Why Back-to-School Shopping Is About More Than Supplies

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Back-to-school shopping is more than a checklist. Patti Williams, associate professor of marketing at the Wharton School, explains why a new backpack, pair of sneakers, or lunchbox can mean so much to families.

In this episode of The Ripple Effect, Patti discusses the consumer psychology behind one of retail’s most reliable seasons. She explores how parents and students navigate needs, wants, budgets, identity, and nostalgia, and why retailers and manufacturers plan so carefully for this annual wave of demand.

ABOUT THE PODCAST Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. This is a really meaningful time of identity visioning and identity enactment, both for parents and
  2. for children, right? Children are imagining the learner they want to be for the next year.
  3. Parents are trying to set them up for success so that, you know, in a world where there are lots of things I can't
  4. control, I can have them ready for that first day of school. Welcome to The Ripple Effect, the podcast that
  5. takes you on a journey through the minds of Wharton faculty. I'm your host, Dan Loney, and in each
  6. episode, we'll be diving deep into the inspiration behind the groundbreaking research that Wharton professors have
  7. conducted and exploring how their findings resonate with the world today. The month of August is a very unique
  8. one for retailers. For many of them, their main focus is back-to-school shopping.
  9. It's a time when parents know that they have to get certain things for their kids
  10. to get them ready for the next school year, but it's also, at the same time, a period where they want to find the
  11. best deals as well. Pleasure to be joined by Patti Williams, who's an associate professor of marketing here at the
  12. Wharton School. She's also senior vice dean for non-degree programs. Good to see you again, Patti.
  13. Happy summer to you and happy soon-to -be back-to-school season. Back at you. Personally, I love back-to-school season.
  14. Don't you? It's been fun in years. Mine are still in school, so I'm still in the midst of some of all of
  15. this. It is, as I say, kind of a unique period for the retail sector, but like a lot of industries right now, it feels
  16. like what was confined to probably, I guess, like August 1st to September 1st, now has
  17. backed up into July. Retail has extended this out once again. Yeah, definitely. As you say, I think that's happening about
  18. every major retail period, but I personally think back-to-school is a little bit special,
  19. right? Again, I'll speak as an academic. For me, the back-to-school period, as someone who loved school always, was this moment
  20. of possibility and what the world could look like and who, if you're excited about it,
  21. doesn't want to start planning a little bit earlier, thinking about what the next year might
  22. look like, maybe planning what your locker's going to look like, what your backpack's going to
  23. be. Maybe for parents, particularly in a time where there's a lot of uncertainty and a lot
  24. of maybe economic challenges that they're navigating, maybe giving themselves a little more runway to buy
  25. the things they know they need to buy makes it a little bit easier for them to navigate all those purchases.
  26. So what makes this period of the year different than, say, well, obviously holiday shopping around
  27. Christmas time is one thing, but I'll ask you that from the retailer's perspective, because they're
  28. still bringing in product, they want to move it out quickly, they want to have enough
  29. supply, and it's kind of a similar mindset, isn't it? Sure. I mean, I think from a retail calendaring
  30. perspective, it's very similar. They know this event is coming. It's a yearly event.
  31. Back to school doesn't happen once every 10 years, it happens once every year. It's something they can plan for.
  32. They know the kinds of purchases that parents and children are likely to be interested in.
  33. They can build that inventory, set aside the space in the retail store, all of those
  34. good things. It's very predictable consumption, and I suspect very reliable consumption.
  35. Your kid needs new shoes. Your kid may need a new backpack. There are new crayons that have to be
  36. purchased, right? Those things are very reliable in some ways. Maybe what makes it a little bit different
  37. from my perspective is sort of the consumer behavior side, right? I think this is a really meaningful time
  38. of identity visioning and identity enactment, both for parents and for children, right?
  39. Children are imagining the learner they want to be for the next year. Parents are trying to set them up for
  40. success, trying to engage in that pre-planning so that in a world where there are
  41. lots of things I can't control, I can have them ready for that first day of school.
  42. But is it more challenging, let's say this year, when you're thinking about trying to reach
  43. some of those goals, when it's been somewhat of a challenging economic time the last several
  44. months? Yes. I mean, I think everything is more challenging right now for retailers and for consumers, for
  45. parents, for sure, right? Maybe one of the things that makes back -to-school shopping a little more certain from
  46. the retailer perspective is that there are certain things that will have to be purchased, right?
  47. I might come back, I buy a less expensive backpack, I see if the backpack can last a little bit longer, but almost surely
  48. my kids have grown and they're going to need some new clothes. Almost surely the next grade is going to
  49. have a list of requirements that I really do have to have prepared so that my student can be the student I want them
  50. to be in the fourth grade or in the seventh grade or as a freshman in college. With the fact that the retailers know that
  51. these products will be purchased, does it impact their decision making in how they present the
  52. potential deals that might they want to bring forward at this time of the year? Yeah.
  53. Oh, I'm sure that's the case. And I'm sure it's a mix of how do I have enough enticement to get people
  54. to start shopping earlier? Maybe I, you know, set up the displays within the store a little bit earlier.
  55. Maybe I showcase some purchases that I think they'd be willing to make today versus the
  56. things that they might not be willing to make today. Maybe I know what I want my locker
  57. to look like as a kid, but I don't yet know what, you know, sort of supplies the teacher's going to give me until
  58. I even know what classroom I'm in closer to, you know, the end of August potentially.
  59. But you do have to make sure at times the kids have the right sneakers because if they don't have the right sneakers, they're
  60. going to be chastised by their friends when they go back to school. Yeah, so important.
  61. So what I love about this time period in particular is, you know, it's an identity
  62. navigation process for both parents and for children, right? The parents are really thinking about how do
  63. I set my kid up for success? How do I do it in a way that teaches them to make good responsible decisions,
  64. not to overspend, you know, to make, you know, good long-lasting decisions? What are the values I'm trying to impart?
  65. And as you say, the kids are just thinking, how's this going to go at school? How am I going to be perceived?
  66. What person do I want to be when I walk in the door? So to a degree, it's a little bit
  67. of a family event, isn't it? It's totally a family event, yes. I mean, I don't know about you.
  68. Did you ever, you know, school shop with your kids? It's a constant, you know, nudging them in
  69. this direction and they're pulling you in the other direction very often, right?
  70. What I think is interesting though, and tell me if I'm wrong here, but it feels like with the retailers, the items that they
  71. are obviously bringing in to supply, to get ready for this time of year, are items
  72. primarily that they can sell throughout the course of the year, where in some cases, when
  73. you're talking about shopping at Christmas time, some of those items have a shelf life that's
  74. maybe shorter than pencils, pens, paper, etc. You got it. These are staples. You know, Christmas lights might not be very
  75. valuable in February. The pens and pencils and backpacks are always going to wear out.
  76. They always need to be replaced, right? Be replenished and renewed. And so I think you're exactly right.
  77. A lot of this is very stable consumption. On the other hand, there's some things that
  78. I think are pretty seasonal still, right? You know, the refrigerator that you might be
  79. buying for your college freshman's dorm, you might only need that in August or September, and
  80. then you don't really need it in January or February. So there certainly is some perishability to some
  81. of this consumption, even while there's stability to other pieces. So then how do retailers look at finding
  82. success during this window? I mean, obviously there's the core numbers, but they want to have a certain level of
  83. success year over year built so that they can prepare for the next year as well.
  84. Yeah, well, so I think you see a lot of this. I've been getting a lot of these emails
  85. for sure at the moment, right? About really helping your child envision who they
  86. want to be for the next year. And so I think as much as it's really about functional items, what are the backpacks
  87. and the shoes and the pens and pencils that I need? It's really about how are you setting your
  88. third grader up for success? What do you really want them to live up to? And so I think trying to be the
  89. retailer that understands the significance of this moment. You know, there are very few times in
  90. our lives where, you know, we take a picture on the first day where the kid might be holding that lunchbox and that backpack
  91. and wearing those new shoes. And it's a marker, it's a ritual. This is very much ritualistic consumption that has
  92. deep meaning, even while it's very functional. So the connection with the student for the
  93. retailer, it's just important for the retailer to connect with the parent as well as you
  94. go through this process. Absolutely. This is a negotiation, right? Parents and kids are negotiating where to go
  95. and what to buy and what to buy when. I think that's exactly right. You said something a moment ago that resonated
  96. with me is that to a degree, probably for some parents, it's almost like going back
  97. in time to what they remember 20, 30, 40 years ago and what they went through to get those particular items.
  98. I think that's definitely true. This is a time where nostalgia is really important to consumers.
  99. Anytime there's uncertainty and, you know, maybe discomfort in the world, we like to retreat to
  100. places of nostalgia to remember a treasured time that makes us feel, you know, happy and
  101. loved. And who doesn't feel a sense of nostalgia when you go back school shopping with your
  102. kids? Maybe you remember the peachy folders that you were so excited to get, right?
  103. All of those good things. And I bet there's a lot of storytelling happening in those aisles.
  104. When I was in seventh grade, I did this, right? I don't know about you, but mine, when
  105. I was growing up, was the Scooby-Doo lunchbox. If I didn't have the Scooby-Doo lunchbox,
  106. I needed to have that with my parents. Absolutely, right? Definitely the case. What does this then for retailers, and I
  107. guess from their mindset, how do they look at this then from one year to the next?
  108. I mean, is there some, you know, the same mindset, same idea when they're preparing for
  109. back to school every year, or does it fluctuate depending on what the kind of the
  110. cool things are at that period of time? Of course. You know, the challenge for retailers is they
  111. probably had to plan for what would be cool. What's the equivalent of today's Scooby-Doo lunchbox,
  112. you know, a year ago in order to get it designed and manufactured and, you know,
  113. delivered and on the store, you know, footprint in many ways. So yes, there's lots of trend prediction, just
  114. like there is for many other things. Many of these things, again, very functional, but
  115. very identity driven, very fashion oriented, right? What backpack should I have?
  116. What color should it be? I have to know what color trends are, you know, what characters are hot at the
  117. moment, all of those things. So this is just as important a time for retailers as the holiday season or, you
  118. know, if you're a chocolate company and you're getting ready for Valentine's Day, this is there
  119. another one of those very important times of the year. Yes. And I would say not just for the
  120. retailers, but for the manufacturers of all those things, too, for the companies that are making
  121. pens and notebooks and backpacks and lunchboxes, really, really important. This is a very reliable time of demand.
  122. The demand is, you know, happens year over year. I know roughly what the items for that
  123. demand look like. It is something that can fuel a company's success in many ways.
  124. And, you know, to go to your earlier point, even in a time when there's a lot of economic challenge and uncertainty, and maybe
  125. I'm going to reduce what I spend at Christmas, maybe I'm going to, you know, buy
  126. less candy for Halloween. There are school purchases I can't skimp on. Some things will have to be purchased.
  127. And so even in a situation where there might be, you know, maybe the highs aren't
  128. as high, but the lows aren't going to be that low either, because parents and kids
  129. need these things. Right. In many cases, the computer is one of those things. And that's not and that's not a cheap
  130. item that you're going to be purchasing. You know, you're making that purchase. I've been seeing all of these stories about
  131. how people are, you know, having a, you know, a Mac sticker shock at the moment,
  132. right, because of the cost of the chips and so on. Very expensive. Patty, thanks very much for your time today.
  133. All the best. It's always a pleasure. And I hope everyone has a great start to the school year.
  134. Patty Williams, associate professor of marketing here at the Wharton School. Thank you for listening to the Ripple Effect.
  135. We hope you found this episode informative and engaging. Don't forget to subscribe and leave us a
  136. review so that we can continue to bring you the best insight from the Wharton School.
  137. Transcribed by https://otter.ai

Brief Summary

Back-to-school shopping involves identity visioning for parents and kids, with retailers adapting to consumer needs amidst economic challenges.

Key points

  • The Ripple Effect Podcast. Join Dan Loney as he explores the insights of Wharton faculty on identity and retail.
  • Back-to-School Shopping Insights. Discover how back-to-school shopping is a unique blend of identity visioning for parents and children.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes