Why Rivalry Can Actually Make Your Team Worse

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Can competing against someone actually make you worse at working with everyone else? Research suggests that individual rivalry can come at a cost to the entire team.

Henning Piezunka, Associate Professor of Management at the Wharton School, joins the show to discuss his research into the relationship between rivalry and performance.

Using NBA matchups like Larry Bird versus Magic Johnson and Kobe Bryant versus Michael Jordan, Piezunka explains why players may score more against individual rivals while making their teams less effective. He also explores the lessons for workplace competition, employee incentives, and business leadership.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#WorkplaceCompetition #Leadership #businessstrategy ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Have you ever been in a situation where you have a person who works for a company,
  2. but has a friend who works for another company, and there is some level of rivalry between the
  3. two? What happens with your own personal success if you're trying to potentially outdo that person?
  4. Henning Piezunka is an Associate Professor of Management here at the Wharton School. He was
  5. part of a research project recently released, which looks into these dynamics of friendship
  6. and rivalry. But he used basketball as kind of the component, the backdrop for how they succeed.
  7. And a pleasure to have him joining us right now. Henning, great to talk to you again. How are you,
  8. sir? I'm great. Good to be with you, Dan. Thanks for having me. So rivalry is an interesting component because I think we think about it more so within the
  9. office. You're trying to outdo another employee. This is a dynamic where, I guess it sounded like
  10. you were trying to do this one versus one, company versus company, employee versus employee.
  11. You know, Dan, first of all, let me say, like, it makes me so happy that you think about rivalry as
  12. an intra-organizational phenomenon, because I think that's something which is underappreciated
  13. and which I explore in a lot of my work. In this context, you're absolutely right, right? You see,
  14. sometimes you have a rival, which is not part of your organization, but maybe part of another
  15. organization, right? So, and you can imagine this in all kinds of contexts, right? Imagine you're
  16. like a journalist for the New York Times. Who do you compare yourself to? A journalist at the
  17. Wall Street Journal, right? You work for the Atlantic. You may also look at what your colleague,
  18. your colleague at The Economist does, right? You see, like, look, we are at Wharton here, right?
  19. Do we sometimes glimpse over and look at what people at RIT or Harvard do? Yeah. So, to be very
  20. clear, this is not to say that those folks are rivals. We think of them as friends and friendly
  21. reviewers. But, you know, like, you sometimes compare yourself. And so there can be a little
  22. bit of rivalry going on, no question about it. But when you get into the world of sports,
  23. that element of rivalry does take on kind of a new level, doesn't it? Absolutely, right? Because you see, like, very often in sports, what you have are,
  24. like, almost two rivalries in parallel, right? So there may be actually, like, rivalry on an
  25. interpersonal level, but there may also be rivalry on an interorganizational level.
  26. And you see, the norms in sports are also very different, right? You see, like, in general,
  27. like, you see, like, in many kind of professions, even if you work for competing companies,
  28. it's kind of a, it's really like a non-zero game typically. And you know what? There may
  29. also be something like, hey, let's kind of foster the greater good, right? You see, like, if I think
  30. about other business schools, I think, look, at the end of the day, we all in the business of kind
  31. of educating people and, you know, like somebody doing well at another school doesn't really
  32. directly harm me in any way. Now, in the context of sports, that's very often very different,
  33. right? That's like a zero-sum game, right? And you see, people are always talking about the goat,
  34. who's the greatest of all time. And no offense, if you are the goat, I can't be the goat, right?
  35. So this is a very often zero-sum competitions. And, you know, and then the norms are also
  36. different, right? You see, like, most people in most offices would not kind of walk around and kind
  37. of engage in trash-talking, right? I mean, we've all seen the show Entourage, where this may be
  38. common, but, you know, like, it's not the most common thing, right? At least at Wharton, we don't
  39. do this. And so, but, you know, like in sports, if you're in an NBA basketball game, it's all about,
  40. like, not all about trash-talking, but, you know, there's a lot of kind of pushing and rivalry,
  41. really, kind of, yeah, it's very prominent. But when that person or one of those two people in
  42. that rivalry are focusing more so on the person, and maybe not on their company or their team,
  43. what's the potential impact that plays out? I mean, there's more focus on that individual
  44. component rather than the team component. So Dan, now you're really hitting the core of the paper,
  45. right? So you see, like, what we often think about rivalry, like, oh, it motivates, I want to
  46. beat the person. And in many ways, this seems like, at first sight, seems like a positive thing.
  47. And this is actually what we find in basketball. You see, like, if you actually have a rival on
  48. the other team, so if Larry Bird plays against Magic Johnson, if Kobe Bryant plays against
  49. Michael Jordan, they actually score more. They want to score more. So you may think they are
  50. performing better and their visible performance, right, so where you actually see how much they
  51. score, actually does better. But here's the thing. In basketball, there's this very neat measure,
  52. which is called the net contribution. And what we can see is how well does the team do if that or
  53. when that person is on the field. And it turns out, despite scoring more, that person scoring
  54. more, the team overall is doing worse, which suggests that they're doing something which kind
  55. of makes the team worse while they are actually kind of scoring more. So you would think, hey,
  56. that person is motivated. This is good for the team. But actually, no, it's good for this person's
  57. individual visible performance, but for the team, it's bad. And so what the paper does, we really
  58. show this divergent effect, how this goes in kind of different direction. One goes up, the other
  59. goes down. And probably the more important goes down, right? The team performance is actually
  60. going down. And then we disentangle, okay, why is this happening? Is it better than for one of the
  61. people in that rivalry, and maybe it's the person who doesn't have as much team success, to focus
  62. more on the team instead of focusing just on that individual component. I guess what I'm asking is,
  63. does focusing on the team benefit the team more in the long run? So, Dan, this is very interesting.
  64. When you ask what's better, right? You always have to ask the question, what's better for whom,
  65. right? You see, if I only care about how many points I score, well, then I should focus on
  66. my scoring. And probably in particular in that game, because I'm actually compared to that rival.
  67. If I'm a good team player, and you see, I think like, look, at the end of the day, my kind of
  68. career will depend upon how well my team does. Then I should focus on the team. But you know what
  69. the funny thing about it is, you should not just kind of think about that person who's in that
  70. situation who faces a rival, but sometimes also the rest of the team actually plays a big role.
  71. Because what sometimes happens is that the team realizes, oh, this person is motivated. Let's
  72. pass the ball more to him. Okay. So this is, I say him because this is NBA basketball,
  73. but this may also kind of go for other kind of genders and sports and so on. So we pass the ball to him. But the issue really is, right, you see, like suddenly you over-rely
  74. on that person. And if you over-rely on a player, you know, that person might not have the strength
  75. to do this or so. What we also see is that person starts kind of scoring or trying to score
  76. out of overly risky positions. And so it really ends up harming the team, which is really odd
  77. because you have one person who's super motivated, but instead of benefiting the team, it actually
  78. hurts the team. So what do you think then this understanding from the world of basketball,
  79. if you take this knowledge and put it in the workforce, in that relationship between two
  80. individuals or two companies, what should they know about the relationship or the working relationship
  81. in the workplace? You see, I think the very first thing it highlights is really like this trade-off
  82. between individual performance and team performance. Just because like an individual
  83. kind of is scoring well on visible kind of benchmarks, like scoring, okay, doesn't mean
  84. that that person is actually a good team player. I give you an example here. So we're here at the
  85. management department at Wharton, right? And you see, if you think about like how we evaluate
  86. professors' performance, we would often look at like teaching ratings and like publication output.
  87. But there are of course many things you do in a department, right? You see like you help your
  88. colleagues, you help PhD students, you help the university and so on and so on. There are all
  89. kinds of activities that people may engage in. And if we get kind of people too focused on like
  90. these individual performance benchmarks, they may actually neglect these other aspects, which
  91. ends up hurting the organization overall. So understanding this trade-off and being
  92. very aware of this trade-off is super important. So for managers, they should think like, look,
  93. I really need to be thoughtful about incentives that this person is not just kind of maximizing
  94. their own scoring, but actually kind of helps the team. The second thing, and this is more specific
  95. when you think about rivalry, right? You want to be a little bit careful. You see, sometimes you may
  96. actually kind of motivate an employee and say like, you know what, I think you have a chance to be
  97. better than that person. I think you have a chance to beat that person. And you see like that can be
  98. very effective and we know that rivalry motivates, but you really want to be thoughtful about what
  99. do you motivate that person to do? Because what you motivate that person to do is to outscore that
  100. person on the dimensions on which the two are compared, right? So imagine my department head
  101. now came to me and said like, oh Henning, I think you can do better than this person. And then I
  102. immediately think, huh, yeah, yeah, I can do better than this person, but this means better
  103. teaching ratings and more papers or something. And as a result, I would kind of neglect my
  104. service requirements. It's an interesting bit of research that you've done, Henning. We appreciate
  105. your time and thanks very much for giving us this insight on the world of basketball, but also how
  106. it applies to work. Thank you, sir. Thanks for having me. Good to see you. Good to see you as
  107. well. Henning Piezunka, Associate Professor of Management here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Henning Piezunka discusses how rivalry impacts individual and team performance in sports and the workplace.

Key points

  • The Dynamics of Rivalry. Henning Piezunka explores how rivalry affects personal success and team performance.
  • Basketball Insights on Teamwork. Research reveals that individual scoring can harm overall team performance.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes