Why Investors Should Pay More Attention to Congress Than the Fed

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Think the Fed moves markets? Congress may have a bigger impact than most investors realize. Courtney Wiegand, Assistant Professor of Finance at the Wharton School, explains how congressional budget decisions can have a direct impact on financial markets. Drawing on her research into fiscal policy shocks, she explores how changing deficit expectations affect bond yields, inflation expectations, investor risk premiums, and even the path of monetary policy. The conversation examines why markets react to deficit news, how fiscal and monetary policy interact, and what rising federal debt could mean for investors in the years ahead.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#Investing #Economy #FederalReserve #Congress #FinancialMarkets ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. There have been so many questions in the last several months, because there's so much focus around the Fed, on monetary policy. But there should be even
  2. some questions being looked at about fiscal policy and the types of reactions you get
  3. when there are shocks thrown into the mix. Some research looks at that component,
  4. and a pleasure to be joined by Courtney Wiegand, who's an assistant professor of finance
  5. here at the Wharton School. Courtney, great to have you with us today, thanks very much for your time. Thank you for having me, happy to be here.
  6. What was it that had you interested in looking at this component of fiscal policy
  7. rather than the monetary side? Yeah, so after I graduated college, I worked for two years as a research assistant at the Federal Reserve Board, and one of the
  8. responsibilities of the section I was in was to look at the real-time financial market response
  9. to various monetary policy shocks. So how is financial markets responding to monetary policy statements, press releases, things like that. So I always thought it would
  10. be really interesting to do a similar thing, but with fiscal policy, because in my mind,
  11. fiscal policy is one of the main macroeconomic policy levers in the United States, but our
  12. understanding of how it affects financial markets in real time is rather limited.
  13. And so I thought it'd be really cool to try to answer that question. And I was able to sort of
  14. leverage my understanding of how Congress formulates this policy from my time interning on the Hill.
  15. So I interned a few times at the Hill, specifically my time at the House Budget Committee was helpful
  16. because that's where I learned about the budget resolution reconciliation process,
  17. and so I was able to use that process to understand how to formulate shocks, essentially, and then study their effects on financial markets.
  18. Is it safe to say that where we are right now around deficits is really an area that is going
  19. to be, it's focused on, but it's going to be focused on even more because of some of these
  20. dynamics at play? Yes, exactly. So we see like there are these growing concerns about rising
  21. debts, debt-to-GDP ratio, rising federal deficits, and that this is kind of like a persistent and
  22. even growing concern more recently. So one thing that I find is like these effects on financial
  23. markets is persistent over time. So even going back to the 80s and 90s where deficits were much
  24. lower, there's still these significant effects of deficit news on financial markets, but I find that
  25. bigger shocks essentially leads to bigger responses in financial markets. So now we're
  26. seeing this current climate, like larger shocks. And so the extent to which larger shocks have
  27. larger effects on financial markets, I think we're seeing even more like commentary about that.
  28. So give us an idea of a shock that you used in this research and the kind of impact that it
  29. ended up having. Yeah, so very broadly, the way I construct these shocks is looking at these
  30. budget resolution documents. There are these outlay ceilings, so essentially how much, you know,
  31. can Congress spend for the next few fiscal years? These revenue floors, how much they're trying to
  32. collect in revenues over the next few fiscal years, so the difference between those being a
  33. deficit target. And so I use changes in these deficit targets as the budget process unfolds
  34. to identify the timing and the magnitude of deficit news. And so a recent example would be the
  35. One Big Beautiful Bill. So this was the result of the budget resolution reconciliation process,
  36. and one of the effects of the One Big Beautiful Bill was this tax cut. So this essentially like
  37. decreased in this revenue floor. So we're finding that this has significant effects on deficits,
  38. increasing them going forward. So then with that reaction, what ends up being the impacts
  39. that you see with these types of shocks on things like the bond market or on Wall Street?
  40. Yeah, so I find that news of higher future expected deficits leads to an increase in nominal
  41. yields. And so looking at this response, I find that about one-third of this increase is in
  42. break-even inflation, and about two-thirds is in real yields. So indeed there is this, you know,
  43. inflationary effect of higher future deficits, but it's not the full story. And then looking at the
  44. real yield side, looking at the full like maturity spectrum, I find that there's both this increase
  45. in short-term rates, which is often used as like a proxy of monetary policy going forward, as well
  46. as when we look at long-term rates, about half of the effect, the increase in yields, is in this
  47. model estimated term premium component, which is essentially measuring the extra compensation
  48. investors are demanding for holding interest rate and inflation risk. So essentially news of higher
  49. future deficits makes this debt riskier, and not necessarily riskier in terms of default risk,
  50. but in terms of greater uncertainty about the future path of inflation and interest rates.
  51. So a lot of times when we're talking about deficits, we are talking about negative,
  52. and we're seeing increases. What then, if we were to see positive news about deficits,
  53. cutting them back, how would that impact? Would it be exactly the reverse? Yeah, it's a really good question. So I do indeed find this like symmetric response. So
  54. news of higher future expected deficits leads to this increase in rates. News of lower future
  55. expected deficits leads to a decrease in rates. And this is actually, I think, really a good
  56. question because we do see this increase in deficits over time. But what I find is really
  57. important is what you expected. So if you expected higher rates, and then they actually are higher
  58. deficits, and then you get a negative shock, so you then have a revision of your expectations to
  59. lower expected deficit rates, that this would lead to a negative response in yields. And so having a
  60. measure that allows for both positive and negative, I find is really important. What do you think then should be the response, or I guess more so the impact,
  61. on fiscal policy and how they think about it and how it's put forward when you see research like this and these shocks that obviously come into play?
  62. Yeah, so I think that it's really a question of like how your decisions today can impact you going
  63. forward. And so we see, for instance, with these shocks coming from the budget resolution
  64. reconciliation process, I think one of the reasons why they get so much attention is because they do
  65. have these long-term impacts. Because, for instance, let's say one example is like the Tax Cuts and
  66. Jobs Act of 2017. So there are these tax cuts that were legislated for 10 years. So that's why you
  67. often hear like, oh, these tax cuts are expiring. What is Congress going to do next? So we find that
  68. there are these effects on financial markets, but also it's likely that it's constraining
  69. potentially what Congress can do going forward since this legislation is so impactful.
  70. You also mentioned in the paper that there are instances where a fiscal shock can have an impact on monetary policy as well. So there is a crossover.
  71. Yes, there is indeed like this kind of like interaction between fiscal and monetary policy.
  72. That was actually one of the first questions I had, one of the original like motivations for
  73. studying this. And so I find that when the Fed is constrained at the zero lower bound,
  74. then the effects of these deficits and news shocks are much more attenuated. So essentially,
  75. when Congress can't decrease rates any further, and they're unlikely to increase rates in response to
  76. news of higher deficits when they're at the zero lower bound because they're trying to stimulate
  77. the economy. So when they get news of higher future deficits kind of in the direction of
  78. policy they would like, that the response in bond markets is much more attenuated.
  79. And this actually leads to a significant increase in equity markets. And so to the extent that
  80. there is this kind of like coordination between fiscal monetary policy, I find that they're
  81. separate institutions with their own mandates and incentives, but it also depends on the
  82. like overall environment. So we see like even let's say in the 90s or 80s, Chair Greenspan
  83. talking about in a testimony to Congress about how, well, what the FOMC is going to do is going
  84. to depend on what Congress does with its budget resolution. So there can be some coordination.
  85. Right. So there is that correlation between how the Fed reacts to what we see go on in fiscal
  86. policy. Maybe we don't correlate it as much as we probably should though, right?
  87. Right. And I think it too can depend on the overall like economic environment as well. So
  88. you could think about a really large negative economic shock like COVID, you'd think, OK,
  89. the Fed's going to lower rates and Congress is going to try to stimulate the economy. So that
  90. could be an example of where there's a kind of predictable correlation between the directions
  91. of these policies. And that's why I think it's really crucial too to have a shock measure that
  92. exists outside of these big negative economic shocks as well, because both policies are
  93. always happening even outside of recessions. And that's why I think that this fiscal policy
  94. measure can be unpredictable because it's always happening and Congress is very difficult to
  95. predict. What do you hope is the big takeaway from doing this research? And on top of that,
  96. is there a next logical step where you would like to take this research into the next level?
  97. That's a good question. Yeah, I think some goals I have with the paper is just to improve our
  98. understanding of how Congress makes its fiscal policy and also to then understand, OK, what are
  99. the effects on financial markets from that? I think why that's really important and why I'm
  100. interested in digging into that further is because what Congress does, the legislation it passes,
  101. has a direct determinant on the overall deficit level. And then the overall deficit level
  102. has a direct impact on the overall Treasury supply. And Treasury supply is like the largest
  103. bond market in the world and the safe haven and often uses like the risk free rate in our model.
  104. So to the extent that Congress affects this very large and important financial market,
  105. I think that's really important and something I'm interested in pushing on further as well.
  106. Courtney, great to talk with you. Thanks very much for your time. I look forward to chatting
  107. again down the road. Thank you. Great talking to you as well. Thank you. Courtney Wiegand,
  108. who is an assistant professor of finance here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Courtney Wiegand discusses fiscal policy's impact on financial markets and the significance of deficit news in this episode.

Key points

  • The Impact of Fiscal Policy. Courtney Wiegand explores how fiscal policy affects financial markets in real time.
  • Understanding Deficits. Growing concerns about rising debts and federal deficits are highlighted in the discussion.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes