I actually think it's far more important than, for example,
  42. being in the right place on social issues. Those things are going to move around. That's going to continually change. And
  43. a company that is chasing whatever's popular socially is gonna have a hard time. But what we argue in the book is that
  44. this is a matter of how you structure the experience. And it's not just about being nice, and it's not just about being
  45. liberal or conservative or somewhere in the middle. It's just about the decisions you make in the architecture of your
  46. experience. And those are— those are— you know, you're gonna make the decisions anyway. It's a matter of whether you make them
  47. taking dignity into account or not. What we found in some data is that we asked consumers to rank the importance of different
  48. things that they can experience in their interactions with a firm. Dignity always comes in second. It comes in second to
  49. the objective value that you get from your interaction with a firm. But what falls way down the list are the things that we
  50. talk about all the time, like whether the firm is sustainable, whether the firm aligns with my political values. What's second is
  51. whether I'm treated with respect, and that comes up in the data over and over and over again.
  52. And so for the company, I guess, because the mindset of each individual consumer can be different, a lot of the
  53. companies have to be prepared for a variety of options along the way, don't they, as well?
  54. Well, there's more uniformity on some of this than you might think. I think that— that idiosyncratic individual preferences take us
  55. back to things like political ideology, or social issues. And that's— that is— that's a whole different topic that's quite
  56. challenging to handle in and of itself. But what we find in our data is that those three things, everybody values them. In
  57. different contexts, to a different extent. But people want to feel some control over what's happening to them. And that's
  58. pretty universal. They like to make choices. Now, of course, you have to think about how to craft that so that people make
  59. choices that are helpful. But everybody likes— nobody likes to feel trapped. No one likes feeling trapped. It's just not—
  60. it doesn't happen. People like to feel seen and heard, or the converse of that is they like to choose when to be seen and
  61. heard. - Right. That's a universal preference. And— and we learn— one of the earliest things we learned developmentally is that
  62. we like things to be fair. You know, "That kid has a toy, and I don't have a toy. And that's not fair. And I'm not okay with it."
  63. So, in a way, I think we would argue that designing for dignity is a much safer approach than, "Let's give everyone exactly what
  64. they want, and try to be all things to all people." You're not going to get that right. But I think you can get this right at
  65. a scalable level. But off of what you mentioned a moment ago, that's why the component of this being the entire journey of a consumer
  66. plays so much into the process here, doesn't it? It does. Because if you only do it in one part, you look very
  67. inauthentic. Right? So, "Oh, congratulations, you're— you're gonna allow a lot of dignity before the consumer makes a
  68. decision." So they come into your store and you do something really respectful, like give them decompression space, don't
  69. overload them with pushy sales tactics. They purchase, everyone's happy, they feel recognized. And that after the
  70. fact, you bombard them with with information, and you don't let them disengage from you. You know, we all know these stories
  71. of these subscriptions you can't get out of without 50 clicks. Okay, so you respected dignity before. And then afterwards, you
  72. want to retain them so badly that you take away agency, you know, and you— and you don't listen to them anymore, as far
  73. as what their preferences are. And if you do that, you kind of— you're not telling the whole story. And consumers will anchor
  74. on that part where you blew it. So it has— ideally, you think about it all the way through the process.
  75. And this is also coming at a time where it seems like the component of performance in a company is even more heightened,
  76. more focused on by firms so that it feels like there's a little bit of a balancing act, kind of off of what you said there, that
  77. you don't want to overdo it with the consumer. You want to hit that— that right level of connection and dignity so that
  78. you can have a great relationship back and forth. Yeah, and I think it's— it's not— not as hard as people might
  79. think it is. What we find is even little small amounts of choice are— they mean something to consumers. They notice even a
  80. change in the language that you use. It doesn't necessarily have to cost a lot more. So one of the companies that I worked with
  81. on this topic a few years ago, who shall remain nameless, was very concerned that this was just expensive. This was, you
  82. know, "Okay, we've got to retrain all of our employees to be nicer." And that's not really the case. It's really about setting
  83. up structures that allow choice and give people voice or allow them privacy along the way. When that structure exists, the
  84. consumer can navigate it. But they're pretty sensitive, again, to small changes. You don't need to rebuild your entire business
  85. necessarily. You just need to be thoughtful about each piece of it. I was gonna ask you whether or not there's a permanence to this
  86. concept that they have, or whether or not there's a fluidity to it. And it almost seems like maybe there's a
  87. little bit of both that companies have to have in this mix. Yeah, it's funny. If you look at a lot of company websites, they'll—
  88. you konw, especially in healthcare, pharmaceuticals, to a lesser extent some other industries, you're gonna see the word
  89. "dignity". It's gonna come up. They built it into their stated purpose. I think that— and so they— they've taken it on as
  90. something that they permanently want to pursue. But then this— the next step, which is systematically building it into
  91. everything the patient, the physician, the caregiver experiences, that— that is the connection that's only partially
  92. made. Another thing that's fluid about it is that it may have to change across cultures. So we've done some work where we've
  93. looked at, for example, what dignity means for people who are in Nigeria, as opposed to people who are in India, as opposed
  94. to people who are in the United States. And in India and the US, it's fairly similar. It
  95. has a lot to do with being seen and heard. And having agency. You see those things come up over and over again. Our Nigerian
  96. respondents, though, talked a lot more about being treated fairly as part of a group, because their group identity was
  97. extremely important. We also found that Indian— or, I'm sorry, consumers in the US were, of the three groups, least sensitive to
  98. the affirmation of dignity. And if you affirm their dignity, in some cases, they actually think— they actually feel like, "Okay,
  99. if you— if you respect me, I'm going to ask for even more from you." Which, you know, could be an opportunity for firms to grow
  100. too. But our consumers from other regions sometimes said, "If you respect me, I might give you some grace, if I don't get
  101. everything I want." So there's a substitute and a complement relationship that may be fluid across different kinds of
  102. markets. - And so there's probably also kind of multiple reactions that you will
  103. get from the consumer. In certain cases, if you don't deliver, there are going to be some consumers that are going to
  104. be mad. They'll go away from the company. You know, they'll have a big negative impact. But as you said, some may have a little
  105. bit of anger or angst towards the firm. - Yeah. There can definitely be heterogeneity. What I'll say is, on average, I
  106. don't think you make anything worse. Especially if you— if you incorporate agency. So if you, early on in the process, say to
  107. consumers, "Listen, we can allow you a lot of choice and a lot of control. Or we can— we can, you know, help you out more along
  108. the way? Which would you prefer?" "Oh, look." Now, you know, somebody can say, "Listen, I don't want to think about
  109. everything, I don't want all the choice." And you just simply send them down one pathway, another. Now we may get to a point where
  110. AI will actually be able to tell who are the people who value agency at every step, and who are the people that are happier
  111. to have a more supported experience. But right now, it's also not a hard thing to do to ask. And people tend to be able to
  112. self report this kind of thing. So you talk about the next step in the process and potentially
  113. being around AI. And obviously, we're learning so much about how AI is going to be impacting what we do on a daily, weekly,
  114. monthly basis. I guess most companies are already starting to think about so many things about AI, including this
  115. component as well. - Yeah, there's a big movement that has— that is focused on data dignity. And
  116. these folks are pointing out again that representation, which is one of these three pieces of dignity, also means not
  117. being seen when you don't want to be seen. Which would mean I don't want to be included in that data set that's used to
  118. predict everyone's preferences. Or certainly, we would want our data to be used in ways that we feel good about. You know,
  119. otherwise, what's basically happening is our voice is being co-opted by a firm. And people do not like that experience. So
  120. I think, too, there— there'll be regulations about that, that will be— that will slowly work their way through the courts. But we
  121. do need to be sensitive to the way that consumers are seen and heard. And the extent to which they begin to feel that their
  122. control is— is being eroded by the way that artificial intelligence is used to connect with them. You know, when we
  123. connect with a person, I think we're all very aware that at the end of the day, we get to walk away. But if everywhere we go in
  124. the environment, there's some AI reaching out to us, we lose agency. And so we probably— we're gonna have to learn a lot about
  125. how to— how to use that in a way that doesn't make humans feel as though they're devalued relative to technology.
  126. Okay, thanks very much for your time today. And thanks for joining us here on Ripple Effect Meet the Authors.
  127. - Thank you so much. - Cait Lamberton, Marketing Professor here at Wharton. The book, by the way, again, is titled <i>Marketplace</i>
  128. <i>Dignity: Transforming How We Engage With Customers Across</i> <i>Their Journey</i>. - Thank you for listening to The Ripple Effect.
  129. We hope you found this episode informative and engaging. Don't forget to subscribe and leave us a review so that we can continue
  130. to bring you the best insight from the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Cait Lamberton discusses marketplace dignity and its impact on consumer interactions in her book, emphasizing the need for companies to prioritize dignity.

Key points

  • Marketplace Dignity Explained. Cait Lamberton discusses her book on how companies can engage customers with dignity.
  • The Power of Consumer Voice. Cait Lamberton explains how social media amplifies consumer voices and expectations.
  • Universal Need for Agency. Cait Lamberton emphasizes that consumers universally desire to feel seen and heard.
  • Small Changes Matter. Cait Lamberton discusses how minor adjustments can significantly impact consumer experiences.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes