Understanding America's Master Shipbuilder

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Named one of The Wall Street Journal's top 10 nonfiction books of 2012, A Man and His Ship: America's Greatest Naval Architect and His Quest to Build the SS United States brings William Francis Gibbs' story to life. Wharton legal studies and business ethics professor G. Richard Shell recently sat down with Ujifusa to learn more about what inspired the author to tell Gibbs' story, what led Gibbs to build ships and how the builder's firm became responsible for 70% of all ships built during World War II. 📂 Leadership

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] uh so hi Steve um I'm here with Steve uh uif fusa uh and Steve is the author of a
  2. wonderful book uh called a man and his ship America's greatest naval architect and his quest to build the SS United
  3. States it was named by the Wall Street Journal as one of the top 10 non-fiction books of
  4. 2012 uh it's a personal favor to mine uh in doing some research on a book that I
  5. was writing uh I came across this and actually ended up using uh some of the stories and and the the the personality
  6. of the William Francis Gibbs the the architect of this great ship uh in uh as an example of some things that I wanted
  7. to talk about so Steve welcome to knowledge of wardon oh thank you so much for having me um so I I just thought it
  8. would be interesting if we could chat a little bit about both uh your journey and writing this book and also uh the
  9. the journey you Chronicle uh William Francis Gibbs and uh his um remarkable achievement in uh in building the SS
  10. United States so why don't we just start by uh giving you a chance to tell uh tell our audience how did you stumble
  11. into this topic what was it that prompted you to write about uh about this remarkable man well for me I was
  12. always interested in um ocean liners for as far back as I could remember and ships in the sea in general uh my
  13. grandmother uh was a passenger on the SS United States and she told me uh stories
  14. of what it was like on board and she also told me the story of the Titanic uh which first got me interested in ships
  15. in the sea when I was around 6 or seven years old and uh it was a personal passion of mine I was a little kid that
  16. built models of ships in my parents' basement and uh I first saw the SS United States when we were looking at
  17. colleges my junior year and we were driving over the walw bridge in 1996 and the SS United States once the glory of
  18. the American passenger Fleet had just arrived in Philadelphia and was sitting there rusted and Abandoned and I pointed
  19. at said oh there it is there it is and my grandmother was in the car with us and she said oh I remember that ship and
  20. I ended up coming to Philadelphia for graduate school and uh never leaving been here ever since and back in 2007 um
  21. I started doing some freelance pieces and one of them was on the SS United States um because I had just been
  22. fascinated with it and um the editor at plan Philly uh gentleman called Matt gois uh said well we've always wanted to
  23. have someone write about that how about you tell us more about the man who designed it and then uh it ended up
  24. evolving into a book proposal and it was published by simonon Schuster after about 5 years of work and for me it
  25. started off with the interest in the ship as an American icon is a true Masterpiece of American Technology built
  26. at a time in the 1940s and 50s when America was at the top of its manufacturing prowess and as One
  27. Maritime historian said this is a ship that was like a cathedral it was built to last forever in terms of how well she
  28. was built but then I began thinking about what about the man who created the ship that's what ultimately made the
  29. book is what sort of creative person did it take to design a ship this spectacular and this um strong and fast
  30. why did he want to build the finest fastest soci liner in the world and then I began looking at William Francis Gibbs
  31. and discovered this man is on par with uh Frank Lord Wright John Augustus robling who designed the Brooklyn Bridge
  32. one of these American creative uh individuals who uses the American industrial system the financial system
  33. and his own creativity and vision to create not just a ship that was built to transport people from A to B but
  34. something to transcend that to be a floating work of art uh this man was so in love with this ship that he would
  35. greet it every time he ca every time the ship came into New York and uh someone once asked him Mr Gibbs do you love that
  36. more than your wife and he responded you're a th% correct what sort of person is this
  37. someone who's married to his work I guess very much so uh so tell us a little bit about um about the U the
  38. story that William Francis Gibbs that you uncovered about him what uh what led him to become interested in ships well
  39. in 1894 when he was an 8-year-old boy he uh was brought by his father to the cramped shipyards in the banks of
  40. Delaware here in Philadelphia and he saw an ocean L launch called the St Louis and she roared down the ways sending up
  41. clouds of smoke as she splashed into the Delaware the crowds were cheering the American flags were waving and Gibb said
  42. from that moment I knew what I wanted to do with my life I knew I wanted to be a
  43. naval architect his father was an extremely wealthy finer um he was very closely connected with the Widener
  44. family he was one one of the richest men in Philadelphia and his father said uh that is not a good career to be a naval
  45. architect and Gibbs ended up going to Harvard in preparation to be a lawyer he proved to be a terrible engineer ing
  46. student and a math student and uh he had he ultimately and this is the defining event of his life he was brought up in a
  47. big mansion in writtenhouse square uh all the Comforts and conveniences of the early 1900s Gilded Age America but then
  48. his senior year his father went bankrupt and the family lost everything this was
  49. about what 192 1910 okay 1910 and Gibbs would later say if not for the fact that my father
  50. father had gone bankrupt I never would have amounted to anything in life and that I think really gave him the drive
  51. to reinvent himself from being the poor little rich boy who loves ships into being someone who's saying you know what
  52. I'm going to be an AAL architect and I'm going to do it on my terms my father pursued this this path and he basically
  53. tried to make me do something I didn't want to do and I'm going to show him I can do what I want to do so so uh so
  54. Gibbs really was a man who uh saw the um the dream very early in life uh when he had this experience with
  55. the the ship launching and then uh found the motivation uh sort of a little bit later
  56. while he was in college and then spent the rest of his life essentially pursuing the the dream very much so and
  57. uh he and his brother Frederick uh became very close business partners and they came up with designs in 1914 for a
  58. thousand foot long American ocean liner and uh this is a time when America was not really building passenger ships and
  59. Gibbs who actually ended up finishing his training as a lawyer at Colombia he ended up working his way through law
  60. school at his father's assistance um said I can't be stuck in this profession I can't stand I need to do something I
  61. really love to do so he ultimately finagled two connections one was to a gentleman called Admiral David W Taylor
  62. who was Chief Constructor of the US Navy uh who also was uh very interested in America building up its passenger and
  63. naval fleets at the time uh Taylor ended up meeting this young very nerdy very socially awkward young man from
  64. Philadelphia and said this kid has some issues with math but he has drive he has
  65. talent and Taylor ends up taking Gibbs under his wing and providing a lot of the training that Gibbs never had and a
  66. lot of the support and credentials but then Gibbs also got introduced to JP Morgan Jr uh who was the son of the
  67. famous banker and JP Morgan Jr had his own issues with shipping because his father was one of the principal actually
  68. he was the principal investor in the White Star Line that built the RMS Titanic ah so all shipping stories
  69. either begin end or go through the Titanic uh oddly enough William Francis Gibbs when he was designing the ship
  70. that became the SS United States his primary uh Focus was I want this ship to be able to withstand the same damage
  71. that sank the Titanic in 1912 and that was sort of the departure point for ship safety and he felt that a
  72. lot of shipping companies were skimping on safety on the in the for the sake of Passenger comfort for the sake of
  73. cost-saving and he would later say that uh it is almost a crime for a company to
  74. skimp on safety uh for the sake of shortterm uh cost saving because the potential damage that could happen to a
  75. company when you know hundreds or in the case of the Titanic you know 1500 people
  76. killed uh is definitely it's actually makes better business sense to over engineer a ship right for safety we're
  77. we're having a little example of air safety uh even as we do this interview with uh the Boeing Dreamliner the latest
  78. uh technology of the air having not been completely uh uh flawlessly designed and
  79. and now The Fleets uh on the sidelines for a few uh weeks or months as they figure out the battery problem that it's
  80. having so uh so let me ask you a little bit um uh I know that William Francis Gibbs was on the cover of Time Magazine
  81. when one year in the uh in the 40s uh what brought him to the to the cover of Time Magazine well Gibbs uh by the 1940s
  82. had founded his own very successful Naval Architecture Firm uh David W Taylor the famous Admiral who become a
  83. partner his brother was a partner and they ended up becoming the leading uh Navy contractors uh building new Navy
  84. ships during the 1930s during the buildup to World War II and gibbs's real strength I mean as one of his colleagues
  85. said he was a great designer but his real strength lay in project management he was very much kind of a Steve Jobs
  86. figure who came up with the concept of how he wanted a ship to look the specifications it would it was to have
  87. and then would work very closely with very talented subordinates who were very good technically to come out with the
  88. finished product he was an utter control freak uh and he also had a very notorious mouth uh he had spoke with
  89. addiction of a Philadelphia Aristocrat but had the mouth of a sailor and uh he um ended up getting on the cover of Time
  90. Magazine because his firm was responsible for the production of the famous Liberty ships which were the
  91. first true mass-produced cargo ships in which America's industrial engine was thrown behind the war effort and this is
  92. a time when America could produce at one time a liberty ship in 3 weeks from stop
  93. to finish from start to finish prefab being a lot of stuff off site and then building these ships basically faster
  94. the Germans could sync them and that's what landed him on the cover of Time Magazine he was called a technological
  95. revolutionist he brought Henry Ford's idea of mass production from Cars to ships interesting and uh and I I seem to
  96. remember uh somewhere in your book uh that actually he not just a liberty ship but he ended up his firm ended up
  97. designing something like 3/4 of all the ships that the Americans uh used in the war effort or some large percentage yes
  98. his firm Gibson Cox was responsible directly or indirectly for 70% of All Ships built during World War II all Navy
  99. ships and his firm uh ended up becoming one of the leading uh military contractors uh he loved passenger ship
  100. design but he saw it didn't really pay that much uh so he decided to focus on government contracts he had a
  101. relationship with President Roosevelt Who Loved ships himself and uh that really grew his business he ended up
  102. having employing nearly 2,000 draftsman designers engineers in his firm in lower
  103. Manhattan by the end of World War II interesting let let's let's uh segue just a little bit you mentioned Steve
  104. Jobs uh as a a a a modern uh person with some of the same qualities that William
  105. Francis Gibbs had um tell me a little bit about uh Steve Jobs's personality is now uh you know part of the public
  106. discourse because of biography recently written uh by Walter Isaacson uh you've uh you've uh you've gotten William
  107. Francis Gibbs into our imagination What kind of person was he and and why do you
  108. compare him as a personality to uh to Steve Jobs well in many ways Gibbs was an engineer with the soul of an artist
  109. and I think Gibbs was someone who had very um little patience for a small talk he wanted very when he was talking he
  110. wanted you know he was very to the point of what he wanted uh he as a young man when he was just starting out uh as a
  111. designer he felt he was too nice and too Meek and he felt that his Pro his his ideas were getting bowled over so in his
  112. early 30s he sort of had this transformation where he said you know what if I want to get something done if
  113. I want to aim for an ambitious goal being disagreeable or even being nasty is a way of getting to a to a greater
  114. goal he would later tell his um his uh staff when they finished design the SS United States I apologize for how I
  115. behaved but this is like trying to build a pyramid here interes and uh and Gibbs
  116. was the sort of guy that would sneak up on his designers when they were working soundlessly it kind of creeped them out
  117. a little bit but he was everywhere he kept um he would he kept um tabs on everything everyone was doing
  118. sort of a control uh a control personality but but he knew exactly what he wanted at the end exactly he was a he
  119. was a very uh controlling personality uh he once he also had a great sense of humor uh love giving speeches and you
  120. know Steve Jobs is a similar way very charismatic Persuader uh for impossible ideas and uh Gibbs once said uh if I
  121. didn't have a sense of humor working with ship Builders I'd be dead a long would have been dead a long time ago and
  122. he says everyone thinks such a mean fellow cuz I like ships More Than People interesting which is I think it was a
  123. dig it himself but also revealing that he um was devoted to Creation did he did he have the same problems with his
  124. family life as as job seems to have had with his he had a very distant relationship with his children uh he and
  125. his wife uh ended up leading uh relatively separate lives uh by their You by when they were in older um Vera
  126. was the daughter of Paul Kath the famous New York attorney who founded Kat Swain
  127. and Moore and she was very um devoted to her husband and his creation but uh Gibbs on one hand I
  128. think relied on her but then he once said in a New Yorker interview my life is my wife is a beautiful intelligent
  129. wonderful woman she goes her way and I go mine perhaps that's why we get along so well so it was kind of a telling
  130. thing I think he was he wanted to create his own world and gibs and Cox's firm was um a very closely guarded um
  131. basically under the mil the context of military secrecy um you there were all mazes of barriers um to get in and get
  132. out uh he once told a security guard um please check the identification of everyone who comes in here and the next
  133. day uh William Fran gibes walks in the door and this this is a story from one Naval architect told me um and the
  134. security guard sees the um Gibbs in and waves them through and Gibbs says you're
  135. fired you should have asked me for ID yeah so I think like jobs and Gibbs they want to create their own sort of little
  136. creative worlds and I guess I guess in the high-tech sense uh Trade Secrets and all that stuff creates the need for that
  137. kind of uh careful scrutiny and security and in and gives his world it was the government contracts and the secrets of
  138. Naval design and and then his own personality that did it oh they all meshed very well I mean the uh the naval
  139. vessels he were designing were top secret right and there were a lot of other Naval firms that wanted to get a
  140. look at what he was doing uh there was one exception though he asked a a bishop to come in and take a look at what he
  141. was doing a bishop and the bishop said are you sure you want me to uh come into this model shop and see this see all the
  142. stuff you're doing you know how clergy talk and Gibb said that's okay I'm not worried about you I'm not only convinced
  143. in your character but the abysmal ignorance of the you're about to see well um uh Steve I uh I remember
  144. when I first moved to Philadelphia going down to the docks uh here in Philadelphia and seeing this great huge
  145. hulking vessel uh parked uh on the Delaware River uh and wondering what on Earth could that be uh and it said SS
  146. United States on the side and having read your book uh a whole area of not just Philadelphia history but also uh
  147. the history of American Business and uh this incredibly important uh ship building industry that the United States
  148. was so strong in over the years uh really came to life so uh so thank you for bringing that all to us thank you
  149. [Music]

Brief Summary

Steve Uif Fusa discusses William Francis Gibbs and his creation of the SS United States, highlighting Gibbs' life, career, and innovations in shipbuilding.

Key points

  • The SS United States: An American Icon. Explore the remarkable story of the SS United States and its architect, William Francis Gibbs.
  • William Francis Gibbs: A Visionary. Gibbs transformed from a wealthy boy to a pioneering naval architect after his father's bankruptcy.
  • Gibbs and the Titanic's Legacy. Gibbs aimed to design a ship that could withstand the same damage that sank the Titanic.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

More from Knowledge at Wharton