When the Government Stops Protecting Your Food

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Wharton Associate Professor of Business Economics and Public Policy, Corinne Low explains why food safety is a public good and why families can't realistically take over the government's role in monitoring pathogens, inspecting facilities and responding to outbreaks.

She discusses the consequences of reduced staffing, weakened inspections and changes to disease surveillance—and why these changes can leave consumers more exposed to foodborne illness. The conversation also explores the responsibility of food companies, the long-term cost of cutting corners and why government oversight can give families the freedom to simply trust the food they buy.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Well, the cyclospora outbreak, which has led to illness with many people in the last couple
  2. of weeks, is the latest case of maybe, just maybe, the government failing to do its job
  3. in protecting people around our food. Warren Professor Corinne Low recently wrote an op-ed for Time magazine about why these
  4. problems continue to occur, and she joins us to discuss the article. Corinne, great to catch up with you.
  5. How are you today? I'm great. Good to see you again, Dan. You know, one of the things you mentioned at the beginning of the article is the fact
  6. that the process of food safety is part of the public good, and that's part of what the
  7. government's responsibility is. Yeah. So there's, in economics, you know, a lot of times people think, oh, econ, everything
  8. should be free market, right? But there's actually, in econ theory, these things called public goods that are more efficiently
  9. provided by the government for everyone than by individuals themselves, and food safety
  10. is one of those things. Because if you think about it, yeah, maybe it takes a couple thousand employees working
  11. for the USDA or the FDA to keep our food safe, but there's 63 million American parents whose
  12. time is going to be saved if they can count on, okay, I can get the baby food pouch for
  13. my kid, and I'm going to be able to squeeze it out, and I know that it's safe. I can get the pre-made salad, and it's not going to give our family diarrhea, right?
  14. I can just buy fruit off the shelf. We can't afford, as individuals, to have laboratories in our homes to try to test our food supply,
  15. right? It doesn't make any sense. And so it's something that is more efficiently provided by the government, and that's why
  16. we had, until recently, set up a system of very robust food safety controls. And this dates back over 100 years, since the publication of Upton Sinclair's The Jungle,
  17. which kind of alerted people to major issues with food safety and quality. And then we started building up this system, and that system has been building up, going
  18. in the direction of greater safety and protection until very recently, when it has been being
  19. dismantled. What has been occurring that has changed some of the dynamics at play here?
  20. Well, this isn't a metaphor when I say that these changes are responsible for things like
  21. the cyclospora outbreak, because actually, that's one of the pathogens that was removed
  22. from a tracking list, because they had cut staff so much that they couldn't track all
  23. of the same pathogens that they had been tracking. And so they've rolled back multiple metrics of food safety.
  24. So first, it's laying off staff in the Human Food Protection Division. It was drastically reducing the size of the USDA and having a great deal of that staff
  25. resign. And then it was actually changing regulations. It was rolling back protections against salmonella.
  26. It was saying we're no longer going to track these four specific pathogens and cyclospora
  27. among them. It was reducing our inspection of foreign food facilities to the lowest level ever,
  28. and rolling back all of our system of kind of intermittent safety checks and the system
  29. of what's called disease surveillance, which is once you get an outbreak, you should be
  30. able to have your staff target it and immediately find what's the source of that, and rolling
  31. back their ability to respond in real time. And so all of those changes have been happening.
  32. And with that, consumers have been noticing. So we're actually at one of the highest levels of foodborne illness, as well as just consumer
  33. complaints about food quality. Things like, oh, I found a chip of wood in my corn dog.
  34. Those complaints are on the rise because we're just not monitoring food safety the way we
  35. used to. So I know that you focus a lot in your research about the family and how women specifically
  36. are taking care of the family. So by a lot of these things occurring within agencies of the federal government, this is
  37. kind of the trickle down effect where the family is having to, to a degree, take the
  38. role of the government and look out for some of these issues. The problem, I assume, is the fact that in many cases, the family is not prepared to
  39. oversee a lot of these concerns like the agencies in the federal government. Yes. So if you think about it, I thought about this because I read this article that said,
  40. oh, here's how you can protect your family against cyclospora. And the list was, you know, OK, don't use pre-bagged salad, get the whole head of
  41. lettuce, peel out the outer leaves and then wash each individual leaf and chop the
  42. lettuce for your salad. And I'm like, well, the reason we're using a bag salad is that
  43. it saves us time. Right. And then here was the kicker. Don't give your family fresh raspberries.
  44. Cook them into pies and jam. And I said, look, I have a job, OK? I'm not making homemade raspberry jam.
  45. So I want to be able to buy food off the shelf and feed it to my family. And the issue is that when the government steps back in their role in food safety, well,
  46. parents have to step up. And so, you know, we've spoken before and I've written a lot about how often the
  47. division of labor between men and women at home can be imbalanced and women do a lot
  48. more. But here's an example where, well, the government isn't pulling their weight in
  49. the households. Neither of us should be doing it. We shouldn't need to divide this task of who's going to individually wash the leaves of
  50. lettuce because we should be able to count on our government to actually protect the
  51. bag salad. Let me ask you this, though, then isn't there also a level of responsibility that the
  52. companies who are producing these foods has as they are taking it through their process
  53. to make sure that they are doing their due diligence so that parents obviously don't
  54. have to worry about it? Obviously, there's a component of the government, but the
  55. companies themselves have a responsibility or two. Well, sure. And, you know, I'm not someone who thinks I think of firms as being
  56. profit maximizing. That's how we model them in economics. And so I don't think of them as necessarily having values, even though we would love for
  57. firms to have values, but really they're profit maximizing. And I think, you know, here we see an example where Taylor Farms may have made a
  58. mistake from a profit perspective because in the short term, by cutting corners, right,
  59. they were probably making more money. But in the long term, that brand value has been completely destroyed.
  60. And so you saw during this outbreak that you would go to the grocery store and you would
  61. see Taylor Farms salad mixes marked down to four for a dollar for the salad mixes
  62. because no one wanted to buy them. And so we're going to probably see that brand actually being replaced on the market.
  63. And so by taking the short term profit, they've probably destroyed this very valuable
  64. long term brand capital. Well, right, exactly. And to a degree, I think as the public, we place a level of trust in the companies that
  65. are producing our food and we place a level of trust in the government for helping us
  66. kind of oversee this as well. And unfortunately, you know, talk about the brand capital.
  67. I think we we've lost a little bit of the brand. You know, all companies are worried about the brand these days that the government and
  68. these companies have lost more of their brand or their trust from us because of this
  69. occurring. Absolutely, absolutely. And, you know, as I said, I think of firms as being profit maximizing.
  70. So the reality is firms are going to try to cut corners and it's the government's job to
  71. keep them in check. Right. It's kind of this ongoing dance and that's what regulation is.
  72. And I think when they know, OK, you know, the the cat is sleeping, the mice will play.
  73. Right. And so if we know the government has signaled that they don't have the capacity to
  74. do the same level of enforcement right now that they have previously done, well, firms
  75. are going to try to cut corners and make those quarterly profits. And realistically, when you think about it, that should be almost the bare minimum,
  76. shouldn't it be in terms of what we expect of companies and of our government is to do
  77. the basic things so that we don't have to have the concerns about them on the daily
  78. basis? Exactly. And that's exactly what my op ed was about, is that everyone's saying, oh, parents need
  79. to be more free range. And this generation of parents is too high strung and they're too paranoid.
  80. And I was like, look, I would love to be able to cut loose as a parent, but for me to
  81. cut loose, I need to know that the government has my back. And so if I know that they are regulating vehicle safety, which they're not right now,
  82. right, right now we have accident investigations at their lowest level ever. If they're regulating vehicle safety, I can let my kid bike outdoors.
  83. If they are monitoring air quality and, you know, attending to the things that pollute
  84. our air, well, I can let my kid play outdoors. If they're abating lead in our environment, I don't have to be paranoid about washing
  85. hands every two minutes. And if they are monitoring pathogens, I can let my kids, you know, eat fruit, you know,
  86. wherever they get it or eat the bagged salad mix. And so for me to relax a little bit more actually means that I need that division of
  87. responsibility with the government. And that's what we're not getting right now.
  88. Corinne, great to talk to you as always. Thank you. Thanks so much, Dan. You got it. Corinne Low, Wharton professor joining us here on the show.

Brief Summary

Corinne Low discusses the cyclospora outbreak and government failures in food safety.

Key points

  • Food Safety and Public Responsibility. Corinne Low discusses the government's role in ensuring food safety and the implications of its failures.
  • The Consequences of Cuts. The reduction of food safety staff has led to increased foodborne illnesses and consumer complaints.
  • Trust in Food Producers. The discussion highlights the responsibility of food companies in maintaining safety standards.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes