How AI-Generated Influencers Are Shaping the Future of Marketing

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

This episode of Knowledge at Wharton features Wharton marketing professor Jonah Berger discussing the rise of virtual influencers—AI-generated personas used by brands to market products. The conversation explores how these digital avatars are designed, why companies choose them over human influencers, and what drives their effectiveness. Berger shares insights from his research, highlighting how human-like features and social presence can increase trust and engagement with virtual influencer content. The discussion also touches on evolving consumer perceptions and the future of digital marketing in an AI-driven world.

The Knowledge at Wharton podcast features interviews with Wharton faculty and industry leaders about the business landscape and the impact of their work. Conversations range from the latest research and books by faculty authors, to Leading Diversity at Work with professor Stephanie Creary.

#AIInfluencers #InfluencerMarketing #AIMarketing #FutureOfMarketing #aicontent ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. this podcast is brought to you by knowled of [Music] warten brands have long used celebrities
  2. athletes and social media influencers to pitch their products now they're getting
  3. endorsements and driving sales in a different way no humans required virtual influencers these are computer created
  4. personalities and they are gaining immense popularity around the world I'm Angie basini and I'm here today with
  5. Wharton marketing Professor Jonah Burger he's bringing us some of his research on
  6. Virtual influencers and what he discovered companies are doing that actually boost the effectiveness of
  7. these avatars Jen welcome back thanks for having me let's just jump right into this what is a virtual influencer why
  8. are they so popular and why would a company choose to use one is in as opposed to a real person what's the
  9. advantage yeah so a virtual influencer they really started out um as almost online abot and some right so uh think
  10. about an image of someone it's a it's not actually real person a a fabricated image of someone that looks real uh
  11. maybe initially they might have taken a real person's body but put uh superimposed a face on top of it that
  12. would have been consistent across images this isn't an actual human being it's a
  13. sort of an online avatar that is run potentially by a design company or by a brand or by a media company um and uh
  14. influencers are interesting right lots of interest in this space obviously companies want to get people to share
  15. word of mouth about the products and services and ideas um and so many companies organizations started paying
  16. traditional human influencers to do this um but there's some challenges working with human infl right you may not be
  17. able to find uh someone who has the exact mix of characteristics that you're looking for maybe you're looking for
  18. someone who's from a particular country and has a certain set of hobbies or a certain set of interests um and has some
  19. other set of characteristics and finding that masch between geography and uh and
  20. demographics and sort of psychographics and interests might be might be difficult to do um and second uh working
  21. with these virtual influ really gives companies organizations a lot more control right when you work with a human
  22. influencer you get some say and exactly what they say about the brand uh but you
  23. don't always get full complete sign off on everything that they do they may have
  24. some leeway in what they get to say or you may be concerned you know maybe if I work with celebrity and they get in
  25. trouble in the future is that going to hurt or have some blowback on the brand uh and so the benefit of working with
  26. these virtual influencers is Media companies or the individuals that run them have a much more control over what
  27. these influencers virtual influencers say and do obviously they're not going to get in trouble with the law because
  28. they're not real people and and so that ability can uh diffuse Word of Mouth uh and influence in a different and know
  29. way I know there's something I I saw in your paper about that regarding that and
  30. it said that you know people consumers don't necessarily believe that a real social media influencer has tried the
  31. product but you're sort of disabused of that notion when it's a virtual influencer you already know that's not
  32. possible so you sort of you get past that worry yeah I mean what's also changed so much in the past few years
  33. even the time we've been working on this paper is the way the virtual influencer
  34. space has changed right originally it might have been an image superimposed on a a real person's face um someone else's
  35. face imposed on their phase but now think about everything going on with llms and all these different models
  36. things going on now they can create images and create videos and uh and do things through AI that were not possible
  37. uh two three four five years ago and so we're not just seeing images now or seeing more things with video and other
  38. things and so there's going to be a lot of more content that's created by people
  39. other than humans um already some of it's going on and there's only going to be more in in the coming years you had
  40. some great stats in your paper I want to share with our audience uh you had that
  41. 58% of American consumers follow at least one virtual influencer that 40% of American consumers have purchased
  42. something that was promoted by a virtual influencer and that VI Market is going to reach 11 billion do this year which
  43. is huge so is the message that if you're a brand or a company just make an avatar
  44. stick it online watch the money roll in well I think there's there's not just one choice there's a couple choices
  45. brands have right one is should we create our own virtual character I think the challenge there is they can't just
  46. like any sort of uh online sort of thing they can't only post about you right most people probably wouldn't want to
  47. follow a virtual influencer if they only talk about I don't know coca colola or Delta Airlines or Nike all the time um
  48. and so one reason people want to follow these virtual influencers they seem like
  49. regular people right yes sure they do some collaborations with Brands but they also post some unbranded content they
  50. also might talk about someplace they're going this weekend or show a picture of them doing something with friends that
  51. has nothing to do with brands that makes them seem more like a real person as we'll talk about in a couple minutes and
  52. so for Brands to create one that may not be the thing that most brands want to do
  53. I think many brands that are considering might want to work with one they want to
  54. collaborate with virtual and lots of uh big brands have started collaborating with virtual influencers just like they
  55. might with a regular human influencer um and I think the question that really becomes is it going to work right so
  56. just like as you work with a regular influencer is working with this person is paying them right this is a form of
  57. paid media after all is paying them GNA have that return on investment or we get
  58. more from working with this person than doing something else with our with our marketing dollars there is a main
  59. takeaway in your paper that I would like for us to talk about and that is the presence of virtual influencers online
  60. and what boosts their effectiveness let's talk about that yeah sure so just I think this nicely ties to the question
  61. we just talked about right but the question is not just should I work with a virtual influencer but what makes
  62. virtual influencers effective right if you look at their posts some of them get a lot of attention uh get a lot of likes
  63. get a lot of comments get a lot of shares others not so much right some get a lot of Engagement some don't why and
  64. you could say the same thing about regular influences as well right certain posts get more engagement certain don't
  65. why as we talked about already though it's really important in this space of virtual influences is trust and it's
  66. it's already important in the space of influences more generally but particularly true in this virtual
  67. influencer phase because uh a virtual influenc can't have actually tried the product that they're talking about right
  68. because they're they're not real they can't have been to that restaurant they can't have gone to that soccer game they
  69. can't have worn the shoes um and so it's it's unlike that they actually engaged with that product and so why would you
  70. want to follow them why would you want to engage with them and so we started looking at this across a number of
  71. different projects we looked some of the language uh that influencers and virtual
  72. influencers use but we also started looking at the images um and there's a lot of interesting work going on in
  73. computer vision and other things in this space content analytics moving not just
  74. from text you I've talked about many times before and sort of analyzing language for insight but think about how
  75. to analyze images or video or audio feature other types of content Analytics for insight so we did here is we looked
  76. at a whole bunch of different influencers we looked at a whole bunch of posts they made and we analyzed
  77. aspects of the photos they posted to see what about those photos might increase engagement and what did you find yeah so
  78. we found something quite interesting so it turns out that appearing with someone
  79. else in an image so if you're a virtual influencer appearing in an image not just by yourself but with someone else
  80. particularly someone else who seems human is much like more likely to to lead to positive engagement on that post
  81. so post where I'm going to photo but it's not just me I'm appearing a photo with other people particularly those
  82. that look human get get more engagement and so whether it's you know being at a restaurant with some folks that look
  83. like your friends being at the gym with uh somebody it looks like that you know and and so on and so we dug deep but we
  84. found something quite interesting which is these posts essentially humanize the virtual influencer so as consumers when
  85. we look at posts online we're trying to figure should I trust this whether virtual influence or regular one should
  86. I trust this post and with virtual influencers trusted low to begin with one thing I I look for I'm trying to
  87. figure out do I trust them is well do they seem human because the more they seem human the more likely I am to say
  88. okay well this is more like a regular person I can trust what they're saying I'm gonna be more like we engaged with
  89. this post and so appearing with someone else appearing like you have a friend um
  90. a social tie a relationship with a real person um seeming like you do even though you're a virtual influencer makes
  91. the individual viewing that post go wow you seem more like a human you seem more
  92. anthropomorphic seem more like human you have human characteristics now I'm going
  93. to trust you more it as a result that post is going get so it's this idea that this Avatar is not really an isolation
  94. that it has a social network a community a tie um does it matter if the Avatar is
  95. appearing with other people that are also other characters that are also avatars or is it better that they appear
  96. with real people real humans yeah great question and I think I think the question is really we don't know as as
  97. viewers of these posts exactly who they're appearing with right um but but uh the more human that person seems the
  98. more human that image seems um if I'm appearing in a photo my face is there and there's another face more it looks
  99. like that other face is an actual real human being the bigger the impact is why because if I'm showing up with someone
  100. who looks like a cartoon or it doesn't really look like a real person then the consumer viewing is go wow this isn't
  101. really really a human and so if it's not really a human I'm not going to trust it
  102. and I'm not going to trust it I'm not going to engage with it and so um engagement is higher in these posts when
  103. it looks like that person you're appearing with is actually really a real human looks like a real human rather
  104. than some other Avatar that you might be connected yeah one of the the important
  105. threads I think that I read in your paper is that you really emphasize that customers consumers are smart they will
  106. not be duped into purchasing something just because there's a cute Avatar or puppy or what have you and I think that
  107. gets back to this issue of trust that you're talking about with with VI influencers so as we're moving deeper
  108. into AI generated content as we discussed before um how you see Brands dealing with that trust Factor you know
  109. it it's been interesting I mean I've been working in the word of mouth field now for probably almost 20 years
  110. thinking about sort of issues related to Word of Mouth and um uh initially um when work in this space St started
  111. people said wow we trust word of mouth because we know it's diagnostic we know that person's objective compared to
  112. let's say a piece of paid or owned media piece of earned media some friend telling me they like something that's
  113. really useful information they're not getting paid going to tell me they like it if it's actually pretty good and so I
  114. can trust them and that information is going to be more targeted and so it's going to have more impact as we Mig
  115. graded online that was still the case at least to some degree um but today things
  116. have gotten more complicated right not only is their AI content out there but there are influencers who may be getting
  117. paid to post things well should I trust that influencer or not and when should I
  118. trust them and when should I not trust them and what's going to make me be more likely to trust them and so I think this
  119. is a really interesting space both for consumers as individuals sort of thinking about how should I consume
  120. content uh online and what should I trust and what should I not trust and also for Brands Brands thinking about
  121. how do we get the word out about our products and services and ideas should we work with these online influencers
  122. should we work with regular Joe's and Janes and really have them sample the product that way that word of mouth is
  123. much more organic and probably more trusted maybe they don't have as big of an audience right um you know if I post
  124. about something online compared to an online lincer my post May as big reach as their post does but hopefully my
  125. friends and colleagues trust me because they know I didn't get paid and so maybe
  126. they're going to be more likely to listen to that message and so it's certainly an interesting space but with
  127. lots of interesting changes going on yeah it's definitely evolving because social media platforms themselves are
  128. evolving so who knows what they're going to look like in five to 10 years so definitely yeah interesting space to
  129. watch yeah thank you so much for being on with me your paper is titled what drives virtual influencers impact you
  130. can find it online along with all of Jonah's books and papers and content about persuasive communication uh his
  131. website is called Jonah it's Jonah burger.com I'm Angie B un for knowledge at Wharton thanks for joining us for
  132. more insight from knowledge at Wharton please visit knowledge. Warton up.edu [Music]

Brief Summary

Virtual influencers are reshaping marketing by enhancing brand control and consumer trust, according to Jonah Berger's research.

Key points

  • The Rise of Virtual Influencers. Virtual influencers are computer-generated personalities gaining immense popularity and changing marketing strategies.
  • Trust Issues with Virtual Influencers. Consumers are skeptical about the authenticity of virtual influencers compared to real ones.
  • Engagement Strategies for Virtual Influencers. Posts featuring virtual influencers with humans lead to higher engagement rates.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes